Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
DATED : 16th JUNE, 2017
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : THE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I.A. No.01 of 2017 in MAC App. No.07 of 2017
Appellants
:
1.
The Branch Manager,
National Insurance Company Limited,
Damber Chowk,
Reshi Road,
Kalimpong,
District : Darjeeling,
West Bengal.
2.
The Branch Manager,
National Insurance Company Limited,
National Highway 10,
P.O. & P.S. Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
versus
Respondents
:
1.
Smt. Meena Chhetri,
W/o Late Anand Chettri
2.
Mr. Dipesh Chetti,
S/o Late Anand Chettri
3.
Mr. Dinesh Chettri,
S/o Late Anand Chettri
All residents of House No.11,
Lower Paiyong, Melli P.W.,
Near ICDS, Mellidara,
Paiyong G.P.U.,
P.O. & P.S. Melli,
South Sikkim.
4.
Mr. Tara Kumar Chettri (Owner),
S/o Late Jit Bahadur Chettri,
R/o Kubinday Busty,
P.O. & P.S. Melli,
South Sikkim.
Application under Proviso to Section 173(1)
of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, read with
Section 5 of the Limitation Act, 1963.
I.A. No.01 of 2017 in MAC App. No.07 of 2017
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited and Others
vs.
Smt. Meena Chhetri and Others
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. Thupden G. Bhutia, Advocate for the Appellants.
Mr. Ajay Rathi, Mr. Pramit Chhetri and Mr. Sailesh Rai, Advocates
for the Respondents No.1 to 3.
None for the Respondent No.4.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
O R D E R (ORAL)
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
By
filing
this
Application,
the
Appellants
seek
condonation of delay of forty-five days in filing of the Appeal. The
grounds put forth for the delay are as follows;
(a)
The Judgment/Award under Appeal was pronounced by
the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, East Sikkim, at
Gangtok (for short “Learned Claims Tribunal”), in MACT
Case No.01 of 2016, on 23-11-2016.
(b)
The certified copy of the Judgment/Award was sought by
the Appellants on 03-02-2017, after the Winter Vacation
and was made available on the same day.
(c)
The Appeal ought to have been filed on 20-02-2017,
i.e., ninety days, from the date of the Judgment/Award.
However, it was filed “today”.
(d)
That,
the
delay
of
forty-five
days
has
occurred
inadvertently on the part of the Appellant-Company.
(e)
After receiving the certified copy of the Judgment/Award
on 03-02-2017 the Counsel delivered it to the Divisional
Office at Gangtok, on 09-02-2017.
(f)
This was in turn forwarded to the Kalimpong Branch
Office, situated at Damber Chowk, Kalimpong, West
Bengal, as the Policy was issued from their said Branch.
I.A. No.01 of 2017 in MAC App. No.07 of 2017
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited and Others
(g)
vs.
Smt. Meena Chhetri and Others
From there the Case File along with the certified copy of
the Judgment/Award was sent to the Divisional Office at
Siliguri.
(h)
From Siliguri, it was forwarded to the Regional Office at
Kolkata, where the decision to prefer an Appeal before
this Court was approved.
(i)
On such decision, the Case File made its way back from
the Regional Office at Kolkata, to the Divisional Office at
Siliguri, with a direction to instruct the Office at Gangtok
to appoint a Counsel for preferring an Appeal before this
Court.
(j)
The Divisional Office at Gangtok on receipt of the Case
File, appointed the Counsel vide Appointment Letter
dated 06-03-2017 to prepare an Appeal.
(k)
Thereafter,
the
Divisional
Office
also
directed
the
Investigator to obtain the entire certified copies relating
to MACT Case No.01 of 2016.
(l)
The Appellant-Company then took some time to issue
the
Cheque
of
Rs.25,000/-
(Rupees
twenty
five
thousand) only, as required under the Proviso to Section
173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (for short “Act”), for
the purpose of preferring an Appeal.
The Cheque is
dated 15-03-2017.
(m)
Consequent thereto, the Appeal was filed.
Thus, the entire aforesaid process contributed to the delay
which may accordingly be condoned, as the Appellant-Company is a
Central Government Undertaking requiring collective decisions and
the sanction of various Departments prior to preferring an Appeal.
2.
In rebuttal, Learned Counsel for the Respondents No.1
to 3 while referring to the Application seeking condonation of delay
I.A. No.01 of 2017 in MAC App. No.07 of 2017
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited and Others
vs.
Smt. Meena Chhetri and Others
exhorted that, the Appellant sought for certified copy of the
Judgment/Award seventy-two days after the pronouncement of the
Judgment/Award. That apart, although the Learned Claims Tribunal
may have observed Winter break, the Registry therein remains open
and any filing or certified copies can be obtained. The Application
reflects that after the certified copy was made over on 03-02-2017
an additional period of six days was taken by the conducting
Counsel to deliver the Judgment to the Divisional Office which is
situated in Gangtok.
That, although the Office in Gangtok is a
“Divisional Office”, it is incomprehensible as to why the Case File
would be forwarded to a “Branch Office” in Kalimpong. That, after
the decision was made on 06-03-2017 to file an Appeal, the Cheque
in terms of the provision of law was only submitted on 15-03-2017,
more than a week, after the decision to Appeal. Thus, the grounds
put forth reveal no bona fides of the Appellant-Company and the
Application requires no consideration which may accordingly be
rejected.
3.
I have heard Learned Counsel for the parties in extenso
and given careful consideration to their submissions.
4.
Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1973, provides
for filing of Appeal. Section 173(1) of the Act affords the Appellant
a period of ninety days from the date of the Award to prefer an
Appeal to the High Court. The First Proviso to the said Section lays
down that the person who is to pay the Award shall deposit a sum of
Rs.25,000/- (Rupees twenty five thousand) only, or 50% of the
amount so awarded, whichever is less, in the manner directed by
I.A. No.01 of 2017 in MAC App. No.07 of 2017
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited and Others
vs.
Smt. Meena Chhetri and Others
the High Court, before an Appeal can be entertained. The Second
Proviso lays down that the High Court may entertain the Appeal
after the expiry of the period of ninety days, if it is satisfied that the
Appellant was “prevented by sufficient cause” from preferring the
Appeal in time.
5.
The Law thus having been laid down, we may proceed
on the anvil of the said Provisions. It needs no reiteration that the
Judgment/Award was pronounced on 23-11-2016.
The certified
copy was applied for only on 03-02-2017. It is not disputed that the
Registry of the District Courts remains open and can be accessed for
obtaining certified copy of any Judgment or Award. Even after the
delay of seventy-two days in obtaining the Judgment/Award for
which no reasons are forthcoming, Learned conducting Counsel has
made it over to the Divisional Office in Gangtok itself, only after six
days. It is not disputed that Learned conducting Counsel before the
Learned Claims Tribunal and the Divisional Office are stationed in
Gangtok. No explanation for this delay has been rendered. It was
clarified by Learned Counsel for the Appellants that the Case File
was forwarded to the Kalimpong Branch Office as the Insurance was
obtained from the said Office.
Nevertheless, I am constrained to
point out that the Application is devoid of the date on when it was
forwarded to the Kalimpong Branch Office, besides which I cannot
help but remark that the application bears various dates of filing and
although an effort was made to explain away the errors, I find that
it is sheer carelessness on the part of the Appellant-Company.
Subsequent to that, although it was urged that the Case File had to
be forwarded to the Regional Office at Kolkata, there is no date of
I.A. No.01 of 2017 in MAC App. No.07 of 2017
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited and Others
vs.
Smt. Meena Chhetri and Others
the event or reasons put forth as to when the Case File made its
journey to Kolkata or what transpired in the interim. It is also
unfathomable as to why when a decision to file the Appeal was
reached on 06-03-2017, the Cheque of Rs.25,000/- (Rupees twenty
five thousand) only, should follow a week later.
Once again, no
reasons are forthcoming.
6.
In such circumstances, it is clear that the Appellant-
Company has been lackadaisical in its approach, leading to the
delay. This Court has time and again in several Orders pertaining to
condonation of delay filed by the Appellant-Company held that they
cannot harbour the belief that delay is a non-serious matter.
A
delay whether of ten days or ten years has to be explained
sufficiently without which no party as of right can claim condonation.
In Esha Bhattacharjee vs. Managing Committee of Raghunathpur Nafar
Academy and Others1, the Hon’ble Supreme Court while culling out
the broad principles for condonation of delay was of the opinion
that—
“22. To the aforesaid principles we may add some
more guidelines taking note of the present day scenario.
They are:
22.1. (a) An application for condonation of delay
should be drafted with careful concern and not in a
haphazard manner harbouring the notion that the courts
are required to condone delay on the bedrock of the
principle that adjudication of a lis on merits is seminal to
justice dispensation system.
22.2. (b) An application for condonation of delay
should not be dealt with in a routine manner on the base
of individual philosophy which is basically subjective.
22.3. (c) Though no precise formula can be laid
down regard being had to the concept of judicial
discretion, yet a conscious effort for achieving consistency
and collegiality of the adjudicatory system should be
made as that is the ultimate institutional motto.
1.
(2013) 12 SCC 649
I.A. No.01 of 2017 in MAC App. No.07 of 2017
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited and Others
vs.
Smt. Meena Chhetri and Others
22.4. (d) The increasing tendency to perceive
delay as a non-serious matter and, hence, lackadaisical
propensity can be exhibited in a nonchallant manner
requires to be curbed, of course, within legal
parameters.”
7.
The Appellant-Company has given the principles a go
by, fraught as the Application is with errors depicting different dates
for one particular event, i.e., date of filing.
While on the question
of condonation of delay, we cannot lose sight of the fact that the
Motor Vehicles Act is a benevolent piece of legislation which makes
an attempt to compensate in pecuniary terms the loss of a human
life although there is no question that life in invaluable. A bereaved
member of the victim’s family approaches the Tribunal and after the
Award is pronounced the Appellant instead of taking steps either
way within time, drags its feet to file the Appeal with a prayer for
condoning the delay. I am afraid this ought not to be the attitude
neither should it be understood that the Courts will adopt a liberal
approach to delay and that an Application for such delay would
suffice.
8.
We may usefully refer to the decision in Oriental Aroma
Chemical
Industries
Limited
Corporation and Another2,
vs.
Gujarat
Industrial
Development
the two-Judge Bench decision of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court held as follows;
“14. ……………………………… The law of limitation is
founded on public policy.
The legislature does not
prescribe limitation with the object of destroying the
rights of the parties but to ensure that they do not resort
to dilatory tactics and seek remedy without delay. The
idea is that every legal remedy must be kept alive for a
period fixed by the legislature. To put it differently, the
law of limitation prescribes a period within which legal
remedy can be availed for redress of the legal injury. At
the same time, the courts are bestowed with the power to
condone the delay, if sufficient cause is shown for not
availing the remedy within the stipulated time.”
2.
(2010) 5 SCC 459
I.A. No.01 of 2017 in MAC App. No.07 of 2017
The Branch Manager, National Insurance Company Limited and Others
9.
vs.
Smt. Meena Chhetri and Others
This Court is of the firm belief that when the provision of
Law exists, it has to be followed to the letter unless sufficient
grounds are put forth or the party is prevented by sufficient cause
from preferring the Appeal on time.
The mere reason that the
Appellant-Company is unwieldy and collective decisions lead to the
delay cannot be countenanced, as MACT matters are not few and far
between.
Infact, accident rates are appear to be limitless and by
now the Appellant-Company ought to have an well-oiled machinery
in place for dealing with such matters.
10.
The aforesaid discussions with clarity indicate that no
such grounds have been put forth which would enable this Court to
exercise the discretion it is clothed with and condone the delay.
11.
Accordingly, finding that the Application is bereft of bona
fides and that no ground reveals that the Appellant was “prevented
by sufficient cause” for the delay, the Application is rejected and
consequently the Appeal.
Sd/-
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
16-06-2017
Approved for reporting : Yes
Internet : Yes
ds
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review