Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:30982
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SATHISH NINAN
&
THE HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN
THURSDAY, THE 10TH DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 20TH CHAITHRA, 1947
MAT.APPEAL NO. 1146 OF 2014
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT DATED 23.07.2014 IN OP NO.2 OF
2013 OF FAMILY COURT, CHAVARA
APPELLANTS/PETITIONERS:
BINDHU
AGED 42 YEARS, D/O.OMANA,
R/A.'KARTHIKA',KOlLAM WARD,
PANMANA VILLAGE, KARUNAGAPALLY TALUK,
KOLLAM DISTRICT
DURGADAS
AGED 19 YEARS, S/O.RAJENDRAN,
R/A.'KARTHIKA',KOlLAM WARD,
PANMANA VILLAGE, KARUNAGAPALLY TALUK,
KOLLAM DISTRICT
GOURI
AGED 11 YEARS, D/O.RAJENDRAN,
R/A.'KARTHIKA',KOLLAM WARD,
PANMANA VILLAGE, KARUNAGAPALLY TALUK,
KOLLAM DISTRICT(MINOR THIRD RESPONDENT REP BY
THE FIRST RESPONDENT BEING THE GUARDIAN AND NEXT
FRIEND)
MAT.APPEAL NO. 1146 OF 2014 & connected case
2025:KER:30982
BY ADV SRI.JOHNSON GOMEZ
RESPONDENT/RESPONDENT:
RAJENDRAN
S/O.KARUNAKARAN PUTHEN PURAYIL FROM REVATHIYIL,
NADAVARATHU CHERRY,
CHAVARA THEKKUMBHAGOM VILLAGE,
KARUNAGAPPALLY, NOW R/A PUTHEN PURAYIL,
KULANGARA BHAGOM, CHAVARA P O,
PIN-NO 691583, KOLLAM
BY ADV SMT.MINI GANGADHARAN
THIS MATRIMONIAL APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON
19.03.2025, ALONG WITH MAT.APPEAL NO.1159/2014, THE COURT
ON 10.04.2025 DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
MAT.APPEAL NO. 1146 OF 2014 & connected case
2025:KER:30982
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SATHISH NINAN
&
THE HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN
THURSDAY, THE 10TH DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 20TH CHAITHRA, 1947
MAT.APPEAL NO. 1159 OF 2014
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT DATED 23.07.2014 IN OP(HMA) NO.1
OF 2013 OF FAMILY COURT, CHAVARA
APPELLANT/PETITIONER:
BINDHU, AGED 42 YEARS, DAUGHTER OF OMANA,
‘KARTHIKA',KOLAMWARD,PANMANA VILLAGE,
KARUNAGAPPALLY TALUK,KOLLAM DISTRICT
BY ADV SRI.JOHNSON GOMEZ
RESPONDENT/RESPONDENT:
RAJENDRAN, S/O.KARUNAKARAN PUTHEN PURAYIL FROM
REVATHIYIL NADAVARATHU CHERRY,CHAVARA
THEKKUMBHAGOM VILLAGE, KARUNAGAPPALLY, NOW
RESIDING AT PUTHEN PURAYIL, KULANGARA BHAGOM,
CHAVARA P.O,PIN NO 691 583,KOLLAM
BY ADV SMT.MINI GANGADHARAN
THIS MATRIMONIAL APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON
19.03.2025, ALONG WITH MAT.APPEAL No.1146/2014, THE COURT
ON 10.04.2025 DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
2025:KER:30982
MAT.APPEAL NO. 1146 OF 2014 & connected case
J U D G M E N T
[Mat.Appeal Nos.1146/2014, 1159/2014]
Shoba Annamma Eapen, J.
The wife is the appellant in both the appeals.
Mat.Appeal No.1146 of 2014 and Mat.Appeal No.1159 of
2014 arise from the common judgment in O.P.No.2 of
2013 and O.P.(HMA) No.1 of 2013 on the files of the
Family
Court,
Chavara
for
recovery
of
her
gold
ornaments and cash, and for divorce.
2.
For the sake of convenience, the parties are
referred to as ‘husband’ and ‘wife’.
3.
The
marriage
between
the
parties
was
solemnised on 23.03.1992. Two children were born in
their
wedlock
on
10.09.1994
and
08.02.2003
respectively. According to the wife, at the time of
marriage she was given 35 sovereigns of gold ornaments
and a sum of ₹2.5 lakhs as patrimony. She claimed that
a
gold
chain
weighing
sovereigns
and
one
ring
2025:KER:30982
MAT.APPEAL NO. 1146 OF 2014 & connected case
weighing 1 sovereign was given to the husband and one
bangle weighing 1 sovereign was given to the husband’s
mother, totaling to 6 sovereigns. She alleged that the
gold ornaments and patrimony were misappropriated by
the husband. She was subjected to cruelty demanding
more dowry by the husband and his mother. She alleged
that the patrimony of ₹2.5 Lakhs was misappropriated
by
the
husband
for
the
purpose
of
renovating
the
building. She further alleged that out of 10 cents of
property
belonging
to the
wife,
she
was
forced
to
convey 5 cents of property to the husband as a precondition
for
conjugal
relationship.
She
contended
that the husband was a drunkard, and became violent
when intoxicated and demanded for more dowry. He used
to bring his friends to the house and the wife was
forced to serve food to them. Thereafter, the husband
was sent to gulf by spending ₹50,000/- by the wife’s
father. Later the husband returned from gulf after
2025:KER:30982
MAT.APPEAL NO. 1146 OF 2014 & connected case
losing
his
job.
On
20.05.2006,
the
wife
and
the
children were forcibly thrown out of the matrimonial
home and the husband failed to take them back home.
Thus the wife filed petitions for divorce, for return
of gold ornaments and money and for past and future
maintenance.
4.
According
to
the
husband,
no
dowry
was
demanded by him from the wife’s family. He also denied
the entrustment of her assets. He alleged that the
wife was having only 20 sovereigns of gold ornaments
at the time of marriage and that the gold ornaments
were in her own custody. He further contended that
since the wife’s brother was in need of money, the
husband had parted with ₹15,000/-, and that is how 5
cents of property was conveyed in his name. He also
contended that he renovated the old building in the
property by availing loans from the bank. He contended
that he did not misappropriate her gold ornaments or
2025:KER:30982
MAT.APPEAL NO. 1146 OF 2014 & connected case
money. He submitted that he is still ready and willing
to maintain the wife and his children.
5.
The
Family
Court,
after
appreciation
of
entire evidence, dismissed O.P.(HMA) No.1 of 2013 and
partly allowed O.P.No.2 of 2013 by allowing the wife
to recover only 26 sovereigns of gold ornaments and
also directed the husband to pay monthly maintenance
of ₹1,000/- to the wife and ₹1,500/- each to the minor
children. Aggrieved by the same, the wife has come up
with the appeals.
6.
We have heard the learned Counsels on both
sides.
7.
The evidence in this case consists of Exts.A1
to A5 and Ext.B1 to B10.
PW1 – the wife, CPW1 – the
husband and CPW2 – Chandradas - Building contractor
were also examined.
8.
the
First, we shall consider the appeal against
dismissal
of
the
petition
for
divorce.
The
2025:KER:30982
MAT.APPEAL NO. 1146 OF 2014 & connected case
marriage
between
the
parties
was
solemnised
on
23.03.1992 and two children were born in their wedlock
in the year 1994 and 2003 respectively. The wife has
made
allegations
including
of
cruelty
ill-treatment
and
against
the
husband
manhandling.
It
was
alleged that the husband was a drunkard and he used to
bring his unethical friends to the matrimonial home
and also forced his wife to serve food to them. It was
also alleged that the husband was a spendthrift and he
had misappropriated her gold ornaments and patrimony
of ₹2.5 Lakhs. Due to the disruption in the marital
life, the relationship got estranged and they were
living separately since 26.05.2006. Except the oral
evidence of PW1, no attempt was made by the wife to
examine any witness or to adduce any evidence to prove
the
cruelty
testified
against
that
she
the
husband.
had
been
However,
she
manhandled
had
after
intoxication of liquor as well as she was abused and
2025:KER:30982
MAT.APPEAL NO. 1146 OF 2014 & connected case
assaulted
in
front
of
his
friends.
No
love
and
affection was shown by the husband towards the wife.
She deposed that her life could be in danger if they
continue to stay together. For a wife, it would be
very difficult, mentally and physically to move on
with a husband who is a drunkard, and also does not
show any care, love and affection towards the wife.
The husband had denied all the allegations levelled
against him. The fact that since 2008, they are living
separately is not disputed.
9.
Cruelty
is
a
course
of
conduct
by
the
offending spouse which makes it impossible for the
complaining spouse to live with him. The parties enter
the marital relationship with many expectations. If
something
goes
wrong
against
the
expectations,
it
would be difficult for the other spouse to continue
with
the
marital
relationship,
and
it
amounts
to
cruelty in matrimonial life. In [2007 (1) KHC 9491
2025:KER:30982
MAT.APPEAL NO. 1146 OF 2014 & connected case
(SC)] Mayadevi v. Jagadish Prasad, it has been held
that physical violence is not essential to constitute
cruelty and a consistent course of conduct inflicting
immeasurable mental agony and torture may constitute
cruelty.
The
continuously
wife
put
had
to
examined
that
immeasurable
torture by the husband.
not
deposed
anybody
she
had
been
mental
agony
and
It is true that the wife has
to
prove
the
allegation
of
cruelty by the husband.
10. The circumstances in each family life will be
different. It may not be possible for everyone to lead
evidence of cruelty by the husband. The finding of the
Family Court in the original petition is that, it was
only an ordinary tear and wear of the family and there
had been no serious issues between the spouse, which
does not appear to be correct. If there was no serious
issue
the
wife
would
have
certainly
joined
the
husband. In the present case, there is irretrievable
2025:KER:30982
MAT.APPEAL NO. 1146 OF 2014 & connected case
break down also. The parties were living separately
from 2008 onwards. They do not have a case that there
was cohabitation after 2008. Refusal to live with the
spouse also amounts to cruelty. In Rakesh Raman v.
Kavitha [2023 SCC OnLine SC 497], it has been held
that though in a given case, cruelty as a fault may
not
be
attributable
to
one
party
alone
and
hence,
despite irretrievable breakdown of marriage, keeping
the parties together amounts to cruelty on both sides.
Similarly,
in
Shilpa
Sailesh
v.
Varun
Sreenivasan
[2023 SCC OnLine SC 544], it has been held that where
there is an irretrievable breakdown of marriage, then,
dissolution of marriage is the only solution. In a
recent decision of the apex court in Rajib Kumar vs.
Sushmita Saha [Civil Appeal No.5454 of 2023] [2023
LiveLaw (SC) 727], it has been held that keeping the
parties
together
despite
irretrievable
breakdown
marriage amounts to cruelty on both sides.
of
2025:KER:30982
MAT.APPEAL NO. 1146 OF 2014 & connected case
11. Considering the above facts, we find that for
more
than
years
they
are
there is no chance of reunion.
living
separately
and
The emotional bond has
weakened and the marital bond has become strained. In
such
circumstances,
granted,
the
if
parties
a decree
of
would
forced
be
divorce
is not
to
endure
unnecessary suffering, misery and emotional distress.
Therefore, while concurring with the Family Court in
its
finding
alleged,
we
on
the
are
of
particular
the
opinion
nature
that
on
of
cruelty
the
other
findings supra, a decree for divorce is liable to be
granted. Hence, we are inclined to allow O.P.(HMA)
No.1 of 2013 regarding the dissolution of marriage.
12. Next we shall consider the claim for return
of
gold
ornaments
and
patrimony.
According
to
the
wife, she was given 35 sovereigns of gold ornaments
and her husband was given a gold chain weighing 4
sovereigns and one ring weighing 1 sovereign was given
2025:KER:30982
MAT.APPEAL NO. 1146 OF 2014 & connected case
to the husband and one bangle weighing 1 sovereign was
given
to
the
husband’s
mother,
totaling
to
sovereigns. She claimed that ₹2.5 lakhs was given to
the husband in November 2001 for renovation of the
building and ₹50,000/- was given by her parents to him
in
connection
with
his
travel
abroad
for
job.
According to the wife, she has claimed return of 41
sovereigns of gold ornaments. She claimed that she was
having 18 bangles of one sovereign each, two chains of
6 and 4 sovereigns, a necklace weighing 2 sovereign, a
pair of stud of 1 sovereign, two rings weighing 1 ½
sovereigns
each.
weighing
sovereign
was
weighing
She
further
claimed
sovereigns
and
one
given
the
husband
to
sovereign
was
given
a
ring
to
gold
chain
weighing
and
the
one
bangle
husband’s
mother. She also claimed that the gold ornaments were
purchased from one Swaminathan Jewellery.
According
to her, ten sovereigns were sold in June 1992 and 25
2025:KER:30982
MAT.APPEAL NO. 1146 OF 2014 & connected case
sovereigns were taken
by the husband in September
1994. In order to substantiate her claim, she relied
on
Ext.A1
series
photographs
and
also
her
own
deposition.
13. According to the husband, he contended that
she had only 20 sovereigns of gold ornaments and that
were in her own custody.
He also denies the claim
that he was given a ring and a chain and his mother
was
given
a
bangle.
He
also
contended
that
the
renovation of the building was done by availing loan
from
the
bank.
Admittedly
no
bills,
estimate
or
receipt for the purchase of the gold ornaments were
produced by the wife.
14. On a perusal of Ext.A1 series photographs, it
is seen that the wife was wearing substantial quantity
of gold ornaments. However, it is not discernible from
the
photos
produced
whether
she
was
wearing
sovereigns of gold ornaments. On a perusal of Ext.B4,
2025:KER:30982
MAT.APPEAL NO. 1146 OF 2014 & connected case
it is seen that the husband had pledged gold ornaments
on 06.05.2003. The husband, in the cross examination,
has admitted that her gold ornaments were pledged by
him. From the documents produced, it is clear that he
was in the habit of pledging gold ornaments. Hence it
is only probable that the husband might have utilised
her gold ornaments and misappropriated the same for
his own needs. The claim of the wife that the gold
ornaments were misappropriated by the husband, has to
be believed.
15. Having considered the facts of this case and
a perusal of Ext.A1 series of photographs, we are of
the view that the wife might have been wearing atleast
25 sovereigns of gold ornaments. The case of the wife
that 6 sovereigns were given to the husband and his
mother, though denied by the husband, the evidence
adduced
by
the
wife
appears
to
be
more
reliable.
Hence, we hold that the wife is entitled for return of
2025:KER:30982
MAT.APPEAL NO. 1146 OF 2014 & connected case
31 sovereigns of gold ornaments.
16. No proper evidence has been adduced by the
wife to substantiate the claim for payment of ₹2.5
lakhs alleged to have been spent for renovation of the
building and ₹50,000/- towards the expenses for the
husband to go to Gulf. Hence we are not inclined to
grant the claim for recovery of the said amount. The
wife has also claimed right over the property assigned
in favour of the husband. However, no such claim has
been made in the present petition.
It is for the wife
to raise claim, if any, in appropriate proceedings.
17. As
regards
the
claim
for
maintenance,
the
wife had claimed ₹1,500/- each to her and her minor
children.
She
claimed
that
the
husband
is
earning
₹10,000/- per month and he is also having business
from which he would be getting ₹10,000/- per month.
She claimed past and future maintenance. The husband
contended that he had been sending maintenance amounts
2025:KER:30982
MAT.APPEAL NO. 1146 OF 2014 & connected case
to the children @ ₹1,000/- each while he was in the
gulf. He also claimed that he was ready to maintain
his wife and children if they are ready to reside with
him. On a perusal of the evidence adduced, the wife
had deposed that the wife was residing in her own
building and was maintained by her father. The husband
did not adduce any contra evidence to prove that the
wife was having sufficient income to maintain herself.
The Family Court, after consideration of the evidence
on board, has awarded maintenance @ ₹1,000/- per month
to the wife and ₹1,500/- each per month to her minor
children
from
12.03.2007
onwards.
The
Family
Court
also awarded a consolidated amount of ₹10,000/- to the
wife and ₹30,000/- to the minor children towards past
maintenance with 6% interest per annum. The said order
passed by the Family Court appears to be just and
reasonable. We do not find any reason to interfere
with the same.
2025:KER:30982
MAT.APPEAL NO. 1146 OF 2014 & connected case
Accordingly,
Mat.
Appeal
No.1159
of
is
allowed, dissolving the marriage between the appellant
and respondent solemnized on 23.03.1992.
Mat.Appeal No.1146 of 2014 is partly allowed, by
modifying
the
impugned
judgment
and
decree
of
the
Family Court, to the extent of directing the husband
to return to the wife thirty one (31) sovereigns of
gold ornaments or its present market value within one
month from today, in default of which, the wife will
be entitled to realize the same from the husband's
assets, both movables and immovables. In all other
respects the impugned judgment shall stand. No costs.
Sd/SATHISH NINAN
JUDGE
Sd/SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN
JUDGE
RK
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review