Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
OWP No.2210/2018
CM Nos. 785 & 8871/2021
IA No. 1/2018
Reserved on: 12.02.2026
Pronounced on: 10.03.2026
Uploaded on: 11.03.2026
Whether the operative part or full
judgment is pronounced: Full
1. Bansi Lal aged 53 years,
2. Gian Chand aged 73 years
3. Chuni Lal aged 67 years,
(All sons of Punnu Ram R/o Village Dadwar,
Tehsil Gandoh, District Doda at present Village
Chhaiyal, Tehsil and District Kathua.)
…..Petitioner(s)
Through: Mr. R P Sharma, Sr. Advocate with
Mr. Rohit Gupta, Advocate
Vs
1. State of J&K through Commissioner-cum-Secretary
Revenue Department, Civil Secretariat, Jammu.
2. J&K Special Tribunal, Jammu.
3. Gurdeep Singh
4. Ashok Kumar
(Both sons of Late Sh. Madho Lal)
5. Amro Devi Wd/o Late Sh. Madho Lal
6. Lata Kumari d/o Late Sh. Madho Lal,
(All residents of Quarter No. 9, Police Family Quarter,
Channi Himmat, Jammu.)
7. Moti Lal S/o Punnu Ram R/o Dadwar, Tehsil Gandoh,
District Doda.
..Respondent(s)
Through: Ms. Priyanka Bhat, Assisting Counsel to
Mrs. Monika Kohli, Sr. AAG
Mr. Vishal Goel, Advocate
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE WASIM SADIQ NARGAL, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
Prayer:
01. Petitioners, through the medium of this petition, have sought the
following relief:
“Issuance of an appropriate writ, direction or order of the nature of
OWP No. 2210/2018
Certiorari to quash and set aside the order dated 17.10.2018, passed by the
J&K Special Tribunal, Jammu in case of Revision File No. STJ/73/2018,
titled ‘Gurdeep Singh and others vs. Bansi Lal and others’.”
Brief Facts:
02. The short grievance projected through the medium of the instant petition
is that the order passed by the Revisional Court is bad in the eyes of law
and is liable to be set aside, whereby the Revisional Authority, while
allowing the said revision petition, set aside the impugned order and
remanded the matter back to the Tehsildar, Kathua, for de novo enquiry
with a direction to pass a fresh order after hearing the parties.
03. It is the case of the petitioners that it was not a case of remand as the
order passed by the Appellate Authority was correct and the revision was
not maintainable and ought to have been dismissed.
04. It is the specific case of the petitioners that the order dated 17.10.2018,
which is impugned in the present petition, has been passed by respondent
No. 2 in case titled ‘Gurdeep Singh & Ors vs. Bansi Lal & Ors’, in File
No. STJ/73/2018, whereunder by exercising powers of revision it has set
aside the judgment of the Additional Deputy Commissioner, Kathua
(Commissioner, Agrarian Reforms) passed in appeal against Mutation
No. 135 under Section 8 and 132 under Section 4.
05. It has also been urged by the learned counsel for the petitioners that the
learned Tribunal has exceeded the scope of its revisional jurisdiction by
reversing the order passed by the Appellate Authority. According to the
petitioners, the revisional jurisdiction under Section 21(2) of the J&K
Agrarian Reforms Act can be exercised only when a question of law or an
issue of public interest is involved.
OWP No. 2210/2018
06. It is contended that in the present case, neither any question of law nor
any issue of public interest was involved in the revision petition and,
therefore, the learned Member of the Tribunal was not competent to
interfere with the order passed by the Appellate Authority. It is further
submitted that the Tribunal has neither recorded its opinion regarding the
existence of any such question of law or public interest nor referred to
any such question while exercising revisional jurisdiction.
07. It is also contended that the Mutation No. 132 dated 12.12.1983 under
Section 4 of the Agrarian Reforms Act was attested by the Tehsildar,
Kathua in favour of Madho Lal, Gian Chand, Chuni Lal, Moti Ram and
Bansi Lal, sons of Punnu Ram, in equal shares on the basis of their
possession since Kharif 1971 as tenants of Jagan Nath. It is submitted that
Jagan Nath himself made a statement for correction of Girdawari for the
year 1971 onwards from his name to the names of Madho Lal, Gian
Chand, Chuni Lal, Moti Ram and Bansi Lal with respect to Survey No.
173 min and Survey No. 175 min situated at village Chhajiyal, Tehsil and
District Kathua, as a consequence whereof they were declared
prospective owners under the Agrarian Reforms Act. Thereafter,
Mutation No. 135 dated 12.04.1984 under Section 8 of the Agrarian
Reforms Act was also attested by the Tehsildar, Kathua in favour of the
aforesaid persons, thereby conferring ownership rights upon them in
equal shares over the said land which was jointly in their possession.
08. It is further submitted that Madho Lal, having been declared as one of the
prospective owners and subsequently conferred ownership rights under
the aforesaid mutations, had himself signed the mutation orders and
OWP No. 2210/2018
admitted cultivation of the land from Kharif 1971 onwards. Since Madho
Lal had never challenged the said orders during his lifetime, the legal
heirs were held to have no right to assail the same. The Appellate
Authority thus concluded that the appellants had not approached the
Court with clean hands and, finding no illegality in the mutation
proceedings, rejected both the appeals.
09. It is the specific case of the petitioners that there was no occasion for the
Tribunal to disbelieve the factual findings returned by the Appellate
Authority. It is further contended that under Mutations No. 132 and 135
attested under Sections 4 and 8 of the Agrarian Reforms Act respectively,
the petitioners were recorded as joint holders of tenancy rights and were
thereafter conferred ownership rights jointly in equal shares along with
Madho Lal with respect to Survey No. 173 measuring 16 kanals and
Survey No. 175 measuring 12 kanals 02 marlas, totalling 28 kanals 02
marlas of land situated at village Chhajiyal.
10. Lastly, it is submitted that the order of remand passed by the J&K Special
Tribunal directing a de novo enquiry amounts to an illegal exercise of
jurisdiction. According to him, the said order is perverse, being based on
erroneous principles of law, and therefore cannot sustain the test of
judicial scrutiny.
Arguments on behalf of the petitioner:
11. Mr. Sharma, learned Senior Counsel appearing on behalf of the
petitioners, has drawn the attention of this Court to the order passed by
the Appellate Authority, a perusal whereof reveals that the father of the
appellants therein, namely Late Sh. Madhu Lal, was present at the time of
OWP No. 2210/2018
attestation of both the mutations and had admitted the contents of the
orders dated 12.12.1983 and 12.04.1984, pertaining to Mutation No. 132
under Section 4 of the Agrarian Reforms Act and Mutation No. 135 under
Section 8 of the Agrarian Reforms Act, respectively, as his signatures are
available on both the orders.
12. The Appellate Court took note of the aforesaid fact and, while dismissing
the appeals preferred by the respondents herein, observed that the legal heirs
of Late Sh. Madhu Lal had no right whatsoever to challenge the said orders,
inasmuch as the father of the appellants therein, who was declared as one of
the prospective owners and was thereafter conferred ownership rights by
virtue of the mutation orders referred to in the appeals, had himself signed
both the mutations and had admitted cultivation of the land from Kharif
1971 till date.
13. The Appellate Court further observed that Late Sh. Madhu Lal had never
challenged the orders passed under Sections 4 and 8 of the Agrarian
Reforms Act during his lifetime and, therefore, his legal heirs were
estopped from assailing the same. In view of the aforesaid facts, the
Appellate Court held that the appellants had not approached the Court
with clean hands and, finding no illegality or violation of the rules,
dismissed both the appeals preferred by the appellants therein.
14. Feeling aggrieved of the same, the respondents therein preferred revision
in terms of the Agrarian Reforms Act against the order dated 17.01.2018
passed by the Additional Deputy Commissioner, Kathua, exercising the
powers of Commissioner, Agrarian Reforms, whereby the said authority
had dismissed two appeals preferred by the petitioners therein–respondents
OWP No. 2210/2018
herein challenging Mutation No. 132 dated 12.02.1983 and Mutation No.
135 dated 12.04.1984. The Revisional Court, as per record, allowed the
revision preferred by the respondents herein, set aside the impugned order
and remanded the matter back to the Tehsildar, Kathua, for de novo
enquiry, with a direction to pass a fresh order after hearing the parties. The
aforesaid order passed by the Revisional Authority is the subject matter of
the instant petition.
Arguments on behalf of the respondents:
15. Per contra, Mr. Vishal Goel, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
respondents, has drawn the attention of this Court to the order passed by
the Appellate Authority, a perusal whereof reveals that the Appellate
Authority, on the same day, had condoned the delay and, in a “hush hush”
manner, decided the appeal on merits by referring to the record when, in
fact, the original record was neither summoned nor examined. It is
submitted that the concerned Additional Deputy Commissioner, exercising
the power of the Appellate Authority, was under a legal obligation to call
for and examine the original record and only thereafter to record findings
based on such record. Having failed to do so, the finding recorded by the
Appellate Authority cannot sustain the test of law, as the order passed by
the Appellate Authority is without due application of mind and also
without examining the original record.
16. The learned counsel further submits that what was required to be done by
the Appellate Authority has not been done and, instead, findings have been
recorded as if the record had been examined, which is factually incorrect.
How and under what circumstances the Appellate Authority could have
OWP No. 2210/2018
examined the record when the Appellate Authority had decided the
condonation application and, on the same day, had also heard the appeal on
merits, remains unexplained. Thus, from perusal of the record, it appears
that the Appellate Authority had not summoned the original record and
instead recorded the findings in a “hush hush” manner, as per the learned
counsel for the respondents.
17. Mr. Goel further submits that the procedural irregularity/illegality which
was committed by the Appellate Authority was later on rectified by the
Revisional Authority, and the Revisional Authority, while passing the
order, had summoned the original record and, after examining the record,
recorded a finding that there was infraction of Rule 50 of the Agrarian
Reforms Rules and also that the Rules framed under the Agrarian
Reforms Act were not adhered to at the time of attestation of the
impugned mutations. In addition, the Revisional Authority has recorded a
finding that all the violations of the rules, although raised in the memo of
appeal before the Appellate Authority, were not considered by the
Appellate Authority, which, according to the Revisional Authority,
constituted questions of law.
18. Thus, according to Mr. Goel, the arguments advanced by Mr. Sharma that
the Revisional Authority has neither recorded its opinion regarding the
existence of any question of law or public interest involved in the case is
factually incorrect when such finding has already been recorded about the
existence of a question of law while passing the aforesaid order. Thus, the
averment to that extent by the petitioner is factually incorrect and liable to
be rejected. Mr. Goel has further drawn the attention of the Court to the
OWP No. 2210/2018
finding recorded by the Revisional Authority that though Late Sh. Madho
Lal was in possession of land in Kharif 1971, the co-sharer who was not in
possession of the land in Kharif 1971 cannot claim share on the basis of
other co-sharers by placing reliance upon the judgment passed by this Court,
and accordingly, by assigning cogent reasons and examining the original
record, the revision petition was allowed, the impugned order was set aside
and the matter was remanded back to the Tehsildar, Kathua, for de novo
enquiry with a direction to pass a fresh order after hearing the parties.
19. Mr. Goel has further submitted that the Revisional Authority, while
minutely examining the original record, recorded a finding that the
Appellate Authority had incorrectly observed that Late Sh. Madho Lal had
put his signatures on both the mutations, whereas the record revealed that
Late Sh. Madho Lal had affixed his thumb impression at the time of
attestation of the mutations. This clearly demonstrated, according to the
learned counsel, that the Appellate Authority had not properly examined
the original record and had recorded findings contrary to the material
available on record. Thus, the Revisional Authority, after examining the
original record, rightly interfered with the order passed by the Appellate
Authority.
20. It has also been submitted by Mr. Goel that the Revisional Authority, upon
examination of the record, has further recorded a finding that mutations in
question were attested at headquarters and not on spot, which was violative
of Rule 14 of the Agrarian Reforms Rules read with Standing Order 23-A
governing the procedure for attestation of mutations. According to the
learned counsel, these violations had been specifically raised before the
OWP No. 2210/2018
Appellate Authority but were not considered, and the Revisional Authority,
after noticing the said violations of statutory provisions and procedural
irregularities, rightly allowed the revision petition and remanded the matter
to the Tehsildar, Kathua, for de novo enquiry and for passing a fresh order
after hearing the parties.
21. Thus, according to Mr. Goel, the order passed by the Revisional
Authority is perfectly legal, and the challenge to the same is ill-founded.
He contends that the challenge to the impugned order is devoid of merit
and that the writ petition deserves to be dismissed. He further submits
that since no prejudice has been caused to the petitioner, the writ petition
is liable to be dismissed, as the impugned order is merely an order of
remand. It was also submitted that the Revisional Authority has already
recorded a finding that Standing Order 23-A has been violated.
Arguments by way of rebuttal:
22. Mr. Sharma, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioners, in
rebuttal, has submitted that the Revisional Authority could have exercised
its powers only in the eventuality of the existence of any question of law
or public interest involved in the case. Merely stating in the impugned
order that a question of law is involved does not satisfy the statutory
requirement and, thus, according to Mr. Sharma, the revision ought not to
have been entertained and the impugned order cannot sustain the test of
law and is liable to be quashed.
23. He further contended that existence of a question of law or public interest
is sine qua non for exercising revisional jurisdiction in conformity with
Section 21(2) of the Agrarian Reforms Act and the Revisional Authority
OWP No. 2210/2018
is required to record findings in that regard. Thus, according to Mr.
Sharma, the Revisional Authority has exceeded its jurisdiction while
interfering with the judgment of the Appellate Authority and, on this
ground alone, the impugned order cannot sustain the test of law and is
liable to be quashed.
Legal Analysis:
24. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the material placed on
record.
25. At the outset, this Court finds considerable force in the contentions
advanced by the learned counsel for the respondents that the impugned
order passed by the revisional authority is merely an order of remand
directing a de novo enquiry by the Tehsildar Kathua. The revisional
authority has neither adjudicated upon the rights of the parties nor has it
conclusively determined the dispute between them. The effect of the
order is only that the matter has been returned back to the competent
authority for fresh consideration after examining the record and hearing
the parties. It is settled principle of law that courts while exercising writ
jurisdiction do not interfere with the orders of remand particularly when
such orders do not finally determine the rights or cause any grave
injustice or prejudice to either of the parties. When a matter is remanded
the authority to whom it is assigned is required to re-examine the issue
afresh after affording equal opportunity of being heard to the concerned
parties. Thus, the parties retain full liberty to place their case before the
competent authority and establish their respective claims. In the present
case, the revisional authority has not adjudicated the rights of the parties,
OWP No. 2210/2018
but has merely set aside the order of the appellate authority directing the
Tehsildar to conduct a fresh enquiry after examining the record. Such an
order cannot be said to have deprived the petitioners of any of their
substantive rights. On the contrary, they will have full opportunity before
the Tehsildar during the de novo enquiry to demonstrate the legality of
the mutations in question. Therefore, the grievance projected by the
petitioner against the remand order is premature as the matter has yet to
be finally adjudicated.
26. This Court in “Mohd. Nasir Ud Din Petitioner vs. Aftab Ahmad Khan
& Anr.”, OWP No. 182/2004, decided on 12.06.2012, while dealing with
the scope of interference by this Court in writ jurisdiction against an order
of remand passed by the revenue authorities, held as under:
“5. Concerned Tehsildar had to make the order while following
the mandate of Order 23A which appears to have not been done.
The order is a remand order and does not affect the rights of any
party. Case has been remanded for enquiry, so it is for the
Revenue Agency and respondent No. 1 to appear before
Tehsildar and project their case.
7. This court, in series of cases, has held that when the writ
jurisdiction can be invoked, obviously the case in hand is not one
of such cases.”
27. It goes without saying that the writ jurisdiction is meant to correct the
jurisdictional errors or manifest illegality resulting in miscarriage of justice.
It is not intended to be invoked against orders which merely facilitated the
proper adjudication of disputes. Viewed from this perspective, challenge to
the impugned order of remand cannot be sustained.
28. The main contention advanced by the learned counsel for the petitioners
is that the revisional authority could have exercised jurisdiction under
OWP No. 2210/2018
section 21(2) of the Agrarian Reforms Act, only when, a ‘question of law’
or ‘public interest’ is involved. According to the learned counsel for the
petitioners, no such question existed in the present case, therefore the
order of revisional authority is without jurisdiction. However, a careful
perusal of the order of the revisional authority reveals that the revisional
authority after summoning and examining the original record noticed
several serious infirmities in the order passed by the appellate authority.
29. The Revisional Authority has categorically recorded the findings that the
Appellate Authority has decided the appeal without summoning and
examining the original record and the findings which were recorded were
contrary to the material available on record. The Revisional Authority
further noticed that the Appellate Authority failed to adhere to the
procedure contemplated under Rule 50 of the Agrarian Reforms Rules,
which casts a duty upon the appellate authority to properly examine the
record and conduct enquiry, where the correctness of entries relating to
personal cultivation is in dispute. Such findings clearly disclose the
existence of a substantial question of law relating to legality and
procedural compliance, thereby justifying the exercise of revisional
jurisdiction. The revisional jurisdiction is intended to ensure that
subordinate authorities act within the limits of law and follow the
procedure prescribed while exercising their powers. When an order is
passed without examining the record or by overlooking the relevant
statutory provisions, the same amounts to a legal infirmity warranting
interference.
30. Since Rule 50 of the Agrarian Reforms Rules also has a direct bearing
OWP No. 2210/2018
on the controversy involved in the present petition, the same is
reproduced hereunder:
[50. Place of hearing.–– The officer competent to hear appeal
may, as far as practicable, hear such appeal at the headquarters
of the district or Tehsil to which it relates:
Provided that where correctness of an entry relating to personal
cultivation of land is in dispute, the objection may, as far as
practicable, be disposed of at site in presence of the general
village body and no costs for serving notice on the villagers to
attend shall be demanded from any party].
31. In the present case, the revisional authority after minutely examining the
record has observed that the appellate authority had recorded the findings
regarding the signatures of Late Sh. Madhu Lal on the mutations orders
whereas the original record reveals that he had affixed his thumb
impression instead of signatures being illiterate. This discrepancy itself
shows that the appellate authority has not examined the original record
with the required degree of scrutiny. Such an error is not merely a factual
irregularity but goes to the root of the legality of the decision. Therefore,
the revisional authority was justified in holding that the matter involved
question of law requiring interference in revision.
32. This Court in “Atta Mohd. Katoch vs. J&K Special Tribunal and
others”, LPAOW No. 251/2002 along with CMA No. 284/2002, decided
on 12.05.2015, while explaining the scope of revisional jurisdiction under
Section 21 of the Agrarian Reforms Act, held as under:
“13. ….According to Section 21 of the Act 1976, the Revisional
authority has the power to exercise revisional jurisdiction if it finds
that a question of law or public interest is involved in the case.
14. Applying the provisions of the Agrarian Reforms Act to a
piece of land, which does not at all attract the provisions of the
Act or attesting a mutation contrary to the provisions prescribed
for attestation of such mutations does involve a question of law
and to that extent, there was nothing wrong in the revisional
OWP No. 2210/2018
authority exercising its revisional jurisdiction and remanding
the matter back to the Tehsildar to conduct a denovo enquiry.”
33. Another aspect which is of significance in the present case is the manner in
which the appellate authority disposed of the appeals filed by the
respondents. The record reveals that the appellate authority condoned the
delay and on the very same day proceeded to decide the appeals on merits.
34. The law relating to condonation of delay requires that the court must first
examine whether sufficient cause has been shown for the delay before
embarking upon an examination of the merits of the case. In this regard,
the Hon’ble Apex court in ‘Thirunagalingam Vs. Lingeswaran &
Anr.’, 2025 INSC 672, has held as under :
“31. It is a well-settled law that while considering the plea for
condonation of delay, the first and foremost duty of the court is
to first ascertain the bona fides of the explanation offered by
the party seeking condonation rather than starting with the
merits of the main matter. Only when sufficient cause or
reasons given for the delay by the litigant and the opposition
of the other side is equally balanced or stand on equal footing,
the court may consider the merits of the main matter for the
purpose of condoning the delay.
32. Further, this Court has repeatedly emphasized in several
cases that delay should not be condoned merely as an act of
generosity.”
35. The same principle has been reiterated by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
“Commissioner, Nagar Parishad, Bhilwara Vs. Labour Court,
Bhilwara And another”, (2009) 3 SCC 525, has held as under:
“….4. While rejecting the application for condonation of delay,
the High Court had considered the merits of the appeal and then
rejected the application for condonation of delay.
OWP No. 2210/2018
5. While deciding an application for condonation of delay, it is
well settled that the High Court ought not to have gone into the
merits of the case and would have only seen whether sufficient
cause had been shown by the appellant for condoning the delay
in filing the appeal before it.”
36. Furthermore, it is important to note that the appellate authority recorded
its findings on the basis of the record without actually summoning or
examining the original record. Such failure to examine the record renders
the entire decision arbitrary and legally unsustainable. The revisional
authority therefore rightly concluded that the order of the appellate
authority suffered from procedural infirmity and lack of proper
application of mind, thereby, necessitating interference in revision.
Consequently, the decision of the revision authority to set aside the order
of the appellate authority and remit the matter for fresh consideration
cannot be faulted.
37. The revisional authority has also recorded a finding that the mutations in
question were attested at headquarters instead of being attested on the
spot, which was contrary to the requirements of Rule 14 of the Agrarian
Reforms Rules read with Standing Order 23-A, which mandates that
mutation proceedings are to be conducted on spot in the village where the
land is situated. In the present case, the revisional authority observed that
the allegations regarding illegal attestation of mutations at headquarters
and violation of statutory procedure had been specifically raised before
the appellate authority but were not examined at all.
38. The respondents had specifically raised before the Appellate Authority
the issue of gross violation of the procedure prescribed under Standing
OWP No. 2210/2018
Order 23-A read with Rule 14 of the Agrarian Reforms Rules governing
the attestation of mutations. Despite these specific objections having been
raised in the memo of appeal, the Appellate Authority failed to advert to
or consider the same and proceeded to decide the matter in a hurried
manner without examining the legality of the mutation proceedings in the
light of the statutory procedure applicable thereto. The relevant averments
made in the memo of appeal are as under:
“5. That again the impugned order has been made ex-parte
without giving any notice to the appellant in a concealed manner
against the principles of natural justice and in violation of
Standing Order 23-A and Rule 14(2), where it is mandatory for
the revenue official to give publicity regarding the attestation of
mutation and to avoid ex-parte mutation, and the order of
mutation itself shall show that sufficient steps were taken to the
persons against whom such proceedings have been taken in
support of the contention of the petitioner.
6. That the impugned mutation has been passed at HQ and not at
the village where the said land has been situated just to confer
undue benefit upon the respondents, as one of the brothers of the
respondents namely Bhag Singh, who was serving as a revenue
official, has connived with the respondents and got the impugned
mutation attested at a place which is more than 20 Kms away
from the spot, same being violative of provisions of law, as the law
creates an obligation on the mutating officer to attest every
mutation and record a finding thereon only after affording an
opportunity of being heard to all concerned and after conducting
enquiry on spot. The mutating officer in the instant case has
passed the mutation arbitrarily, perversely and illegally, with
material irregularities and utter disregard to the sound principles
of law, as has been held by the Hon’ble J&K Special Tribunal in a
Revision Petition titled Des Raj and Ors. vs State of J&K,
reported in J&K Judgments, page 803 of 2003, Vol. (I), “Mutation
attested in absence of petitioner is bad in law and liable to be set
aside.”Accordingly, appeal was accepted and case was remanded
OWP No. 2210/2018
back to Tehsildar for passing fresh order. Mutation attested in
absence of the petitioner is bad in law and liable to be set aside.”
39. Such failure to consider a material issue affecting the legality of the
proceedings itself constitutes a legal error. Therefore, the revisional
authority was right in holding that the matter required reconsideration
after examining whether the mutation proceedings were conducted in
accordance with the statutory rules.
40. In order to appreciate the controversy in its proper perspective and to
examine the legality of the mutation proceedings in question, it would be
appropriate to notice the relevant statutory provision governing the
procedure for attestation of mutations under the Agrarian Reforms Rules.
Rule 14 of the Agrarian Reforms Rules, which has a direct bearing on the
issue involved in the present petition, reads as under:
“14. Procedure and competence for attesting mutations. –– (1)
Mutations under this Chapter shall, subject to the provisions
herein contained, be attested, in accordance with the procedure
provided by Standing Order No. 23-A, by a Revenue Officer, in or
near the village to which these pertain.
[Provided that no Naib-Tehsildar shall attest any disputed
mutation or any other such mutation where change or correction
of any entry of Khasra Girdawari is involved unless he is
empowered for the said purpose by the Commissioner appointed
under section 18 of the Act.]
(2) Ex parte proceedings on mutations, even if permitted shall be
avoided, as far as possible, and where such proceedings are taken
in accordance with law, the mutation order and the record
accompanying such mutation, shall show that sufficient steps
were taken to give notice to the person against whom such
proceedings have been taken.”
41. A plain reading of the aforesaid provision makes it abundantly clear that
mutation proceedings under the Agrarian Reforms Act are required to be
OWP No. 2210/2018
conducted in accordance with the procedure prescribed under Standing
Order 23-A and ordinarily in or near the village where the land in
question is situated so as to enable the revenue officer to verify the claims
of the parties on the spot and in their presence.
42. In the present case, the record reveals that the mutations in question were
attested at the headquarters instead of being attested on the spot in the
village where the land is situated. Such a course adopted by the mutating
authority is clearly contrary to the procedure mandated under Rule 14 read
with Standing Order 23-A and renders the mutation proceedings vulnerable
in law, particularly when the legality of such proceedings is called into
question before the competent forum. It is a settled principle of law that
where the law prescribes a specific manner for performing an act, the same
must be adhered to strictly, and any deviation from the prescribed procedure
renders the action legally unsustainable.
43. The above principle has been recognized by the Apex Court in ‘Meera
Sahni Vs. Lieutenant Governor of Delhi and others’, (2008) 9 SCC
177, held as under:
“35. It is by now a certain law that an action to be taken in a
particular manner as provided by a statute, must be taken, done or
performed in the manner prescribed and in no other manner. In this
connection we may appropriately refer to the decision of this Court in
Babu Verghese v. Bar Council of Kerala (1999) 3 SCC 422 wherein it
was held as under:
“31. It is the basic principle of law long settled that if the manner of
doing a particular act is prescribed under any statute, the act must be
done in that manner or not at all. The origin of this rule is traceable to
the decision in Taylor v. Taylor (1875) 1 Ch D 426 which was
followed by Lord Roche in Nazir Ahmad v. King Emperor (1936) 63
IA 372, AIR 1936 PC 253 (2) who stated as under: (IA pp. 381-82)
‘where a power is given to do a certain thing in a certain way, the
OWP No. 2210/2018
thing must be done in that way or not at all.’
44. This Court in “Puran Chand and others Vs. J&K Special Tribunal
and others”, WP(C) No. 1327/2020, decided on 04.09.2024, while
dealing with the scope of revisional jurisdiction under the Agrarian
Reforms Act and the legality of mutation proceedings conducted in
violation of Standing Order 23-A, has held as under:
“6. Perusal of the record reveals that mutation Nos. 570 and 582
supra attested in favour of the father of the petitioners herein under
section 4 and 8 of the Act, 1976 indisputably have had not been
attested in line and tune with the provisions of the Standing Order 23A which standing order provides for attestation of mutations in the
Deh (village) wherein the land is situated which requirement is aimed
at to determine the rights and interests of the parties on spot in
presence of the parties. In view of the aforesaid position obtaining in
the matter inasmuch as the claims and counter claims lodged by the
parties against each other qua the land in question, the Revisional
Forum-respondent 1 herein thus on this question of law falling under
Section 21 of the Act of 1976 has rightly set aside the mutations and
directed holding of a de novo enquiry by the concerned Tehsildar and
for passing of fresh orders after affording an opportunity of hearing to
the parties leaving it open to the parties to project their respective
claims before the Tehsildar and in turn requiring the Tehsildar
concerned to adjudicate upon the same in accordance with law.
8. Having regard to the aforesaid position and principle of law
inasmuch as the facts noticed in the preceding paras, this Court is of
the considered opinion that interference under Article 226 of the
Constitution is not warranted in the matter, firstly, on the ground of
nature of the order passed by the Tribunal being admittedly an order
of remand and secondly, in view of the nature of the dispute raised by
the parties herein being disputed facts.”
45. Similarly, this Court in “Ab. Salam Bangroo Vs. Financial
Commissioner and another”, OWP No. 157/2005, decided on
27.06.2016, while emphasizing the importance of adherence to the
statutory procedure governing mutation proceedings, held as under:
OWP No. 2210/2018
“16) Attestation of mutation is not a routine matter. It should not
offend the procedure prescribed under Standing Order 23- A nor
should it be attested on the basis of any document or otherwise, which
shall be in contravention of any law.”
46. The aforesaid statutory provision as well as the judicial precedents noticed
hereinabove clearly emphasize that mutation proceedings under the
Agrarian Reforms Act are required to be conducted strictly in accordance
with the procedure prescribed under Standing Order 23-A read with Rule 14
of the Agrarian Reforms Rules.
47. The requirement of conducting mutation proceedings on spot in the
village where the land is situated is intended to ensure transparency in the
process and to enable the revenue officer to ascertain the factual position
regarding possession and cultivation in the presence of the concerned
parties. Any departure from such procedure, particularly where mutation
is attested at the headquarters instead of on spot, would naturally invite
scrutiny by the competent forum.
Conclusion:
48. In view of the foregoing discussion and upon a careful consideration of the
pleadings, record and the settled legal position governing the field, this
Court is of the considered opinion that the impugned order passed by the
Revisional Authority does not suffer from any illegality, perversity or
jurisdictional error warranting interference by this Court in exercise of its
extraordinary writ jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India. On the contrary, the record reveals that the Revisional Authority,
after summoning and examining the original record, has rightly noticed the
procedural irregularities committed by the Appellate Authority,
OWP No. 2210/2018
particularly the failure to examine the original record and the nonadherence to the statutory procedure governing mutation proceedings. The
Revisional Authority was therefore fully justified in exercising its
revisional jurisdiction under Section 21 of the Agrarian Reforms Act and in
remanding the matter to the competent authority for a fresh enquiry in
accordance with law.
49. It is trite that an order of remand which merely facilitates proper
adjudication of the dispute and affords opportunity to the parties to
establish their respective claims cannot ordinarily be interfered with in writ
jurisdiction unless it results in manifest injustice or jurisdictional error,
which is conspicuously absent in the present case. The petitioners shall
have full opportunity before the Tehsildar during the de novo enquiry to
place their case and demonstrate the legality of the mutations in question.
Consequently, this Court finds no merit in the present petition.
50. Accordingly, the writ petition being devoid of merit is dismissed along
with connected applications.
51. Registry is directed to return the records of the case to the concerned
authorities forthwith.
(WASIM SADIQ NARGAL)
JUDGE
Jammu:
10.03.2026
Vijay
Whether the order is speaking: Yes
Whether the order is reportable: Yes
Vijay Kumar
2026.02.11 03:45
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review