Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:24978
[WA Nos.1298/2024, 1823/2024]
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE DEVAN RAMACHANDRAN
&
THE HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE M.B. SNEHALATHA
MONDAY, THE 24TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 3RD CHAITHRA, 1947
WA NO. 1298 OF 2024
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT DATED 06.06.2024 IN WP(C) NO.19392 OF
2021 OF HIGH COURT OF KERALA
APPELLANT/PETITIONER:
BALASUNDARAM S.
AGED 68 YEARS
S/O.SHANMUGHASUNDARAM, RETIRED DEPUTY MANAGER, STATE
BANK OF TRAVANCORE (PRESENTLY STATE BANK OF INDIA),
LOCAL HEAD OFFICE, POOJAPPURA, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN
- 695 012, RESIDING AT "HANUKRIPA", T.C.12/1057,
CONVENT ROAD, KARUNYA LANE, NALANCHIRA P.O.,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695 015.
BY ADVS.
SMITHA S.PILLAI
M.C.SINY
N.NANDAKUMARA MENON (SR.)
RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS:
STATE BANK OF INDIA
REPRESENTED BY THE CHIEF GENERAL MANAGER, LOCAL HEAD
OFFICE, POOJAPPURA, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695012.
2025:KER:24978
[WA Nos.1298/2024, 1823/2024]
ASSISTANT GENERAL MANAGER (PPG)
STATE BANK OF INDIA, LOCAL HEAD OFFICE, POOJAPPURA,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM., PIN - 695012
ADDL R3. STATE OF KERALA
REPRESENTED BY THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY, SC/ST
DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT, GOVERNMENT OF KERALA,
SECRETARIAT, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM -1
ADDL R4. THE DIRECTOR,
KIRTADS, CHAVAYOOR, KOZHIKODE-17.
(ADDL.R3 AND R4 ARE IMPLEADED AS PER ORDER DTD 17/12/24
IN IA 1/24 IN WA 1298/24.
SMT LATHA THANKAPPAN-SPL GP; SRI P RAMAKRISHNAN-SC
THIS WRIT APPEAL HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON 24.03.2025,
ALONG WITH WA.1823/2024, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE
FOLLOWING:
2025:KER:24978
[WA Nos.1298/2024, 1823/2024]
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE DEVAN RAMACHANDRAN
&
THE HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE M.B. SNEHALATHA
MONDAY, THE 24TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 3RD CHAITHRA, 1947
WA NO. 1823 OF 2024
AGAINST THE ORDER DATED 22.07.2024 IN RP NO.701 OF 2024 OF
HIGH COURT OF KERALA
APPELLANT/REVIEW PETITIONER:
BALASUNDARAM S, AGED 68 YEARS
S/O. SHANMUGHASUNDARAM, RETIRED DEPUTY MANAGER, STATE
BANK OF TRAVANCORE (PRESENTLY STATE BANK OF INDIA),
LOCAL HEAD OFFICE, POOJAPPURA, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN:
695 012, RESIDING AT 'HANUKRIPA', T.C.12/1057, CONVENT
ROAD, KARUNYA LANE, NALANCHIRA P.O. THIRUVANANTHAPURAM,
PIN - 695015
BY ADVS.
SMITHA S.PILLAI
ALICE THOMAS
M.C.SINY
N.NANDAKUMARA MENON (SR.)
P.K.MANOJKUMAR
RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS:
STATE BANK OF INDIA
REPRESENTED BY THE CHIEF GENERAL MANAGER, LOCAL HEAD
OFFICE, POOJAPPURA, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN – 695012.
ASSISTANT GENERAL MANAGER (PPG)
STATE BANK OF INDIA, LOCAL HEAD OFFICE, POOJAPPURA,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695012
THIS WRIT APPEAL HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON 24.03.2025, ALONG
WITH WA.1298/2024, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE
FOLLOWING:
2025:KER:24978
[WA Nos.1298/2024, 1823/2024]
JUDGMENT
Devan Ramachandran, J.
We are disposing of these appeals together
because they are edificed on the same factual
circumstances and factors.
2.
Compendiously,
the
appellant
filed
WP(C) No.19392/2021, seeking a direction to the
State Bank of India (SBI) – from whose services
he
retired
pensionary
on
31.03.2001
benefits;
and
–
to
praying
honour
that
his
Exts.P8
and P10 communications therein – by which such
prayer was declined by the Bank – be quashed.
This writ petition was heard by a learned Judge
of this Court and dismissed through the judgment
impugned,
which
is
dated
06.06.2024,
holding
that, since the appellant's caste status as a
“Paanan” is pending consideration at the hands
of
the
“Scrutiny
Committee”
constituted
under
2025:KER:24978
[WA Nos.1298/2024, 1823/2024]
the provisions of the Kerala (Scheduled Castes
and
Scheduled
Community
Tribes)
Regulation
Certificates
Act,1996
of
[Act
Issue
Of
11/1996],
and since a time frame of six months had been
fixed
in
the
judgment
(which
was
filed
by
members
of
the
said
in
the
WP(C)
No.5170/2009
appellant
community
and
other
against
the
proceedings of the said Committee), no relief
against the Bank can be granted until such time
expires.
3.
It
thereupon
transpires
filed
RP
that
No.701/2024
the
appellant
against
the
judgment in WP(C) No.19392/2021, but which has
also been dismissed.
4. The appellant has thus challenged the
judgment of the learned Single Judge in WP(C)
No.19392/2021, through WA No.1298/2024; and the
order
in
RP
No.701/2024,
through
WA
2025:KER:24978
[WA Nos.1298/2024, 1823/2024]
No.1823/2024.
5. Sri.N.Nandakumara Menon, learned senior
counsel,
instructed
appearing
for
the
by
Smt.Smitha
appellant
S.Pillai
(who
is
-
the
petitioner in the RP), argued that his client
joined the services of the erstwhile State Bank
of Travancore (SBT), as early as on 11.01.1978,
however, conceding that it was on the strength
of a Caste Certificate which certified him to be
a member of the “Paanan” Community, which is a
notified Scheduled Caste. He pointed out that
his
client
retired
voluntarily
on
31.03.2001
without any blemish on his career and was, in
fact, paid 50% of the ex gratia amounts eligible
under
the
Voluntary
along
with
his
Retirement
Eligible
Death
Scheme
cum
(VRS);
Retirement
Gratuity (DCRG) and Provident Fund (PF) sums, by
causing an adjustment of the same against the
2025:KER:24978
[WA Nos.1298/2024, 1823/2024]
loans
he
had
availed
argued
that,
refused
to
honour
balance
50%
ex
this,
they
of
however,
him
gratia
relied
upon
from
the
Bank.
He
thereafter,
the
SBT
or
the
that
for
the
pension,
payment;
a
and
communication
which
they say they received from the Chairman of the
“Scrutiny Committee” as early as on 25.04.2001,
intimating
that
the
appellant
was
being
proceeded
against
for
having
illegally
and
unfairly claimed himself to be a member of a
Scheduled Caste.
6. Sri.N.Nandakumara Menon argued that the
proceedings
Committee”
continued
initiated
was
ad
in
by
error
infinitum
the
and
without
that
“Scrutiny
it
has
finality;
and
hence that his client and others approached this
Court through WP(C) No.5170/2009, which had been
disposed of by a learned Single Judge directing
2025:KER:24978
[WA Nos.1298/2024, 1823/2024]
the said Committee to complete the proceedings
within a period of six months from the date of
receipt
of
the
said
judgment,
which
was
delivered on 06.06.2024.
upon
7.
The
learned
us
that,
it
senior
was
counsel
because
of
impressed
the
above
judgment that the learned Single Judge disposed
of WP(C) No.19392/2021, declining to accede to
the request of his client for release of his
pension
and
balance
50%
ex
gratia
sums,
justifiably being guided by the impression that
the proceedings before the “Scrutiny Committee”
will obtain a finality within a period of six
months.
8.
ruefully
Sri.Nandakumara
that
the
Menon
“Scrutiny
then
submitted
Committee”
has,
however, neither completed the proceedings, nor
even continued with the enquiry; and thus that
2025:KER:24978
[WA Nos.1298/2024, 1823/2024]
his
client
is
now
facing
a
very
tenebrious
scenario, where he is in the winter of his life
without any financial support and wholly at the
mercy of friends and relatives, whose patience
is now wearing. He explained that this is more
so
because,
his
client
difficulties
of
old
has
age
all
and
the
is
medical
unable
to
support it because his “DCRG” and “PF”, as said
above, had been adjusted against his loans by
the bank. The learned Senior Counsel, therefore,
prayed that both these Appeals be allowed.
9.
Sri.P.Ramakrishnan
Standing Counsel for the
–
learned
State Bank of India
[into which the State Bank of Travancore (SBT)
had
subsequently
client
has
merged]
nothing
submitted
against
the
that
his
appellant
and
that they are willing to abide by any direction
to
be
issued
by
this
Court.
He,
however,
2025:KER:24978
[WA Nos.1298/2024, 1823/2024]
expressed
his
apprehension
“Scrutiny
Committee”
that,
eventually
should
find
that
the
the
appellant does not belong to a Scheduled Caste
Community, then his appointment with the “SBT”
in the year 1978 would be rendered null and void
and would consequently be ineligible to obtain
any amount, much less the sums already paid to
him.
He,
therefore,
beseeched
this
Court
to
allow the “Scrutiny Committee” to complete the
proceedings,
so
that
his
client
can
then
act
upon its resultant order, without fear of any
further action from the controlling Authorities.
10.
Smt.Latha
Thankappan
–
learned
Special Government Pleader, very interestingly,
submitted
file
that the Government has decided to
an Appeal against the judgment of this
Court in WP(C)No.5170/2009. She said that the
direction therein, that the “Scrutiny Committee”
2025:KER:24978
[WA Nos.1298/2024, 1823/2024]
must
complete
fresh
proceedings
months,
was
unfair
and
illegal
earlier
proceedings
did
not
for
it
vitiating
factors,
within
six
because,
the
suffer
to
have
from
any
been
set
aside, as has been done in the said Judgment.
She argued that, therefore, since the “Scrutiny
Committee”
had
already
finalised
its
decision
against the appellant, he cannot now maintain an
Appeal against the impugned judgment because, he
is
not
entitled
to
claim
any
benefit
on
his
assertion that he belongs to a Scheduled Caste
Community.
being
11.
The
rival
thus
stated,
we
submissions
must
of
record
parties
that,
on
24.02.2025, when we considered these matters, we
issued the following interim order:
“Before we decide this matter, we
certainly require information as to when
the
Scrutiny
Committee
proposes
to
complete the exercise as ordered by this
2025:KER:24978
[WA Nos.1298/2024, 1823/2024]
Court
in
the
judgment
in
WP(C)
No.5170/2009.
2. Normally, we need not have
waited
for
the
because,
going
Committee
was
proceedings
afore
by
clarification
the
judgment,
directed
within
a
to
period
the
complete
of
six
months from the date of receipt of the
aforesaid
expired
judgment,
sometime
which
in
the
would
last
have
week
of
December, 2024 or in the first week of
January, 2025.
State
3.
But,
Bank
of
predicament
we
are
India
because,
aware
is
that
placed
their
in
the
a
specific
stand is that, if the Scrutiny Committee
is
to
find
against
the
petitioner’s
caste, then his appointment would have
to be treated as null and void, going by
the
judgment
of
the
Hon’ble
Supreme
Court in Viswanatha Pillai v. State of
Kerala [2004(1)KLT 708 (SC)]; and hence
that any further payments would militate
against such a proposition.
4. That being said, we could have
been justified in allowing this Appeal
and directing the payments to be made to
the
petitioner
solely
because
the
2025:KER:24978
[WA Nos.1298/2024, 1823/2024]
Scrutiny Committee has not been able to
complete
the
action,
directed
by
this
Court. But we choose to give them one
more opportunity. 5. The learned Special
Government
Pleader
is,
therefore,
directed to obtain specific instructions
as to the status of the enquiry by the
Scrutiny
Committee
and
if
a
final
proceedings has been issued by him.
List, therefore, on 03.03.2025”.
12.
Pertinently, Smt.Latha Thankappan is
unable to inform us even today, as to when the
“Scrutiny Committee” will be able to complete
the
enquiry
against
the
appellant;
and
she
candidly confessed that she would not be even
able to give us a ballpark period for this. She
refused
to
offer
any
specified
time
frame,
reiterating that the Government is intending to
file
an
Appeal
against
the
judgment
in
WP(C)No.5170/2009, since the directions therein
-
through
which
an
earlier
report
of
the
2025:KER:24978
[WA Nos.1298/2024, 1823/2024]
“Scrutiny
Committee”
had
been
set
aside
-
is
illegal.
13.
The
factual
surely indicates a
14.
scenario
we
now
see
piquant situation.
It is admitted that the appellant
joined
service
retired
under
Retirement
as
early
as
the
applicable
(VRS)
on
Scheme
on
11.01.1978
and
Voluntary
31.03.2001,
when,
admittedly, he was not subjected to any enquiry.
This is manifest from the factum of the bank
itself
producing
Annexure
WP(C)No.19392/2021,
along
with
R1(a)
their
in
counter
affidavit, which is the notice dated 25.04.2001,
they received from the Chairman of the “Scrutiny
Committee”.
15.
letter
is
appellant
Needless
to
say,
Annexure
dated
nearly
a
retired
from
service;
month
R1(a)
after
and
it
the
is
2025:KER:24978
[WA Nos.1298/2024, 1823/2024]
perhaps, therefore, that the bank had honoured
50% of the ex gratia payment to him and had also
adjusted his eligible “DCRG” and “PF’ into his
loan account. However, when they received this
letter, which, as said above, they did nearly
after
a
month
of
the
appellant’s
retirement,
they held up the balance amounts; and the said
position has remained so, for the last nearly 24
years now.
16.
the
In the meanwhile, it appears that
“Scrutiny
Committee”
completed
enquiry
against the appellant and other members of his
community,
to
settle
a
report,
but
which
was
then set aside by a learned Judge of this Court
in
WP(C)No.5170/2009,
signed
by
its
since
members,
it
had
not
been
but
only
by
its
Chairperson. In the said judgment, status quo as
on its date was ordered to be maintained till
2025:KER:24978
[WA Nos.1298/2024, 1823/2024]
fresh
orders
are
passed
by
the
“Scrutiny
Committee”; with a further direction to it to
issue such orders within a period of six months
from the date of its receipt.
17.
nine
As
months
presently
have
above-mentioned
available,
passed
in
after
more
the
WP(C)No.5170/2009
than
judgment
had
been
delivered.
The period of six months fixed by it
has
elapsed;
long
but
even
so,
Smt.Latha
Thankappan – learned Special Government Pleader,
is unwilling or unable – as the case may be, to
give us a period, much less a date, within which
the enquiry could be completed by the “Scrutiny
Committee”.
In
fact,
when
we
pointedly
asked
her, she could not even inform us whether it
could be done this year; and it thus creates a
situation
where
the
any visible terminum.
enquiry
continues
without
2025:KER:24978
[WA Nos.1298/2024, 1823/2024]
18.
specific
As we have recorded above, it is the
submission
of
Smt.Latha
Thankappan,
that the Government intends to file an Appeal
against the judgment in WP(C)No.5170/2009; but,
crucially, such has still not yet been filed,
concededly.
19.
for
the
Obviously,
Government
particularly
when
to
this
Court
cannot
wait
act
on
future
date,
judgment
in
the
a
WP(C)No.5170/2009 was delivered more than nine
months ago and had been virtually accepted by it
until now. We are guided to the suspicion that a
decision to file such an Appeal was only because
of the interim order above extracted, presumably
since the Government has now become aware that
the appellant may be able to obtain his retiral
benefits on account of the delay caused by the
“Scrutiny Committee”.
2025:KER:24978
[WA Nos.1298/2024, 1823/2024]
20.
It does not require expatiation to
remind the official respondents that delay is
anathema to the processes of law, particularly
when it is very large.
21.
In this case, the enquiry against
the appellant began some time in the year 2001,
as evident from Annexure R1(a) letter produced
by the “SBI”. Nearly 24 years have now passed,
but a final report regarding the caste status of
the
appellant
is
nowhere
in
vision,
or
even
anticipated. The appellant is more than 75 years
in age and we find no cause to disbelieve the
submissions
of
Sri.Nandakumara
his
learned
Menon,
that
Senior
counsel
–
his
client
is
suffering from medical conditions, as any person
of that age normally would. It is without doubt,
as also admitted by Sri.P.Ramakrishnan, that the
appellant’s DCRG and Pension never reached his
2025:KER:24978
[WA Nos.1298/2024, 1823/2024]
hands,
but
were
outstanding.
adjusted
Thus,
all
against
which
he
the
has
loans
received
until now, is 50% of the ex gratia payment under
the
“VRS”;
pension
though
and
the
he
is
balance
eligible
of
the
to
said
obtain
payment,
under the terms of retirement.
22.
We
cannot
be
oblivious
to
the
realities of life, particularly that of old age.
The
appellant
surely
also
succor,
for
minimum
dignity.
requires
him
One
to
cannot
sustenance,
live
wait
further
as
with
indefinitely
for the “Scrutiny Committee” to finalise their
enquiry; and their argument, that the earlier
report had been set aside wrongly by this Court,
cannot be countenanced in these proceedings. Of
course, they may obtain the liberty or remedy of
filing
an
Appeal
against
the
judgment
in
WP(C)No.5170/2009, but when it is admitted that
2025:KER:24978
[WA Nos.1298/2024, 1823/2024]
it has not been done even today, it exposes the
frailty of their stand.
23.
We
have,
therefore,
little
doubt
that it is now time for us to intervene, to
ensure that the appellant is able to live his
life with the unexpendable support entitled to
him, under the constitutional imperatives.
24.
That
said,
though
these
Appeals
arise from the judgment of the learned Single
Judge, it could not really require for us to
intervene with it because, even if we are to
confirm it, the appellant’s claims would deserve
of being allowed, since the time frame fixed by
this
Court
in
WP(C)No.5170/2009
has
long
expired. This is more so since, in the impugned
judgment, the learned Single Judge has refused
relief, not because it found it to be untenable,
but solely on account of a time frame having
2025:KER:24978
[WA Nos.1298/2024, 1823/2024]
been
fixed
in
the
earlier
judgment,
in
WP(C)No.5170/2009.
In the afore circumstances, we dispose of
these Appeals directing the “SBI” to immediately
release
all
the
eligible
payments
to
the
appellant, dehors the pendency of the enquiry by
the “Scrutiny Committee”, within a period of two
months from the date of receipt of a copy of
this judgment.
Needless
to
say,
we
have
not
reflected
upon any liberty that the Government of Kerala
may
have
against
WP(C)No.5170/2009;
and
the
if
judgment
any
in
contrary
directions are to be issued therein within the
time
afore
fixed,
our
directions
would
stand
modulated as per it.
That being so ordered, adverting to the
request of Sri.P.Ramakrishnan, that the officers
2025:KER:24978
[WA Nos.1298/2024, 1823/2024]
of
the
“SBI”
prejudice
be
in
not
subjected
future,
Sri.Nandakumara
Menon,
we
learned
to
unnecessary
put
it
Senior
to
Counsel,
whether his client would be willing to execute
an indemnity qua the amounts to be received by
him,
in
favour
of
the
Bank.
He
graciously
agreed, saying that his client is confident that
no report of the “Scrutiny Committee” would find
against him. This is recorded.
We, consequently, direct that the above
orders
of
ours
be
implemented
by
the
“SBI”,
after accepting a simple undertaking from the
appellant
to
indemnify
them
of
any
claim
against them in future.
Sd/DEVAN RAMACHANDRAN
JUDGE
Sd/stu/SAS
M.B. SNEHALATHA
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review