Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:24588
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT RAWAL
&
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE K. V. JAYAKUMAR
THURSDAY, THE 20TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 29TH PHALGUNA, 1946
OP (CAT) NO. 134 OF 2019
AGAINST THE ORDER DATED 20.02.2019 IN OA NO.415 OF 2018 OF
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL, ERNAKULAM BENCH
PETITIONERS/RESPONDENTS:
THE CHIEF GENERAL MANAGER,
TELECOM, BHARAT SANCHAR NIGAM LIMITED, KERALA CIRCLE,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM- 695033.
THE GENERAL MANAGER TELECOM,
BHARAT SANCHAR NIGAM LIMITED, ALAPPUZHA- 688011.
THE ASSISTANT GENERAL MANGER (ADMN),
BHARAT SANCHAR NIGAM LIMITED, ALAPPUZHA- 688011.
THE ACCOUNTS OFFICER (PC),
BHARAT SANCHAR NIGAM LIMITED, ALAPPUZHA- 688011.
BY ADV RAJIT
RESPONDENT/APPLICANT
CHANDRASEKHARAN PILLAI R., AGED 59 YEARS, S/O.RAGHAVAPANIKER,
TELECOM TECHNICIAN, TELEPHONE EXCHANGE, BSNL NOORANAD P.O.,
ALAPPUZHA, RESIDING AT VILAYIL VEEDU, R.C.VILLA, THATHAMUNNA,
NOORANAD P.O., ALAPPUZHA DISTRICT- 690504.
BY ADVS.
SRI.T.C.GOVINDA SWAMY
SMT.KALA T.GOPI
SRI.R.S.SARAT
THIS OP (CAT) HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 20.03.2025, ALONG WITH OP
(CAT).150/2020, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
OP(CAT) Nos.134/2019 and 150/2020
2025:KER:24588
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT RAWAL
&
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE K. V. JAYAKUMAR
THURSDAY, THE 20TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 29TH PHALGUNA, 1946
OP (CAT) NO. 150 OF 2020
AGAINST THE ORDER DATED IN OA NO.961 OF 2018 OF CENTRAL
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL, ERNAKULAM BENCH
PETITIONERS (RESPONDENTS 2 TO 5):
BHARAT SANCHAR NIGAM LIMITED
REPRESENTED BY ITS CHAIRMAN -CUM - MANAGING DIRECTOR,
CORPORATE OFFICE, BHARAT SANCHAR BHAVAN, HARISH CHANDRA
MATHUR LANE, JANPATH, NEW DELHI - 110 001.
THE CHIEF GENERAL MANAGER
BHARAT SANCHAR NIGAM LIMITED, KERALA CIRCLE,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, KERALA.
THE GENRAL MANAGER
B.S.N.L., SANCHAR BHAVAN, PALAKKAD - 678 014.
THE DEPUTY GENERAL MANAGER
B.S.N.L., SANCHAR BHAVAN, PALAKKAD - 678 014.
BY ADV T.C.KRISHNA
RESPONDENT/APPLICANT:
AMBIKA K.K., W/O. LATE RAJAGOPALAN O.,
RESIDING AT ODUPARA HOUSE, KUTTAMASSERY P. O.,
THIRUVAZHITYODE VIA, PALAKKAD, KERALA - 679 514.
BY ADVS.
SMT.REKHA VASUDEVAN
SMT.M.N.UMARANI
THIS OP (CAT) HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 20.03.2025, ALONG WITH OP
(CAT).134/2019, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
OP(CAT) Nos.134/2019 and 150/2020
2025:KER:24588
COMMON JUDGMENT
K. V. JAYAKUMAR, J
This
judgment
shall
dispose
of
two
OP(CAT)s.
OP(CAT) No.134/2019 is preferred by the Bharath Sanchar Nigam Limited
(BSNL) impugning the order of the Central Administrative Tribunal in
O.A.No.415/2018 dated 20.02.2019 and OP(CAT) No.150/2020 is
preferred impugning the order in O.A.No.961/2018 dated 03.01.2020,
whereby
the
claim
of
the
respondents/applicants
for
medical
reimbursement was allowed.
2.
The facts in narrow compass are as follows:
The respondent in OP(CAT) No.134/2019 retired from the BSNL
as a Telecom Technician. The respondent/applicant was treated at Amrita
Institute of Medical Sciences and Research Hospital, Ernakulam and when
he made a claim for medical reimbursement, that was rejected by the
petitioners holding that, though Amrita Institute is an empanelled hospital
of the petitioners’ organization, there is no provision under BSNL Medical
Reimbursement Scheme for full reimbursement.
OP(CAT) Nos.134/2019 and 150/2020
2025:KER:24588
3.
The respondent in OP(CAT) No.150/2020 is aggrieved
by the denial of medical reimbursement for the treatment undergone by
her husband, late O.Rajagopalan, an employee of the Bharat Sanchar
Nigam Limited.
4.
The stand of the petitioner, BSNL, is that the
employees of BSNL are entitled to reimbursement of medical benefits at
the rate prescribed under the Central Government Health Scheme (CGHS).
5.
The Tribunal noticing the rival contentions of the
counsel for the parties, placing reliance on the decisions reported in Shiva
Kant Jha Vs. Union of India (2018 KHC 6285), Kirloskar Bros.
Ltd. Vs. ESI Corpn. [(1996) 2 SCC 682], Surjit Singh Vs. State of
Punjab (AIR 2006 SC 1388) and in Paschim Banga Khet Mazdoor
Samity Vs. State of W.B. [(1996) 4 SCC 37] allowed full
reimbursement to the claimant. Impugning the said order, the petitioners
preferred this O.P.(CAT).
6.
The short question involved in this case is whether the
reimbursement of a retired/serving Government employee or his family
members can be rejected on the ground that he was treated in a hospital
OP(CAT) Nos.134/2019 and 150/2020
2025:KER:24588
not approved by the State Government or on the ground that the claim is
above the limit prescribed under CGHS? In Shiva Kant Jha Vs. Union
of India (2018 KHC 6285) the Honourable Apex Court held that, the
right to medical claim cannot be denied merely because name of the
hospital is not included in the Government Order. It was observed that the
real test must be the factum of treatment supported by records duly
certified by Doctors/hospitals concerned. It was made clear that survival
of the person is the prime consideration, and the law does not require that
prior permission has to be taken in such situation.
Paragraph Nos.13, 14
and 15 of the Shiva Kant Jha’s case (supra) are extracted hereunder:
“13) It is a settled legal position that the
Government employee during his life time or after his
retirement is entitled to get the benefit of the medical
facilities and no fetters can be placed on his rights. It is
acceptable to common sense, that ultimate decision as to
how a patient should be treated vests only with the Doctor,
who is well versed and expert both on academic
qualification and experience gained. Very little scope is left
to the patient or his relative to decide as to the manner in
which the ailment should be treated. Speciality Hospitals
are established for treatment of specified ailments and
services of Doctors specialized in a discipline are availed by
patients only to ensure proper, required and safe treatment.
Can it be said that taking treatment in Speciality Hospital
by itself would deprive a person to claim reimbursement
solely on the ground that the said Hospital is not included
in the Government Order. The right to medical claim
cannot be denied merely because the name of the hospital is
not included in the Government Order. The real test must
be the factum of treatment. Before any medical claim is
OP(CAT) Nos.134/2019 and 150/2020
2025:KER:24588
honoured, the authorities are bound to ensure as to
whether the claimant had actually taken treatment and the
factum of treatment is supported by records duly certified
by Doctors/Hospitals concerned. Once, it is established, the
claim cannot be denied on technical grounds. Clearly, in the
present case, by taking a very inhuman approach, the
officials of the CGHS have denied the grant of medical
reimbursement in full to the petitioner forcing him to
approach this Court.
14) This is hardly a satisfactory state of affairs.
The relevant authorities are required to be more responsive
and cannot in a mechanical manner deprive an employee of
his legitimate reimbursement. The Central Government
Health Scheme (CGHS) was propounded with a purpose of
providing health facility scheme to the central government
employees so that they are not left without medical care
after retirement. It was in furtherance of the object of a
welfare State, which must provide for such medical care
that the scheme was brought in force. In the facts of the
present case, it cannot be denied that the writ petitioner
was admitted in the above said hospitals in emergency
conditions. Moreover, the law does not require that prior
permission has to be taken in such situation where the
survival of the person is the prime consideration. The
doctors did his operation and had implanted CRT-D device
and have done so as one essential and timely. Though it is
the claim of the respondent-State that the rates were
exorbitant whereas the rates charged for such facility shall
be only at the CGHS rates and that too after following a
proper procedure given in the Circulars issued on time to
time by the concerned Ministry, it also cannot be denied
that the petitioner was taken to hospital under emergency
conditions for survival of his life which requirement was
above the sanctions and treatment in empanelled hospitals.
15) In the present view of the matter, we are of
the considered opinion that the CGHS is responsible for
taking care of healthcare needs and well being of the central
government employees and pensioners. In the facts and
circumstances of the case, we are of opinion that the
OP(CAT) Nos.134/2019 and 150/2020
2025:KER:24588
treatment of the petitioner in non-empanelled hospital was
genuine because there was no option left with him at the
relevant time. We, therefore, direct the respondent-State to
pay the balance amount of Rs. 4,99,555/- to the writ
petitioner. We also make it clear that the said decision is
confined to this case only.”
7.
In Central Provident Fund Commissioner, New
Delhi and Others Vs. N.Satheesan and Another (2018(1) KHC
921), the Division Bench of this Court opined that, when the genuineness
of the bill submitted cannot be doubted, the denial of a portion of amount
claimed, asserting that there was deviation from the relevant Rules, is
quite unjustifiable and illegal.
8.
The learned counsel for the respondents/applicants
supported the order of the Tribunal.
9.
Per contra, the learned Deputy Solicitor General of
India (in-charge), Sri.T.C.Krishna, submitted that the impugned orders of
the Tribunal are illegal. According to the DSGI (in-charge), the employees
of the Central Government and their family members are permitted to
avail medical facilities in any of the hospitals, recognized by the State
Government and only at the rates prescribed by the CGHS.
10.
We have heard the rival contentions of the counsel for
OP(CAT) Nos.134/2019 and 150/2020
2025:KER:24588
the parties and appraised the paper books.
The issue involved in these cases are no longer res integra in
view of the dictums laid down by the Honourable Apex Court in various
judicial pronouncements.
We are of the considered view that,
O.P.(CAT).Nos.134/2019 and 150/2020 are devoid of any merit and are
liable to be dismissed. Thus, the O.P.(CAT)s are dismissed.
Sd/-
AMIT RAWAL
JUDGE
Sd/-
K. V. JAYAKUMAR
JUDGE
Sbna/
OP(CAT) Nos.134/2019 and 150/2020
2025:KER:24588
APPENDIX OF OP (CAT) 150/2020
PETITIONER ANNEXURES
ANNEXURE-A6
ANNEXURE-A9
ANNEXURE-A1
ANNEXURE-A2
ANNEXURE-A3
ANNEXURE-A4
ANNEXURE-A5
ANNEXURE-A7
ANNEXURE-A8
ANNEXURE-A10
ANNEXURE-A11
ANNEXURE-12
ANNEXURE-A13
ANNEXURE-RA1
EXHIBIT P1
TRUE
COPY
OF
THE
LETTER
NO.DGM(
P&A)
GMY/PGT/CPGRAMS/20-16-17/213
DATED
3.12.2016
ISSUED BY THE 5TH RESPONDENT
TRUE COPY OF LETTER NO 4641/IP MEDL/AO(PC)/PGT/2
DATED 21.8.2017 ISSUED FROM THE OFFICE OF THE
4TH RESPONDENT
TRUE
COPY
OF
BSNL,
EMPLOYEES
MEDICAL
REIMBURSEMENT SCHEME (BSMRS)
TRUE COPY OF ADDITIONAL GUIDELINES FOR THE
IMPLEMENTATION OF BSNL, MEDICAL REIMBURSEMENT
SCHEME
TRUE COPY OF REIMBURSEMENT OF MEDICAL CLAIM FOR
RETI3ED EMPLOYEES OF BSNL,
TRUE COPY OF ENROLLMENT CARD OF THE APPLICANT'S
HUSBAND IN THE MEDICAL REIMBURSEMENT SCHEME OF
BSNL
TRUE COPY OF DEATH CERTIFICATE ISSUED BY THE
REGISTRAR
OF
BIRTH
AND
DEATH,
NETTOOR
MUNICIPALITY ,KERALA STATE
TRUE COPY OF LETTER DATED 6/.7/2017 ISSUED BY
DR.WESLEY
M
JOSE
THE
CLINICAL
ASSOCIATED
PROFESSOR, DEPARTMENT OF MEDICAL ONCOLOGY, AIMS,
KOCHI
TRUE COPY OF REPRESENTATION DATED 4.8.2017
SUBMITTED BY THE APPLICANT TOT HE 4TH RESPONDENT
TRUE COPY OF REPRESENTATION DATED 17.1.2018
SUBMITTED BY THE APPLICANT TO THE 4TH RESPONDENT
TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT DATED 19.1.2018
RENDERED BY THE HONOURABLE HIGH COURT OF KERALA
IN OP(CAT) NO.167/2017 AS REPORTED IN 2018 ICO
TRUE COPY OF ORDER DATED 19.9.2018 OF THE
CENTRAL
ADMINISTRATIVE
TRIBUNAL
IN
OA
180/530/2017
TRUE COPY OF IDENTITY CARD ISSUED TO THE
DECEASED HUSBAND OF THE APPLICANT BY THE AGM(A)
IN THE OFFICE OF THE 4TH RESPONDENT
TRUE COPY OF ORDER DATED 3/1/2020 IN OA
NO.961/2018
TRUE COPY OF ORIGINAL APPLICATION FILED BEFORE
THE CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL, ERNAKULAM
OP(CAT) Nos.134/2019 and 150/2020
2025:KER:24588
EXHIBIT P2
EXHIBIT P3
EXHIBIT P4
EXHIBIT P5
EXHIBIT P6
EXHIBIT P7
EXHIBIT P8
EXHIBIT P9
EXHIBIT P10
EXHIBIT P11
EXHIBIT P12
EXHIBIT P13
BENCH AS OA NO.961/2018 WITH ANNEXURES.
TRUE COPY OF REPLY STATEMENT FILED BY THE
PETITIONER IN OA NO.961/2018 DATE NIL
TRUE COPY OF REJOINDER FILED BY THE RESPONDENT
IN OA NO.961/2018 WITH ANNEXURES DATE 12.8.2019
TRUE COPY OF ADDITIONAL REPLY STATEMENT FILED BY
PETITIONERS IN OS NO.961/2018 DATE NIL
TRUE COPY OF ORDER DATED 3/1/2010 IN OA
NO.961/2018
TRUE COPY OF REVIEW APPLICATION DATED 6.2.2020
FILED BY THE PETITIONER IN OA 961/2018
TRUE COPY OF ORDER DATED 14.2.2020 PASSED BY THE
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATE TRIBUNAL IN RA 3/2020 IN OA
NO.961/2018
TRUE COPY OF LETTER NO-BSNL/ADMN.1/15-10/07
DATED 16.4.2010
TRUE COPY OF MEMORANDUM OF UNDERSTANDING DATED
18/9/2014 ARRIVED AT WITH LAKESHORE HOSPITAL
TRUE COPY OF COMPILED STATEMENT OF CLAIM AND
PAID EXPENDITURE FOR AMRITHA HOSPITAL BILLS.
TRUE COPY OF ORDER OF THE CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE
TRIBUNAL DATED 20.2.2019 IN OA NO 415/2018
TRUE COPY OF ORDER OF THE HON'BLE HIGH COURT OF
KERALA DATED 30.5.2019 IN OP CAT 134/2019
TRUE COPY OF COMPILED STATEMENT OF CLAIM AND
PAID AMOUNT FOR BILLS PERTAINING TO INDOOR
TREATMENT AT LAKESHORE HOSPITAL.
RESPONDENT EXHIBITS
EXHIBIT R1(A)
EXHIBIT R1(B)
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER NO GENL/197-11/2002
DATED 3.7.2003 ISSUED BY THE DEPUTY GENERAL
MANAGER(PG) FOR THE 2ND PETITIONER
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER NO AOPC/IP MEDICAL
BILL/RAJAGOPALAN O/2020-2021/8 DATED 28.9.2020
ISSUED BY THE CHIEF ACCOUNTS OFFICER IN THE
OFFICE OF THE 4TH PETITIONER
OP(CAT) Nos.134/2019 and 150/2020
2025:KER:24588
APPENDIX OF OP (CAT) 134/2019
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
EXHIBIT P1
Exhibit P1-A1
Exhibit P1-A1(a)
Exhibit P1-A2
Exhibit P1-A3
Exhibit P1-A4
Exhibit P1-A4(a)
Exhibit P1-A5
Exhibit P1-A6
Exhibit P1-A7
Exhibit P1-A8
Exhibit P1-A8(a)
Exhibit P1-A9
Exhibit P1-A10
Exhibit P1-A11
Exhibit P1-A12
Exhibit P2
TRUE COPY OF THE ORIGINAL APPLICATION FILED BY
THE RESPONDENT.
A TRUE COPY OF REPRESENTATION DATED 29.12.2017
ADDRESSED TO THE 3RD RESPONDENT
TRUE TRANSLATION OF A1
A TRUE COPY OF COMMUNICATION DATED 03 JAN 2018,
ISSUED BY THE DEPARTMENT OF UROLOGY, AMRITA
INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES & RESEARCH CENTRE.
A TRUE COPY OF ESTIMATE DATED 08.01.2018 ISSUED
BY THE AMRITA INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCE &
RESEARCH CENTRE.
A TRUE COPY OF REPRESENTATION DATED 09.01.2018,
ADDRESSED TO THE 4TH RESPONDENT.
TRUE TRANSLATION OF A4
A TRUE COPY OF APPLICATION FORM FOR MEDICAL
ADVANCE IN THE PRESCRIBED FORMAT SUBMITTED TO
THE 4TH RESPONDENT.
A TRUE COPY OF DISCHARGE SUMMARY ISSUED BY THE
AMRITA INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES & RESEARCH
CENTRE
A TRUE OF MEDICAL REIMBURSEMENT CLAIM FOR INDOOR
TREATMENT IN THE PRESCRIBED FORMAT AFFIXING ALL
THE REQUIRED DOCUMENTS
A TRUE COPY OF REPRESENTATION DATED 12.03.2018
SUBMITTED TO THE 3RD RESPONDENT
TRUE TRANSLATION OF A8
A TRUE COPY OF COMMUNICATION DATED 06TH APRIL
2018 ISSUED BY THE DEPARTMENT OF URO-ONCOLOGY,
AMRITA INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCE & RESEARCH
CENTRE.
A TRUE COPY OF LETTER BEARING NO. G97/BSNL
MRS/2016-2017/VOL. II/92 DATED 12.03.2018 ISSUED
BY THE 3RD RESPONDENT.
A TRUE COPY OF REPORT DATED 15.03.2018 SUBMITTED
BY THE DIVISIONAL ENGINEER/ BSNL/ TELEPHONE
EXCHANGE/ KALOOR
A TRUE COPY OF LETTER BEARING F. NO. G91/BSNL
MRS/2016-17/VOL. II/198 DATED 20.03.2018, ISSUED
BY THE 3RD RESPONDENT.
TRUE COPY OF THE REPLY STATEMENT FILED BY THE
OP(CAT) Nos.134/2019 and 150/2020
2025:KER:24588
Exhibit P3
Exhibit P4
PETITIONER HEREIN IN THE O.A.
TRUE
COPY
OF
THE
ORDER
PASSED
IN
O.A.NO.180/00145/2018 DATED 20.02.2019.
TRUE
COPY
OF
THE
OFFICE
MEMORANDUM
BSNL/ADMN.I/15-10/07 DATED 16TH APRIL 2010.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review