Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
NAFR
Digitally
RAGHVENDRA signed by
JAT
RAGHVENDRA
JAT
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
CR No. 315 of 2025
Order Reserved on: 9.2.2026
Order Delivered on: 9.4.2026
1 - Bank Of Baroda Branch - Rosarb, Through Chief Manager, Prahlad
Kumar Jha, S/o Deochandra Jha, Aged About 45 Years, Address Bank
Of Baroda, Regional Office Rajkishor Nagar Bilaspur, District- Bilaspur
C.G. (Defendant No. 1)
... Applicant(s)
versus
1 - M/s. Start Up Engineers I.D.B.I Bank In Front Of A T M, Sindhi
Colony, Tahsil And District Bilaspur, Through Partner Fazle Rasul, R/o
H/88, Narmada Nagar, Nehru Nagar, Tahsil And District Bilaspur C.G.
And Partner- Smt. Sujata Manik (Plaintiff No. 1).
2 - Smt. Shabnam Aara W/o Abdul Kalam Aged About 60 Years R/o
Ward No. 7, House No. 1569, Gurughasidas Nagar Mini Basti,
Jarhabhatha, Tahsil And District Bilaspur C.G.(Plaintiff No. 2).
3 - Rashtriya Laghu Ughog Nigam Limited (Government Of India
Undertaking), Through Manager, 204, A-Block,cristal Arkid, Near
Lodhipara Chowk, Raipur 492007 C.G.(Defendant No.2).
4 - Vishwajeet Bhoumik, Proprietor, Uddan Finance Company
Jarhabhatha, Bilaspur C.G. (Defendant No. 3).
5 - M/s Abhilash Engineering, Through Manager, Abhilash Banarjee,
Office Address- Uddan Finance Company Building, Jarhabhatha,
Bilaspur R/o Lane No. 3 And 4 Bangali Para, Sarkanda Tahsil And
District Bilaspur C.G. (Defendant No. 4).
6 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through The Collector, Bilaspur, District
Bilaspur C.G. (Defendant No. 5)
... Respondent(s)
For Applicant(s)
: Mr. Punit Ruparel, Advocate.
For Respondent(s) No. : Mr. Neeraj Kumar Sharma, Advocate
1&2
along
with
Mr.
Anurag
Agrawal,
Advocate.
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Amitendra Kishore Prasad
C A V Order
1. By way of this revision, the applicant has prayed for following
reliefs:“i.
quash/set-aside
the
impugned
order
dated
24.06.2025 passed by First Additional District Judge,
Bilaspur
(C.G.)
in
Civil
Suit
(A)/88/2019
and
consequently the application filed under Order 7 Rule
11of CPC may kindly be pleased to allow and dismiss
the civil suit as prayed in the said application.
ii. quash/set-aside the order 24.06.2025 passed by the
trial court i.e. First Additional District Judge, Bilaspur in
Civil Suit (A)/88/2019.
iii. call for the entire record pertaining to the Civil Suit
(A)/88/2019 for kind perusal.
iv. any other relief as Hon'ble Court may pleased to
grant it.”
2. Brief facts of the case, is that, by way of the present civil revision,
the revisionist Bank has challenged the impugned order dated
24.06.2025 passed by the First Additional District Judge, Bilaspur
(C.G.) in Civil Suit (A)/88/2019, whereby the application filed by
the revisionist under Order VII Rule 11 of the Code of Civil
Procedure was dismissed. The plaintiffs/respondent Nos. 1 and 2
instituted a civil suit seeking declaration and injunction for a sum
of Rs. 60,00,600/-, contending that plaintiff No. 1 had availed a
loan of Rs. 40,00,000/- from the revisionist Bank on 04.06.2019
for extension of his business, and that, as security, defendant No.
2 (mother of plaintiff No. 1) mortgaged her immovable property
situated at Tifra, P.H. No. 21, diverted land Sheet No. 19/20, Plot
No. 45, Khasra No. 724/05, Rakba 2200 sq.ft., Gayatri Nagar
Ward, Bhartiya Nagar, Tahsil and District Bilaspur, with original
documents handed over to defendant No. 3, however, upon
default, the plaintiffs alleged fraud and cheating against defendant
No. 3, Vishwajeet Bhaumik, who had allegedly assured sanction
of the loan and retained signed cheques of plaintiff No. 2. The
Bank/defendant No. 1 filed a counter-claim raising all objections
and asserting that the allegations of fraud do not confer
jurisdiction upon the civil court. Simultaneously, the Bank
approached the Debt Recovery Tribunal, Jabalpur, which, after the
borrowers remained ex parte, passed judgment dated 04.11.2024
in Original Application No. 230/2022 in favour of the Bank,
permitting sale of the mortgaged and other properties, restraining
the borrowers from dealing with their assets, and issuing a
Recovery Certificate under Section 19(22) of the Recovery of
Debts and Bankruptcy Act for Rs. 59,07,165/-. Thereafter, on
29.07.2025, the Recovery Officer issued a demand notice
claiming the awarded amount with simple interest and costs of Rs.
62,000/-. Earlier, the plaintiffs preferred M.A. No. 33/2022
challenging rejection of their application under Order XXXIX Rules
1 and 2 CPC, wherein status quo was granted by the Hon’ble
Court and the matter remains pending. The revisionist Bank had
also approached the Hon’ble Court in Writ Petition (227) No.
6/2023, wherein by order dated 22.08.2023 the trial court was
directed to conclude the suit within one year, yet no substantial
progress has been made since the suit’s institution on 04.12.2019.
It is submitted that the plaintiffs have not challenged the DRT
judgment before the Debt Recovery Appellate Tribunal, and the
DRT order has thus attained finality, nevertheless, they continue
the civil suit on the same subject matter relating to the mortgaged
property, while the Bank is proceeding to realize its dues through
auction pursuant to the DRT order. The revisionist had earlier filed
Writ Petition (227) No. 599/2023 challenging dismissal of its order
VII Rule 11 application, which was withdrawn with liberty to file a
civil revision under Section 115 CPC, and thereafter Civil Revision
No. 125/2023 was allowed by judgment dated 10.07.2024,
wherein it was held that Section 34 of the SARFAESI Act, 2002
bars the jurisdiction of civil courts in matters falling within the
domain of the DRT and consequently the suit was held not
maintainable. The revisionist further relies upon the judgment of
the Hon’ble Supreme Court reported in (2014) 1 SCC 479,
wherein it has been categorically held that the jurisdiction of the
civil court is completely barred in such matters and that the
borrower’s remedy lies under Section 13(4) read with Section 17
of the SARFAESI Act before the DRT. Despite the statutory bar
and the finality of the DRT proceedings, the trial court dismissed
the application under Order VII Rule 11 CPC, compelling the
revisionist to file the present civil revision, as the civil suit is clearly
barred by law and not maintainable in view of the SARFAESI Act
and the Recovery of Debts and Bankruptcy Act.
3. Learned counsel for the applicant submits that the present civil
revision has been preferred assailing the impugned order dated
24.06.2025 passed in Civil Suit No. A-88/2019 whereby the
learned Trial Court rejected the applicant’s application under
Order VII Rule 11 of the CPC, and it is prayed that the suit
pending before the Trial Court be dismissed as not maintainable.
Learned counsel contends that the suit is barred in law,
particularly in view of Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation
Act, and further submits that the Bank had already initiated
proceedings before the Debt Recovery Tribunal, Jabalpur, which
culminated in an order in favour of the Bank that has attained
finality, the same having not been challenged before the Debt
Recovery
Appellate
Tribunal,
Allahabad,
notably,
the
plaintiffs/respondent Nos. 1 and 2 neither appeared nor filed any
reply before the DRT proceedings. It is argued that despite having
availed and enjoyed the loan amount, which was duly credited to
their accounts and remains unpaid, the plaintiffs have instituted
the present civil suit on the plea of fraud in respect of the
mortgaged property, which action is legally impermissible and
amounts to an attempt to circumvent and overreach the final order
passed by the DRT. Learned counsel further submits that the
objection raised by the plaintiffs regarding the earlier rejection of
an application under Order VII Rule 11 and the filing of WP (227)
No. 6/2023 is misconceived, as the said writ petition was disposed
of merely with a direction for expeditious disposal of the suit and
did not adjudicate upon the merits of the application under Order
VII Rule 11, hence, the principle of res judicata is not attracted. It
is also contended that the impugned order dated 24.06.2025 does
not record any finding that the subsequent application is barred by
res judicata, and since the plaintiffs have not independently
challenged the said order on that ground before any competent
forum, they are precluded from raising such objection in the
present revision. Placing reliance upon the judgment of the
Calcutta High Court in Ashwin Desai v. Bijay Kumar Manish
Kumar HUF (C.O. 3348 of 2016), it is urged that a second
application under Order VII Rule 11 CPC is maintainable,
particularly when there is a material change in circumstances, as
in the present case where the Bank secured a final order from the
DRT after rejection of the earlier application. It is further submitted
that the doctrine of res judicata does not bar successive
applications where subsequent developments materially alter the
factual matrix, and the applicant has approached this Hon’ble
Court with full disclosure of all prior proceedings, including the
order dated 22.08.2023 passed in WP (227) No. 6/2023. Learned
counsel additionally relies upon recent pronouncements of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court holding that an application under Order
VII Rule 11 CPC can be entertained at any stage of the
proceedings, and submits that the controversy involved in the
present case is squarely covered by the judgment rendered by
this Hon’ble Court in Civil Revision No. 125/2023 (AFR Judgment)
dated 10.07.2024, wherein in similar circumstances the suit was
dismissed. On these grounds, it is prayed that the present revision
be allowed and the civil suit pending before the Trial Court be
rejected in limine.
4. On the other hand, learned counsel for respondents No. 1 & 2
submits that Civil Suit No. 58-A/2019 is presently pending before
the learned First Additional District Judge, Bilaspur, at the stage of
production of evidence by the revisioner/defendant, and the trial is
proceeding in accordance with law. It is contended that the
present civil revision is wholly misconceived and not maintainable
either in law or on facts, inasmuch as the revisioner is seeking to
re-agitate an issue that already stood conclusively decided by
order dated 23.12.2019, whereby the earlier application under
Order VII Rule 11 CPC was rejected and the said order has
attained finality. The impugned order dated 24.06.2025 arises
from rejection of a second application under Order VII Rule 11
CPC filed by the same defendant on identical grounds, which is
impermissible and barred by law. Learned counsel submits that in
WP (227) No. 6/2023, the Hon’ble High Court merely directed
expeditious disposal of the suit and did not interfere with or set
aside the order dated 23.12.2019; hence, the revisioner cannot
derive any benefit from the said proceedings to justify the filing of
a subsequent application. It is further submitted that the order
dated 31.03.2022 passed in MA No. 33/2022 only directed the
parties to maintain status quo with respect to the suit property and
did not adjudicate upon the merits of the rejection of plaint. The
issue regarding rejection of the plaint under Order VII Rule 11
CPC having already been adjudicated between the same parties
by a competent court and not having been overturned, the same
operates as res judicata under Section 11 CPC, and therefore a
second application on the same grounds is clearly barred. It is
also a settled principle of law that while deciding an application
under Order VII Rule 11 CPC, the Court is required to confine
itself strictly to the averments contained in the plaint and the
documents filed therewith, and the defence taken in the written
statement or the documents relied upon by the defendant are
wholly irrelevant for that purpose. In view of the aforesaid
submissions, it is most respectfully prayed that this Hon’ble Court
be pleased to dismiss the present civil revision as not
maintainable. He has placed reliance upon the judgment in the
matter of Sulthan Said Ibrahim vs. Prakasan and others, 2025
INSC 764.
5. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
material available on record.
6. The Calcutta High Court in the matter of Ashwin Desai vs. Bijay
Kumar Manish Kumar HUF, (2017) 3 CalHCN 788, the High
Court has observed as under:“18. The learned Court below the rejected second
application of the defendant petitioner for rejection of the
plaint filed in the suit on the ground that on rejection of
the earlier application under Order 7. Rule 11 of the Code
no such second application lies under the same
provision. The learned Court below held that the
aforementioned order dated March 31, 2015 passed by
this Court in C.O. 1093 of 2015 not having been assailed
by the defendant anywhere is binding on it. It was
contended on behalf of the plaintiff opposite party that
the said finding of the learned Court below is the correct
exposition of law. However, no decision or authority was
cited before me to support the said finding of the learned
Court below. However, it is to be noted that the reasoned
decision by which this Court held the earlier application
of the defendant petitioner under Order 7, Rule 11 to be
not maintainable was passed in C.O. 1092 of 2015 and
not in C.O. 1093 of 2015 as recorded in the impugned
order. In the facts of the present case already discussed
above, it is evident that the grounds urged by the
defendant petitioner in the second application for
rejection of plaint and the ground urged in his said earlier
application decided by this Court in the aforementioned
earlier revisional application are completely different.
Therefore, the dismissal of the earlier application of the
defendant petitioner for rejection of the plaint could not
render the second application of the defendant petitioner
under Order 7, Rule 11 of the Code to be not
maintainable. For all these reasons, I am unable to
convince myself to sustain the finding of the learned
Court below that in view of the rejection of the earlier
application of the defendant petitioner under Order 7,
Rule 11 of the Code, his said second application for
rejection of the plaint was not maintainable. In the facts
of the instant case, as I have already discussed, the
finding of the learned Court below that the defendant filed
the said second application to misuse and abuse the
judicial process cannot be sustained.”
7. Considering the facts and circumstances of the case and further
considering the rival submissions advanced by learned counsel
for the parties and a comprehensive scrutiny of the material
available on record, this Court is of the considered opinion that the
impugned order dated 24.06.2025 passed by the learned First
Additional District Judge, Bilaspur, rejecting the application
preferred by the revisionist Bank under Order VII Rule 11 of the
Code of Civil Procedure, is legally unsustainable and suffers from
patent infirmity. The record unequivocally reveals that the
revisionist Bank had already invoked the jurisdiction of the Debt
Recovery Tribunal, Jabalpur, by instituting Original Application No.
230/2022, which culminated in a final judgment and order dated
04.11.2024 in favour of the Bank, whereby a Recovery Certificate
under Section 19(22) of the Recovery of Debts and Bankruptcy
Act was duly issued for recovery of a sum of Rs. 59,07,165/together with applicable interest and costs. It is not in dispute that
the said adjudication has not been assailed before the Debt
Recovery Appellate Tribunal and has, therefore, attained finality
and binding effect between the parties. In the face of such
conclusive adjudication, the statutory bar engrafted under Section
34 of the SARFAESI Act, 2002 squarely operates, expressly
excluding the jurisdiction of the civil court in respect of matters
which fall within the domain and competence of the Tribunal, and
relegating the aggrieved borrower to the remedies provided under
Sections 13(4) and 17 of the said Act. The continuation of the civil
suit, which in substance seeks to impede, question, or nullify the
enforcement of the secured asset and the recovery proceedings
undertaken pursuant to the DRT’s order, is thus manifestly barred
by law and constitutes an impermissible collateral challenge to a
final and binding adjudication. The objection raised on behalf of
the respondents that the second application under Order VII Rule
11 CPC is hit by the doctrine of res judicata is equally untenable,
for
the
reason
that
significant
and
material
subsequent
developments have intervened after the rejection of the earlier
application, most notably the final determination by the DRT and
issuance of the Recovery Certificate, which substantially alter the
factual and legal matrix of the case. It is well settled that an
application under Order VII Rule 11 CPC can be entertained at
any stage of the proceedings if, from a plain reading of the plaint,
the suit appears to be barred by any law for the time being in
force. The principles laid down in Ashwin Desai vs. Bijay Kumar
Manish Kumar HUF fortify the proposition that a subsequent
application is maintainable where fresh or distinct grounds arise
due to changed circumstances. The learned Trial Court, while
passing the impugned order, has failed to appreciate the binding
effect of the DRT’s final adjudication, the statutory ouster of civil
court jurisdiction, and the legal consequences flowing therefrom,
thereby exercising jurisdiction with material irregularity.
8. Consequently, the present civil revision merits acceptance and is
hereby allowed.
9. The impugned order dated 24.06.2025 passed in Civil Suit
(A)/88/2019 by the learned First Additional District Judge, Bilaspur
(C.G.) is set aside. As a necessary corollary, the plaint in the
aforesaid civil suit stands rejected under Order VII Rule 11(d)
CPC, being barred by law.
10. There shall be no order as to costs.
Sd/(Amitendra Kishore Prasad)
Judge
The date when The date when The date when the judgment is
the judgment is the judgment is uploaded on the website
reserved
9.2.2026
Raghu Jat
pronounced
9.4.2026
Operative
Full
-
15.4.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review