Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Extraordinary Jurisdiction)
DATED: 9th October, 2018
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : THE HON’BLE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE, MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I.A. No. 1 of 2018
In
MAC App. No. 7 of 2018
…… Petitioner
Branch Manager,
National Insurance Co. Ltd.
Versus
Krishna Bahadur Chettri and Others
…... Respondent(s)
Application under Section 173(1) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988
read with Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance:
Mr. Sudhir Prasad, Advocate for the Appellant.
Mr. Rahul Rathi, Advocate for the Respondents No.1 and 2.
None for the Respondents No.3 and 4.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ORDER
Meenakshi Madan Rai, ACJ
1.
By filing this Application under Section 173(1) of the
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, read with Section 151 of the Code of
Civil Procedure, 1908, the Appellant seeks Condonation of 64
days delay in filing the Appeal.
I.A. No. 1 of 2018 I MAC App. No. 7 of 2018
Branch Manager, National Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Krishna Bahadur Chettri and Others
2.
The grounds put forth for the delay are that, pursuant to
the Judgment pronounced by the learned Motor Accidents
Claims Tribunal, East Sikkim at Gangtok, in MACT Case No. 38
of 2016 on 28.11.2017, copy thereof was made over to the
Appellant on 29.12.2017. After receiving a certified copy of
the Judgment and Award from the concerned
Advocate at
Gangtok Court, the Branch Manager of the Appellant at
Gangtok examined the Judgment. On verification of the policy
papers, he forwarded the matter to the Senior Divisional
Manager at Siliguri Divisional Office. Pursuant thereto, the
matter “... was forwarded to Branch Manager, Gangtok Branch
(sic).” The Divisional Office at Siliguri then sought the opinion
of the Counsel at Siliguri who advised that the matter was a fit
case for preferring Appeal. Mr. Sudhir Prasad, Advocate, was
then appointed as Counsel for the Appellant vide letter dated
19.02.2018, to prefer an Appeal before this Court. The
appointment letter was received by Mr. Prasad on 22.02.2018.
While drafting the Memo of Appeal, certain clarifications were
sought from the Appellant Company including additional
documents related to the matter. Added to the above grounds
was the inexperience of the Counsel in motor accidents appeal
matters, thus the Appeal came to be filed on 02.05.2018.
That, the above grounds prevented the Appellant from
preferring the Appeal within the statutory period of 90 days
and is sufficient cause. That, the Appellant Company has a
strong prima facie case on merits and should the delay not be
I.A. No. 1 of 2018 I MAC App. No. 7 of 2018
Branch Manager, National Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Krishna Bahadur Chettri and Others
condoned, prejudice will be caused to them, hence the prayer
for Condonation of delay.
3.
Learned Counsel for the Respondents, on the other
hand, vehemently objected to the Petition for Condonation of
delay, inter alia, on grounds that in the first instance, the
certified copy of the Judgment, as records would reveal, was
ready on 15.12.2017, the Judgment having been pronounced
on 28.11.2017. The Appellant Company failed to collect the
Judgment
from
the
relevant
Section
of
the
Court
on
15.12.2017 and cannot lay the blame at the door of the
Tribunal. The Claim Petition before the learned Motor Accident
Claims Tribunal was under Section 163A of the Motor Vehicles
Act, 1988 where compensation of Rs.5,43,650/- (Rupees Five
Lakhs, Fourty Three Thousand, Six Hundred and Fifty) only,
was granted based on the salary of the victim placed at
Rs.3,325/- (Rupees Three Thousand, Three Hundred and
Twenty Five) only, per month. There is no error in the
Multiplier of 17 adopted by the learned Tribunal as per the
Second Schedule to the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 as the age of
the deceased was about 33 years. Besides, the Appeal is filed
on a wrong interpretation of the insurance cover as it is clear
that the Petition is one under Section 163A of the Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988 and as per the conditions of the Insurance
Policy, Driver‟s Clause has been included. The deceased was
self-employed and the owner of the vehicle in accident which
I.A. No. 1 of 2018 I MAC App. No. 7 of 2018
Branch Manager, National Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Krishna Bahadur Chettri and Others
he was driving and as owner he was not barred from driving
the vehicle and hence an extra coverage to the tune of
Rs.2,00,000/- (Rupees Two Lakhs) only, had been obtained
under the Personal Accident Claim benefit. It was mandatory
that the Claimants be granted Rs.2,00,000/- (Rupees Two
Lakhs) only, under the said claim benefit. Further, the policy
issued was a package policy and not limited to Rs.2,00,000/(Rupees two lakhs) only, as it is also covered by IMT
No.15/extra premium of Rs.100/- (Rupees One Hundred) only.
Hence, the petition for Condonation of delay is a ruse to
prevent the Claimants from obtaining their rightful reliefs
under the benevolent legislation and deserves dismissal as
also the Appeal.
4.
I have considered the submissions of learned Counsel
for both parties and perused the Petition seeking Condonation
of delay. It is but apposite to pause here and remark that the
Petition appears to have been drafted with nary a care to
detail,
anomalies appearing on the face of the Petition, are
extracted herein below:-
“4.
That the Branch Manager, Gangtok Branch
after verification of the policy papers thereafter
forwarded the same to the Sr. Divisional
Manager at Siliguri Divisional Office.
5.
That thereafter the same was forwarded
to Branch Manager, Gangtok Branch.
6.
The Divisional Office at Siliguri then
sought the opinion of their Counsel, at Siliguri on
I.A. No. 1 of 2018 I MAC App. No. 7 of 2018
Branch Manager, National Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Krishna Bahadur Chettri and Others
the Award passed by the Ld. Tribunal, East
Sikkim at Gangtok and he opined that his is a fit
case for preferring an appeal.”
5.
Once the matter was forwarded to the Divisional Office
at Siliguri, it is not clear why it was reverted back to the
Gangtok Branch sans steps as reflected in paragraph 5 supra.
It is a clear indication of carelessness in drafting and lack of
application of mind which has been derided by the Hon‟ble
Supreme Court in Esha Bhattacharjee vs. Managing Committee of
Raghunathpur Nafar Academy and Others1. Referring to various
authorities on Condonation of delay, the Hon‟ble Supreme
Court would hold inter alia as follows;
“22.1. (a) An application for condonation of
delay should be drafted with careful concern and
not in a haphazard manner harbouring the
notion that the courts are required to condone
delay on the bedrock of the principle that
adjudication of a lis on merits is seminal to
justice dispensation system.
....................................................................
22.4. (d) The increasing tendency to perceive
delay as a non-serious matter and, hence,
lackadaisical propensity can be exhibited in a
nonchallant manner requires to be curbed, of
course, within legal parameters.”
The above observation clearly cautions the party seeking
Condonation of delay to desist from such practices.
(2013) 12 SC 649
I.A. No. 1 of 2018 I MAC App. No. 7 of 2018
Branch Manager, National Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Krishna Bahadur Chettri and Others
6.
Now turning to address the grounds furnished by the
Appellant for the delay, one such ground urged was belated
supply of the copy of the Judgment. Evidently, this is an
erroneous statement. As pointed out by learned Counsel for
the Respondents, the certified copy of the Judgment was
ready on 15.12.2017 and is visible on the stamp affixed by the
concerned authority of the District Courts on the copy of the
Judgment. The same clearly reveals as follows;
“Member, MACT
Date of application 28.11.17
...................
..................
Date of ready on 15.12.17
Date of issue/delivery on 29.12.17
Total Number of words Thirty Four Pages
Total Cost paid Rs.34/-“
The copy remained unclaimed by the Appellant Company till
29.12.2017. In the circumstance, it cannot be said that the
delay arose out of belated supply of the Judgment. Apart from
the above carelessness, evident from the conduct of the
Appellant, it is also evident that the dates or the number of
days which each office took to consider the matter lacks
mention in the Petition. The Appellant Company has deigned it
fit only to state that after the certified copy of the Judgment
was received, it was forwarded to the Branch Manager,
Gangtok. How many days this exercise involved has not been
reflected in the Petition.
I.A. No. 1 of 2018 I MAC App. No. 7 of 2018
Branch Manager, National Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Krishna Bahadur Chettri and Others
7.
It is the next contention of the Appellant that the Branch
Manager at Gangtok verified the policy papers and forwarded
it to the Senior Divisional Manager at Siliguri Divisional Office.
The number of days that such verification required, the date of
receipt of the Judgment by the Gangtok Branch or the date on
which it was forwarded to the next office is unaccounted for in
the Petition. Learned Counsel would further contend that the
Divisional Office at Siliguri sought the opinion of their Counsel
at Siliguri. No dates have been mentioned on this count as
well and no effort has been made to disclose as to how many
days it took to obtain the opinion of the Counsel. The date
mentioned at para 7 of the Petition, viz. „19.02.2018,‟
according to learned Counsel was the date on which he was
appointed by the Appellant. Thereafter, the Appeal has been
filed on 02.05.2018 leading to a delay of 64 (sixty-four) days.
No explanation yields as to the delay obtained therein. The
Counsel has failed to explain what restrained him from filing
the Appeal soon after his appointment, besides submitting
that he was a new Counsel and that he had not done motor
accidents appeal matters. Surely, this ground would not merit
consideration.
8.
It has been laid down in Collector, Land Acquisition,
Anantnag and Another vs. Mst. Katiji and Others2 that everyday‟s
delay must be explained. This does not mean that a pedantic
(1987) 2 SCC 107
I.A. No. 1 of 2018 I MAC App. No. 7 of 2018
Branch Manager, National Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Krishna Bahadur Chettri and Others
or hypertechnical approach ought to be adopted but at the
same time there has to be a justice-oriented approach
adopted by the Court. It is a well-settled principle of law that
the rules of limitation are not in place to obliterate the rights
of the parties but the rules do not intend that the parties
resort to dilatory tactics while seeking remedy. The Court is to
adjudicate and advance substantial justice to the parties. This
Court is alive to the principle that rules of procedure are the
handmaids of justice, nevertheless the Court is to weigh
whether
the
delay
prejudices
the
party
opposing
the
application at the same time whether there are bona fides for
the delay. The delay has to be sufficiently explained, in sum
and substance, this means that Courts are to give priority to
meting out even handed justice on the merits of a case.
9.
It is essential to point out that “sufficient cause” means
that there must be adequate cause for the delay. While
explaining “sufficient cause”, the Hon‟ble Apex Court in
Basawaraj and Another vs. Special Land Acquisition Officer 3,
referred to the decision in Arjun Singh vs. Mohindra Kumar,
wherein it was held as follows;
“10. In Arjun Singh v. Mohindra Kumar this Court
explained the difference between a "good cause"
and a "sufficient cause" and observed that every
"sufficient cause" is a good cause and vice versa.
However, if any difference exists it can only be that
(2013) 14 SCC 81
I.A. No. 1 of 2018 I MAC App. No. 7 of 2018
Branch Manager, National Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Krishna Bahadur Chettri and Others
the requirement of good cause is complied with on a
lesser degree of proof than that of "sufficient
cause".
11. The expression "sufficient cause" should be
given a liberal interpretation to ensure that
substantial justice is done, but only so long as
negligence, inaction or lack of bona fides cannot be
imputed to the party concerned, whether or not
sufficient cause has been furnished, can be decided
on the facts of a particular case and no straitjacket
formula is possible. (Vide Madanlal v. Shyamlal :
[(2002) 1 SCC 535] and Ram Nath Sao v.
Gobardhan Sao [(2002) 3 SCC 195]”
10.
In consideration of the grounds put forth and the
discussions hereinabove, there is evidently negligence and
inaction on the part of the Appellant, the explanation extended
is neither reasonable nor satisfactory. The Appellant ought to
keep in mind that the Hon‟ble Supreme Court has observed in
Syed Mehaboob vs. New India Assurance Co. Ltd.4,
that the
“Motor Vehicle Act is a beneficent legislation intended to place
the claimant in the same position that he was before the
accident and to compensate him for his loss. Thus it should be
interpreted liberally so as to achieve the maximum benefit.”
The Claimants herein are the aged parents of the victim, their
son, who they have lost in the tragic accident. If the Appellant
herein was of the opinion that the Judgment of the Tribunal
was incorrect they ought to have proceeded within time and if
they had failed to proceed within time then satisfactory
explanation for the delay ought to be put forth which is sadly
lacking in the instant matter. Consequently, the application for
(2011) 11 SCC 625
I.A. No. 1 of 2018 I MAC App. No. 7 of 2018
Branch Manager, National Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Krishna Bahadur Chettri and Others
Condonation of Delay is rejected and disposed of, as also the
Appeal.
(Meenakshi Madan Rai)
Acting Chief Justice
09.10.2018
bp
Index
: Yes
Internet
: Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review