The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
27. It is not possible to quantify any amount in lieu of the services rendered by the wife/mother to the family ie. the husband and children. However for the purpose of award of compensation to the dependants some pecuniary estimate has to be made of the services of the housewife/mother. In that context the term ‘services’ is required to be given a broad meaning and must be construed by taking into account the loss of personal care and attention given by the deceased to her children as a mother and to her husband as a wife. They are entitled to adequate compensation in lieu of the loss of gratuitous services rendered by the deceased. The amount payable to the dependants cannot be diminished on the ground that some close relation like a grandmother may volunteer to render some of the services to the family which the deceased was giving earlier.’ In the instant case the Learned Trial Judge upon considering different factors and upon assigning reasons took the notional income as Rs. 5,000/per month and arrived at the compensation of Rs. 9,17,000/- which cannot be said to be meager. However considering the status of the family and the responsibility taken by the deceased Rs. 11,00,000/- compensation is considered just and reasonable. Thus the respondent no-1/claimant is entitled to Rs. 11,00,000/- (Rupees Eleven lakh) from the appellant Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Co. Ltd. along wi…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
Civil Appellate Jurisdiction
Appellate Side
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Biswaroop Chowdhury
F.M.A. 527 of 2025
Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Co. Ltd.
VERSUS
Saanvi Samanta & Anr.
With
COT 8 of 2025
Saanvi Samanta represented by her Guardian Grandfather, Banamali
Samanta
VERSUS
Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Co. Ltd. & Anr.
With
FMA 1421 of 2024
Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Co. Ltd.
VERSUS
Alo Samanta & Ors.
With
COT 9 of 2025
Alo Samanta & Ors.
VERSUS
Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Co. Ltd. & Anr.
For
the
Appellant/Insurance
Company in FMA 527/2025, FMA
1421/2024andRespondent/Insurance
Company COT 8/2025, COT 9 of
2025:
Mrs. Sucharita Paul, Adv.
Mr. Jayanta Kumar Mandal, Adv.
For the Appellant/Claimants in COT
8/2025, COT 9 of 2025 and
Respondent/Claimants
FMA
527/2025, FMA. 1421/2024:
Last Heard on: April 21, 2026
Judgment on: June 09, 2026
Biswaroop Chowdhury,J:
The above appeals being FMA-527 of 2025, and FMA-1421 of 2024 are
directed against Judgment dated 20th August 2024 passed by Learned
Additional District Judge Fast Track 3rd Court Sadar Paschim Medinipur in
MAC case No-262 of 2022 and MAC-261 of 2022 respectively. Both the claim
cases arise out of the accident dated 16-04-2022 allegedly caused by vehicle
no. WB-33/5717.
The case of the claimants in MAC Case No. 262 of 2022 may be summed
up thus:
On 16-04-2022 at about 9.00. AM while the deceased Barnali Samanta
Nandi was coming with a vehicle being No. WB-82E/2293 which was driving
also her husband with view to reach home from Kolkata towards Midnapore at
that time at near Harina Bus stand at N.H.-6 road under Kharagpur (Local)
Police Station suddenly one lorry with excessive high speed over took the
vehicle of the victim at the extreme left side of road. The said vehicle ranover
upon soiled road for that reason suddenly the area was covered with dust. The
area became invisible and at that time one vehicle being WB. No. 33/5717 was
standing middle of the highway without signal (non-parking area) and deceased
bounded to dash the back side of standing vehicle as a result all the occupants
of the car of victims got severe injuries, and the deceased as well as her
husband died on the spot, elder daughter named Sinjini was taken to
Midnapore Medical College and Hospital and after few hours she was declared
dead. Younger daughter named Saanvi got severe injuries on her both knee
and her treatment is going on.
The accident took place solely due to rash and negligent parking at the
non area parking zone and middle of the N.H.-6 road. In the event the driver of
the vehicle WB-33/5717 did not keep the vehicle upon middle of the highway
the accident could have been avoided.
Contribution made by the deceased to the house is invaluable and
cannot be computed in terms of money. Deceased did not work by the clock,
deceased was in the constant attendance of the family throughout the day and
night she took care of all requirements of the husband and children, and she
taught her daughters and provided invaluable guidance to them for their future
life. She took care of her two daughters as a mother and to her husband as a
wife and to her parents-in-Law as a daughter in law.
The deceased was a healthy person and she had a good future prospect.
In MACC-No-261 of 2022 the case of the claimants may be summed up
thus:-
On 16-04-2022 at about 9.00 AM while the deceased Shamit Samanta
was driving his vehicle bearing No. WB-82E/2293 with his wife and two minor
daughters from Kolkata towards Midnapur at the time at near Harina Busstand at N-H. 6-road under Kharagpur (Local) Police Station suddenly one lorry
with excessive high speed overtook the vehicle of the deceased from the
extreme left side of road. The said vehicle ranover upon soiled road for that
reason suddenly the area was covered with dust, the area became invisible and
at that time one vehicle being No. WB-33/5717 was standing middle of the
highway without signal (non parking area) and the deceased bounded to dash
the back side of standing vehicle as a result all the occupants of the car of
deceased got severe injuries. Deceased his wife named Barnali Samanta Nandi
died on the spot elder daughter named Sinjini was taken to Midnapore Medical
College and Hospital and after a few hours doctor declared her dead. Younger
daughter named Saanvi got severe injuries on her both knee and her treatment
is going on.
The accident took place solely due to rash and negligent parking at the
non area parking zone and middle of the N-H-6 road. In the event the driver of
the vehicle WB-33/5717 did not keep the vehicle upon the middle of the highway the accident could have been avoided.
The deceased was the sole bread earner of his family and family
members of the deceased were dependent upon income of the deceased, and
due to his premature death, family members of the deceased are passing their
days with great hardship. Growing up education, marriage protection etc. of
the daughter of the deceased are seriously hampered and the children of the
deceased are deprived from love, care, and guidance of her parents. Parents
lost filial consortium due to death of their only son. The deceased was a well
healthy person and he had a good future prospect.
Pursuant to the filing of the claim cases notices were issued upon the
opposite parties, vehicle owner and Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Co. Ltd.
Opposite party vehicle owner did not contest the case. However opposite party
Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Co. Ltd contested the case by filing written
statements. Issues were framed and evidence was adduced in both the cases.
Learned Trial Judge upon considering the evidence adduced in both the
cases, and upon hearing the Learned Advocates was pleased to dispose of both
the claim cases.
In MAC case No-262 of 2022 which is the subject matter of Appeal FMA527 of 2025 Learned Trial Judge was pleased to Award Compensation of Rs.
9,17,000/-. (Rupees nine lakh seventeen thousand) together with interest @6%
per annum from date of filing claim case till full liquidation.
In MAC Case-No-261 of 2022 which is subject matter of Appeal in FMA
No-1421 of 2024, Learned Trial Judge was pleased to award compensation of
Rs. 2,10,79,100/- along with interest @6% per annum from date of filing of
claim case till realization.
The ground of challenge in the appeal FMA-527 of 2025 against the order
in MAC Case No. 262 of 2022 is that firstly the offending vehicle was stationary
when victim vehicle struck from behind. Secondly the accident took place at 9
a.m. in the morning in broad day light and therefore it was not a case where
visibility was an issue. Thirdly the driver of the offending vehicle produced
photographs of victim vehicle which showed that the vehicle was driven in high
speed. Fourthly Learned Judge erred in accepting monthly income of victim as
Rs. 5000/-.
The claimants have filed cross objection in the appeal challenging the
quantum
of
compensation.
According
to
the
respondents/claimants
compensation granted is inadequate and the notional monthly income should
be Rs. 10,000/-.
Heard Learned Advocates for the parties. Perused the materials on
record. The following decisions are relied upon by Learned Advocates.
Kirti and Anr. VS Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. and ors.
Reported in 2021 SAR (civ) 147.
Shiv Kumar and others VS Gainda Lal and others.
Reported in 2022 (4) TAC 707 (S.L.).
Sarla Verma (Smt.) and others VS Delhi Transport Corporation and
Anr.
Reported in (2009) 6 SCC-121.
National Insurance Company Ltd. VS Pronay Sethi and ors.
Reported in 2017(4) TAC 673. (S.L.)
Rasmita Biswal and ors. VS Divisional Manager National Insurance
Company Ltd. and Anr.
Reported in 2022 SAR Online. (SC)-747.
Khenyei VS New India Assurance Co. Ltd and ors.
Reported in 2015 (2) TAC-677 (SC)
Kusum Lata and ors. VS Satbiz and ors.
Reported in 2011(2) TAC. 1 (S.C)
Anita Sharma and ors. VS The New India Assurance Co. Ltd. and Anr.
2021 SAR. (civ). 1.
ICICI Lombard General Insurance Co. Ltd. VS Rajani Sahoo and
others.
Reported in 2025(1) TAC. 374 (S.C.)
Radha Rani and ors. VS Mohar Singh and Anr.
Reported in 2024 (2) TAC. 20 (S.C.)
Mamata and others VS Bhav Singh @ Mansingh and Another.
2022 (4) TAC-746 (S.C.)
With regard to the submission regarding ex-oneration of the vehicle being
WB-33/5717 as the said vehicle was stationary it is to be remembered that
mere plea that a vehicle was stationary does not absolve the owner of vehicle
from liability if the said vehicle was parked in an improper place causing such
accident. Learned Trial Judge upon considering the evidence has assigned
reasons for coming to conclusion about negligence of driver of vehicle no. WB33-5717 (Mini-Truck) in parking of the vehicle on the middle of the road. Upon
perusal of charge sheet it appears that the police stated that the incident
happened because the driver of the vehicle having registration no-WB-33-5717
parked the vehicle illegally on the road. Thus there is no error in the findings of
the Learned Trial Judge about the accident caused due to negligent parking of
the driver of the vehicle bearing no. WB-33-5717 (Mini-Truck) on the middle of
the road.
Now with regard to the quantum of compensation as the victim was
housewife there is no straight-jacket formula to consider the notional income
and each case is to be decided on its own facts and on the basis of guidelines
as laid down in different judicial pronouncements. However the loss suffered by
members of family on the death of a housewife cannot be compensated by
money. Thus the compensation which appears to the Court as just and
reasonable should be awarded.
In the case of Arun Kumar Agarwal V National Insurance Co. Ltd. (2010)
9 SCC. P-218 the Hon’ble Supreme Court observed as follows:‘26 In India the Courts have recognized that the contribution made by
the wife to the house is invaluable and cannot be computed in terms of money.
The gratuitous servives rendered by the wife with true love and affection to the
children and her husband and managing the household affairs cannot be
equated with the services rendered by others. A wife/mother does not work by
the clock she is in the constant attendance of the family throughout the day
and night unless she is employed and is required to attend the employer’s work
for particular hours. She takes care of all the requirements of the husband and
children including cooking of food washing of clothes etc. she teaches small
children and provides invaluable guidance to them for their future life. A
housekeeper or maidservant can do the household work such as cooking food,
washing clothes and utensils, keeping the house clean etc. but she can never
be a substitute for a wife/mother who renders selfless service to her husband
and children.
27. It is not possible to quantify any amount in lieu of the services
rendered by the wife/mother to the family ie. the husband and children.
However for the purpose of award of compensation to the dependants some
pecuniary estimate has to be made of the services of the housewife/mother. In
that context the term ‘services’ is required to be given a broad meaning and
must be construed by taking into account the loss of personal care and
attention given by the deceased to her children as a mother and to her
husband as a wife. They are entitled to adequate compensation in lieu of the
loss of gratuitous services rendered by the deceased. The amount payable to
the dependants cannot be diminished on the ground that some close relation
like a grandmother may volunteer to render some of the services to the family
which the deceased was giving earlier.’
In the instant case the Learned Trial Judge upon considering different
factors and upon assigning reasons took the notional income as Rs. 5,000/per month and arrived at the compensation of Rs. 9,17,000/- which cannot be
said to be meager. However considering the status of the family and the
responsibility taken by the deceased Rs. 11,00,000/- compensation is
considered just and reasonable. Thus the respondent no-1/claimant is entitled
to Rs. 11,00,000/- (Rupees Eleven lakh) from the appellant Bajaj Allianz
General Insurance Co. Ltd. along with interest @6% p.a. from date of filing
claim case till realization.
Now the ground of challenge in the appeal FMA-1421 of 2024 against the
Order in MAC Case No. 261 of 2022 is that, firstly the Learned Trial Court
failed to appreciate that the truck driver was not negligent as the same was
stationary.
Secondly the Learned Trial Judge failed to appreciate that the deceased
himself contributed to the accident by driving in a rash and negligent manner.
Thirdly Learned Trial Judge failed to appreciate that the accident took
place at 9 a.m. in the morning i.e. in broad daylight on the soil portion of NH 6
and therefore it was not a case wherein ‘visibility’ was an issue.
Fourthly Learned Judge failed to appreciate that the witness is not a
summoned witness and came to depose at the request of the claimants.
Fifth Learned Trial Judge failed to appreciate that income was variable
and FORM 16 of the victim was not exhibited by the claimants to prove the
total income.
The
respondents/claimants
have
challenged
the
quantum
of
compensation awarded on the ground that filial consortium is not awarded and
the compensation should be enhanced.
Heard Learned Advocate for the appellant and Learned Advocate for the
respondents/claimants. Perused the material on records.
With regard to the ground of the appellant that the offending truck was
stationary and hence not responsible for the accident it is to be remembered
that merely a vehicle is stationary does not absolve its driver with regard to
accident in the event said vehicle is parked in an unauthorized place. Learned
Trial Judge upon considering the evidence of 2 eye witnesses came to the
conclusion that the accident took place due to the negligent parking of the
vehicle being WB-33-5717. Moreover the charge sheet submitted by the Police
Authority states that the incident happened because the offending vehicle
having registration no. WB-33-5717 parked the vehicle illegally on the road.
Thus the charge sheet corroborates the case of the claimants. Learned Judge
also made it clear that no material evidence has been produced by the opposite
party Insurance Company to substantiate that the deceased was responsible
for the accident in any manner.
Now with regard to the argument that P.W. 2 and P.W. 4 were not
summoned witness it is to be remembered that the fact the eye witness in
motor accident claim case are not summoned witness does not destroy the
credibility of the said witnesses if their evidence creates confidence in the
minds of Court. Moreover P.W. 2 is witness named in the charge sheet
submitted by the Police Authority. The statements made by P.W. 2 and P.W. 4
in cross-examination will clearly go to show that they have witnessed the
accident.
Thus there is no error in the findings of the Learned Trial Judge with
regard to accident taking place due to negligent parking of the vehicle being
WB-33/5717.
Now with regard to the quantum of compensation it appears that the
claimants have proved the income by examining the employer of the victim.
Learned Trial Judge upon considering the income of the victim and upon
applying the principles as laid down, by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case
of National Insurance Company Ltd. VS Pronay Sethi reported in AIR-2017 S.C.
P-5157 has granted just and reasonable compensation. Although it is
contended by the respondents/claimants in their cross-objection about nongranting of filial consortium but the fact that the decision of Pronay Sethi does
not deal with filial consortium and considering the quantum of compensation
awarded by Learned Trial Court further interference is not required.
Thus this Appeal FMA-1421 of 2024 along with COT-9/2025 stands
dismissed. Judgment and Award passed by Learned Additional District Judge
Fast Track 3rd Court Sadar Paschim Medinipur in MAC Case No. 261 of 2022
stands affirmed. The claimants/respondents are entitled to withdraw the
compensation amount if deposited including accrued interest upon compliance
of necessary formalities. In the event the deposit is not made the same be made
within 8 weeks from the date of communication of this order.
The Appeal FMA-527 of 2025 along with COT-8/2025 stands disposed.
Judgment and Award dated 20th August 2024 passed by Learned Additional
District Judge Fast Track 3rd Court Sadar Paschim Medinipur in MAC Case No.
262 of 2022 stands modified to the extent that the respondent no-1/claimant
is entitled to compensation of Rs. 11 lakh along with interest @6% p.a. from
date of filing of claim case till today.
Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Co. Ltd. shall deposit before Registrar
General High Court Calcutta Rs. 11 lakh along with interest @6% p.a. within 8
weeks from the date of communication of this Order. In the event amount
awarded by Learned Trial Court is already deposited balance amount be
deposited.
The claimant/respondent will be entitled to withdraw the compensation
including accrued interest if any upon compliance of necessary formalities.
Urgent photostat certified copy of this order, if applied for, should be
made available to the parties upon compliance with the requisite formalities.
(Biswaroop Chowdhury, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review