Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
DATED: 26.04.2019
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MAC App. No. 04 of 2017
Appellant
:
The Branch Manager,
Shriram General Insurance Co. Ltd.,
Branch Office 142/14 Sevoke Road,
1st Floor,
Opposite PAN Card Office,
Beside Raymond Showroom,
Siliguri, District Darjeeling,
West Bengal.
versus
Respondents
:
1.
Mrs. Kavita Rai,
Wife of Late Suddha Kumar Rai.
2.
Miss Angel Rai,
D/o Late Suddha Kumar Rai.
3.
Miss Rashi Rai,
D/o Late Suddha Kumar Rai.
[Residents of Begha Busty,
P.O. Dentam, P.S. Kaluk,
West Sikkim].
4.
Shri Moni Prasad Gurung,
S/o Shri Laxmi Prasad Gurung,
Resident of Begha Busty,
P.O. Dentam, P.S. Kaluk,
West Sikkim.
(Owner of vehicle SK-02J/1030)
Appeal under Section 173 of the
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988
-------------------------------------------------------Appearance:
Mr. Yadev Sharma, Advocate for the Appellant.
Mr. N. Rai, Senior Advocate with Ms. Tamanna Chhetri, Ms.
Malati Sharma and
Ms. Sudha Sewa, Advocates
for
Respondents No. 1, 2 and 3.
Mr. Yogesh Gurung, Advocate for Respondent No. 4.
--------------------------------------------------------
MAC App. No. 04 of 2017
The Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Company Limited Vs. Smt. Kavita Rai & Ors.
JUDGMENT
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J
1.
Quantification
Rs.79,20,000/-
(Rupees
of
seventy
the
compensation
nine
lakhs
and
of
twenty
thousand) only, payable by the Appellant to the Respondents
No. 1 to 3, is being assailed in this Appeal. The learned Motor
Accidents Claims Tribunal, East Sikkim at Gangtok (hereinafter
'learned Tribunal') in MACT Case No. 09 of 2016 (Mrs. Kavita
Rai and Others vs. Mr. Moni Prasad Gurung and Others),
granted the aforestated amount on account of the death of the
husband of Respondent No. 1 and father of Respondents No. 2
and 3, in a motor vehicle accident, on 15.09.2015. The claim
petition was filed by the Respondents No. 1 to 3 under Section
166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (hereinafter “M.V. Act”).
2.
The Respondents No. 1, 2 and 3 herein were the
Claimants No. 1, 2 and 3 and Respondent No. 4 was the
Opposite Party No. 1, while the Appellant herein was the
Opposite Party No. 3 before the learned Tribunal. The parties
shall be referred to in their order of appearance before this
Court.
3.
The case of the Respondents No. 1 to 3 before the
learned Tribunal was that on 15.09.2015, the victim was
travelling to Gangtok, East Sikkim from Dentam, West Sikkim
in the vehicle bearing Registration No. SK-02J/1030 (Tata
Sumo Gold) when it met with an accident at “Kapuray Bhir,”
MAC App. No. 04 of 2017
The Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Company Limited Vs. Smt. Kavita Rai & Ors.
Ranipool, East Sikkim and the deceased succumbed to his
injuries at Central Referral Hospital, Tadong, East Sikkim. That,
the cause of death was due to the rash and negligent act of the
driver.
That,
compensation
claimed
was
Rs.65,75,500/-
(Rupees sixty five lakhs, seventy five thousand and five
hundred) only, with interest at the rate of 10% per annum from
the date of filing of the claim petition.
The Appellant denied and disputed the claims of the
4.
Respondents No. 1 to 3 before the learned Tribunal inter alia on
grounds that the income of the deceased was not proved. It
was
also
agitated
that
Exhibit
the
“Panchayat
Recommendation”, Exhibit 13 the letter addressed to the Block
Development Officer by Gram Panchayat, 20 Dentam GPU,
West Sikkim and Exhibit 14 the income certificate issued by the
Block Development Officer, Dentam, showing the income of the
deceased as Rs.40,000/- (Rupees forty thousand) only, were
issued after the death of the deceased. That, the documents
were thus unreliable.
5.
The points pressed before this Court was that the
aforestated documents were procured after the death of the
deceased with the motive of acquiring enhanced compensation.
That, the income of the deceased has remained unestablished,
hence the quantum of compensation granted by the learned
Tribunal is exorbitant and the impugned Judgment and Award
deserves to be set aside. In support of his contention, learned
MAC App. No. 04 of 2017
The Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Company Limited Vs. Smt. Kavita Rai & Ors.
Counsel placed reliance on Sutinder Pal Singh Arora and others
vs. Ashok Kumar Jain and others1.
6.
Learned Senior Counsel for the Respondents No. 1
to 3 for his part contended that the Block Development Officer
who is a Government Officer has certified the income of the
deceased as Rs.40,000/- (Rupees forty thousand) only, per
month. That, he is the concerned authority who is empowered
to issue the Income Certificate, hence there is no reason to
doubt the document Exhibit 14. On this count, the ratio of this
Court in The Branch Manager, Oriental Insurance Company
Ltd. vs. Smt. Meena Bania and Others2 was relied on. That, the
vehicle was insured with the Appellant Company and the
Insurance
Policy
valid
from
19.04.2015
to
midnight
of
18.04.2016.
7.
I have heard in extenso and considered the rival
submissions of learned Counsel for the parties. I have also
carefully
perused
the
impugned
Judgment
including
the
documents and evidence on record.
8.
It is reiterated that the only grievance in this
Appeal is the quantum of compensation of Rs.79,20,000/(Rupees seventy nine lakhs and twenty thousand) only,
computed by the learned Tribunal, which according to the
Appellant is exorbitant. We may usefully refer to Exhibit 14 in
this context, which is a Certificate issued by the Block
2004 ACJ 782
(2012) 1 TAC 444
MAC App. No. 04 of 2017
The Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Company Limited Vs. Smt. Kavita Rai & Ors.
Development Officer, Office of the Block Administrative Center,
Dentam, duly certifying that the deceased, a resident of Begha,
Dentam passed away on 15/10/2015 in the vehicle accident at
32 mile near Singtam (sic). Further the existing income of
victim was around Rupees 40,000 per month as per his
personal properties and other sources of income. He was a
Class IIA Government Contractor and resourceful person.
9.
considering
In Meena Bania's case supra, this Court while
the
Income
Certificate
issued
by
the
Block
Development Officer had held as follows;
“17.1 Income certificate issued by
the BDO on agricultural income is a valid
and accepted document in the State of
Sikkim and the position is the same as
regards validity while being presented to
other authorities also. The BDO or the
Block Development Officer in a State is a
revenue authority and is competent under
the State Government Rules to issue such
certificates, a fact which this Court takes
judicial notice of.
In view of the above, the objection
raised on this account is clearly sustainable
(sic) and, therefore, stands rejected
accordingly.”
The finding of this Court in Meena Bania's case supra was also
cited with approval in Smt. Anita Sunam and others vs. Shri
Hom Nath Timshina and Another3.
10.
The evidence of Respondent No. 1 before the
learned Tribunal indicates that Exhibit 12 is the “Panchayat
Recommendation” regarding the profession and income of the
deceased and Exhibit 13 is the letter issued by the Gram
2013 SCC OnLine Sikk 67
MAC App. No. 04 of 2017
The Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Company Limited Vs. Smt. Kavita Rai & Ors.
Panchayat,
20-Dentam
GPU,
West
Sikkim
to
the
Block
Development Officer, Dentam, which indicates that the income
of the deceased was Rs.40,000/- (Rupees forty thousand) only,
per month. Exhibit 14 already extracted hereinabove was
issued
by
the
Block
Development
Officer.
The
cross-
examination of the Respondent No. 1 indicates that the fact of
the earnings of her husband could not be demolished. Although
it was argued that these documents were obtained after the
death of the deceased, it may be remarked that prior to that
there was indeed no necessity for such documents. It was only
on account of the tragic mishap that the requirement arose. It
is not the case of the Appellant that the Block Development
Officer is not empowered to issue the Income Certificate of the
deceased. He is indeed the concerned authority at the Block
Administrative
Level
to
issue
such
a
Certificate.
The
ratiocinations of this Court referred to supra lend credence to
this stand. In the absence of any document to the contrary,
Exhibit 14 is accepted as the correct information pertaining to
the income of the deceased.
11.
Witness No. 2 for the Respondents, Keshab Kumar
Rai, the brother of the deceased has also stated in crossexamination that It is true that my brother used to earn
Rs:40,000/- per month. This evidence remained undecimated
in cross-examination. That, the deceased was working as a
Contractor by profession and used to do contract works with
MAC App. No. 04 of 2017
The Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Company Limited Vs. Smt. Kavita Rai & Ors.
the witness and that his monthly income was Rs.40,000/(Rupees forty thousand) only, from the contract works.
12.
Exhibit 15 is the Contractor Enlistment Form of the
deceased which records that he was a Grade II 'A' Contractor
under the Sikkim Public Works Department, Government of
Sikkim, Roads and Bridges Department, Gangtok, Sikkim. The
Respondent No. 1 in her evidence has also stated that the
deceased had a financial partnership with his brother Keshab
Kumar Rai. P.W.2 Keshab Kumar Rai for his part has stated
that the deceased also used to do contract works with him in
partnership. Exhibit 24 is the Contractor Enlistment Form of
P.W.2 Keshab Kumar Rai, indicating that the witness was a
Grade I 'A' Contractor while Exhibit 25 reveals that he was
issued certain contract works by the Divisional Engineer, Rural
Management and Development Department, Government of
Sikkim to the tune of Rs.1952.45 lakhs. Exhibit 26 is a contract
for another work estimated at Rs.22,33,01,419/- (Rupees
twenty two crores, thirty three lakhs, one thousand, four
hundred and nineteen) only. Consequently, in the absence of
any other document to contradict the documents on record, I
am of the considered opinion that the Appellant has not been
able to establish a case contrary to that of the Respondents No.
1 to 3.
13.
So
far
as
the
question
of
compensation
is
concerned, while computing the loss of income, the learned
Tribunal rightly adopted the Multiplier of “16” in terms of the
MAC App. No. 04 of 2017
The Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Company Limited Vs. Smt. Kavita Rai & Ors.
approved table laid down in Sarla Verma (Smt.) and Others vs.
Delhi Transport Corporation and Another4
as the age of the
deceased was 34, as per Exhibit 9, the Secondary School
Examination Certificate of the deceased which document is not
assailed herein.
14.
The learned Tribunal has granted 50% of monthly
income while computing future prospects, on this point, in
National Insurance Company Limited vs. Pranay Sethi & Ors.5, it was
held as follows;
“61. ...
(i) The
two-Judge
Bench
in Santosh
Devi should have been well advised to refer the
matter to a larger Bench as it was taking a
different view than what has been stated in Sarla
Verma, a judgment by a coordinate Bench. It is
because a coordinate Bench of the same strength
cannot take a contrary view than what has been
held by another coordinate Bench.
(ii) As Rajesh has not taken note of the
decision in Reshma Kumari, which was delivered
at earlier point of time, the decision in Rajesh is
not a binding precedent.
(iii) While determining the income, an
addition of 50% of actual salary to the income of
the deceased towards future prospects, where
the deceased had a permanent job and was
below the age of 40 years, should be made. The
addition should be 30%, if the age of the
deceased was between 40 to 50 years. In case
the deceased was between the age of 50 to 60
years, the addition should be 15%. Actual salary
should be read as actual salary less tax.
(iv) In case the deceased was selfemployed or on a fixed salary, an addition
of 40% of the established income should be
the warrant where the deceased was below
the age of 40 years. An addition of 25% where
the deceased was between the age of 40 to 50
years and 10% where the deceased was between
the age of 50 to 60 years should be regarded as
the necessary method of computation. The
(2009) 6 SCC 121
AIR 2017 SC 5157
MAC App. No. 04 of 2017
The Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Company Limited Vs. Smt. Kavita Rai & Ors.
established income means the income minus the
tax component.”
(Emphasis supplied)
15.
No
arguments
were
forthcoming
from
the
Respondents No. 1 to 3 as to the expected rise in the income of
the deceased in future. Consequently his income is deemed to
be a fixed monthly income of Rs.40,000/- (Rupees forty
thousand) only. Hence, in view of the ratio supra of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court, it is evident that where the deceased was on a
fixed income and below the age of 40 years, an addition of 40%
of the established income should be made towards future
prospects. Thus, 40% shall be calculated as future prospects
instead of 50% as calculated by the learned Tribunal.
16.
So far as loss of estate, loss of consortium and
funeral expenses are concerned, the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
Pranay Sethi (supra), inter alia held as follows;
“(viii)
Reasonable
figures
on
conventional heads, namely, loss of estate,
loss of consortium and funeral expenses
should be ₹15,000/-, ₹40,000/- and
₹15,000/- respectively.”
(Emphasis supplied)
Consequently Rs.15,000/- (Rupees fifteen thousand) only, is
granted towards funeral expenses, Rs.40,000/- (Rupees forty
thousand) only, granted towards loss of consortium and a sum
of Rs.15,000/- (Rupees fifteen thousand) only, granted towards
MAC App. No. 04 of 2017
The Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Company Limited Vs. Smt. Kavita Rai & Ors.
loss of estate instead of Rs.25,000/-, Rs.1,00,000/- and
Rs.10,000/- only, respectively, granted by the learned Tribunal
under the aforestated heads.
17.
With regard to the amount of Rs.5,000/- (Rupees
five thousand) only, having been granted towards “Transport
from hospital,” apart from the statement made by Respondent
No. 1 at Paragraph 9 of her Evidence-on-Affidavit Exhibit 10 to
the effect that after the post mortem examination of the dead
body of the deceased the dead body was handed over to Shri
madan rai brother of deceased Suddha Kumar Rai and filing of
Exhibit 7 i.e. the Dead Body Handing and Taking Memo, no
evidence has been furnished by the Respondents No. 1 to 3 to
support
the
claim
towards
payment
of
transportation.
Therefore, the Respondents No. 1 to 3 are not entitled to
compensation towards “Transport from hospital.”
18.
The question of compensation on account of loss of
love and affection as granted by the learned Tribunal, in view of
the ratio supra is superfluous and is deducted from the
compensation amount.
19.
In conclusion, in light of the above discussions and
findings, the compensation stands re-calculated and modified,
and is found to be just as follows;
MAC App. No. 04 of 2017
The Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Company Limited Vs. Smt. Kavita Rai & Ors.
Monthly Income of the deceased
Rs.40,000.00
Annual Income of the deceased (Rs.40,000x12)
Rs.4,80,000.00
Add 40% of Rs.4,80,000.00 as future prospects
Rs.1,92,000.00
Yearly income of the deceased
Rs.6,72,000.00
Less 1/3 of Rs.6,72,000.00
[deducted from the said amount in consideration
of the instances which the victim would have
incurred towards maintenance had he been alive.]
Rs.2,24,000.00
Net yearly income
Rs.4,48,000.00
Multiplier of ‘16’ adopted in terms of
Sarla Verma’s case (supra) (Rs.4,48,000 x 16)
Rs.71,68,000.00
Add Funeral expenses
Rs.15,000.00
Add Loss of consortium
Rs.40,000.00
Add Loss of estate
Rs.15,000.00
Total
Rs.72,38,000.00
(Rupees seventy two lakhs and thirty eight thousand) only.
20.
The Respondents No. 1, 2 and 3 shall be entitled to
simple interest @ 9% per annum on the above amount, with
effect from the date of filing of the Claim Petition before the
learned Tribunal, until its full realisation.
21.
The Appellant is directed to pay the awarded
amount to the Respondents No. 1, 2 and 3 within one month
from today, failing which, the Appellant shall pay simple
interest @ 12% per annum from the date of filing of the Claim
Petition till realisation, duly deducting the amounts, if any,
already paid by the Appellant to the Respondents No. 1, 2 and
3.
22.
Appeal allowed to the extent above.
23.
No order as to costs.
MAC App. No. 04 of 2017
The Branch Manager, Shriram General Insurance Company Limited Vs. Smt. Kavita Rai & Ors.
Copy of this Judgment be sent to the learned
24.
Tribunal for information.
Records
25.
of
the
learned
Tribunal
be
remitted
forthwith.
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
26.04.2019
Approved for reporting: Yes
Internet: Yes
ml
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review