Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CGHC010431072026
2026:CGHC:46760
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WPC No. 5504 of 2026
Smt. Shweta Poorna W/o. Satmohan Poorna Aged About 33 Years R/o.
Village Manikpur, Gram Panchayat, Manikpur, Tehsil Bodla, Dist
Kabirdham (C.G.)
... Petitioner(s)
versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through The Secretary, Department Of
Panchayat And Rural Development, Vikas Bhawan, Ground Floor,
Sector 19, North Block, Atal Nagar, Naya Raipur, Dist Raipur (C.G.)
2 - Collector And District Election Officer Kabirdham, Dist Kabirdham
(C.G.)
3 - Sub-Divisional Officer And Presiding Officer (Panchayat) Bodla, Dist
Kabirdham (C.G.)
4 - Returning Officer (Panchayat) And Tehsildar Bodla, Tehsil Office
Bodla, Dist Kabirdham (C.G.)
5 - Smt. Chameli Chandrawanshi W/o. Kedar Chandrawanshi R/o.
Village Manikpur, Gram Panchayat, Manikpur, Tehsil Bodla, Dist
Kabirdham (C.G.)
6 - Smt. Nirmala Chandrawanshi W/o. Hariram Chandrawanshi R/o.
Village Manikpur, Gram Panchayat, Manikpur, Tehsil Bodla, Dist
Kabirdham (C.G.)
7 - Smt. Pampi Chandrawanshi W/o. Devnarayan Chandrawanshi R/o.
Village Manikpur, Gram Panchayat, Manikpur, Tehsil Bodla, Dist
Kabirdham (C.G.)
... Respondent(s)
(Cause-title taken from the Case Information System)
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------For Petitioner
:-
Mr. N. Naha Roy, Advocate
For State
:-
Mr. Akhilesh Kumar, GA
For Respondent No.5 :-
Mr. Chandrikaditya Pandey, Advocate
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SB-Hon’ble Shri Justice Amitendra Kishore Prasad
Order on Board
04.11.2026
1. By way of the present petition, the petitioner is challenging the
order dated 22.10.2026 passed by respondent No. 3, whereby the
election petition preferred by respondent No. 5 herein, challenging
the election of the petitioner to the post of Sarpanch under Section
122 of the Chhattisgarh Panchayat Raj Adhiniyam, 1993
(hereinafter referred to as the "Adhiniyam of 1993"), has been
allowed. By the said order, directions have been issued for
opening of the ballot boxes and recounting of votes in the
presence of all concerned, without framing the necessary issues
and without affording the petitioner a proper opportunity of hearing
and to lead evidence, which, in the facts and circumstances of the
case, was an essential requirement in law.
2. Following reliefs have been prayed in this petition:“10.1 Issue an appropriate writ in the nature
of mandamus and quash the order dated
22.10.2026 (Annexure P/1) passed by the
respondent No. 3 in the election petition
filed by the respondent No. 5 herein for the
same being absolutely arbitrary and illegal.
10.2. That the Hon’ble Court may kinldy be
pleased to pass any other relief, which this
Hon'ble High Court deems fit and proper be
also awarded.”
3. Facts of the case are that the petitioner, being the duly elected
Sarpanch of Gram Panchayat Manikpur, District Kabirdham
(C.G.), has preferred the instant writ petition challenging the order
dated 22.10.2026 passed by respondent No. 3, whereby the
election petition preferred by respondent No. 5 under Section 122
of the Chhattisgarh Panchayat Raj Adhiniyam, 1993, has been
allowed, directing the reopening of ballot boxes and recounting of
votes, with a further direction to alter the declared election result in
the event of any variation. The petitioner was declared elected by
a margin of two votes in the election held on 20.02.2025.
Respondent No. 5 challenged the election primarily on the
grounds of inadequate electricity arrangements, delay in counting
and improper scrutiny of ballot papers. However, the election
petition was decided without framing the necessary issues,
without affording the petitioner an effective opportunity to crossexamine the witnesses or to lead evidence in rebuttal, and without
recording sufficient reasons to justify the recounting of votes.
Furthermore, despite the report of the Returning Officer indicating
that there was no interruption or disturbance during the counting
process, respondent No. 3 directed recounting merely on the
basis of the allegations made in the election petition and the
affidavits filed therein. It is contended that the impugned order has
been passed in gross violation of the principles of natural justice
and the settled legal principles governing recounting of votes. The
impugned
order
is,
therefore,
arbitrary
and
procedurally
unsustainable and warrants interference by this Court. Hence, the
writ petition.
4. Mr. N. Naha Roy, learned counsel for the petitioner, submits that
respondent No. 5 herein has filed an election petition under
Section 122 of the Chhattisgarh Panchayat Raj Adhiniyam, 1993
(hereinafter referred to as the "Adhiniyam of 1993"), challenging
the election of the petitioner. He submits that the concerned SubDivisional
Officer-cum-Prescribed
Authority,
Bodla,
District
Kabirdham (C.G.), has allowed the election petition without
framing issues and without recording the evidence of the parties,
in violation of Rule 11 of the Chhattisgarh Panchayats (Election
Petitions, Corrupt Practices and Disqualification for Membership)
Rules, 1995 (hereinafter referred to as the "Rules of 1995"). He
further submits that, in terms of Rule 11 of the Rules of 1995, an
election petition is required to be enquired into, as nearly as may
be, in accordance with the procedure applicable to the trial of suits
under the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908. Therefore, respondent
No. 1 was required to frame appropriate issues and afford the
parties an opportunity to lead evidence and to examine and crossexamine witnesses. Learned counsel submits that the framing of
issues and examination of witnesses are essential for the proper
adjudication of an election petition. He further contends that the
impugned order, having been passed without framing issues or
recording evidence, is contrary to the statutory procedure and is,
therefore, liable to be set aside. Accordingly, he prays that the
matter be remitted to respondent No. 1 for fresh adjudication of
the election petition in accordance with law.
5. Mr. Akhilesh Kumar, learned State counsel, fairly submits that,
upon perusal of the impugned order, it appears that the procedure
prescribed under the Rules has not been duly followed by the
concerned authority. He further submits that the issues were not
framed, nor was any evidence of the parties recorded before
adjudicating the election petition. Thus, the mandatory procedural
requirements contemplated under the Rules have not been
complied with. Learned State counsel, therefore, fairly concedes
that the impugned order has been passed without adhering to the
procedure prescribed under law and, as such, cannot be said to
be legally sustainable.
6. Learned counsel appearing for respondent No. 5 submits that the
difference between the votes secured by the petitioner and
respondent No. 5 is merely two votes. He further submits that, in
view of the narrow margin of victory, the concerned authority has
rightly passed an order directing recounting of votes without
undertaking a detailed exercise of recording evidence. He,
therefore, contends that the impugned order has been passed in
accordance with law and does not warrant any interference by this
Court.
7. Having heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
material available on record.
8. The
Chhattisgarh
Panchayats
(Election
Petitions,
Corrupt
Practices & Disqualification for Membership) Rules, 1995, framed
under Section 95(1) read with sub-sections (1) & (3) of Section
122 of the Chhattisgarh Panchayat Raj Adhiniyam, 1993, lay down
the procedure to be followed in election petitions. In particular,
Rule 11 and Rule 12 are relevant, which are reproduced below :
“ Rule 11. Procedure before the specified
officer and his powers - (1) Subject to the
provisions of these rules, every election petition
shall be enquried into by the specified officer as
nearly, as may be, in accordance with the
procedure applicable under the Code of the Civil
Procedure, 1908 to the trial of suits:
Provided that it shall only be necessary for the
specified officer to make a memorandum of the
substance of the evidence of any witness
examined by him.
Rule 12. Parties to produce their witnesses –
It shall be the duty of the parties to produce their
witnesses on the date fixed for evidence, and
they shall not be entitled to an adjournment for
non-attendance of their witnesses:
Provided that the specified officer may, at his
discretion, order the issue of summons to any
witness on the necessary process fee and costs
being deposited by the party concerned.”
9. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the matter of Makhan Lal Bangal
vs. Manas Bhunia & Others, (2001) 2 SCC 652 has laid down
that an election petition is to be treated like a civil trial, requiring
the framing of issues and the recording of evidence. The trial of an
election petition must proceed in a manner similar to that of a civil
suit, where the issues are framed, evidence is led, and the merits
of the petition are examined. The summary dismissal of the
petition at the preliminary stage, without framing issues or
recording evidence, is contrary to the established legal procedure.
Relevant paragraph of the said judgment is quoted below for
ready reference :
“19. An election petition is like a civil trial. The
stage of framing the issues is an important one
inasmuch as on that day the scope of the trial is
determined by laying the path on which the trial
shall
proceed
departures
excluding
therefrom.
The
diversions
and
date
for
fixed
settlement of issues is, therefore, a date fixed for
hearing. The real dispute between the parties is
determined, the area of conflict is narrowed and
the concave mirror held by the court reflecting the
pleadings of the parties pinpoints into issues, the
disputes on which the two sides differ. The correct
decision of civil lis largely depends on correct
framing of issues, correctly determining the real
points in controversy which need to be decided.
The scheme of Order 14 of the Code of Civil
Procedure dealing with settlement of issues
shows that an issue arises when a material
proposition of fact or law is affirmed by one party
and
denied
by
the
other.
Each
material
proposition affirmed by one party and denied by
other should form the subject of a distinct issue.
An obligation is cast on the court to read the
plaint/petition and the written statement/counter, if
any, and then determine with the assistance of the
learned counsel for the parties, the material
propositions of fact or of law on which the parties
are at variance. The issues shall be framed and
recorded on which the decision of the case shall
depend. The parties and their counsel are bound
to assist the court in the process of framing of
issues. Duty of the counsel does not belittle the
primary obligation cast on the court. It is for the
Presiding Judge to exert himself so as to frame
sufficiently expressive issues. An omission to
frame proper issues may be a ground for
remanding the case for retrial subject to prejudice
having been shown to have resulted by the
omission. The petition may be disposed of at the
first hearing if it appears that the parties are not at
issue on any material question of law or of fact
and the court may at once pronounce the
judgment. If the parties are at issue on some
questions of law or of fact, the suit or petition
shall be fixed for trial calling upon the parties to
adduce evidence on issues of fact. The evidence
shall be confined to issues and the pleadings. No
evidence on controversies not covered by issues
and the pleadings, shall normally be admitted, for
each party leads evidence in support of issues the
burden of proving which lies on him. The object of
an issue is to tie down the evidence and
arguments and decision to a particular question
so that there may be no doubt on what the dispute
is. The judgment, then proceeding issue-wise
would be able to tell precisely how the dispute
was decided.”
10. Rule 11 of the Chhattisgarh Panchayats (Election Petitions,
Corrupt Practices and Disqualification for Membership) Rules,
1995 specifically provides that every election petition shall be
enquired into by the specified officer, as nearly as may be, in
accordance with the procedure applicable under the Code of Civil
Procedure, 1908 to the trial of suits. The aforesaid provision, when
read with Rule 12 of the Rules of 1995, clearly contemplates an
adjudicatory process wherein the real questions in controversy
between the parties are required to be identified and the parties
are to be afforded an opportunity to produce their witnesses and
lead evidence in support of their respective cases.
11. This Court is of the considered opinion that, in view of the nature
of the controversy raised in the election petition, the concerned
authority ought to have framed appropriate issues on the basis of
the pleadings of the parties and thereafter afforded them adequate
opportunity to lead evidence in support of their respective claims.
The election petition could not have been dismissed in a summary
manner without framing issues and without recording evidence,
particularly when specific factual disputes relating to the counting
of votes. The course adopted by concerned authority is contrary
to the procedure contemplated under Rule 11 of the Rules of 1995
and the principles laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
Makhan Lal Bangal v. Manas Bhunia and Others, (2001) 2 SCC
652, wherein the importance and necessity of framing issues in an
election trial involving disputed questions of fact or law has been
emphasized.
12. In view of the foregoing discussions and in light of the aforesaid
judgment passed by Hon’ble Apex Court, this Court finds that the
impugned order dated 22.10.2026 (Annexure P/1), passed by the
respondent No. 3 suffers from a procedural illegality and cannot
be sustained in the eyes of law. Accordingly, the impugned order
dated 22.10.2026 (Annexure P/1) is hereby set aside. The matter
is remanded back to the concerned authority for fresh adjudication
of the election petition in accordance with law. The concerned
authority shall frame appropriate issues on the basis of the
pleadings of the parties and shall afford adequate opportunity to
all the parties to lead evidence in support of their respective cases
and thereafter decide the election petition on its own merits,
strictly in accordance with the provisions of the Rules of 1995.
13. Considering that the dispute pertains to an election matter, the
concerned authority is directed to conclude the proceedings and
decide the election petition as expeditiously as possible,
preferably within a period of 60 days from the date of receipt of a
certified copy of this order. It is made clear that this Court has not
expressed any opinion on the merits of the rival claims of the
parties and all the issues are left open to be considered and
decided by the concerned authority in accordance with law.
14. Accordingly, the writ petition stands allowed to the extent
indicated hereinabove.
SD/(Amitendra Kishore Prasad)
Judge
AMIT PATEL
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review