Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Revisional Jurisdiction)
DATED : 3rd October, 2020
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : THE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CRP No.02 of 2017
Petitioner
:
Bishnu Maya Rai
versus
Respondents
:
Dr. Rameshwar Prasad and Others
Revision Petition under Section 115 read with Section 151
of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. N. Rai, Senior Advocate with Ms. Susmita Gurung, Advocate for
the Petitioner.
Mr. Sudhir Prasad and Mr. Kazi Sangay Thupden, Advocates for the
Respondent No.1.
Mr. B. Sharma, Senior Advocate with Mr. Sajal Sharma, Advocate for
the Respondents No.2 and 3.
Mr. Santosh Kumar Chettri, Government Advocate for the StateRespondents No.4 to 7.
Mr. K.T. Bhutia, Senior Advocate with Ms. Sunita Chettri, Advocate for
the Respondent No.8.
None for Respondent No.9.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ORDER
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
The learned Civil Judge, East Sikkim at Gangtok, by the
impugned Order, dated 28.07.2016, in Title Suit No.12 of 2014 (Dr.
Rameshwar Prasad and Others vs. The Chief Secretary and Others)
was considering the two preliminary issues framed, viz.
signed by
MEENAKSHI Digitally
MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI
Date: 2020.10.03
MADAN RAI 13:40:08 +05'30'
(i)
Whether the Suit is barred by res judicata?
(ii) Whether the present Suit is barred by the
provisions of Order II Rule 2 of the CPC in
CRP No.02 of 2017
Bishnu Maya Rai
vs.
Dr. Rameshwar Prasad and Others
view of Title Suit No.02 of 2010 having been
finally decided?
The Court concluded that the Suit of the Respondents No.1, 2 and 3
herein was neither barred by res judicata nor Order II Rule 2 of the
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (for short, “CPC”) for reasons
enumerated in the impugned order. Aggrieved thereof the Petitioner
assails the Order.
2.(i)
It is the Petitioner’s case that the Respondents No.1, 2
and 3 as Plaintiffs had filed Title Suit No.15 of 2008 (later
renumbered as Title Suit No.02 of 2010) seeking Declaration,
Cancellation/quashing of documents, Injunction and Consequential
reliefs inter alia against the Petitioner herein, who was the
Defendant No.4 in the said Title Suit. The Title Suit was dismissed
by the Court of the learned District Judge, Special Division II, East
Sikkim, at Gangtok vide its Judgment dated 30.03.2011 and an
Appeal was preferred before this Court. By its Judgment dated
30.06.2011, in Regular First Appeal No.02 of 2011, the Judgment of
the learned trial Court was upheld by this Court. Dissatisfied
thereof, the Respondents No.1, 2 and 3 filed a Special Leave
Petition before the Hon’ble Supreme Court being Special Leave to
Appeal (Civil) No.24765/2011 which was dismissed in limine vide its
Order dated 06.02.2012.
(ii)
MADAN
MEENAKSHI MEENAKSHI
RAI
MADAN RAI Date: 2020.10.03
After
the
dismissal
of
the
previous
Suit,
the
Respondents No.1, 2 and 3 again filed a Suit for Declaration,
13:40:48 +05'30'
Cancellation of documents, Injunction and other reliefs inter alia
against the Petitioner, i.e. Title Suit No.15 of 2012 which was later
renumbered as Title Suit No.12 of 2014. Consequent thereto the
Petitioner herein filed an application requesting the learned trial
CRP No.02 of 2017
Bishnu Maya Rai
vs.
Dr. Rameshwar Prasad and Others
Court to frame preliminary issues on the question of maintainability
of the present Suit, accordingly the two preliminary issues supra
were framed vide Order dated 24.06.2013 and subsequently the
impugned Order pronounced.
(iii)
Before this Court, learned Senior Counsel for the
Petitioner submitted that the Title Suit No.12 of 2014 that has been
filed before the learned trial Court by the Respondents No.1, 2 and
3, is in fact old wine in new bottles as it raises the same issues that
have already been decided in the Title Suit No.02 of 2010 and
upheld right up to the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India. That, the
Respondents No.1, 2 and 3 have attempted to confuse the learned
trial Court with regard to the issues involved by enumerating
several Schedules in the Plaint as properties in dispute but have
failed to pinpoint as to what exactly is the issue in dispute. This is in
view of the fact that they are well aware that the matter was fully
and finally adjudicated upon previously and no further issues
persist. That, the landed property detailed in Schedule “A” of the
previous Suit i.e. Title Suit No.02 of 2010 being Plot No.882 is the
same as reflected in Schedule “C” in the new Suit i.e. Title Suit
No.12 of 2014. That, this plot number is not even relevant as the
plot of land allotted to the Petitioner was from Plot No.881 and it
has conclusively been found that the said plot of land belongs to the
Government, who had the option of allotting it according to the
MEENAKSHI
MADAN RAI
MEENAKSHI MADAN
RAI
Date: 2020.10.03
13:41:21 +05'30'
prevailing rules and regulations. That, any construction made by the
Petitioner over and above the allotted site has been duly regularized
by the Respondent No.5, while one such construction measuring an
area of 222 square feet of land is pending regularization, however
this construction too falls within Plot No.881 which as already
CRP No.02 of 2017
Bishnu Maya Rai
vs.
Dr. Rameshwar Prasad and Others
decided indubitably belongs to the Government. That, the learned
trial Court vide its impugned Order, while dismissing the preliminary
objections raised by the Petitioner failed to appreciate that the
parties and the subject matter in the previous Suit and the present
Suit are identical. That, settled issues cannot be re-agitated by the
Respondents No.1, 2 and 3 being barred by the provisions of
Section 11 of the CPC. That, the Respondents No.1, 2 and 3 are not
entitled to the reliefs claimed by them for the foregoing reasons and
the impugned Order deserves to be set aside and quashed. No
specific arguments were put forth by learned Senior Counsel with
regard to Order II Rule 2 of the CPC.
Learned Counsel for the Respondent No.1 submitted
3.
that the instant matter does not pertain to Plot No.881 as sought to
be made out by learned Senior Counsel for the Petitioner but in fact
relates to Plot No.882 on which plot the Petitioner has now
encroached. That, this is evident from the fact that as per the
Allotment Order, dated 25.01.2008, an area measuring 520 square
feet was allotted to her from Plot No.881, a Government plot. That,
the issue at hand concerns Schedule “C” of the Plaint filed by the
Plaintiffs (Respondents No.1, 2 and 3 herein) before the learned
trial Court in Title Suit No.12 of 2014. That, a perusal of the
Inspection Report shows that the Petitioner is also in occupation of a
portion of Plot No.882 when her allotment admittedly was only from
MADAN
MEENAKSHI MEENAKSHI
Plot
RAI
MADAN RAI Date: 2020.10.03
No.881, measuring 520 square feet. In fact, the Inspection
13:41:54 +05'30'
Report indicates that she is now in occupation of 1102.00 square
feet and the excess land which is shown in the said record is
encroached
upon
from
Plot
No.882
which
belongs
to
the
Respondents No.1, 2 and 3, hence, the necessity for filing Title Suit
CRP No.02 of 2017
Bishnu Maya Rai
vs.
Dr. Rameshwar Prasad and Others
No.12 of 2014. That, the question of the Suit being barred by res
judicata or the provisions of Order II Rule 2 of the CPC as rightly
concluded by the learned trial Court does not arise since the claim
of the Respondents No.1, 2 and 3 in the Title Suit No.12 of 2014
pertains to encroachment of Plot No.882 which is their ancestral
property and not Government land. That, the cause of action herein
is different from that of the previous Title Suit.
4.
Learned Senior Counsel for the Respondents No.2 and 3
endorsed and relied upon the submissions made by the Respondent
No.1 and submitted that the encroachment made by the Petitioner
on Plot No.882 which belongs to the Respondents No.1, 2 and 3 is
to be adjudicated upon and that the instant matter is not concerned
with Plot No.881.
5.
The State-Respondents No.4 to 7 had no submissions to
make except to contend that the documents on record would
indicate their stand. That, Plot No.881 has been found to be
Government land from where the Petitioner had been allotted the
land.
6.
Learned Senior Counsel appearing for Respondent No.8
submitted
that
the
Inspection
Report,
dated
08.01.2013,
is
indicative of the fact that the Respondents No.1, 2 and 3 are now
laying claim to Plots No.882 and 883 whereas initially their claim
MADAN
MEENAKSHI MEENAKSHI
RAI
MADAN RAI Date: 2020.10.03
13:42:23 +05'30'
was confined to Plot No.881. That, the learned trial Court has only
relied on the Inspection Report of the State-Respondents No.6 and
7 which cannot be taken at face value, therefore, the Respondents
No.1, 2 and 3 herein have no case.
7.
Due consideration has been given by me to the rival
contentions advanced by learned Counsel for the parties. I have
CRP No.02 of 2017
Bishnu Maya Rai
vs.
Dr. Rameshwar Prasad and Others
also carefully perused all documents placed before me including the
impugned Order.
8.
The learned trial
Court,
by the impugned Order,
considered the two preliminary issues already extracted supra and
on considering the submissions of learned Counsel for the parties as
well as the documents furnished, observed inter alia that the
Respondents No.1, 2 and 3 herein, although pitted against the same
parties, the dispute did not concern the same plot of land i.e. Plot
No. 881 and therefore concluded that the Suit was not barred either
by res judicata or by Order II Rule 2 of the CPC as the subject
matter in the instant Suit was different from the previous Suit.
9.(i)
Having perused the pleadings and the documents placed
before me, it appears that the parties in Title Suit No.15 of 2008
(renumbered as Title Suit No.02 of 2010) and Title Suit No.15 of
2012 (renumbered as Title Suit No.12 of 2014) were identical with
the exception of the District Collector, East, who has been
impleaded as Defendant No.4 in the fresh Suit i.e. Title Suit No.12
of 2014. It is evident that vide Allotment Order No.GOS/UD&HD/
7(272)97-98/2173, dated 29.10.1999, an area measuring 40 feet x
30 feet was allotted to the Petitioner herein, by the Defendant No.2
(Respondent No.5 herein) at the Flour Mill Area, Tadong, East
Sikkim. This allotment is not the subject matter of dispute and any
further discussions on its fate is truncated here.
MEENAKSHI
MADAN RAI
MEENAKSHI MADAN
RAI
Date: 2020.10.03
13:42:56 +05'30'
(ii)
Vide
letter
bearing
No.38/77/3077/UD&HD,
dated
25.01.2008, a site measuring 26 feet x 20 feet, equivalent to 520
square feet, was allotted to the Petitioner herein by the Respondent
No.5 herein, from Plot No.881 at “Old Gangtok Bazaar” now “M.G.
Marg,” as described in Schedule “D” to the Plaint in the Title Suit
CRP No.02 of 2017
Bishnu Maya Rai
vs.
Dr. Rameshwar Prasad and Others
No.12 of 2014 and Schedule “B” to the Plaint in the old Suit (i.e.
Title Suit No.02 of 2010). A dispute arose between the parties i.e.
the Petitioner and the Respondents No.1, 2 and 3 regarding the
ownership of the land from where the allotment was made, leading
to the filing of Title Suit No.02 of 2010. The learned trial Court came
to the finding that Plot No.881 belonged to the Government. The
High Court upheld the Judgment while the Hon’ble Supreme Court
dismissed the Special Leave Petition filed by the Respondents No.1,
2 and 3 herein. It is also not in dispute that Plot No.881 measures a
total area of 9801 square feet from where the allotment was made
to the Petitioner. However, the records of the Defendant No.2 in the
Title Suit No.12 of 2014 (Respondent No.5 herein) reveal that on an
inspection conducted by the representatives of the Respondents
No.6 and 7 herein, the Petitioner was found to be in possession of
1102 square feet of land whereas the total area allotted to her was
829 square feet. It is on this count that conflicting claims are being
raised by the opposing parties.
(iii)
It is relevant to clarify here that after the initial
allotment of 520 square feet was made to the Petitioner, an
additional area of 190 square feet was allotted to her vide order of
the Respondent No.5 herein, bearing number 38(77)/ 1043/UD&HD,
dated 25.04.2011 thereby adding the allotment to a total area of
MADAN
MEENAKSHI MEENAKSHI
RAI
Date:
2020.10.03
MADAN RAI
13:43:25 +05'30'
710 square feet. Later 119 square feet of unauthorized horizontal
construction was also regularized by the Respondent No.5 herein,
vide letter No.38(77)/UD&HD/1978, dated 30.05.2011, thus, the
overall area allotted to the Petitioner measured 829 square feet.
These facts are admitted by the Petitioner and can also be gleaned
from the documents furnished before this Court. According to the
CRP No.02 of 2017
Bishnu Maya Rai
vs.
Dr. Rameshwar Prasad and Others
Petitioner, a staircase on a piece of land measuring 222 square feet
has been constructed by her, also in excess of the land allotted to
her, which is pending regularization by the Government, and this
admitted unauthorized construction, as per the Petitioner, falls on
Plot No.881 (“Sarkar”). The Respondents No.1, 2 and 3, for their
part, contend that it is not merely 222 square feet of land that she
has encroached upon as the Inspection Report clearly indicates that
she is in possession of 1102 square feet of land and the
encroachment is not confined to Plot No.881 as attempted to be
made out by the Petitioner but is from Plot No.882 which belongs to
the Respondents No.1, 2 and 3.
10.
On due consideration of the rival stands it thus emerges
that the dispute in the fresh Title Suit (i.e. Title Suit No.12 of 2014)
pertains to the alleged encroachment made by the Petitioner
allegedly on Plot No.882 and is not confined to her admitted
encroachment on Plot No.881, although I have to remark here that
nebulous drafting on the part of the Plaintiffs (Respondents No.1, 2
and 3 herein) in the Title Suit No.12 of 2014 has confounded the
matter. In view of the above flagged circumstances, as correctly
held by the learned trial Court, it is clear that neither the Suit is
barred by res judicata nor is it barred by Order II Rule 2 of the CPC.
11.
signed by
MEENAKSHI Digitally
MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI
2020.10.03 13:43:59
shall
MADAN RAI Date:
+05'30'
Section 11 of the CPC inter alia provides that no Court
try any Suit or issue in which the matter directly and
substantially in issue, has been directly and substantially in issue in
a former Suit between the same parties, or between parties under
whom they or any of them claim, litigating under the same title, in a
Court competent to try such subsequent Suit or the Suit in which
such issue has been subsequently raised and has been heard and
CRP No.02 of 2017
Bishnu Maya Rai
vs.
Dr. Rameshwar Prasad and Others
finally decided by such Court. Order II Rule 2 of the CPC provides
that every Suit shall include the whole of the claim which the
Plaintiff is entitled to make in respect of the cause of action but a
Plaintiff may relinquish any portion of his claim in order to bring the
Suit within the jurisdiction of any Suit. Where the Plaintiff omits to
sue in respect of or intentionally relinquishes any portion of his
claim, he shall not afterwards sue in respect of the portion so
omitted or relinquished.
12.
It is pertinent to recapitulate here that the learned trial
Court in its Judgment in Title Suit No.02 of 2010, has observed inter
alia that Plot No.882 was not relevant for that case. It is evident
that the entire Suit of the parties in Title Suit No.02 of 2010
pivoted around the ownership of Plot No.881 which ultimately was
found to be recorded in the name of “Sarkar” (Government).
Neither was the ownership of Plot No.882 adjudicated upon nor can
it be said that the Respondents No.1, 2 and 3 herein had, at any
point of time, relinquished their claims over any other plot of land
which was not the subject matter of the old Suit (i.e. Title Suit
No.02 of 2010). As already noticed no specific arguments were
placed before this Court with regard to Order II Rule 2 of the CPC
by the Petitioner besides the averments also raises no claim of the
signed by
MEENAKSHI Digitally
MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI
Date: 2020.10.03
MADAN RAI 13:44:34 +05'30'
Respondents No.1, 2 and 3 having relinquished any portion of their
claim in order to bring the Suit within the jurisdiction of any Court.
No averment or argument has been advanced with regard to the
Respondents No.1, 2 and 3 having omitted to sue in respect of any
portion of their claim or their intentional relinquishment of any
portion of their claim. The objective of Order II Rule 2 of the CPC is
based on the principle that the Defendants should not be twice
CRP No.02 of 2017
Bishnu Maya Rai
vs.
Dr. Rameshwar Prasad and Others
vexed for one and the same cause, thereby restraining the Plaintiffs
from dividing their claims and the remedies thereof. For the Rule to
be invoked two conditions must be satisfied viz. the previous Suit
and the fresh Suit must arise out of the same cause of action and
they must also be between the same parties. However, the Rule
does not preclude a second Suit based on a distinct and separate
cause of action. Merely because the parties to the fresh litigation
are the ones who were involved in a previous litigation it cannot be
concluded that the matter is res judicata nor does it mean that the
Respondents No.1, 2 and 3 had relinquished any of their claims to
any other landed property. The requirements of the provisions of
Law supra have to be fulfilled in order for it to apply to the Title Suit
No.12 of 2014 which is not so in the instant case, as already
discussed.
13.
All parties to the Suit are required to go into trial and
establish their divergent claims considering that a new plot of land
is in dispute and the lis cannot be adjudicated upon fully and finally
without examining witnesses and documents which the parties may
seek to rely upon during the course of trial to establish their
opposing claims.
14.
Hence, I find that, no reason whatsoever warrants any
interference in the impugned Order of the learned trial Court. The
signed by
MEENAKSHI Digitally
MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI
Revision
2020.10.03
MADAN RAI Date:
13:45:14 +05'30'
Petition thus stands dismissed and disposed of. Pending
applications, if any, also stand disposed of.
15.
Considering that the Title Suit pertains to the year
“2012,” the learned trial Court shall make all efforts to dispose of
this matter within six months and no later, from the date of
appearance of the parties before it.
CRP No.02 of 2017
Bishnu Maya Rai
Dr. Rameshwar Prasad and Others
The learned trial Court shall proceed in the matter as
16.
per
vs.
Law
and
conclude
it
accordingly,
unencumbered
and
unprejudiced by the observations in this Order, which are, in no
manner, to be construed as findings on the merits of the Suit.
17.
Copy of this Order be forwarded to the learned trial
Court forthwith, for information and compliance, along with its
records.
signed by
MEENAKSHI Digitally
MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI
2020.10.03
MADAN RAI Date:
13:46:01 +05'30'
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
03.10.2020
ml
Approved for reporting : Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review