Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
DATED: 26.10.2018
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : THE HON’BLE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE, MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MAC App. No. 10 of 2017
Appellant
:
The Branch Manager,
Shriram General Insurance Company
Limited,
Having its Branch Office at
142/14 Sevoke Road, 1st Floor,
Opposite PAN Card Office,
Beside Raymond Showroom,
District Darjeeling,
Siliguri, West Bengal.
versus
Respondents
:
1.
Mr. Churamani Sharma,
Son of late Dilli Ram Sharma.
2.
Smt. Pushpa Devi Sharma,
Wife of Mr. Churamani Sharma.
Both are residents of
Padamchey Busty,
P.O. Pachak, P.S. Pakyong,
East Sikkim.
3.
Mrs. Neelam Chettri,
Wife of Kumar Chettri,
Resident of Pacheykhani,
Pakyong, East Sikkim.
(Owner of vehicle SK-01-D/1001).
Appeal under Section 173 of the
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988
----------------------------------------------------------Appearance:
Mr. Yadev Sharma and Mr. Dilip Kumar Tamang, Advocates
for the Appellant.
Mrs. Vidya Lama and Mr. Nima Tshering Sherpa, Advocates
for Respondents No. 1 and 2.
Mr. Rajendra Upreti, Advocate for Respondent No. 3.
-----------------------------------------------------------
MAC App. No. 10 of 2017
The Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Company Limited Vs.
Mr. Churamani Sharma and Others
JUDGMENT
Meenakshi Madan Rai, ACJ
1.
The Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, East Sikkim at
Gangtok (for short 'learned Tribunal'), vide the impugned
Judgment and Award dated 22.02.2017 in MACT Case No. 51
of 2015, directed the Appellant to pay a sum of Rs.6,72,500/(Rupees six lakhs, seventy two thousand and five hundred)
only, with interest at the rate of 10% per annum, on the said
sum, to the Respondents No. 1 and 2, from the date of filing
of the Claim Petition i.e. 21.12.2015, till full and final
payment.
2.
Aggrieved by the
said Judgment
and Award, the
Appellant is before this Court assailing both, on one ground
viz. that the learned Tribunal wrongly computed the Notional
Income
of
the
deceased,
a
minor
aged
years
at
Rs.6,000/- (Rupees six thousand) only, per month. The other
grounds were not pressed in Appeal.
3.
The
Respondents
No.
and
herein,
were
the
Claimants No. 1 and 2 before the learned Tribunal. The
Appellant herein was the Opposite Party No. 2 and the
Respondent No. 3 herein was the Opposite Party No. 1 before
the learned Tribunal. They shall be referred to in their order of
appearance before this Court.
MAC App. No. 10 of 2017
The Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Company Limited Vs.
Mr. Churamani Sharma and Others
4.
Before the learned Tribunal, the Respondents No. 1 and
2, sought compensation amounting to Rs.12,21,604/- (Rupees
twelve lakhs, twenty one thousand, six hundred and four)
only, on account of the death of their son, aged 12 years, on
08.06.2014 at around 15:30 Hrs, in a motor vehicle accident
which occurred at Padamchey, about 12 kilometres south of
Pakyong Police Station, Pakyong, East Sikkim.
5.
The only argument accentuated by learned Counsel for
the Appellant is that as the child was 12 years old at the time
of the accident, hence, the learned Tribunal was in error in
computing the compensation on the assumption that the loss
of earning of the victim would be Rs.6,000/- (Rupees six
thousand) only, per month. Seeking a modification of the
compensation, attention was drawn to the decision of this
Court in MAC App. No. 23 of 2015 (The Branch Manager,
National Insurance Company Limited vs. Mr. Pankaj Kumar
Balabhai Kapadia and Others), which while considering an
Appeal filed by the Insurance Company where the learned
Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, North Sikkim at Mangan had
awarded a compensation of Rs.6,17,500/- (Rupees six lakhs,
seventeen thousand and five hundred) only, to the Claimants
No. 1 and 3, held that so far as the children between the age
group of 10 to 15 years were concerned, their Notional
Income was to be assessed at Rs.24,000/- (Rupees twenty
four thousand) only, per annum and the Multiplier of 15 was
MAC App. No. 10 of 2017
The Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Company Limited Vs.
Mr. Churamani Sharma and Others
found to be appropriate. This was in view of the decision of
the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Lata Wadhwa and
Others vs. State of Bihar and Others1. That the same consideration
may be adopted while disposing of the instant Appeal.
6.
Learned Counsel for the Respondents No. 1 and 2 would
submit that the loss of a child cannot be calculated in
pecuniary terms and no error obtains in the Judgment and
Award computed by the learned Tribunal which ought to be
left undisturbed.
7.
I have considered the submissions of learned Counsel
for the parties. I have also perused the documents and
evidence on record.
8.
The facts, as unfurled, reveal that the victim, son of the
Respondents No. 1 and 2, aged 12 years was travelling from
his residence at Padamchey on 08.06.2014, in vehicle bearing
No. SK-01-D/1001, to the construction site of his uncle when
the unfortunate accident occurred at Padamchey, about 12
kilometres south of Pakyong Police Station, Pakyong, East
Sikkim which claimed his life.
9.
It is not denied by either party that the deceased was 12
years old at the time of his death and studying in Class VI in a
(2001) 8 SCC 197
MAC App. No. 10 of 2017
The Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Company Limited Vs.
Mr. Churamani Sharma and Others
Government Secondary School in Padamchey, Pakyong, East
Sikkim.
10.
In MAC App. No. 23 of 2015 referred to supra, this Court
was examining the award of compensation of a sum of
Rs.6,17,500/- (Rupees six lakhs, seventeen thousand and five
hundred) only, to the Respondents No. 1, 2 and 3, the parents
and sibling respectively of the victim aged about eight years
by the learned Tribunal, her Notional Income having been
computed at Rs.6,000/- (Rupees six thousand) only, per
month. This Court took into consideration the ratiocination in
Lata Wadhwa's case supra, and inter alia held as follows;
“...(7) In Lata Wadhwa's case (supra), while
considering compensation for children who had died
during celebrations within the Tata Iron and Steel
Company (TISCO) factory in a devastating fire which
had engulfed the VIP Pandal, the assessment of
compensation to children was made after dividing them
into groups based on their age. The first group was
between the age of 5 to 10 years and the second group
between the age of 10 to 15 years. In case of children
between the age group of 5 to 10 years, a uniform sum
of Rs.50,000/- was held to be payable by way of
compensation to which the conventional figure of
Rs.25,000/- was added and as such a consolidated sum
of Rs.75,000/- each was awarded. These amounts had
been arrived at on calculations made by Shri Justice Y.V.
Chandrachud. The Hon'ble Apex Court while considering
the said compensation was of the opinion that the
amount for the children between the age group of 5 to
10 years should be three times over the suggested
amount, in other words, it sould be Rs.1.5 lakhs to
which the conventional figure of Rs.50,000/- was added
making it a total of Rs.2 lakhs for each of the children.
(8)
So far as the children between the age group of
10 to 15 years were concerned, they were all students
of Class 6 to Class 10 and children of employees of
TISCO, which has a tradition of employing one child of
its employee, in the Company. Having regard to these
facts, in their case, the contribution of Rs.12,000/- per
annum was found to be on the lower side and the
contribution was calculated to be Rs.24,000/-. The
multiplier of '15' was found to be appropriate. What is
apparent from the decisions supra is that the amount of
compensation for children between the age of 5 to 10
years was assessed at a total amount of Rs.2,00,000/(Rupees two lakhs) only, while for children between the
MAC App. No. 10 of 2017
The Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Company Limited Vs.
Mr. Churamani Sharma and Others
age group of 10 to 15 years, another assessment was
made. ...”
11.
In Kishan Gopal and Another vs. Lala and Others2, the Hon’ble
Supreme Court while relying on the decision in Lata Wadhwa
supra also took into consideration the Notional Income for
compensation of those who had no income prior to the
accident as laid down in the Second Schedule of Section 163-A
of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, at clause 6 and inter alia held
as follows;
“… In our considered view, the aforesaid legal principle
laid down in Lata Wadhwa’s case with all fours is
applicable to the facts and circumstances of the case in
hand having regard to the fact that the deceased was 10
years old, who was assisting the appellants in their
agricultural occupation which is an undisputed fact. We
have also considered the fact that the rupee value has
come down drastically from the year 1994, when the
notional income of the non-earning member prior to the
date of accident was fixed at Rs.15,000/-. Further, the
deceased boy, had he been alive would have certainly
contributed substantially to the family of the appellants
by working hard. In view of the aforesaid reasons, it
would be just and reasonable for us to take his notional
income at Rs.30,000/- and further taking the young age
of the parents, namely the mother who was about 36
years old, at the time of accident, by applying the legal
principles laid down in the case of Sarla Verma v. Delhi
Transport Corporation [2009 6 SCC 121], the multiplier
of 15 can be applied to the multiplicand. Thus, 30,000/x15=4,50,000 and 50,000/- under conventional heads
towards loss of love and affection, funeral expenses, last
rites as held in Kerala SRTC v. Susamma Thomas [1994
2 SCC 176], which is referred to in Lata Wadhwa’s case
and the said amount under the conventional heads is
awarded even in relation to the death of children
between 10 to 15 years old. In this case also we award
Rs.50,000/- under conventional heads. In our view, for
the aforesaid reasons the said amount would be fair,
just and reasonable compensation to be awarded in
favour of the appellants. …”
12.
It may appositely be stated here that in Lata Wadhwa's
case, the amount of compensation for children between the
age group of 10 to 15 was assessed at Rs.4,10,000/- (Rupees
(2014) 1 SCC 244
MAC App. No. 10 of 2017
The Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Company Limited Vs.
Mr. Churamani Sharma and Others
four lakhs and ten thousand) only, inasmuch as the minor’s
contribution was assessed as
Rs.24,000/- (Rupees twenty
four thousand) only, per annum,
the appropriate Multiplier of
15 was adopted and the compensation so calculated was
Rs.3,60,000/- (Rupees three lakhs and sixty thousand) only,
to which an additional sum of Rs.50,000/- (Rupees fifty
thousand) only, was added on account of conventional heads.
13.
In consideration of the aforesaid ratiocinations, it would
not be incorrect to reach a finding that the Notional Income of
the victim ought to be assessed at Rs.30,000/- (Rupees thirty
thousand) only, per annum, his age being 12 years at the time
of accident. There is no error in the adoption of the Multiplier
of 15 as per the table in the case of Sarla Verma (Smt.) and Others
vs. Delhi Transport Corporation and Another3 as also the decison in
Amrit Bhanu Shali and Others vs. National Insurance Company Limited and
Others4 wherein it was held that the age of the victim should be
taken into consideration for choice of Multiplier and not that of
the Claimants.
14.
Thus, in light of the above discussions and findings, the
compensation stands re-calculated and modified as follows;
Yearly Notional Income of the deceased
30,000 x 15
= Rs.4,50,000.00
50,000
=
Loss of love and affection, funeral
expenses and last rites
Total
(2009) 6 SCC 121
(2012) 11 SCC 738
Rs.50,000.00
Rs.5,00,000.00
MAC App. No. 10 of 2017
The Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Company Limited Vs.
Mr. Churamani Sharma and Others
(Rupees five lakhs) only
15.
The Respondents No. 1 and 2 shall be entitled to simple
interest @ 9% per annum on the above amount with effect
from the date of filing of the Claim Petition before the learned
Tribunal, until its full realisation.
16.
The Appellant is directed to pay the awarded amount to
the Respondents No. 1 and 2 within one month from today,
failing which, the Appellant shall pay simple interest @ 12%
per annum from the date of filing of the Claim Petition till
realisation, duly deducting the amounts, if any, already paid
by the Appellant to the Respondents No. 1 and 2.
17.
The impugned Judgment and Award of the learned
Tribunal stands modified accordingly, and Appeal is allowed to
that extent.
18.
No order as to costs.
19.
Copy of this Judgment be sent to the learned Tribunal
and its records be remitted forthwith.
(Meenakshi Madan Rai)
Acting Chief Justice
26.10.2018
Approved for reporting: Yes
Internet: Yes
ml
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review