Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CRA-S-382
3825-2025
-11-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJA
PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT
CHANDIGA
DIGARH
CRA-S-3825-2025
Date of Decision: 9.1.2026
Bablii and aanother
…Appellants.
Vers
Versus
State of Ha
Haryana and others
…Respondents.
ents.
CORAM:
AM: HON’BLE MS. JUSTICE
CE AA
AARADHNA SAWHNEY.
Present:
Mr. S.P. Chahar, Advocate
ate for the appellants.
Mr. Vishal Singh, AAG,, Harya
Haryana.
Ms. Monika Jangra, Advocate
vocate for respondent No.2.
****
AARADHN
ADHNA SAWHNEY, J. (Oral)
1.
Appellants have filed the present appeal for grant
rant of
o
anticipatory
ipatory bail in case FIR No. 319 date
dated 07.11.2025, registered against
again
them, under
unde Sections 115(2), 351(3), 333, 3(5) of BNS and Section 3(2)(va)
3(2)(v
and 3(1)(s)
3(1)(s of Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribe (Prevention
tion of
o
Atrocities)
cities) Act, 1989, at Police Station Kala
Kalanaur, District Rohtak.
2.
Relevant facts as emerging
rging from documents on record
cord be
b
noticed
ed hereinbelow:her
On 6.11.2025, an intimation
ion w
was received in the Police Statio
tation
regarding
ing admission of injured Shri Niw
Niwas and Sanjay, son of Satyawa
yawan
Singh, both residents of village Basana,
a, Di
District Rohtak, in CHC, Kalanau
anaur.
On reachin
ching at CHC, Kalanaur, it came
me to his notice that injured hass been
bee
GURBACHAN SINGH
2026.01.21 15:00
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRA-S-382
3825-2025
-22-
referred
d to Government Hospital, Rohtak
htak. On the following day, i.e.,
.e., on
o
7.11.2025,
025, HC Pawan Kumar along with
ith C
Constable Priyanka arrived at the
th
hospitall and
an after taking permission from Doctor on duty, questioned
ed the
th
injured,, on
one of them, namely, Shri Niwas
as ggave a written complaint pointin
inting
therein tha
that he is running a grocery shop
op nnext to his house. His daughter--inlaw, Pinki
inki is Sarpanch of village Basana.
na. In the evening of 6.11.2025, Babli
Bab
(appellant
lant No.1) came to their house and questioned his daughter-in-la
law
(Pinki) as to why MNREGA wages have
ve nnot been cleared. Pinki explaine
lained
her positio
sition and assured that the money
ey w
would be paid by the Governme
nment
very soon.
on. Though at that point of time,
e, B
Babli left the spot, but in an angry
ang
mood. Later
Lat on, around 7 PM, aforesaid
aid Babli (appellant No.1) along
g with
wi
her sons
ns M
Manjeet, Ankit and daughter Jy
Jyoti (appellant No.2) entered
ed the
th
shop off co
complainant and without anyy pro
provocation again used derogato
gatory
language
ge a
as also assaulted him.
Ass pe
per complainant, Manjeet stabbe
abbed
screw drive
driver in his stomach. When Sonu
nu ((worker of complainant) rushed
hed to
his rescue
scue, he was also not spared.
d.
On hearing hue and cries
ies of
complainan
inant, people started gatheringg nnear at which point in time,
e, the
th
assailants
nts including two appellants fled
ed aaway. Complainant requested
ed the
th
police auth
authorities to take legal action agai
against the accused.
On the basis of the said comp
complaint and Medico legal report
eport of
o
all the
he inju
injured, a formal case vide FIR No. 319 dated 07.11.2025, was
wa
registered
tered against
a
the appellants, under
er Sec
Sections 115(2), 351(3), 333,, 3(5) of
BNS and Section
S
3(2)(va) and 3(1)(s) of Scheduled Caste and Schedule
heduled
Tribe (Prevention
(Prev
of Atrocities) Act,
ct, 19
1989, at Police Station Kalanau
alanaur,
District Rohtak.
Ro
GURBACHAN SINGH
2026.01.21 15:00
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRA-S-382
3825-2025
3.
-33-
Apprehending their arrest,
st, app
appellants moved an application
tion for
fo
grantt of anticipatory
an
bail before the lear
learned Additional Sessions Judge,
Judg
Rohtak,
ak, wh
which was dismissed vide order
der da
dated 28.11.2025. Aggrieved
d of the
th
same,, the present
p
appeal has been filed.
4.
Learned counsel, at thee outs
outset, submits that appellants
ts have
hav
been falsely implicated in the present case.
se. No specific allegations have
ve been
bee
levelled
led against
ag
them. Initially, the FIR w
was registered against them
m under
und
Sections
ons 11
115(2), 351(3), 333, 3(5) off BNS and later on, as an after thought,
though
offences
ces un
under Sections 3(2)(va) and 3(1)(
3(1)(s) of SC and ST Act weree added.
adde
Learned
ned counsel
co
further submits that
hat un
unexplained delay of one day in
lodging
ing the FIR, suggests that incident
nt has been given a different colour
lour by
b
the compla
omplainant party only with a view
ew to harass appellants and theirr family
fami
members,
bers, as
a also to extract illegal monetary
onetary benefit from them.
Continuing further learned
rned ccounsel submits that in fact the
th
complainan
lainant party had assaulted the appell
appellants but for reasons best known,
know
policee did n
not initiate action on their compl
complaint and rather false FIR has been
registered
tered against
a
them. Further, no specifi
specific injury has been attributed
d to the
th
appellants.
llants. Learned counsel next submits
mits th
that allegations levelled in the FIR,
FIR
when appreciated
appr
in the light of conne
connecting circumstances brought
ught on
o
record,
d, no offence u/s 3(2)(va) of SC/ST
C/ST Act is made out. Furtherr as per
p
learned
ed cou
counsel, though presence of appel
appellants, is not needed for custodi
ustodial
interrogatio
rogation, as nothing is to be recovere
covered at their instance, but they are
a
nonetheless
theless willing to join the investigatio
stigation as and when called forr by the
th
Investigatin
stigating Officer. Primarily on thes
these grounds, it was prayed
ed that
th
concession
ession of pre-arrest bail be granted
ed to tthe appellants.
GURBACHAN SINGH
2026.01.21 15:00
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRA-S-382
3825-2025
5.
-44-
Reply by way of an affidavit
idavit oof Mr. Gulab Singh, HPS Deputy
Depu
Superintend
rintendent of Police, District Rohtak
htak hhas been placed on record. In paras
para
12 and
nd 13 thereof, the role of the appella
appellants has been specified. As per
p
prosecution
cution, appellant No.1 abused comp
complainant and her daughter-in-la
law
Pinkii on account
ac
of non receipt of wages under MNREGA and thereafte
ereafter,
she in
n connivance
conn
with her sons Manjeet,
anjeet, Ankit and appellant No.2 again
aga
arrived
ed at the shop of complainant and
nd ga
gave slaps/fist blows to him (c) and
an
Sanjay
ay @ Sonu.
S
Further, at the instance
ance of appellant No.1, her son Manjeet
Manje
who was armed
a
with Screw Driver stabbe
stabbed Sanjay @ Sonu with the
he same
sam
and also
lso used
us derogatory words in the
he nam
name of ‘Caste’ against complaina
plainant
party.
Learned State counsel subm
submits that the bar created
d under
und
Section
on 18 of the SC/ST Act is attracted
cted in the present case. There being
eing no
n
illegality
ality or infirmity in the impugnedd orde
order dated 28.11.2025 passed
d by the
th
learned
ed Ad
Additional Sessions Judge, Rohta
Rohtak. Learned State counsel further
furth
submits
its tha
that custodial interrogation off the aappellants is needed to throw
ow light
lig
on thee intricacies
intr
involved in the case. D
Dismissal of the petition has
as been
bee
prayed
d for.
6.
I have heard the learned
ed co
counsel for the parties and
d gone
gon
through
gh the documents on record.
7.
Before expressing any opin
opinion on the merits of the
he rival
riv
contentions
ntions raised by learned counsel for the petitioner and learned
ed State
Sta
counsel,
sel, it would be appropriate to refer to certain relevant judgments
ents of
o
Hon'ble
ble Su
Supreme Court, wherein the factor
factors to be kept in mind while dealing
dealin
with an app
application for grant of anticipatory
ipatory bail, have been discussed.
GURBACHAN SINGH
2026.01.21 15:00
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRA-S-382
3825-2025
8.
-55-
Hon’ble the Supreme Cou
Court in “P. Chidambaram
m vs.
v
Directorate
orate of Enforcement, (2020) 133 SC
SCC 791), has observed as under:
der:“67. Ordinarily, arrest is a part of procedure off the
th
investigation to secure nott onl
only the presence of the accused
ed but
b
several other purposes. Power
ower under Section 438 Cr.P.C 1973
is an extraordinary powerr an
and the same has to be exercise
rcised
sparingly. The privilege off the pre-arrest bail should be grante
ranted
only in exceptional cases.
s. T
The judicial discretion conferre
erred
upon the court has to be prope
roperly exercised after application
tion of
mind as to the nature and gra
gravity of the accusation; possibili
ibility
of applicant fleeing justicee an
and other factors to decide wheth
hether
it is a fit case for grant
ant of anticipatory bail. Grant
nt of
anticipatory bail to somee ex
extent interferes in the sphere
ere of
investigation of an offence
nce and hence, the court must
st be
b
circumspect while exercisin
cising such power for grant
nt of
anticipatory bail. Anticipator
atory bail is not to be granted as a
matter of rule and it has to bbe granted only when the court
ourt is
convinced that exceptionall cir
circumstances exist to resort to that
th
extraordinary remedy.”
9.
Hon’ble the Supreme Court
ourt w
while deciding the case titled as
a
“Ms. X Vs. The State of Maharashtra and another” (2023 SCC Online
ne SC
S
279) held
eld as
a under:“11.1. We propose to takee a quick look at the consideration
ations
that ought to govern grantt of aanticipatory bail. There are a line
lin
of decisions of this court tha
that have underscored the fact
ct that
th
while deciding an application
tion for bail, the court ought to refra
efrain
GURBACHAN SINGH
2026.01.21 15:00
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRA-S-382
3825-2025
-66-
from undertaking a detailed
ed aanalysis of the evidence, the focus
focu
being on the prima facie issue
ssues including consideration off some
som
reasonable grounds that woul
would go to show if the accused
d has
ha
committed the offence or thos
those facts that would reflect on the
th
seriousness of the offence.. The self-imposed restraint on delvin
elving
deep into the analysis of the eevidence at that stage is for valid
val
reasons, namely, to prevent
nt an
any prejudice to the case set up by
b
the prosecution or the defence
ence likely to be taken by the accuse
cused
and to keep all aspects of tthe matter open till the trial
rial is
concluded.
12. In Prasanta Kumarr Sa
Sarkar's case (supra) (Prasan
asanta
Kumar Sarkar Vs. Ashish
h Ch
Chatterjee and another), a Divisio
ivision
Bench of this Court had highli
ighlighted the factors that oughtt to be
b
borne in mind while con
considering the anticipatory bail
ba
application and had stated tha
that :"9. We are of the opinionn tha
that the impugned order is clear
learly
unsustainable. It is trite that this Court does not, normall
mally,
interfere with an order passe
assed by the High Court granting
ing or
o
rejecting bail to the accused.
sed. However, it is equally incumbe
mbent
upon the High Court to exe
exercise its discretion judiciousl
iously,
cautiously and strictly in com
compliance with the basic principl
ciples
laid down in a plethora off dec
decisions of this Court on the point.
poin
It is well settled that, among
ng oother circumstances, the factors
tors to
be borne in mind while conside
nsidering an application for baill are:
are
(i) whether there is any prim
prima facie or reasonable ground
und to
believe that the accused had
ad co
committed the offence;
(ii) nature and gravity of the
he aaccusation;
(iii)severity of the punishment
ent in the event of conviction;
GURBACHAN SINGH
2026.01.21 15:00
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRA-S-382
3825-2025
-77-
(iv)danger of the accused abs
absconding or fleeing, if released
sed on
o
bail;
(v) character, behaviour, mea
means, position and standing of the
th
accused;
(vi) likelihood of the offence
ce be
being repeated;
(vii) reasonable apprehension
sion of the witnesses being influence
enced;
and
(viii) danger, of course, of just
justice being thwarted by grant of
bail.”
10.
In Nikita Jagganath Shetty
etty @ Nikita Vishwajeet Jadhav
av vs.
v
The State
tate of Maharashtra and another,
her, 2025 AIR SC 3375, the Hon’ble
Hon’b
Supreme
eme Court
C
held that “Anticipatory
ry ba
bail is an exceptional remedyy and
an
ought not tto be granted in a routine manne
nner.”
11.
Factual aspects of the case le
leading to the lodging of the FIR
FI
have alread
already been noted in para 2 off this order. While interpreting Section
Sectio
18 off the SC/ST
S
Act, Hon’ble Supreme
me Co
Court in Kiran vs. Rajkumar Jivraj
Jivr
Jain and
nd another,
a
2025(4) RCR (Criminal
inal) 18, held as under:“5.2 It is evident from thee ab
above provision of Section 18 that it
expressly excludes the applica
plicability of Section 438 of the Code
Cod
of Criminal Procedure, 1973
973 (“hereinafter referred to ass “the
“th
Cr.PC”). In another words,
ds, iin relation to any case involvin
olving
arrest of a person whoo iis facing the accusation about
abo
committing offence underr thi
this Act, protection of Section
n 438
Cr.P.C. would not be availabl
ilable. The Legislature has taken away
awa
the benefit of anticipatoryy ba
bail in respect of the arrest for
or the
th
offences alleged under thee SC
SC/ST Act. The bar in Section 18 of
the SC/ST Act would operate.”
ate.”
It would also be appropriate
riate to refer to Section 3(2)(va) of the
SC/ST
T Act, which reads as under:“commits any offence specif
pecified in the Schedule, against
inst a
person or property, knowing
ing tthat such person is a member
er of a
GURBACHAN SINGH
2026.01.21 15:00
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRA-S-382
3825-2025
-88-
Scheduled Caste or a Schedule
eduled Tribe or such property belong
elongs
to such member, shall be pun
punishable with such punishment
ent as
a
specified under the Indiann Pe
Penal Code (45 of 1860) forr such
suc
offences and shall also be liab
liable to fine;”
The offences with whichh the appellants have been charged
rged are
a
mentioned
ioned in the Schedule appended along with The Scheduled Castes
stes and
an
the Schedu
cheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atroci
Atrocities) Act, 1989.
12.
In view of discussion made hereinabove, the Court iss of the
th
opinion
ion that
tha prima facie offence under
der Se
Section 3(2)(va) of the Schedule
heduled
Castee and S
Scheduled Tribe (Prevention
on of Atrocities) Act, 1989 is made
ade out
o
from the b
bare reading of the FIR. Appella
ppellants have, thus, not been able to
make out a case of exceptional depravity/h
ravity/hardship in their favour, entitling
entitlin
them for the
th grant of this extra ordinary
ry reli
relief of pre-arrest bail.
13.
The appeal being devoid of me
merit, is hereby dismissed.
(AARADHNA SAWHNEY)
NEY)
JUDGE
09.01.2026
.2026
gbs
Whether Speaking/reasoned
Whether Reportable
GURBACHAN SINGH
2026.01.21 15:00
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
:
:
Yes/No
Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review