Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
DATED : 30th SEPTEMBER, 2019
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
SINGLE BENCH : THE HON‟BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MAC App. No.03 of 2019
Appellant
:
The Branch Manager,
Chola MS General Insurance Company Limited
versus
Respondent
:
Mrs. Radha Pradhan and Others
Appeal under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. Yadev Sharma and Mr. Dilip Kumar Tamang, Advocates for
the Appellant.
Mr. Tarun Choudhary, Advocate for the Respondents No.1 to 8.
Mr. Dilli Bahadur Pradhan, Advocate for the Respondent No.9.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT
Meenakshi Madan Rai, ACJ
1.
The only question that arises for determination in
this Appeal is whether the deceased was a gratuitous passenger
in the vehicle in accident, i.e., truck (Tata), bearing registration
No.WB 73 D 8533, the resultant relief or denial thereof would be
contingent upon such determination.
2.
It was contended by Learned Counsel for the
Appellant-Insurance
Company
that
the
deceased
was
a
MAC App. No.03 of 2019
The Branch Manager, Chola MS General Insurance Co. Ltd.
vs. Radha Pradhan and Others
gratuitous passenger and travelling in a goods carrier vehicle
which met with the accident and hence was not entitled to claim
any compensation whatsoever.
The other arguments raised
were that the Respondent did not produce any eye-witnesses to
the alleged accident nor was the authority who issued the
relevant documents including the Driving Licence of the driver
examined before the Learned Claims Tribunal. That, the Income
Certificate of the deceased was procured only for the purpose of
obtaining enhanced compensation and in the absence of proof of
income or voucher thereto an income of Rs.3,10,000/- per
annum as projected by the Claimants-Respondents cannot be
considered as the correct income of the deceased. The seizure
list of the vehicle does not reflect that the goods carried therein
were bricks as alleged by the Claimants-Respondents, but was
infact timber. The owner of the goods alleged to be one Arun
Rai was not produced as a witness to prove the plea of the
Claimants/Respondents. The aforestated grounds do not entitle
the Claimants-Respondents to any compensation, thus the
impugned Judgment and Award dated 24-10-2018 of the
Learned Claims Tribunal be set aside.
3.
Refuting
the
arguments
advanced
by
Learned
Counsel for the Claimants-Respondents it was contended that
the deceased was travelling in the goods carrier with the loaded
goods as the representative of the owner and therefore the
compensation cannot be declined. The income of the deceased
being Rs.3,10,000/- (Rupees three lakhs and ten thousand)
MAC App. No.03 of 2019
The Branch Manager, Chola MS General Insurance Co. Ltd.
vs. Radha Pradhan and Others
only, per annum, as has been established by the documentary
evidence.
All other documents furnished by the Respondents
also substantiate their claims and in such circumstances, the
impugned Judgment requires no interference.
Having heard and considered the submissions and
4.
the relevant records, we may briefly advert to the facts of the
matter
at
hand
hereinabove.
for
determination
of
the
issue
flagged
The Respondents herein were the Claimants
before the Learned Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, South
Sikkim, at Namchi, being the widow and five minor children of
the deceased and his aged parents.
The deceased Santosh
Pradhan was travelling in the truck bearing No.WB 73 D 8533
with loaded goods for one Arun Rai of Jorethang.
When the
truck met with an accident on 20-08-2017 at about 1530 hours
near a place called “Tanam Khola”, South Sikkim, where he
succumbed to his injuries.
The Claimants‟ case is that the
deceased was 32 years at the time of the accident, a selfemployed business man with an annual income of Rs.3,10,000/(Rupees three lakhs and ten thousand) only. Income Tax had
also been deducted from his income for the financial year 201718 through his Pan Card.
On account of the accident, he
succumbed to his injuries on the spot. The vehicle was insured
with the Appellant Company.
The claimants sought a total
compensation of Rs.59,10,200/- (Rupees fifty nine lakhs, ten
thousand and two hundred) only.
MAC App. No.03 of 2019
The Branch Manager, Chola MS General Insurance Co. Ltd.
5.
vs. Radha Pradhan and Others
The Appellant-Company who was the Opposite Party
No.1 before the Learned Claims Tribunal contested the Claim
raising the ground that a gratuitous passenger travelling in a
goods carrier vehicle was disentitled to any compensation.
That, there was a statutory violation of the conditions of the
Insurance Policy as contemplated under Section 149(2) of the
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (hereinafter, M.V. Act). That, the
Respondents
had
failed
to
substantiate
by
documentary
evidence that the goods loaded in the vehicle in accident
belonged to the deceased or that he was therefore the
representative of the owner of the consignment. That apart, the
deceased was said to be travelling from Siliguri to Jorethang,
but documents, such as, road challan, invoice, bill, vouchers,
etc., were not produced nor were reasons given for non-filing of
the said documents casting a cloud on the Claims put forth
which was in any event excessive. Hence, the Petition ought to
be rejected.
6.
The Respondent No.9, who was Opposite Party
No.2, before the Learned Claims Tribunal, wife of the driver of
the truck averred that all documents pertaining to the vehicle
were valid and effective and the O.P. No.1 would be liable to
pay the award, if any.
7.
The Learned Claims Tribunal framed a single issue,
viz., (i) Whether the Claimants are entitled for compensation as
claimed, if so, who is liable to pay the same?
MAC App. No.03 of 2019
The Branch Manager, Chola MS General Insurance Co. Ltd.
8.
vs. Radha Pradhan and Others
The Claimant No.1 filed her evidence-on-affidavit as
C.W.1 along with that of one Dawa Tamang, C.W.2.
The
Opposite Party filed the evidence-on-affidavit of its Legal
Manager. The Opposite party No.2 had no witness to examine
nor any evidence to file.
After considering the evidence and
documents on record, the Learned Claims Tribunal pronounced
the
impugned
Judgment
and
awarded
compensation
of
Rs.56,25,200/- (Rupees fifty six lakhs, twenty five thousand and
two hundred) only, as total compensation to the Claimants.
Thus, aggrieved this Appeal has arisen.
9.
While addressing the issue flagged before this Court,
i.e., whether the deceased Santosh Pradhan was a gratuitous
passenger in the goods vehicle, it may be relevantly noted that
the term „gratuitous‟ does not find any definition or explanation
in the M.V. Act.
The term however is understood to indicate a
passenger travelling in a commercial vehicle without payment.
That, having been said, the relevant portions of Section 147 of
the M. V. Act are extracted below;
“147. Requirement of policies and limits of
liability.─(1) In order to comply with the
requirements of this Chapter, a policy of insurance
must be a policy which─
(a) is issued by a person who is an
authorised insurer; and
(b) insures the person or classes of
persons specified in the policy to the
extent specified in sub-section (2)─
(i)
against any liability which
may be incurred by him in
respect of the death of or
bodily injury to any person
including owner of the goods
or
his
authorised
representative carried in the
MAC App. No.03 of 2019
The Branch Manager, Chola MS General Insurance Co. Ltd.
vs. Radha Pradhan and Others
motor vehicle or damage to
any property of a third party
caused by or arising out of
the use of the motor vehicle
in a public place;
(ii)
against the death of or bodily
injury to any passenger of a
transport
vehicle,
except
gratuitous passengers of a
goods vehicle, caused by or
arising out of the use of the
motor vehicle in a public
place.
Provided that a policy shall not be required(i)
(ii)
to cover liability in respect of the
death, arising out of and in the
course of his employment, of the
employee of a person insured by the
policy or in respect of bodily injury
sustained by such an employee
arising out of and in the course of
his employment other than a
liability
arising
under
the
Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923
(8 of 1923) in respect of the death
of, or bodily injury to, any such
employee─
(a)
engaged
in
vehicle, or
driving
the
(b)
if it is a public service vehicle
engaged as conductor of the
vehicle
or
in
examining
tickets on the vehicle, or
(c)
if it is a goods carriage, being
carried in the vehicle, or
to cover any contractual liability.
(2) ……………………………………………………
(3) ……………………………………………………
(4) ……………………………………………………
(5) ……………………………………………………”
10.
The object of the provision is to lay down the
requirements of the policies and the limits of liability in respect
of passengers and persons other than passengers in relation to
passenger vehicles and goods carriages. Thus, the said Section
provides that the policy of insurance is to be issued by an
MAC App. No.03 of 2019
The Branch Manager, Chola MS General Insurance Co. Ltd.
vs. Radha Pradhan and Others
authorized insurer, which must insure the specified person or
class of persons, against any liability incurred in respect of
death or of bodily injury, to any person or damage to any
property of a third party, as well as against the death of or
bodily injury caused to any passenger of a public service
vehicle, caused by or arising out of the use of the vehicle in a
public place.
The liability extends to damage to any property to
a third person but not of the insured. It includes the owner of
the goods carried in the vehicle or his authorized representative.
11.
The specific argument of the Appellant is that the
deceased was neither the owner of the goods nor the authorized
representative of the owner and he was merely travelling in the
vehicle. The evidence on record, I find however would establish
to the contrary. The Claimants‟ witness Dawa Tamang, C.W.2
was also travelling in the ill-fated vehicle. He has clearly stated
that although he boarded the vehicle from Melli as it belongs to
his brother who was also the driver of the vehicle, the deceased
was already an occupant in the said vehicle. On his enquiry, the
deceased told him that he was travelling in the truck with
goods, i.e., bricks, loaded in the truck which belonged to one
Arun Rai of Jorethang. The Claimant No.1 has also supported
this evidence and the cross-examination of both the witnesses
were not decimated in this context.
Exhibit 23 is the
Supervision Charge-Receipt Book of the Transport Department,
Sikkim Nationalised Transport (SNT) dated 19-08-2017 which
infact lends credence to the statements of both C.W.1 and
MAC App. No.03 of 2019
The Branch Manager, Chola MS General Insurance Co. Ltd.
vs. Radha Pradhan and Others
C.W.2 inasmuch as the document reveals that bricks were
loaded in the truck which met with an accident. The argument
of the Appellant that the seizure memo revealed the goods to be
timber and not bricks is also obliterated by Exhibit 23 and is
therefore an incorrect argument advanced by the Appellant.
Exhibit 22 further substantiates that a sum of Rs.1,892/(Rupees one thousand, eight hundred and ninety two) only, was
received from one Arun Rai of Jorethang for the said goods. It
also emerges from the evidence of the witness of the Appellant,
Deborshi Bhowmick that they had appointed an Investigator to
look
into
the
matter
but
admittedly
the
report
Investigator had not been filed before the Tribunal.
of
the
This
concealment raises doubts about the bona fides of the Appellant
Company and an adverse inference is drawn under Section
114(g) of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872.
In the light of the
evidence on record, in no way can it be stated that the
deceased was a gratuitous passenger in the ill-fated vehicle. In
this view of the matter, it consequently cascades that the
Claimants are entitled to compensation.
Besides, it needs no
reiteration that matters filed before the Motor Accidents Claims
Tribunals is to be proved by the Claimant by a preponderance of
probability and not beyond a reasonable doubt.
12.
The rash and negligent driving of the deceased has
been categorically established by Dawa Tamang, the brother of
the deceased driver who was also travelling in the truck from
Melli, South Sikkim. The fact of accident is established by the
MAC App. No.03 of 2019
The Branch Manager, Chola MS General Insurance Co. Ltd.
FIR, Exhibit 1.
vs. Radha Pradhan and Others
The death of the deceased is established by
Exhibit 2 the Inquest Report and Exhibit 3 the document of
which the death body was forwarded for post-mortem. Exhibit 4
is the Insurance Policy pertaining to the vehicle in accident with
validity at the time of the accident.
The income of the deceased was contested as being
13.
exorbitant.
The Claimants for their part have relied on the
“Indian Income Tax Return Verification”, Form Exhibit 12, where
the
Gross
Total
Income
of
the
deceased
is
shown
as
Rs.3,10,000/- (Rupees three lakhs and ten thousand) only. The
total taxes paid is indicated as Rs.1,030/- (Rupees one
thousand and thirty) only. Thus, the net annual income of the
deceased would be Rs.3,08,970/- (Rupees three lakhs, eight
thousand, nine hundred and seventy) only.
No document was
produced by the Appellant to controvert the income of the
deceased.
In such a circumstance, no error arises on the
reliance of the Learned Claims Tribunal on Exhibit 12.
Exhibit
14 is the document pertaining to the computation of the total
income of the deceased with income tax deduction. Hence, the
annual income of the deceased would be Rs.3,08,970/- (Rupees
three lakhs, eight thousand, nine hundred and seventy) instead
of Rs.3,10,000/- as held by the Learned Claims Tribunal, which
failed to consider the tax deducted.
This settles the contest
with regard to the deceased‟s income hence the correct
multiplier for loss of income has been adopted by the Learned
Claims Tribunal.
MAC App. No.03 of 2019
The Branch Manager, Chola MS General Insurance Co. Ltd.
vs. Radha Pradhan and Others
His date of birth is established by Exhibit 16, his
14.
Birth Certificate, as 06-03-1985.
As the date of accident was
20-08-2017, he was approximately 32 years 5 months and 14
days at the time of accident.
In view of the aforestated discussions, there is no
15.
error in the findings of the Learned Claims Tribunal, however,
the compensation stands re-calculated and modified in view of
the
observations
supra
pertaining
to
the
income
of the
deceased.
Annual income of the deceased
Rs.
3,08,970.00
Add 40% of Rs.3,08,970/- as Future Prospects
(+) Rs.
Rs.
1,23,588.00
4,32,558.00
Less 1/5th of Rs.4,32,558/-
(−)
Rs.
86,511.60
Rs.
3,46,046.40
Rs.
3,46,046.00
(Rs.3,46,046/- x 16) Rs.
55,36,736.00
[in consideration of the expenses which
The victim would have incurred towards
maintaining himself had he been alive]
Net yearly income
(rounded off)
Multiplier to be adopted „16‟
[The age of the deceased at the time of death
between 31 and 35 and the relevant multiplier
as per Judgment of Sarla Verma is „16‟]
Funeral Expenses
(+)
Rs.
15,000.00
(+)
Rs.
15,000.00
(+)
Rs.
40,000.00
(+)
Rs.
2,00,000.00
(+)
Rs.
40,000.00
=
Rs.
58,46,736.00
[in terms of the Judgment of Pranay Sethi : (2017) 16 SCC 680]
Loss of Estate
[in terms of the Judgment of Pranay Sethi]
Loss of Spousal consortium
[in terms of the Judgment of Magma General Insurance
: (2018) 18 SCC 130]
Loss of Parental consortium
(Rs.40,000/- x 5)
[in terms of the Judgment of Magma General Insurance]
Loss of Filial consortium
(Rs.40,000/- x 1)
[in terms of the Judgment of Magma General Insurance]
Total
(Rupees fifty eight lakhs, forty six thousand, seven hundred and thirty six) only.
16.
The
Claimants-Respondents shall be
entitled to
simple interest @ 10% per annum on the above amount with
effect from the date of filing of the Claim Petition before the
MAC App. No.03 of 2019
The Branch Manager, Chola MS General Insurance Co. Ltd.
Learned
Claims
Tribunal,
i.e.,
vs. Radha Pradhan and Others
09-11-2017,
until
its
full
realisation.
The Appellant is directed to pay the awarded amount
17.
to the Claimants-Respondents within one month from today,
failing which the Appellant-Insurance Company shall pay simple
interest @ 12% per annum from the date of filing of the Claim
Petition, till realisation, duly deducting the amounts, if any,
already paid by the Appellant-Insurance Company to the
Claimants-Respondents.
To consider division of the compensation amongst
18.
the Claimants-Respondents, it is appropriate to refer to the ratio
in Sarla Verma (Smt) and Others vs. Delhi Transport Corporation and
Another
which while considering the dependants of the deceased
held as follows;
“31. Where the deceased was a bachelor
and the claimants are the parents, the deduction
follows a different principle. In regard to bachelors,
normally, 50% is deducted as personal and living
expenses, because it is assumed that a bachelor
would tend to spend more on himself. Even
otherwise, there is also the possibility of his getting
married in a short time, in which event the
contribution to the parent(s) and siblings is likely to
be cut drastically. Further, subject to evidence to
the contrary, the father is likely to have his own
income and will not be considered as a dependant
and the mother alone will be considered as a
dependent. In the absence of evidence to the
contrary, brothers and sisters will not be
considered as dependents, because they will either
be independent and earning, or married, or be
dependent on the father.”
[emphasise supplied]
19.
As no evidence was furnished to establish the
dependency of the father only the mother would be considered
(2006) 6 SCC 121
MAC App. No.03 of 2019
The Branch Manager, Chola MS General Insurance Co. Ltd.
vs. Radha Pradhan and Others
as a dependant of the deceased besides his spouse and children.
The awarded amount of compensation shall be divided amongst
the
Claimant-Respondent
No.1
being
the
spouse
of
the
deceased, Claimant-Respondent Nos.2 to 6 being his minor
daughters and Claimant-Respondent No.8 being his mother.
(i)
From of the amount awarded, Claimant-Respondent
No.1, spouse of the deceased is entitled to 15%, while
Claimant-Respondent No.8 shall also be granted 15%
considering the fact that she is aged and would
obviously has been dependant on the deceased, along
with interest as specified above.
(ii)
70% of the total amount awarded shall be divided
amongst the Claimant-Respondent Nos.2 to 6, of
which 50% of the share of each child shall be kept in
individual Fixed Deposit in a Nationalised Bank, until
the child attains the age of majority.
The remaining
50% of each of the minor‟s share shall be expended
on their education.
20.
The impugned Judgment of the Learned Claims
Tribunal is upheld with modifications to the impugned Award.
21.
Appeal allowed to the extent above.
22.
No order as to costs.
23.
Copy of this Judgment be sent to the Learned
Claims Tribunal for information.
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Acting Chief Justice
30-09-2019
Approved for reporting : Yes
ds
Internet : Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review