Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
DATED : 12th JULY, 2017
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : THE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MAC App. 1 of 2017
Appellant
:
The Branch Manager,
United India Insurance Co. Ltd.,
N.H.-10, Deorali Bazaar,
Near Khadi Bhawan,
P.O. Tadong, P.S. Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
Versus
Respondents
:
1.
Mr. Subash Rai,
Son of late Yam Prasad Rai,
Aged about 50 years.
2.
Mrs. Pavitra Rai,
Wife of Subash Rai,
Aged about 48 years.
3.
Mr. Sambu Rai,
Son of Subash Rai,
Aged 23 years.
4.
Mr. Mangal Rai,
Son of Subash Rai,
Aged about 21 years.
5.
Mr. Ramesh Rai,
Son of Subash Rai,
Aged about 17 years,
(represented by Claimants No.1, 2, 3 & 4)
6.
Miss Sumita Rai,
Daughter of Subash Rai,
Aged about 15 years,
(represented by Claimants No.1, 2, 3 & 4)
(All are residents of Power Colony, Near Food
Godown, Mangan Nagar Panchayat, Mangan,
P.O. & P.S. Mangan, North Sikkim.)
Respondent/Owner:
7.
Mrs. Bhaktika Devi Ruchal,
Wife of Pempa Norbu Sherpa,
R/o Chandey, P.O. & P.S. Mangan,
North Sikkim.
MAC App. 1 of 2017
The Branch Manager, United India Insurance Company Limited
vs. Mr. Subash Rai & Others
Appeal under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. Pema Ongchu Bhutia, Advocate for the Appellant.
Mr. Ajay Rathi, Mr. Rahul Rathi and Ms. Phurba Diki Sherpa,
Advocates for the Respondents No.1 to 6.
Mr. Deven Sharma Luitel, Advocate for the Respondent No.7.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
J U D G M E N T (ORAL)
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
Contending that the learned Motor Accident Claims
1.
Tribunal, East Sikkim at Gangtok (for short „Claims Tribunal‟), was in
error in granting compensation to the tune of Rs.26,49,500/(Rupees twenty-six lakhs, forty-nine thousand and five hundred)
only, in MACT Case No. 7 of 2016 on 29.11.2016, the instant Appeal
assails the award of the learned Claims Tribunal on the following
grounds;
i. That, the multiplier adopted by the learned Claims
Tribunal was „18‟, instead of „17‟, in terms of the ratio in
Sarla
Verma
(Smt.)
and
Others
vs.
Delhi
Transport
Corporation and Another1, as the age of the deceased on
the date of accident was 27 years.
ii. That,
the
learned
Claims
Tribunal
erred
in
not
considering that the deceased was a bachelor and
deducted one-third only towards personal and living
(2009) 6 SCC 121
MAC App. 1 of 2017
The Branch Manager, United India Insurance Company Limited
vs. Mr. Subash Rai & Others
expenses of the deceased, when a deduction of 50%
was appropriate, as laid down in Sarla Verma1.
2.
Learned Counsel for the Respondents No. 1 to 6, fairly
conceded that the choice of multiplier ought to have been „17‟, as
the victim was 27 years at the relevant time. However, the
argument pertaining to 50% deduction was vehemently contested,
inter alia, on the ground that the deceased has parents and four
siblings, who are dependent on him. That, the father is aged about
50 years, while the mother is aged about 48 years and both are
struggling with several physical ailments and are unable to earn a
living. Consequently, both parents and siblings have lost their bread
winner. Relying on the ratio of Sarla Verma1, it was pointed out that
the Judgment specifically provides at Paragraph 30, that deduction
towards living expenses ought to be calculated on the basis of the
dependents. As the deceased had six dependents, the deduction
ought to have been calculated accordingly and that in fact, the
learned Claims Tribunal was in error in deducting one-third towards
living
expenses
of
the
deceased,
without
considering
his
dependents.
No submissions were made by learned Counsel for the
Respondent No.7.
3.
Having heard the parties and on admission of learned
Counsel for the Respondents No. 1 to 6, with regard to the
multiplier, no further discussion need ensue on this point and the
matter is accordingly settled, inasmuch as the multiplier to be
adopted shall be „17‟ in terms of the ratiocination in Sarla Verma1.
MAC App. 1 of 2017
The Branch Manager, United India Insurance Company Limited
4.
vs. Mr. Subash Rai & Others
I now limit myself to the question of 50% deduction, for
which it not necessary to delve into the facts of the case. Suffice it
to say that admittedly the deceased was a bachelor at the time of
the accident, on account of which he met his death on the
intervening night of 29.12.2015 to 30.12.2015, near Makha, East
Sikkim, while he was travelling from Mangan to Singtam, in a
vehicle Maruti Alto, bearing Registration No. SK-03-T-0170, driven
by one Budhi Raj Subba.
5.
In Sarla Verma1, which was also upheld in the decision of
Munna Lal Jain and Another vs. Vipin Kumar Sharma and Others2, it was
held at Paragraphs 30 and 31, as follows;
“30. Though in some cases the deduction to
be made towards personal and living expenses is
calculated on the basis of units indicated in Trilok
Chandra [(1996) 4 SCC 362], the general practice is to
apply standardised deductions. Having considered
several subsequent decisions of this Court, we are of
the view that where the deceased was married the
deduction towards personal and living expenses of
the deceased, should be one-third (1/3rd) where the
number of dependent family members is 2 to 3, onefourth (1/4th) where the number of dependent family
members is 4 to 6, one-fifth (1/5th) where the
number of dependent family members exceeds six.”
31.
When the deceased was a bachelor and
the claimants are the parents, the deduction follows a
different principle. In regard to bachelors, normally,
50% is deducted as personal and living expenses,
because it is assumed that a bachelor would tend to
spend more on himself. Even otherwise, there is also
the possibility of his getting married in a short time,
in which event the contribution to the parent(s) and
siblings is likely to be cut drastically. Further, subject
to evidence to the contrary, the father is likely to
have his own income and will not be considered as a
dependent and the mother alone will be considered as
a dependant. In the absence of evidence to the
contrary, brothers and sisters will not be considered
as dependants, because they will either be
(2005) 6 SCC 347
MAC App. 1 of 2017
The Branch Manager, United India Insurance Company Limited
vs. Mr. Subash Rai & Others
independent and earning,
dependent on the father.”
6.
or
married,
or
be
Thus, it is clear that the mother only can be considered
as a dependent of her deceased bachelor son. The argument of the
Respondents that the deduction for living expenses of the deceased
ought to be based on the number of his dependents, flies in the face
of the settled position of law, in other words the deduction has to be
50% for personal and living expenses of the deceased, who was a
bachelor. His father and siblings cannot be considered as his
dependents.
7.
Although, it has been urged by learned Counsel for the
Respondents No. 1 to 6, that the legislation is a benevolent
legislation and should be extended accordingly. However, as per the
decision extracted supra, it is clear that siblings cannot be
considered as the responsibility of the deceased. Moreover, if we are
to take the retirement age of government servants as a yardstick, in
the case at hand, the father has not even stepped into the age of
retirement.
8.
The learned Counsel for the Respondents contended that
the learned Claims Tribunal was in error in granting a sum of
Rs.2500/- (Rupees two thousand & five hundred) only, towards Loss
of Estate, when it has been clearly laid down in the decision of
Kalpana Raj & Ors. vs. Tamil Nadu State Transport Corpn. 3 and Sandhya
Rani Debbarma & Ors. vs. National Insurance Company Ltd. & Anr. 4, that
(2015) 2 SCC 764
2016 (8) SCJ 775
MAC App. 1 of 2017
The Branch Manager, United India Insurance Company Limited
vs. Mr. Subash Rai & Others
the amount to be granted for such compensation ought to be
Rs.1,00,000/- (Rupees one lakh) only.
In view of the said decision, there is no reason to hold
9.
otherwise. Thus, a sum of Rs.1,00,000/- (Rupees one lakh) only, is
allowed as compensation towards Loss of Estate.
10.
Having considered the submissions of learned Counsel
on the aspects above and after perusing the records, the citation of
learned Counsel at the Bar and the impugned Judgment, I am of the
considered opinion that the compensation granted by the learned
Claims Tribunal is to be recalculated as follows;
Monthly income of the deceased
Rs.
12,000.00
Annual Income of the deceased (Rs.12,000/- x 12 months)
Rs. 1,44,000.00
Multiplier of ‘17’ adopted.
Rs.24,48,000.00
Add 50% of Rs.24,48,000/- as Future Prospects
Rs.12,24,000.00
Rs.36,72,000.00
Less 50% of Rs.36,72,000.00 as deceased was a Bachelor
Rs.18,36,000.00
Net yearly income
Rs.18,36,000.00
Add Funeral Expenses
Rs.
Add Loss of estate (in terms of the decision of Munna Lal)
Rs. 1,00,000.00
Add Cost of transportation of the body of the victim
Rs.
5,000.00
Add Non-pecuniary damages
Rs.
25,000.00
Total
=
25,000.00
Rs.19,91,000.00
(Rupees nineteen lakhs and ninety-one thousand) only.
11.
The Judgment of the learned Claims Tribunal stands
modified accordingly and Appeal is allowed to that extent.
MAC App. 1 of 2017
The Branch Manager, United India Insurance Company Limited
13.
Consequently,
the
vs. Mr. Subash Rai & Others
Appellant-Insurance
Company
is
directed to pay the awarded amount to the Respondent No.2, within
one month from today with interest @ 10% per annum, failing
which the Appellant-Insurance Company shall pay simple interest @
12% per annum, from the date of filing of the Claim Petition till full
realisation.
14.
Copy of this Judgment be sent to the Learned Motor
Accident Claims Tribunal, East Sikkim at Gangtok, for information.
15.
Records be remitted forthwith.
Sd/( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
12-07-2017
Approved for reporting : Yes
Internet : Yes
bp
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review