Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
DATED : 17th September, 2018
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : THE HON’BLE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I.A. No.01 of 2018 in MAC App. No.08 of 2018
Appellant
:
The Branch Manager,
Shriram General Insurance Co. Ltd.
versus
Respondents
:
Dik Bir Damai and Others
and
I.A. No.01 of 2018 in MAC App. No.09 of 2018
Appellant
:
The Branch Manager,
Shriram General Insurance Co. Ltd.
versus
Respondents
:
Bhoj Kumar Chettri and Others
Applications under Section 173(1) of the Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988 read with Section 151
of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. Yadev Sharma and Mr. Dilip Kr. Tamang, Advocates for the
Appellant-Insurance Company.
Mr. Ashok Pradhan, Advocate for the Respondents-Claimants.
Ms. Pritima Sunam, Advocate for the Respondent-Owner.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
O R D E R (ORAL)
Meenakshi Madan Rai, ACJ
1.
Since the grounds put forth for the delay in the two
Petitions are identical and arise out of the same accident they are
I.As No. 01 of 2018 in MAC App. Nos.08 and 09 of 2018
The Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Co. Ltd.
vs. Dik Bir Damai and Others
being disposed of by this common Order. It is pertinent to mention
here that the Learned Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, West Sikkim,
at Gyalshing (for short “Learned Claims Tribunal”), passed two
separate Judgments being MACT Case No.36 of 2016 and MACT
Case No.33 of 2016, both dated 28-12-2017 as the RespondentsClaimants were different families in the cases supra.
2.
The Appellant/Applicant is before this Court seeking
condonation of fifty days’ delay in filing both the Appeals.
The
grounds being put forth for the delay are inter alia as under;
(i)
The impugned Judgment was pronounced on 28-122017, copies thereof were forwarded to the AppellantCompany through the Learned Claims Tribunal on 2912-2017 via e-mail. After receiving the said e-mail, the
Appellant immediately applied for the certified copies on
03-02-2018, which were ready on 06-02-2018.
(ii)
The Kolkata Branch on receipt of the copies thereof
forwarded the matter to the Jaipur Head Office for
preferring the Appeals.
(iii)
As per the internal procedure, the Jaipur Head Office
again sent back the Files to the Kolkata Division Office
for appointing an Advocate for defending the cases.
(iv)
Due
to
other
practical
problem,
the
Files
took
considerable amount of time to reach the Kolkata
Branch and finally the Appellant appointed the Counsel
for defending the same.
3.
That the reasons assigned constitute sufficient cause
and there being no deliberate delay, it is urged that this Court take
a liberal approach in condoning the delay.
That, it is a settled
I.As No. 01 of 2018 in MAC App. Nos.08 and 09 of 2018
The Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Co. Ltd.
vs. Dik Bir Damai and Others
proposition of law that Government and Government Undertakings
have been permitted some flexibility in case of condonation of delay
and the Hon’ble Supreme Court as well as High Courts have upheld
the said view in condoning delay. That, the Appellant has a good
case and will suffer irreparable loss and injury if the delay in filing
the Appeals are not condoned.
4.
Learned Counsel for the Respondents-Claimants while
vehemently objecting to the Petitions would contend that in the first
instance although the delay was of “fifty days” the Appellant has in a
most negligent manner computed the delay to be of “fifteen days” in
the Petitions indicating their utter callousness in the matter. That,
although it is true that the Court can exercise its discretion in
condoning delay, nevertheless delay is required to be explained
sufficiently as laid down by the provision of law invoked by the
Appellant.
In the instant matters, the Appellant has failed to put
forth any substantial grounds for the occurrence of the delay and
has also not specified the dates pertaining to the movement of the
Files to enable assessment of the authenticity of the claims. That,
in other matters pertaining to the same accident, the Appellant has
released the amounts due to the Claimants, but has adopted a
merciless attitude in the instant matters shorn of reasons. That, the
legislation being beneficial, the Claimants ought not to suffer despite
the compensation having been granted to them, and the grounds
taken in the Petitions being frivolous, deserve a dismissal.
5.
Learned Counsel for the Respondent-Owner advanced no
submissions.
I.As No. 01 of 2018 in MAC App. Nos.08 and 09 of 2018
The Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Co. Ltd.
6.
Counsel
vs. Dik Bir Damai and Others
I have considered the opposing submissions of Learned
for
the
parties
and
also perused all documents on
record.
7.
The cardinal point in condoning delay is that the Court
ought to be satisfied that the Appellant was prevented by sufficient
cause in preferring the Appeal on time. It is also settled law that
the Appellant has to put forth bona fide grounds for the delay
besides establishing that there was no negligence on their part in
initiating steps.
The length of the delay is not the consideration
while exercising discretion by the Courts, in certain circumstances, a
delay of one day may not be condoned lacking acceptable
explanation, whereas in other cases inordinate delays can be
condoned if the explanation afforded is satisfactory. In other words,
each case is distinguishable from the next and must exhibit some
bona fides and grounds for exercise of discretion by the Court tilted
in favour of the Appellant/Petitioner. In a plethora of Judgments the
Hon’ble Supreme Court has held that sufficient cause should be
given a liberal interpretation to ensure that substantial justice is
done, but that is only so long as negligence, inaction or lack of bona
fides cannot be imputed to the party concerned.
That, while
considering a Petition for condonation of delay it is relevant to bear
in mind that the expiration of the period of limitation prescribed for
making an Appeal gives rise to a right in favour of the decreeholder. That, this right which has thus accrued should not be lightly
disturbed on account of a lapse of time.
I.As No. 01 of 2018 in MAC App. Nos.08 and 09 of 2018
The Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Co. Ltd.
8.
In
Esha
Bhattacharjee
vs.
vs. Dik Bir Damai and Others
Managing
Committee
of
Raghunathpur Nafar Academy and Others1 the Hon’ble Supreme Court
while enunciating the principles applicable to an application for
condonation of delay would inter alia hold as hereinbelow extracted;
“21. From the aforesaid authorities
principles that can broadly be culled out are:
the
……………………………………………………………………….
21.4. (iv) No presumption can be attached to
deliberate causation of delay but, gross negligence on
the part of the counsel or litigant is to be taken note of.
21.5. (v) Lack of bona fides imputable to a party
seeking condonation of delay is a significant and
relevant fact.
……………………………………………………………………….
21.7. (vii) The concept of liberal approach has
to encapsule the conception of reasonableness and it
cannot be allowed a totally unfettered free play.
……………………………………………………………………….
21.9. (ix) The conduct, behaviour and attitude
of a party relating to its inaction or negligence are
relevant factors to be taken into consideration. It is so
as the fundamental principle is that the courts are
required to weigh the scale of balance of justice in
respect of both parties and the said principle cannot be
given a total go by in the name of liberal approach.
21.10. (x) If the explanation offered is
concocted or the grounds urged in the application are
fanciful, the courts should be vigilant not to expose the
other side unnecessarily to face such a litigation.
……………………………………………………………………….
22. To the aforesaid principles we may add
some more guidelines taking note of the present day
scenario. They are:
22.1. (a) An application for condonation of delay
should be drafted with careful concern and not in a
haphazard manner harbouring the notion that the
courts are required to condone delay on the bedrock of
the principle that adjudication of a lis on merits is
seminal to justice dispensation system.
………………………………………………………………….”
(2013) 12 SCC 649
I.As No. 01 of 2018 in MAC App. Nos.08 and 09 of 2018
The Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Co. Ltd.
9.
vs. Dik Bir Damai and Others
On the bedrock of the aforesaid principles, we may now
examine the grounds put forth by the Appellant.
Admittedly, the
impugned Judgments were pronounced on 28-12-2017. It is also
undisputed that the Judgments were forwarded to the Appellant
through the Learned Claims Tribunal on 29-12-2017 via email.
Certified copies of the Judgment were however applied for by the
Appellant on 03-02-2018, after thirty-five days of pronouncement.
No explanation issues for such delay, despite copy being available to
the Appellant through email giving them sufficient notice to enable
initiation of steps.
That having been said, the next ground urged
was that the Kolkata Branch Office forwarded the same to the Jaipur
Head Office. Pausing here for a moment, it is apparent that no date
pertaining to this aspect has been revealed before this Court.
Thereafter, according to the Appellant, as per the internal procedure
the Files were sent back to the Kolkata Division by the Jaipur Head
Office for appointing an Advocate which also took some time.
No
dates or days are forthcoming herein as well. It is not denied by
Learned Counsel for the Appellant that he was representing the
Appellant before the Learned Claims Tribunal and was in the know of
the facts in dispute, therefore why the delay occurred in engaging a
Counsel is inexplicable in the absence of details. The date of
appointment of the Counsel has also not been stated. That apart,
practical problems that arose on various dates or the number of
days that elapsed while taking such steps are devoid in the
explanation furnished to this Court.
It is not disputed that the
impugned Judgments granted compensation to the RespondentsClaimants being the parents and other dependents of the deceased
I.As No. 01 of 2018 in MAC App. Nos.08 and 09 of 2018
The Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Co. Ltd.
vs. Dik Bir Damai and Others
who was earning and was contributing to the family expenses. It is
also not denied that the Respondents-Claimants were entitled to
compensation. If the Appellant was aggrieved by the alleged wrong
findings of the Learned Claims Tribunal on account of deductions
made and addition of future prospects the alternative open to the
Appellant was to approach this Court on time, and if done belatedly
furnish sufficient and bona fide reasons for the delay.
Relying on
precedents concerning Government Departments appears to be sans
reason as the Appellant has not put forth any ground to establish
that it is a Government Organisation or a Public Sector Undertaking.
By mere fact that it is an unwieldy Organisation and decisionmaking process cumbersome does not entitle the Appellant to
expect the Court to exercise discretion in their favour, when even
the Petition which ought to mention delay of “fifty days” has been
reflected as “fifteen days” showing haphazard drafting of the Petition
with no attention to what is infact the pivotal point.
The grounds
for delay lack in bona fides and do not reveal as to how the
Appellant was prevented by sufficient cause in approaching the
Court or how the circumstances were beyond the control of the
Appellant.
Indeed the legislation invoked by the Respondents is
benevolent and for the welfare of the family/dependents of the
deceased/victim and, in my considered opinion, should not be kept
in limbo for the inaction of the Appellant manifesting as injustice to
the Respondents-Claimants when compensation for the loss of a
member of the family has been computed and granted.
I.As No. 01 of 2018 in MAC App. Nos.08 and 09 of 2018
The Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Co. Ltd.
10.
vs. Dik Bir Damai and Others
In view of the gamut of facts and circumstances put
forth for the delay, it is but relevant to opine that the Petitions have
been filed with a nonchalant attitude reflecting negligence, inaction
and lack of bona fides and being devoid of merit do not deserve the
indulgence of this Court.
Consequently, I am not inclined to
exercise the discretion vested in this Court, in favour of the
Appellant.
11.
Petitions for condonation of delay are rejected and
disposed of as also the Appeals.
12.
No order as to costs.
13.
Records be remitted forthwith.
Sd/-
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Acting Chief Justice
17-09-2018
Approved for reporting : Yes
Internet : Yes
ds
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review