Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CHANDRAKANT
DEWANGAN
Digitally signed
by
CHANDRAKANT
DEWANGAN
Date:
2026.11.05
19:47:05 +0530
CGHC010434122026
2026:CGHC:46688
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WPC No. 5550 of 2026
1 - Sanvi Anand (Minor) D/o Shri Varun Anand Through Mother And
Natural Guardian, Smt. Akansha Anand (Dua), Aged About 40 Years
R/o House No. 6, Near Gurudwara, Ward No. 37, Adarsh Colony,
Bilaspur, (C.G.)
... Petitioner(s)
versus
1 - Union Of India Through - Secretary, Ministry Of External Affairs, New
Delhi.
2 - Regional Passport Office, Raipur 1st Floor, Commercial Complex,
Sector-4, Pt. Deendayal Upadhyay Nagar, Raipur (C.G.)
3 - Shri Varun Anand S/o Shri Ashok Anand Aged About 42 Years R/o
House No. 26, Chamber Of Commerce, Lalitpur Colony, Near Dr. Laha
Clinic, P.S. Indraganj, Tah. And Distt.- Gwalior (M.P.)
... Respondents
(Cause-title taken from the Case Information System)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------For Petitioner
:
Mr. Prafull N. Bharat, learned Senior
Advocate appears along with Mr.
Akash Pandey, Advocate
For Respondents No.1 and 2:
Mr. Abhishek Banjare, CGS
For Respondent No.3
:
None
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SB- Hon'ble Shri Justice Amitendra Kishore Prasad
Order On Board
04.11.2026
1. As the issue involved in this petition has already been
decided by this Court in Writ Petition (C) No.2186 of 2024 decided
on 29.04.2026 in the matter of Smt. Anshula Chaturvedi Versus.
Union of India and Another, as such, issuance of notice to
respondent No.3 is not required. Accordingly, after hearing
learned counsel for the concerned parties, i.e. Union of India, this
Court deems it proper to pass a final order.
2. The present writ petition under Article 226 and 227 of the
Constitution of India has been filed by the petitioner challenging
the order dated 18.09.2026, whereby the application filed by the
minor petitioner for grant of passport has been rejected on the
ground that her father had not issued no objection for the said
purpose. The petitioner has further sought a direction to the
respondents to issue passport/visa in her faour without insisting
upon such consent.
3. The case of the petitioner in brief is that the parents of the
petitioner, namely, Smt. Akansha Dua and Shri Varun Anand got
married on 20.06.2014 and out of the said wedlock, the petitionerSanvi Anand was born on 27.10.2020. It is submitted that the
marriage between the parents of the petitioner has been dissolved
by a decree of divorce dated 09.05.2025. Mother of the petitioner,
namely, Akansha Anand is holding a passport. The petitioner, on
13.12.2025 submitted an application for grant of passport before
respondent No.2 and oп 18.09.2026, respondent No.2 passed an
order and communicated the petitioner that in view of nonsubmission of no objection by her father regarding giving consent
for issuance of passport, the application of the petitioner has been
rejected.
4. Following reliefs have been prayed by way of this petition:-
“10.1. To call for the records of the case for the kind
perusal of this Hon'ble Court.
10.2 To issue an appropriate writ or order and declare
that the order dated 18.09.26 (Annexure P-1) is illegal
and bad in law and also in contravention of the
Passport Act, 1967 and the Passport Act, 1967 and the
Passport Rules, 1980.
10.3 To issue an appropriate writ or order and quash
that the order dated 18.09.26 (Annexure P-1) is illegal
and bad in law and also in contravention of the
Passport Act, 1967 and the Passport Rules, 1980.
10.4 To issue an appropriate writ or order and direct
res.no.1 & 2 to issue the passport of petitioner on the
strength of Annexure C without requiring the consent
or appearance of the father.
10.5 Any other relief deemed fit in the facts and
circumstances of the case may also be granted. ”
5. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the action of the
respondent authorities in refusing to issue passport in the name of
the petitioner (minor) solely on the ground of not giving consent by
her father is illegal, arbitrary, and unsustainable in law, being
violative of Articles 14 and 21 of the Constitution of India. It is
contended that the insistence on such consent, despite the
peculiar facts of the case, is mechanical and without application of
mind. It is further submitted that the marriage between the parents
of the petitioner already stands dissolved by a judgment and
decree dated 09.05.2025 passed under Section 13-B of the Hindu
Marriage Act, 1955, and the petitioner (minor child) is residing with
her mother. As per the said decree, the custody of the minor child
has been granted to the petitioner’s mother and it has been
recorded that the father has no objection to the custody of the
minor child remaining with her mother, therefore, insistence on
obtaining consent of the father is wholly unjustified. It is also
submitted that there is no dispute regarding custody of the minor
child, and the petitioner (minor) residing with her mother, is
competent to apply for issuance of passport/visa. The petitioner’s
mother is not aware of the present whereabouts of her former
husband, making compliance of such requirement impossible and
unreasonable.
6. Learned counsel further submits that the petitioner, who is a
minor, on 13.12.2025 submitted an application for grant of
passport before respondent No.2 and oп 18.09.2026, respondent
No.2 passed the order and communicated the petitioner that in
view of non-submission of no objection by her father regarding
giving consent for issuance of passport, the application of the
petitioner has been rejected. The petitioner was compelled to
seek closure only due to the persistent and unjustified insistence
of the Passport Authority on furnishing the father’s consent,
despite subsistence of a valid decree of divorce and undisputed
custody.
Such
closure
cannot
be
treated
as
voluntary
abandonment, but was merely a procedural compulsion. It is also
submitted that the action of the respondents is contrary to the
provisions of the Passport Act, 1967, particularly Section 6, which
exhaustively enumerates the grounds for refusal of passport, and
the insistence on obtaining consent of the father, does not fall
within any of the statutory grounds prescribed therein.
7. Learned counsel further submits that the minor petitioner had
applied for grant of passport in terms of Annexure ‘C’ of the
Passport Manual, which specifically governs case, where one
parent is unable to obtain consent of the other parent. A plain
reading of Annexure ‘C’ makes it clear that it is intended to relax
the requirement of consent of both parents in genuine cases. The
rigid insistence by the respondent authority defeats the very object
and purpose of the said provision. It is also argued that as per the
Passport Rules, 1980 and the Passport Manual, 2020, in cases
involving divorced parents, applications for issuance of passport
to minor children are required to be processed with care and
sensitivity, and the child’s right to travel abroad cannot be
defeated merely due to absence of consent of the other parent,
particularly when custody is undisputed. Reliance is placed on the
judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Maneka Gandhi vs.
Union of India (1978) 1 SCC 248 to contend that the right to
travel abroad is an integral part of personal liberty under Article 21
of the Constitution of India, and therefore, denial of passport to the
minor child on such technical grounds is unconstitutional.
Reliance has also been placed upon the various judgments
passed in the matter of Yushika Vevek Gedam vs. Union of
India and Ors. 2025 SCC OnLine Bombay 46, Chaitanya S.
Nair (Minor) vs. Union of India in the High Court of Kerala in
WPC No.22555/2021, Poem Jaiswar vs. Union of India and
Another in the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad in WPC No.
9771/2025 as also in Juvairiya vs. Regional Passport Officer in
the High Court of Kerala in WPC No. 1870/2014. It is thus
submitted that the petitioner has fulfilled all necessary formalities,
and the rejection of the application solely on the ground of nonproduction of father’s consent is arbitrary, illegal, and liable to be
set aside.
8. Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the respondents
submits that the requirement of consent of both parents is in
accordance
with
the
applicable
rules/guidelines
governing
issuance of passport to a minor. It is contended that such
requirement is to safeguard the interest of the minor child and to
avoid any dispute relating to custody or parental rights. It is further
submitted that unless the requisite documents or exemptions as
per rules are furnished, the respondents cannot process the
application.
9. Having heard learned counsel for the parties at length and upon
perusal of the material available on record, this Court proceeds to
examine the controversy in its proper legal and factual
perspective. At the outset, certain foundational facts are not in
dispute: (i) the petitioner (minor) is living with her biological
mother; (ii) the marriage between the parents of the petitioner
stands dissolved by a decree of divorce dated 09.05.2025 passed
under Section 13-B of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955; and (iii) the
custody of the minor child has been unequivocally granted to the
petitioner’s mother, with the father retaining only limited visitation
rights. The decree further records that the father has no objection
to the child residing with her mother. Thus, the petitioner’s mother
status as the custodial parent is not only factual, but also legally
crystallized. The core issue that arises for consideration is
whether, in the facts of the present case, the respondent
authorities were justified in insisting upon the consent of the father
for issuance of passport to the minor child.
10.
Upon a careful reading of the statutory scheme governing
the field, particularly the Passports Act, 1967 and the Passport
Rules, 1980, it is evident that the law does not mandate an
inflexible or absolute requirement of consent of both parents in
every case. Section 5 of the Act permits an application for a
passport to be made by a parent or guardian in respect of a minor.
Further, the administrative framework, including the Passport
Manual and prescribed forms, specifically contemplates situations
where one parent may not be available or where consent cannot
be obtained. Annexure ‘C’, which has been placed on record, is a
clear reflection of such legislative and administrative intent,
providing a mechanism for declaration by a single parent in
appropriate cases.
11.
In the present case, the petitioner has invoked the said
mechanism by furnishing the requisite declaration and has also
explained that she is not aware of the present whereabouts of her
former husband. This assertion has not been controverted by the
respondents through any cogent material. In addition, the divorce
decree itself records the mutual understanding between the
parties regarding custody, thereby eliminating any apprehension
of inter se dispute concerning the minor child.
12.
In this context, reference may also be made to the decision
rendered by the High Court of Gujarat in Minor Khrisha Suresh
Hemnani & Ors. vs. Regional Passport Office Ahmedabad &
Anr. in R/Special Civil Applicaiton No. 14738 of 2025, wherein
the Court observed that procedural requirements relating to
consent of parents cannot be enforced in a rigid manner so as to
defeat the welfare and legitimate rights of a minor child,
particularly when one parent has lawful custody and there exists
no subsisting dispute regarding guardianship. The said decision
reiterates that the Passport Authorities are required to adopt a
pragmatic and purposive approach while dealing with applications
concerning minors and cannot insist upon compliance with
conditions that are either impracticable or unnecessary in the facts
of a given case. The principle laid down therein fully supports the
case of the present petitioner. Relevant paras of the said order are
quoted hereinbelow:-
“5. As per Section Section 4(3) of the
Schedule-II of the Passport Rules, 1980
provides that a single parent who is separated,
but not formally divorced, is also eligible to
endorse consent to prefer an application and
get a passport and it apparently by way of
abundant
caution
that
the
authority
has
indicated that the passport could not be
granted unless there is consent of any of the
parent or if there was a Court order.
6. So far as the present case on hand is
concerned, it is not in dispute that decree of
divorce has already been obtained by the
present petitioner no.3 and respondent no.2 husband and subsequently, they got divorce
and as per the Memorandum of Understanding
executed between them, the custody of the
minor daughter and son is to be kept with the
mother i.e. the petitioner no.3 and considering
the same, the petitioner no.3 has applied for
renewal of the passport and the same was
rejected by the respondent no.1 on the ground
that the father's consent or No Objection for
minors' passports has not been produced
along with the application form.
7. Considering the above, this Court is inclined
to allow the present petition and the same is
hereby allowed. The respondent no.1 authority
is directed to consider the application dated
11.07.2025 preferred by the petitioner no.3 as
a single parent and renew the passports of
both the minor petitioner nos.1 and 2 i.e.
Khrisha Suresh Hemnani and Kiaan Suresh
Hemnani
as
expeditiously
as
possible
preferably within a period of 1 week from the
date of passing of this order.”
13.
Similarly, the High Court of Judicature at Bombay in the
matter of Miss Yushika (Supra) has held as under:“21……………..In these circumstances, in our
opinion, considering the well-settled position in
law, it cannot be that the petitioner's right to travel
abroad by issuance of a passport can in any
manner be scuttled and/or taken away by denying
her a passport to be issued/re-issued merely for
the reason that the father for the only reason that
he has disputes with the mother, is not supporting
the petitioner's application by consenting to it. Also
the petitioner's mother has submitted a declaration
in Annexure-C, which is now required to be
considered and processed by respondent no. 2.
22. It is well-settled that the expression "person
liberty"
which
occurs
in Article
of
the
Constitution includes right to travel abroad and no
person can be deprived of that right except
according to the procedure established in law. It is
held that the procedure prescribed by law has to
be
fair,
just
and
reasonable,
not
fanciful,
oppressive or arbitrary. The right to travel abroad
is a facet of fundamental right guaranteed under
Article 21 of the Constitution of India (See.
Maneka Gandhi vs. Union of India (1978 1 SCC
248)). The petitioner iscertainly entitled to such
constitutional right guaranteed under Article 21.
25. We may also observe that in the contemporary
times traveling abroad cannot be considered to be
a fanciful affair but has became an essential
requirement of modern life. Such need to travel
which may be the requirement of a child, a student
or an employee, professional or a person from any
other strata of the society, has undergone a
monumental change. Thus, the right to travel is
required to be not only recognized but made more
meaningful. This can be achieved and supported
by the authoritics implementing the provisions of
the Passport Act by effectively recognizing such
contemporary needs in dealing with passport
applications. The present case is an example of a
student being given an opportunity to undertake a
study tour by visiting a foreign country. Any action
of the Passport Authority in denying the passport
would
have
severe
consequence
not
only
adversely affecting the applicant in a given
situation, but it may cause irreparable harm to the
prospects of the applicant, for any venture she or
he intended to undertake. Thus, a mechanical
approach in this regard by the Passport Authority
cannot be countenanced.
24.We thus find that such valuable constitutional
right of the petitioner cannot be prejudiced much
less be taken away, and merely on the ground as
contained in the impugned communication dated
18 November, 2024 issued by respondent no. 2.
Further Section 6 of the Passport Act, 1967
provides
documents
for
Refusal
etc.
The
of
passports,
ground
on
travel
which
the
application of the petitioner is not being processed
is in no manner whatsoever recognized Section 6
of
the
Passport
Act.
In
the
aforesaid
circumstances, we find that there is no warrant in
law for respondent no. 2 to deny the re-issuance of
passport to the petitioner when the declaration in
Annexure-C was submitted by the petitioner's
mother.”
14.
The High Court of Kerala in the matter of Chaitanya
(Supra) has held as under:“12…………….., the passport issuing authority
cannot insist on consent from both parents for
issuing a passport to a minor child. Though in
earlier times, there was ambiguity and confusion
regarding the procedure to be adopted when
consent of both parents could not be obtained
while issuing a passport to a minor, by virtue of
several precedents, which were subsequently
incorporated as guidelines in the Passport
Manual, it has been provided that, if an affidavit is
filed in the form of Annexure-C (earlier AnnexureG) of Schedule III of the Passport Rules, 1980,
the passport issuing authority can issue a
passport to a mino child, without insisting upon
the consent of both parents. Therefore, even if
one of the parents of a minor child refused to give
consent, the passport issuing authority is entitled
to issue a passport to a minor, provided
Annexure-C is submitted. Juvairiya v. Regional
Passport Officer, Malappuram (2014 (2) KHC 53)
is an authority for the above proposition.”
15.
Also, the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad in the matter
of Poem Jaiswar (Supra) has held as under:“22. On the issue of passport issuance to the
minor where parents had dispute, Bombay High
Court observed that a minor's right to travel
abroad cannot be prejudiced merely because the
father,
involved
in
ongoing
matrimonial
proceedings, refuses to give his consent or no
objection certificate. The absence of consent
from one parent in such circumstances cannot
nullify the constitutional rights of a minor, and a
mechanical refusal to process the application
cannot be countenanced.”
25. It appears that the Passport Rules, 1980,
have specifically foreseen the situation where the
consent of one parent of a minor may not be
obtainable due to unavoidable circumstances. In
such cases, the Rule provide a complete
procedural mechanism to ensure that the minor's
right to a passport is not defeated. The
prescribed Annexure C is required to be
submitted along with the passport application by
the
applying
recognized
parent.
This
annexure
is
a
declaration
that
takes
care
of
necessary procedural requirements, enabling the
passport authorities to process and issue the
passport, even in the absence of consent from
one parent………..”
16.
Similarly, the High Court of Kerala in the matter of Juvairiya
(Supra) has held as under:-
“7. It is evident from the guidelines quoted
above,
that
in
the
normal
course,
the
signature/consent of both parents is required for
issuance of a passport to a minor. It is however
stipulated that if in case the applicant parent is
not in a position to get the consent of the other
parent "for whatever reason" the parent applying
for a passport for the minor child may sign the
form and submit a sworn affidavit as per
Annexure
"G"
stating
the
facts
and
circumstances of the case along with the
application. It is also stipulated that the affidavit
should also state that in the event of a court
case, he/she would be responsible and not the
Passport Officer. The guidelines also stipulate
that in such cases where only one parent is
applying, physical appearance of the minor child
may be requested to ensure the applicant parent
has actual custody of the minor child.
11…………. As stated in section III of schedule
III, if the applicant parent is not in a position to
get the consent of the other parent whatever be
the reason for such inability, all that is required
to be produced along with the application, apart
from
other
documents,
is
an
affidavit
in
Annexure "G". It is not necessary for such an
applicant to produce the consent of the other
parent or an order by the court granting custody
of the child to him/her.”
17.
In such a scenario, the insistence on production of consent
of the father appears to be not only misplaced but also contrary to
the very object of the relaxation provided under the rules. The
authorities have failed to appreciate that the requirement of
consent is not an end in itself, but a safeguard intended to protect
the interests of the minor and to avoid disputes relating to custody
or unauthorized removal of the child. Where such concerns are
demonstrably absent, as in the present case, the mechanical
enforcement of the requirement defeats the purpose of the law.
18.
This Court is also of the considered view that the approach
adopted by the respondent authorities suffers from nonapplication of mind. The rejection of the petitioner’s application
appears to be based on a rigid and formulaic interpretation of
procedural requirements, without due regard to the peculiar facts
and the legal position governing the case. Administrative
discretion, particularly in matters affecting fundamental rights,
must be exercised in a fair, reasonable and context-sensitive
manner. The failure to do so renders the action vulnerable to
judicial interference.
19.
Further, the right to travel abroad, as recognized by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court, forms an integral part of personal liberty
under Article 21 of the Constitution of India. While such right is not
absolute and may be subject to reasonable restrictions, any denial
thereof must be supported by valid statutory grounds. Section 6 of
the Passports Act exhaustively enumerates the grounds on which
issuance of a passport may be refused. Notably, absence of
consent of one parent especially in circumstances, where custody
is undisputed, is not one of the grounds contemplated under the
statute. Therefore, the impugned action cannot be sustained even
on statutory touchstone.
20.
Equally important is the welfare of the minor child, which
must remain the paramount consideration in all such matters.
Denial of passport to a minor, who is under the lawful custody of
one
parent,
on
account
of
an
impracticable
procedural
requirement, would operate to the detriment of the child’s interests
and opportunities. The law cannot compel compliance with a
condition that is either impossible to fulfill or has become
redundant in the given factual matrix. The contention of the
respondents that the petitioner ought to have obtained consent of
the father or complied strictly with procedural requirements does
not impress this Court, particularly when the statutory framework
itself provides for exceptions. Similarly, the argument that the
petitioner voluntarily closed her subsequent application does not
alter the legal position, as such closure appears to have been
occasioned by the persistent insistence of the authorities on an
untenable requirement.
21.
In view of the aforesaid discussion, this Court is satisfied
that the refusal of the respondent authorities to process the
application of the petitioner solely on the ground of nonsubmission of consent of the father is arbitrary, unreasonable, and
not in consonance with the statutory provisions. The action also
fails the test of proportionality and fairness, which are essential
components of Article 14 of the Constitution. Accordingly, the
stand taken by the respondents cannot be sustained in law.
22.
Accordingly, the writ petition is allowed. The respondent
authorities are directed to issue passport in favour of the minor
petitioner, namely Sanvi Anand, without insisting upon consent of
the father, subject to fulfillment of other formalities as required
under law.
23.
The aforesaid exercise shall be completed within a period of
four weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this order.
24.
No order as to costs.
Sd/(Amitendra Kishore Prasad)
Judge
sunita
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review