Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) No.54 of 2025
Benu Ranjan Goswami,
Son of Late Rash Mohan Goswami,
Resident of Singhamura, South Badharghat,
PO-Charipara, PS-Amtali, Agartala,
West Tripura, Pin-799003, Age-62 years.
.....Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. The State of Tripura, represented by the Commissioner &
Secretary to the Department of Agriculture & Farmers Welfare,
Government of Tripura, New Secretariat Complex, Gurkhabasti,
Agartala, PO-Kunjaban, PS-New Capital Complex, Sub-DivisionSadar, District-West Tripura.
2. The Commissioner & Secretary, Finance Department,
Government of Tripura, New Secretariat Complex, Gurkhabasti,
Agartala, PO-Kunjaban, PS-New Capital Complex, Sub-DivisionSadar, District-West Tripura.
3. The Director, Department of Agriculture & Farmers
Welfare, Government of Tripura, Krishi Bhawan, Akhaura Road,
PO-Agartala, PS-West Agartala, Sub-Division-Sadar, District-West
Tripura.
4. The Executive Engineer (Mechanical), Department of
Agriculture & Farmers’ Welfare, Government of Tripura, POAgartala, PS- West Agartala, District- West Tripura, Pin-799001.
5.
The Accountant General (A & E), Tripura, PO- Kunjaban,
PS- New Capital Complex, Sub-Division- Sadar, District- West
Tripura.
6.
The Senior Accounts Officer, Office of the Accountant
General (A & E), Tripura, PO- Kunjaban, PS- New Capital Complex,
Sub-Division- Sadar, District- West Tripura.
----Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. Purusuttam Roy Barman, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Koomar Chakraborty, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Dipankar Sarma, Addl. GA
Mr. Soumyadeep Saha, Adv.
Date of hearing
and delivery
of Judgment & Order :
30.07.2025
Whether fit for
reporting
YES
:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order(Oral)
The present writ petition is filed by the petitioner
seeking the following reliefs:
“i) Issue Rule, calling upon the Respondents and
each one of them, to show cause as to why a Writ of
Mandamus and/or in the nature thereof, shall not be
issued, mandating/directing them to revoke/rescind
the
impugned
Letters
dated
25.04.2023
&
10.01.2025 (Annexures-2 & 7 respectively supra);
ii) Issue Rule, calling upon the Respondents and
each one of them, to show cause as to why a Writ of
Mandamus and/or in the nature thereof, shall not be
issued, mandating/directing them, not to recover
any amount, either from the pensionary benefits of
the Petitioner, or from his monthly pension, on
account of the alleged excess payment;
iii) Issue Rule, calling upon the Respondents and
each one of them, to show cause as to why a Writ of
Mandamus and/or in the nature thereof, shall not be
issued, mandating/directing them, to release the
remaining Gratuity (amounting to Rs.2.5 lacs),
alongwith Interest thereon (due to belated payment
thereof), in favour of the Petitioner, and also, to
modify the PPO of the Petitioner by restoring his
actual Last Pay of Rs.1,20,500/-, and thereupon,
release the arrears thereof;
iv) In the Ad-interim, and thereafter, on hearing the
parties, in the Interim, an Order in terms of (i) & (ii)
above;
v) Call for the records, appertaining to this Writ
Petition;
vi) After hearing the parties, be pleased to make the
Rule absolute in terms of (i) to (iv) above;
vii) Costs of and incidental to this proceeding;
viii) Any other Relief(s) as to this Hon’ble High
Court may deem fit and proper;”
2.
Heard Learned Senior Counsel, Mr. Purusuttam Roy
Barman assisted by Learned Counsel, Mr. Koomar Chakraborty
appearing on behalf of the petitioner. Also heard Learned Addl. GA,
Mr. Dipankar Sarma appearing on behalf of the respondents-State
and Learned Counsel, Mr. Soumyadeep Saha appearing on behalf of
the respondent Nos.5 and 6.
3.
Ranjan
Brief fact of the case is that the petitioner namely, Benu
Goswami
joined
in
the
post
of
Extension
Officer
(Engineering), Group-C under the Department of Agriculture,
Government of Tripura on 29.12.1987. Thereafter, on completion of
4(four) years of service, he was given the benefit of gradation/auto
movement to the post of Junior Engineer (Mechanical), Grade-I
(Group-B) w.e.f. 29.12.1991. Again, on completion of next 8(eight)
years of service, he was granted the benefit of CAS-II w.e.f.
29.12.1999. After that on completion of 25 years of service he was
given the benefit of ACP-III w.e.f. 29.12.2012 and after rendering a
considerable period of time, he superannuated from service on
31.01.2023.
3.1.
Thereafter, the petitioner received one letter dated
25.04.2023 issued by the respondents reducing the Last Pay of the
petitioner from Rs.1,20,500/- to Rs.1,13,600/- on the premise of a
purported fixation. It was also mentioned in the said letter that the
balance amount of gratuity and the entire commuted value of
pension was withheld by the respondents. After that, again on
18.08.2023 a revised PPO was issued indicating his reduced Last
Pay of Rs.1,13,600/-. Thus, the monthly pension of the petitioner in
terms of his reduced Last pay was initiated and 75% of the gratuity
amount
was
released.
However,
the
respondents
withheld
remaining gratuity amounting to Rs.2.5 lakhs and the entire
commuted value of pension. Being aggrieved, the petitioner
submitted a representation on 27.07.2023 to the respondent
authority requesting not to recover any amount and to release his
outstanding dues. But as his grievance was unaddressed so, the
petitioner filed one writ petition before this Court bearing WP(C)
No.778 of 2023 which was disposed of on 29.01.2024 with a
direction to consider his representation within a period of 3(three)
months. However, the same was not complied with so, the
petitioner further filed Cont.Cas(C) No.93 of 2024 and in the
contempt proceeding this Court vide order dated 06.01.2025
directed the respondents to conclude the proceeding in pursuance
of order dated 29.01.2024 and to issue a speaking order by
01.02.2025. Thereafter, the respondent No.4 vide communication
dated 10.01.2025 directed the petitioner to deposit the alleged
excess
amount
of
Rs.5,75,504/-
within
4(four)
days.
Being
aggrieved with that communication, the petitioner filed the present
writ petition seeking the reliefs as stated above.
4.
At the time of hearing, Learned Senior Counsel for the
petitioner submitted that there was no fraud or misrepresentation in
discharging duties on the part of the petitioner and the Department
itself fixed the pay of the petitioner and if any excess payment was
made, that was due to the wrong fixation of pay by the
Department.
Moreover,
since
the
petitioner
has
gone
on
superannuation so, if at this stage, any recovery order is made that
should cause undue hardships to the petitioner and also would be
iniquitous. Learned Senior Counsel, Mr. Roy Barman further
submitted that in view of the principle of law laid down by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in State of Punjab vs. Rafiq
Masih, reported in (2015) 4 SCC 334 and in Thomas Daniel vs.
State of Kerala & Ors., reported in 2022 SCC OnLine SC 536
recovery is impermissible in the eye of law. Further, Learned Senior
Counsel referring another citation of the Hon’ble High Court of
Himachal Pradesh in S.S. Chaudhary vs. State of H.P. & Ors.
reported in 2022 SCC OnLine HP 900 drawn the attention of this
Court that in the said order, judgments passed by Hon’ble Supreme
Court of India and other High Courts were taken into consideration
and it was the observation of the High Court of Himachal Pradesh
that recovery would be impermissible at this stage although the
petitioner was a Group-B employee of the State Government and
furthermore observed that since the undertaking was executed long
back by the petitioner so, if at this stage recovery is made in that
case serious undue hardships would be caused to the petitioner.
5.
The claim of the petitioner was contested by the State-
respondents stating that the petitioner opted for ROP, 1999 and
gave an undertaking and in pursuance of that undertaking the
petitioner is bound to refund the amount. As such, the recovery
memo was valid as per law. It was further submitted that 75% of
gratuity and leave salary have already been paid to the petitioner
and a request was made to the Accountant General to release the
remaining amount of gratuity.
6.
The respondents-Accountant General took the plea that
discrepancy was found in pay fixation w.e.f. 01.01.2000 under ROP,
1999 and accordingly, a communication dated 25.04.2023 was sent
to Department with a copy to the petitioner. Learned Counsel for
respondent Nos.5 and 6 submitted that the commuted pension of
the petitioner was released on 18.08.2023 and further action will be
taken after Departmental clarification. It was further submitted that
the Office of respondent Nos.5 and 6 is working as the authorizing
agency.
7.
Learned Addl. GA for the State-respondents submitted
that the petitioner would not be covered by the provisions under
Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 rather as a State Government
employee his service conditions would be covered under the Tripura
State Civil Services (Revised Pay) Rules. Rules 5 and 6 of the
Tripura State Civil Services (Revised Pay) Rules, 2017 and
subsequent pay rules framed by the government time to time
governs the fixation of pay and recovery of excess payments, if
made, of the State government employees. Learned Addl. GA
submitted that in the judgment passed by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court of India in High Court of Punjab and Haryana & Ors. vs.
Jagdev Singh, reported in (2016) 14 SCC 267, Hon’ble the Apex
Court held that recovery from a retired government employee is
permissible if an undertaking was furnished at the time of making
option for a revised pay scale. It was further submitted that
whenever any government employee is moved from one scale to
another revised pay scale in that case he/she is to execute one
option as per the existing rules. Furthermore, the Government of
Tripura has formulated revised pay rules but in the citations
referred by Learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner nowhere it is
found that in those citations any discussions were made about the
service rules of a particular State. The petitioner in the present case
has not challenged the PPO on the basis of which his payment was
reduced and since the judgments relied upon by the Learned Senior
Counsel for the petitioner has not been passed on the basis of any
service rules so, the same cannot be binding upon the employees of
the State government. Moreso, the petitioner was a retired Group-B
employee so, the principles laid down in the said judgment cannot
be applied. In this connection, Learned Addl. GA relied upon
another citation of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in State of
Punjab & Ors. vs. Ram Lubhaya Bagga & Ors. reported in
(1998) 4 SCC 117 and submitted that in view of para Nos.20, 28
and 33 it is revealed that until and unless the policy and the rule is
not challenged there is no scope to pass any order in favour of the
petitioner. Further, Learned Addl. GA relied upon another citation of
the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in Hardev Singh vs. Union of
India & Anr. reported in (2011) 10 SCC 121 wherein in para
No.26, Hon’ble the Apex Court observed as under:
“26. Similarly, in Balco Employees' Union v. Union of India
[(2002) 2 SCC 333] it has been held that a court cannot
strike down a policy decision taken by the Government
merely because it feels that another policy would have been
fairer or wiser or more scientific or logical. It is not within
the domain of the court to weigh the pros and cons of the
policy or to test the degree of its beneficial or equitable
disposition.”
Relying upon the same Learned Addl. GA submitted that
since the Government of Tripura has formulated pay rules and in
the pay rules it is clearly mentioned regarding execution of
undertaking, that in the event of excess drawal of payment due to
miscalculation, the concerned employee would be bound to refund
the amount and as in the present case the petitioner was a Group-B
employee and he executed option. So, in view of the judgment of
the Hon’ble Supreme Court as cited supra the petitioner cannot take
the benefit of the same until and unless the revised pay rule of the
State is set aside or modified by the State authority. It was further
submitted that as per Central Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1972
as adopted by the State of Tripura and as per Rule 64(3) and Rule
75(2)(b) of the said rules there is scope for recovery of the excess
amount, if made. Learned Addl. GA further submitted that the
citations referred by Learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner
would also not be applicable in the given case because those
judgments does not cover the effect of binding service rules or
undertaking given under the State government regulation and the
action taken by the department is within the scope of the relevant
rules of the State. Learned Addl. GA further submitted that 75% of
the gratuity and other retirement benefits including leave salary
have already been disbursed/released in favour of the petitioner
and after the Court’s order dated 29.01.2024 in WP(C) No.778 of
2023, instructions were issued to the Account Officer, O/o the
Principal Accountant General (A&E) on 23.02.2024 to release the
remaining amount of Rs.2.5 lakhs of gratuity. The commuted value
of pension was also released on 18.08.2023. Learned Addl. GA also
submitted that the judgments relied upon by the Learned Senior
Counsel for the petitioner did not speak anything regarding the
decision rendered by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Jagdev Singh’s
case. Finally, Learned Addl. GA for the State-respondents submitted
that there is no merit in the present writ petition and as such, the
same deserves to be dismissed henceforth.
8.
To counter the submissions advanced by Learned Addl.
GA for the State-respondents, Learned Senior Counsel for the
petitioner further submitted that as cited by Learned Addl. GA in
Jagdev Singh(supra), the principle of law laid down in the said
citation would not be applicable in the present case as the subject
matter of the present case is different from that case.
9.
Now, after hearing both the sides it is to be decided by
this Court whether the recovery memo issued by respondent No.4
dated 10.01.2025 is legally permissible at this stage?
9.1.
Admittedly, the petitioner superannuated from service
on 31.01.2023. It is on record that he received the notice regarding
receiving of excess payment due to wrong pay fixation after
proceeding on retirement. It is also the admitted position that when
the petitioner went on superannuation that time he was in the
category of Group-B employee of the State. According to this Court,
since the petitioner was serving under the State Government
Department so he will not be guided under the provisions of the
Payment of Gratuity Act as because the payment of the gratuity of
the State Government employees is covered by the relevant service
rules of the State.
9.2.
Further, it is on record that 75% of gratuity is already
been released in favour of the petitioner and the rest 25% is still
pending for disbursal. The Accountant General in absence of
clarification from the Department or any other communication from
the Finance Department was reluctant to release the balance
amount of payment of gratuity in favour of the petitioner on the
ground that he has drawn excess payment. There cannot be any
divergent opinion that if any Group-B employee receives any excess
payment due to wrong fixation of pay in that case in view of the
undertaking executed by him he is not bound to refund the excess
amount to the Department. Here, in the case at hand, the action of
the
Department
started
after
the
petitioner
went
on
superannuation.
10.
Now, it is to be decided as to whether at this stage it
would be possible to restrain the Department from recovering any
amount from the petitioner allowing the Department to withhold the
payment of pending gratuity?
10.1.
This question is to be answered in the light of law
laid down by the Hon’ble Apex Court. As already stated, Learned
Senior Counsel for the petitioner relied upon two judgments of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and an order of Hon’ble High Court
of Himachal Pradesh at the time of hearing and submitted that
every government employee of the State has to submit an option
form for coming under the revised pay scale and has to give
undertaking that he will refund to the Government any amount
which may be drawn by him in excess of what is admissible to him
on account of erroneous fixation of pay in the revised pay structure
as soon as the fact of such excess drawal comes/brought to his
notice.
10.2.
Here, in the case at hand, the matter came to the
knowledge of the Accountant General and from para No.8 of the
counter affidavit filed by respondents Nos.5 and 6 it is revealed that
during the course of checking of the pension case some ambiguity
was found in the pay fixation w.e.f. 01.01.2000 as per option under
FR-22(I)(a)(2) vide memo No.F.6(1)-FIN(PC)/98, dated 03.07.2000
issued by the Finance Department, Government of Tripura for
admissible
benefit
of
CAS
under
ROP,
at
SL.
No.2.
Accordingly, the office of respondent No.5 communicated the
matter with the concerned Department vide letter dated 25.04.2023
and the commuted value of pension had already been released by
the office of respondent No.5 on 18.08.2023. It is further revealed
that the concerned Department has not furnished any reply as per
the
office
letter
dated
01.05.2023
as
well
as
letter
dated
03.10.2024 along with reminder letter dated 09.12.2024.
11.
In course of hearing of argument, Learned Senior
Counsel for the petitioner relied upon three citations as stated
above and Learned Addl. GA relied upon the judgment of Hon’ble
Supreme Court of India in Jagdev Singh (supra) and two other
judgments.
12.
I have gone through all the citations.
Let us discuss about the relevant paragraphs of the
citations referred by Learned Counsel for the parties.
13.
In Rafiq Masih (supra) referred by Learned Senior
Counsel for the petitioner Hon’ble the Apex Court at para No.18,
observed as under:
“18. It is not possible to postulate all situations of hardship
which would govern employees on the issue of recovery,
where payments have mistakenly been made by the
employer, in excess of their entitlement. Be that as it may,
based on the decisions referred to hereinabove, we may, as a
ready reference, summarise the following few situations,
wherein
recoveries
impermissible in law:
by
the
employers,
would
be
(i) Recovery from the employees belonging to Class III
and Class IV service (or Group C and Group D service).
(ii) Recovery from the retired employees, or the
employees who are due to retire within one year, of
the order of recovery.
(iii) Recovery from the employees, when the excess
payment has been made for a period in excess of five
years, before the order of recovery is issued.
(iv) Recovery in cases where an employee has
wrongfully been required to discharge duties of a
higher post, and has been paid accordingly, even
though he should have rightfully been required to
work against an inferior post.
(v) In any other case, where the court arrives at the
conclusion, that recovery if made from the employee,
would be iniquitous or harsh or arbitrary to such an
extent, as would far outweigh the equitable balance of
the employer's right to recover.”
Further, in Thomas Daniel(supra), Hon’ble the Apex
Court in para Nos.12 and 13 referred the cases of Syed Abdul
Qadir vs. State of Bihar, (2009) 3 SCC 475 and Rafiq Masih
(supra) respectively and finally allowed the same setting aside the
judgment of the Division Bench of the High Court and the connected
writ Court. The relevant para Nos.12 and 13 are reproduced
hereunder:
“12. In Syed Abdul Qadir v. State of Bihar, (2009) 3 SCC 475
excess payment was sought to be recovered which was made
to the appellants-teachers on account of mistake and wrong
interpretation of prevailing Bihar Nationalised Secondary
School (Service Conditions) Rules, 1983. The appellants
therein contended that even if it were to be held that the
appellants were not entitled to the benefit of additional
increment on promotion, the excess amount should not be
recovered from them, it having been paid without any
misrepresentation or fraud on their part. The Court held that
the appellants cannot be held responsible in such a situation
and recovery of the excess payment should not be ordered,
especially when the employee has subsequently retired. The
court observed that in general parlance, recovery is
prohibited by courts where there exists no misrepresentation
or fraud on the part of the employee and when the excess
payment
has
been
made
by
applying
a
wrong
interpretation/understanding of a Rule or Order. It was held
thus:
“59. Undoubtedly, the excess amount that has been
paid to the appellant teachers was not because of any
misrepresentation or fraud on their part and the
appellants also had no knowledge that the amount that
was being paid to them was more than what they were
entitled to. It would not be out of place to mention
here that the Finance Department had, in its counteraffidavit, admitted that it was a bona fide mistake on
their part. The excess payment made was the result of
wrong interpretation of the Rule that was applicable to
them, for which the appellants cannot be held
responsible. Rather, the whole confusion was because
of inaction, negligence and carelessness of the officials
concerned of the Government of Bihar. Learned
counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant teachers
submitted that majority of the beneficiaries have
either retired or are on the verge of it. Keeping in view
the peculiar facts and circumstances of the case at
hand and to avoid any hardship to the appellant
teachers, we are of the view that no recovery of the
amount that has been paid in excess to the appellant
teachers should be made.”
13. In State of Punjab v. Rafiq Masih (White Washer), (2015)
4 SCC 334 wherein this court examined the validity of an
order passed by the State to recover the monetary gains
wrongly extended to the beneficiary employees in excess of
their entitlements without any fault or misrepresentation at
the behest of the recipient. This Court considered situations
of hardship caused to an employee, if recovery is directed to
reimburse the employer and disallowed the same, exempting
the beneficiary employees from such recovery. It was held
thus:
“8. As between two parties, if a determination is
rendered in favour of the party, which is the weaker of
the two, without any serious detriment to the other
(which is truly a welfare State), the issue resolved
would be in consonance with the concept of justice,
which is assured to the citizens of India, even in the
Preamble of the Constitution of India. The right to
recover being pursued by the employer, will have to be
compared, with the effect of the recovery on the
employee concerned. If the effect of the recovery from
the employee concerned would be, more unfair, more
wrongful, more improper, and more unwarranted, than
the corresponding right of the employer to recover the
amount, then it would be iniquitous and arbitrary, to
effect the recovery. In such a situation, the employee's
right would outbalance, and therefore eclipse, the
right of the employer to recover.
xxx
xxx
xxx
18. It is not possible to postulate all situations of
hardship which would govern employees on the issue
of recovery, where payments have mistakenly been
made by the employer, in excess of their entitlement.
Be that as it may, based on the decisions referred to
hereinabove, we may, as a ready reference, summarise
the following few situations, wherein recoveries by the
employers, would be impermissible in law:
(i) Recovery from the employees belonging to
Class III and Class IV service (or Group C and
Group D service).
(ii) Recovery from the retired employees, or the
employees who are due to retire within one year,
of the order of recovery.
(iii) Recovery from the employees, when the
excess payment has been made for a period in
excess of five years, before the order of recovery is
issued.
(iv) Recovery in cases where an employee has
wrongfully been required to discharge duties of a
higher post, and has been paid accordingly, even
though he should have rightfully been required to
work against an inferior post.
(v) In any other case, where the court arrives at
the conclusion, that recovery if made from the
employee, would be iniquitous or harsh or
arbitrary to such an extent, as would far outweigh
the equitable balance of the employer's right to
recover.”
Again, in Jagdev Singh(supra) referred by Learned
Addl. GA, the Hon’ble Apex Court in para Nos.8 to 13 observed as
under:
“8. The order of the High Court has been challenged in these
proceedings. From the record of the proceedings, it is evident
that when the respondent opted for the revised pay scale, he
furnished an undertaking to the effect that he would be liable
to refund any excess payment made to him. In the counteraffidavit which has been filed by the respondent in these
proceedings, this position has been specifically admitted
[State of Punjab v. Rafiq Masih, (2015) 4 SCC 334 : (2015) 2
SCC (Civ) 608 : (2015) 2 SCC (L&S) 33] . Subsequently, when
the Rules were revised and notified on 7-5-2003 it was found
that a payment in excess had been made to the respondent.
On 18-2-2004, the excess payment was sought to be
recovered in terms of the undertaking.
9. The submission of the respondent, which found favour
with the High Court, was that a payment which has been
made in excess cannot be recovered from an employee who
has retired from the service of the State. This, in our view,
will have no application to a situation such as the present
where an undertaking was specifically furnished by the
officer at the time when his pay was initially revised
accepting that any payment found to have been made in
excess would be liable to be adjusted. While opting for the
benefit of the revised pay scale, the respondent was clearly
on notice of the fact that a future refixation or revision may
warrant an adjustment of the excess payment, if any, made.
10. In State of Punjab v. Rafiq Masih [State of Punjab v.
Rafiq Masih, (2015) 4 SCC 334 : (2015) 2 SCC (Civ) 608 :
(2015) 2 SCC (L&S) 33] this Court held that while it is not
possible to postulate all situations of hardship where
payments have mistakenly been made by an employer, in the
following situations, a recovery by the employer would be
impermissible in law : (SCC pp. 334-35)
(i) Recovery from employees belonging to Class III
and Class IV service (or Group C and Group D service).
(ii) Recovery from retired employees, or employees
who are due to retire within one year, of the order of
recovery.
(iii) Recovery from employees, when the excess
payment has been made for a period in excess of five
years, before the order of recovery is issued.
(iv) Recovery in cases where an employee has
wrongfully been required to discharge duties of a
higher post, and has been paid accordingly, even
though he should have rightfully been required to
work against an inferior post.
(v) In any other case, where the Court arrives at the
conclusion, that recovery if made from the employee,
would be iniquitous or harsh or arbitrary to such an
extent, as would far outweigh the equitable balance of
the employer's right to recover.
(emphasis supplied)
11. The principle enunciated in Proposition (ii) above cannot
apply to a situation such as in the present case. In the
present case, the officer to whom the payment was made in
the first instance was clearly placed on notice that any
payment found to have been made in excess would be
required to be refunded. The officer furnished an undertaking
while opting for the revised pay scale. He is bound by the
undertaking.
12. For these reasons, the judgment of the High Court which
set aside the action for recovery is unsustainable. However,
we are of the view that the recovery should be made in
reasonable instalments. We direct that the recovery be made
in equated monthly instalments spread over a period of two
years.
13. The judgment [Jagdev Singh v. State of Haryana, CWP
No. 3999 of 2005, decided on 1-8-2005 (P&H)] of the High
Court is accordingly set aside. The civil appeal shall stand
allowed in the above terms. There shall be no order as to
costs.”
14.
From the revised pay rules of the State it appears that
at the time of movement from one scale to another as per the
prevailing rule, any employee of the State Government is/was
supposed to execute option form/undertaking. In the present case
also the petitioner submitted option form/undertaking to the
respective department during his movement from one scale to
another. In the case relied upon by the respondents-State it
appears that on the basis of undertaking given by the petitioner of
that case, the Hon’ble Apex Court set aside the order of the High
Court and observed that the judgment of the High Court which set
aside the action for recovery was unsustainable. Ultimately, the
Hon’ble Apex Court passed an order for recovery in reasonable
installments.
15.
Here, in the case at hand, after hearing both the sides
and also after perusal of the documents relied upon by the parties it
appears that the petitioner being a Group-B employee of the State
Government submitted option form to the Department that in the
event of drawal of excess payment, he should be bound to refund
the same. But, in the judgments relied upon by the petitioner there
was no fact regarding the execution of any option form by the
concerned employees. So, the principle laid down in the aforesaid
judgments relied upon by the petitioner cannot be applied in the
present case. Furthermore, it is also not the case of the petitioner
that the petitioner is an employee under the category of Group-C or
Group-D of the State Government rather it is on record that he
superannuated from service holding a post under Group-B category
under the State-Government. So, the recovery notice issued by
respondent No.4 cannot be said to be legally unsustainable at this
stage.
16.
As such, considering the facts and circumstances of the
case no relief can be granted in favour of the present petitioner.
Learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner in course of hearing of
argument although asserted some other points but those points are
not at all relevant for decision of the present writ petition and this
Court does not think it prudent to discuss all those points at this
stage for the sake of decision of this writ petition.
In view of the above, the present writ petition bears no
merit. Accordingly, the same stands dismissed. However, there shall
be no order as to cost.
17.
It is necessary to be mentioned herein that there was no
fault on the part of the petitioner concerned and there was no fraud
or misrepresentation on the part of the petitioner in regard to
fixation of his pay rather it was the Department who fixed the time
to time pay structure of the petitioner concerned and by this time
the petitioner has proceeded on superannuation. So, considering
the facts and circumstances of this case it would be prudent that
the respondent department may adjust the unpaid amount of
gratuity with the proposed recovered amount and after adjustment
the balance amount, if still remains unpaid, would be recovered by
the respondent department within a period of 6(six) years in equal
installments that too without any interest.
JUDGE
Snigdha
signed by
MOUMIT Digitally
MOUMITA DATTA
2025.07.31
A DATTA Date:
15:30:32 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review