Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
B.A. No.138 of 2025
Bina Dhar Choudhury aged about 59 years,
Wife of Pradyut Dhar Choudhury,
resident of Usha Bajzar,
Chhinaihani Airport, Agartala, West Tripura.
---- Applicant(s)
On behalf of accused person
Shri Pradyut Dhar Choudhury,
S/o: Lt. Adhir Dhar Choudhury,
Resident of Ushabazar,
P.S. Airport, Agartala, Tripura West.
---- Accused Person(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura
Represented by the Secretary,
To the Department of Home, New Secretariat Complex,
P.S.: N.C.C., District: West Tripura.
…….Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
: Mr. Ratan Datta, Adv,
Mr. Ankan Tilak Paul, Adv,
Ms. Saswati Nag, Adv,
Mr. Aditya Baidya, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. Sankar Lodh, Spl. P.P.
Date of Hearing
: 27.01.2026
Date of delivery of
Judgment and Order : 29.01.2026
Whether fit for
Reporting
: NO
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
This bail application under Section 439 of Cr.P.C. is
filed for granting bail to the accused-in-custody namely Sri
Pradyut Dhar Choudhury in connection with Airport P.S. case
No.37 of 2024 corresponding to S.T.(T-1) No.31 of 2025 under
Section 302, 120B and 34 of IPC and Section 27 of the Arms
Act.
02.
Heard Learned Counsel, Mr. Ratan Datta assisted by
Learned Counsel, Mr. Ankan Tilak Paul, Ms. Saswati Nag and
Mr. Aditya Baidya appearing on behalf of the accused-incustody and also heard Learned Special P.P., Mr. S. Lodh
appearing on behalf of the State-respondent.
03.
Taking part in the hearing, Learned Counsel, Mr. R.
Datta drawn the attention of the Court that on behalf of this
accused earlier bail applications were moved to this Court
which were rejected but this time the accused has come before
the Court with certain new grounds which may be considered
for granting bail to the accused-in-custody. It is submitted by
Learned Counsel that in this case, ground of arrest was not
communicated to the accused. Referring Annexure-3, column
No.5 i.e. the arrest memo, Learned Counsel has drawn the
attention that from the contents of the said column, it appears
that no grounds of arrest was communicated to the accused at
the time of arrest and also during his production before the
Court. In this regard he relied upon one citation of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court of India in Mihir Rajesh Shah vs. State of
Maharashtra & Anr. reported in (2025) SCC OnLine SC
2356, wherein in para Nos.2 and 56, the Hon’ble Apex Court
observed as under:
“2. The main issue as raised by the Appellants
in these Appeals is the violation of the
Appellants' right under Article 22(1) of the
Constitution of India and Section 50 of the
Criminal Procedure Code, 1973 (“CrPC 1973”)
now Section 47 of Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha
Sanhita, 2023 (“BNSS 2023”) as the appellants
assert that they were not informed of grounds
of their arrest in writing.
56. In conclusion, it is held that:
i) The constitutional mandate of informing the
arrestee the grounds of arrest is mandatory in
all offences under all statutes including
offences under Penal Code, 1860 (now BNS
2023);
ii)
The
grounds
of
arrest
must
be
communicated in writing to the arrestee in the
language he/she understands;
iii)
In
case(s)
where,
the
arresting
officer/person is unable to communicate the
grounds of arrest in writing on or soon after
arrest, it be so done orally. The said grounds be
communicated in writing within a reasonable
time and in any case at least two hours prior to
production of the arrestee for remand
proceedings before the magistrate.
iv) In case of non-compliance of the above, the
arrest and subsequent remand would be
rendered illegal and the person will be at
liberty to be set free.”
Referring the same, Learned Counsel submitted that
since no ground of arrest was communicated to the accused-incustody, so, he may be released on bail in any condition. In
support of his contention he further referred another citation of
Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in Vihaan Kumar vs. State
of Haryana & Anr. reported in (2025) 5 SCC 799, wherein
in para No.41, the Hon’ble Apex Court observed as under:
“41. The issue on the requirement of
communication of grounds of arrest to the
person arrested, as mandated under Article
22(1) of the Constitution of India, which has
also been incorporated in the Prevention of
Money Laundering Act, 2002 under Section 19
thereof has been succinctly reiterated in this
judgment. The constitutional mandate of
informing the grounds of arrest to the person
arrested in writing has been explained in
Pankaj Bansal [Pankaj Bansal v. Union of India,
(2024) 7 SCC 576 : (2024) 3 SCC (Cri) 450] so
as to be meaningful to serve the intended
purpose which has been reiterated in Prabir
Purkayastha [Prabir Purkayastha v. State (NCT
of Delhi), (2024) 8 SCC 254 : (2024) 3 SCC
(Cri) 573] . The said constitutional mandate
has been incorporated in the statute under
Section 50CrPC (Section 47 of the BNSS). It
may also be noted that the aforesaid provision
of requirement for communicating the grounds
of arrest, to be purposeful, is also required to
be communicated to the friends, relatives or
such other persons of the accused as may be
disclosed or nominated by the arrested person
for the purpose of giving such information as
provided under Section 50-ACrPC. As may be
noted, this is in the addition of the requirement
as provided under Section 50(1)CrPC.”
Referring the same further he submitted that since
the direction of the Hon’ble Apex Court has not been complied
with by the arresting authority, so, the accused may be
released on bail in any condition.
Learned Counsel thereafter, drawn the attention of
the Court referring para No.6 of the charge-sheet wherein it
was mentioned that prior to incident on and from 01.03.2024
to 30.04.2024, there were 191 numbers of phone calls in
between the accused-in-custody and the principal accused Raju
Barman which consumed eight hours thirty seven minutes and
soon thereafter, the victim was killed/murdered. So, save and
except the allegation prosecution could not project any other
material before this Court showing involvement of the accused
with the alleged offence. In support of his contention he relied
upon one citation of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in
Kiriti Pal vs. State of West Bengal reported in (2015) 11
SCC 178, wherein in para Nos.28 and 29, the Hon’ble Apex
Court observed as under:
“Involvement of A-2, A-3 and A-4 and their
conviction.
28. For conviction of appellants A-2, A-3 and A4,
the
courts
below
relied
upon
two
circumstances: (i) that soon before the time of
the incident and after the incident all the
accused were in contact with each other on the
phone calls and thus had conspired in
perpetrating the crime; (ii) recovery of
incriminating articles from Appellants 2 and 3.
29. To arrive at a conclusion that the appellantaccused have conspired together to commit the
offence, the courts below mainly relied upon
the phone calls details:
29.1. Ext. 30 is the call record of Mobile No.
9232589186 of Kiriti Pal which shows that
Kiriti Pal made 41 calls to A-4 Durga Sutradhar
from 7-12-2008 to 15-1-2009.
29.2. Ext. 31 is the call record of Siddique Mia.
Ext. 31 indicates that 144 calls were made from
the mobile phone of Mustaque Mia to Siddique
Mia. Some of the calls were incoming calls from
the mobile of Siddique Mia to Mustaque Mia.
Ext. 31 indicates that there was telephonic
conversation between the accused Mustaque
Mia and accused Siddique Mia.
29.3. Ext. 32 shows that Kiriti Pal made seven
calls to Anjali's mobile from 11-7-2008 to 9-112008.
29.4. Ext. 34 shows that Saraswati made seven
calls to Siddique Mia during the period from 1111-2008 to 14-11-2008. Documentary evidence
indicates that Siddique Mia made 13 calls to
Saraswati during the period from 10-11-2008
to 27-11-2008.
29.5. Ext. 35 shows that Saraswati made 38
calls to Durga Sutradhar during the period from
11-11-2008
to
20-11-2008.
Documentary
evidence also indicates that all the accused
were in contact with one another over the
phone. Scrutiny of call details revealed that on
11-11-2008 Saraswati made 2 calls to Anjali.
One call was at 1255 hrs and another call was
at 1258 hrs and four calls to Siddique Mia, first
call was at 0955 hrs and the last call was at
1720 hrs. Documentary evidence further
indicates that on 11-11-2008 Siddique Mia had
a telephonic conversation with Mustaque Mia
around 1919 hrs and Siddique Mia had also
telephonic conversation with Saraswati and the
first call was at around 0955 hrs and the last
call was at 2142 hrs. Saraswati had a
telephonic
conversation
too
with
Durga
Sutradhar on that date and there were six
incoming and outgoing calls. The first call was
at around 1057 hrs and the last call was at
1757 hrs.”
Referring the same Learned Counsel submitted that
since prosecution in this case save and except the allegation of
telephonic conversation could not adduce any other materials
on record against the accused-in-custody. So, in view of the
said observation of the Hon’ble Apex Court, there is no scope
to detain the accused furthermore in custody. He also relied
upon another citation of the High Court of Delhi in Dalip Singh
alias Langda vs. State (NCT of Delhi) reported in (2019)
SCC OnLine Del 6494, wherein in para No.11 (last part), it is
written “merely because the petitioner has been having
telephonic conversation with the co-accused, would not be
sufficient to hold that petitioner is guilty of the subject offence.
There is no recovery made from the petitioner.”
Referring the case, Learned Counsel submitted that
on the basis of telephonic conversation, the High Court of Delhi
granted bail to the accused.
It was further submitted by Learned Counsel that in
para No.4 of the bail application, it is specifically asserted by
the accused-applicant that he is suffering from chronic heart
disease and he has undergone heart surgery on 26.12.2024
and he requires constant medical treatment which is not
possible if he remains in custody. Furthermore, the daughter of
the accused-in-custody died on 27.12.2022 and his mother
also expired on 11.11.2024. So, excepting the accused-incustody, there is no other male person in the family of the
accused to look after the wife of the accused and as such for
the purpose of medical treatment and since he is a senior
citizen presently aged about 65 years, the accused is required
to be released on bail in any condition. In support of this
contention, he relied upon one citation in Dr. P. Varavara Rao
vs. National Investigation Agency & Anr. reported in
(2022) SCC OnLine SC 1004, wherein in para No.16, the
Hon’ble Apex Court observed as under:
“16. We need not go into the rival contentions
as some of the notable factual aspects which
emerge from the record are:
“a. The appellant is 82 years of age.
b. He was taken in custody initially on
28.08.2018 and has actually spent 2½
years of custody, leaving aside the
period for which benefit of bail was
granted pursuant to the order dated
22.02.2021.
c. Though the charge-sheet has been
filed, some of the accused are still not
apprehended and the matter has not
even been taken up for consideration
whether the charges need to be framed
against the accused who are presently
before the Trial Court or not.
d. Various applications preferred by the
accused seeking discharge are still
pending consideration.
e. The medical condition of the
appellant has not improved to such an
extent, over a period of time, that the
facility of bail which was granted earlier
be withdrawn.”
“11. On perusal of the record, it is prima facie
seen that there are two major missing links in
the case of the prosecution. There is no link
established by the prosecution between the
petitioner with the alleged supplier Manoj.
Further the entire case of the prosecution, in so
far as petitioner is concerned is circumstantial
i.e. based solely on disclosure statement of a
co-accused which is per se not admissible
without
there
being
any
corroboration.
Prosecution has not been able to establish any
connection between the subject offence and
the bank accounts, where the petitioner is
alleged to have been depositing money or with
the holders of those accounts.”
Further, he referred another citation of the Hon’ble
Supreme of India in Satyendar Kumar Jain vs. Directorate
of Enforcement reported in 2023 SCC OnLine SC 686,
wherein in para Nos.3 and 4, the Hon’ble Apex Court observed
as under:
“3. After hearing learned counsel for the
parties, at present there is no reason to
disbelieve the Report of G.B. Pant Institute of
Post Graduate Medical Education and Research.
We think it appropriate that the citizen is
having a right to take treatment of his choice,
at his own expenses, in a private hospital.
4. Therefore, we deem it appropriate to release
the petitioner on interim bail on medical
grounds for a limited period of six weeks.”
Referring the same, Learned Counsel submitted that
since the accused is a senior citizen, so, considering his
physical condition and also the fact that he requires continuous
treatment, he may be released on bail in any condition.
Learned Counsel again submitted that the petition is
a retired Government employee and he has been falsely
implicated in this case and furthermore, in the charge-sheet it
is also mentioned that co-accused Susmita Sarkar made
statement before the Court but from the statement of said
Susmita Sarkar, no evidence reveals against the accused-incustody that he was directly or indirectly involved with the
alleged murder of accused. So, simply on the ground that he
was the president of Bharat Ratna Club the accused has been
falsely implicated in this case and as such the accused cannot
be detained furthermore in custody.
It was further submitted that on the basis of
statement of co-accused, there is no scope to convict a person.
Learned Counsel in this regard referred the judgment of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in Surender Kumar Khalina Vs.
Intelligence Officer Directorate of Revenue Intelligence
reported in AIR (2018) SC 3574.
It was further submitted that some other accused
persons by this time have been enlarged on bail in this case
and since the accused is lodging in bail more than 1 ½ years,
so, no purpose would be served by keeping the accused in J/C
furthermore. So, Learned Counsel urged for releasing the
accused on bail in any condition and further submitted that
since charge-sheet is submitted as such there is no question of
further interrogation of the accused.
It was further submitted by Learned Counsel that
prosecution in this case in the charge-sheet save and except
telephonic conservation in between the accused-in-custody and
the present principal accused could not adduce any other
materials on record to substantiate the involvement of the
accused with the alleged offence and furthermore, the accused
is languishing in jail almost for a period of 18 months. So,
considering the long incarceration of the accused-in-custody
and also considering the fact that the accused is a senior
citizen suffering from heart related issue, Learned Counsel
urged for releasing the accused on bail in any condition.
04.
On the other hand, Learned Special P.P., Mr. S.
Lodh appearing on behalf of the State-respondent submitted
that the plea of “grounds of arrest” cannot be accepted in this
case. In support of his contention he submitted that when the
accused was arrested and was produced before the Court, that
time the ground of arrest was duly communicated to him in
writing separately by the arresting authority. Even after
detention till today on so many occasions, bail applications
were moved and during that period no such plea was taken on
behalf of the accused that the “grounds of arrest” was not
communicated. It was further submitted by Learned Counsel
that initially he was granted bail by the Court with certain
condition with some direction, but the accused failed to obey
the order of the Court. So, warrant of arrest was issued against
him and on the basis of warrant of arrest, he has taken into
custody later on. So, in view of the provision provided under
Section 50 of Cr.P.C., even if it is assumed that the “grounds of
arrest” was not communicated is not a legal ground to ensure
compliance of the same by the arresting authority. In this
regard, he referred the provision of Section 50 of Cr.P.C. which
provides as under:
“50. Person arrested to be informed of grounds
of arrest and of right to bail.—
(1) Every police officer or other person
arresting any person without warrant shall
forthwith communicate to him full particulars
of the offence for which he is arrested or other
grounds for such arrest.
(2) Where a police officer arrests without
warrant any person other than a person
accused of a non-bailable offence, he shall
inform the person arrested that he is entitled
to be released on bail and that he may arrange
for sureties on his behalf.
[50A. Obligation of person making arrest to
inform about the arrest, etc., to a nominated
person.—
(1) Every police officer or other person making
any arrest under this Code shall forthwith give
the information regarding such arrest and
place where the arrested person is being held
to any of his friends, relatives or such other
persons as may be disclosed or nominated by
the arrested person for the purpose of giving
such information.
(2) The police officer shall inform the arrested
person of his rights under sub-section (1) as
soon as he is brought to the police station.
(3) An entry of the fact as to who has been
informed of the arrest of such person shall be
made in a book to be kept in the police station
in such form as may be prescribed in this
behalf by the State Government.
(4) It shall be the duty of the Magistrate before
whom such arrested person is produced, to
satisfy himself that the requirements of subsection (2) and sub-section (3) have been
complied with in respect of such arrested
person.]”
Referring the same, he submitted that the plea
taken by Learned Counsel for the petitioner cannot be
considered. It was further submitted that excepting the plea of
“grounds of arrest”, the other grounds projected by the
Learned Counsel for the petitioner accused-in-custody cannot
be considered since those issues have already been dealt with
by this Court in disposal of the bail applications filed by the
accused-in-custody earlier, so, in absence of any new grounds
the same is liable to be dismissed henceforth. In this regard,
Learned Special P.P. relied upon one citation of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court of India in Lt. Col. Prasad Shrikant Purohit
vs. State of Maharashtra reported in (2018) 11 SCC 458,
wherein in para No.30, the Hon’ble Apex Court observed as
under:
“30. Before concluding, we must note that
though an accused has a right to make
successive applications for grant of bail, the
court entertaining such subsequent bail
applications has a duty to consider the reasons
and grounds on which the earlier bail
applications were rejected. In such cases, the
court also has a duty to record the fresh
grounds which persuade it to take a view
different from the one taken in the earlier
applications.”
Referring the same, Learned Special P.P. submitted
that since no new grounds have been projected by the
accused-in-custody because those points have already been
dealt with by this Court in earlier occasions on the bail
applications filed by the accused. So, the same cannot be reagitated again and the same may lead to a speculation and
uncertainty in the administration of justice and may lead to
forum hunting. Further reference was made in another citation
of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in Kalyan Chandra
Sarkar vs. Rajesh Ranjan alias Pappu Yadav & Anr.
reported in (2005) 2 SCC 42, wherein in para No.19, the
Hon’ble Apex Court observed as under:
“19. The principles of res judicata and such
analogous
principles
although
are
not
applicable in a criminal proceeding, still the
courts are bound by the doctrine of judicial
discipline having regard to the hierarchical
system prevailing in our country. The findings
of a higher court or a coordinate Bench must
receive serious consideration at the hands of
the court entertaining a bail application at a
later stage when the same had been rejected
earlier. In such an event, the courts must give
due weight to the grounds which weighed with
the former or higher court in rejecting the bail
application. Ordinarily, the issues which had
been canvassed earlier would not be permitted
to be reagitated on the same grounds, as the
same would lead to a speculation and
uncertainty in the administration of justice and
may lead to forum hunting.”
Referring the same, Learned Counsel submitted that
although there is no legal bar to file successive applications for
granting of bail but the Court at the time of considering the
fresh bail application must consider the grounds for which the
earlier petitions were rejected and to arrive at a view different
from the other decisions taken in the earlier applications.
Finally, Learned Special P.P. submitted that since
the plea of “grounds of arrest” is not tenable at this stage, the
grounds taken by the accused are not new, rather those have
been considered in earlier occasions by this Court in dealing
with the bail applications filed by the accused-in-custody which
remain unchallenged and until and unless those orders were
challenged, there is no fresh grounds in the hands of accusedin-custody for consideration.
It was further submitted that in para No.8 of the
charge-sheet, it was specifically mentioned that regarding the
plan of the deceased for having physical with one of the coaccused, Susmita Sarkar, the matter was conveyed to the
accused-in-custody being the president of the club. So, the
submission of Learned Counsel for the accused that excepting
the allegation of telephonic conversation, no other evidence is
there, is not correct. So, in summing up, Learned Special P.P.
urged for dismissal of the bail application. It was further
submitted that trial is not yet been commenced, so, at this
stage, till recording of evidence, it cannot be said that the
accused is innocent and falsely implicated in this case.
05.
Heard both the sides at length and also perused the
relevant prosecution papers. It is admitted that the accused-incustody is lodging in jail more than 1 ½ years. It is also the
admitted position that based on the FIR laid by S.I. Srikanta
Guha of Airport P.S. to O/C., Airport P.S. on 30.04.2024, this
case was registered. The accused is FIR named and in the
initial FIR, it was mentioned that this present accused and
others made conspiracy to kill the deceased and ultimately the
deceased was murdered, although on the following day of the
alleged occurrence a detailed FIR was laid by the wife of the
deceased which was tagged in the C/D after making necessary
entry in the G/D and in the said FIR also there was direct
allegation against this present accused. It is the admitted
position that earlier on so many occasions, this present
accused filed applications for bail which were rejected. From
the relevant prosecution papers, it appears that when the
accused was arrested, he was duly intimated the “grounds of
arrest” in writing. He was all along represented by his engaged
counsel. At one point of time, he was granted bail on the
ground of sudden death of his mother but he did not comply
with the condition of the bail, so, warrant of arrest was issued
against him and he was re-arrested again by police and
produced before the Court. So, Section 50 of Cr.P.C. would no
longer attract the case of the present applicant at this stage.
So, on the point of “grounds of arrest”, there is no
06.
scope to consider bail of the accused. In respect of other
points, at the time of hearing of B.A. bearing No.45 of 2025
and B.A. No.09 of 2025 and the B.A.No.103 of 2025 all the
points raised by Learned Counsel for the accused were
discussed in detail and after considering all these aspects, the
bail applications were rejected. So, at this stage, no new
grounds have been projected before this Court to consider the
bail application of the accused. Furthermore, trial of this case
has
not
yet
been
commenced
and
from
the
relevant
prosecution papers at this stage, the prima facie involvement
of the accused cannot be ruled out.
07.
In the result, the bail application filed stands
rejected. The accused is to remain in J/C as before.
Send down the record to the Learned Trial Court
along with a copy of this order.
Return back the Case Diary to I.O. through Learned
Special P.P. along with a copy of this order.
JUDGE
PURNITA DEB
Purnita
Date: 2026.01.29 18:16:08 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review