The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
5. 11 Thus, we find that there is no justifiable reason with the respondent authorities to deny allotment of a suitable plot to the Petitioner for rehabilitation as a project affected person. The Petitioner is entitled for such allotment as per the policy and the provisions.
5. 12 WP.9092.2019 Hence, we are of the opinion that the Writ Petition deserves to be allowed. Hence we pass following order:ORDER Writ Petition stands allowed; The Respondent nos. 2, 7 and 8 shall expedite the process of rehabilitation of the Lower Dudhana project affected persons from Mapegaon (BK.), Taluka Partur, district Jalna, within a period of 12 months from today, if not already done; Within Six months from today, the Respondent nos. 2, 7 and 8 shall allot a suitable plot to the Petitioner for his rehabilitation out of the land acquired for rehabilitation of Lower Dudhana Project affected persons; The aforesaid directions are subject to Petitioner’s compliance if any, as per the scheme and provisions of law. Rule made absolute in above terms. [AJIT B. KADETHANKAR, J.] [KISHORE C. SANT, J.] ………..
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:BHC-AUG:34115-DB
WP.9092.2019.odt
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
WRIT PETITION NO.9092 OF 2019
District : Jalna
Balasaheb S/o Panditrao Sakalkar,
Age: 48 years, Occu: Agriculture,
R/o. Village Mapegaon (Bk),
Tq. Partur, District Jalna
VERSUS
1]
The State of Maharashtra,
Through its Secretary,
Water Resources Department,
Mantralaya, Mumbai-32.
2]
The Divisional Commissioner/
Chief Controlling Authority,
Aurangabad Division,
Divisional Commissioner’s Office,
Aurangabad.
3]
The Chief Engineer and
Chief Administrator,
Command Area Development Authority,
Water Resources, CADA Office,
Auranagabad.
4]
The Assistant Chief Engineer
(Water Resources),
Water Resources Department,
Aurangabad.
5]
Special Land Acquisition Officer,
Krishna Valley Development
Corporation, Jalna.
6]
The Executive Engineer,
Lower Dudhana Project,
Irrigation Department, Jalna.
..Petitioner
7]
The Collector, Jalna,
Tq. And Dist. Jalna.
8]
The Tahsildar, Partur,
Tq. and Dist. Jalna
WP.9092.2019
..Respondents
---Mr.Mahesh V. Ghatge, Advocate for petitioner
Ms.J.P.Reddy, AGP for respondent nos.1, 2, 5, 7 and 8
---CORAM :
RESERVED ON :
PRONOUNCED ON :
KISHORE C. SANT &
AJIT B. KADETHANKAR, JJ.
AUGUST 03, 2026
AUGUST 06, 2026
JUDGMENT (Per Ajit B. Kadethankar, J.) :1.
Inaction on the part of the Respondent nos. 2, 7 and 8 to
allot a residential plot to the Petitioner under the rehabilitation
scheme
following
the
Maharashtra
Project
Affected
Persons
Rehabilitation Act 1999 (‘the Act’ for brevity), has brought the
Petitioner before us vide present Writ Petition.
2.
Rule. Rule made returnable forthwith. Pleadings are
completed by the Parties. We heard the Writ Petition for final disposal
by consent of the Parties.
3.
Facts in brief:
3.1
Petitioner owned a residential plot bearing Village
Property No.46/2 at Village Mapegaon (Budruk), Taluka Partur,
District Jalna. The mutation record stands exclusively in his name.
WP.9092.2019
There is no dispute over independent ownership of the Petitioner
over the said plot.
3.2
On 31-12-2001, the respondent authorities initiated land
acquisition process at village Mapegaon (Bk.) for the purpose of
Lower Dudhana Project. Accordingly, notification u/s.4 of the Land
Acquisition Act, 1864, was issued. In the due course of time, lands at
Mapegaon
village
including
Petitioner’s
plot
were
acquired.
Compensation against land acquisition was also paid to the land
losers.
3.3
For the purpose of rehabilitation of the project affected
persons, the State Government acquired about 16 hectors land at
Partur Shivar. The said land fell deficit to accommodate all the
beneficiaries. A number of families from the Petitioner’s village
remained non benefited of the rehabilitation. The Petitioner too could
not get any benefit of the Act.
3.4
Village
Panchayat
Mapegaon
(Bk.)
on
01-05-2017
unanimously resolved to file a representation to the Government
authorities for rehabilitation of the project affected persons. Such
representation was filed with various authorities. It was learnt that
the representation of the Petitioner and others were even forwarded
to the Respondent no. 3 authorities. However, no heed is paid to the
same.
3.5
WP.9092.2019
Hence this petition is filed by the Petitioner with a prayer
for directions to the Respondent nos. 2, 7 and 8 to expedite
rehabilitation for the project affected persons from Mapegaon (Bk.),
Taluka Partur, District Jalna. A prayer is also made to allot a suitable
plot to the Petitioner.
3.6
The
Writ
Petition
is
opposed
by
the
respondent
authorities. A reply affidavit is also filed under the seal and signature
of Dr.Pratibha Gore-Karanjkar, the then Tahsildar, Partur, District
Jalna.
3.7
At paragraph No.5 of the reply affidavit, the deponent
candidly accepted that 161 land losers and 91 landless labours were
allotted 16 hectors of land. It is further accepted that 22 plots for
project affected persons and 07 plots for landless labours remained
to be allotted.
3.8
So far as Petitioner is concerned, it is submitted that (i)
Petitioner’s plot was an open plot, and hence he is not entitled for
plot allotment; (ii) property of Petitioner’s father was also acquired
for which compensation is already paid, hence no allotment could be
made to the Petitioner; and (iii) since the Talathi reported that the
Petitioner was unmarried and residing with his father in a joint
family, he is not entitled for any allotment.
3.9
WP.9092.2019
With above defense, the respondent authorities sought to
justify declination to allot any plot to the Petitioner.
4.
Submissions:-
4.1
Mr. Ghatge, learned advocate for the Petitioner would
submit that the authorities are not at all justified for denying
allotment of plot to him on any count.
4.2
He would submit that his independent ownership is not
disputed by anybody. Compensation for land acquisition cannot be a
ground for denial of plot for rehabilitation.
4.3
That, the report of Talathi is absolutely perverse to the
record. The record clearly show that that Petitioner’s residential
house was situated over the plot. At the relevant time, the Petitioner
was unmarried, but later he got married. Anyhow, this cannot be a
ground to deny him the benefit of rehabilitation. Hence, the Writ
Petition be allowed with directions to the authorities to allot the
Petitioner a plot for rehabilitation.
4.4
Mrs.
Reddy,
learned
Assistant
Government
Pleader
vehemently opposes the Writ Petition. She would rely upon the reply
affidavit filed by the concerned Tahsildar.
4.5
Mrs. Reddy would take us to the Part IV of Schedule
appended to the Act r/w Section 13(3) (c) and 14 (3) and (4) and 16
WP.9092.2019
(1) of the Act. She would submit that in view of the Part IV of the
Schedule, the Petitioner is not entitled for any allotment.
4.6
It is further argued by the learned Assistant Government
Pleader that, it was an undisputed fact that the Petitioner was
unmarried person residing with his father. That, for this reason only
he would not be entitled for any allotment.
4.7
Learned Assistant Government Pleader concludes her
arguments with a submission that as per the Talathi report,
Petitioner’s property was an open plot. Hence he won’t be entitled
for allotment of plot for rehabilitation. With such arguments
Mrs.
Reddy prays to dismiss the Writ Petition.
5.
Discussion and consideration:-
5.1
We have heard the parties at length. With their able
assistance, we have perused the record. On the basis of the
pleadings, record and verbal submissions, we now deal with the
matter.
5.2
The petitioner’s ownership on plot no.46/2, village
Mapegaon (Bk.), Taluka Partur, District Jalna is not disputed, nor it is
disputed that the said property is acquired for the Lower Dudhana
Project. The Form-8 maintained by the Village Panchayat, Mapegaon
WP.9092.2019
(Bk.) is before us. It shows Petitioner’s name as owner and possessor
of the said plot.
5.3
A notice dated 31-12-2001 issued by the Special Land
Acquisition Officer, Krishna Valley u/s 4(1) of the Land Acquisition Act
to the Petitioner is also on record. It is in respect of petitioner’s
aforesaid land.
5.4
Final Award ‘E’ statement also shows that compensation
is paid to the Petitioner against acquisition of his aforesaid plot.
5.5
Thus, there is no dispute that the Petitioner is a project
affected person within the meaning of the Act. The benefit is denied
only on two counts. As far as objection that the Petitioner was
unmarried at the relevant time and was allegedly residing with his
father, we find this reason to deny the benefit of the Act to the
Petitioner to be absolutely irrational.
5.6
Learned Assistant Government Pleader could not point
out any provision in the Act or any Government policy which debars
an unmarried person from getting benefit of plot allotment for
rehabilitation purpose. What is required, that a person’s independent
property stands acquired for some project covered by the Act.
Admittedly, the Lower Dudhana Project, is a project within the
meaning of the Act.
5.7
WP.9092.2019
The Petitioner is covered by the definition of ‘affected
person’ within the meaning of Section 2 (2) (a) of the Act which
reads thus:
Section 2 (Definitions)
(2) “affected persons” means—
(a) an occupant whose land in the affected zone (including land in the
gaothan) is acquired under section 14 for the purposes of a project ;
5.8
Thus, it is clear that the Petitioner is covered by the
definition of ‘affected person’ as enumerated in the Act. This is
because, the definition expressly covers the land falling in Gaothan
too. Petitioner’s land undisputedly falls within Gaothan as could be
seen from the documents, particularly the Form-8 annexed to the
Petition.
Learned
Assistant
Government
Pleader
could
not
demonstrate that there is any prohibition on open plot for
rehabilitation allotment. Hence we are of the considered opinion that
the first objection raised by the respondent does not stand on merit.
5.9
So far as another objection as regards payment of
compensation is concerned, it is not in dispute that the Petitioner
was paid compensation. However, this cannot be a ground for
denying rehabilitation and
allotment of plot to a land loser.
Allotment of plot for rehabilitation cannot be in lieu of compensation,
or vice-a-versa. Rehabilitation is a complete separate scheme under
WP.9092.2019
the Act, which is governed by the parameters laid down in the
Statute. One who is covered by those parameters, shall be entitled
for the benefit of allotment. Hence, we find that the second objection
is misconceived.
5.10
The
last
objection
raised
by
learned
Assistant
Government Pleader is reference to the Part IV of Schedule appended
to the Act. The said part only shows
quantum/area that can be
allotted to a beneficiary in proportion to the family size. Reference to
the said provision is of no avail to the learned Assistant Government
Pleader.
Upon
our
cautious
query
to
the
learned
Assistant
Government Pleader as to how the said provision bars the Petitioner,
we could not get any satisfactory, nor even remotely convincing
explanation. Again, it was sought to impress that Petitioner
was
residing with this father, and that he won’t be entitled for allotment
of plot.
5.11
Thus, we find that there is no justifiable reason with the
respondent authorities to deny allotment of a suitable plot to the
Petitioner for rehabilitation as a project affected person. The
Petitioner is entitled for such allotment as per the policy and the
provisions.
5.12
WP.9092.2019
Hence, we are of the opinion that the Writ Petition
deserves to be allowed. Hence we pass following order:ORDER
I.
Writ Petition stands allowed;
II.
The Respondent nos. 2, 7 and 8 shall expedite the process
of rehabilitation of the Lower Dudhana project affected
persons from Mapegaon (BK.), Taluka Partur, district Jalna,
within a period of 12 months from today, if not already
done;
III.
Within Six months from today, the Respondent nos. 2, 7
and 8 shall allot a suitable plot to the Petitioner for his
rehabilitation out of the land acquired for rehabilitation of
Lower Dudhana Project affected persons;
IV.
The
aforesaid
directions
are
subject
to
Petitioner’s
compliance if any, as per the scheme and provisions of law.
V.
Rule made absolute in above terms.
[AJIT B. KADETHANKAR, J.]
KBP
[KISHORE C. SANT, J.]
………..
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review