Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Digitally Signed
Signed by: BHABAGRAHI JHANKAR
Reason: Authentication
Location: ORISSA HIGH COURT, CUTTACK
Date: 05-Feb-2026 10:42:43
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
FAO No. 593 of 2023
(An appeal under Section 23 of the Railway Claims Tribunal Act,
1987)
Bidulata Swain
….
Appellant (s)
….
Respondent (s)
-versus-
Union of India
Advocates appeared in the case through Hybrid Mode:
For Appellant (s)
:
Mr. Jatadhari Barik, Adv.
For Respondent (s)
:
Ms. Sulochana Patra, CGC
CORAM:
DR. JUSTICE SANJEEB K PANIGRAHI
DATE OF HEARING:-05.01.2026
DATE OF JUDGMENT:-22.01.2026
Dr. Sanjeeb K Panigrahi, J.
1.
The present First Appeal (FAO) has been filed by the appellant assailing
the order passed by the Railway Claims Tribunal, Bhubaneswar Bench,
in O.A. No.291 of 2017, whereby the Original Application seeking
compensation of ₹4,00,000/- on account of the death of her husband was
dismissed.
I.
FACTUAL MATRIX OF THE CASE:
2.
The brief facts of the case are as follows:
i.
It is the case of the appellant that while her husband and son were
travelling from Cuttack to Balasore by Gurudev Express after
Page 1
Digitally Signed
Signed by: BHABAGRAHI JHANKAR
Reason: Authentication
Location: ORISSA HIGH COURT, CUTTACK
Date: 05-Feb-2026 10:42:43
purchasing general tickets, they boarded a general compartment
which was overcrowded. As no seats were available, they were
standing near the door of the compartment.
ii.
While the said train was passing through Soro Railway Station, the
deceased fell from the running train due to jostling among copassengers in the overcrowded compartment, sustained injuries
and subsequently died.
iii.
The appellant filed O.A. No. 291 of 2017 before the Railway Claims
Tribunal,
Bhubaneswar
Bench,
seeking
compensation
of
₹4,00,000/- on account of the death of her husband. The said
Original Application was initially dismissed, whereafter the
appellant preferred FAO No. 142 of 2020 before this Court.
iv.
By order dated 24.11.2022, this Court remitted the matter to the
Tribunal for fresh adjudication after affording an opportunity of
hearing to both parties.
v.
Upon remand, the Tribunal reheard the matter and, by the
impugned judgment dated 20.09.2023, dismissed the Original
Application, holding that the incident did not constitute an
untoward incident and that the deceased was not a bona fide
passenger.
vi.
Being aggrieved by the judgment dated 20.09.2023 passed by the
Tribunal, the appellant has preferred the present appeal.
II.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE APPELLANT:
3.
Learned counsel for the appellant earnestly made the following
submissions in support of his contentions:
Page 2
Digitally Signed
Signed by: BHABAGRAHI JHANKAR
Reason: Authentication
Location: ORISSA HIGH COURT, CUTTACK
Date: 05-Feb-2026 10:42:43
i.
The appellant submitted that the learned Tribunal dealt with the
Original Application in a hyper-technical manner without
properly appreciating the evidence on record and thereby arrived
at an erroneous conclusion in dismissing the claim. The impugned
order is, therefore, liable to be set aside.
ii.
The appellant further contended that the learned Tribunal failed to
appreciate the veracity of the evidence adduced by the claimant
and instead placed undue reliance on the version of the
respondent.
iii.
The learned Tribunal, without properly appreciating the factual
matrix, disbelieved the evidence adduced by the appellant despite
the specific assertion in the Original Application that the
appellant’s younger son was travelling along with the deceased.
Instead, the learned Tribunal placed reliance on the statement of
the Loco Pilot, who failed to produce the duty chart of the relevant
day.
iv.
The appellant further contended that the learned Tribunal erred in
relying upon the statement of the Loco Pilot, who failed to assign
any reason for not reporting the incident, as required under Rule 3
of the Railways Passengers (Manner of Investigation of Untoward
Incidents) Rules, 2003, at the nearest railway station, namely, Soro
Railway Station. The appellant submitted that the materials relied
upon by the respondent appear to have been prepared as an
afterthought.
Page 3
Digitally Signed
Signed by: BHABAGRAHI JHANKAR
Reason: Authentication
Location: ORISSA HIGH COURT, CUTTACK
Date: 05-Feb-2026 10:42:43
v.
The learned Tribunal accepted the version of the Loco Pilot despite
his own statement that the train was detained near Soro Railway
Station after the occurrence, whereas the matter was reported only
at Balasore Railway Station. It was further contended that the
Station Master of Soro Railway Station did not visit the spot,
which casts doubt on the reliability of the version relied upon by
the Tribunal. The appellant also submitted that she was deprived
of an effective opportunity to adduce evidence at the time of the
initial dismissal of the Original Application.
vi.
The learned Tribunal dismissed the Original Application in a
mechanical manner without properly considering the evidence
adduced by the appellant. The impugned order dated 20.09.2023
is, therefore, liable to be set aside.
III. SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENT:
4.
Learned counsel for the respondent earnestly made the following
submissions in support of his contentions:
i.
The respondent submitted that the averments made by the
appellant in the Original Application are false and fabricated and
fall beyond the scope of Section 123(c)(2) of the Railways Act, 1989.
ii.
The respondents further asserted that there is a direct eyewitness
to the alleged incident, who has categorically deposed that the
deceased, without using the foot overbridge for crossing the
railway track from Platform No. 1 to Platform No. 2, attempted to
cross the track at the surface by committing trespass and was hit
by a running train, resulting in his death.
Page 4
Digitally Signed
Signed by: BHABAGRAHI JHANKAR
Reason: Authentication
Location: ORISSA HIGH COURT, CUTTACK
Date: 05-Feb-2026 10:42:43
iii.
The respondents contended that the incident is a clear case of
death arising out of an act of criminal negligence on the part of the
deceased and that the respondent Railway is squarely protected
under the exception provided in Section 124-A of the Railways
Act, 1989, and is, therefore, not liable to pay any compensation.
iv.
The respondents further submitted that, as per the inquest report,
the deceased was not holding a valid journey ticket at the time of
the incident and that the plea of loss of the journey ticket is wholly
false.
IV. FINDINGS OF THE RAILWAY CLAIMS TRIBUNAL, BHUBANESWAR:
5.
The learned Tribunal, upon hearing the parties and considering the
materials on record, framed the following issues for determination:
a) Whether the death of deceased was due to any
untoward incident as defined u/s 123(c) of the Railways
Act 1989?
b) Whether the deceased was travelling as a bona fide
passenger of the train at the time of occurrence of the
untoward incident?
c) Whether the Applicant entitled to get compensation u/s
124 A of the Railways Act 1989?
d) Whether the Applicants are the dependents of the
deceased to receive the compensation as claimed?
e) To what relief the Applicants are entitled to?
6.
The learned Tribunal noted that while the claimants alleged that the
deceased fell from an overcrowded general compartment of Gurudev
Page 5
Digitally Signed
Signed by: BHABAGRAHI JHANKAR
Reason: Authentication
Location: ORISSA HIGH COURT, CUTTACK
Date: 05-Feb-2026 10:42:43
Express due to push and pull of passengers, the said version was not
supported by any independent contemporaneous evidence. The
Tribunal observed that the wife and son of the deceased were not
eyewitnesses to the incident and that the testimony of the alleged copassenger was inconsistent with the surrounding circumstances.
7.
The learned Tribunal placed reliance on the evidence of the Loco Pilot,
who deposed that the deceased was run over while trespassing on the
railway track at Soro Railway Station and that the incident was
immediately reported through official channels. The Tribunal further
relied upon station diary entries and investigation reports, holding that
such records were admissible in evidence under Section 191 of the
Railways Act, 1989.
8.
The Tribunal rejected the contention of the claimants that the incident
was a case of accidental fall from the running train, observing that it was
not possible for a person falling from a compartment located behind the
engine to suffer a frontal hit by the locomotive. It was further noted that
there was no report of alarm chain pulling or any immediate reporting
by co-passengers, despite the incident having allegedly occurred during
daylight hours.
9.
The learned Tribunal also held that the deceased was not established to
be a bona fide passenger, as no journey ticket was recovered and the
plea of loss of ticket was not supported by convincing evidence.
10.
In view of the above findings, the learned Tribunal concluded that the
death of the deceased did not arise out of an untoward incident but was
covered by the exceptions contained in the proviso to Section 124-A of
Page 6
Digitally Signed
Signed by: BHABAGRAHI JHANKAR
Reason: Authentication
Location: ORISSA HIGH COURT, CUTTACK
Date: 05-Feb-2026 10:42:43
the Railways Act, 1989. Accordingly, the Original Application was
dismissed.
V.
COURT’S REASONING AND ANALYSIS:
11.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the material available
on record.
12.
At the outset, it would be apposite to advert to the statutory framework
governing claims for compensation under the Railways Act, 1989.
13.
Section 123(c) defines an “untoward incident” and is replicated
hereinunder:
14.
“123(c) “untoward incident” means—
(1)(i) the commission of a terrorist act within the
meaning of sub-section (1) of Section 3 of the
Terrorist and Disruptive Activities (Prevention)
Act, 1987 (28 of 1987); or
(ii) the making of a violent attack or the commission
of robbery or dacoity; or
(iii) the indulging in rioting, shoot-out or arson,
by any person in or on any train carrying
passengers, or in a waiting hall, cloakroom or
reservation or booking office or on any platform or in
any other place within the precincts of a railway
station; or
(2) the accidental falling of any passenger from a
train carrying passengers.”
Section 124-A of the Railways Act, 1989 provides for compensation on
account of untoward incidents. The provision stipulates that when, in
the course of working a railway, an untoward incident occurs, the
Railway Administration shall be liable to pay compensation for death or
injury to a passenger, subject to the exceptions enumerated in the
proviso thereto. The section is provided hereinunder:
Page 7
Digitally Signed
Signed by: BHABAGRAHI JHANKAR
Reason: Authentication
Location: ORISSA HIGH COURT, CUTTACK
Date: 05-Feb-2026 10:42:43
15.
“124-A. Compensation on account of untoward
incidents.—When in the course of working a railway
an untoward incident occurs, then whether or not
there has been any wrongful act, neglect or default
on the part of the railway administration such as
would entitle a passenger who has been injured or
the dependant of a passenger who has been killed to
maintain an action and recover damages in respect
thereof, the railway administration shall,
notwithstanding anything contained in any other
law, be liable to pay compensation to such extent as
may be prescribed and to that extent only for loss
occasioned by the death of, or injury to, a passenger
as a result of such untoward incident:
Provided that no compensation shall be payable
under this section by the railway administration if
the passenger dies or suffers injury due to—
(a) suicide or attempted suicide by him;
(b) self-inflicted injury;
(c) his own criminal act;
(d) any act committed by him in a state of
intoxication or insanity;
(e) any natural cause or disease or medical or
surgical treatment unless such treatment becomes
necessary due to injury caused by the said untoward
incident.
Explanation.—For the purposes of this section,
“passenger” includes—
a railway servant on duty; and
a person who has purchased a valid ticket for
travelling, by a train carrying passengers, on any
date or a valid platform ticket and becomes a victim
of an untoward incident.”
A conjoint reading of Sections 123(c) and 124-A makes it clear that the
statutory scheme is founded on the principle of strict or no-fault liability.
Once the occurrence falls within the description of an untoward
Page 8
Digitally Signed
Signed by: BHABAGRAHI JHANKAR
Reason: Authentication
Location: ORISSA HIGH COURT, CUTTACK
Date: 05-Feb-2026 10:42:43
incident, compensation must ordinarily follow, unless the Railway
Administration clearly establishes that the case falls within one of the
statutory exceptions.
16.
The legal position in this regard is no longer res integra. In Kalandi
Charan Sahoo v. South-East Central Railways1, the Supreme Court
observed that Section 124-A warrants payment of compensation
whenever an untoward incident occurs, whether or not such incident
has occurred due to any wrongful act, neglect or default on the part of
the Railway Administration.
17.
In Union of India v. Prabhakaran Vijaya Kumar2, the Supreme Court
held that the expression “accidental falling of a passenger from a train
carrying passengers” in Section 123(c) cannot be construed narrowly or
restrictively. The relevant observation reads as under:
“14. In our opinion, if we adopt a restrictive meaning
to the expression “accidental falling of a passenger
from a train carrying passengers” in Section 123(c) of
the Railways Act, we will be depriving a large number
of railway passengers from getting compensation in
railway accidents. It is well known that in our country
there are crores of people who travel by railway trains
since everybody cannot afford travelling by air or in a
private car. By giving a restrictive and narrow
meaning to the expression we will be depriving a large
number of victims of train accidents (particularly poor
and middle class people) from getting compensation
under the Railways Act. Hence, in our opinion, the
expression “accidental falling of a passenger from a
train carrying passengers” includes accidents when a
bona fide passenger i.e. a passenger travelling with a
(2019) 12 SCC 387.
(2008) 9 SCC 527.
Page 9
Digitally Signed
Signed by: BHABAGRAHI JHANKAR
Reason: Authentication
Location: ORISSA HIGH COURT, CUTTACK
Date: 05-Feb-2026 10:42:43
valid ticket or pass is trying to enter into a railway
train and falls down during the process. In other
words, a purposive, and not literal interpretation
should be given to the expression.”
18.
It is also well settled that mere non-recovery of a journey ticket does not
ipso facto negate the claim of the deceased being a bona fide passenger.
Once the claimant discharges the initial burden by placing relevant facts
on record, the onus shifts to the Railway Administration to rebut the
same.
19.
In this regard, the Supreme Court in Union of India v. Rina Devi3
observed:
“29. We thus hold that mere presence of a body
on the railway premises will not be conclusive to
hold that injured or deceased was a bona fide
passenger for which claim for compensation could
be maintained. However, mere absence of ticket
with such injured or deceased will not negative
the claim that he was a bona fide passenger.
Initial burden will be on the claimant which can
be discharged by filing an affidavit of the relevant
facts and burden will then shift on the Railways
and the issue can be decided on the facts shown or
the attending circumstances. This will have to be
dealt with from case to case on the basis of facts
found. The legal position in this regard will stand
explained accordingly.”
20.
Tested on the aforesaid legal position, this Court now proceeds to
examine whether the findings recorded by the learned Tribunal suffer
from any perversity or legal infirmity warranting interference.
(2019) 3 SCC 572.
Page 10
Digitally Signed
Signed by: BHABAGRAHI JHANKAR
Reason: Authentication
Location: ORISSA HIGH COURT, CUTTACK
Date: 05-Feb-2026 10:42:43
21.
Pursuant to the remand by this Court, the learned Tribunal afforded full
opportunity of hearing to both parties and undertook a comprehensive
reconsideration of the claim.
22.
During the rehearing, the Loco Pilot of the train, the then Station Master
of Soro Railway Station and the present Station Master were examined
and subjected to cross-examination at the instance of the claimants.
23.
The learned Tribunal noted that the wife and son of the deceased,
examined as AW-1 and AW-2 respectively, were not eyewitnesses to the
incident. The testimony of AW-3, the alleged co-passenger, was carefully
scrutinised and was found to be inconsistent with the surrounding
circumstances and the contemporaneous records.
24.
On the other hand, the evidence of the Loco Pilot, examined as CW-1,
disclosed that the deceased suddenly appeared in front of the engine
while attempting to cross the railway track at Soro Railway Station and
was hit by the train. The testimony of the Loco Pilot remained unshaken
in cross-examination and was corroborated by station diary entries,
investigation reports and the inquest report.
25.
The learned Tribunal relied upon the station diary entries and other
railway records, which are admissible in evidence in terms of Section
191 of the Railways Act, 1989. The Tribunal further recorded cogent
reasons explaining the reporting of the incident at Balasore, noting that
the Gurudev Express did not have a scheduled stoppage at Soro and
that, after application of brakes, the train would have come to a halt at a
distance ahead, making such reporting a logical consequence.
Page 11
Digitally Signed
Signed by: BHABAGRAHI JHANKAR
Reason: Authentication
Location: ORISSA HIGH COURT, CUTTACK
Date: 05-Feb-2026 10:42:43
26.
A significant factor weighed by the Tribunal was the physical
improbability of the version projected by the claimants. The Tribunal
recorded a reasoned finding that a person falling from a compartment
situated behind the engine could not have suffered a frontal impact with
the locomotive. This finding, based on physical probability, directly
undermined the plea of accidental fall from the running train.
27.
The Tribunal also took note of the absence of any alarm chain pulling or
immediate reporting by co-passengers, despite the incident having
allegedly occurred during daylight hours and in an overcrowded
compartment. These circumstances, taken cumulatively, were found to
be inconsistent with the version advanced by the claimants.
28.
On the issue of bona fide passenger status, the Tribunal did not rest its
conclusion merely on the non-recovery of the journey ticket. The finding
was arrived at upon an evaluation of the overall factual matrix,
including the manner of occurrence and the lack of credible
corroboration in support of the plea that the deceased fell from the train
during travel.
29.
The material on record establishes that the deceased was unauthorisedly
present on the railway track at the time of the incident. Unauthorised
crossing or presence on railway tracks constitutes trespass and is an
offence under the Railways Act, 1989. Such conduct involves voluntary
exposure to a known and obvious risk associated with the movement of
trains. Where death or injury results from such conduct, the same
squarely falls within the scope of clauses (b) and (c) of the proviso to
Page 12
Digitally Signed
Signed by: BHABAGRAHI JHANKAR
Reason: Authentication
Location: ORISSA HIGH COURT, CUTTACK
Date: 05-Feb-2026 10:42:43
Section 124-A of the Act, namely, self-inflicted injury and death arising
from one’s own criminal act.
30.
The Railway Administration has discharged its burden of establishing
the applicability of the statutory exceptions by leading direct and
contemporaneous evidence, including the testimony of the Loco Pilot,
station diary entries and the inquest report. The cumulative effect of this
evidence reasonably supports the conclusion that the death did not arise
out of an untoward incident within the meaning of Section 123(c).
31.
This Court is conscious that Section 124-A of the Railways Act is a
welfare provision and that claims thereunder are not to be defeated on
hyper-technical grounds. However, where the material on record
reasonably supports the conclusion that the death fell within the
statutory exceptions, the Tribunal is justified in declining compensation.
32.
This Court finds that the conclusions reached by the learned Tribunal
are founded on a careful appreciation of both oral and documentary
evidence and constitute a possible and plausible view. No perversity or
legal infirmity has been demonstrated so as to warrant interference in
exercise of appellate jurisdiction.
VI.
CONCLUSION:
33.
In view of the foregoing discussion, this Court finds no merit in the
present appeal.
34.
The appeal is, accordingly, dismissed. The impugned judgment dated
20.09.2023 passed by the Railway Claims Tribunal, Bhubaneswar Bench,
in O.A. No. 291 of 2017 is hereby affirmed.
Page 13
Digitally Signed
Signed by: BHABAGRAHI JHANKAR
Reason: Authentication
Location: ORISSA HIGH COURT, CUTTACK
Date: 05-Feb-2026 10:42:43
35.
Interim order, if any, passed earlier stands vacated.
(Dr. Sanjeeb K Panigrahi)
Judge
Orissa High Court, Cuttack,
Dated the 22nd Jan., 2026/-
Page 14
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review