Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Shampa Dutt (Paul)
WPA 28819 of 2025
Board of Trustees, Steel Authority of India, Raw Materials Division
Vs
Union of India & Ors.
For the Petitioner
:
Mr. Aniruddha,
Mr. Sagar Agarwal.
For the Respondent No. 1
:
Mr. Rajen Dutta,
Mr. Srikumar Chakraborty.
For the P.F. Authority
:
Mr. Shiv Chandra Prasad.
Judgment reserved on
:
22.01.2026
Judgment delivered on
:
29.01.2026
Shampa Dutt (Paul), J.:
1.
The writ petition has been preferred praying for directing the
respondents no. 1 to 5 to accept and process the applications and joint
options for payment of pension on higher wages along with payment of
regular and arrears of higher pension to the all the 132 beneficiaries of
the petitioner trust and to process the applications and joint options for
payment of pension on higher wages along with payment of regular and
arrears of higher pension to the all similarly placed individuals and
quashing the rejection order dated 06.02.2025 to 34 beneficiaries.
2.
The petitioner herein being the Board of Trustees, Steel Authority of
India, Raw Materials Division, Administrative Offices Employees’
Provident Fund Trust have filed the writ application on behalf of its 132
members (both retired and in service) after 01.09.2014 (the cutoff date)
for higher pension as per the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court
in EPFO & Anr. Sunil Kumar B. & Ors., 2022 SCC OnLine SC
1521.
3.
The respondents/EPF has challenged the maintainability of the writ
application on the ground that the Board of Trustees as petitioner
herein, cannot raise or espouse the cause of the employees who claim
higher pension by way of putting in joint option form with their
establishment.
4.
It is their further contention that the petitioner Trust has no locus
standi to represent the employees as they are not its employees. The
trust only maintains the trust fund and its function solely relates to
everything to be done in respect of the said fund.
5.
In the present case, its the EPF who has the authority to consider the
joint option exercised by the establishment and its employee and its
only they, (the establishment and its employee) who have the locus
standi to pray for such relief by maintaining a writ application.
6.
Relying upon the judgment of the Calcutta High Court in Kelvin Jute
Company Limited vs Krishna Kumar Agarwal and Ors., 2006 SCC
OnLine Cal 82, the petitioner states that all affected individuals are
either current or former members of the Petitioner Trust and as such
the Petitioner Trust has a direct and substantial interest in the subject
matter of the present proceedings.
The denial of higher pension benefits by the Respondents is
predicated solely because of the cap mentioned in the Petitioner
Trust's governing rules. This misplaced reliance on the trust rules in
an attempt to blame the Petitioner Trust for denial of higher pension to
its members, renders the Petitioner Trust a directly aggrieved party as
the applications have been rejected on the pretext of non-amendment
of the trust Rules.
7.
The petitioner relies upon Para 7 of the judgment of the Supreme Court
in Union of India vs Jyoti Chit Fund and Finance & Ors., (1976) 3
SCC 607, Where in the Court held:“7. Processual law is neither petrified nor purblind but
has a simple mission — the promotion of justice. The
court cannot content itself with playing umpire in a
technical game of legal skills but must be activist in the
cause of deciding the real issues between the parties.
And one guiding principle is not to exaggerate the
efficacy of procedural defects where issues of public
concern are involved and a public authority vitally
interested in the correct principle alerts the attention of
the court to the problem. A broadened view of locus
standi leads to the futility of technical flaws where
larger issues are involved — and that is the trend of
modern processual jurisprudence. These general
considerations were trite, yet too often ignored, and so
need reiteration. Further, the consumers of justice can
have scant respect for a procedural policy which is
obsessed more with who sparks the plugs of the court
system than with what the merits of the rights or
wrongs of the relief are. A shift on the emphasis, away
from technical legalistics, is overdue if the Judicature is
not to aid its gravediggers. We express the view
strongly so that hopefuls may be dissuaded from
taking up court time by playing up technicalities.”
8.
The petitioner also relies upon the judgment in:i.
Krishna Kumar Agarwala & Ors. vs Kelvin Jute Company
Limited Workers Provident Fund Trust & Ors., 2002 SCC
OnLine Cal 901, wherein the Court held:“17. With regard to the question of locus standi of the
petitioners on the ground that they are not persons
aggrieved, it appears that the said contention is deviod
of merit. The individual member workman or workmen,
may have right as against the Trust and could have
complained to the Provident Fund Commissioner and
may approach the Court on account of his or their
claim. But that will not preclude the Trustees, in the
facts and circumstances of the case, to approach the
Court. Inasmuch as, the Trustees of the fund, though a
private trust, are discharging statutory liability in
respect of the statutory fund, since exempted but
recognized by the statute. It is the responsibility of the
Trustees to discharge their statutory liability in respect
of the fund, exempted under Section 17 of the 1952 Act
according to the scheme approved. The accumulation of
the provident fund dues of each individual member till
30th June, 1986, was, admittedly, maintained by
Kelvin Trust. With the transfer of the members of
Kelvin Trust to Waverly Trust, such accumulation is
liable to be transferred to the Waverly Trust from
Kelvin Trust. Therefore, as trustees of the Waverly
Trust, the petitioners, have every right to demand such
transfer, without which they are unable to discharge
their statutory liability viz : to pay the dues payable to
the members of the Waverly Trust. That apart, the
letter dated 24th January, 2000 though issued during
the pendency of the writ petition, yet it related to the
position as it stood before the writ petition was moved.
As such, in the facts and circumstances of the case,
the petitioners are persons aggrieved.
18. The ground that the transferee is not the
beneficiary is also untenable, in view of the fact that as
such Trustees of the Waverly Trust, the petitioners are
responsible for the purpose of administering the fund
and discharging their statutory liability. The question
that the beneficiary is paid by the employer, therefore,
the Trustees could not claim transfer, is also equally
untenable. Inasmuch as, there is nothing to show that
the entire amount Was paid. It might be an inept
drafting; but still then the statement made in Para-6 of
the writ petition, on which Mr. Mitra had relied upon,
does not bear out the meaning as was sought to be
imputed by Mr. Mitra. Relying on the statement, Mr.
Mitra sought to contend that Hooghly Mills Company
had deposited the entire amount. In order to appreciate
the said question, it would be beneficial to quote para6 as hereafter:
“6. Petitioner states that the dues in re spect of
provident fund arrears liability taken by Hooghly Mills
Ltd. till 29th June, 1986 has already been deposited
by the Hooghly Mills Company Limited with the new
Provi dent Fund Trust.””
ii.
Gadde Venkateswara Rao vs State of A.P., 1965 SCC OnLine
SC 25, (Para 8).
iii.
Fertilizer Corporation Kamgar Union vs Union of India,
(1981) 1 SCC 568, (Para 48).
9.
The point of maintainability has been raised by respondent/EPF for the
first time here.
10.
The petitioner’s contention that the writ petition is maintainable is on
the following grounds:a) That the employees whose interest is being espoused here
are/were members of the petitioner trust, which has substantial
interest in the subject matter (higher pension).
b) As the denial of higher pension relates to the cap mentioned in
the petitioner’s un amended trust rules, the petitioner trust being
an aggrieved party has the locus standi to maintain the writ
application.
11.
The respondent/EPF’s contention on the writ petition not being
maintainable is that the petitioner trust not being an aggrieved party
has no locus standi.
12.
On hearing the parties and considering the grounds challenging the
maintainability of the writ application and the petitioner trust’s case
that it is maintainable, and also the status of the petitioner trust
herein, it appears that:i.
Admittedly the petitioner/trust maintains the trust fund of the
employees of the establishment.
ii.
Admittedly the joint option is exercised by the employee and the
establishment. Thus the trust has no role in the said exercise of
option for higher pension.
iii.
The stand taken by the petitioner trust is that it has the locus
standi to maintain this writ, as the reason for refusal and
rejection of the joint option application are:(a) The un amended trust rules.
(b) The prayer for amendment after the judgment in Sunil B.
(Supra).
(c) The (limit) cap in the existing trust rules.
iv.
Admittedly the rejection of joint option for higher pension is
on quoting existing trust rules, and not allowing prayer for
amendment/modification
of
the
trust
rules
after
the
Supreme Court’s judgment in Sunil Kumar B. (Supra), even
though admittedly there is not a single word in the judgment
in Sunil Kumar B. (Supra) about internal trust rules of an
establishment.
13.
Thus the petitioner trust is clearly an aggrieved party and has the
locus standi to maintain a writ application for the relief as prayed.
14.
The writ application has been preferred praying for directing the
respondents no. 1 to 5 to accept and process the applications and joint
options for payment of pension on higher wages along with payment of
regular and arrears of higher pension to the all the 132 beneficiaries of
the petitioner trust and to process the applications and joint options for
payment of pension on higher wages along with payment of regular and
arrears of higher pension to the all similarly placed individuals and
quashing the rejection order dated 06.02.2025 to 34 beneficiaries.
15.
The petitioner further prays for a direction upon the respondent no. 3
to disburse pension on higher wages and/or accept contribution for
higher wages on the basis of the exercise of joint option made by the
petitioner along with his employer as per Employees’ Pension Scheme,
1995, on setting aside/quashing the order dated 06.02.2025 passed by
the respondent no. 3.
16.
The petitioner relying upon the order passed by this Court in WPA
15459 of 2025 and other writs have prayed for similar relief on the
ground that the petitioner’s employees herein are all similarly placed
with the petitioners in WPA 15459 of 2025 and ors. writ applications
(14).
17.
The petitioner’s application for higher pension has been rejected by an
order passed by the respondent no. 3 on 06.02.2025 on the ground of
the trust rules of the exempted establishment.
18.
The respondent no. 6 establishment enjoys exemption under Section
17(1) of the said PF Act of 1952 from the operation of Employees’
Provident Funds Scheme, 1952.
19.
It is submitted that all employees of both exempted and unexempted
establishments are considered to be the same as far as pension under
EPS’ 1995 is concerned and EPFO directly deals with pension matters
for both classes of establishments. For the purpose of contribution to
pension fund, employers only forward the requisite contribution every
month to EPFO and they have no further role as employer under the
EPS, 1995.
20.
The petitioner states that the employees are all in service since/after
01.09.2014, which is the cut off date as decided by the Supreme Court
in The Employees Provident Fund Organisation & Anr. ETC. vs
Sunil Kumar B. & Ors. ETC., in Civil Appeal Nos. ……… of 2022
(arising out of the SLP (C) Nos. 8658-8659 of 2019), decided on
November 04, 2022.
21.
Thus considering that the petitioner’s employees herein stand on the
same footing as the petitioners in WPA 15459 of 2025 and other writs,
it is directed that the order dated 06.02.2025 passed by the
respondent no. 3, is hereby quashed and set aside.
22.
It is further directed that:-
a) Any joint option application presented on or before
31.01.2025, or before any other further extension of time
by the authority considered, if any shall be accepted by
the respondents.
b) On remittance of the differential contribution amount
to the pension scheme, to the Employees’ Provident
Fund
Organisation,
by
the
employees,
along
with
applicable interest, higher pension shall be disbursed to
them from the succeeding month of their remittance.
23.
WPA 28819 of 2025 is allowed.
24.
All connected application, if any, stands disposed of.
25.
Interim order, if any, stands vacated.
26.
Urgent Photostat certified copy of this Judgment, if applied for, be
supplied to the parties, expeditiously after complying with all necessary
legal formalities.
(Shampa Dutt (Paul), J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review