Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/28
GAHC040014862023
undefined
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : CRL.A(J)/38/2023
Biswajit Narzary
S/o Lt. Sanjit Narzary, R/o Lamabari Village, PO/PS Mazbat, District Udalguri,
Assam
VERSUS
THE STATE OF AP
Through the Public Prosecutor
Advocate for the Petitioner
Binggep
: Legal Aid Counsel, Abhisek Bhattacharjee,Abhijit Bhattacharya,O
Advocate for the Respondent : P P of AP,
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE PRANJAL DAS
Advocate for the appellant
:
Mr. A.Bhattarcharya
Advocate for the State respondent
:
Ms. L. Hage, Addl. P.P
Date on which judgment is reserved
: 05.08.2026
Date of pronouncement of judgment
: 21.08.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of the : No
operative part of the judgment ?
Whether the full judgment has been
: Yes
Page No.# 2/28
pronounced?
JUDGMENT & ORDER (CAV)
Date : -21-08-2026
Heard Mr. A Bhattarcharya, learned counsel for the appellant.
Also heard Ms. L. Hage, learned Addl. P.P appearing for the State.
Introductory facts:
2. The instant criminal appeal has been filed by the convict Biswajit
Narzary against the judgment dated 09-01-2023 and sentence order
dated 13-01-2023 passed by the learned Special Judge of East
Kameng, West Kameng and Tawang at Bomdila in Special NDPS Case
No. 13 of 2020 arising out of Kalaktang Case No. 15 of 2018 whereby the appellant has been convicted under the provisions of
section 20(b)(ii)(C) of the NDPS Act and sentenced to undergo
rigorous imprisonment for 10 years and pay a fine of Rs. 1 lakh (in
default to undergo simple imprisonment for 3 months). He has been
given the benefit of set off. The convict/appellant is presently in jail
undergoing the sentence.
3. The prosecution case in brief is that on 06-10-2018, a complaint
was lodged by Inspector Pyiloki Lotha of Sashastra Seema Bal with
the allegations that on 06-10-2018 they got an information around
2:00 P.M that a blue colour Alto K10 vehicle bearing Registration No.
AS-27A-7077 was coming from Kalaktang side and accordingly,
checking was launched under the leadership of the informant and his
team. It is further stated that around 4:10 P.M on the same day a
Page No.# 3/28
blue colour Alto K10 vehicle bearing Registration No. AS-27A7077 was coming towards the checking and upon the driver being
signaled to stop he stopped the vehicle and tried to run away,
whereupon he fell down on the road and got bruised. He was caught
by the SSB troops and upon checking the vehicle in the presence of
two witnesses being ASI Deepak Dole and Head Constable A.
Shankar Singh on the spot, it was found that there were four white
coloured polythene bags containing suspected cannabis. It was found
that bag A contained 4 kgs of cannabis; bag B contained 4 kgs of
cannabis; bag C contained 5 kgs; bag D contained 4 kgs; bag E
contained 4 kgs; bag F contained 4 kgs and bag G contained 4 kgs.
Upon being asked, the detained person stated that he was carrying
the cannabis to deliver at Mazbat area and he could not show any
documents and accordingly, the apprehended person along with the
total 29 kgs of seized cannabis and the vehicle were handed over to
the Police.
4. On the basis of the aforesaid complaint, Kalaktang Case No. 15
of 2018 was registered under section 20(B) of the NDPS Act and was
endorsed to take up the investigation. The investigation progressed
and upon completion of investigation, final form in the form of
Charge-Sheet being C.S No. 02 of 2020 dated 11-01-2020 was
filed against the appellant under section 20(B) of the NDPS Act. The
charge sheet listed 8 witnesses.
5. Subsequently, upon completion of the usual formalities pertaining
to copies etc., the learned Trial court vide order dated 18-02-
Page No.# 4/28
2021 framed charge against the appellant under section 20(b) of the
NDPS Act. The charge upon being read over to the appellant, as
accused was denied by him, whereupon the Trial started. During the
Trial, the prosecution examined 8 witnesses. Thereafter, the appellant
as accused was examined under section 313 Cr.PC. The defense did
not adduce any evidence. After completion of the Trial, the appellant
was convicted and sentenced as already mentioned above. Hence,
the present appeal.
Evidence:
6.
PW1 is Deepak Doley who stated in his deposition that on 06-10-
2018,
at
Chain,
during
surprise checking,
the
accused
was
apprehended along with suspected ganja and that he was coming in an
Alto car. He further testified that the total suspected ganja was around 29
kgs and later he handed over the accused along with ganja to the OC of
Kalaktang Police Station. Testifying further, PW1 stated that during
surprise checking, he along with other personnel comprising 4 personnel
were
conducting
checking
and
Inspector
P.Lotha
was
leading
the
checking and Mr. A Shankar was also participating in the check. He proved
the seizure list of the seized items as P. Ex.1 and his signature thereon as
P.Ex.1
(A).
He
proved
another
seizure
list
as
P.Ex.2
and
his
signature thereon as P.Ex.2(A). However, during his testimony he stated
that he was not sure whether the accused standing on the dock was the
present convict/appellant. He further stated that he saw him once during
the time of apprehension and do not properly remember the face of the
accused. In cross-examination, he stated that he had seen the suspected
contraband at the time of the seizure.
Page No.# 5/28
7.
In cross-examination, he stated that he had seen the suspected
contraband at the time of seizure but he does not remember whether
these were weighed or not by the Police at the time of taking over by the
Police. He stated that he did not know whether the vehicle apprehended
was the personal car of the accused or a hired vehicle. He stated that
seizure list Exhibit P.Ex.2 was prepared on the spot. He denied the
suggestion that they had falsely implicated the accused. However, he
admitted that the sample was not collected in his presence. He stated that
the distance between place of occurrence and Police Station was about 15
kilometers and he even admitted the possibility that there could be
manipulation of seized contraband between the place of occurrence and
the Police Station. This witness was re-examined by the prosecution and in
re-examination he clearly stated that there was no manipulation of seized
contraband from the place of occurrence to the Police Station.
8.
PW-2 is A. Shankar Singh who stated that in the year 2018 at 900
Chain they intercepted a vehicle and seized suspected ganja from it. He
stated that many SSB personnel participated in the operation including Mr.
P. Lotha and PW-1. He stated that the apprehended person was from
Assam who was later on handed over along with the ganja to the OC of
Kalaktang Police Station. He proved as exhibit Ex.1(B) as his signature on
seizure list Exhibit P. Ex.1. He also proved his signature on another seizure
list as Exhibit P.Ex.2(B). He stated the distance between the place of
occurrence and the Police Station to be about 20 kilometers. In crossexamination, he stated that the seized items were not shown to him by
the Police and he did not witness the sample collection. He also stated that
he did not know about the car of the accused and as to whether it was a
personal car or hired vehicle. He also admitted the possibility of
manipulation of seized contraband in between place of occurrence and
Page No.# 6/28
Police Station. However, he denied that the car along with the contraband
was not seized and also denied about false implication against the
accused. Upon re-examination by the prosecution, PW-2 clarified that
there was no manipulation of seized contraband between the place of
occurrence and the Police Station. He stated further that the seized items
were brought by them and handed over to the Police and thereafter, P.Ex.1
was prepared. With regard to the re-examination, PW-2 was crossexamined by the defense in which he stated that the seized items were
handed over to the Police by his Senior Officer and he has personally
witnessed the process of handing and taking over.
9.
PW-3 Bidyut Paul is a seizure witness. He stated that the owner of
the vehicle was Bholadas Panika and the vehicle was an Alto. He proved
the zimma document as Exhibit P.Ex.3 and his signature thereon as Exhibit
P.Ex3(A); stating further that vehicle was handed over to the said
Bholadas Panika. In cross-examination he stated that his name is Bidyut
Paul and that he does not know why Police has written his name as Bappi
Paul.
10. PW-4 Raja Paul is another zimma witness stating the same name
Bholadas Panika as the owner of the vehicle. He also proved his signature
on the zimma document as Exhibit P.Ex.3. He stated about handing over of
the vehicle to the owner. Cross-examination was declined.
11. PW5 Mr. T. Aran is an executive official who was stated to be ADC
Kalaktang at the relevant time and he has stated about destroying the
cannabis in connection with this case and other cases in his capacity as a
Magistrate. He
proved
the
certificate
of
correctness
of
inventory,
photographs and samples as Exhibit P Ex.4 and his signatures P Ex.4 and P
Ex.5(a). He proved the correctness certificate as Exhibit P Ex. 6 and his
Page No.# 7/28
signature as P Ex. 6(a). In cross examination, he admitted that seized
cannabis of several cases were destroyed and that he had not given
permission for destruction of cannabis in the present case. He also stated
that he cannot say as to whether the collected samples were drawn from
the seized cannabis in this particular case or not.
12. PW6 Pyiloki Lotha is the Investigating Officer of the case and he
stated in his deposition that on 06-10-2018 upon receiving information
about transportation of contraband, Naka checking was laid and during
such checking one Alto K10 vehicle bearing Registration No. AS-27A-7077
was signaled to stop whereupon though the vehicle stopped the driver
tried to run away but fell down and sustained injuries. He further testified
about the driver being apprehended and upon search 7 plastic bags
containing suspected ganja weighing 29 kgs was found. He proved the FIR
as Exhibit P.Ex.8 with Ext. 8(a) being his signature. He proved the seizure
list as Exhibit 1 and 2 and his signatures being Exhibit 1 (c) and 2(c). In
cross examination, he admitted that the Naka was conducted on prior
information but the information was not written down in office and he had
not intimated his Commanding Officer nor police or Magistrate. He stated
that sometimes checking fails due to information leakage and so he has
not informed anyone before the checking. He admitted that during seizure
there were no civil witnesses. He admitted that he had not sealed the
contraband substance after recovery and that there was no MR number.
However he denied that the accused has been falsely implicated.
13. PW7 Miding Borang adduced evidence on behalf of the FSL stating
that a sample of the case was examined by scientific officer S. Iboma Devi
and upon such examination it gave positive test for cannabis. He proved
the FSL report as exhibit P. Ex.13 and as P. Ex.13(a) the signature of S.
Page No.# 8/28
Iboma Devi which he identified. He exhibited as M.Ex.13 the sample
returned after the examination. In cross examination, he clarified that he
had not conducted the examination himself.
14. PW-8 Dige Tayeng stated in his deposition that on 06-10-2018 he
was posted at the Kalaktang Police Station as the OC and on that day one
written FIR was received from Inspector Pyiloki Lotha of the 61st Battalion
of SSB alleging that on 06-10-2018 at around 2 P.M based on input SSB
personnel conducted checking of one Alto K10 vehicle bearing Registration
No. AS-27A-7077. That it was further stated that at the time of checking
the vehicle was signaled to stop whereupon the driver stopped but tried to
run away and while doing so fell on the road and sustained some bruises
and he was apprehended by the SSB personnel. Testifying further, PW8 stated that during checking of the vehicle they recovered seven plastic
bags containing suspected ganja measuring 29 Kgs and subsequently, the
accused as well as the contraband was handed over to the Police Station.
Upon receipt of the FIR, he registered Kalaktang P.S Case No. 15 of 2018
under
section
20(B)
investigation himself.
of
the
Testifying
NDPS
Act
and
further,
he
stated
undertook
that
the
during
investigation he re-seized the ganja and forwarded the ganja for FSL
examination. He took photographs of the seized ganja, car and accused
person. He prepared inventory of the contraband ganja taking photograph
of the same and placed it before the Magistrate and on his prayer, the
contraband
was
destroyed
by
the
Magistrate. Upon
completion
of
investigation, he submitted charge-sheet against the accused/Biswajit
Narzary under section 20(B) NDPS Act. He proved the seizure lists as
Exhibit P Ex.1 and P.Ex.2 proving his signatures thereon as Exhibit
P.Ex.1(d) and P. Ex.2(d). He proved as Exhibit P.Ex.4 application for
Page No.# 9/28
certifying correctness of inventory photograph and sample as Exhibit
P.Ex.4,
identifying
signature
thereon
as
P.
Ex.4(d).
He
proved
the inventory-cum-correctness certificate of the contraband as Exhibit
P.Ex.5 and his signature there on his Exhibit P.Ex.5(d). He also proved the
correctness certificate of contraband issued by Magistrate as Exhibit
P.Ex.6. He proved the FIR as Exhibit P.Ex.8 and his signatures there on as
Exhibit P.Ex.8(b) to (d). He proved as P.Ex. 9, the proforma of seizure. He
proved as Exhibit P.Ex.15, the inventory of seized contraband and his
signature there on as Exhibit P.Ex.15(a). He proved as Exhibit P.Ex.16 the
certificate of registration of seized vehicle. He proved the charge-sheet as
Exhibit P.Ex.18 and his signatures there on his Exhibit P.Ex.18(a) to (d). He
proved as material Exhibit 1, 2 and 3, the photographs of the
seized substances and his signatures thereon as material Exhibit 1(a to
e). He proved as Material Exhibit 13, the return sample of seized cannabis
received from the FSL Bandardewa. He proved as Material Exhibit 14 to
16, the photographs of the seized vehicle and his signatures thereon as
Exhibit Mat. Ex.14(a) to 16(a).
15.
In cross-examination by defense, PW-8 he stated that checking was
conducted as per specific information. He further stated that in the FIR
the informant has not mentioned as to whether the complainant had
written down the information and intimated to his superior officer. He
stated that the contraband was not produced at the Police Station with
seal and that the informant had not mentioned about the custody of the
seized contraband before producing at Police Station. He also admitted
that there were no independent witnesses on Exhibit P.Ex.1 and Exhibit
P.Ex.2. He stated that during seizure no Magistrate was present. He also
stated that during seizure he had not taken any photograph or video. He
also stated that he had not mentioned the date, time, weight regarding
Page No.# 10/28
the sample sent for FSL. He had also not mentioned regarding the custody
of the sample. He stated that FSL was done prior to the inventory and
sampling during destruction. He stated that he had collected the sample
of seven bags without mixing the same. He also stated that he had not
explained the delay in sending the sample to FSL examination. He stated
that he had not mentioned regarding custody of the seized materials and
that application of correctness inventory were made for several cases
together and that during certification of the correctness of inventory he
had produced the seized materials before the Magistrate. He also admitted
that the destruction of materials was done together of several cases. He
stated that inventory was prepared after more than a year of seizing the
same and that during this period the seized materials were kept
at malkana under the charge of the in-charge. But the same has not been
mentioned in the charge-sheet. However, he denied that the accused has
been wrongly implicated or investigation not carried out properly. He also
denied that the inventory was not as per the format provided under
section 52(A) of the NDPS Act.
Submissions:
16. Mr. Bhattacharya, the learned counsel for the appellant, submits that
the prosecution case suffers from several procedural lapses as a result of
which the appellant has been prejudiced during the trial. It is submitted
that the Malkhana register was never exhibited and that all the witnesses
of seizure were police personnel. It is submitted that one Bholadas, stated
to be the owner of the vehicle, was not made a witness and that the said
Bikash Boro was from a different case.
17. It is submitted that there is also no evidence of any bruises to show
that the accused ran away from the place of occurrence at the time of the
Page No.# 11/28
alleged apprehension. It is submitted that the purported seizure was on
06-10-2018, but the inventory was prepared on 26-11-2019 and that said
time
gap
is
violative
of
the
provisions
of
the
NDPS
Act.
The
learned counsel for the appellant also questions that there are doubts
about the FSL report and as to whether the same contraband which was
seized was the one which was examined at the FSL laboratory.
18. Referring to the 2022 NDPS Rules, the learned counsel submits that
as per Rule 13, the inventory has to be prepared before the Magistrate
without any delay, but here there was a delay of one year, thereby vitiating
the proceedings completely. It is submitted that the seized contraband was
not properly mixed in. The learned counsel summing up his submissions,
submits that apart from fatal procedural infirmities, the prosecution case
has violated mandatory provisions of the NDPS Act and therefore, the
impugned judgment and order is vitiated and liable to be set aside.
19.
In
support
of
his
contentions,
the
learned
counsel
for
the
convict/appellant cites the following decisions:
(i) Union of India -versus- Mohan Lal & Another, reported in
(2016) 3 SCC 379, (para-16).
(ii) Arif Khan @ Agha Khan -versus- State of Uttarkhand, in Cril.
Appeal No. 273/2007, Crl. Appeal No. 27/2018, (para-23).
(iii) Rishi Dev @ Onkar Singh -versus- State (Delhi Admn.),
(para-23).
(iv) Surepally Srinivas -versus- State of Andhra Pradesh in
Criminal Appeal No. 1474/2025, (para-13,14, 15).
(v) Bharat Aambale -versus- State of Chattisgarh, reported in
2025 INSC 78.
Page No.# 12/28
20.
On the other hand, Ms. L. Hage, the learned Additional Public
Prosecutor, submits that the seizure was made on 06-10- 2018 and that
the seals were intact and sent to the Malkhana on the same day and on
11-12-2018, it was sent to the FSL. It is submitted by the prosecution that
the chain of custody is complete and proper and that the procedures
followed have not caused any prejudice to the appellant as accused during
the trial. It is submitted that there was no seizure from his body and
therefore, the question of compliance with section 50 does not arise. She
submits that the seizure witnesses have supported the prosecution case
regarding the seizure of the contraband from the vehicle.
21. It is submitted by the learned Additional Public Prosecutor that there
might be some minor procedural lapses but the chain of circumstances is
complete. It is submitted that any infirmity with regard to compliance
under section 52A of the NDPS Act cannot be ground for acquittal. It is
submitted that the conduct of the accused in trying to run away from the
place of occurrence is a relevant factor to be taken into account. Summing
up her submissions, the learned Additional Public Prosecutor supports the
impugned judgment and order and prays for dismissing of the appeal.
In support of her contentions, the learned Additional PP cites the
following decisions:
(i). Bikash Boro -versus- The State of Arunachal Pradesh &
Others, passed in Crl. A No. 12/2024 dated 30.01.2026.
(ii) Narcotics Control Bureau -versus- Kashif, reported in 2024
SCC OnLine SC 3848, (para-39).
(iii) Mehboob Shah -versus- State of Madhya Pradesh, 2026
INSC 729, (para-15 & 17).
Page No.# 13/28
Discussion:
22.
Section 42 of the NDPS Act provides inter-alia that when such
operation to find contraband is conducted by an authorised officer based
on information about such illegal drugs being concealed in any building,
conveyance or enclosed space - upon the said information being taken
down in writing - then within 72 hours, the said information has to be sent
to his immediate superior official. For ready reference, the entire contents
of section 42 of the NDPS Act may be reproduced herein below, with the
relevant provisions underlined:
“42. Power of entry, search, seizure and arrest without warrant or
authorisation.-- (l) Any such officer (being an officer superior in rank to a
peon, sepoy or constable) of the departments of central excise, narcotics,
customs, revenue intelligence or any other department of the Central
Government including para-military forces or armed forces as is empowered in
this behalf by general or special order by the Central Government, or any such
officer (being an officer superior in rank to a peon, sepoy or constable) of the
revenue, drugs control, excise, police or any other department of a State
Government as is empowered in this behalf by general or special order of the
State Government, if he has reason to believe from personal knowledge or
information given by any person and taken down in writing that any narcotic
drug, or psychotropic substance, or controlled substance in respect of which an
offence punishable under this Act has been committed or any document or
other article which may furnish evidence of the commission of such offence or
any illegally acquired property or any document or other article which may
furnish evidence of holding any illegally acquired property which is liable for
seizure or freezing or forfeiture under Chapter VA of this Act is kept or
concealed in any building, conveyance or enclosed place, may between
sunrise and sunset,(a) enter into and search any such building, conveyance or place;
(b) in case of resistance, break open any door and remove any obstacle to such
entry;
(c) seize such drug or substance and all materials used in the manufacture
thereof and any other article and any animal or conveyance which he has
reason to believe to be liable to confiscation under this Act and any document or
other article which he has reason to believe may furnish evidence of the
Page No.# 14/28
commission of any offence punishable under this Act or furnish evidence of
holding any illegally acquired property which is liable for seizure or freezing or
forfeiture
under
Chapter
VA
of
this
Act;
and
(d) detain and search, and, if he thinks proper, arrest any person whom he has
reason to believe to have committed any offence punishable under this Act:
2[Provided that in respect of holder of a licence for manufacture of
manufactured drugs or psychotropic substances or controlled substances
granted under this Act or any rule or order made thereunder, such power shall
be exercised by an officer not below the rank of sub-inspector:
Provided further that] if such officer has reason to believe that a search
warrant or authorisation cannot be obtained without affording opportunity for the
concealment of evidence or facility for the escape of an offender, he may enter
and search such building, conveyance or enclosed place at any time between
sunset and sunrise after recording the grounds of his belief.
(2) Where an officer takes down any information in writing under subsection (1) or records grounds for his belief under the proviso thereto, he shall
within seventy-two hours send a copy thereof to his immediate official
superior.”
(emphasis added)
23.
The leading authority on the law pertaining to section 42 of the NDPS
Act is the Constitutional Bench judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
the case of Karnail Singh v. State of Haryana, reported in (2009) 8
SCC 539. One of the main principles laid down therein is that section 42
and its compliance is mandatory. However, while a total non-compliance
may not be excusable, but in certain situations, substantial compliance
could fulfill the requirement of section 42 of the NDPS Act. The relevant
para of Karnail Singh (supra) may be reproduced herein below:
“35. In conclusion, what is to be noticed is that Abdul Rashid
[(2000) 2 SCC 513 : 2000 SCC (Cri) 496] did not require literal
compliance with the requirements of Sections 42(1) and 42(2) nor
did Sajan Abraham [(2001) 6 SCC 692 : 2001 SCC (Cri) 1217] hold
that the requirements of Sections 42(1) and 42(2) need not be
fulfilled at all. The effect of the two decisions was as follows:
Page No.# 15/28
(a) The officer on receiving the information [of the nature
referred to in sub-section (1) of Section 42] from any person had to
record it in writing in the register concerned and forthwith send a
copy to his immediate official superior, before proceeding to take
action in terms of clauses (a) to (d) of Section 42(1).
(b) But if the information was received when the officer was
not in the police station, but while he was on the move either on
patrol duty or otherwise, either by mobile phone, or other means,
and the information calls for immediate action and any delay would
have resulted in the goods or evidence being removed or destroyed,
it would not be feasible or practical to take down in writing the
information given to him, in such a situation, he could take action as
per clauses (a) to (d) of Section 42(1) and thereafter, as soon as it is
practical, record the information in writing and forthwith inform the
same to the official superior.
(c) In other words, the compliance with the requirements of
Sections 42(1) and 42(2) in regard to writing down the information
received and sending a copy thereof to the superior officer, should
normally precede the entry, search and seizure by the officer. But in
special circumstances involving emergent situations, the recording
of the information in writing and sending a copy thereof to the official
superior may get postponed by a reasonable period, that is, after the
search, entry and seizure. The question is one of urgency and
expediency.
(d) While total non-compliance with requirements of subsections (1) and (2) of Section 42 is impermissible, delayed
compliance with satisfactory explanation about the delay will be
acceptable compliance with Section 42. To illustrate, if any delay
may result in the accused escaping or the goods or evidence being
destroyed or removed, not recording in writing the information
received, before initiating action, or non-sending of a copy of such
information to the official superior forthwith, may not be treated as
violation of Section 42. But if the information was received when the
police officer was in the police station with sufficient time to take
action, and if the police officer fails to record in writing the
Page No.# 16/28
information received, or fails to send a copy thereof, to the official
superior, then it will be a suspicious circumstance being a clear
violation of Section 42 of the Act. Similarly, where the police officer
does not record the information at all, and does not inform the
official superior at all, then also it will be a clear violation of Section
42 of the Act. Whether there is adequate or substantial compliance
with Section 42 or not is a question of fact to be decided in each
case. The above position got strengthened with the amendment to
Section 42 by Act 9 of 2001.”
(emphasis added)
24.
The underlying principle behind these procedural safeguards is
that considering the nature of offences under the NDPS Act, certain
procedural safeguards are held to be essential so as to guard against any
possibility
of
false
implication.
The
objective of
the
procedural
requirements is to ensure that in a situation when a person is
prosecuted for offences under the NDPS Act, it is proved to the satisfaction
of the judicial conscience of the Court that the contraband in the nature
of narcotic drugs or psychotropic substances have been seized actually and
properly from the accused. That, the chain of custody has been maintained
and that, the contraband which was actually seized at the place of
occurrence is the contraband which is examined in the Forensic Laboratory.
25.
The decision in Arif Khan @ Agha Khan (supra) relied upon by
the appellant side, would not be much relevant to the present adjudication,
as in paragraph No.-23 of the said decision, the Hon’ble Apex Court
emphasised the mandatory nature of section 50 of the Act. It is well
settled that section 50 of the NDPS Act applies to a situation where bodily
search is conducted on the accused and contraband recovered from such
bodily search. The decision of the Constitutional Bench of the Hon’ble Apex
Court in the State of Punjab -versus- Baldev Singh, reported in (1999) 6
Page No.# 17/28
SCC 172 holds the field and the said decision mandates strict compliance
with the provisions of section 50 of the Act.
26. In the instant case, the recovery has been from bags allegedly carried
by the appellant - in his vehicle and though section 42 was applicable as
the search was conducted in a conveyance (vehicle) - Section 50 would not
be applicable as contraband was not recovered pursuant to any bodily
search.
27. One of the contentions of the appellant side is that the prosecution
case herein involves gross irregularities in compliance with the procedure
of sampling, inventory, etc. as envisaged under section 52A of the Act, and
in terms of the law laid down in Mohan Lal (supra). The learned counsel for
the appellant refers to para 16 of the said judgment and upon perusing the
same, I find that the principles laid down therein have relevance to the
present case. Therefore, paragraph-16 of Mohan Lal (supra) may be
reproduced herein:
“16. Sub-section (3) of Section 52-A requires that the Magistrate shall as
soon as may be allow the application. This implies that no sooner the seizure is
effected and the contraband forwarded to the officer-in-charge of the police
station or the officer empowered, the officer concerned is in law duty-bound to
approach the Magistrate for the purposes mentioned above including grant of
permission to draw representative samples in his presence, which samples will
b then be enlisted and the correctness of the list of samples so drawn certified
by the Magistrate. In other words, the process of drawing of samples has to be
in the presence and under the supervision of the Magistrate and the entire
exercise has to be certified by him to be correct.”
28. As mentioned earlier, the informant, Inspector Pyiloki Lotha, adduced
evidence as PW6 during the trial. From his testimony, it emerges that a
secret
information
was
received
regarding
contraband, whereupon the Naka checking was laid.
transportation
of
Page No.# 18/28
29. PW-6 is an eyewitness to the incident as he stated to be part of the
team conducting the operations at the time of the Naka checking. Though,
he has stated about the driver of the vehicle trying to run away upon being
stopped and sustaining bruises on the knee and he has also stated
about the subsequent recovery of seven plastic bags containing suspected
ganja, which after weighing was found to be 29 kgs – that however, in his
cross-examination, he has admitted that the information received was
neither written down nor intimated to the Commanding Officer. It may be
mentioned herein that PW6 was a personnel of the SSB. From the crossexamination conducted by defence, it is revealed that PW6 led the
operation which was conducted on prior information, but the said
information was not written down in his office and higher officials of SSB
or Police were not intimated. It also emerges from his testimony that he
had not intimated the Police and Magistrate. He justified the non-sending
of information on the ground that it risked leakage of information.
30. Another aspect that emerges from the cross-examination of PW6 is
that the contraband was not sealed by him after the recovery, and he
handed over the same at the Police Station. He also admitted in crossexamination that there is no MR number. However, he denied that
the appellant as accused was falsely implicated.
31.
The
revelation
from
the
testimony
of
PW-6
(informant-cum-
eyewitness) shows that there was complete non-compliance with the
provisions of section 42 of the Act. Here, it is not a case of any substantial
compliance or partial compliance. No attempt was made to comply with
the provision of section 42 of the Act. Risk of information leakage could
not justify non-compliance with section 42 of the Act, which is mandated
under the law, statutorily laid down, and explained as such by the Hon’ble
Page No.# 19/28
Apex Court. Therefore, the total non-compliance with the provisions under
section 42 of the Act constitutes a significant infirmity in the prosecution
case.
32.
Both PW 1 and PW 2 were eyewitnesses to the occurrence as
revealed from their testimony and both of them have stated in crossexamination that the samples were not collected in their presence.
33. PW 2 has also stated that the seized items were not shown to him by
the Police. Interestingly, both of them have initially stated in crossexamination that there was a possibility that the contraband could be
manipulated between the place of occurrence and Police Station. However,
they were re-examined by the prosecution later where they specifically
stated that there was no manipulation of the contraband between the
place of occurrence and the police station. Nevertheless, such nature of
the testimony of PW 1 and PW 2 in their cross-examination has weakened
the evidentiary value of their testimony, and also regarding the chain
of custody. Another infirmity that has been noticed in the testimony of PW
1 is that, though he was part of the operation, but at the time of his
deposition, he could not identify the accused properly, stating that he was
not sure whether he was the same person who was apprehended at the
time of the incident.
34. The testimony of PW 3 and PW 4 is not so crucial as they have mainly
stated about the owner of the vehicle in the question and signed as
witnesses on the zimma document.
35.
From the testimony of PW 7, I.O in his cross-examination, it is
revealed that the contraband was not produced at the Police Station with
seal, and the informant had not mentioned about the custody of the seized
contraband before producing at the Police Station. It may be mentioned
Page No.# 20/28
herein that PW 6, the informant had also stated that there was no MR
number with regard to the seized contraband, which is a matter of
surprise.
36. It is an admitted position that there were no independent seizure
witnesses pertaining to the seizure of the contraband. The same has also
been stated specifically by PW 7, the I.O, in his cross-examination. The
law is settled that testimony about seizure is not to be disbelieved merely
because the witnesses are policemen. It would depend upon the facts and
circumstances of the case, and in an appropriate situation, such police
witnesses can also be found to be reliable and trustworthy. However, there
is no doubt about the desirability of having independent witnesses from
the public as witnesses to search and seizure. That would enhance the
credibility of the prosecution case.
37. The testimony of Executive official PW-5, who certified the inventory,
also weakens the prosecution case. It is revealed from his testimony that
he had not given permission for destruction of cannabis in the instant case
and that seized cannabis of several cases were destroyed together.
However, more importantly, the statement that damages the prosecution
case most is his statement that he cannot say as to whether the collected
samples were drawn from the seized cannabis in this particular case or
not. For a person who, in his capacity as Magistrate, had certified the
correctness of the inventory, proving the relevant documents in this
regard, to say in cross-examination that he cannot say whether samples
were drawn from the seized cannabis in this particular case constitutes an
infirmity and weakens the prosecution case. Such nature of the testimony
of a vital witness like PW-5 also throws doubt regarding the integrity of the
seized items and their chain of custody.
Page No.# 21/28
38. An infirmity that emerges from the testimony of PW 8 is that he had
not mentioned the date, time, weight regarding the sample sent for
FSL, and also did not mention anything regarding the custody of the
sample. He admitted that he had not explained the delay in sending the
sample.
39.
It has emerged from the cross-examination of PW 8, the I.O,
that apart from not mentioning regarding custody of the seized materials,
when he made application for inventory, he clubbed several cases together
and subsequently, destruction of materials of different cases was also done
together. This is undoubtedly an infirmity in the procedure envisaged
under section 52A of the NDPS Act and as explained by the Hon’ble Apex
Court in Mohan Lal (supra), which has already been noticed above.
40.
In the case of Suryapally Srinivas (supra), the Hon’ble Apex Court
made it clear that a minor breach of Standing Order No. 1 up to 1989
laying
down
procedure
for
sampling,
storage, disposal
of
seized
contraband would not necessarily vitiate a conviction. However, the Court
emphasized that there should be substantial compliance of the statutory
provisions and the procedure laid down in the Standing Order. Paragraph
No.-12 is reproduced herein below:
”12. We do not propose to hold that a conviction should be interdicted for
any minor breach of Standing Order No.1/89. What is required is a
substantial compliance of the statutory provisions and the procedure laid
down in such standing order.”
41. In the same decision, i.e., Suryepally Srinivas (supra), the Hon’ble
Apex Court referring to Bharat Ambale (supra) and Kasif (supra) stated
that the purpose of section 52A read with Standing Order No.1 of
Page No.# 22/28
1989 serves
a
broader
purpose
of
strengthening
the
evidentiary
framework of the NDPS Act and in a situation where there has not been
even substantial compliance of the same, the Court has to be convinced
that such non-compliance has not affected the prosecution case against
the accused. The relevant paragraph-13 may be reproduced here in below:
“13. In Bharat Aambale (supra), this Court held that the purport
of Section 52- A, NDPS Act read with Standing Order No. 1/89 extends
beyond mere disposal and destruction of seized contraband and serves
a broader purpose of strengthening the evidentiary framework under
the NDPS Act. This decision stresses upon the fact that what is to be
seen is whether there has been substantial compliance with the mandate
of Section 52-A and if not, the prosecution must satisfy the court that
such non-compliance does not affect its case against the accused. This
is also what has been held in Kashif (supra).”
42.
One startling aspect which is revealed from the testimony of PW-8
Dayal, the I.O in his cross-examination is that the inventory was prepared
more than a year after seizing of the contraband, and that during this
period; the seized materials were in the Police Malkhana. Though, the
forensic examination has returned a positive finding about cannabis
(ganja), but upon carefully scrutinizing the FSL report (Exhibit 13), I find
that it is dated 31-01-2019 and it refers to the letter received from Police
dated 07-12-2018. Therefore, though the I.O as PW-8 has stated
about sending the contraband for inventory after a year, but Exhibit 13,
the FSL report and communication dated 31-01-2019 sent by the forensic
official to the office of the Superintendent of Police, West Kameng District
refers to the police forwarding letter dated 7-12-2018. Nevertheless, even
going by the same, there was a delay of approximately two months in
sending sample to the FSL from the date of the incident on 6-10-2018. In
Page No.# 23/28
this context, the appellant side has referred to a decision of the Delhi High
Court in Rishi Dev @ Onkar Singh (supra). In that case, the Court found
the delay of three months in sending the sample to be fatal, vitiating the
conviction. The relevant paragraph-23 is reproduced herein below:
“23. This Court finds that the prosecution has in this case failed
miserably in satisfying the requirement of the law. The delay of three
months in sending the sample for testing the instant case must be held
to be fatal to the case of the prosecution since on the facts of this case,
this Court is not satisfied that the seized sample was properly preserved
during the period of the delay and that the sample sent for testing was
the one that was seized. Since the accused is entitled to succeed on this
ground, this Court is not examining other grounds urged by the
accused.”
43. The prosecution has referred to the decision of Kashif (supra) where
the Hon’ble Apex Court has emphasised interpretation of the provisions of
the NDPS Act, keeping in mind the scheme, object and purpose of the Act.
The relevant paragraph 39 may be reproduced herein below:
“39. The upshot of the above discussion may be summarized as under:
(i) The provisions of NDPS Act are required to be interpreted
keeping in mind the scheme, object and purpose of the Act; as also
the impact on the society as a whole. It has to be interpreted
literally and not liberally, which may ultimately frustrate the object,
purpose and Preamble of the Act.
(ii) While considering the application for bail, the Court must bear in
mind the provisions of Section 37 of the NDPS Act which are
mandatory in nature. Recording of findings as mandated in Section
37 is sine qua non is known for granting bail to the accused
involved in the offences under the NDPS Act.
(iii) The purpose of insertion of Section 52A laying down the
Page No.# 24/28
procedure for disposal of seized Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic
Substances, was to ensure the early disposal of the seized
contraband drugs and substances. It was inserted in 1989 as one
of the measures to implement and to give effect to the International
Conventions on the Narcotic drugs and psychotropic substances.
(iv) Sub-section (2) of Section 52A lays down the procedure as
contemplated in sub-section (1) thereof, and any lapse or delayed
compliance thereof would be merely a procedural irregularity which
would neither entitle the accused to be released on bail nor would
vitiate the trial on that ground alone.
(v) Any procedural irregularity or illegality found to have been
committed in conducting the search and seizure during the course
of investigation or thereafter, would by itself not make the entire
evidence collected during the course of investigation, inadmissible.
The Court would have to consider all the circumstances and find
out whether any serious prejudice has been caused to the accused.
(vi) Any lapse or delay in compliance of Section 52A by itself would
neither vitiate the trial nor would entitle the accused to be released
on bail. The Court will have to consider other circumstances and
the other primary evidence collected during the course of
investigation, as also the statutory presumption permissible
under Section 54 of the NDPS Act.”
44.
Similarly,
in
Mehboob
Shah
(supra),
relied
upon
by
the
prosecution, the court delved into the provisions under section 52A of the
Act. The relevant paragraph 15 and 17 may be reproduced herein below:
“15. It is undisputed that the samples were drawn by PW-9 himself
at the time of seizure and not in the presence of a Magistrate. However,
the appellant has failed to demonstrate that such non-compliance has
caused him any serious prejudice. It is pertinent to note that the NDPS
Act, as it then stood, did not prohibit drawing of samples at the spot of
seizure. As noticed above, the requirement under Section 52A is
procedural in nature. The documents like panchnama, seizure memo,
arrest memo, etc., prepared by the Investigating Officer on the spot or
Page No.# 25/28
during the course of investigation constitute primary evidence, with regard
to search and seizure of the contraband, which cannot be overlooked
merely because of some lapse or non-compliance is found with Section
52A of the Act. [See: Kashif (supra)]
17. In view of the foregoing discussion, we find that the Trial Court
and the High Court have meticulously appreciated the entire evidence.
On such close scrutiny, both the Courts below have rightly concluded that
the prosecution has proved its case beyond reasonable doubt. We find no
perversity or legal infirmity in the findings recorded by the Courts below
so as to warrant interference under Article 136 of the Constitution.”
45. It is no doubt true that the NDPS Act has a very important objective
of tackling the drug menace in our part of the world and a hyper-technical
approach should not be taken to defeat the objectives of the Act.
Nevertheless,
the
underlying
philosophy
behind
the
procedural
safeguards required to be followed have been referred to earlier. The body
of laws that has been developed by the Hon’ble Apex Court with regard to
the various procedural safeguards envisages mandatory and/or substantial
compliance with many of the safeguards, failing which the fate of the
prosecution case would be adversely affected.
46. In the instant case, upon analyzing and appreciating the prosecution
evidence as discussed above, one finds that there have been multiple
infirmities in complying with procedural safeguards and the mandate of
the law in this regard. These can be briefly summarized herein below:
(i) Total non-compliance with section 42 of the Act about
recording the information and sending it to higher authority within 72
hours.
(ii) Significant laxity in seizure and sealing of the contraband.
The statement of the IO that even the MR number was not given.
Page No.# 26/28
(iii) The contraband was deposited in an unsealed manner.
(iv) Proper procedural safeguards envisaged under section 52A of
the Act read with Order 1 of 1989 were not followed. The inventory
was sought to be made before the Magistrate, clubbing several cases
together.
(v) There is hardly any evidence regarding proper drawing of
sample in terms of section 52A of the Act, the NDPS Rules and the
Standing Orders governing the field.
(vi)
There is significant delay of two months in sending the
contraband to the FSL, even if we overlook the statement of the I.O
in his evidence that inventory was done more than a year after
seizure.
(vii) There is lack of evidence regarding proper and safe keeping
of the contraband in the police station from the time of the seizure
till sending of the contraband to the FSL.
47.
To sum up, the 4 (four) major infirmities in the prosecution case
herein are; non-compliance with the provision under section 42 of the
NDPS Act; gross irregularities in sampling and inventory; lack of evidence
regarding chain of custody and delay in sending the sample for forensic
examination.
48.
In view of so many infirmities in the procedural aspects of the
prosecution case, including non-compliance with section 42 of the NDPS
Act, the prosecution case, in my considered view, suffers from fatal
defects. To that extent, I find force in the contentions of the learned
counsel for the appellant.
49. In a prosecution under the NDPS Act, the Investigating Agency and the
Page No.# 27/28
prosecution have to be alive to the importance of chain of custody, both
from the point of view of defence and the judicial conscience of the
Court. It has to be convincingly proved that the contraband which was
seized was the contraband which was examined in the FSL. During
investigation, the I.O has to make sure that such chain of custody
evidence is gathered and during the trial, the prosecution has to
ensure that the proper chain of custody evidence is adduced in support of
the prosecution case.
50.
The
importance
of
tackling
the
drug
menace
cannot
be
overemphasized. The criminal justice system, which is one of the guardians
of the societal interest, cannot afford technical acquittals in NDPS
prosecutions.
51. Coming back to the instant case, in view of the deficiencies in the
prosecution case, which have been found to be fatal by this court, the
conviction and sentence of the appellant is required to be interfered with in
this appeal.
Decision:
52. Accordingly, the impugned judgment dated 09-01-2023 and sentence
order dated 18-01-2023, passed by the learned Special Judge, NDPS of
East Kameng, West Kameng and Tawang at Bomdila in Special NDPS Case
No. 13 of 2020 (arising out of Kalaktang Case No. 15 of 2018) convicting
and sentencing the accused/appellant is hereby set aside.
53.
The appellant shall be set at liberty forthwith, unless wanted in any
other case.
54. Return back the original TCR to the learned trial court.
55. A copy of this judgment and order shall be sent to the Superintendent
Page No.# 28/28
of Police, West Kameng for his kind information.
56.
The criminal appeal stands allowed and disposed of.0 of 3 daily
transcriptions used
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review