Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/15
GAHC010176252009
2026:GAU-AS:16605
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : Crl.Rev.P./333/2009
BHARAT CHANDRA DAS
S/O LT. LALIT CHANDRA DAS R/O VILL- BARNALIKUCHI SUNDARPUR
SUBA UNDER PATACHARKUCHI POLICE STATION IN THE DIST. OF
BARPETA, ASSAM.
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND ANR
2:SRI SARAT CHANDRA DAS
S/O LT. LALIT CHANDRA DAS R/O VILL- BARNALIKUCHI SUNDARPUR
SUBA UNDER PATACHARKUCHI POLICE STATION IN THE DIST. OF
BARPETA
ASSAM
Advocate for the Petitioner : MS.N AHMED, MS. P KALITA,MR. S DAS,MR K P
PATHAK(Amicus curiae),MR.H THAKURIA,MS.B HAZARIKA,MR.A RAHMAN
Advocate for the Respondent : PP, ASSAM, MR SARFRAZ NAWAZ, AMICUS CURIAE (R-2),,,
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE N. UNNI KRISHNAN NAIR
ORDER
Date : 02.11.2026
Heard Mr. K.P. Pathak, learned Amicus Curiae, appearing for
the petitioner. Also heard Mr. B. Sarma, learned Additional Public
Page No.# 2/15
Prosecutor, appearing for the respondent no.1 as well as Mr. S. Nawaj,
learned Amicus Curiae, appearing for the respondent no.2.
2.
The present Criminal Revision Petition has been instituted by
the petitioner assailing Judgment & Order dated 19.05.2009, passed by
the Court of the learned Sessions Judge, Barpeta, in Criminal Appeal
No.6/2008, affirming the Judgment & Order dated 29.03.2008 passed by
the Court of the learned Sub-Divisional Judicial Magistrate (M), Bajali,
Pathsala, in Complaint Case No.9/2007, convicting the petitioner, herein,
under Section 465 IPC and sentencing him to undergo Rigorous
Imprisonment for 06 (six) months.
3.
The facts in brief requisite for adjudication of the issues,
arising in the present Criminal Revision Petition is noticed, as under;
3.1.
Sarat Chandra Das, had instituted a complaint petition before
the Court of the Learned Sub-Divisional Judicial Magistrate (M), Bajali,
Pathsala, against Bharat Chandra Das, Phulen Kalita, Hiren Roy and
Promod Das. In the complaint, it was inter alia, alleged that the plot of
land, over which he had built a house and lived there for around 20
(twenty) years, during the time of the family partition had fallen to his
share. However, the Deed of the family partition was kept with the
petitioner Bharat Chandra Das for the purpose of mutating their names in
respect of the plot of land coming to their respective shares. It was further
Page No.# 3/15
projected that the plot of land was mutated in the name of the elder
brother of the complainant viz. Uday Das prior to the family partition. It
was highlighted that in the month of August 2006, the complainant has
gone to the Office of the Circle Officer, Bajali, for the purpose of obtaining
loan by mortgaging the scheduled land and then he came to learn that the
land possessed by him was transferred by his elder brother Uday Das in
favour of the petitioner, herein, by way of executing a Gift Deed. On
further enquiry being made, it was revealed that the Gift Deed was so
registered on 21.02.2000 and therein, Uday Das was shown as the Donor
while the petitioner was shown as the Donee. Phulen Kalita and Hiren Roy,
were the witnesses to the said Gift Deed while the scribe of the Deed was
Promod Das. It was further highlighted that Uday Das had expired on
22.09.1993.
3.2.
In the complaint, it was further highlighted that on the said
aspect coming to his notice, the complainant had a altercation with the
petitioner, herein, and accordingly, the matter was brought to the notice of
the police. The police had thereafter, called both the complainant Sarat
Chandra Das and the petitioner, herein, to the police station and therein, a
written Deed of Agreement was executed by the petitioner, herein. In
terms of the said Agreement executed by the petitioner, he had
undertaken to return the plot of land to the complainant and also to
Page No.# 4/15
transfer the right, title and possession of the said land to the complainant
through a Registered Deed. The said Agreement, as executed, not being
implemented, the complainant Sarat Chandra Das had instituted the said
complaint case.
3.3.
The learned Trial Court had taken cognizance of the said
complaint case under Sections 120(B)/468/419/420/34 IPC against the
accused persons including the petitioner, herein. On receipt of summons,
02 (two) accused i.e. the petitioner, herein, and one Promod Das appeared
before the learned Trial Court and they were allowed to go on bail. The
summons upon the other remaining accused not being served, the
complainant filed a petition for dropping their names and accordingly, the
Trial Court vide order dated 15.05.2007, allowed the said petition by
dropping the accused Phulen Kalita and Hiren Roy from the proceedings
and thereafter, the complainant was allowed to proceed against Promod
Das and the petitioner, herein.
3.4.
Basing on the evidences adduced by the complainant, the
learned Trial Court vide Order dated 10.07.2007, framed a charge under
Section 471 IPC against the petitioner, herein, and under Section 465 IPC
against the accused Promod Das. The charges being explained to the
petitioner and Promod Das and they having pleaded not guilty and claimed
to be tried, accordingly, a Trial ensued.
Page No.# 5/15
3.5.
On conclusion of the Trial, the learned Trial Court considering
the evidences coming on record proceeded vide Judgment & Order dated
29.03.2008, to acquit said Promod Das from the charge framed against
him under Section 465 IPC. The learned Trial Court thereafter, proceeded
to convict the petitioner, herein, under Section 465 IPC and sentenced him
to undergo Rigorous Imprisonment for 06 (six) months.
3.6.
The petitioner, herein, being aggrieved by his conviction by the
learned Trial Court vide Judgment & Order dated 29.03.2008, assailed the
same by way of preferring an appeal before the Court of the learned
Sessions Judge, Barpeta. The said appeal was registered as Criminal
Appeal no.6/2008. The learned Appellate Court on considering the issues
arising in the matter in the light of the evidences coming on record during
the Trial, proceeded vide Judgment & Order dated 19.05.2009, affirmed
the conviction and sentencing of the petitioner, herein, by the learned Trial
Court under Section 465 IPC and held that the petitioner was guilty of the
offence under Section 465 IPC read with Section 471 IPC.
Being aggrieved, the petitioner has instituted the present Criminal
Revision Petition.
4.
Mr. K.P. Pathak, learned Amicus Curiae, appearing for the
petitioner, by referring to the evidences adduced by the prosecution
witnesses, has submitted that the allegation leveled against the petitioner,
Page No.# 6/15
herein, emanates from a Gift Deed executed by Uday Chandra Das on
21.02.2000. He submits that in the said Gift Deed, the petitioner, herein,
has been referred to as the Donee of the land so transferred by the Donor
Uday Chandra Das. However, from the evidences coming on record, it has
not been established that the said Gift Deed was so made by the
petitioner, herein. In the absence of evidence, identifying the petitioner,
herein, as the person who had made the Gift Deed, Mr. Pathak, submitted
that the convictions under Sections 465 IPC and 471 of the IPC are
unsustainable.
4.1.
Mr. Pathak, submits that making of a document is different
from causing it to be made. By referring to Explanation-2 to Section 464
IPC, he submits that for constituting an offence under Section 464 IPC, it
is imperative that a false document is made and the accused is identified
as its maker; otherwise, the accused person is not liable for the offence of
forgery. He submits that in the present case, there is no evidence adduced
by the prosecution, to the effect that the petitioner, herein, had made the
Gift Deed and accordingly, he submits that the petitioner cannot be held to
have made the Gift deed, which was exhibited as Exhibit-2 before the
learned Trial Court.
4.2.
Mr. Pathak, further submits that it is a settled position of law
that, however, strong a suspicion may be, it cannot take the place of
Page No.# 7/15
proof; even grave doubts or strong coincidences cannot substitute for
concrete evidence. Mr. Pathak, further submits that the learned Trial Court
as well as the learned Appellate Court got carried away by the fact that the
petitioner, herein, was the sole beneficiary of the deed. However,
prosecution had miserably failed to prove the Gift Deed as a fraudulent
and forged transaction. In support of his such submissions, Mr. Pathak, has
placed reliance on the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case
of Sheila Sebastian Vs. R Jawaharaj & Anr., reported in (2018) 7
SCC 581.
4.3.
In the above premises, Mr. Pathak, submits that the petitioner,
herein, is entitled to the benefit of doubt and would be required to be
acquitted of the charges framed against him under Sections 465/471 IPC.
5.
Per contra, Mr. S. Nawaj, learned Amicus Curiae, appearing for
the respondent no.2, submits that the Gift Deed i.e. Exhibit No.2, was
made by the petitioner, herein, is established from the Agreement dated
29.08.2006, made by the petitioner and the complainant, wherein, the
petitioner had stated that he had taken a loan by mortgaging the land
which was transferred to him by Uday Das vide Exhibit-2 Gift Deed. He
submits that the petitioner had undertaken to return the possession of the
land along with the right, title and interest, thereon, to the complainant
through a Registered Deed which he however, failed to do.
Page No.# 8/15
5.1.
Mr. Nawaj, submits that the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in the case of Sheila Sebastian (supra) relied upon by the learned
Amicus Curiae for the petitioner, is distinguishable and in view of the
evidences coming on record during the Trial Court including Exhibit No.1,
which stands duly proved, it is established beyond reasonable doubt that
the petitioner, herein, had committed an offence punishable under Section
465 IPC.
5.2.
Mr. Nawaj, after taking this Court through the conclusions
drawn by the learned Trial Court as well as the Appellate Court, has
submitted that the conclusions so drawn are based on the evidences
coming on record and accordingly, the conviction of the petitioner under
Section 465 IPC read with Section 471 IPC would not mandate an
interference from this Court.
6.
I have heard the learned counsel for the parties and also perused
the materials available on record.
7.
The facts leading to the institution of the complaint petition is not
disputed. The Gift Deed which forms the basis of the complaint was
admittedly executed on 21.02.2000. From the evidences coming on record,
it is established that the donor of the land, Uday Das had expired on
22.09.1993. The fact that the donor of the land, in question, was not alive
on the date when the Deed was executed i.e. on 21.02.2000 is not
Page No.# 9/15
disputed by the petitioner, herein. The petitioner while cross-examining the
prosecution witness No.4 Hari Charan Das, had suggested to him that
Uday Das had expired on 16.11.1993. Further, during his examination
under Section 313 CrPC, the petitioner, herein, had stated that Uday
Chandra Das had died on 16.11.1993. Accordingly, the death of the
executor of Exhibit-2 Gift Deed is not in dispute. It can be concluded that
on the date when the said Gift Deed was so executed i.e., on 21.02.2000,
the donor Uday Das was not alive. On a consideration of the said aspect in
the light of Exhibit-1, the Agreement executed by the petitioner, wherein,
he had undertaken to return the plot of land, in question, to the
complainant, it is apparent that the Gift Deed Exhibit-2 was so made by
the petitioner, herein.
8.
It is to be noted that while a plea was taken that the petitioner
had not executed the said Gift Deed and further, that the Agreement
executed in the police station would have no evidentiary value, the
petitioner had not taken a plea that the Agreement i.e, Exhibit -1 was not
executed by him and/or disputed his signature in the said Agreement. The
petitioner had also not urged that he was compelled to execute the said
Agreement at the police station under coercion. Further, the petitioner had
not filed any suit or other proceedings to get the said Agreement annulled.
Accordingly, Exhibit-1 Agreement cannot be doubted and can be relied
Page No.# 10/15
upon as a piece of evidence. The said aspects of the matter was
considered by the learned Trial Court and had drawn the following
conclusions;
“Keeping in mind the above interpretation of the term 'making of a false document"
it is an admitted fact in the present case that the accused, Bharat Das and the donor of
the questioned, Gift deed Uday Das are brothers and the accused was well aware of
the death of his brother, Uday Das on 16-11-93. Moreover it is also an admitted fact
that the accused, Bharat Das is the sole donee of the schedule land under the Gift
deed, Exhibit '4' and as such he is the single most beneficiary under that deed.
Therefore it is only the accused, Bharat Das whose interest is involved in the
execution of the false Gift deed, as no other person stand derive any benefit out of
that deed. That apart the accused by entering into an Agreement i.e. Exhibit '1' with
the complainant on 29-8-06 had admitted that he had committed a mistake by
mortgaging the land under the possession of the complainant to the government and
had obtained a loan. In view of the above admission made by the accused, and the
fact that the accused was himself a party to the false document; being the 'donee' of
the Gift deed, Exhibit '4' hence it has become apparent that the accused in order to
derive under gain had made the false document i.e. Gift deed inspite of having
knowledge that the donor of that deed Uday Das was not alive on the date of
execution of the deed.
Thus the accused having dishonest and fraudulent intention had got the false Gift
deed i.e. Exhibit '4' signed and executed with the intention of causing it to be
believed that such document was signed and executed by Uday Das, inspite of
having knowledge that Uday Das had expired and that Uday Das did not sign and
execute the said Gift deed and there by had committed the offence of 'Forgery'
punishable U/S465 IPC. Although accused, Bharat Das was charged under Section
471 IPC yet then the complainant by adducing cogent and reliable evidence has
failed to prove as to how and where the accused, Bharat Das had used Exhibit '4',
Gift deed as genuine, hence the offence U/S 471 IPC has not been proved beyond all
reasonable doubt and therefore acquit accused Bharat Das from the charge under
Page No.# 11/15
Section 471 IPC”
9.
Basing on the said conclusions, while the learned Trial Court had
acquitted the petitioner from the charge under Section 471 IPC,
it
proceeded to convict the petitioner under Section 465 IPC by giving
justification for the same and accordingly, sentenced the petitioner to
undergo Rigorous Imprisonment for 06 (six) months under Section 465
IPC.
10.
On a close perusal of the conclusions drawn by the learned Trial
Court in the light of the evidences coming on record, including Exhibit-1,
this Court is of the considered view that the conclusions so drawn are
strictly based on the evidences coming on record and the same would not
mandate an interference from this Court.
11.
Having drawn the said conclusions, this Court would now
examine the conclusions drawn by the learned Appellate Court vide the
Judgment & Order dated 19.05.2009. The learned Appellate Court on
examining the evidences coming on record had drawn the following
conclusions;
“As regards the allegation of forgery by executing a false deed of gift dated
20.2.2000 registered on 21.2.2000 purported to be executed by Uday Das who died
on 22.9.93; The P.W. 1 (The respondent/ complainant) in his evidence categorically
mentioned that The Scheduled land had been in his possession since last 30 years
and The said land was originally purchased by deceased Uday Das and at the time
of partition The Schedule land was given to the respondent/ complainant; and the
Page No.# 12/15
appellant/accused was entrusted to get the name of the respondent/ complainant
mutated on the Scheduled land. But The appellant/accused instead of getting the
name of the respondent mutated in the said land he got the said land mutated in his
name. The respondent/ complainant came to know the latest development regarding
the mutation of their disputed land while he enquired the office of the circle officer,
Patacharkuchi; and subsequently the respondents/complainant on enquiry
discovered that Late Uday Das by executing a deed of gift on 20.2.2000 registered
on 21.2.2000 bequeathed the land as described in schedule in favour of the
appellant/ accused. He has proved The certified copy of the alleged deed of gift
marked as Ext.2. In support of his contention The respondent/ complainant has
produced one attested copy of death certificate in respect of Uday Das issued by
Shillong Municipality and one Photo-copy of death certificate in respect of Uday
Das was issued by the Registrar, Birth and Death, Patacharkuchi P.H.C. The PW2,
PW3 and PW4 in their evidence Categorically stated that on 22.9.93 The alleged
doner Uday Das Died at Shillong. In Course of his cross examination The PW4
denied the Suggestion tendered by the defence that said Uday Das died on 16.11.93.
The PW5 Chakradhar Thakuria, The Junior Assistant, office of The Sub- Registrar,
Patacharkuchi also appeared before the court and alongwith the original deed of gift
and has proved the same marked as Ext. 4. He also produced the volume of
Register maintained in the office of The Sub- Registrar, Patacharkuchi and has
proved the relevant entry in regard to the alleged deed of gift being No. 133/2000
vide Ext.6 (although The Ext.6 is found not available on record). Besides the
appellant/ accused Bharat Ch. Das in course of his examination u/s 313 Cr.P.C. also
admitted that the alleged donor Uday Das died on 16.11.93. However although the
appellant disputing the exact date of death of the deceased, The Prosecution has
been able to prove that the death of alleged donor Uday Das took place in the year
1993 Which is 7 years prior to the date of execution of the alleged deed of gift
(Ext.2) i.e. 20.2.2000.
It is also found well established that the alleged deed of gift marked as Ext.4 was
executed in collusion on 20.2.2000 i.e. after death of the alleged testator Uday Das
with intent to grab the land in possession of the respondent/complainant as
described in the schedule; and thereby cheated The respondent/complainant, for his
Page No.# 13/15
wrongful gain. As Such it is crystal clear that the prosecution has been able to prove
the elements of the offence of forgery as embodied in the provision of Section 463
and 464 IPC.
………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………
……………………………………………………………….
The alleged deed of gift marked as Ext. 4 shows that the deceased Bharat ch. Das is
the sole donee of the scheduled land and he is the only beneficiary as per the
alleged deed of gift. Therefore, The appellant / accused Bharat ch. Das is found
involving the execution of the forged deed As such it can safely be held that the
appellant/ accused Bharat Ch. Das having dishonest and fraudulent intention got the
forged deed of gift signed and executed by the donor Uday Das after his death, with
the intention of causing to be believed that such document was signed and executed
by late Uday Das in order to grab the scheduled land in possession of the
respondent/complainant”
12.
Basing on the said conclusions, the learned Appellate Court
had passed the following directions;
“In view of my above discussion and having regard to the facts and
circumstances of the case and the evidence available on record in its entirety,
it is held that the appellant / accused is guilty u/s 465 IPC. read with section
471 IPC and hence he is liable to be punished. Accordingly the appeal is
dismissed on contest upholding the impugned judgment and the order of
conviction and sentence dated 29.03.2008. passed by learned S.D.J.M(M)
Bajali, Pathsala in CR. Case No- 9/2007 convicting and sentencing the
appellant / accused u/s 465 IPC read with section 471 IPC to suffer rigorous
imprisonment for 6(six) months.”
13.
I have carefully, perused the conclusion drawn by the learned
Appellate Court and find the same to be supported by the evidences
Page No.# 14/15
coming on record and accordingly, the same would not mandate any
interference from this Court.
14.
In view of the above discussion, the conviction of the
petitioner, herein, under Section 465 IPC read with Section 471 IPC by the
learned Trial Court and affirmed by the learned Appellate Court would not
mandate any interference from this Court.
15.
Having drawn the said conclusions, this Court notices that the
complaint case was instituted in the year 2007 and the learned Trial Court
had convicted the petitioner, herein, vide Judgment & Order dated
29.03.2008. Thereafter, the learned Appellate Court had affirmed the said
conviction of the petitioner vide Judgment & Order dated 19.05.2009 and
thereafter, the present Criminal Revision Petition is pending before this
Court since the year 2009.
16.
More than 18 (eighteen) years have elapsed since the date of
conviction of the petitioner, herein, by the learned Trial Court and
accordingly, considering the long lapse of time occasioning in the matter
and the provisions of Section 465 IPC also mandating imposition of a fine
in lieu of imprisonment, this Court is of the considered view that the
present case is a fit one for modifying the sentencing of the petitioner,
herein.
17.
Accordingly, while upholding the conviction of the petitioner
Page No.# 15/15
under Section 465 IPC, the sentencing of the petitioner is modified and for
the offence under Section 465 IPC, he is sentenced to pay a fine of
Rs.2000/- (Rupees Two Thousand) in lieu of the imprisonment.
18.
With the above modification of the sentencing of the
petitioner, the present Criminal Revision Petition stands disposed of.
19.
Registry to send down the records of the case to the learned
Trial Court along with a copy of the present order to the Court of the
learned Sub-Divisional Judicial Magistrate (M), Bajali, Pathsala, for further
compliance of the directions so passed.
20.
Before parting with the records of the case, this Court records
its appreciation to the able assistance provided by Mr. K.P. Pathak and Mr.
S. Nawaj, as learned Amicus Curiae in the matter, which had facilitated
disposal of the present matter.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review