The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
16. The plaintiff is seeking recovery of possession of 67 cents included in plaint A schedule property excluding plaint E schedule property. Plaint E schedule property is shown as tiled building No.IV/233 situated in Survey No.285/9. The first question to be considered whether the plaintiff has identified the plaint schedule property in accordance with the title deed by which they obtained the property. The learned counsel for the appellant pointed out that the descriptions of the plaint schedule property in the plaint and in Ext.A2 document do not tally. The northern boundary shown as item No.3 in Ext.A1. 2025:KER:28062 RSA No. 989 of 2011 : 14 : But in the plaint schedule property it is the property belonged to one Anandan. That apart, the location of E schedule property is not shown in Ext.C2 Rough sketch. The plaint A schedule property having an extent of 67 cents of land should have been identified by the plaintiff with reference to the title deeds relied by them. Even though the defendants have not filed any objection for the commission report, it is the burden of the plaintiffs to identify plaint schedule property with a survey commission. That was not done in the case on hand. Plaint E schedule property is a building. If plaint E schedule property is to be excluded from Plaint A schedule property, necessarily the land on which the building is situated and the land for acces…
17. In view of the answer to the substantial question of law Number 2, I find that the matter liable to be remanded to the 2025:KER:28062 RSA No. 989 of 2011 : 15 : Trial Court for the limited purpose of identifying the plaint A schedule property excluding plaint E schedule property with a Survey Commission. All other findings in the impugned judgments and decrees are confirmed. Accordingly, I set aside the judgment and decree passed by the Trial Court as well as the First Appellate Court and remanded the matter back to the Trial Court for a limited purpose of identifying the plaint A schedule property excluding plaint E schedule property with a Survey Commission.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:28062
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE M.A.ABDUL HAKHIM
WEDNESDAY, THE 2ND DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 12TH CHAITHRA,
RSA NO. 989 OF 2011
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 10.02.2011 IN AS
NO.19 OF 2008 OF DISTRICT COURT,THRISSUR ARISING OUT OF
THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 23.07.2007 IN OS NO.1371 OF
2000 OF MUNSIFF COURT, CHAVAKKAD
APPELLANTS/DEFENDANTS 1 AND 3:
BHANUMATHY, W/O.LATE ASHOKAN,
KOTTUKKAL PALAKKAL HOUSE, NATTIKA P.O.,,
THRIPRAYAR DESOM, NATTIKA VILLAGE,
CHAVAKKAD TALUK, PIN - 680 566.
BALAKRISHNAN S/O.LATE ASHOKAN
RESIDING AT DO. DO.
BY ADV SRI.P.RAMACHANDRAN
RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS/PLAINTIFFS AND DEFENDANTS:
SREE NARAYANA TRUST, KOLLAM
REPRESENTED BY SECRETARY, V.K.NADESAN,
VELLAPPALLIL VEETTIL, KANICHUKULANGARA DESOM,
CHERTHALA TALUK, 688 582
NATTIKA SREENARAYANA COLLEGE
REPRESENTED BY PRINCIPAL, N.AYYAPPA DAS,
S.N.COLLEGE, NATTIKA P.O., THRISSUR DISTRICT,
PIN 680 566.
RAMACHANDRAN,S/O.BHANUMATHY & LATE ASHOKAN,
KOTTUKAL PALAKKAL HOUSE,, NATTIKA P.O.,
THRIPRAYAR DESOM,NATTIKA VILLAGE,
CHAVAKKAD TALUK, PIN 680 566.
2025:KER:28062
RSA No. 989 of 2011
:2:
RAHNA D/O.MARAT RAMACHANDRAN
THRIPRAYAR DESOM, NATTIKA P.O.,
THRISSUR DISTRICT PIN 680 566.
DELETED FROM THE PARTY ARRAY OF THE APPEAL
AT THE RISK OF THE APPELLANT AS PER ORDER
DATED 26.02.2019 IN I.A.02/2019.
NIRMALA, W/O.PUTHUR CHANDRANGADHAN,
THRIPRAYAR DESOM, NATTIKA P.O.,
THRISSUR DISTRICT, PIN 680 566.
SHIBU S/O. DO. RESIDING AT DO. DO.
SHAJU S/O. DO. RESIDING AT DO. DO.
BY ADVS.
SRI.P.K.SAJEEV
SRI.P.GOPALAKRISHNAN
SRI.A.N.RAJAN BABU
SRI.P.R.SHAJI
THIS
ADMISSION
REGULAR
ON
SECOND
02.04.2025,
DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
APPEAL
THE
HAVING
COURT
ON
COME
THE
UP
FOR
SAME
DAY
2025:KER:28062
RSA No. 989 of 2011
:3:
M.A.ABDUL HAKHIM, J.
===========================
RSA No. 989 of 2011
============================
Dated this the 2nd day of April, 2025
JUDGMENT
1.
The Regular Second Appeal is filed by the defendants 1
and 3 in the suit. The suit was one for recovery of possession
and also for mandatory and prohibitory injunctions. The first
plaintiff is a Trust by name ‘Sree Narayana Trust’ and the 2 nd
plaintiff is Nattika Sreenarayana College run by the 1st plaintiff.
The plaint A schedule property is 67 cents of land situated in
Survey No.284/9 of Nattika Village. The plaintiffs claimed title
over the plaint schedule property as per Ext.A1 title deed dated
02.05.1967 executed by one Raghavan.
2.
As per plaint allegations, the plaint A schedule property
originally
belonged
to
one
Velayi
as
per
document
No.559/1948. Velayi executed Ext.A7 document of the year
1950 with respect to 50 cents in favour of one Unnoolikutty
creating a possessory mortgage in her favour.
Remaining
property was retained by Velayi. Later, as per Ext.A2 document
of the year 1966, Velayi assigned the 17 cents of land in favour
2025:KER:28062
RSA No. 989 of 2011
:4:
of Raghavan with right of redemption of 50 cents of land from
Unnoolikutty.
Thereafter,
Unnoolikkutty
executed
Ext.A3
document of the year 1966 releasing the mortgage in favour of
Raghavan. Raghavan executed Ext.A1 document of the year
1967 with respect to plaint schedule property in favour of the
1st plaintiff and thus, plaintiffs got title and possession of the
plaint A schedule property. The defendants 1 to 3 are the legal
heirs of Unnoolikutty.
They trespassed into the plaint A
schedule property in July 2000. The 4 th defendant constructed
plaint B schedule shed and plaint C schedule shed without roof.
The
5th
defendant
constructed
plaint
D
schedule
shed.
Defendants 1 to 3 have been residing in plaint E schedule
property, which is a part of the plaint A schedule property, with
the permission of the plaintiff.
The plaintiffs sought for
recovery of plaint A schedule property except plaint E schedule
property based on title, stating that the plaintiffs will be taking
separate steps to evict the defendants 1 to 3 from plaint E
schedule property. Consequential prohibitory and mandatory
injunctions were also sought.
3.
The defendants 1 and 3 filed joined Written Statement
contending,inter alia, that the plaintiffs and their predecessors
2025:KER:28062
RSA No. 989 of 2011
:5:
had no title over the plaint schedule properties.
The
defendants’ predecessor Unnoolikutty obtained 50 cents as per
Ext.A7 document. Unnoolikuty obtained the remaining 17 cents
as per varam arrangement in the year 1951. On the death of
Unnoolikutty, his son Asokan who was the husband of the 1 st
defendant and father of the defendants 2 &3
obtained
possession of the plaint A schedule property, and on the death
of Asokan, the defendants 1 to 3 are in possession of the plaint
schedule properties. Raghavan was never in possession of the
plaint schedule properties. Ext.A3 Release Deed executed by
Unnoolikutty is not valid. Since the defendants 1 to 3 and their
predecessors have been in possession of the plaint schedule
properties since the year 1966, the plaintiffs have lost their title
by adverse possession and limitation
4.
The 2nd defendant filed Written Statement adopting the
written statement of 1st and 3rd defendants.
5.
The fourth defendant filed separate Written Statement
contending that he had obtained 17 cents of land as per the
document executed by the defendants 1 to 3.
2025:KER:28062
RSA No. 989 of 2011
6.
:6:
The defendants 6 to 8 who are the legal heirs of the 5 th
defendant also filed Written Statement supporting the written
statement filed by the defendants 1 and 2.
7.
The Trial Court decreed the suit finding that the plaintiff is
having title over the plaint A schedule property and directing
the defendants 1 to 4 and the defendants 6 to 8 to surrender
vacant possession of plaint A schedule property except plaint E
schedule property and directing them to demolish plaint B to D
schedule properties, directing them to demolish the concrete
posts and iron rod fence in the plaint A schedule property and
further restraining them by way of a permanent prohibitory
injunction from committing any act of waste in the plaint A
schedule property.
8.
The defendants 1 and 3 filed appeal before the First
Appellate Court, and the same was dismissed, confirming the
judgment and decree passed by the Trial Court.
admitted
the
Regular
Second
Appeal
on
This Court
the
substantial questions of law.
(1)
When the defendants pleaded in the written statement
that Ext.A3 release deed was executed without any intention to
transfer the right and it is only a sham and nominal document,
following
2025:KER:28062
RSA No. 989 of 2011
:7:
whether the trial court was justified in not framing an issue and
considering whether Ext.A3 is a sham and nominal document
and thereby Raghavan, the assignor obtained possession of
the mortgaged property.
(2)
Whether on the evidence courts below were justified in
holding that the plaint schedule properties are properly
identified.
9.
I
heard
the
learned
counsel
for
the
appellant
Sri.P.Ramachandran, the learned counsel for the 1 st respondent
Sri.A.N.Rajan Babu and the learned counsel for the 2 nd
respondent Sri.P.R.Shaji.
10.
The learned counsel for the appellant contended that the
Trial Court ought to have formulated an issue whether Ext.A3 is
a sham and nominal document when such contention was
specifically raised by the defendants in their Written Statement
and adjudicated the said issue. The learned counsel relied on
the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
Chebrol
Sriramalu v. Vakalapudi Satyanarayana [2013 (9) SCC
404]
to support the said contention.
The learned counsel
further contended that the property is not properly identified by
the plaintiff.
Only an ex-parte commission was taken at the
2025:KER:28062
RSA No. 989 of 2011
:8:
time of filing of the suit and Ext.C1 and C2 were obtained.
Ext.C2 is only a Rough sketch on the basis of which the decree
could not be given. The learned counsel relied on the decision
of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in P. Chandrasekharan and
others v. S.Kanakarajan and others [2007 KHC 3567], in
this regard. The learned counsel further cited the decision of
this Court in Naduvatheyath Sulochana v. Syndicate Bank
Branch Manager [2022 (2) KHC 253] to substantiate the
point that when the defendants raised a contention that
particular document is sham, it is permissible to adduce
extrinsic evidence about the nature and possession of the
property after the purchase, motive, if any, for making the
sham transaction and the position of the parties and the
relationship, if any, between the claimant and the alleged
‘shammer’.
When this extrinsic evidence is available in the
present case to hold Ext.A3 as a sham transaction, the Trial
Court ought to have found that Ext.A3 is sham document. The
learned
counsel
further
contended
that
admittedly
the
documents relating to the plaint schedule property produced by
the plaintiffs is in Survey No. 284/11, but the plaintiff
2025:KER:28062
RSA No. 989 of 2011
:9:
contended that the actual Survey No. is 284/9. The said fact is
not proved by the plaintiff.
11.
On
the
other
hand,
the
learned
counsel
for
the
respondents contended that the substantial questions of law
formulated in the appeal do not amount to substantial question
of law as laid down by the test in the decision of the Hon'ble
Supreme court in Government of Kerala v. Joseph [ 2023
(5) KLT 74 (SC)] Question of law shall be having substance,
essential, real, of sound worth, important or considerable. It is
to be understood as something in contradistinction with technical, of no substance or consequence, or academic merely.
The learned counsel further contended that the substantial
questions of law formulated in the present appeal do not arise
from the facts and circumstances of the case. There is no
dispute with regard to the identity of the property. Even though
the defendants claimed that Ext.A3 document is sham and
nominal document, no evidence in this regard is produced to
support the said contention. If they had any grievance with
respect to non framing of any particular issue, they should have
prayed to the Trial Court to frame issue in this regard.
12.
I have considered the rival contentions.
2025:KER:28062
RSA No. 989 of 2011
13.
: 10 :
The first substantial question of law is with respect to the
non-framing of the issue regarding the validity of the Ext.A3
release deed. Both sides admit that the plaint schedule
property of 67 cents originally belonged to one Velayi and 50
cents out of the same was mortgaged to Unnoolikutty,
predecessors of the defendants 1 to 3. The execution of Ext.A3
Release Deed by Unnoolikutty is admitted by the defendants. If
Ext.A3 Release Deed is invalid, the plaintiff’s will not get title as
the mortgage in favour of Unnoolikutty is not released. With
respect to the remaining 17 cents not covered by mortgage,
though the defendants 1 to 3 claimed varam arrangement,
there is no document to prove the same. So, the defendants
cannot claim any right over the remaining 17 cents, and the
same belonged to Velayi and came into the ownership of the
plaintiffs as per Exts.A1 and A2 Sale Deeds.
14.
It is true the defendants had raised a contention in the
Written
Statement
that
Ext.A3
is
a
sham
and
nominal
document. According to the Counsel for the appellant, the 1 st
plaintiff represented to Unnoolikutty that 30 acres of land is
required for starting a college for the plaintiffs, and on the
basis
of
such
representation,
Ext.A3
document
was
2025:KER:28062
RSA No. 989 of 2011
executed
: 11 :
only to show that the 1 st plaintiff is having 30 acres
of land. It is true that the Trial court did not frame an issue in
this regard. But that does not in any way curtail the right of the
plaintiff to file an application to frame an issue in this regard.
No such application was filed by the defendants before the Trial
Court by the defendants. It appears from the evidence that the
defendants were not serious enough to prosecute the said
contention. No evidence whatsoever was adduced in support of
their contention that Ext.A3 is only a sham and nominal
document. They relied on Exts.B1 to B13 documents to show
that in spite of executing Ext. A3 document, their possession
continued after the date of Ext.A3. True, it appears that cause
of action claimed by the plaintiff that defendants trespassed
into the plaint schedule property in July
2000 may not be
correct. Exts. B1 to B8 documents are subsequent to 1966,
which is the date of Ext.A3 document. It would show that the
defendants have been continuing possession of the plaint
schedule property after Ext.A3.
But when the title of the
plaintiffs is proved by the title document, the plaintiff is entitled
to recover plaint schedule property on the strength of the title.
The
subsequent
documents
showing
the
continuance
of
2025:KER:28062
RSA No. 989 of 2011
: 12 :
possession will not be enough to hold that Ext.A3 document is
a document executed with an intention not to implement the
same. Even though the defendants contended that Ext.A3 was
executed for showing that plaintiffs are having enough property
for the college, no evidence is produced by the defendants.
Hence, I am of the view that the nonframing of the issue
regarding the validity of the Ext.A3 release deed is relevant or
material in the facts and circumstances of the present case.
Hence, I answer the substantial question of law No.1 in the
affirmative and against the appellant.
15.
The substantial question of law No.2 relates to the
identity of the plaint schedule property. The defendants raised
contention that the plaintiff did not prove the correct survey
number of the plaint schedule property. Even though the
plaintiff claimed that correct survey number of the property is
Survey No.284/9 and the title document showed that Survey
No. is 284/11. As rightly found by the Trial Court, in Ext.A5
Reply Notice, the 2nd defendant has admitted that there is a
mistake in the survey number and that the correct Survey No.
is 284/9 on the report of the authorities. The contention of the
learned counsel for the appellant is that Ext.A5 is a Reply sent
2025:KER:28062
RSA No. 989 of 2011
: 13 :
by the 2nd defendant and the appeal is filed by the defendants 1
and 3 who filed separate Written Statement in the suit.
It is
seen that defendants 1 to 3 are claiming title under the very
same person.
According to them, they are the legal heirs of
Unnoolikutty who obtained mortgage of the plaint schedule
property from Velayi. They advanced identical contentions and
the defended the suit through very same counsel. Hence Ext.A5
Reply Notice sent by the 2nd defendant is to be treated as
binding on the defendants 1 & 3 also. Hence the contention of
that the plaintiff did not prove the correct survey number of the
plaint schedule property is not sustainable.
16.
The plaintiff is seeking recovery of possession of 67 cents
included in plaint A schedule property excluding plaint E
schedule property. Plaint E schedule property is shown as tiled
building No.IV/233 situated in Survey No.285/9.
The first
question to be considered whether the plaintiff has identified
the plaint schedule property in accordance with the title deed
by which they obtained the property. The learned counsel for
the appellant pointed out that the descriptions of the plaint
schedule property in the plaint and in Ext.A2 document do not
tally.
The northern boundary shown as item No.3 in Ext.A1.
2025:KER:28062
RSA No. 989 of 2011
: 14 :
But in the plaint schedule property it is the property belonged
to one Anandan.
That apart, the location of E schedule
property is not shown in Ext.C2
Rough sketch.
The plaint A
schedule property having an extent of 67 cents of land should
have been identified by the plaintiff with reference to the title
deeds relied by them.
Even though the defendants have not
filed any objection for the commission report, it is the burden
of the plaintiffs to identify plaint schedule property with a
survey commission. That was not done in the case on hand.
Plaint E schedule property is a building. If plaint E schedule
property is to be excluded from Plaint A schedule property,
necessarily the land on which the building is situated and the
land for access are to be identified for excluding the same from
plaint A schedule property. These things are not available in
Ext.C2 Sketch. The decree granting recovery of possession as
per Ext.C2 Rough Sketch is not sustainable. I am of the view
that for identifying plaint A schedule property and plaint E
schedule property by a survey commission, the matter is liable
to be remanded back to the Trial Court.
17.
In view of the answer to the substantial question of law
Number 2, I find that the matter liable to be remanded to the
2025:KER:28062
RSA No. 989 of 2011
: 15 :
Trial Court for the limited purpose of identifying the plaint A
schedule property excluding plaint E schedule property with a
Survey
Commission. All other findings in the impugned
judgments and decrees are confirmed. Accordingly, I set aside
the judgment and decree passed by the Trial Court as well as
the First Appellate Court and remanded the matter back to the
Trial Court for a limited purpose of identifying the plaint A
schedule property excluding plaint E schedule property with a
Survey Commission.
18.
The parties are directed to appear before the Trial Court
on 30.05.2025.
Sd/-
M.A.ABDUL HAKHIM
JUDGE
nk
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review