The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
16. In view of the aforesaid discussion, this Court is of the considered view that the impugned order passed by the Hon’ble Minister cannot be sustained. The petition, therefore, deserves to be allowed and is allowed accordingly in the following terms : (i) Order dated 04.09.2019 passed by the Hon’ble Minister in Consolidation Case Rev. No.3319/1935/pk.36/j-6 (Ramdas Bala Chavan Vs. State of Maharashtra and Others), is quashed and set aside. (ii) Orders dated Superintendent of
30. 07.2016 Land passed Records in by Appeal the District Application Land Records in Appeal SR No/654/2016/Ahmednagar, are restored and confirmed.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:BHC-AUG:47507
IN THE JUDICATURE OF HIGH COURT AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
909 WRIT PETITION NO. 13871 OF 2019
Bhikubai Kondiba Gadhwe (Gaikwad)
Since deceased Through her Legal Heirs
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
Sukhdeo s/o Kondiba Gadhwe (Gaikwad),
sambhaji s/o Kondiba Gadhwe (Gaikwad),
Tanhaji s/o Kondiba Gadhwe (Gaikwad),
Surekha w/o Gangadhar Dive,
Smt. Suman w/o Bhaskar Kate
...Petitioners
VERSUS
1.
The Hon’ble Minister (Revenue,
Maharashtra State, Mantralaya, Mumbai.
2.
The State of Maharashtra, Through
Secretary Revenue Dept. Mantralaya,
3.
The Deputy Director of Land Record, Nashik,
4.
The District Superintendent of Land Record,
Ahmednagar,
5.
The Deputy Superintendent of Land Record,
Parner,
6.
Ramdas s/o Bala Chavan,
7.
Ramesh s/o Ramdas Chavan,
8.
Dwarkabai Laxman Thorat,
9.
Harubai Baban Gat,
10. Gajrabai @ Laxmibai Bhau Chavan,
11. Dada s/o Aba Gadhve (Died Through L.Rs.)
11A. Surekha wd/o Dada Saheb Gadve,
11B. Navnath s/o Dada Saheb Gadve,
11C. Jayshree w/o Sandip Dhamne,
11D. Suvarna w/o Sunil Narsing,
11E. Swati w/o Changdeo Bhor,
11F. Jyoti w/o Ramchandra Gunjal.
12. Gorakh s/o Aba Gadhve,
13. Machindra s/o Aba Gadhve,
14. Padmabai w/o Subhash Gavli.
...Respondents
...
Advocate for the Petitioner : Mr.Mahesh Ghatge h/f Mr. Taur Mahesh S.
AGP for Respondents No.1 to 5 - State: Mr. S. G. Joshi
Advocate for Respondent No.7 : Mr. Jadhavar Santosh Sampatrao
Advocate for Respondents No.6 to 10 : Mr. D. B. Shinde
…
CORAM : ROHIT W. JOSHI, J.
Dated
: October 08, 2026
909 WP 13871-2019
ORAL JUDGMENT :
1.
Rule. Rule is made returnable forthwith. With the consent of
the learned Advocates for the parties, the matter is taken up for final
disposal.
2.
The petitioners take exception to the order dated 04.09.2019
passed by the Hon’ble Minister Revenue in Consolidation Case Rev.
No.3319/1935/pk.36/j-6
(Ramdas
Bala
Chavan
Vs.
State
of
Maharashtra and Others).
3.
At the outset, it is necessary to clarify that though the
impugned order, refers to the revisional jurisdiction under Section
257 of the Maharashtra Land Revenue Code, 1966, the revision was,
in fact, required to be considered under Section 35 of the
Maharashtra Prevention of Fragmentation and Consolidation of
Holdings Act, 1947 (for short, “the said Act”).
4.
The
ancestors
of
the
petitioners
and
the
contesting
respondents had jointly purchased lands bearing Survey Nos. 113,
114, 115 and 116, situated at Village Rajangaoon Masjit,
Tahsil
Parner, District Ahmednagar, having total area of around 87 acres.
5.
It is not in dispute that the predecessors of the petitioners and
909 WP 13871-2019
the predecessors of the contesting respondents had equal shares in
the aforesaid lands, each share admeasuring 43 acres and 20
gunthas in the said land purchased in the year 1935. It is also not in
dispute that the predecessor of the contesting respondents, namely,
Bala Chavan, sold land admeasuring 30 acres and 39 gunthas out of
Survey Nos. 114, 115 and 116 to late Abasaheb Namdeo Gadve,
predecessor of the petitioners, by a registered sale deed dated
12.11.1965. After the sale deed dated 12.11.1965, 12 acres and 30
gunthas of land remained with the contesting respondents. In the
year 1974, the consolidation scheme was implemented in Village
Rajangaon Masjid, whereby the aforesaid Survey Nos. 113, 114, 115
and 116 were converted into Gut Nos. 346, 347, 349 and 351,
respectively.
6.
After implementation of the consolidation scheme, respondent
No.6 filed an application seeking correction of the area of land
bearing Gut No.350 and prayed for recording land admeasuring 7
acres and 20 gunthas in his name. Pursuant to the said application,
the District Superintendent of Land Records called for a report from
the Deputy Superintendent of Land Records. The report came to be
submitted on 28.08.2013. According to the said report, area
admeasuring 43 acres and 20 gunthas had fallen to the share of the
predecessors of respondent Nos. 6 and 7. It is stated that out of that
43 acres and 20 gunthas, land admeasuring 30 acres and 39 gunthas
909 WP 13871-2019
was sold by the predecessor of respondent Nos. 6 and 7 to the
predecessor
of
the
petitioners.
The
report
of
the
Deputy
Superintendent of Land Records makes a reference to a subsequent
sale deed executed by respondent No.6 on 19.05.1985. There is also
a reference to Mutation Entry Nos.1117, 1118 and 1588 in the said
report. The said mutation entries pertain to sale of 1.84 HR (1 acre
40 gunthas) of land by respondent No. 6 from land bearing Gut
No.349, sale deed of 1 H (2 acres 38.84 gunthas) of land from the
said Gut No.349 and sale deed of 1 H (2 acres 38.84 gunthas) of land
from Gut No.351, respectively. The report further records that
respondent No.6, the original applicant, had admitted before the
Deputy Superintendent of Land Records that, after execution of the
aforesaid sale deeds, he was not in possession of any portion of the
aforesaid lands. The report also records that the relevant revenue
entries in the names of respondent Nos. 6 and 7 or their
predecessors were not found in the revenue records and that they
were not in possession of the same.
7.
The
application
was
initially
rejected
by
the
District
Superintendent of Land Records by order dated 17.09.2014. The
application was rejected merely on the ground of delay, without
dealing with the merits of the contentions raised by respondent No.6.
8.
Aggrieved by the said order, respondent No. 6 preferred an
909 WP 13871-2019
appeal before the Deputy Director of Land Records, being Appeal
No.Consolidation/SR-374/2014/Ahmednagar.
The said appeal came
to be partly allowed by order dated 21.09.2015, whereby the District
Superintendent of Land Records was directed to decide the
application on its merits.
9.
The District Superintendent of Land Records rejected the
application by order dated 30.07.2016. The appeal preferred against
the
said
order,
being
Consolidation
Appeal
No.
SR-654/2016/Ahmednagar, came to be dismissed by the Deputy
Director of Land Records by order dated 27.12.2018. These orders
passed by the District Superintendent of Land Records and the
Deputy Director of Land Records were assailed before the Hon’ble
Minister Revenue in the revision, which came to be allowed vide
impugned order dated 04.09.2019.
10.
It is not in dispute that the predecessors of the petitioners and
respondent Nos. 6 and 7 had received 43 acres and 20 gunthas of
land each from the total 87 acres of land purchased by them. The
sale of land admeasuring 30 acres and 39 gunthas, as aforesaid, is
also
not
disputed.
The
report
submitted
by
the
Deputy
Superintendent of Land Records further indicates sale of 4 acres and
55 gunthas of land on 19.05.1985 (Mutation Entry No. 1117), sale of
land admeasuring 2 acres and 48 gunthas on 19.05.1985 (Mutation
909 WP 13871-2019
Entry No. 1118), and a further sale of 2 acres and 48 gunthas of land
in the year 1990 (Mutation Entry No. 1588). It is contended by the
learned Advocate for the petitioners that apart from this, another
sale deed with respect to 3 acres and 1 guntha of land was executed
in the year 2006 (Mutation Entry No. 3041).
11.
Perusal of the orders passed by the District Superintendent of
Land Records and the Deputy Director of Land Records will indicate
that the application is rejected treating the total area of respondents
No. 6 and 7 as 43 acres and 20 gunthas. The foundation of the order
passed by the Hon’ble Minister is that respondent Nos. 6 and 7 were
entitled to land admeasuring 52 acres and 13 gunthas. In the
application filed by respondent No. 6 as well, he claims land to the
extent of 52 acres and 13 gunthas.
12.
As recorded above, admittedly, the predecessors of the
petitioners and respondent Nos. 6 and 7 had jointly purchased 87
acres of land and had partitioned the same in equal half, each
getting 43 acres and 20 gunthas. In these circumstances, the claim
for land admeasuring 52 acres and 13 gunthas is completely
untenable. 43 acres 20 gunthas land fallen to the shares of
predecessors of respondents No.6 and 7 is already sold by them as
will
be
apparent
from
the
report
prepared
by
the
Superintendent of Land Records and Mutation Entry No.3041.
Deputy
909 WP 13871-2019
13.
The Hon’ble Minister has not considered the report furnished
by the Deputy Superintendent of Land Records at all. The finding of
entitlement of respondents No. 6 and 7 to 52 acres and 13 gunthas
of land is completely perverse in the sense that it is not based on
any material on record. It must also be stated that the Hon’ble
Minister was exercising revisional jurisdiction. The scope of such
jurisdiction is to examine the legality or propriety of the orders
passed by the subordinate authorities. The impugned order does not
record any reasons as to why the concurrent findings recorded by
the District Superintendent of Land Records and the Deputy Director
of Land Records warranted interference. The reasons recorded by the
subordinate authorities have not been dealt with by the Hon’ble
Minister. The Hon’ble Minister has not only erred in appreciating the
material on record but has also exceeded the limits of revisional
jurisdiction by interfering with the orders passed by the subordinate
authorities without demonstrating how the said orders were illegal or
improper.
14.
Apart from the merits of the matter, this Court is of the view
that there is no plausible explanation for approaching the authorities
for correction of area after an inordinate delay of approximately 39
years. Having regard to the nature of the claim and the absence of a
satisfactory explanation for such delay, the application ought to have
been rejected on that ground as well.
909 WP 13871-2019
15.
It is also significant that respondent No.6 did not disclose
before the authorities the execution of the registered sale deeds in
respect of the lands in question. This circumstance assumes
relevance while considering the claim made by respondent No. 6 and
the correctness of the order passed by the Hon’ble Minister.
16.
In view of the aforesaid discussion, this Court is of the
considered view that the impugned order passed by the Hon’ble
Minister cannot be sustained. The petition, therefore, deserves to be
allowed and is allowed accordingly in the following terms : (i)
Order dated 04.09.2019 passed by the Hon’ble Minister
in Consolidation Case Rev. No.3319/1935/pk.36/j-6 (Ramdas
Bala Chavan Vs. State of Maharashtra and Others), is quashed
and set aside.
(ii)
Orders
dated
Superintendent
of
30.07.2016
Land
passed
Records
in
by
Appeal
the
District
Application
No.601/2015 and 27.12.2018 passed by the Deputy Director of
Land Records in Appeal SR No/654/2016/Ahmednagar, are
restored and confirmed.
17.
Rule is made absolute in the aforesaid terms.
( ROHIT W. JOSHI, J. )
vj gawade/-.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review