Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:BHC-AUG:44629-DB
{1}
drp
wp9540-26.doc
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE OF BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
WRIT PETITION NO.9540 OF 2026
M/s Balraje Construction
Through Sole Proprietor
Bappasaheb Nathaji Ghatul,
Age – 64 years, Occ – Business
R/o Saraswati Colony, Georai
Taluka – Georai, District - Beed
PETITIONER
VERSUS
1.
The State of Maharashtra
Through the Principal Secretary
Public Works Department,
Maharashtra State, Mantralya,
Mumbai – 32
2.
The Chief Engineer,
Public Works Department,
Bandhkam Bhavan,
Chh. Sambhaji Nagar 431 005
3.
The Superintending Engineer
Public Works Department,
Public Work Circle, Dharashiv (Osmanabad)
Having office at Office of
Superintending Engineer,
Public Works Circle,
Near Collector Office Campus
Dharashiv (Osmanabad) 413 501
4.
The Executive Engineer
Public Works Division Office, Beed
Taluka and District – Beed 431 122
.......
Mr. Amol K. Gawali, Advocate for the Petitioner
Mr. Neha B. Kamble, AGP for Respondent - State
.......
RESPONDENTS
{2}
wp9540-26.doc
[CORAM : NITIN B. SURYAWANSHI, &
ABASAHEB D. SHINDE, J. J.]
RESERVED ON
: 2nd SEPTEMBER, 2026
PRONOUNCED ON : 29th SEPTEMBER, 2026
JUDGMENT (PER NITIN B. SURYAWANSHI, J.):
1.
Rule. Rule is made returnable forthwith. Heard finally with
the consent of the learned Advocates for the parties.
2.
By this Petition, filed under Article 226 of the Constitution
of India, the Petitioner prays for the following relief :
“A.
The Hon’ble High Court may be pleased to quash and set
aside the action of the respondent No.3 and 4 to technically disqualify
the present petitioner as per its order / communication uploaded on
31/07/2026 on the official website of www.mahatenders.gov.in,
wherein it has been held that, the present petitioner had been
technically disqualified by the Tender Scrutiny Committee headed by
the respondent No.3 and 4 from the tender process initiated by the
respondent No.4 for work of construction of approached road for
Gopatpimpalgaon Bridge on SH-222 KM-233/00 to 234/440, Tq.
Gevrai, Dist – Beed (2 Call).”
3.
The Petitioner is a joint venture working in the name and
style as M/s Balraje Construction and claims to be a reputed
contractor working with Public Works Department. Respondent
No.4 – Executive Engineer, Public Work Division, Beed had
floated
a
tender
for
construction
of
approach
road
for
Gopatpimpalgaon Bridge on SH-222 KM 233/00 to 234/440,
{3}
Taluka
–
Georai,
District
–
wp9540-26.doc
Beed.
The
tender
cost
was
Rs.6,29,37,818/- and the work was to be executed within 12
calendar months.
It is the case of the Petitioner that, since sufficient number
of contractors did not participate in the first call, therefore,
fourth Respondent recalled the tender and by virtue of the same
tender notice, initiated tender process by way of a second call.
4.
The Petitioner, since was satisfying the eligibility criteria of
technical
qualification
mentioned
in
the
tender
notice,
participated in the tender process by filing the tender. The
Petitioner contends that, since sufficient number of contractors
did not participate in the first call, Respondent No.4 recalled the
tender by virtue of the same tender notice and initiated the
tender process by way of a second call.
5.
The Petitioner was required to fill up two envelopes. In the
first envelope, the Petitioner was expected to submit all the
documents satisfying technical criteria and in the second
envelope, financial offer was to be submitted. The Petitioner
uploaded 373 pages, which according to the Petitioner were
fulfilling all the eligibility criteria.
6.
On scrutiny of the technical bids of the tenderers, by the
{4}
wp9540-26.doc
Scrutiny Committee headed by Respondent No.3, the Petitioner
was informed following deficiencies by communication dated 24 th
July, 2025.
“i)
Motor Grader : One number own / hired not attached
ii)
Wet Mix Macadam : 790.00 Cum. Not attached
iii)
Dense Bituminous Macadam : 151.00 Not attached
iv)
Quality Surveyor Engineer : B. E. (Civil) + 5 years
Experience or D.C.E. + 7 years experience : 1 No. Not
attached”
7.
The Petitioner was called upon to remove the deficiencies
within 3 days or else the Petitioner was to be disqualified. The
Petitioner claims to have removed all the deficiencies by
forwarding all the necessary documents. Thereafter the Scrutiny
Committee
uploaded
checklist
of
all
the
four
participant
contractors, based on the scrutiny of the documents and their
compliance of technical criteria. The Petitioner is held to be
disqualified on the following ground :
“iii. Dense Bituminous Macadam : 151.00 Cum.
‘physically submitted but not acceptable certificate’’”
8.
The Petitioner noticed his disqualification on 1 st August,
2026. Since 2nd August, 2026 was Sunday, the Petitioner
approached office of Respondent No.4 on 3 rd August, 2026 and
pointed out by letter dated 3rd August, 2026 that, the Petitioner
{5}
wp9540-26.doc
had submitted a certificate showing that he had executed
quantity to the extent of 1250 cum. of Dense Bituminous
Macadam (BDM) as against the technical requirement of having
executed 151 cum DBM, as per the tender condition. According
to the Petitioner it has submitted the certificate issued by
Assistant
Engineer,
Grade-I,
PWD
and
it
was
sufficient
compliance. The Petitioner also contended that Respondent
Nos.2 and 3 had acted in arbitrary manner and the two
contractors, who were held to be technically qualified, were in
fact disqualified, as Bitumen plants which are shown to have
been available with them, were at a distance of more than 60
kilometers from the work site. In fact, their plants were at a
distance of more than 70 kilometers. The Respondents failed to
consider clause 34 (A) to (a) and page 31 of the tender
document, while wrongly qualifying the other contractors and
disqualifying the Petitioner.
9.
The Petitioner further claims that the two tenderers, whose
bitumen plants were at a distance of more than 60 km from the
work site, are wrongly held to be qualified in the technical bid.
10.
The Petitioner claims that the mail seeking compliance of
the documents and removal of deficiencies was received by the
Petitioner on Friday and compliance was sought within 3 days.
{6}
Since
the
Executive
Engineer
wp9540-26.doc
was
not
available,
he
has
submitted certificate of the Assistant Engineer, Grade-I, PWD,
under whose supervision the work has to be carried out and that
is sufficient compliance. Being aggrieved by its disqualification in
the technical bid, the Petitioner has approached this Court.
11.
The Respondents have opposed the Petition by filing
affidavit in reply of Respondent No.4 – Executive Engineer,
contending that after issuance of the tender and on scrutiny of
the documents submitted online by all the four tenderers, it was
revealed that, some documents were not uploaded online by the
tenderers, which were supposed to be submitted by them at the
time of submission of the tender, on 12 th February, 2026.
Therefore, the documents shortfall letters were forwarded to all
the tenderers by official email, from Respondent No.4 on 13 th
April, 2026 and all the tenderers were asked to submit the
shortfall documents within 3 days from that date. Two tenderers,
excluding the Petitioner and M/s Sitai Constructions, submitted
their shortfall documents within 3 days. Hence, the scrutiny was
finalized and scrutiny sheets, qualifying two agencies, namely,
M/s
Rajkamal
Construction
Company
and
M/s
Mhaske
Infrastructure were uploaded on 13 th May, 2026. Five days’ time
till 18th May, 2026 was granted for submission of objections.
{7}
12.
wp9540-26.doc
The Petitioner took objection to the final tender scrutiny,
on 15th May, 2026 (by offline letter) stating that the Petitioner
has not received the email dated 13 th April, 2026 from
Respondent No.4. The Respondents, however, have annexed the
email sent report to their affidavit in reply. Yet, by accepting the
objection of the Petitioner, the Scrutiny Committee headed by
Respondent No.3 – Superintending Engineer, by uploading the
scrutiny sheet, unanimously decided on 4 th June, 2026 to revoke
the tender and to give one more chance to the Petitioner.
Accordingly, the tender was revoked and revised letters for
shortfall of documents were issued to all the tenderers by email,
on 24th July, 2026 and they were called upon to submit reply by
email / physically to the office of Respondent No.4.
13.
This time, the Petitioner submitted shortfall documents
physically, in the office. M/s Rajkamal Construction Company and
M/s Mhaske Infrastructure submitted the valid documents,
however, the Petitioner submitted the quantity certificate issued
by the Assistant Engineer Grade-I, which was not acceptable, as
per clause XV (c) and (f) of the tender document, in which it is
clearly mentioned that this certificate must be given by the
Officer not below the rank of Executive Engineer / Divisional
Accounts Officer. The certificate submitted by the Petitioner
{8}
wp9540-26.doc
bears the date of issue as 27 th July, 2026. The same was not
acceptable, as the date of submission of the bid was 12 th
February, 2026 and the Petitioner was expected to submit the
quantity certificate issued by the Executive Engineer, before the
last date of submission of the tender i.e. 12 th February, 2026.
Therefore, the Petitioner was held disqualified in the technical
bid, in the meeting held by the Scrutiny Committee on 31 st July,
2026. The Scrutiny Sheet was uploaded on the website on 31 st
July, 2026 and objections were invited.
14.
The Respondents have denied that the hot mix plants of
the two tenderers who have qualified the technical bid, are
beyond the distance of 60 kilometers. The certificate showing
distance of 57.1 km for M/s Rajkamal Construction Company and
59.6 km of M/s Mhaske Infrastructure are also placed on record.
15.
It is further stated that in view of the interim orders
passed by this Court, the tender Scrutiny Committee has decided
not to open the envelope – 2 of this tender, and hence the final
bid is not yet opened. The Respondents, therefore, contend that
there is no substance in the petition. In support of her
submissions, learned AGP has placed reliance on the decision of
the Apex Court in “Tata Motors Limited V/s The Brihan Mumbai Electric
Supply and Transport Undertake (BEST) and Others” 2023 LiveLaw (SC) 467.
{9}
16.
wp9540-26.doc
We have heard learned Advocate for the Petitioner and the
learned AGP at length. We have perused the grounds raised in
the Writ Petition, the Annexures thereto and the affidavit in reply
filed by the Respondents, rejoinder filed by the Petitioner so also
the citation relied on by the Respondents.
17.
In the tender document, qualification criteria is mentioned
in clause xv. Sub clauses “c” and “f” of said clause are as
follows:
“c
Satisfactorily executed in any one year of last Five years i.e.
2018-19, 2019-20, 2020-21, 2021-22 and 2022-23 following
minimum quantities of work. (Information to be given only in
proforma of Statement No.VI on page No.33).
i.
ii.
iii.
iv.
v.
vi.
G. S. B. (Granular Sub Base) / Water
Bound Macadam Gr. I & II
Wet Mix Macadam
Dense Bituminous Macadam
Bituminous Concrete
C. C. M-20 & Above
Earth Work
: 810.00 Cum
“f.
The necessary certificates as mentioned in qualification
: 790.00 Cum
: 151.00 Cum
: 91.00 Sqm
: 55.00 Cum
: 7405.00 Cum.”
criteria from Sr. No. (a) to (c) are required to be obtained from the
officer not below the rank of Executive Engineer / Divisional
Accounts Officer. A copy of these certificates duly attested by a
gazetted office along with availability of equipments for this work
mentioned in Sr. No. (d) shall be put in envelope No.1 only. In
absence of these certificates envelope No.2 (Financial Bid) shall not
be opened.”
{10}
wp9540-26.doc
18.
The e-tender notice gives the time schedule as follows;
SN
Particulars
Date and time
Tender available for download
Dt.05.02.2026 to 12.02.2026 up to 18.00 Hrs.
Pre Bid Conference Date and Dt. 09.02.2026 @ 15.00 Hrs
Time for Work No.2, 3
Place fo Pre Bid Conference
At Office of the Chief Engineer, Public Works
Region, Chh. Sambhajinagar
Bid Opening on or after
Dt. 13.02.2026 @ 18.05 Hrs.
19.
Admittedly, after the first time scrutiny of the tender, all
the tenderers were issued documents shortfall letters by
Respondent No.4, on 13th April, 2026, asking them to submit
shortfall documents within 3 days from 13th April, 2026. Two
tenderers, i.e. namely M/s Rajkamal Construction Company and
M/s
Mhaske
Infrastructure
have
submitted
their
shortfall
documents within three days. Hence, the scrutiny was finalized
and scrutiny sheets, qualifying those two agencies i.e. M/s
Rajkamal Construction Company and M/s Mhaske Infrastructure
in technical bid, were uploaded on 13 th May, 2025. At that time,
five days’ time till 18 th May, 2026 was granted for submission of
objections.
20.
It is a matter of record that, the Petitioner took objection
to the final tender scrutiny, on 15 th May, 2026, by offline letter
contending that it has not received email dated 13 th April, 2026
from Respondent No.4. Though Respondent No.4 has annexed
{11}
wp9540-26.doc
email forwarded to the Petitioner along with the affidavit in reply,
yet, by accepting the objection of the Petitioner, the scrutiny
committee
headed
by
Respondent
No.3
–
Superintending
Engineer, on 4th June, 2026, unanimously decided to revoke the
tender and has decided to again scrutinize the tenders of all the
tenderers.
21.
On evaluation of the technical bid and the documents
submitted by all the tenderers, on 24th July, 2026, all the
tenderers were issued revised letters for shortfall documents by
email, calling upon them to submit reply by email / physically, to
the
office
submitted
of
Respondent
shortfall
No.4.
documents
This
time,
physically.
the
Petitioner
The
Petitioner
submitted quantity certificate issued by Assistant Engineer,
Grade -I and M/s. Rajkamal Construction Company and M/s
Mhaske Infrastructure submitted valid documents.
22.
Indisputably, qualification criteria are mentioned in clauses
a to c of clause xv of the tender document. These are the
essential criteria. Sub Clause ‘f’ of Clause xv of the tender
document stipulates that the necessary certificate is required to
be obtained from the officer not below the rank of Executive
Engineer / Divisional Accounts Officer and in absence of
certificates mentioned in clause “f”, envelope
2 (financial bid)
{12}
shall
not
be
opened.
Thus,
wp9540-26.doc
in
spite
of
giving
several
opportunities, the Petitioner has failed to submit quantity
certificate issued by officer not below the rank of Executive
Engineer / Divisional Accounts Officer. By submitting certificate
issued by the Assistant Engineer, the Petitioner has failed to fulfill
the essential qualification criteria. Therefore, no fault can be
found with the disqualification of the Petitioner in the technical
bid.
23.
Even if,
for the sake
of argument,
the Petitioner’s
contention is accepted that the Petitioner has submitted the
certificate issued by the Executive Engineer, subsequently, on
27.07.2026, it is mentioned in the said certificate that the
Petitioner is given the work of improvement of the Georai –
Kolher – Revaki road Egima 117, KM. 0/200 to 3/000, on 15 th
July, 2024 and till 27 th July, 2026 the Petitioner has completed
1250 cubic meter work. This certificate does not meet the
qualification criteria, as the Petitioner was expected to submit
the certificate of completion of the said work prior to the last
date of filing of the tender form i.e. 12.02.2026.
Along with the rejoinder, the Petitioner has annexed
certificate dated 14th August, 2026 issued by the Executive
Engineer, certifying that the Petitioner has completed 2287.84
{13}
wp9540-26.doc
Cubic Meter DBM, in the year 2023-24 and 2024-25. However,
since this certificate is issued after the appointed date, the same
cannot be accepted. The Petitioner ought to have submitted this
certificate within stipulated time.
24.
There is no merit in the contention of the Petitioner that
the plants of the tenderers who are held qualified in technical
bid, are beyond the distance of 60 km. Respondents No.1 to 4, in
their affidavit in reply, have annexed the distance certificates of
these two tenderers, which show that the plant of M/s Rajkamal
Construction Company is within 57.1 km via Beed – Pimpalner –
Majalgaon Road and plant of M/s Mhaske Infrastructure is within
the distance of 59.6 km via Beed – Pimpalner – Majalgaon road.
25.
Record
indicates
that
the
Petitioner
was
given
fair
opportunity to submit shortfall documents. The Petitioner failed
to submit the certificate contemplated in qualification criteria
clause “C”, within the extended time. Therefore, the Petitioner is
rightly held disqualified by the Respondents in the technical bid.
26.
In “Tata Motors V/s Best” (supra), the Apex Court has held
that there shall not be judicial review in commercial matters
unless case of arbitrariness, mala fides, bias or irrationality is
made out. The relevant observations of the Apex Court are as
{14}
wp9540-26.doc
follows :
“48. This Court being the guardian of fundamental rights is dutybound to interfere when there is arbitrariness, irrationality, mala
fides and bias. However, this Court has cautioned time and again
that courts should exercise a lot of restraint while exercising their
powers of judicial review in contractual or commercial matters. This
Court is normally loathe to interfere in contractual matters unless a
clear-cut case of arbitrariness or mala fides or bias or irrationality
is made out. One must remember that today many public sector
undertakings compete with the private industry. The contracts
entered into between private parties are not subject to scrutiny under
writ jurisdiction. No doubt, the bodies which are State within the
meaning of Article 12 of the Constitution are bound to act fairly and
are amenable to the writ jurisdiction of superior courts but this
discretionary power must be exercised with a great deal of restraint
and caution. The courts must realise their limitations and the havoc
which needless interference in commercial matters can cause. In
contracts involving technical issues the courts should be even more
reluctant because most of us in Judges' robes do not have the
necessary expertise to adjudicate upon technical issues beyond our
domain. The courts should not use a magnifying glass while
scanning the tenders and make every small mistake appear like a big
blunder. In fact, the courts must give “fair play in the joints” to the
government and public sector undertakings in matters of contract.
Courts must also not interfere where such interference will cause
unnecessary loss to the public exchequer. (See: Silppi Constructions
Contractors v. Union of India, (2020) 16 SCC 489)
52. Ordinarily, a writ court should refrain itself from imposing its
decision over the decision of the employer as to whether or not to
accept the bid of a tenderer unless something very gross or palpable
is pointed out. The court ordinarily should not interfere in matters
relating to tender or contract. To set at naught the entire tender
process at the stage when the contract is well underway, would not
be in public interest. Initiating a fresh tender process at this stage
may consume lot of time and also loss to the public exchequer to the
tune of crores of rupees. The financial burden/implications on the
public exchequer that the State may have to meet with if the Court
directs issue of a fresh tender notice, should be one of the guiding
factors that the Court should keep in mind. This is evident from a
{15}
wp9540-26.doc
three-Judge Bench decision of this Court in Association of
Registration Plates v. Union of India and Others, reported in (2005)
1 SCC 679.
53. The law relating to award of contract by the State and public
sector corporations was reviewed in Air India Ltd. v. Cochin
International Airport Ltd., reported in (2000) 2 SCC 617 and it was
held that the award of a contract, whether by a private party or by a
State, is essentially a commercial transaction. It can choose its own
method to arrive at a decision and it is free to grant any relaxation
for bona fide reasons, if the tender conditions permit such a
relaxation. It was further held that the State, its corporations,
instrumentalities and agencies have the public duty to be fair to all
concerned. Even when some defect is found in the decision-making
process, the court must exercise its discretionary powers under
Article 226 with great caution and should exercise it only in
furtherance of public interest and not merely on the making out of a
legal point. The court should always keep the larger public interest
in mind in order to decide whether its intervention is called for or
not. Only when it comes to a conclusion that overwhelming public
interest requires interference, the court should interfere.
54. As observed by this Court in Jagdish Mandal v. State of Orissa
and Others, reported in (2007) 14 SCC 517, that while invoking
power of judicial review in matters as to tenders or award of
contracts, certain special features should be borne in mind that
evaluations of tenders and awarding of contracts are essentially
commercial functions and principles of equity and natural justice
stay at a distance in such matters. If the decision relating to award of
contract is bona fide and is in public interest, courts will not
interfere by exercising powers of judicial review even if a procedural
aberration or error in assessment or prejudice to a tenderer, is made
out. Power of judicial review will not be invoked to protect private
interest at the cost of public interest, or to decide contractual
disputes.”
27.
Applying aforesaid ratio to the facts of the present case,
we are of the considered view that, the Petitioner has failed to
make out a case of arbitrariness, mala fides, bias or irrationality.
{16}
wp9540-26.doc
The record indicates that, the entire tender process is held in
transparent manner and since the Petitioner failed to meet the
qualification criteria, it is rightly disqualified by the Respondents
in the technical bid. We do not find any merit in the challenge
raised by the Petitioner in the present petition. The Writ Petition
is, therefore, dismissed. The Interim relief stands vacated. Rule
stands discharged.
[ ABASAHEB D. SHINDE ]
JUDGE
drp/wp9540-26.doc
[ NITIN B. SURYAWANSHI ]
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review