Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
RVWPET No.311 of 2024
(An application under Section 114 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1976)
*****
Bhawani Shankar Choudhury
Petitioner
…
-versus1. State of Odisha, represented through the
Principal Secretary, Revenue and Disaster
Management Department, At-Lokseva Bhawan,
Bhubaneswar, Dist: Khordha.
2.
Rehabilitation
and
Periphery
Development
Advisory
Committee
(RPDAC), being represented through its
Chairman, Revenue Divisional Commissioner
(North Division), Sambalpur, Town/Dist,
Sambalpur
3. Collector,
Sundargarh, At/Po/Dist-
Sundargarh,
4. The Land Acquisition Officer-cumTahasildar, Hemgir, At/PO/PS- Hemgir,
Dist-Sundargarh.
5. Odisha Coal and Power Corporation
Ltd., represented through its Chief Executive
Officer, At: Fortune Tower, Bhubaneswar753023, Dist- Khordha
…
Opp. Parties
Advocates appeared :
For Petitioner
: Mr. Jagatjit Panda, Advocate
For Opposite Parties : Mr. Manmaya Kumar Dash,
Additional Standing Counsel
CORAM:
JUSTICE K.R. MOHAPATRA
JUSTICE V. NARASINGH
---------------------------------------------------Heard and disposed of on 08.05.2026
--------------------------------------------Page 1 of 9
RVWPET No.311 of 2024
JUDGMENT
By the Bench;
1.
This matter is taken up through hybrid mode.
2.
Petitioner in this RVWPET seeks for review of order dated
26th July, 2024 passed by the Coordinate Bench in W.P.(C) No.9455
of 2024 (of which one of us, Mr. V. Narasingh, J. was a member).
3.
Vide order dated 26th July, 2024, the writ Court dismissed
the Writ Petition.
4.
Mr. Panda, learned counsel for the Review Petitioner
submits that the Writ Petition was filed seeking a direction to set
aside order dated 25th January, 2024 passed by the Revenue
Divisional Commissioner (Northern Division), Sambalpur-Opposite
Party No.2 (for brevity ‘the Revenue Divisional Commissioner’)
thereby refusing to extend the Rehabilitation and Resettlement
benefit to the Petitioner in terms of Orissa Resettlement and
Rehabilitation Policy, 2006 (for brevity, ‘R&R Policy, 2006’). It is
submitted that the Petitioner is a member of displaced family of
village Manoharpur, whose land was acquired under the Coal
Bearing Areas (Acquisition and Development) Act, 1957.
4.1.
The Petitioner received compensation for acquisition of his
land in Village Manoharpur. But, no benefit under the R & R
Policy, 2006 was extended to him. Hence, the Petitioner initially
moved this Court in W.P.(C) No.4890 of 2017, which was
dismissed as withdrawn on 11th July, 2017. Thereafter, the Petitioner
filed W.P.(C) No.16830 of 2017, which was disposed of on 23rd
August, 2017. Subsequently, the Petitioner filed W.P.(C) No.8052
RVWPET No.311 of 2024
of 2018, which was disposed of on 26th April, 2023 with a direction
to consider the case of the Petitioner by the Revenue Divisional
Commissioner in terms of order dated 6th November, 2019 passed in
W.P.(C) No.29 of 2017. Accordingly, the Revenue Divisional
Commissioner on consideration of the grievance of the Petitioner,
rejected his prayer to extend the benefit under the R&R Policy, 2006
which was assailed in W.P.(C) No.9455 of 2024. And was
dismissed by order dated 26th July, 2024, which is sought to be
reviewed in this RVWPET.
5.
Mr. Panda, learned counsel further submits that the Revenue
Divisional Commissioner while considering the case of the
Petitioner did not take into account the Voter Card, Aadhaar Card
and the Resident Certificate (Annexures-4 to 6 respectively to the
review petition) and held that the Petitioner was a permanent
resident of village-Tumbapali.
5.1.
This Court, in the order sought to be reviewed, also
committed error in affirming the same, which is apparent on the face
of the record. Had these documents been taken into consideration by
this Court, then the outcome of the Writ Petition would have been
different.
5.2.
By not considering the relevant documents indicating that
the Petitioner has lost his residential house in the acquired villageManoharpur, the Petitioner was deprived of getting the benefit under
R & R Policy, 2006.
5.3.
Hence, he prays for review of the said order.
6.
Mr. Dash, learned Additional Standing Counsel, on the other
hand, submits that Annexures-4 to 6 were neither produced before
RVWPET No.311 of 2024
the Revenue Divisional Commissioner nor before this Court during
adjudication. Hence, there is no error what to speak of ‘apparent
error’ on the face of the record, as alleged by Mr. Panda, learned
counsel for the Review Petitioner. It is his submission that
scrutinizing the facts and circumstances of the case and the
documents available, the Revenue Divisional Commissioner passed
a reasoned order, which was rightly confirmed by this Court in the
order sought to be reviewed. He, further, submits that the Petitioner
essentially seeks for a fresh adjudication of his case on merit on
some additional documents, which were never produced before the
Authority/Court, though available with him in guise of RVWPET
which is not permissible. Hence, the Petitioner does not make out
any case for review of the order passed in the W.P.(C) No.9455 of
2024 and prays for dismissal of the Review Petition with cost.
7.
Heard learned counsel for the parties. Perused the materials
on record.
7.1.
In course of hearing of the Review Petition, this Court vide
order dated 10th April, 2026, directed Mr. Panda, learned counsel for
the Petitioner to apprise the Court as to whether the documents at
Annexures-4 to 6, i.e., Voter Card, Aadhaar Card as well as
Resident Certificate respectively were produced before the Revenue
Divisional Commissioner or not.
7.2.
Mr. Panda, learned counsel fairly submits that those
documents were neither produced before the Revenue Divisional
Commissioner nor before this Court at the time of adjudication.
7.3.
He, however, places reliance on a case law Kamlesh Verma
Vs. Mayawati and others; (2013) 8 SCC 320 to fortify his
RVWPET No.311 of 2024
submissions. He verily relied upon Paragraph-20.1 of the said case
law, which is reproduced hereunder:
“20. Thus, in view of the above, the following
grounds of review are maintainable as stipulated by
the statute:
20.1 When the review will be maintainable:
(i) Discovery of new and important matter or
evidence which, after the exercise of due diligence,
was not within knowledge of the petitioner or could
not be produced by him;
(ii) Mistake or error apparent on the face of the
record;
(iii) Any other sufficient reason.
The word “any other sufficient reason” have
been interpreted in Chhajju Ram V. Neki and
approved by this Court in Moran Mar Basselios
Catholicos v. Most Rev. Mar Poulose Athanasius to
mean “a reason sufficient on grounds at least
analogous to those specified in the rule”. The same
principles have bene reiterated in Union of India v.
Sandur Manganese & Iron Ores Ltd.”
8.
From the submissions made by Mr. Panda, learned counsel,
it is apparent that his case solely rests upon Annexures-4 to 6, which
were neither produced before the Revenue Divisional Commissioner
nor before this Court.
8.1.
Paragraph 20.1 (i) of the Judgment quoted above in the case
of Kamlesh Verma (supra) makes it clear that a Review would be
maintainable when discovery of new facts and important matter or
evidence which, after the exercise of due diligence, was not within
the knowledge of the Petitioner or could not be produced by him.
8.2.
The Petitioner miserably failed to make out any case as to
whether in exercise of due diligence, he could not have produced
RVWPET No.311 of 2024
those
documents
either
before
the
Revenue
Divisional
Commissioner or before this Court.
8.3.
It is also not the case of the Petitioner that documents under
Annexures- 4 to 6 were not available with him at the time of
adjudication of his grievance by the Revenue Divisional
commissioner and this Court.
8.4.
Further Paragraph-20.2 of the said case law in Kamlesh
Verma (supra) reads as under:“20.2 When the review will not be maintainable:
(i) A repetition of old and overruled argument is not
enough to reopen concluded adjudications.
(ii) Minor mistakes of inconsequential import.
(iii) Review proceedings cannot be equated with the
original hearing of the case.
(iv) Review is not maintainable unless the material
error, manifest on the face of the order, undermines
its soundness or results in miscarriage of justice.
(v) A review is by no means an appeal in disguise
whereby an erroneous decision is reheard and
corrected but lies only for patent error.
(vi) The mere possibility of two views on the subject
cannot be a ground for review.
(vii) The error apparent on the face of the record
should not be an error which has to be fished out and
searched.
(viii) The appreciation of evidence on record is fully
within the domain of the appellate court, it cannot be
permitted to be advanced in the review petition.
(ix) Review is not maintainable when the same relief
sought at the time of arguing the main matter had
been negatived.”
(Emphasis supplied)
8.5.
The Petitioner has taken the following grounds in the
Review Petition to maintain the same;
“A) For that though the counsel of the petitioner had
not submitted some relevant documents like Aadhaar
RVWPET No.311 of 2024
card of the petitioner, Voter Identity card of the
petitioner and residence certificate of the petitioner at
the time of filing the above writ petition.
B) For that this Hon'ble Court without awaiting the
counter of the Opp. Parties only on the basis of
rejection order passed by the R.D.C. Sambalpur
rejected the claim of the petitioner for compensation
under 2006 R.R. Policy.
C) For that admittedly the petitioner was residing
since 2003 in Manoharpur Mouza. For that he had
only filed the report of I.R, statement of villagers and
statement of local Sarpanch but the learned Court has
not considered the documents filed by the petitioner
and rejected the writ petition is illegal.
D) For that the voter identity card, aadhaar card and
residence certificate of the petitioner were available
in favour of petitioner. Except some undivided landed
property the petitioner has no relation in the village
Tumbapalli and the learned Tahasildar has not
produced any documents in the name of petitioner in
Tumbapalli village. But this Hon'ble Court has
rejected the prayer of the petitioner.
E) For that the petitioner is entitled to receive the
compensation as per 2006 R.R. Policy. The petitioner
has submitted (sic) all the documents before the
R.D.C Sambalpur at the time of hearing of the
petitioner. But the learned R.D.C rejected the prayer
of the petitioner on the ground that the Petitioner is a
resident of village Tumbapalli. The petitioner has
nothing in village except some undivided agricultural
land of his ancestors. The rejection of prayer by the
learned R.D.C as well as this Hon’ble Court is illegal
against the documents available in the case record.
F) For that the petitioner has lost his residential
house as well as homestead land of Manoharpur
mouza. But at the time of filing the writ petition the
earlier advocate for the Petitioner has not annexed
the relevant documents of the Petitioner like Voter
Identity Card, Aadhaar Card, Residence Certificate of
Petitioner issued by Tahasildar, Hemgir and
Residential Survey report submitted by Joint Enquiry
RVWPET No.311 of 2024
Committee. This Hon'ble Court without (sic) awaiting
the counter of the Opp. Parties at the time of
admission dismissed the petition on the basis of
rejection order passed by the R.D.C. Sambalpur.
G) For that the petitioner has(sic) fulfilled all the
criteria to receive compensation under 2006 R.R.
Policy but this Hon'ble Court rejected the petition of
the petitioner is illegal and harass to the Petitioner.
H) For that the Petitioner has no money and man
power to approach before Hon'ble Apex Court to get
justice. Therefore he approaches before this Hon'ble
Court for review the earlier order passed on
26.07.2024 in W.P.(C) No.9455 of 2024.”
8.6.
In the considered view of this Court, on a perspicuous
analysis and the materials on record, the case of the Petitioner
squarely falls under Clauses-(iii) and (iv) of paragraph- 20.2 of
Kamlesh Verma (supra).
8.7.
When the documents under Annexures-4 to 6 were not
produced either before the Revenue Divisional Commissioner or
before this Court, question of not considering the same does not
arise at all. As such, there is no error apparent on the face of the
record as alleged by Mr. Panda, learned counsel for the Petitioner.
8.8.
And on a plain reading of the grounds as urged in this
RVWPET, it is manifestly clear that none of the grounds, mentioned
above, makes out a case for review of the order dated 26th July, 2024
passed by this Court in W.P.(C) No.9455 of 2024.
RVWPET No.311 of 2024
9.
Hence, the Review Petition merits no consideration and
stands dismissed accordingly. In the facts and circumstances of the
case, there shall be no order as to costs.
(K.R. Mohapatra)
Judge
(V. Narasingh)
Judge
The High Court of Orissa, Cuttack
Dated the 8th day of May, 2026/ sashikant
Digitally Signed
Signed by: SASHIKANT PARIDA
Reason: Authentication
Location: OHC
RVWPET No.311 of 2024
Date: 14-May-2026 16:21:25
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review