Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
Arb P No. 78/2023
Reserved on:06.02.2026
Pronounced on: 13.02.2026
Uploaded on: 13.02.2026
Whether the operative part or full judgment
is pronounced: Full judgment.
Bikram Singh Slathia, Age 46 years,
S/o Late Sh. P. S. Slathia, R/o Ward No. 8
Udhampur.
....Appellant(s)/Petitioner(s)
Through: Mr. Anil Khajuria, Advocate
Vs
1. Municipal Council UdhampurThrough
its Chief Executive Officer, Town Hall
Complex, Udhampur.
2. Chief Executive Officer, Udhampur, .…. Respondent(s)
Town Hall Complex, Udhampur.
3. Director,Urban Local Bodies, Near Rail
Head Complex, Opposite Petrol Pump
Jammu.
Through: Mrs. Monika Kohli, Sr. AAG
Coram: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJNESH OSWAL, JUDGE
ORDER
1.
Respondent No. 1 invited bids for auction of a multi-purpose hall situated at
MH Chowk, Udhampur. The petitioner participated in the process and was
declared as highest bidder for his offer of Rs. 11,11,111/- as yearly rentals.
His bid was accepted and thereafter, when he inspected the premises, it was
observed that the multipurpose hall was in a very bad condition and
required huge investment for making it presentable. After making the
overall assessment of the amount required for renovation, the petitioner
Arb P No. 78/2023
claims to have addressed several communications to the respondents
requesting them to consider the huge investment required for renovation of
the multipurpose hall and fresh construction of public utilities, kitchen,
parking and flooring in addition to several other expenses. The respondents
considered the grievance of the petitioner and consequently decided to
extend the period of lease from 5 years to 7 years, subject to the condition
that the investments so made by the petitioner shall not be reimbursed by
the respondents. Thereafter, lease agreement dated 12.08.2016 was entered
into between the parties and registered on 19.08.2016.
2.
It is stated by the petitioner that as per terms and conditions of the lease, the
period of lease was to commence from the date of handing over of the
possession of the multipurpose hall to the petitioner after execution of
proper document of handing over and taking over. Clause ‘2’ of the lease
deed clarified that the date of commencement of lease inter se the parties
shall be from the date the vacant possession of the demised premises after
removal of all articles belonging to the respondents is handed over to the
petitioner. It is contended by the petitioner that the articles were not
removed from the demised premises till March 2018 but at the same time
the petitioner was permitted to carry on the renovation of the hall in order
to make it presentable. Besides, it is contended that because of Covid-19
pandemic in the month of March, 2020, the multipurpose hall was taken
over by the District Administration upon the consent so given by the
respondents and the same remained with the respondents as well as the
Administration till October, 2021 and for initial period of eight months, the
multipurpose hall was being used as quarantine/isolation centre for suspect
Arb P No. 78/2023
cases of Covid-19 and the travellers. Thereafter, permanent staff of police
had remained deployed in the Hall till October, 2021 and during this period
i.e. from March-2020 to October- 2021, not even a single function was
held. The petitioner further claims to
have addressed separate
representations to the respondents highlighting his grievances but to no
effect. However, the petitioner was served with a notice dated 04.03.2022
for depositing an outstanding amount of Rs. 4,16,776/-. In the month of
March, 2023, the petitioner claims to have deposited Rs. 20.00 lacs with the
respondents. It is stated that on 20.07.2023, respondent No. 2 issued
another notice calling upon the petitioner to deposit an amount of Rs.
27,83,979/- and the petitioner responded to the same and asked for the
details of the time schedule in respect of which the demand was raised.
Thereafter, another notice dated 04.08.2023 was issued to the petitioner by
respondent No. 2, whereby the petitioner was cautioned that in the event of
non-payment of amount, the respondents will be forced to seal and take
over the possession of the leased premises. The contention of the petitioner
is that the respondents are bound to settle the actual date of commencement
of lease and also the settlement of period of Covid-19 pandemic, when the
premises were taken over by the respondents.
3.
The petitioner had also filed an application under Section 9 of Arbitration
and Conciliation Act, 1996 before Principal District Judge, Udhampur and
the Principal District Judge, Udhampur vide order dated 12.09.2023,
directed the respondents-authorities not to dispossess the petitioner from the
demised premises without adopting due procedure of law. Thereafter, the
petitioner sent a notice dated 12.08.2023 to the respondents for appointment
Arb P No. 78/2023
of an Arbitrator and when despite the notice, the respondents failed to
appoint the Arbitrator, the petitioner filed this petition for appointment of
an independent Arbitrator for adjudicating the disputes arise between the
parties, arising out of the registered lease deed dated 12.08.2016.
4.
The respondents have come up with their response by asserting that the
lease agreement dated 12.08.2016 was entered into between the petitioner
and respondent No. 2 and the allotment was made in his favour vide letter
dated 18.08.2016 w.e.f. 12.08.2016. Soon after the allotment, the
possession of the hall was handed over to the petitioner, who immediately
after taking over the possession, started renovation of the hall and on
22.11.2016, the premises was inaugurated by then Deputy Chief Minister,
of erstwhile State of J&K. It is further averred that the petitioner also
deposited the yearly premium for the period 2016-17 on 29.06.2016, for the
year 2017-18 in the month of March, 2018 and on 27.06.2019, for the year
2018-19 on 02.04.2019 and for the year 2019-20 on 27.03.2020, and till
that time, he never raised any dispute qua the handing over of the
possession of the premises. It is also averred that the petitioner made
several representations with the respondent Nos. 2 and 3, wherein he
requested for extension of lease period because of Covid-19 pandemic, and
he never raised any dispute regarding the handing over the possession of
the premises in the said representations. The said representations were
examined by the respondents and as a policy decision, were not considered
favourably and rejected. It is contended by the respondents that the
multipurpose hall is a public property but at present the same is in illegal
occupation of the petitioner.
Arb P No. 78/2023
5.
Heard learned counsel appearing for the parties and perused the record.
6.
The respondents have admitted the execution of lease agreement dated
12.08.2016 between the petitioner and respondent No. 2. It is the contention
of the petitioner that the possession of the premises was required to be
handed over to him after the removal of the articles in terms of Clause ‘2’
of the agreement, whereas the respondents have disputed the said
contention by asserting that the possession was handed over to the
petitioner on 12.08.2016 only and that is why the petitioner got the
multipurpose hall inaugurated by then Deputy Chief Minister of erstwhile
State of J&K. The petitioner further claims that the premises remained in
occupation of the District Administration w.e.f. March, 2020 to October,
2021 and this period was required to be settled for the purpose of
calculating the period of lease. The respondents in turn have contended that
they have rejected the representations submitted by the petitioner for
granting him the benefit of extension of lease in view of the Covid-19
pandemic. These issues are the disputed questions of fact, which are
required to be adjudicated by an Arbitrator. But this is also a fact that even
if the contention of the petitioner is accepted that the possession of the
premises was handed over to him in March, 2018 and further, even if his
contention is accepted that in view of the period of Covid-19 pandemic
from March, 2020 till October, 2021, the lease is required to be extended
for the said period, still the petitioner cannot remain in possession beyond
the extended period which may expire in 2027.
7.
Be that as it may, Clause ‘10’ of the lease agreement provides that in the
event of any dispute or difference arising out of and between the parties or
Arb P No. 78/2023
related to the construction of this agreement, the same shall be referred to
the Director Urban Local Bodies, who shall be the sole arbitrator.
8.
In view of subsequent amendment, the Director Urban Local Bodies cannot
be appointed as an Arbitrator. The petitioner has categorically stated that
notice dated 12.08.2023 was served upon the respondents and the
respondents in reply to Para ‘20’ of the petition, wherein reference to notice
dated 12.08.2023 has been made, have stated that the contents of Para 20
are matter of record, meaning thereby, there is admission on their part that
notice was served upon them by the petitioner. In so far as the contention of
the respondents that the petitioner has no right to remain in occupation as
he is in unauthorized and illegal possession of the property is concerned,
the respondents can file their counter claim and may also seek relief of
mesne profits before the learned Arbitrator.
9.
In view of the above, I appoint Mr. Deepak Sethi, Retired District and
Sessions Judge as sole Arbitrator, who shall proceed in the matter in
accordance with the provisions of the Act. The Arbitrator shall, after
hearing both the parties, make an award within the time provided in the Act
itself after charging the prescribed fee, to be shared by the parties.
10.
Registry to inform the above-named Arbitrator about his appointment as an
Arbitrator in this matter.
11.
Disposed of.
(RAJNESH OSWAL)
JUDGE
Jammu
13.02.2026
Neha-II
Whether the order is speaking:
Whether the order is reportable:
Arb P No. 78/2023
Sahil Padha
2026.02.13 14:07
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Yes/No.
Yes/No.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review