Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
BEFORE:
THE HON’BLE JUSTICE SHAMPA DUTT (PAUL)
WPA 28528 of 2024
Blue Star Limited
Vs.
The State of West Bengal & Ors.
For the Petitioner
:Mr. Ranjay De, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Basabjit Banerjee, Adv.
Mr. A.A. Bose, Adv.
For the Respondent Nos.4,8,12,14
21, 23, 25, 26
: Mr. Susanta Pal, Adv.
Mr. Prabir Kumar Ray, Adv.
For the State
:Mrs. Soma Chakraborty, Adv.
Mr. Kaustav Seal, Adv.
Mr. Saikat Koley, Adv.
Judgment reserved on
: 07.08.2026
Judgment delivered on
: 07.09.2026
SHAMPA DUTT (PAUL), J.:-
1.
The present writ application has been filed assailing order no. 87 dated
12.08.2024 passed by Learned Civil Judge (Sr. Division), Suri, Birbhum
in connection with Application No. 01/2013 filed at the instance of the
Respondent No. 2 herein alleging non-compliance of minimum rates of
wages declared by the Government of West Bengal on 08.11.1995
which was meant for construction or maintenance of roads or in
building operations.
2.
The petitioner contends that he is not liable to make payment of
minimum wages which is meant for construction and maintenance of
roads or in building operations works.
It is the contention of the
petitioner that the petitioner being a manufacturer of air conditioners,
air purifiers and water coolers and also in
the
business
of
maintenance of air conditioning systems, air-washer systems,
cooling tower overhauling and operational maintenance of central
air conditioning systems etc. cannot be considered as per the said
notification dated 08.11.1995 meant for construction or maintenance of
roads or in building operations.
3.
The background of the case is that the petitioner has a contractual
arrangement in connection with Bakreshwar Thermal Power Project of
the
West
Bengal
Power
Development
Corporation
Limited
(a
Government of West Bengal Enterprise) at one of its power-generating
units situated at Post Office Bk.T.P.P., district Birbhum, Pin-731104.
From the year 2009, which subsequently was amended/extended vide
amended
order
dated
15.05.2012,
01.06.2012,
06.04.2013
in
connection with the operation and maintenance of the Central Air
Conditioning Plant of the said power generating unit. The present
service contract dated 16.11.2022 is valid on renewal till 31.12.2026.
4.
It is stated that without giving any opportunity of personal hearing, the
Petitioner Company, received a summons dated 28.01.2014 from the
Civil Judge (Senior Division) (hereinafter referred to as the Learned
Court) enclosing an Application for claim under Section 20 (2) of the
Minimum Wages Act, 1948, filed by the Respondent No.2 on 27.09.2013
alleging that the Petitioner Company failed to pay the minimum rates of
wages fixed by the State Government based on the Gazette Notification
dated 08.11.1995 as well as the notifications dated 11.11.2011,
21.12.2011, 09.07.2012 and 27.12.2012 payable to the employees
employed in the employment of, "Construction or Maintenance of Roads
or in Building Operations" in the State of West Bengal which falls within
Part-I of the Schedule of the said Act of 1948. The same was filed by the
Respondent No. 2 under a misconception to the effect that the said
judicial forum, was as if, an authority under Section 20 (1) of the said
Act of 1948. The said case was registered as Misc. Case No. 42 of 2013.
5.
The learned Counsel for the petitioner on filing written notes argues
that admittedly, Section 4 of the Minimum Wages Act, 1948 (hereinafter
referred to as the said Act of 1948) deals with fixation of minimum rates
of wages or revision thereof by the appropriate Government in respect of
the scheduled employment. Section 2(g) of the said statutory provision
defines "Scheduled Employment" to the following effect:"2.(g) "scheduled employment" means an employment
specified in the Schedule, or any process or branch of work
forming part of such employment;"
6.
The petitioner further states that it is explicit from the said definition
that the employment specified in the schedule or any process or any
branch of work would come within the purview of "scheduled
employment" and not otherwise. Keeping this aspect in mind, if we take
a turn to Item No.7 of the Part I of the Schedule under which the
Respondent no.2 sought to implement the coverage reads as follows:“(7) Employment on the construction or maintenance of roads
or in building operations”
The materials on records both oral and documentary clear prove
that the functioning of the petitioner does not come within the purview
of Item no.7 of Part I of the Schedule in any manner whatsoever.
7.
Mr. De relies upon the judgment of the Hon‟ble Delhi High Court in the
case of Amcon Construction v. Labour Enforcement Officer and Ors.
reported in 2019 SCC OnLine Del 1218 wherein while considering
the power under Section 20(3)(i) of the said Act of 1948 has been
pleased to hold that the possession of power directing of maximum
compensation does not mean that the same should be imposed without
assigning any reason. In other words, it is not punitive rather equitable
in nature. The material portions of the said judgment are being
reproduced hereinafter:"6. Merely because the Competent Authority was vested
with the discretionary power to pass an order directing
payment of maximum compensation, does not mean that it
should necessarily pass such an order without setting out any
compelling reasons for directing the highest compensation
grantable under the statute. The impugned order, on the other
hand, is lacking in this regard since the only two grounds
relied upon by the Competent Authority to arrive upon this
exorbitant figure of Rs.50,350/- was the hardships caused to
the respondent no.2 and the petitioner's default in not paying
the minimum wages to its five employees. While these are
certainly valid factors which must be taken into consideration,
the discretionary power under Section 20(3)(i) of the MW Act
must be exercised impartially by balancing the rights and
claims of both the claimant and the employer to carry out
justice on both sides. From the impugned order, however, it is
evident that the Competent Authority has
wielded its
discretion in a punitive manner against the petitioner, when
that is not the object and purpose of Section 20(3)(i) of the MW
Act, the provision serves to even out the losses and hardships
caused to an employee from the wrongful acts of an errant
employer. Therefore, the core intent of Section 20(3) of the MW
Act is equity, not punitive. In these circumstances, I am of
the view that the direction in the impugned order insofar as it
awards compensation of Rs.50,350/- cannot be sustained and
is, accordingly, set aside."
8.
Finally it is argued that the activities carried on by the writ petitioner
cannot and does not come within the purview of construction or
maintenance of roads or in building operations as mentioned in the
notification dated 08.11.1995 and as a consequence thereof the other
notifications have got no manner of applicability in any manner what so
ever. Secondly, the order impugned is a perverse one since the same is
contrary to and inconsistent with the materials on records both oral
and documentary.
Thirdly, the Learned Court has relied on the
notification which has not been exhibited or the copies thereof have
been supplied to the petitioner. Fourthly, the order impugned is an
unreasoned one and lastly, the decision of Amcon Construction (supra)
has made it abundantly clear that the provision of Section 20(3)(i) is not
punitive rather equitable in nature and as such the compensation of Rs.
33 lakhs awarded by the Learned Court below is unjust and bad in law.
Moreover, the persons named in the application filed by the Respondent
No. 2 are not in the system. Under these circumstances, the petitioner
prays for an order holding that the decision of the Learned Court below
directing the petitioner to pay a sum of Rs. 33 lakhs is unsustainable in
law and accordingly the same should be quashed.
9.
The State/respondents have filed their written notes and stated
therein that the nature of their duties of the operators was technical
and
continuous
and
was
directly
connected
with
construction,
operation and maintenance activities of the power project. Their
employment
therefore
fell
within
the
scheduled
employment
of
"Construction or Maintenance of Roads or in Building Operations" as
included in Part I of the Schedule to the Minimum Wages Act, 1948.
10.
The respondent has also stated that the employees were designated as
Technicians, Electricians, Operators and Assistant Technicians. In
actual practice, Technicians and Electricians were performing
duties requiring a high degree of technical skill, independent
judgment, long experience and responsibility for execution of
specialized tasks and were therefore covered under the category of
"Highly Skilled Work" as defined in the Labour Department
Notification published in the Calcutta Gazette Extraordinary dated
08.11.1995. Operators and Assistant Technicians were performing
duties involving technical competence, training and experience and
were therefore covered under the category of "Skilled Work" as defined
in the same notification. That prior to 29.09.2011, the company
itself treated these employees as skilled and highly skilled workers
and paid them wages corresponding to those categories without
any dispute regarding their classification or the nature of work
performed by them. Their wage structure was thus settled and
protected. On 29.09.2011, the Government of West Bengal revised the
minimum wages applicable to the said scheduled employment by
issuing
Notification
No.
742/Stat/RW/68/564/LCS/JLC
dated
11.11.2011, followed by subsequent notifications dated 21.12.2011,
09.07.2012 and 27.12.2012. Each of these notifications specifically
provided that where the existing wages of any employee were higher
than the newly notified minimum wages, such higher wages must be
protected and treated as the applicable minimum wages. After the said
notification became effective, the company did not change the
nature of duties of the workers but changed their wage categories
on paper. Highly Skilled workers were shown as Skilled workers and
Skilled
workers
were
shown
as
Semi-Skilled
workers.
This
reclassification was not based on any operational or functional change
in job responsibilities but was done only after the revised notification
came into force and only to reduce the statutory minimum wage liability
of the company. Because of this artificial lowering of categories, the
wages paid from 29.09.2011 onwards became lower than the minimum
wages applicable to the actual nature of work performed by the workers.
This resulted in continuous violation of Section 12(1) of the Minimum
Wages Act, 1948.) 1948. On 01.02.2013, all 36 affected employees
submitted a joint written complaint alleging payment of wages below the
statutory minimum rates. On the basis of the said complaint, an
inspection was conducted on 06.02.2013 at the worksite. During
inspection,
wage
registers,
pay
slips,
attendance
registers
and
employment records were examined. It was found that the workers had
been paid less than the prescribed minimum wages applicable to skilled
and highly skilled categories. An inspection report was prepared on the
same date recording contravention of Section 12(1) of the Minimum
Wages Act, 1948 and was handed over to the site supervisor with
direction to rectify the violations and submit explanation. Upon full
consideration of the evidence, the authority found that the workers
were performing skilled and highly skilled work, that their wage
categories
were
wrongly
lowered
after
the
government
notifications, that they were continuously paid less than the
statutory minimum wages from 29.09.2011 onwards and that the
underpayment
was
deliberate
and
systematic.
The
authority
accordingly passed an order directing payment of the differential wages
along with compensation under Section 20(3) of the Minimum Wages
Act, 1948.
11.
The State has denied the case of the petitioner as stated in the writ
application and their written notes. In concluding their argument as
noted in the written arguments the State submitted as follows:The RTI documents obtained from Bandel Thermal Power
Station under the West Bengal Thermal Power Development
Corporation revealed that the same company was engaged
there, for operation, and maintenance of air-conditioning
systems and allied works and engaged same type of
workers who were designated as Operators, Technicians,
Assistant Technicians, Electricians Etc. and further the fact
remains that minimum wage notifications were applicable to
such work. The RTI material further showed that identical
work was being performed by the same contractor at both
Bandel and Bakreshwar projects, thereby disproving the
company's claim that the employment did not fall under the
scheduled employment of the Minimum Wages Act.
And thus prays for dismissal of the writ application.
12.
The respondent nos. 4,8,12,14,21,23,25 and 26 have also filed their
written notes and have stated that an inspection under the minimum
wages Act, 1948.
On conducting an inspection in spite of an
application for claim under the Minimum Wages Act and inspection was
conducted in respect of the nature of their duties of the operators was
technical and continuous and was directly connected with construction,
operation and maintenance activities of the power project. Their
employment
therefore
fell
within
the
scheduled
employment
of
"Construction or Maintenance of Roads or in Building Operations" as
included in Part I of the Schedule to the Minimum Wages Act, 1948.
13.
That the employees were designated as Technicians, Electricians,
Operators
and
Assistant
Technicians.
In
actual
practice,
Technicians and Electricians were performing duties requiring a
high
degree
of
technical
skill,
independent
judgment,
long
experience and responsibility for execution of specialized tasks and were
therefore covered under the category of "Highly Skilled Work" as defined
in the Labour Department Notification published in the Calcutta
Gazette Extraordinary dated 08.11.1995. Operators and Assistant
Technicians were performing duties involving technical competence,
training and experience and were therefore covered under the category
of "Skilled Work" as defined in the same notification.
14.
That prior to 29.09.2011, the company itself treated these
employees as skilled and highly skilled workers and paid them
wages corresponding to those categories without any dispute
regarding their classification or the nature of work performed by
them. Their wage structure was thus settled and protected. On
29.09.2011, the Government of West Bengal revised the minimum
wages applicable to the said scheduled employment by issuing
Notification No. 742/Stat/RW/68/564/LCS/JLC dated 11.11.2011,
followed by subsequent notifications dated 21.12.2011, 09.07.2012 and
27 12.2012. Each of these notifications specifically provided that where
the existing wages of any employee were higher than the newly notified
minimum wages, such higher wages must be protected and treated as
the applicable minimum wages.
15.
It is further stated that after the said notification became effective, the
company did not change the nature of duties of the workers but
changed their wage categories on paper. Highly Skilled workers were
shown as Skilled workers and Skilled workers were shown as SemiSkilled workers. This reclassification was not based on any operational
or functional change in job responsibilities but was done only after the
revised notification came into force and only to reduce the statutory
minimum wage liability of the company. Because of this artificial
lowering of categories, the wages paid from 29.09.2011 onwards became
lower than the minimum wages applicable to the actual nature of work
performed by the workers. This resulted in continuous violation of
Section 12(1) of the Minimum Wages Act, 1948. On 01.02.2013, all 36
affected employees submitted a joint written complaint alleging payment
of wages below the statutory minimum rates. On the basis of the said
complaint, an inspection was conducted on 06.02.2013 at the worksite.
During inspection, wage registers, pay slips, attendance registers and
employment records were examined. It was found that the workers had
been paid less than the prescribed minimum wages applicable to skilled
and highly skilled categories.
16.
An inspection report was prepared on the same date recording
contravention of Section 12(1) of the Minimum Wages Act, 1948 and
was handed over to the site supervisor with direction to rectify the
violations and submit explanation. No satisfactory explanation was
submitted within the stipulated period. On 18.02.2013, a representative
of the company appeared with certain records but without proper
authorization and without making payment of the wage difference.
17.
On hearing the learned Counsel for the parties and on perusal of the
materials on record including the judgment relied upon along with
documents related to the job of the workers in the present case, it
appears that admittedly, the workmen herein are the employees of the
petitioner, Blue Star Ltd. Admitedly, the workmen herein are the
operators who monitor the Air Conditioning of the factory/plant and/or
Air Conditioning (AC) Plant. Operators are responsible for the
continuous, safe and efficient operation of large scale commercial or
industrial cooling systems. Their job centers on monitoring equipment,
regulating temperatures, performing routine preventive maintenance
and troubleshooting system faults to ensure optimal climate control and
uninterrupted facility operations. Continuously check gauges, dials and
thermostats on the central control board to ensure the plant operates
within safe parameters temperature.
18.
An AC Plant Operator under the Government of West Bengal (such as
in the Public Works Directorate) serves in a vital skilled or technical
role. Their core responsibility is the uninterrupted, safe, and efficient
operation of central air conditioning and refrigeration systems in
government buildings, hospitals, and secretariats. Key responsibilities
and the nature of the job include:Primary Operations
Operating central AC plants, compressor units, chillers, Air Handling
Units (AHUs), and cooling towers.
Monitoring: Regulating chilled water valves, monitoring pressure levels,
and measuring temperatures to maintain a comfortable, climatecontrolled environment.
Preventive Checks: Routinely inspecting terminal connections, air
filters, blower motors, and refrigerant lines to prevent equipment
failures.
Minor Repairs: Conducting minor mechanical repairs, cleaning filters,
and providing routine lubrication and greasing.
Safety Protocols: Taking immediate corrective measures during
emergencies. such as power surges, erratic performance, or fire
hazards, and coordinating with electrical JEs (Junior Engineers).
Operators typically possess an ITI (Industrial Training Institute)
certificate in Refrigeration & Air Conditioning alongside relevant
field experience. An AC Plant Operator under the Government of West
Bengal (such as in the Public Works Directorate) serves in a vital skilled
or technical role. Their core responsibility is the uninterrupted, safe,
and efficient operation of central air conditioning and refrigeration
systems in buildings, hospitals, and secretariats.
19.
The Government of West Bengal in its notification no. NIQ-17 of 202223 for a period of 1 year laid down the following conditions in respect
of an agency:“For operation of the chilled water AC plant comprising with compressor,
allied pump motor sets, cooling tower, FCUs & AHUs round the clock
throughout the year (inclusive of all holidays).
The AC Plant Operator/ Attendant should have relevant license
and sound knowledge about the A.C. Plant………….”
MONTHLY PREVENTIVE MAINTENANCE –
Compressor & Condenser Unit
1. Checking and rectification, if required for abnormal noise, vibration,
leakage of oil, refrigerant etc.
2 Topping up system with refrigerant and oil, replace dehydrator etc if
required.
3 Checking of operation of oil heater, loading unloading, safety switches,
O/L etc. & necessary rectification if required.
4 Checking of electrical starter and drum control and control panel &
necessary rectification if required.
5 Develop action plan for rectifying, abnormalities if any observed in
performance of the system.
6. All repairing work of compressor including rewinding of compressor
motor etc.
AHU & FCU
1 Inspection and cleaning of all filters.
2 Chemical/Water cleaning of cooling and heating coils as per
requirement.
3. Checking leakage in pipeline, valve connection & rectification.
4. Checking and rectification of operation of fan, impeller, drive pulley,
belt tensions, bearing noise, abnormal sound, motor vibration and pulley
alignment.
5. Cleaning of drain trays.
6. Checking inspection and rectification of AHU starter, fuses, and all
electrical connections include checking of motor current & rewinding of
motor if required.
Pumps
1 Checking for leakage and repair/ replacement/ adjustment of pump
seals, glands, valve glands, gaskets.
2. Checking and rectification/ replacement of all bearings for sound,
heating and vibration.
3 Inspection of terminal connections and megger of pump motor including
rewinding of motor.
Cooling Tower
1 Checking & cleaning of water distribution trays, nozzles, strainers,
sump etc & necessary rectification.
2 Checking & tightening of all electrical terminals.
20.
The terms and conditions are laid down by the Government of west
Bengal:“1.
The
contractor
has
to
depute
no.
skilled
AC
Mechanic/Operator (Skilled labour) per shift (1shift = 8 hours)
on
all
function/programme
days
as
per
Mechanic/Operator
should
have
&
from
any
booking
schedule/requirement of the authority.
2.
The
AC
Refrigeration
Air-conditioning
I.T.I.
in
authorized
institute and minimum 2 years of working experience. (The
Agency has to provide necessary certificates before issuance of
Final Acceptance). The AC Mechanic has to take preventive
measures/action in case of any type of abnormalities/fault found
before
as
well
as
during
functioning/operation
of
A.C.
machines/Plant unit as well as cope up with any kinds of fatal
accident i.e., causing of fire break-out arising out of A.C. machines.
This should be treated as mandatory.”
21.
It appears from the said document that the AC mechanic has been
treated as an operator (thus skilled labour) and as such the agency
should be responsible for payment of minimum wages to the engaged
worker(s) as per relevant circular of Labour Department, Govt. of W.B.
in Vogue. The bills have to be produced by the agency through their
Letter Head & should contain a certificate that the engaged worker(s)
were paid complying the minimum wages as per relevant circular issued
by Labour Department, Govt. of W.B. in Vogue and non-compliance of
the same may lead to termination of the contract. (minimum wages
means daily rate as per recent circular of Labour Department, W.B
corresponding to category of labour x 30 days).
22.
Mr. De, learned Counsel for the petitioner submits that admittedly he
receives a specified amount from the employer of Bakreswar
Thermal Power Plant. The petitioner as the employer on receiving the
specified amount makes payment to the staff. It is an admitted case
that the petitioner pays the operators the minimum wages which
admittedly is not the amount as notified for maintenance of building
operations. It is stated that he pays the rate of minimum wages fixed for
“semi skilled workers”. It appears that by treating the said operators as
“semi skilled workers” the petitioner does not pay the minimum wages
which is higher and paid in respect of “skilled workers” in maintenance
of building operations.
23.
It is the contention of Mr. De that the specified amount received by him
at the rate for semi skilled workers as per Government notification is
paid.
It is further stated that if the petitioner is directed to pay the
minimum wages in respect of „skilled‟ in respect of maintenance of
building operation workers, then the petitioner will suffer financial loss.
Mr. Dey further contends that he pays the rate of semi skilled workers
to the operators as they do not perform any duty, as that of skilled
workers. Their only job is to switch on and switch off the AC and it is
clear that it does not require a skilled person to do so.
24.
From the materials on record it appears that the petitioner‟s case is that
the workers herein are „operators‟ and thus semi skilled.
25.
Admittedly they work to operate air conditioning of the establishment
and an air conditioning mistry is classified as “highly skilled” in the
Govt. of West Bengal, Gazette, Labour Department dated November 8,
1995.
26.
The petitioner admittedly is in the business of manufacturing air
conditioners, air purifiers and water coolers. It is also in the business of
maintenance of air conditioning systems, air-washer systems, cooling
tower
overhauling
and
operational
maintenance
of
central
air
conditioning systems etc.
27.
The petitioner‟s further case is that the employees/workers appointed
by it are classified into groups being operators, technician, electrician. It
is also stated that the nature of work is duly classified among the
categories maintained.
28.
It is further stated that herein the operators only switch on and switch
off the air conditioning machine, a work which doesn‟t need any
technically qualified person as
it can also be operated by the user
themselves, as done in our homes.
29.
In the present case it is the air conditioning of a plant and the machines
installed in the thermal power plants, which are to be operated and
maintained. The
classification
herein
thus
appears
to
be
a
camouflage to deprive a category of workers their lawfully entitled
minimum wages.
30.
Admittedly the air conditioning and other cooling system herein is for
the thermal power plants, wherein the petitioner admits includes
operational maintenance of Central Air Conditioning System etc.
31.
The maintenance of air conditioning is a core part of building
operations and maintenance. It falls under the HVAC (Heating.
Ventilation, and Air Conditioning) category, which is a standard
component of technical services and facility management.
Building operations cover all workflows and processes required to
keep a facility functional, safe, and comfortable on a daily basis.
Technical services and Mechanical & Electrical (M&E) operations
explicitly include the servicing of HVAC systems.
Routine upkeep ensures optimal air quality, energy efficiency, and
temperature control for occupants.
32.
Building maintenance covers a wide range of work, including here are a
few examples that most facilities deal with regularly:
1. HVAC Maintenance
Heating, ventilation, and air conditioning systems need regular
inspection and cleaning. Filters are replaced, ducts cleaned, and
thermostats calibrated. This keeps the air clean, prevents energy
waste, and ensures comfort in every season and
2. Electrical System Maintenance
Electrical inspections check for damaged wiring, overloaded circuits,
and safety issues. Lighting systems are tested, backup generators
are serviced, and emergency lighting is maintained.
33.
As such the minimum wages for „construction or maintenance‟ of roads
or in building operations is applicable to all the employees herein, and
such nature of work is a skilled trade as, Heating, Ventilation, and Air
Conditioning (HVAC) is a skilled trade that requires formal education,
specialized technical knowledge, and hands-on experience.
34.
Technicians must understand electrical control circuits, refrigeration
theory, computer networking, and airflow dynamics. Finding why a
system fails takes years of practice. Workers must interpret electrical,
mechanical, and chemical signs at the same time.
Workers usually need a certificate, an associate degree, or a
multi-year apprenticeship from a trade school or technical college.
Technicians must follow strict safety rules and often hold legal licenses
or certifications to handle refrigerants and electrical components.
35.
36.
Routine AC care within building operations typically involves:
Inspecting and replacing air filters
Cleaning evaporator and condenser coils
Checking refrigerant levels and testing pressures
Calibrating thermostats and examining electrical connections
Clearing condensate drain lines and lubricating moving parts
Considering the said facts and circumstances, the employees herein are
thus entitled to the minimum wages as declared by the State Labour
Department for skilled workers in building operations.
37.
Admittedly the petitioner receives a lump sum of payment from
principal employer and makes payment as alleged depriving the
workers.
38.
The entitlement of these workers is to be paid by the principal employer
to the contractor (petitioner herein) as per Govt. rate of minimum wages
towards building operations for skilled workers, so no prejudice is
caused to the petitioner herein, which can be reimbursed on the
amount being paid.
39.
Thus the impugned order no. 87 dated 12.08.2024 passed by Learned
Civil Judge (Sr. Division), Suri, Birbhum in connection with Application
No. 01/2013 filed at the instance of the Respondent No. 2 herein
alleging non-compliance of minimum rates of wages declared by the
Government of West Bengal on 08.11.1995 which was meant for
construction or maintenance of roads or in building operations,
(skilled workers) does not require any interference, being in accordance
with law.
40.
WPA 28528 of 2024 is dismissed.
41.
Applications,
if
any,
connected
thereto
stand
disposed
of
consequently.
42.
Interim order, if any, stands vacated.
43.
Photostat certified copy of this Judgment, if applied for, be given to
the parties on priority basis upon compliance of all formalities.
(Shampa Dutt (Paul), J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review