Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
fa3868.17
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY,
AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD
FIRST APPEAL NO. 3868 OF 2017
Mahadeo s/o Haribhau Shinde
age 52 yrs. Occ. Agril.
r/o Kedarwakadi, Tq. Mantha,
Dist. Jalna
… Appellant
Orig. Petitioner
VERSUS
1] The State of Maharashtra,
through Collector, Jalna,
2] The Special Land Acquisition Officer,
Minor Irrigation Works, Jalna,
3] The Executive Engineer,
Nimna Dudhana Project, Sailu,
Dist. Parbhani
… Respondents
WITH
FIRST APPEAL NO. 3869 OF 2017
Sakhubai w/o Tukaram Shinde,
age 52 years, occ. Agril.,
R/o Kedarwakdi, Tq.Mantha,
District Jalna.
VERSUS
1] The State of Maharashtra,
through Collector, Jalna,
District Jalna,
… Appellant
Orig. Petitioner
fa3868.17
2] The Special Land Acquisition Officer,
Minor Irrigation Works, Jalna,
3] The Executive Engineer,
Nimna Dudhana Project, Sailu,
Dist. Parbhani
… Respondents
FIRST APPEAL NO. 3285 OF 2017
Balasaheb s/o Tulshiram Late
(died L.Rs.)
1] Sarubai w/o Babasaheb Late,
age major, occ. Agril.,
r/o Kedarwakadi, Tq.Mantha,
Dist. Jalna,
2] Sudhakar s/o Babasaheb Late,
age major, occ. Agril.,
r/o as above,
3] Kamlakar s/o Babasaheb Late,
age major, occ. Agril.,
r/o as above
… Appellants
Orig. Petitioners
VERSUS
1] The State of Maharashtra,
through Collector, Jalna,
District Jalna,
2] The Special Land Acquisition Officer,
Minor Irrigation Works, Jalna,
3] The Executive Engineer,
Nimna Dudhana Project, Sailu,
Dist. Parbhani
… Respondents
fa3868.17
FIRST APPEAL NO. 3287 OF 2017
Sheshrao s/o Thavra Rathod,
age 42 years, occ. Agril.,
r/o Kedarwakadi, Tq.Mantha,
Dist. Jalna,
… Appellant
Orig. Petitioner
VERSUS
1] The State of Maharashtra,
through Collector, Jalna,
District Jalna,
2] The Special Land Acquisition Officer,
Minor Irrigation Works, Jalna,
3] The Executive Engineer,
Nimna Dudhana Project, Sailu,
Dist. Parbhani
… Respondents
FIRST APPEAL NO. 3288 OF 2017
Kundlik s/o Ashroba Kavhale,
age 43 years, occ. Agril.,
r/o Kedarwakadi, Tq.Mantha,
Dist. Jalna,
… Appellants
Orig. Petitioners
VERSUS
1] The State of Maharashtra,
through Collector, Jalna,
District Jalna,
2] The Special Land Acquisition Officer,
Minor Irrigation Works, Jalna,
3] The Executive Engineer,
Nimna Dudhana Project, Sailu,
Dist. Parbhani
… Respondents
fa3868.17
.....
Mr. Kailas B. Jadhav, advocate for the appellants
Mr. A.M.Phule, Mr. B.A.Shinde, Mr. S.S.Dande
A.G.P. for respondent nos. 1 and 2
Mr.S.G.Bhalerao, Mr. S.C.Arora, advocate for
respondent no.3
.....
CORAM : K.L.WADANE, J.
Reserved On
Pronouncement on
J U D G M E N T
Heard
appearing
on
Mr.
: 26.09.2017
: 05.10.2017
:
K.B.Jadhav,
behalf
of
the
learned
counsel
appellants
in
all
Appeals.
2.
have
First Appeal Nos. 3868 and 3869 of 2017
been
already
admitted
by
this
Court
on
9.8.2017 and are pending.
There
are
connected
3285, 3287 and 3288 of 2017.
Mr.
A.M.Phule,
Mr.
First
Appeal
Nos.
Admit.
B.A.Shinde
and
S.S.Dande learned A.G.P. for respondent nos. 1 and
2 and Mr. S.C.Bora, learned counsel for respondent
no.3 waive service of notice on admission in above
appeals.
3.
fa3868.17
With the consent of learned counsel for
the parties, the appeals are taken up for final
hearing.
The parties are referred by their original
status.
4.
The
present
appeals
are
filed
by
the
appellants for enhancement of compensation awarded
to them by the learned District Judge2, Jalna by
judgment
and
award,
passed
in
Land
Acquisition
Reference Nos. 41 of 2001 and No. 202 of 2002 on
22.8.2008, and in Land Acquisition Reference Nos.
23 of 2001, 338 of 2002 and No. 38 of 2001 on
25.7.2008.
Lands of the appellants in all the
appeals were acquired for Nimna Dudhana Project
from
the
village
Kedarwakadi,
Taluka
Mantha,
District Jalna.
5.
The appellants in First Appeal Nos. 3868
and 3869 of 2017 claimed that their lands acquired
for
the
irrigated
said
with
project
were
of
fruit
bearing
irrigated,
trees.
In
non
First
Appeal
Nos.
3285,
fa3868.17
and
of
2017,
the
appellants claimed that their lands acquired for
the
said
project
were
of
nonirrigated/Jirayat
lands. Therefore, the claim of the appellants is
to be determined as per their categorization of
the acquired lands.
6.
The evidence in support of claim of the
claimants/appellants
is
considered
in
Land
Acquisition Reference No. 181 of 2001 as the basis
for
deciding
other
Land
Acquisition
References.
Hence, the said evidence is adopted for decision
of these appeals.
7.
It was the case of the appellants before
the Special Land Acquisition Officer that Lands
owned
by
the
Kedarwakadi,
appellant
Taluka
situated
Mantha,
District
at
village
Jalna
are
irrigated, nonirrigated with fruit bearing trees
in First Appeal Nos. 3868 and 3869 of 2017 and
nonirrigated/Jirayat in First Appeal Nos. 3285,
3287 and 3288 of 2017.
As aforesaid, lands were
the
fa3868.17
acquired
by
respondents
for
Nimna
Dudhana
Project.
Notification under Section 4(1) of the
Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (for short, 'the Act')
was
published
in
the
Gazette on 13.5.1995.
Maharashtra
Government
Notice under Section 12(1)
of the Act was issued on or about 2.6.1999.
possession
of
the
acquired
lands
and
The
other
structures and trees were taken on different dates
as
per
payment
the
documents
produced
of
compensation
was
2.6.1999,
which
was
accepted
on
made
by
record
on
the
or
and
about
petitioner
under protest.
8.
The
Special Land Acquisition Officer has
awarded total compensation for the lands acquired
of
the
respective
appellants
at
the
rate
of
Rs.1,800/ per Are in First Appeal Nos. 3868 and
of
and
Rs.1,200/
per
Are
in
First
Appeal Nos. 3285, 3287 and 3288 of 2017 and for
Potkharab land at the rate of Rs.600/ per Are as
follows :
fa3868.17
In Land acquisition Reference No. 41 of
2001 for land 1 Hectare 06 Are from Gut No. 43/1C,
the
claimants
Special
and
Land
the
claimed
compensation
Acquisition
Special
Land
Officer
before
Rs.
Acquisition
the
2,07,112/
Officer
has
awarded total compensation of Rs. 1,10,888/.
In Land acquisition Reference No. 202 of
2000 for land 0.35 Hectare from Gut No. 43/2A, the
claimants claimed compensation before the Special
Land Acquisition Officer Rs. 1,10,567/ and the
Special Land Acquisition Officer has awarded total
compensation of Rs. 38,903/.
In Land acquisition Reference No. 23 of
2001 for land 0.82 Hectare from Gut No. 7/4, the
claimants claimed compensation before the Special
Land
Acquisition
Officer
Rs.
82,935/
and
the
Special Land Acquisition Officer has awarded total
compensation of Rs. 53,792/.
In Land acquisition Reference No. 338 of
2002 for land 1.24 Hectare from Gut No. 22/4B, the
claimants claimed compensation before the Special
Land Acquisition Officer Rs. 1,50,000/ and the
fa3868.17
Special Land Acquisition Officer has awarded total
compensation
of
Rs.
82,366/
including
for
Potkharab land 0.02 Hectare.
In Land acquisition Reference No. 38 of
2001 for land 4.43 Hectare from Gut No. 10/1, the
claimants claimed compensation before the Special
Land Acquisition Officer Rs. 4,07,667/ and the
Special Land Acquisition Officer has awarded total
compensation of Rs. 3,01,883/ including potkharab
land of 0.10 hectare.
9.
Being
aggrieved
by
compensation
awarded
by
Acquisition
Officer,
the
the
the
amount
Special
appellants
of
Land
preferred
Applications under Section 18 of the Act to the
Collector,
Jalna,
who
forwarded
it
for
adjudication to the District Judge, Jalna.
Before
Reference
Court,
the
appellants
claimed
compensation
at
rate
of
the
Rs.2,00,000/
per
hectare for nonirrigated land, Rs.3,00,000/ for
seasonally
irrigated
land
and
Rs.4,00,000/
for
perennially irrigated land including consequential
fa3868.17
benefits such as solatium, component and interest
as provided under the Act.
The claimants also
claimed additional compensation for trees and well
in their acquired lands.
10.
Common
before
the
Special
grounds
Reference
Land
considered
raised
by
Court
were
Acquisition
the
quality
advantageous situation.
of
the
that
Officer
land,
appellants
the
has
the
not
fertility
and
No legal inquiries were
made. The appellants claim that the Special Land
Acquisition Officer has not considered the income
of the lands. The respondents have totally ignored
the
factors
determining
required
the
awarding
of
the
just
be
compensation
Section 23 of the Act.
adopted
to
ready
considered
as
provided
while
under
The method compared and
recknor
compensation
to
is
unsuitable
the
for
petitioners.
The sale instances considered by the Special Land
Acquisition Officer did not reflect correct and
proper market value of the acquired lands.
fa3868.17
11.
Petitioners
have
also
submitted
village
Kedarwakadi
is
connected
to
that
Bageshwari
Sahakari Sakhar Karkhana. The lands acquired of
the petitioners were fertile lands.
Land
Acquisition
compensation
at
Officer
the
Rs.30,000/ per Are.
ought
rate
The Special
to
of
have
awarded
Rs.25,000/
to
Thus, the petitioners have
prayed to grant enhanced compensation for their
lands acquired.
12.
The
contending
State/respondents
that
the
resisted
enhancement
in
the
claim
compensation
claimed
by
the
petitioners
is
exorbitant
and
liable
to
be
rejected.
The
Special
Land
considered
the
Acquisition
Officer
has
properly
situation of lands under acquisition and assessed
the market price for determining the
compensation
by considering the other factors on the date of
Section
notification.
The
Special
Land
Acquisition Officer has classified the lands on
the basis of its quality of soil assessment and
other
factors.
The
Special
Land
Acquisition
Officer
has
instances.
also
fa3868.17
considered
the
genuine
sale
The award passed by the Special Land
Acquisition Officer is based upon sound and cogent
reasons.
The amount of compensation awarded is
adequate and hence, the respondents contended that
the
petitioners
are
not
entitled
for
enhanced
amount of compensation. Thus, the respondents have
prayed
that
the
Applications
deserve
to
be
in
the
dismissed.
13.
Reference
Court
has
observed
judgment that the petitioners have not produced
and
proved
the
valuation
report
in
their claim for fruit bearing trees.
support
of
No expert
opinion as mentioned in the petition as regards
additional compensation for well is produced on
record.
Hence, no separate amount of compensation
is granted by the Reference Court in respect of
well and trees.
14.
Considering
the
oral
and
documentary
evidence produced on record, the Reference Court
fa3868.17
held that the compensation awarded by the Special
Land
Acquisition
Officer
is
inadequate,
and
therefore, the petitioners in First Appeal Nos.
and 3869 of 2017 are entitled for enhanced
compensation at the rate of Rs.1,800/ per Are for
their
irrigated/nonirigated
lands
with
fruit
bearing trees and in First Appeal Nos. 3285, 3287
and 3288 of 2017 the petitioners are entitled for
compensation at the rate of Rs.1,200/ per Are for
their
nonirrigated/Jirayat
lands,
with
other
benefits considering the crop inspection column of
7/12 extracts.
Reference Court granted the amount
of compensation as below :
__________________________________________________
LAR No Gut No. Area
Ref. Court SLAO
Diff.
H. Are
awarded
awarded
41/01
43/1C
1.06
190800
110888
79912
202/00 43/2A
0.35
63000
38903
24097
23/01
0.82
98400
53792
44608
338/02 22/4B
1.24
148000
82336
67634
38/01
4.43
531600
301683
235767
7/4
10/1
15.
The
claimants
present
seeking
fa3868.17
appeals
are
filed
by
the
enhancement
in
the
amount
of
compensation awarded by the Reference Court.
16.
I
have
heard
the
arguments
of
both
the
learned counsel for the parties and perused the
oral and documentary evidence produced on record.
17.
Learned
counsel
contended
that
the
erroneous
and
is
for
award
the
under
passed
awarded
by
the
challenge
without
appreciation of evidence on record.
compensation
appellants
is
proper
The amount of
Reference
Court
is
very meagre, insufficient, inadequate looking to
the
quality
situation.
enhanced
of
The
the
lands,
fertility
Reference
Court
and
ought
compensation
properly
counsel
the
advantages
to
have
for
the
acquired lands.
18.
Learned
for
appellants
produced on record the judgment delivered by this
Court in First Appeal No. 2649 of 2017 along with
fa3868.17
group of appeals, decided on 31.8.2017 arising out
of the Land Acquisition References in respect of
the lands acquired from village Kedarwakdi, Taluka
Mantha, District Jalna for Nimna Dudhana Project.
19.
I
have
gone
through
the
said
judgment.
This Court held that appellants in those appeals
are
entitled
for
compensation
for
the
acquired
lands at the rate of Rs.1,500/ per Are for non
irrigated
lands,
Rs./2250/
irrigated
lands
and
perennially
irrigated
per
Are
Rs.3,000/
per
lands
along
for
semi
Are
for
with
the
statutory benefits and interest on the enhanced
amount of compensation as per provisions of the
Act in respect of the lands acquired from village
Kedarwakdi,
Taluka
Mantha,
Nimna Dudhana Project.
Appeal Nos. 3868
appellants
are
District
Jalna
for
As stated above in First
and 3869 of 2017 the lands of
irrigated/nonirigated
lands
with
fruit bearing trees and in First Appeal Nos. 3285,
3287 and 3288 of 2017 the lands of appellants are
nonirrigated/Jirayat
lands.
Therefore,
the
fa3868.17
appellants in First Appeal Nos. 3868
and 3869 of
2017 are entitled for enhanced compensation for
their acquired lands at the rate of Rs.2,250/ per
Are and in First Appeal Nos. 3285, 3287 and 3288
of 2017 the appellants are entitled for enhanced
compensation for their acquired lands at the rate
of Rs.1,500/ per Are.
20.
In the result, I pass following order.
(i)
Appeals are partly allowed.
(ii)
The
market
value
of
the
lands
involved in the present appeals shall be
determined
The
as
per
appellants
in
their
categorization.
First
Appeal
Nos.
and 3869 of 2017 are entitled for
enhanced
compensation
acquired
lands
at
for
the
their
rate
of
Rs.2,250/ per Are and in First Appeal
Nos. 3285, 3287 and 3288 of 2017 the
appellants
are
entitled
for
enhanced
compensation for their acquired lands
at the rate of Rs.1,500/ per Are.
(iii)
fa3868.17
The appellants are held entitled
to the statutory benefits and interest on
the
enhanced
amount
of
compensation
in
accordance with the provisions of the Act.
Interest under Section 34 of the Act shall
be
paid
from
the
date
of
Award
under
Section 11 of the Act even on the amount
of compensation awarded by the Reference
Court.
dbm
(K.L.WADANE, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review