Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:25334
O.P.(C)Nos.1410 & 1595 of 2022
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE K. BABU
TUESDAY, THE 25TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 4TH CHAITHRA, 1947
OP(C) NO. 1410 OF 2022
AGAINST THE ORDER DATED 20.07.2022 IN I.A.NOS. 8 &
9 OF 2022 IN OS NO.190 OF 2017 OF THE II - ADDITIONAL SUB
COURT,ERNAKULAM
PETITIONER/DEFENDANT:
BERNY FRANCIS,
AGED 57 YEARS,
S/O. FRANCIS KARIPPATT,
KARIPPATT HOUSE,
ANTONY KATTIKAREN LANE,
KACHERIPADY, KOCHI,
PIN - 682018
BY ADVS.
SRI.K.T.THOMAS
SRI.MATHEW BOB KURIAN
RESPONDENT/ADDL.2ND PLAINTIFF:
LINTU SABU,
AGED 32 YEARS,
D/O. LATE SABU VARGHESE,
PANDIKUDI HOUSE, VENGOOR P.O,
PERUMBAVOOR, ERNAKULAM,
PIN - 683554
BY ADVS.
SRI.GOPIKRISHNAN NAMBIAR M.
SRI.K.JOHN MATHAI(J-212)
2025:KER:25334
O.P.(C)Nos.1410 & 1595 of 2022
SRI.JOSON MANAVALAN(J-526)
SRI.KURYAN THOMAS(K/131/2003)
SRI.PAULOSE C. ABRAHAM(MAH/58/2006)
SRI.RAJA KANNAN(K/356/2008)
THIS
OP
(CIVIL)
HAVING
BEEN
FINALLY
HEARD
ON
25.03.2025, ALONG WITH OP(C).1595/2022, THE COURT ON THE
SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
2025:KER:25334
O.P.(C)Nos.1410 & 1595 of 2022
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE K. BABU
TUESDAY, THE 25TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 4TH CHAITHRA, 1947
OP(C) NO. 1595 OF 2022
AGAINST THE ORDER DATED 20.07.2022 IN I.A.NO.10 OF
2022 IN OS NO.190 OF 2017 OF THE II - ADDITIONAL SUB
COURT,ERNAKULAM
PETITIONER/DEFENDANT:
BERNY FRANCIS,
AGED 57 YEARS,
S/O. FRANCIS KARIPPATT,
KARIPPATT HOUSE, ANTONY KATTIKAREN LANE,
KACHERIPADY, KOCHI, PIN - 682018
BY ADVS.
SRI.K.T.THOMAS
SRI.MATHEW BOB KURIAN
RESPONDENT/ADDL.2ND PLAINTIFF:
LINTU SABU,
AGED 32 YEARS,
D/O. LATE SABU VARGHESE,
PANDIKUDI HOUSE, VENGOOR P.O,
PERUMBAVOOR, ERNAKULAM,
PIN – 683554
BY ADVS.
SRI.GOPIKRISHNAN NAMBIAR M.
THIS
OP
(CIVIL)
HAVING
BEEN
FINALLY
HEARD
ON
25.03.2025, ALONG WITH OP(C).1410/2022, THE COURT ON THE
SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
2025:KER:25334
O.P.(C)Nos.1410 & 1595 of 2022
please check the pages correction made
K.BABU, J.
-------------------------------------------
O.P.(C) Nos.1410 & 1595 of 2022
--------------------------------------------Dated this the 25th day of March, 2025
JUDGMENT
The challenge in these Original Petitions is to the
orders in I.A.Nos.8,9 and 10 of 2022 in O.S.No.190/2017.
The petitioner is the defendant in the suit.
2.
The plaintiff instituted the Original Suit for
realisation of money. The plaintiff pleaded that the
defendant
on
18.03.2017
borrowed
a
sum
of
Rs.10,00,000/-. The plaintiff stated that he paid the
amount by way of issuing a cheque dated 18.03.2017
drawn on the Federal Bank Limited. According to the
plaintiff,
the defendant encashed the cheque and
received the money from the Bank. The plaintiff further
pleaded that the defendant executed a promissory note
agreeing to repay the amount on the same day.
3.
The defendant resisted the suit denying the
entire transactions. The defendant pleaded that he did not
2025:KER:25334
O.P.(C)Nos.1410 & 1595 of 2022
receive
money from the plaintiff and that he did not
execute a promissory note as pleaded. The defendant also
pleaded that he had not received money by encashing the
cheque dated 18.03.2017 as pleaded by the plaintiff.
4.
Based on the rival contentions, the Trial Court
framed the issues. The case was placed in the special list
for trial. Both sides proceeded to lead evidence.
5.
On
the
application
of
the
plaintiff
the
promissory note was sent for expert examination. The
report of expert examination on the promissory note
revealed that the signature of the executant in the
promissory note was that of the defendant. On the
application of the defendant, cheque dated 18.03.2017
was produced before the Court on 13.06.2018.
6.
During the course of proceedings the original
plaintiff died. His daughter was impleaded as his legal
representative. The husband of the plaintiff’s daughter
gave evidence as PW1. The Manager of Federal Bank was
examined as PW2. The defendant denied his signature in
2025:KER:25334
O.P.(C)Nos.1410 & 1595 of 2022
the cheque stated to have been used for encashing the
amount on 18.03.2017. The Manager of Federal Bank
(PW2) gave evidence that it was the defendant who
presented the cheque in question on 18.03.2017 and
encashed the same. While examined in cross, the
Manager stated that he had identified the ID card
produced by the person who presented the cheque. The
defendant challenged the version given by PW2 by
suggesting that he did not present the cheque before the
Bank and the encashment of the cheque was by way of
impersonation. Therefore, the defendant filed I.A.No. 9 of
2022 seeking to summon the Manager of the Bank to
produce the following documents:(1)
The register evidencing the issuance
of cheque to the account of the plaintiff.
(2) The
bank records and transaction
approval
documents
relating
to
the
encashment of the cheque.
(3)
The name and address details of the
2025:KER:25334
O.P.(C)Nos.1410 & 1595 of 2022
Chief Manager of the Bank at the time of
the disputed transaction.
(4) The relevant guidelines of the Reserve
Bank of India.
7.
The defendant also filed I.A.No.8/2022 to recall
the witness [PW2]. The defendant filed I.A.No.10/2022
under Section 45 of the Indian Evidence Act seeking to
send the disputed cheque for expert examination.
8.
The Trial Court rejected I.A.No.10/2022 holding
that the application was belated. The relevant portion of
the order is extracted below:“6. The point:- It is to be noted that the disputed
cheque bearing No.754251 was produced before
this court on 13.06.2018. Thereafter, Ext.A1
promissory note was sent for scientific
examination on 30.09.2021 and its report was
received by this Court on 25.11.2021 stating that
the defendant himself is the author of the
signature appearing in it. More over, no reason is
stated by the petitioner for not taking any steps
to send the disputed cheque for scientific
examination at that time or at any time before
starting the trial.
7. It is clear that the petitioner comes with
application, one after the other on an
experimental basis and with intent to protract
the proceedings. Hence, the petition stands
dismissed with costs.”
2025:KER:25334
O.P.(C)Nos.1410 & 1595 of 2022
9.
The
application
seeking
production
of
documents as per I.A.No.9/2022 was also dismissed by the
Trial Court holding that allowing the application will serve
no purpose.
10.
I have heard the learned counsel for the
petitioner and the learned counsel for the respondent.
11.
The
learned
counsel
for
the
petitioner
submitted that only at the time when the Manager was
examined as PW2, the defendant got the opportunity to
make a request for sending the cheque for expert
examination. The learned counsel submitted that the Trial
Court was not justified in not permitting the defendant to
lead evidence to rebut the presumption that may be
drawn in favour of the plaintiff.
12.
The
learned
counsel
for
the
respondent
submitted that though the cheque was produced before
the Court on 13.06.2018 and even after sending the
promissory note for expert examination on the application
of the plaintiff, the defendant did not care to make an
2025:KER:25334
O.P.(C)Nos.1410 & 1595 of 2022
application to send the cheque for expert examination.
13.
The learned counsel for the plaintiff further
submitted that the attempt of the defendant is only to
prolong the matter, that too at the fag end of the trial.
14.
In the plaint the plaintiff had pleaded that the
amount was given to the defendant by way of cheque
dated 18.03.2017. This version was within the knowledge
of the defendant from the very commencement of the
proceedings before the Trial Court. The cheque in question
was produced before the Court on the application of the
defendant on 13.06.2018. He made the application only in
2022, after the examination of most of the witnesses. The
defendant had an opportunity to request for expert
examination of the cheque at the time when the case was
posted for pre-trial steps. He did not make such a request
at that stage though he was well aware of the pleading set
up by the plaintiff that the amount was given by way of
the cheque in question. It is also relevant to note that
PW2, the Manager of Federal Bank had
given evidence
2025:KER:25334
O.P.(C)Nos.1410 & 1595 of 2022
that the Bank verified the identity of the person who
presented the cheque for encashment.
15.
Adducing evidence in support of the defence is
a valuable right and denial of that right would mean denial
of a fair trial and such a request is to be allowed by the
Trial Courts unless the Court thinks that the object of the
defendant/accused is to delay the proceedings.
16.
In Francis v. Pradeep [2004 (2) KLT 1080],
this Court held thus:“The easiest way to protract proceedings under
Section 138 of the N.I. Act and thus stultify the
spirit and object of the provisions of Section 138
of the N.I. Act is to request that the cheque be
sent to the expert. The soul of the provision will
be lost if there is no expeditious enforcement. On
account of pressure of work at the Forensic
Science Laboratory, it is common knowledge that
the expert will not be able to give the report
within a period of three to four years. Convenient
protraction can be achieved by requesting that
the cheque be forwarded to the expert for
examination. It is for the Trial Court to alertly
consider the acceptability of such request and
ensure that the cheque is forwarded to the expert
only if satisfactory reasons are available”.
(emphasis supplied).
17.
The Trial Court has considered the pleadings
set up by the parties.
It carefully considered the
acceptability of the request for sending the cheque for
2025:KER:25334
O.P.(C)Nos.1410 & 1595 of 2022
expert examination. The Court came to the conclusion
that the attempt of the defendant was only to protract the
matter. The Court took note of the fact that eventhough
the cheque in question was produced before the Court on
13.06.2018, the defendant did not take steps to send the
cheque for expert examination.
18.
Therefore, this Court is of the view that the
refusal on the part of the Trial Court to send the cheque
for expert examination requires no interference by this
Court exercising the jurisdiction under Article 227 of the
Constitution of India.
19.
However, this Court is of the view that if the
defendant makes an application under Section 73 of the
Indian
Evidence
Act/72
of
the
Bharatiya
Sakshya
Adhiniyam 2023, the Trial Court shall consider it in
accordance with law.
20.
If such a responsibility is undertaken, the
Court shall follow the directions issued by this Court in
2025:KER:25334
O.P.(C)Nos.1410 & 1595 of 2022
S.Sivadas v. State of Kerala (MANU/KE/4089/2022),
which reads thus:“34. In a case where the Court is constrained to
undertake the responsibility of comparing the
disputed writing or signature with the admitted
handwriting or signature, it shall make a careful
study, if necessary, with the assistance of counsel,
to ascertain the characteristics, similarities and
dissimilarities. The judgment shall contain the
reasons for any conclusion based on a comparison
of the handwriting/signature if the Court proceeds
to record a finding thereon. Conclusions arrived
based on a casual or routine glance, or perusal
shall not be relied on to enter into a finding
leading to the conviction of an accused.”
21.
In view of the fact that I have permitted the
defendant to make an application under Section 73 of the
Indian
Evidence
Act/72
of
the
Bharatiya
Sakshaya
Adhiniyam, 2023, Ext.P9 order in O.P.(C) No.1410 of 2022
is liable to be set aside.
In the result:(1)
Ext.P9 order in O.P.(C) No.1410 of 2022
stands set aside.
(2)
I.A.No.9/2022 in O.S.No.190/2017 is
allowed. The Court below shall direct the
witness concerned to produce the documents
2025:KER:25334
O.P.(C)Nos.1410 & 1595 of 2022
sought to be produced.
(3)
Ext.P10
order
stands
set
aside.
I.A.No.8/2022 in O.S.No.190/2017 is allowed.
(4)
The order in I.A.No.10/2022
stands
confirmed.
The Suit is of the year 2017. The Trial Court shall
make earnest efforts to expedite the Trial.
The Original Petitions are disposed of as above.
VPK
Sd/K.BABU
JUDGE
2025:KER:25334
O.P.(C)Nos.1410 & 1595 of 2022
APPENDIX OF OP(C) 1595/2022
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
Exhibit P1
TRUE COPY OF THE PLAINT IN O.S NO.190
OF 2017 BEFORE SUB COURT -ILL,
ERNAKULAM
Exhibit P2
TRUE COPY OF THE WRITTEN STATEMENT IN
O.S NO.190 OF 2017 BEFORE SUB COURTIII, ERNAKULAM
Exhibit P3
TRUE COPY OF CHEQUE BEARING NO,754251
DATED 18.03.2017 OF FEDERAL BANK LTD
Exhibit P4
TRUE COPY OF THE DEPOSITION OF PW2
DATED 24.06.2022 IN O.S NO.190 OF 2017
BEFORE SUB COURT-ILL, ERNAKULAM
Exhibit P5
TRUE COPY OF I.A NO. 10 OF 2022 IN O.S
NO.190 OF 2017 BEFORE SUB COURT-III,
ERNAKULAM
Exhibit P6
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED
20.07.2022 IN I.A NO. 10 OF 2022 IN
O.S NO.190 OF 2017 BEFORE SUB COURT ILL, ERNAKULAM
Exhibit P7
TRUE COPY OF THE INTERIM ORDER DATED
02.08.2022 IN OP (C) NO.1410 OF 2022
OF THIS HONBLE COURT
2025:KER:25334
O.P.(C)Nos.1410 & 1595 of 2022
APPENDIX OF OP(C) 1410/2022
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
Exhibit P1
TRUE COPY OF THE PLAINT IN O.S NO.190
OF 2017 BEFORE SUB COURT, ERNAKULAM
Exhibit P2
TRUE COPY OF THE WRITTEN STATEMENT IN
O.S NO.190 OF 2017 BEFORE SUB COURT,
ERNAKULAM.
Exhibit P3
TRUE COPY OF CHEQUE BEARING NO.754251
DATED 18.03.2017 OF A/C
NO.13750200037039 IN THE NAME OF THE
PLAINTIFF IN FEDERAL BANK LTD
Exhibit P4
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED
31.05.2018 IN I.A NO. 1786 OF 2018 IN
O.S 190 OF 2017 PASSED BY SUB COURT
ERNAKULAM.
Exhibit P5
TRUE COPY OF THE PROMISSORY NOTE DATED
18.03.2017 PRODUCED BY THE PLAINTIFF
IN O.S 190 OF 2017 SUB COURT ERNAKULAM
Exhibit P6
TRUE COPY OF THE I.A NO. 9 OF 2022 IN
O.S 190 OF 2017 OF SUB COURT,
ERNAKULAM.
Exhibit P7
TRUE COPY THE I.A NO. 8 OF 2022 IN O.S
190 OF 2017 OF SUB COURT, ERNAKULAM
Exhibit P8
TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT DATED
22.07.2022 IN O.P (C) NO.1335 OF 2022
Exhibit P9
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED
20.07.2022 IN I.A NO. 9 OF 2022 IN O.S
190 OF 2017 BEFORE SUB COURT,
ERNAKULAM
Exhibit P10
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED
20.07.2022 I,A NO. 8 OF 2022 IN O.S
190 OF 2017 BEFORE SUB COURT,
ERNAKULAM
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review