Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
DATED: 26.04.2019
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MAC App. No. 03 of 2017
Appellant
:
The Branch Manager,
Shriram General Insurance Co. Ltd.,
Branch Office 142/14 Sevoke Road,
1st Floor,
Opposite PAN Card Office,
Beside Raymond Showroom,
Siliguri, District Darjeeling,
West Bengal.
versus
Respondents
:
1.
Mrs. Krishna Kumari Limboo,
Wife of Late Jeetendra Limboo.
2.
Master Aamindra Limboo,
S/o Late Jeetendra Limboo.
3.
Miss Aaminma Limboo,
D/o Late Jeetendra Limboo.
[Residents of Hee Gaon,
P.O. Hee Gaon, P.S. Kaluk,
West Sikkim].
4.
Shri Moni Prasad Gurung,
S/o Shri Laxmi Prasad Gurung,
Resident of Begha Busty,
P.O. Dentam, P.S. Kaluk,
West Sikkim.
(Owner of vehicle SK-02J/1030)
Appeal under Section 173 of the
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988
---------------------------------------------------------------Appearance:
Mr. Yadev Sharma and Mr. Dilip Tamang, Advocates for the
Appellant.
Mr. N. Rai, Senior Advocate with Ms. Tamanna Chhetri and Mr.
K.B. Chettri, Advocates for Respondents No. 1, 2 and 3.
Mr. Yogesh Gurung, Advocate for Respondent No. 4.
---------------------------------------------------------------
MAC App. No. 03 of 2017
The Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Company Limited Vs. Smt. Krishna Kumari Limboo & Ors.
JUDGMENT
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J
1.
Assailing the quantification of compensation placed at
Rs.40,80,000/- (Rupees forty lakhs and eighty thousand) only, by
the learned Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, East Sikkim at
Gangtok (hereinafter 'learned Tribunal'), in MACT Case No. 47 of
2015 (Mrs. Krishna Kumari Limboo and Others vs. Mr. Moni
Prasad Gurung and Others), vide Judgment dated 21.09.2016, the
Appellant is before this Court.
2.
The Respondents No. 1, 2 and 3 herein were the
Claimants No. 1, 2 and 3 and Respondent No. 4 was the Opposite
Party No. 1 before the learned Tribunal. The Appellant herein was
the Opposite Party No. 3 before the learned Tribunal. The parties
shall be referred to in their order of appearance before this Court.
3.
Placing his arguments for the Appellant, learned
Counsel would submit that before the learned Tribunal the
Respondent No. 1 has admitted in her cross-examination that she
had not filed “qualification details” of her late husband along with
the Claim Petition. That, nothing emanated in her evidence to
establish the educational level of the deceased qualifying him to
work as an Accountant under the Contractor, P.W.2 Keshab
Kumar Rai. That, apart from the Salary Certificate, Exhibit 12,
issued by the said Contractor showing the income of the deceased
as Rs.20,000/- (Rupees twenty thousand) only, per month, there
were no documents to prove that her deceased husband was
MAC App. No. 03 of 2017
The Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Company Limited Vs. Smt. Krishna Kumari Limboo & Ors.
working as an Accountant or drawing salary of the said amount.
That, Exhibit 12 was issued by P.W.2 after the accident had
occurred and is in all probability a false document reflecting an
enhanced
income
for
the
purposes
of
obtaining
higher
compensation. That, no transaction pertaining to the deceased
were shown by the Respondent No. 1 in support of his income. In
support of this contention, learned Counsel sought to draw
strength from the ratio in Sutinder Pal Singh Arora and others vs.
Ashok Kumar Jain and others . Hence, the impugned Judgment and
Award deserves to be set aside.
4.
Learned Counsel for the Respondents No. 1 to 3 would
on the other hand contend that the victim was working as an
Accountant under a Class I A, Government Contractor and earning
an amount of Rs.20,000/- (Rupees twenty thousand) only, per
month and hence when the Salary Certificate was issued by the
employer,
the
question
of
doubting
the
document
as
a
manufactured one is not tenable. That, the vehicle was insured
with the Appellant Company and the Insurance Policy was valid
from 19.04.2015 to the midnight of 18.04.2016. That no error
obtains in calculation made in the impugned Judgment and Award
of the learned Tribunal, hence the Appeal be dismissed.
5.
I have heard in extenso and considered the rival
submissions of learned Counsel for the parties. I have also
carefully
perused
the
impugned
documents and evidence on record.
2004 ACJ 782
Judgment
including
the
MAC App. No. 03 of 2017
The Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Company Limited Vs. Smt. Krishna Kumari Limboo & Ors.
6.
Briefly the facts of the case are that the deceased,
husband of the Respondent No. 1 and father of Respondents No.
2 and 3, aged about 33 years, was allegedly employed as an
Accountant by one Keshab Kumar Rai, a Class IA Government
Contractor,
Dentam,
West
Sikkim
and
earning
Rs.20,000/-
(Rupees twenty thousand) only, per month. On 15.09.2015 he
was travelling in the vehicle bearing registration No. SK-02J/1030
to Gangtok, East Sikkim from Dentam, West Sikkim, which met
with an accident at “Kapuray Bhir,” Ranipool, East Sikkim. He
sustained head and chest injuries to which he succumbed on the
same day at Central Referral Hospital, Tadong, East Sikkim,
where he had been evacuated for treatment. Before the learned
Tribunal, the Respondents No. 1 to 3 sought compensation of
Rs.41,72,500/- (Rupees forty one lakhs, seventy two thousand
and five hundred) only, on account of his death in a motor
accident. This claim was denied and disputed by the Appellant
inter alia on grounds as already reflected hereinabove.
7.
The evidence of Respondent No. 1 to the effect that
the deceased was working as an Accountant of Shri Keshab
Kumar Rai (Government Contractor Class IA) and earning a
monthly income of Rs.20,000/- (Rupees twenty thousand) only,
was not demolished in cross-examination. Exhibit 12, the original
Salary Certificate issued by the said Keshab Kumar Rai was
furnished by her before the learned Tribunal. She has also
established that the employer was a Class IA Government
Contractor with sufficient work at hand by furnishing Exhibit 19,
MAC App. No. 03 of 2017
The Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Company Limited Vs. Smt. Krishna Kumari Limboo & Ors.
the attested copy of his Contractor Enlistment Form, Exhibit 20
being a Work Order dated 04.03.2014 issued by the Tourism and
Civil Aviation Department, Government of Sikkim amounting to
Rs.22,23,01,419/- (Rupees twenty two crores, twenty three
lakhs, one thousand, four hundred and nineteen) only, and Exhibit
21 another Work Order for Rs.1952.45 lakhs issued in the name
of P.W.2.
8.
Although it was stated by learned Counsel for the
Appellant that under cross-examination, Respondent No. 1 has
stated there are no “transaction details” to prove that her
deceased husband was drawing a salary of Rs.20,000/- (Rupees
twenty thousand) only, it is but apposite to state here that the
cross-examination does not specify which “transaction” reference
is being made to. The Counsel for the Appellant cannot expect the
Court to draw insinuations that the transaction details pertained
to Bank Accounts in the absence of specific cross-examination in
this context.
9.
Witness No. 2 for the Respondents No. 1 to 3,
(Keshab Kumar Rai), the employer of the deceased has also
substantiated the evidence of the victim's wife and his crossexamination does not demolish the fact of income of the deceased
as Rs.20,000/- (Rupees twenty thousand) only, per month. There
is no document on record to contradict the evidence of the income
of the deceased. Consequently although the Appellant asserts that
the income of the deceased has not been established, yet, the
Appellant itself has failed to furnish any document to establish to
MAC App. No. 03 of 2017
The Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Company Limited Vs. Smt. Krishna Kumari Limboo & Ors.
the contrary. Therefore in view of the evidence on record, the
income of the deceased is accepted as Rs.20,000/- (Rupees
twenty thousand) only, per month.
10.
So far as the question of compensation is concerned,
while computing the loss of income, the learned Tribunal rightly
adopted the Multiplier of “16” in terms of the approved table laid
down in Sarla Verma (Smt.) and Others vs. Delhi Transport
Corporation and Another2 as the age of the deceased was 33, as per
Exhibit 8, which document remained undecimated.
11.
The learned Tribunal has granted 50% of monthly
income while computing future prospects, on this point, in
National Insurance Company Limited vs. Pranay Sethi & Ors. 3, it was
held as follows;
“61. ...
(i) The
two-Judge
Bench
in Santosh
Devi should have been well advised to refer the
matter to a larger Bench as it was taking a different
view than what has been stated in Sarla Verma, a
judgment by a coordinate Bench. It is because a
coordinate Bench of the same strength cannot take
a contrary view than what has been held by
another coordinate Bench.
(ii) As Rajesh has not taken note of the
decision in Reshma Kumari, which was delivered at
earlier point of time, the decision in Rajesh is not a
binding precedent.
(iii) While determining the income, an
addition of 50% of actual salary to the income of
the deceased towards future prospects, where the
deceased had a permanent job and was below the
age of 40 years, should be made. The addition
should be 30%, if the age of the deceased was
between 40 to 50 years. In case the deceased was
between the age of 50 to 60 years, the addition
should be 15%. Actual salary should be read as
actual salary less tax.
(2009) 6 SCC 121
AIR 2017 SC 5157
MAC App. No. 03 of 2017
The Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Company Limited Vs. Smt. Krishna Kumari Limboo & Ors.
(iv) In case the deceased was selfemployed or on a fixed salary, an addition of
40% of the established income should be the
warrant where the deceased was below the
age of 40 years. An addition of 25% where the
deceased was between the age of 40 to 50 years
and 10% where the deceased was between the age
of 50 to 60 years should be regarded as the
necessary method of computation. The established
income means the income minus the tax
component.”
(Emphasis supplied)
12.
Hence, in view of the ratio supra of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court, it is evident that where the deceased was on a
fixed salary and below the age of 40 years, an addition of 40% of
the established income should be made towards future prospects.
Thus, 40% shall be calculated as future prospects instead of 50%
as calculated by the learned Tribunal.
13.
So far as loss of estate, loss of consortium and
funeral expenses are concerned, the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
Pranay Sethi (supra), inter alia held as follows;
“(viii)
Reasonable
figures
on
conventional heads, namely, loss of estate,
loss of consortium and funeral expenses
should
be
₹15,000/-,
₹40,000/and
₹15,000/- respectively.”
(Emphasis supplied)
Consequently Rs.15,000/- (Rupees fifteen thousand) only, is
granted towards funeral expenses, Rs.40,000/- (Rupees forty
thousand) only, granted towards loss of consortium and a sum of
Rs.15,000/- (Rupees fifteen thousand) only, granted towards loss
of estate, instead of Rs.25,000/- (Rupees twenty five thousand)
only, Rs.1,00,000/- (Rupees one lakh) only, and Rs.10,000/(Rupees ten thousand) only, respectively, granted by the learned
Tribunal under the aforestated heads.
MAC App. No. 03 of 2017
The Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Company Limited Vs. Smt. Krishna Kumari Limboo & Ors.
14.
With regard to the amount of Rs.5,000/- (Rupees five
thousand) only, having been granted towards “Transport from
hospital” is concerned, no documentary evidence has been
furnished by the Respondents No. 1 to 3, to support this claim.
Therefore, the Respondents No. 1 to 3 are not entitled to
compensation towards “Transport from hospital.”
15.
The question of compensation on account of loss of
love and affection granted by the learned Tribunal, in view of the
ratio supra is superfluous and is deducted from the compensation
amount.
16.
In conclusion, in light of the above discussions and
findings, the compensation stands re-calculated and modified and
is found to be just, as follows;
Monthly Income of the deceased
Rs.20,000.00
Annual Income of the deceased (Rs.20,000x12)
Rs.2,40,000.00
Add 40% of Rs.2,40,000.00 as future prospects
Rs.96,000.00
Yearly income of the deceased
Rs.3,36,000.00
Less 1/3 of Rs.3,36,000.00
[deducted from the said amount in consideration
of the instances which the victim would have
incurred towards maintenance had he been
alive.]
Rs.1,12,000.00
Net yearly income
Rs.2,24,000.00
Multiplier of ‘16’ adopted in terms of
Sarla Verma’s case (supra) (Rs.2,24,000 x 16)
Rs.35,84,000.00
Add Funeral expenses
Rs.15,000.00
Add Loss of consortium
Rs.40,000.00
Add Loss of estate
Rs.15,000.00
Total
(Rupees thirty six lakhs and fifty four thousand) only.
Rs.36,54,000.00
MAC App. No. 03 of 2017
The Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Company Limited Vs. Smt. Krishna Kumari Limboo & Ors.
17.
The Respondents No. 1, 2 and 3 shall be entitled to
simple interest @ 9% per annum on the above amount, with
effect from the date of filing of the Claim Petition before the
learned Tribunal, until its full realisation.
18.
The Appellant is directed to pay the awarded amount
to the Respondents No. 1, 2 and 3 within one month from today,
failing which, the Appellant shall pay simple interest @ 12% per
annum from the date of filing of the Claim Petition till realisation,
duly deducting the amounts, if any, already paid by the Appellant
to the Respondents No. 1, 2 and 3.
19.
Appeal allowed to the extent above.
20.
No order as to costs.
21.
Copy of this Judgment be sent to the learned Tribunal
for information.
22.
Records of the learned Tribunal be remitted forthwith.
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
26.04.2019
Approved for reporting: Yes
Internet: Yes
ml
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review