Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:27826
Mat.Appeal No.312/2015
..1..
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SATHISH NINAN
&
THE HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN
WEDNESDAY, THE 2ND DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 12TH CHAITHRA, 1947
MAT.APPEAL NO. 312 OF 2015
ORDER DATED 21.11.2014 IN OA NO.156 OF 2012 OF FAMILY COURT, KOZHIKODE
APPELLANT/RESPONDENT:
BIJU V.J., AGED 37 YEARS
S/O.VARKEY,VADAKKEDATH VEETTIL, AVIDANALLUR P.O.,
KOORACHUNDU, KOYILANDY, KOZHIKODE-673 614.
BY ADVS.
SRI.NAGARAJ NARAYANAN
SRI.BENOJ C AUGUSTIN
SMT.J.KASTHURI
SRI.PRATHAP PILLAI
SRI.SAIJO HASSAN
SRI.SEBIN THOMAS
SRI.VISHNU BHUVANENDRAN
RESPONDENT/PETITIONER:
MARIYET, AGED 33 YEARS, D/O.ALEX,KALLANICKAL VEETTIL,
MATHAKKADAVU P.O., KOODARANJI, THIRUVAMBADI, KOZHIKODE-673
604.
BY ADVS.
SRI.A.RANJITH NARAYANAN
SRI.S.K.SAJU
SMT.A.SIMI
THIS MATRIMONIAL APPEAL HAVING COME UP FOR HEARING ON 26.03.2025,
THE COURT ON 02.04.2025 DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
2025:KER:27826
Mat.Appeal No.312/2015
..2..
JUDGMENT
SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN, J.
The husband is the appellant. The appeal is filed challenging
the impugned order dated 21.11.2014 in OA No.156 of 2012 on the
files of the Family Court, Kozhikode, entitling the wife to recover
from the husband and his assets 13½ sovereigns of gold ornaments
and an amount of ₹2,00,000/-. The respondent is the wife.
2. For sake of convenience, the parties are referred to as,
“husband” and “wife”.
3.
The
marriage
between
the
parties
was
solemnized
on
13.09.2010. The wife claimed that she was given 20 sovereigns of
gold
ornaments
₹2,00,000/-
was
at
the
given
time
to
the
of
marriage,
husband
two
and
an
amount
weeks
prior
to
of
the
marriage. According to her, out of the 20 sovereigns of gold
ornaments, 14 were purchased and six were obtained as gifts from
relatives. The wife alleged that the husband, who was a contractor
of civil works, took all the gold ornaments except a gold ring of ½
sovereign. Immediately after the marriage, there was disharmony
2025:KER:27826
Mat.Appeal No.312/2015
..3..
between the parties and the wife went to the parental home. Due to
the intervention of the church priest, the wife returned to the
matrimonial
home.
However,
on
account
of
the
strained
relationships, the wife again left the matrimonial home. OP is
filed for realization of gold ornaments and money from the husband.
4. The husband denied the allegations that the wife was having
20 sovereigns of gold ornaments and that he was given ₹2,00,000/two weeks before the marriage. According to him, most of the
ornaments worn by the wife were imitation jewellery. He also denied
the allegation that he misbehaved and quarrelled with the wife. It
was further contended that the documents produced by the wife to
support the purchase of gold ornaments are fabricated. He prayed
for dismissal of the petition, contending that he purchased the
“thali” chain and the wedding ring for the wife; and the wife was
having only two bangles, a pair of anklets having 1½ sovereign and
a stud of ½ sovereign.
5.
The
Family
Court,
on
an
appreciation
of
the
entire
evidence, decreed the petition entitling the wife to recover 13½
sovereigns of gold ornaments and an amount of ₹2,00,000/- from the
husband.
2025:KER:27826
Mat.Appeal No.312/2015
..4..
6. We have heard the learned counsel on both sides.
7. The marriage between the parties on 13.09.2010 is admitted.
According to the wife, the entire gold ornaments given to her at
the time of marriage except a gold ring weighing ½ sovereign, were
sold by the husband, who was engaged in civil works contract. It is
also her case that an amount of ₹2,00,000/- was entrusted to the
husband by her parents two weeks before marriage in the presence of
two witnesses. In order to prove the claim for return of gold
ornaments, the wife relied on Ext.A2 quotation bill issued from
M.M.Jewellery, Thiruvambadi, and Ext.A6 series photographs. The
wife was examined as PW1. During cross-examination, she deposed
that,
sovereigns
of
gold
ornaments
were
purchased
from
M.M.Jewellery, Thiruvambadi, and six were gifted by her relatives.
She further deposed that Ext.A2 quotation bill was obtained from
M.N.Jewellery to facilitate a gold loan from the Bank for the
purpose of purchasing gold ornaments. The original of Ext.A2 was
allegedly submitted to the Bank for availing gold loan. During
cross-examination, it was admitted by the wife that some of the
ornaments worn by her at the time of marriage were imitation
ornaments taken from the beauty parlour, which were returned after
marriage.
The
relevant
statements
of
the
wife
during
cross-
2025:KER:27826
Mat.Appeal No.312/2015
..5..
examination are as follows:
“Ext.A6(a) and (b) photo യയൽ കകണനതതലകല സസർണല അലലലക (Q).
അല, Make up സകധനങളമണ. അതയൽ കകണന അരപടയല വളകളല കഴതയത"
show മക" എനയവ make up centre -ൽ നയന തനതകണ, അവ പയന&ട തയരയച
തകകടത (A). Ext.A6 ൽ കകണനതയൽ ഭരയഭകഗവല rold gold ആതണനല, അത
ധരയചകണ നയങൾ ക"3കണതയന ഹകജരകതയന പറയന (Q). അതയൽ 20 പവത7
ആഭരണങൾ സസർണമകയയരന (A).”
8. A reading of the deposition of the wife reveals that she
has
stated
the
true
facts
during
cross-examination.
She
has
admitted that some of the ornaments worn at the time of marriage
were imitation ornaments and she has specifically identified those
items. She further added that, “അതയൽ 20 പവത7 ആഭരണങൾ സസർണമകയയരന”.
Ext.A2 quotation is for 14 sovereigns of gold ornaments. It is the
specific case of the wife that in order to purchase new gold
ornaments, some old gold ornaments weighing 14 sovereigns were
entrusted to the M.M.Jewellery for making new gold ornaments. The
wife’s father was examined as PW2, who also deposed in tune with
his daughter that 14 sovereigns of gold ornaments were purchased
and six were gifted by family relatives. However, the husband
denied that the wife had 20 sovereigns of gold ornaments. According
to him, she had only two bangles, a pair of anklets having 1½
sovereign and a stud of ½ sovereign. He also contended that since
there was a custom prevalent that the dress and gold ornaments are
2025:KER:27826
Mat.Appeal No.312/2015
..6..
to be taken in the presence of the bride, the groom and their
family members, they arrived at Chemmannur Jewellery on 08.09.2010,
however, no gold ornaments were purchased by the wife’s family on
that day, but enquired about the price of two bangles, a pair of
anklets having 1½ sovereign and a stud of ½ sovereign. He claimed
that he had purchased a “thali” chain of 29 grams and a wedding
ring.
9. The husband had filed IA No. 1011 of 2013 before the Family
Court
to
summon
and
examine
the
proprietor
of
M.M.Jewellery,
Thiruvambadi, to disprove that the mother of the wife had purchased
gold ornaments from that jewellery on 09.08.2010. Accordingly, the
witness filed Ext.C1 statement as follows:
“അനകടയ എന അന ചകണയ, മതകടവ എനവതര എനയക അറയയകല. അവർ എത7
സകപനതയത7 ഒര കസമർ ആണ. അവർ 9.8.2010 തയയതയ എത7 സകപനതയൽ
നയനല സസർണകഭരണങൾ വകങയയയടയല. അവർ എത7 സകപനതയൽ കറച പഴയ
സസർണകഭരണങൾ തകകണ വരയകയല അതയത7 തകല ലനകകയ തടകത7 പകൽ പതകയ പണയയകൻ
തകകടകകയല തചയയടണ. ബകങയൽ നയനല ല"കൺ എടലകണ ആവശ3തയല"കകയയ തകല
ലനകകയയ പഴയ സസർണതയന ത"3മകയ തകതയന അവർ ആവശ3തപട പകകരല അവർക എത7
സകപനതയൽ നയനല ഒര തകകലടഷൻ തകകടതയടണ.”
The above statement reveals that the wife’s family did not purchase
any gold from M.M.Jewellery on 09.08.2010, but they brought certain
quantity of gold ornaments and after weighing, it was entrusted for
remaking and thereafter, an estimate was obtained by Annakutti @
2025:KER:27826
Mat.Appeal No.312/2015
..7..
Anna Chandi, the wife’s mother, from M.M.Jewellery for availing
bank
loan.
Ext.A3
certificate
issued
by
the
Manager
of
the
Kozhikode Primary Co-operative Agricultural & Rural Development
Bank Ltd., Mukkam Branch, shows that a loan for ₹1,50,000/- was
availed
by
Annakutti
@
Anna
Chandi
for
purchase
of
gold
for
marriage. The quantity of gold claimed to have been purchased by
the wife tallies with Ext.A2 quotation bill of M.M.Jewellery,
Thiruvambadi. The details of gold ornaments claimed for, have been
detailed in schedule A of the petition. Except a ½ sovereign of
gold ring, 13½ sovereigns of gold ornaments have been listed in the
schedule.
Ext.A2
quotation
bill
as
well
as
Ext.A6
series
photographs reveal that she had worn almost 20 sovereigns of gold
ornaments.
evidence
The
on
Family
board,
Court,
granted
on
return
consideration
of
13½
of
the
sovereign
entire
of
gold
ornaments from the husband. The findings of facts by the Family
Court are on the evidence available and does not require any
interference.
10. The next claim is regarding the entrustment of ₹2,00,000/alleged to have been given to the husband two weeks before the
marriage. According to the wife, the said amount was entrusted by
the wife’s father to the husband in the presence of two witnesses,
2025:KER:27826
Mat.Appeal No.312/2015
..8..
viz.,
one
Kochettan
@
Paulose,
Kanhirathinkal
and
one
Jose,
Kanhirathinkal, on 09.08.2010, on the road near the Chemmannur
Jewellery, Kozhikode. PW2/wife’s father deposed that ₹2,00,000/was paid to the husband on the said road for convenience of the
husband and his family members. The husband completely denied the
contention that ₹2,00,000/- was received by him on the road near
the Chemmannur Jewellery, Kozhikode. During cross-examination, the
husband admitted that he had purchased the “thali” chain weighing
29 grams and a wedding ring on 08.10.2010. According to the wife,
her
father
gave
₹2,00,000/-
to
the
husband
in
front
of
the
Chemmannur Jewellery, Mavoor road, Kozhikode, however, they do not
remember the date of entrustment. From records, it is clear that
the wife’s mother availed a bank loan from the Kozhikode Primary
Co-operative Agricultural & Rural Development Bank Ltd., Mukkam
Branch, and they have arrived at the Chemmannur Jewellery, for
handing over cash to the husband. Though the husband has denied
entrustment of ₹2,00,000/-, circumstantial evidence as well as
depositions of PW1 & PW2 substantiate the claim of entrustment of
₹2,00,000/- to the husband. It appears that by utilizing the said
amount, he had purchased the “thali” chain and wedding ring from
the Chemmannur Jewellery. The Family Court found that ₹2,00,000/-
2025:KER:27826
Mat.Appeal No.312/2015
..9..
was entrusted to the husband and has directed return the same. We
do not find any reason to interfere with the said finding.
11. The decree and judgment of the Family Court do not call
for any interference.
The appeal is dismissed accordingly.
Sd/SATHISH NINAN
JUDGE
Sd/SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN
JUDGE
bka/-
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review