Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:HON’BLE JUSTICE CHAITALI CHATTERJEE DAS.
CRA 2 OF 1993
BIDHI CHAND CHOWRASIA
VS
THE STATE OF WEST BENGAL
For the Amicus Curiae : Mr. Anirudha Bhattacharyya , Adv.
For the State
:
Ms. Manisha Sharma, Adv.
Ms. Pushpita Saha, Adv.
Last heard on
: 3.12.2026
Judgement on
: 06.02.2026
Uploaded on
: 06.02.2026
CHAITALI CHATTERJEE DAS:1. This criminal appeal was filed under Section 374(2) of the Code of Criminal
Procedure against the order of conviction and sentence dated December 18,
1992 passed by the special E.C Act, in Special Court case no. 87 of 1990
convicting the accused appellant under section 7(1)(a)(ii) of the essential
commodities act for violation of paragraph 3(2) of the West Bengal declaration
of stocks and prices of Essential Commodities order, 1977 and 3(2) of the
West, Bengal, motor spirit, and high speed diesel oil (licensing control, and
maintenance of supplies) order, 1860, and sentenced him to suffer, regardless
imprisonment for6 six months and to pay a fine of ₹2000 in default to suffer as
imprisonment for another one month
Fact of the case.
2. . On November 22, 1990 at about 14.00 hrs when the appellant was not
personally present at the Sage service station and one employee of the firm,
Anil Kumar Mishra was looking the business, some police officers, and
enforcement branch, Hooghly raided the shop and found one wooden board
with writing <Tail nahi hai= and they found after ported measurement, shortage
in the stock to the extent of 279 L of the said oil, and they seized stock cum
rate board. Subsequently Dankuni Police Station case no.
102 dated
November 22, 1990 start and on completion of investigation, the charge-sheet
was submitted against the present. Appellant and the learned Special Court
passed the order of conviction. Being aggrieved by this Appeal was filed.
Submission
3. The learned Amicus representing the appellant argued that the measurement
of H.S.D oil in the two underground tanks of the service station by D.E.B
Officials was not done following the procedure. It is his further contention that
no satisfactory explanation for the allegation of keeping hundred litres of oil as
alleged. The specific defence was taken by the person who was present at the
spot that the license was lying in the DM Office and hence such document
could not be produced. The prosecution failed to prove the case as the
independent witnesses became hostile. The Appellant was in a position to
show that 750 Ltrs. of HSD oil sold on that day. The firm was not made a party
and the raid was conducted in absence of the present appellant. The search
and seizure are absolutely doubtful and hence the order of conviction cannot
stand.
4. The learned prosecution raises objection and argued that the prosecution case
was proved beyond the shadow of reasonable doubt. In order to bring home
the charges, they cited seven witnesses and the materials were exhibited and
the learned special court, considering the facts and circumstances, such order
of conviction which is not to be interfere with. Accordingly prayed for dismissal
of this appeal.
5. Having heard both the learned amicus as well as the prosecution and on-going
through the materials and record the issue appears to be decided is that as to
whether the order of conviction was passed by the special court was right or
not . The foundation of the prosecution case rests upon a complaint dated
November 22, 1990 by the DEOIII, Surojit N. Biswas to the Officer-Charge
Dankuni Police Station. It was alleged by the concern Officer that on receipt of
secret information he along with S.IN.K Shikhdar W/C107 Vishwanath Dutta,
both of DEB, visited M/S Chaurasia service station located at par – Dankuni
under the direct supervision of deputy SP. DEB Hooghly.. On inspection the
pump, they found one wooden board with writing no oil available display in
front office room of the said petrol pump. During inspection, they checked
Stock cum Rate Board, Stock, cum Sale Register, Cash Memo Book, etc. in
respect of dealing with H.S.D oil and found opening stock on November 23,
1990 as 3447 L, but on physical verification of the underground tank of the
said petrol pump found shortage of 279 L oil. They also found one barrel
containing hundred litres of H.S.D oil kept on the northern side of the petrol
pump clandestinely. They took the sample in two containers from the same
barrel and sealed both the sample containers in presence of the witnesses. The
tank was inspected in presence of the accused and witness, namely Jawaharlal
Ghosh and Utpal Ghosh and W/c 107, Bishwanath Dutta. They also found
that 750 L of said oil were sold on that day to various customers against seven
cash memos. They also seized the above articles and the articles were duly
labelled and one copy of the S.L was handed over to the accused person. It was
also mentioned in the complaint that the appellant disclosed himself as main
partner of the said service station and reported that another partner is
Surendra Prasad Chaurasia. The licensed dealer /appellant could not produce
any license in support of dealing of H.S oil and took the plea that that the
licence has been lying in DM 8s office for renewal but could not show any
receipt in support of his statement .
6. From the evidence of Surojit Narayan Biswas,the admission of that opening
stock shown in the stock register and the stock cum rate board was found in
consonance. The witness was not aware that the underground tank of the
service station had a sloping. He had no knowledge about the measurement
and diameter of the underground tank in question and admitted that no
measurement chart of the oil in the underground tank of the service station in
question was made. He could not say about the measurement of the oil kept in
the underground tank with reference to evaporation, handling loss linkage etc.
he also admitted that the writing on the board displayed outside the service
station and noted by him was permanently written and the said board is
removable. P.W.2 Vishwanath Dutta, who was attached to D.E.B, Chinavada
on November 22, 1990, accompanied Inspector Surajit Biswas at the service
Station. According to this witness with the help of a stick given by the accused
Anil, the oil in the underground tank of the service station was measured and
found 3447 L of diesel and 2138 L respectively. They arrested Anil Mishra and
they arrested the appellant while proceeding to Thana. This witness was
declared hostile.
7. P.W.3 Jawaharlal Ghosh the year 1990 in one evening when he went to service
station to bring oil, he noticed the police at the state station He could not
collect the exact quantity of diesel he purchased from the service station on
that day. He signed on a paper as per asking by the police on the plea that
they came there for the purpose of checking. This witness identified his
signature on the seizure list but did not notice whether any checking was done
by the police. Not any recovery of the said service station. He could not identify
any person on the dock. This witness was declared hostile.
8. P.W.4, Jung Bahadur Shukla, an employee of Chaurasia Service Station. He
and Anil Mishra was present when Police went to their Service Station. He
deposed that a board with writing <not available= kept over in Almirah was
taken into custody by the police. He could not say the quantity of oil found out
by the police during checking of the underground tank with deep rod. They
also noticed ¾ litres of oil kept at the station, which was taken by Daroga
Babu. He accepted the zimma of all those articles by signing on the
zimmanama. He deposed also in his cross-examination that the correct
calculation of oil in the underground tank can be made if two sides of the said
underground tank was measured with deep rod as the underground tank to
some extent had sloping. The measurement of the oil in the underground tank
was not done by the Daroga Babu and his men of the service station properly.
9. P.W.5 Mr. Shah depose that on receipt of the sample taken in connection with
Dankuni P.S case no. 102 of November 22, 1990, he submitted a report after
examination through scientific process. He proved his report. His cross
examination was declined. P.W.6 N.K Shikdar during his evidence could not
recollect the particulars of the stock noted in the stock registered and stock
and rate board. He could recollect on verification of the physical stock of diesel
kept on the underground tanks with reference to the stock of diesel noted in
the relevant register and rate board and found shortage of 270 L of diesel. He
could not say the quantity of oil found from the other tank at the time of
adducing evidence. He denied that there was no shortage.
10. P.W.7 Debobroto Das the I.O. of the case. He submitted the charge-sheet on
completion of the investigation against the appellant and Anil Kumar Mishra.
He admitted that Witness Jawaharlal Ghosh stated to him that outside the
office room of the pump a board with writing the oil is not available in English
and in Hindi was hung and he requested Anil Mishra to sell at least 20 L of
diesel to him. Otherwise he there would be damage to his cultivation. Anil did
not sell diesel to him by saying oil was not available and by the time officer
from D.T.B office came to the petrol pump for the purpose of checking the
stock. From the above evidence, it is seen that accepting P.W.1, all other
witnesses become hostile, who was said to be present at the spot along with
P.W.1. Constable who accompanied the P.W.1 was also declared hostile since
he stated that Anil Kumar Mishra was arrested first and on the way to proceed
towards Thana, the present appellant was arrested. That apart, he also said
that with a stick, the measurement was taken in respect of the storage of
underground tank of the service station on the basis of which the shortage of
297 L of diesel oil was detected. The P.W.1 admitted that the opening stock
shown in the stock register and the stock cum rate board was found in
consonance.
11. In this case the appellant at the time of examination under Section 313
specifically stated that he was not present at the pump and the measurement
was not done in the proper way. He denied the allegations level against him.
The learned Special Court passed the order of acquittal in favour of accused,
Anil Kumar Mishra, who was an employee of Chaurasia Service Station. The
question arises as to whether the accused person can be indicated for nondisplay of stock and price list as required under para 3 (2) of W.B. Declaration
of stocks and prices of E.C order, 1977. The fact of selling of 750 L of H.S.DL2
different customers under cash memos were not controverted, and there was
nothing contrary proved and also therefore, the sale of such quantity was
affected from the service station on that day was also proved. Jawaharlal
Ghosh P.W.3 before he was declared hostile stated that he got oil from the
service station on payment of price on the said date. He denied to have stated
to the I.O. that outside the office room, he found the boat written as oil not
available. The other employee, Jung Bahadur Shukla PW 4 deposed that police
took the board which was kept over an Almira and was taken into custody
where it was written that oil is not available. It has also come that they had the
board in their office which was to be used when required. This P.W.4 was not
declared as hostile. That apart the other factor to be considered is the manner
of measurement of the tank which had a slop, admitted by all the witnesses. It
is also found that the measurement was taken only on the basis of a deep rod
and not with the assistance of any other measurement tools. The P.W.1 had no
knowledge about the sloping of the underground tank and neither the
measurement were taken from both sides of the same tank in order to assesses
the actual quantity. That P.W.1 had no knowledge about the measurement and
diameter of the underground tank in question and no measurement chart of
the oil in the underground tank of the service station in question was made.
Therefore, the quantity that was decided was not on the basis of a robust
scientific mechanism, but mostly on primary measurement made with a stick.
12. The complaint itself manifest that regarding non-production of the license in
respect of the dealing with H.S.D oil, it was specifically stated that the license
was lying in D.M9s office but
no receipt in support office statement was
recorded. The I.O. only on the averment of the present appellant did not
proceed against the other partner when admittedly, it was a partnership
business. In terms of the W.B. Declaration of stocks and prices of essential
commodities order, 1977, Section 3 (1) provides that every producer and
importer shall display conspicuously at a place near to the entrance of his
place of business as possible at least inform a indicating the opening stock of
each essential commodity held by him on each day. 3(2) read as 8every
wholesaler, and every retailer shall display conspicuously at a place as near to
the entrance of his place of business as possible, a list in Form B indicating the
opening stock and the wholesale or retail price as the case maybe of each
essential commodity held by him on each day.’
13. The fact of not displaying the stock and price Board of the service station
showing opening balance of oil as well as its sale price on the relevant day
itself, remain doubtful in absence of any corroborative evidence with regard to
the prosecution case. The learned Special Court relied upon the evidence of
P.W.1 and 6 for passing an order of conviction and the actual measurement of
the oil found from the underground tanks, which has been challenged by the
defence counsel was not considered as the zimma holder, did not demur the
receipt of the quantity of oil mentioned in the document.
Conclusion
14.
On close scrutiny of all of the evidence of the witnesses and specially P.W.1,
it is evident that, they found a board displayed outside the service station
where it was mentioned that oil is not available but at the board was
removable and it is doubtful whether at all at that time the Board was there or
not.
15. In terms of criminal jurisprudence the order of conviction can only be
passed after the Court is satisfied that the prosecution has proved the case
beyond the shadow of all reasonable doubts. Where the police accompanying
the raid turned hostile, the foundation of the complaint remains doubtful and
the officers measuring the excess quantity having no knowledge of the slopping
of the underground tanks, create a doubt over the correct measurement of the
quantity itself .Further the stock cum rate Board was found at the service
station and seized, primarily do not established that the prosecutions proved
the case beyond doubt that there was violation .
16. Hence this criminal appeal stands allowed.
17. The Judgement and order of conviction passed by the learned Special court
is hereby set aside.
18. This court records appreciation for the able assistance rendered by the
learned Amicus Curiae in disposing of this appeal.
19. No order as to costs.
20. Urgent certified copy if applied by any of the parties to be supplied subject
to observance of all formalities.
(CHAITALI CHATTERJEE DAS, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review