Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:28909
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
W.P.(C) No.7293 of 2019
---Baleshwar Yadav son of late Dego Yadav, resident of village & Post
Dowari, PS Itkhori (Gidhore), District Chatra, Jharkhand.
…
…
Petitioner
Versus
1.The State of Jharkhand.
2.The Principal Secretary, Department of Rural Development, Govt. of
Jharkhand, PO & PS Dhurwa, Ranchi, Dist. Ranchi.
3. The Executive Engineer, Rural Development Department (Rural
Works Affairs) Work Division, Chatra, PO and PS and District Chatra.
4. The Assistant Engineer, Rural Development Department (Rural Works
Affairs), Work Division, Chatra, PO and PS and District Chatra,
Jharkhand.
…
…
Respondents
---CORAM
:
SRI ANANDA SEN, J.
---For the Petitioner:
Mr. Anil Kumar, Sr. Advocate
Ms. Chandana Kumari, Advocate
For the Respondents: Mr. Rakesh Kumar Sahi, Advocate
---ORDER
Reserved on 14.09.2026
Pronounced on: 25.09.2026
By way of filing this writ petition, the petitioner has prayed to quash the
order as contained in letter No.847 dated 22.06.2019 (Annexure 12), issued by
respondent No.3, whereby and whereunder, a direction has been issued to the
petitioner to correct the work with respect to maintenance and repair of road
from Pakha to Lerho School (Road Length – 10.300 K.M.) until then the bills
will be kept pending. Further prayer has been made to pay the dues of
Rs.52,12,000/-, which according to the petitioner has been admitted by the
authorities, as he has completed the work of repair and maintenance of the
road way back on 29.06.2017. He also prays for release of security money of
Rs.8,80,000/- and the amount equivalent to 5%, which has already been
deducted from the payable amount in relations to the works done, and also
prayed for payment of interest as well.
2.
The petitioner is a registered contractor. The work of repair of road from
Pakha to Lerho School (10.300 k.m.) was allotted to the petitioner. At the time
of execution of the agreement, the petitioner deposited the necessary security
money. The petitioner claimed that the area was a disturbed area as
disturbance was created by extremists. The petitioner asked to provide
security so that the work can be executed, but no help was provided. Petitioner
-: 1 :-
2026:JHHC:28909
claims that the work could not be completed due to failure on the part of the
respondent-State in providing security. Several letters of the petitioner
addressed to the authorities to provide security fell to deaf ears. It is his
contention that the period of work was extended till 30.06.2018. Vide letter
dated 12.12.2018 (letter No.1668), the Executive Engineer, Rural Development
Department requested the District Mining Officer, Chatra to repair the road as
the same was damaged due to plying of vehicles by the stone lessees. The
District Mining Officer communicated to the respondent No.3 (Executive
Engineer, Rural Development Department), that if the road has been damaged
due to plying of heavy vehicles, it is the Rural Development Department, which
has to repair the same. As per the petitioner, as the work was complete, the
authorities asked for allotment of fund of Rs.52,12,000/-, but the same was not
paid. Ultimately, allotment of Rs.38.611 lakh was released for payment to the
petitioner. It is the grievance of the petitioner that once the said amount was
allotted, the respondent No.3, in an arbitrary manner, directed the petitioner to
repair the damaged road, whose repairing work was already completed by the
petitioner. Thus, the petitioner has filed the instant writ petition.
3.
Respondents, in their counter affidavit, refuted the claim of the petitioner.
On amongst others, their plea is that the entire work was not completed, thus
the petitioner is not entitled for the amount, which he has claimed. It has also
been mentioned in the Counter Affidavit that Section III, Part 2 (Special
Condition for F2 Contract) at Clause 3.18 provides that the defect liability
period of the completed work will be three years. The contractor has to rectify
all the major and minor construction defects and the violations, at the cost of
the contractor. Their claim is that since the work was not fully complete and
several defects and shortcomings were found, viz. Incomplete parapet of hume
pipe, premix coming out and breakage of hume pipe etc. the respondents took
a stand that unless these defects are cured and repair work is done, petitioner
is not entitled for the remaining amount.
4.
When this writ petition was taken up on 15.04.2026, this Court directed
the State to file a Supplementary Counter Affidavit intimating as to whether the
petitioner is entitled to any amount or not and if the petitioner is not entitled to
any, the reasons thereof should be mentioned. It was also ordered that the
State will inform this Court the amount, which till date has been paid to the
petitioner. In compliance to the aforesaid order, a Supplementary Counter
Affidavit has been filed, wherein the State disputed the claim. They stated that
-: 2 :-
2026:JHHC:28909
the agreement amount for the work is Rs.1,75,92,377/-. Though the work was
not completed within 31.03.2017, which was the completion date, yet
extension was granted till 30.06.2017. Even then the petitioner failed to
complete the work. Thereafter, again extension was granted till 30.06.2018 by
imposing penalty. In the said counter affidavit, it has been mentioned that the
petitioner, vide letter dated 07.08.2018, informed that only work of ½ k.m.
remains. However, in letter dated 18.12.2018, it has been submitted that the
entire work has been completed. The officials of the respondents inspected the
work on 20.06.2019, wherein several shortcomings were detected. It was
found that the parapet of hume pipe was incomplete, premix was coming out,
breakage of hume pipe, thus, the petitioner was asked to cure those defects so
that his bills can be passed. Petitioner was also informed that unless the work
is completed, his bills will not be paid. The respondents have taken a specific
plea that the remaining work was not complete, inspite of reminders, therefore,
final measurement could not be taken. It is their defence that since the work
remained incomplete, the measurement book also reflected entries only till 4th
Running Account Bill and no final measurement has been entered in the
measurement book as the work is incomplete. It has also been submitted that
the petitioner has been paid an amount of Rs.1,23,80,413/- for the work, which
he has done and they have categorically taken a stand that the petitioner is not
entitled to any further amount and there is no admissible due.
5.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court, in the case of ABL International Ltd.
versus Export Credit Guarantee Corpn. of India Ltd. reported in (2004) 3
SCC 553at paragraph 27 has held that in appropriate case, a writ petition as
against a State or an instrumentality of a State arising out of a contractual
obligation is maintainable. It has also been held that a writ petition, involving
consequential monetary claim is also maintainable. Paragraph 27 of the said
judgment reads as under: 27. From the above discussion of ours, the following legal
principles emerge as to the maintainability of a writ petition:
(a) In an appropriate case, a writ petition as against a State or an
instrumentality of a State arising out of a contractual obligation is
maintainable.
(b) Merely because some disputed questions of fact arise for
consideration, same cannot be a ground to refuse to entertain a
writ petition in all cases as a matter of rule.
(c) A writ petition involving a consequential relief of monetary
claim is also maintainable.
-: 3 :-
2026:JHHC:28909
6.
In Utkal Highway Engineers and Contractors versus Chief General
Manager and Others reported in 2025 SCC OnLine SC 1400, the Hon’ble
Supreme Court at paragraph 8 has held that non-payment of admitted dues
can be considered an arbitrary action. Paragraph 8 of the said judgment reads
as under: “8. Be that as it may, the High Court has not dealt with the merits
of the writ petition. Moreover, it is not an inviolable rule that no
money claim can be adjudicated upon in exercise of writ
jurisdiction. Non-payment of admitted dues, inter alia, may be
considered an arbitrary action on the part of respondents and for
claiming the same, a writ petition may lie. Further, throwing a writ
petition on ground of availability of alternative remedy after 10
years, particularly, when parties have exchanged their affdavits, is
not the correct course unless there are disputed questions of fact
which by their very nature cannot be adjudicated upon without
recording formal evidence.”
7.
In the case of M/s. Jalakash versus State of Uttar Pradesh&
Others[Special Leave Petition (Civil) No.6036 of 2020], the Hon’ble
Supreme Court, vide order dated 25.01.2024 at paragraph 6, has held that a
writ petition is maintainable even when it involves disputed question of facts,
but it did not require elaborate recording of evidence. Paragraph 6 of the said
judgment reads as under: “6. It is settled law as per the decision of this Court in the case of
ABL International Ltd. vs. Export Credit Guarantee Corporation of
India Ltd.; (2004) 3 SCC 553, that even in a writ petition involving
disputed question of facts, which do not require elaborate
recording of the evidence, the High Court can entertain the
petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India. In any
case, non-exercise of the jurisdiction under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India, on the ground of availability of an alternate
remedy is not a hard and fast rule but a rule of selfrestraint.”
This clearly means that where an elaborate evidence needs to be
recorded, the writ petition should not be entertained. Recording of elaborate
evidence is necessary when the facts are complicated and those facts require
minute details, marshalling of evidence.
8.
Thus, from the aforesaid judgment, it is clear that even in the matter of
contractual dues, writ application will lie, but the said dues should be admitted.
If there is no admission of any dues and the facts are complicated and
disputed, which requires leading of extensive evidence, both oral and
-: 4 :-
2026:JHHC:28909
documentary, those matters cannot be adjudicated and decided in an
application under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
9.
In the instant case, I find that the respondents have nowhere admitted
the amount which the petitioner has claimed. It is true that merely refusing a
claim without any ground of refusal, cannot be said to be a disputed question
of fact, but in this case, I find that the respondents have taken a ground, which
clearly needs leading of evidence. Their ground is that the work is not
complete and several instances have been given in support of their claim, like
breakage of hume pipe, coming out of premix etc. It is also their plea that there
was a defect liability period of 3 (three) years and the petitioner, inspite of
letters and reminders, did not remove those defects. The aforesaid facts and
allegations raised by the respondents needs to be rebutted by the petitioner by
leading evidence. This rebuttal cannot only be by filing a statement on oath
and denying the allegations by statement on oath. Thus, the facts, which
needs to be proved and established in this case are complicated, and can only
be done by leading oral and documentary evidence.
10.
Thus, in view of what has been discussed, since the facts are
complicated, which needs leading of evidence, moreso, when the dues are not
admitted and it is also the stand of the respondents that the work has not yet
been completed by the petitioner as per agreement, I am not inclined to grant
any relief to the petitioner by exercising jurisdiction under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India. The petitioner, if so advised, should approach a Civil
Court of competent jurisdiction putting forth his money claim.
11.
This writ petition is, accordingly, dismissed with the aforesaid liberty to
the petitioner. Pending interlocutory applications, if any, stand disposed of.
(Ananda Sen, J.)
Ranchi
Dated 25th September, 2026
Kumar/Cp-02
Uploaded on 25.09.2026
-: 5 :-
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review