Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
DATED : 10th December, 2021
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
SINGLE BENCH : THE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I.A. No.01 of 2021 in MAC App. No.05 of 2021
:
Appellant
Branch Manager,
Shriram General Insurance Co. Ltd.
versus
Respondents
:
Sarada Devi and Others
Application for condonation of delay under second
proviso to Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. Rahul Rathi, Advocate for the Appellant.
Mr. Manish Kr. Jain, Advocate for the Respondents No.1 to 3.
Ms. Neetu Tamang, Advocate for Respondent No.4.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
O R D E R (ORAL)
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
I.A. No.01 of 2021 is an application seeking
condonation of 1897 (one thousand, eight hundred and ninety
seven) days delay in filing the Appeal. Learned Counsel for the
Appellant while advancing the grounds that contributed to the
delay submitted that the delay occurred on account of the fact
that
the
Judgment
Debtor/Opposite
Party
No.2/Appellant
herein, was unaware of the Award passed by the Learned
Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, East Sikkim, at Gangtok (for
short, “Learned Claims Tribunal”), in MACT Case No.21 of
2015, as it was an ex parte Judgment. It was only after three
years when the Respondents No.1 to 3 herein filed MACT
Execution Case No.02 of 2018 before the Learned Claims
I.A. No.01 of 2021 in MAC App. No.05 of 2021
Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Co. Ltd.
vs. Sarada Devi and Others
Tribunal that they came to learn of the matter.
That, the
Kolkata Branch Office after receiving the Notice in the
Execution proceedings forwarded the same to the Jaipur Head
Office for preferring the instant Appeal.
That, as per the
internal procedure, the Jaipur Head Officer sent back the File
to the Kolkata Division Office for appointing an Advocate in the
matter, but due to other practical problems the File took
considerable
time
to
reach
the
Kolkata
Branch
Office.
Thereafter, the Counsel engaged by the Appellant Company
could not file the Appeal due to personal pre-occupation and
subsequently,
resigned
Insurance Company.
from
the
empanelment
of
the
The present Counsel was appointed
thereafter on which he advised the Appellant Company to
prefer an Appeal and prepared the Memo of Appeal for which
he took some time.
Government
and
That, it is a settled position of law that
Government
Undertakings
have
been
permitted some flexibility in case of condonation of delay due
to the fact that it takes time to get papers processed in such
Offices.
It is urged that the reasons assigned in filing the
Appeal constitute sufficient cause and that there is no
deliberate delay. That, the Court may take a liberal approach
and condone the delay which is unintentional.
2.
Resisting the arguments of the Appellant, Learned
Counsel for the Respondents No.1 to 3 contended that in the
first instance the delay is of almost 5 (five) years. That,
despite Notice having been issued and duly received by the
Appellant Company in MACT Case No.21 of 2015 they failed to
appear before the Learned Claims Tribunal. That, the grounds
I.A. No.01 of 2021 in MAC App. No.05 of 2021
Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Co. Ltd.
vs. Sarada Devi and Others
given by the Appellant with regard to processing of Files does
not constitute sufficient grounds to condone delay.
That, in
the Execution Case receipt of Notice is not denied. However,
Notice in the MACT Case No.21 of 2015 was also issued in the
same address despite which the Appellant failed to enter an
appearance. That, instead of filing the Appeal on learning of
the Execution Case No.02 of 2018 they have filed it belatedly
on 12-03-2021 (resubmitted on 23-03-2021).
Hence, the
Petition deserves to be dismissed.
3.
I have heard the submissions of Learned Counsel
for the parties in extenso and duly perused the documents on
record.
4.
In the first instance, the Appellant Company claims
that they did not receive Notice in MACT Case No.21 of 2015,
consequently the Appellant was proceeded ex parte before the
Learned Claims Tribunal.
At this juncture, it would be
beneficial to refer to the provisions of Order IX Rule 6(1)(a) of
the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, which provides as follows;
“6. Procedure when only plaintiff appears.─(1)
…………………………………………………………………
(a)
When summons duly served.─If it is
proved that the summons was duly
served, the Court may make an
order that the suit be heard ex
parte;
…………………………………………………………………………”
5.
Evidently, the matter was proceeded ex parte on
the ground of non-appearance of the Appellant despite service
of summons.
The Appellant has not annexed any document
for the perusal of this Court to fortify their submissions that
they were unaware of the proceedings before the Learned
I.A. No.01 of 2021 in MAC App. No.05 of 2021
Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Co. Ltd.
vs. Sarada Devi and Others
Claims Tribunal, such an allegation cannot be believed or relied
upon without the benefit of perusing documents.
6.
The Appeal ought to have been filed within 90 days
from 30-09-2015, but has been filed only in the month of
March, 2021.
The grounds taken for the delay such as File
processing methods and movement of File from one Office to
the other are obnoxious to say the least. This Court cannot be
concerned with how the Office proceedings of the Appellant
Company are carried out. Suffice it to note that while carrying
out their administrative duties, the provisions of law cannot be
disregarded or given a go by especially when the provision is
benevolent legislation. No dates of File movement have been
revealed by the Appellant from the Kolkata Branch Office to
the Jaipur Head Office and thereafter back to the Kolkata
Division Office.
No dates are revealed with regard to the
application seeking a copy of the impugned Judgment, date of
receipt of Judgment and other relevant facts.
7.
It was urged that it is a settled position of law that
Government and Government Undertakings are permitted
some flexibility in cases of delay.
Company
is
neither
a
Admittedly, the Appellant
Government
Department
nor
a
Government Undertaking, hence the submissions of Learned
Counsel for the Appellant is to mislead this Court and cannot
be countenanced.
Indeed, this Court is aware of the
pronouncement in Office of the Chief Post Master General and
Ors. vs. Living Media India Ltd. & Anr. wherein the Supreme
Court in Paragraph 12 held as follows;
“12. It is not in dispute that the
person(s) concerned were well aware or
I.A. No.01 of 2021 in MAC App. No.05 of 2021
Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Co. Ltd.
vs. Sarada Devi and Others
conversant with the issues involved including the
prescribed period of limitation for taking up the
matter by way of filing a special leave petition in
this Court. They cannot claim that they have a
separate
period
of
limitation
when
the
Department was possessed with competent
persons familiar with court proceedings. In the
absence of plausible and acceptable explanation,
we are posing a question why the delay is to be
condoned mechanically merely because the
Government or a wing of the Government is a
party before us. Though we are conscious of the
fact that in a matter of condonation of delay
when there was no gross negligence or deliberate
inaction or lack of bona fide, a liberal concession
has to be adopted to advance substantial justice,
we are of the view that in the facts and
circumstances, the Department cannot take
advantage of various earlier decisions. The claim
on account of impersonal machinery and
inherited bureaucratic methodology of making
several notes cannot be accepted in view of the
modern technologies being used and available.
The law of limitation undoubtedly binds
everybody including the Government.”
The observation speaks for itself, even with regard to
Government Departments there is no blanket condonation of
delay. The Court is to exercise its discretion judiciously. No
Organisation can take advantage of its deliberate inaction and
the facts and circumstances pleaded by the Appellant for the
delay do not merit consideration.
8.
We may also refer beneficially to the observations
of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Esha Bhattacharjee vs.
Managing Committee of Raghunathpur Nafar Academy and Others 1.
In
the
ratio,
while
referring
to
various
authorities
on
condonation of delay the following points inter alia were
summarised as guiding principles for such condonation;
“21. From the aforesaid authorities the
principles that can broadly be culled out are:
…………………………………………………………………….
21.4. (iv) No presumption can be attached
to deliberate causation of delay but, gross
negligence on the part of the counsel or litigant
is to be taken note of.
(2013) 12 SCC 649
I.A. No.01 of 2021 in MAC App. No.05 of 2021
Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Co. Ltd.
vs. Sarada Devi and Others
21.5. (v) Lack of bona fides imputable to a
party seeking condonation of delay is a
significant and relevant fact.
…………………………………………………………………….
21.7. (vii) The concept of liberal approach
has
to
encapsule
the
conception
of
reasonableness and it cannot be allowed a
totally unfettered free play.
…………………………………………………………………….
21.9. (ix) The conduct, behaviour and
attitude of a party relating to its inaction or
negligence are relevant factors to be taken into
consideration. It is so as the fundamental
principle is that the courts are required to weigh
the scale of balance of justice in respect of both
parties and the said principle cannot be given a
total go by in the name of liberal approach.
21.10. (x) If the explanation offered is
concocted or the grounds urged in the
application are fanciful, the courts should be
vigilant
not
to
expose
the
other
side
unnecessarily to face such a litigation.
…………………………………………………………………….
22. To the aforesaid principles we may add
some more guidelines taking note of the present
day scenario. They are:
22.1. (a) An application for condonation of
delay should be drafted with careful concern and
not in a haphazard manner harbouring the notion
that the courts are required to condone delay on
the bedrock of the principle that adjudication of a
lis on merits is seminal to justice dispensation
system.
22.2. (b) An application for condonation of
delay should not be dealt with in a routine
manner on the base of individual philosophy
which is basically subjective.
22.3. (c) Though no precise formula can
be laid down regard being had to the concept of
judicial discretion, yet a conscious effort for
achieving consistency and collegiality of the
adjudicatory system should be made as that is
the ultimate institutional motto.
22.4. (d) The increasing tendency to
perceive delay as a non-serious matter and,
hence, lackadaisical propensity can be exhibited
in a nonchallant manner requires to be curbed,
of course, within legal parameters.”
[emphasis supplied]
These principles clearly enunciate the parameters which
Courts ought to consider while condoning delay.
9.
It is clear from the second proviso to Section 173
of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, that the High Court may
entertain the Appeal after expiry of the period of ninety days if
I.A. No.01 of 2021 in MAC App. No.05 of 2021
Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Co. Ltd.
vs. Sarada Devi and Others
it is satisfied that the Appellant was prevented by “sufficient
cause” from preferring the Appeal in time.
While explaining
what “sufficient cause” entails, the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
Basawaraj and Another vs. Special Land Acquisition Officer2 held
as follows;
“9.
Sufficient cause is the cause for
which the defendant could not be blamed for his
absence. The meaning of the word “sufficient” is
“adequate” or “enough”, inasmuch as may be
necessary to answer the purpose intended.
Therefore, the word “sufficient” embraces no
more than that which provides a platitude, which
when the act done suffices to accomplish the
purpose intended in the facts and circumstances
existing in a case, duly examined from the
viewpoint of a reasonable standard of a cautious
man. In this context, “sufficient cause” means
that the party should not have acted in a
negligent manner or there was a want of bona
fide on its part in view of the facts and
circumstances of a case or it cannot be alleged
that the party has “not acted diligently” or
“remained inactive”. However, the facts and
circumstances of each case must afford sufficient
ground to enable the court concerned to exercise
discretion for the reason that whenever the court
exercises discretion, it has to be exercised
judiciously. The applicant must satisfy the court
that he was prevented by any “sufficient cause”
from prosecuting his case, and unless a
satisfactory explanation is furnished, the court
should not allow the application for condonation
of delay. The court has to examine whether the
mistake is bona fide or was merely a device to
cover an ulterior purpose. (See Manindra Land
and Building Corpn. Ltd. v. Bhutnath Banerjee
[AIR 1964 SC 1336], Mata Dinv. A. Narayanan
[(1969) 2 SCC 770 : AIR 1970 SC 1953], Parimal
v. Veena [(2011) 3 SCC 545 : (2011) 2 SCC (Civ) 1 : AIR
2011 SC 1150] and Maniben Devraj Shah v.
Municipal Corpn. of Brihan Mumbai [(2012) 5 SCC
157 : (2012) 3 SCC (Civ) 24 : AIR 2012 SC 1629].)
10. In Arjun Singh v. Mohindra Kumar [AIR
this Court explained the difference
between a “good cause” and a “sufficient cause”
and observed that every “sufficient cause” is a
good cause and vice versa. However, if any
difference exists it can only be that the
requirement of good cause is complied with on a
lesser degree of proof than that of “sufficient
cause”.
1964 SC 993]
(2013) 14 SCC 81
I.A. No.01 of 2021 in MAC App. No.05 of 2021
Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Co. Ltd.
vs. Sarada Devi and Others
11. The expression “sufficient cause”
should be given a liberal interpretation to ensure
that substantial justice is done, but only so long
as negligence, inaction or lack of bona fides
cannot be imputed to the party concerned,
whether or not sufficient cause has been
furnished, can be decided on the facts of a
particular case and no straitjacket formula is
possible. (Vide Madanlal v. Shyamlal [(2002) 1 SCC
535 : AIR 2002 SC 100] and Ram Nath Sao v.
Gobardhan Sao [(2002) 3 SCC 195 : AIR 2002 SC
1201].)
12. It is a settled legal proposition that
law of limitation may harshly affect a particular
party but it has to be applied with all its rigour
when the statute so prescribes. The court has no
power to extend the period of limitation on
equitable grounds. “A result flowing from a
statutory provision is never an evil. A court has
no power to ignore that provision to relieve
what it considers a distress resulting from its
operation.” The statutory provision may cause
hardship or inconvenience to a particular party
but the court has no choice but to enforce it
giving full effect to the same. The legal
maxim dura lex sed lex which means “the law is
hard but it is the law”, stands attracted in such a
situation. It has consistently been held that,
“inconvenience is not” a decisive factor to be
considered while interpreting a statute.
13. The statute of limitation is founded
on public policy, its aim being to secure peace in
the community, to suppress fraud and perjury, to
quicken diligence and to prevent oppression. It
seeks to bury all acts of the past which have not
been agitated unexplainably and have from lapse
of time become stale. According to Halsbury's
Laws of England, Vol. 28, p. 266:
“605. Policy of the Limitation Acts.—
The courts have expressed at least three
differing reasons supporting the existence
of statutes of limitations namely, (1) that
long dormant claims have more of cruelty
than justice in them, (2) that a defendant
might have lost the evidence to disprove a
stale claim, and (3) that persons with good
causes of actions should pursue them with
reasonable diligence.”
An unlimited limitation would lead to a sense of
insecurity and uncertainty, and therefore,
limitation prevents disturbance or deprivation of
what may have been acquired in equity and
justice by long enjoyment or what may have
been lost by a party's own inaction, negligence or
laches. (See Popat and Kotecha Property v. SBI
Staff Assn. [(2005) 7 SCC 510], Rajender Singh v.
Santa Singh [(1973) 2 SCC 705 : AIR 1973 SC 2537]
and Pundlik Jalam Patil v. Jalgaon Medium
Project [(2008) 17 SCC 448 : (2009) 5 SCC (Civ) 907].)”
[emphasis supplied]
I.A. No.01 of 2021 in MAC App. No.05 of 2021
Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Co. Ltd.
vs. Sarada Devi and Others
The parameters discussed in the ratio of Basawaraj and
Another (supra) in the context of “sufficient cause” is obviously
not fulfilled in the instant matter as obtains from the grounds
put forth by the Appellant Company, which have been
extracted supra.
10.
The conduct of the Appellant discloses not only
irresponsibility but total disregard for the law and callousness
towards the Respondents No.1 to 3.
Their circumstances of
financial difficulty, which the provisions of the Motor Vehicles
Act, 1988 seeks to mitigate to an extent have not even been
considered.
This Court is indeed conscious that it would be
impossible to ameliorate the mental and emotional trauma of
the Respondents No.1 to 3, by way of pecuniary compensation,
nevertheless it is an effort by benevolent legislation to at least
compensate the financial aspect of the loss.
The Appellant
Company ought to bear in mind the spirit of the Act and the
circumstances it seeks to address. The grounds for delay put
forth by the Appellant Company are absolutely frivolous devoid
of substance and deserves to be and is accordingly dismissed.
11.
The Appellant shall pay total cost of Rs.25,000/-
(Rupees twenty five thousand) only, to the Respondents No.1
to 3, within a month from today, failing with they shall pay
interest @ 10% per annum on the above amount.
12.
Copy of this Order be transmitted to the Learned
Claims Tribunal for information.
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
10-12-2021
ds
Approved for reporting : Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review