Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
LPAOW No. 13/2018
CM no. 2151/2020
IA No. 01/2018
CM No. 5194/2023
Reserved on:28.04.2026
Pronounced on:- 20 .05.2026
Uploaded on:20.05.2026
Whether the operative part or full
judgment is pronounced:- Full
1.
Sh. Baj Singh age 77 years S/o Sh. Kundan Singh R/o Village
Seera Kotla, Now Tehsil Katra District Reasi.
2.
Sh. Kamaljit Singh age 57 Years S/o Sh. Baj Singh R/o BSNL
Staff residential quarter No. B-4, Udhampur.
3.
Sh. Sanjeet Singh age 54 years S/o Sh. Baj Singh R/o H. No.
Canal Raod, Jammu.
4.
Sh. Sukhdev Singh age 37 years S/o Baj Singh R/o Village Seera
Kotla, Now Tehsil Katra District, Reasi.
……...Appellant(s)
Through:
Mr. O. P Thakur, Sr. Advocate with
Mr. R. K. S. Thakur, Advocate &
Mr. O. S. Bandral, Advocate
Versus
1.
State of Jammu and Kashmir through Chi9ef Secretary, Civil
Secretariat, Srinagar.
2.
Commissioner-cum-Secretary,
Secretariat, Srinagar.
3.
Collector Land Acquisiton (Mata Vaishno Devi University,
Katra), Headquarter, Udhampur.
4.
Shree Mata Vaishno Devi University having its office Kakriyal,
Tehsil Katra District Reasi.
…..Respondent(s)
Through:
Mohammad Yaseen Dar
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
document
Revenue
Department,
Civil
Ms. Monika Kohli, Sr. AAG with
Ms. Sagira Jaffer, Assisting Counsel for R- 1 to 3
Mr. Rajnish Raina, Sr. Advocate (through VC) with
Mr. Rishu Rajeshwar, Advocate &
Mr. Prabhat Sangotra, Advocate for R-4
CORAM:
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON’BLE MR JUSTICE RAJNESH OSWAL, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
Per Oswal ‘J’
01.
Learned senior counsel for the appellants submits that appellant No.1
has expired and is survived by appellants 2 to 4. As such, there is no
requirement to bring the legal representatives of the deceased appellant No.1
on record. In view of the above, appellant No.1 is directed to be deleted from
the array of appellants. The Registry shall update the cause title of the appeal
accordingly.
02.
The appellants, along with their late father, Baj Singh (deceased
appellant No.1), had filed a writ petition, bearing OWP No. 1124/2004,
seeking a direction to the respondents to exclude their houses and four shops
from the acquisition proceedings, and to restrain the respondents from
demolishing them or handing them over to the Shri Mata Vaishno Devi
University. Alternatively, the petitioners sought a direction to the
respondents to provide 18 Marlas of land to each appellant for constructing
their houses, along with one commercial plot each at the proposed colony
earmarked for the oustees of villages Seera Kotla and Kakriyal, upon
payment of the requisite cost.
Mohammad Yaseen Dar
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
document
03.
The appellants sought the aforementioned reliefs on the grounds that
they owned separate houses on land falling under Survey No. 128 at Village
Seera Kotla, Tehsil and District Udhampur, as well as four adjacent shops
under Survey No. 68. They stated that the entire land measuring 11 Kanals
under Survey No. 68, along with another parcel measuring 15 Kanals and 9
Marlas under Survey No. 128, had been acquired for Shri Mata Vaishno
Devi University.
04.
The appellants contended that the respondents had decided to provide
18 Marlas of land to each family whose residential houses were acquired,
charging a rate of ₹9,000/- per family for the allotment. The appellants based
their claims on the minutes of the meeting of the Executive Council of Shri
Mata Vaishno Devi University held on 01.03.2003. Therein, it was resolved
that the University would explore the possibility of constructing shops for
various planned services and allot them on a lease basis to the evictees.
Furthermore, evictees who did not possess alternative residential
accommodation in the neighbourhood, or in and around Katra, could be
considered for the allotment of residential plots, the size of which would
depend on the amount of compensation paid to them.
05.
Respondent No. 4 countered the appellants' claim, asserting that the
deceased, Baj Singh, owned agricultural land under Survey No. 68, which
included four shops. This property was acquired for establishing Shri Mata
Vaishno Devi University. At the request of the late Baj Singh, four
alternative shops located directly opposite the acquired structures were
allotted to the appellants in lieu of the original shops. While Respondent No.
Mohammad Yaseen Dar
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
document
4 admitted there was a proposal to allot 18 Marlas of land to completely
displaced persons, it was contended that because only a portion of Baj
Singh's land was acquired and full compensation was paid, the deceased was
never actually displaced. This is substantiated by the fact that he
subsequently constructed a residential house on his remaining land at
Village Seera Kotla. Furthermore, no land belonging to the appellants
themselves was acquired. Regarding the assertions in paragraph 11 of the
writ petition, that the appellants owned separate houses on land under
Survey No. 128 at Village Seera Kotla, Udhampur, respondent No. 4 denied
knowledge of the same.
06.
By way of the impugned judgment dated 01.05.2017, the learned
Single Judge dismissed the writ petition. The writ court noted that the
grievance of the deceased appellant, Baj Singh, stood redressed since four
shops had been allotted to him and his three sons (the appellants herein).
Furthermore, the court observed that the petitioners had failed to
demonstrate the existence of any structure on Survey No. 128 to substantiate
their claim.
07.
Aggrieved by the judgment dated 01.05.2017 rendered by the learned
writ court in OWP No. 1124/2004, the appellants have preferred this intracourt appeal. They assert that the writ court failed to properly consider their
contention that their houses existed on Survey No. 128. They emphasize that
while respondent No. 4 merely denied the contents of paragraph 11 of the
writ petition for want of knowledge, respondent Nos. 1 to 3 including the
Collector Land Acquisition, failed to file an independent reply and simply
Mohammad Yaseen Dar
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
document
adopted respondent No. 4's objections. Furthermore, the appellants urge that
respondent No. 4’s contention that only entirely landless persons are entitled
to rehabilitation plots is factually incorrect and misconceived. They maintain
that the acquired land was the ancestral property of the appellants and the
deceased appellant, Baj Singh. A copy of the final award, along with details
of the compensation paid to the late Baj Singh, has been placed on record.
08.
Learned senior counsel for the appellants relied on Serial No. 64 of
the final award to establish that the house of the deceased appellant, Baj
Singh, was acquired. He argued that pursuant to the Council's resolution, the
deceased was entitled to a residential plot as he was left without
accommodation. Addressing the respondent's claim regarding alternative
land, counsel referred to the deceased's supplementary affidavit, noting that
the small parcel under Survey No. 06 in Village Seera Kotla was a kilometer
off the Panthal/Jhagger Kotli road and unfit for residential use; the deceased
only built a structure there out of necessity after his original home was
taken. Finally, senior counsel submitted that the appellants forgo their claim
for individual 18-Marla allotments for each of them, restricting their relief
strictly to the acquired house of the late Baj Singh.
09.
Per contra, Mr. Rajnish Raina, learned senior counsel for Respondent
No. 4, submitted that the deceased appellant, Baj Singh, received due
compensation. He argued that the appellants’ claim before the writ court
regarding owning four houses was incorrect, as the final award shows that
only the deceased’s property was acquired. Senior Counsel further stated
that the Respondent has no objection if the Collector/SDM, Katra, is directed
Mohammad Yaseen Dar
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
document
to verify whether the deceased's house was among the acquired properties.
Upon confirmation of the acquisition, the eligibility of the late Baj Singh for
the allotment of a residential plot, pursuant to the Executive Council’s
resolution, will be evaluated, and appropriate orders will be passed
expeditiously.
10.
Heard learned counsel appearing for the parties and perused the
record.
11.
The sole issue for consideration is the appellants' claim, as the legal
heirs of the deceased Baj Singh, to the allotment of a residential plot. The
appellants contend that because the late Baj Singh's only residential house
was acquired for Shri Mata Vaishno Devi University, they being the legal
heirs of late Baj Singh are entitled to one residential plot under the rules and
schemes formulated by the University's Executive Council.
12.
The final award establishes that the deceased appellant, Baj Singh,
owned the acquired house. However, whether he met the eligibility criteria
for an 18-Marla plot under the University's resolution is a question of fact
that must be decided by the respondents following a detailed examination of
the record.
13.
Learned Writ Court has not examined the issue with regard to
acquisition of house, though the learned Writ is correct in observing that the
appellants have failed to demonstrate the existence of structure in Survey
No. 128 as pleaded by the appellants.
Mohammad Yaseen Dar
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
document
Without being influenced by any observations made herein regarding
14.
the acquisition of the late Baj Singh's house, we dispose of this appeal by
modifying the impugned judgment. The Collector, Land Acquisition, Katra,
is directed to verify whether a house belonging to the deceased appellant
was acquired for Shri Mata Vaishno Devi University, and to identify its
specific Survey Number.
15.
The Collector shall also assess whether the deceased met the criteria
under the Executive Council's resolution for a residential plot, ignoring the
fact that he later built a structure on Survey No. 06 in Village Seera Kotla
out of necessity. Should the Collector hold that the deceased appellant was
eligible, the respondents are directed to allot one residential plot to the
appellants pursuant to the governing rules and rehabilitation scheme. The
respondents are directed to complete this entire exercise within three months
from receiving a copy of this order.
16.
Disposed of along with all connected CM(s).
(RAJNESH OSWAL)
JUDGE
(ARUN PALLI)
CHIEF JUSTICE
Srinagar
20.05.2026
“Mohammad Yasin Dar”
Whether the Judgment is reportable: No.
Mohammad Yaseen Dar
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this
document
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review