Judgments
LegalFirms.in Judgments · legalfirms.in/judgments/babasaheb-tulshiram-late-died-lrs-sarubai-and-ors-vs-the-state-of-maharashtra-and-ors-20260418-2/ · Printed 19 Nov 2026
Civil

Babasaheb Tulshiram Late Died Lrs Sarubai and Ors vs The State of Maharashtra and Ors

Add to a compilation

Keep judgments in folders, mark the paragraphs you rely on, and print a compilation with an index. It comes with the Research and Advocate Pro judgment plans and with a campus licence. Sign in · See the plans

Court
Bombay High Court
Date
18 April 2026
Case No.
FA 3285/2017
Result
Partly allowed
Bench
Justice Shri Justice S. G. Chapalgaonkar
Cite this judgment
Citation
Link for your website or blog
Cite the court's own record or the law report in court filings.

The court's order

The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.

20. In the result, I pass following order. (i) Appeals are partly allowed. (ii) The market value of the lands involved in the present appeals shall be determined The as per appellants in their categorization. First Appeal Nos. and 3869 of 2017 are entitled for enhanced compensation acquired lands at for the their rate of Rs.2,250/­ per Are and in First Appeal Nos. 3285, 3287 and 3288 of 2017 the appellants are entitled for enhanced compensation for their acquired lands at the rate of Rs.1,500/­ per Are. (iii) fa3868.17 The appellants are held entitled to the statutory benefits and interest on the enhanced amount of compensation in accordance with the provisions of the Act. Interest under Section 34 of the Act shall be paid from the date of Award under Section 11 of the Act even on the amount of compensation awarded by the Reference Court. dbm (K.L.WADANE, J.)

In this case

Other papers of FA 3285/2017 on LegalFirms.in, oldest first.

Full Judgment Text

Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs, CC BY 4.0). The court's own copy is the authoritative text.

fa3868.17 IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY, AURANGABAD BENCH, AURANGABAD FIRST APPEAL NO. 3868 OF 2017 Mahadeo s/o Haribhau Shinde age 52 yrs. Occ. Agril. r/o Kedarwakadi, Tq. Mantha, Dist. Jalna … Appellant Orig. Petitioner VERSUS 1] The State of Maharashtra, through Collector, Jalna, 2] The Special Land Acquisition Officer, Minor Irrigation Works, Jalna, 3] The Executive Engineer, Nimna Dudhana Project, Sailu, Dist. Parbhani … Respondents WITH FIRST APPEAL NO. 3869 OF 2017 Sakhubai w/o Tukaram Shinde, age 52 years, occ. Agril., R/o Kedarwakdi, Tq.Mantha, District Jalna. VERSUS 1] The State of Maharashtra, through Collector, Jalna, District Jalna, … Appellant Orig. Petitioner fa3868.17 2] The Special Land Acquisition Officer, Minor Irrigation Works, Jalna, 3] The Executive Engineer, Nimna Dudhana Project, Sailu, Dist. Parbhani … Respondents FIRST APPEAL NO. 3285 OF 2017 Balasaheb s/o Tulshiram Late (died L.Rs.) 1] Sarubai w/o Babasaheb Late, age major, occ. Agril., r/o Kedarwakadi, Tq.Mantha, Dist. Jalna, 2] Sudhakar s/o Babasaheb Late, age major, occ. Agril., r/o as above, 3] Kamlakar s/o Babasaheb Late, age major, occ. Agril., r/o as above … Appellants Orig. Petitioners VERSUS 1] The State of Maharashtra, through Collector, Jalna, District Jalna, 2] The Special Land Acquisition Officer, Minor Irrigation Works, Jalna, 3] The Executive Engineer, Nimna Dudhana Project, Sailu, Dist. Parbhani … Respondents fa3868.17 FIRST APPEAL NO. 3287 OF 2017 Sheshrao s/o Thavra Rathod, age 42 years, occ. Agril., r/o Kedarwakadi, Tq.Mantha, Dist. Jalna, … Appellant Orig. Petitioner VERSUS 1] The State of Maharashtra, through Collector, Jalna, District Jalna, 2] The Special Land Acquisition Officer, Minor Irrigation Works, Jalna, 3] The Executive Engineer, Nimna Dudhana Project, Sailu, Dist. Parbhani … Respondents FIRST APPEAL NO. 3288 OF 2017 Kundlik s/o Ashroba Kavhale, age 43 years, occ. Agril., r/o Kedarwakadi, Tq.Mantha, Dist. Jalna, … Appellants Orig. Petitioners VERSUS 1] The State of Maharashtra, through Collector, Jalna, District Jalna, 2] The Special Land Acquisition Officer, Minor Irrigation Works, Jalna, 3] The Executive Engineer, Nimna Dudhana Project, Sailu, Dist. Parbhani … Respondents fa3868.17 ..... Mr. Kailas B. Jadhav, advocate for the appellants Mr. A.M.Phule, Mr. B.A.Shinde, Mr. S.S.Dande A.G.P. for respondent nos. 1 and 2 Mr.S.G.Bhalerao, Mr. S.C.Arora, advocate for respondent no.3 ..... CORAM : K.L.WADANE, J. Reserved On Pronouncement on J U D G M E N T Heard appearing on Mr. : 26.09.2017 : 05.10.2017 : K.B.Jadhav, behalf of the learned counsel appellants in all Appeals. 2. have First Appeal Nos. 3868 and 3869 of 2017 been already admitted by this Court on 9.8.2017 and are pending. There are connected 3285, 3287 and 3288 of 2017. Mr. A.M.Phule, Mr. First Appeal Nos. Admit. B.A.Shinde and S.S.Dande learned A.G.P. for respondent nos. 1 and 2 and Mr. S.C.Bora, learned counsel for respondent no.3 waive service of notice on admission in above appeals. 3. fa3868.17 With the consent of learned counsel for the parties, the appeals are taken up for final hearing. The parties are referred by their original status. 4. The present appeals are filed by the appellants for enhancement of compensation awarded to them by the learned District Judge­2, Jalna by judgment and award, passed in Land Acquisition Reference Nos. 41 of 2001 and No. 202 of 2002 on 22.8.2008, and in Land Acquisition Reference Nos. 23 of 2001, 338 of 2002 and No. 38 of 2001 on 25.7.2008. Lands of the appellants in all the appeals were acquired for Nimna Dudhana Project from the village Kedarwakadi, Taluka Mantha, District Jalna. 5. The appellants in First Appeal Nos. 3868 and 3869 of 2017 claimed that their lands acquired for the irrigated said with project were of fruit bearing irrigated, trees. In non­ First Appeal Nos. 3285, fa3868.17 and of 2017, the appellants claimed that their lands acquired for the said project were of non­irrigated/Jirayat lands. Therefore, the claim of the appellants is to be determined as per their categorization of the acquired lands. 6. The evidence in support of claim of the claimants/appellants is considered in Land Acquisition Reference No. 181 of 2001 as the basis for deciding other Land Acquisition References. Hence, the said evidence is adopted for decision of these appeals. 7. It was the case of the appellants before the Special Land Acquisition Officer that Lands owned by the Kedarwakadi, appellant Taluka situated Mantha, District at village Jalna are irrigated, non­irrigated with fruit bearing trees in First Appeal Nos. 3868 and 3869 of 2017 and non­irrigated/Jirayat in First Appeal Nos. 3285, 3287 and 3288 of 2017. As aforesaid, lands were the fa3868.17 acquired by respondents for Nimna Dudhana Project. Notification under Section 4(1) of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (for short, 'the Act') was published in the Gazette on 13.5.1995. Maharashtra Government Notice under Section 12(1) of the Act was issued on or about 2.6.1999. possession of the acquired lands and The other structures and trees were taken on different dates as per payment the documents produced of compensation was 2.6.1999, which was accepted on made by record on the or and about petitioner under protest. 8. The Special Land Acquisition Officer has awarded total compensation for the lands acquired of the respective appellants at the rate of Rs.1,800/­ per Are in First Appeal Nos. 3868 and of and Rs.1,200/­ per Are in First Appeal Nos. 3285, 3287 and 3288 of 2017 and for Potkharab land at the rate of Rs.600/­ per Are as follows : ­ fa3868.17 In Land acquisition Reference No. 41 of 2001 for land 1 Hectare 06 Are from Gut No. 43/1C, the claimants Special and Land the claimed compensation Acquisition Special Land Officer before Rs. Acquisition the 2,07,112/­ Officer has awarded total compensation of Rs. 1,10,888/­. In Land acquisition Reference No. 202 of 2000 for land 0.35 Hectare from Gut No. 43/2A, the claimants claimed compensation before the Special Land Acquisition Officer Rs. 1,10,567/­ and the Special Land Acquisition Officer has awarded total compensation of Rs. 38,903/­. In Land acquisition Reference No. 23 of 2001 for land 0.82 Hectare from Gut No. 7/4, the claimants claimed compensation before the Special Land Acquisition Officer Rs. 82,935/­ and the Special Land Acquisition Officer has awarded total compensation of Rs. 53,792/­. In Land acquisition Reference No. 338 of 2002 for land 1.24 Hectare from Gut No. 22/4B, the claimants claimed compensation before the Special Land Acquisition Officer Rs. 1,50,000/­ and the fa3868.17 Special Land Acquisition Officer has awarded total compensation of Rs. 82,366/­ including for Potkharab land 0.02 Hectare. In Land acquisition Reference No. 38 of 2001 for land 4.43 Hectare from Gut No. 10/1, the claimants claimed compensation before the Special Land Acquisition Officer Rs. 4,07,667/­ and the Special Land Acquisition Officer has awarded total compensation of Rs. 3,01,883/­ including potkharab land of 0.10 hectare. 9. Being aggrieved by compensation awarded by Acquisition Officer, the the the amount Special appellants of Land preferred Applications under Section 18 of the Act to the Collector, Jalna, who forwarded it for adjudication to the District Judge, Jalna. Before Reference Court, the appellants claimed compensation at rate of the Rs.2,00,000/­ per hectare for non­irrigated land, Rs.3,00,000/­ for seasonally irrigated land and Rs.4,00,000/­ for perennially irrigated land including consequential fa3868.17 benefits such as solatium, component and interest as provided under the Act. The claimants also claimed additional compensation for trees and well in their acquired lands. 10. Common before the Special grounds Reference Land considered raised by Court were Acquisition the quality advantageous situation. of the that Officer land, appellants the has the not fertility and No legal inquiries were made. The appellants claim that the Special Land Acquisition Officer has not considered the income of the lands. The respondents have totally ignored the factors determining required the awarding of the just be compensation Section 23 of the Act. adopted to ready considered as provided while under The method compared and recknor compensation to is unsuitable the for petitioners. The sale instances considered by the Special Land Acquisition Officer did not reflect correct and proper market value of the acquired lands. fa3868.17 11. Petitioners have also submitted village Kedarwakadi is connected to that Bageshwari Sahakari Sakhar Karkhana. The lands acquired of the petitioners were fertile lands. Land Acquisition compensation at Officer the Rs.30,000/­ per Are. ought rate The Special to of have awarded Rs.25,000/­ to Thus, the petitioners have prayed to grant enhanced compensation for their lands acquired. 12. The contending State/respondents that the resisted enhancement in the claim compensation claimed by the petitioners is exorbitant and liable to be rejected. The Special Land considered the Acquisition Officer has properly situation of lands under acquisition and assessed the market price for determining the compensation by considering the other factors on the date of Section notification. The Special Land Acquisition Officer has classified the lands on the basis of its quality of soil assessment and other factors. The Special Land Acquisition Officer has instances. also fa3868.17 considered the genuine sale The award passed by the Special Land Acquisition Officer is based upon sound and cogent reasons. The amount of compensation awarded is adequate and hence, the respondents contended that the petitioners are not entitled for enhanced amount of compensation. Thus, the respondents have prayed that the Applications deserve to be in the dismissed. 13. Reference Court has observed judgment that the petitioners have not produced and proved the valuation report in their claim for fruit bearing trees. support of No expert opinion as mentioned in the petition as regards additional compensation for well is produced on record. Hence, no separate amount of compensation is granted by the Reference Court in respect of well and trees. 14. Considering the oral and documentary evidence produced on record, the Reference Court fa3868.17 held that the compensation awarded by the Special Land Acquisition Officer is inadequate, and therefore, the petitioners in First Appeal Nos. and 3869 of 2017 are entitled for enhanced compensation at the rate of Rs.1,800/­ per Are for their irrigated/non­irigated lands with fruit bearing trees and in First Appeal Nos. 3285, 3287 and 3288 of 2017 the petitioners are entitled for compensation at the rate of Rs.1,200/­ per Are for their non­irrigated/Jirayat lands, with other benefits considering the crop inspection column of 7/12 extracts. Reference Court granted the amount of compensation as below : ­ __________________________________________________ LAR No Gut No. Area Ref. Court SLAO Diff. H. Are awarded awarded 41/01 43/1C 1.06 190800 110888 79912 202/00 43/2A 0.35 63000 38903 24097 23/01 0.82 98400 53792 44608 338/02 22/4B 1.24 148000 82336 67634 38/01 4.43 531600 301683 235767 7/4 10/1 15. The claimants present seeking fa3868.17 appeals are filed by the enhancement in the amount of compensation awarded by the Reference Court. 16. I have heard the arguments of both the learned counsel for the parties and perused the oral and documentary evidence produced on record. 17. Learned counsel contended that the erroneous and is for award the under passed awarded by the challenge without appreciation of evidence on record. compensation appellants is proper The amount of Reference Court is very meagre, insufficient, inadequate looking to the quality situation. enhanced of The the lands, fertility Reference Court and ought compensation properly counsel the advantages to have for the acquired lands. 18. Learned for appellants produced on record the judgment delivered by this Court in First Appeal No. 2649 of 2017 along with fa3868.17 group of appeals, decided on 31.8.2017 arising out of the Land Acquisition References in respect of the lands acquired from village Kedarwakdi, Taluka Mantha, District Jalna for Nimna Dudhana Project. 19. I have gone through the said judgment. This Court held that appellants in those appeals are entitled for compensation for the acquired lands at the rate of Rs.1,500/­ per Are for non­ irrigated lands, Rs./2250/­ irrigated lands and perennially irrigated per Are Rs.3,000/­ per lands along for semi­ Are for with the statutory benefits and interest on the enhanced amount of compensation as per provisions of the Act in respect of the lands acquired from village Kedarwakdi, Taluka Mantha, Nimna Dudhana Project. Appeal Nos. 3868 appellants are District Jalna for As stated above in First and 3869 of 2017 the lands of irrigated/non­irigated lands with fruit bearing trees and in First Appeal Nos. 3285, 3287 and 3288 of 2017 the lands of appellants are non­irrigated/Jirayat lands. Therefore, the fa3868.17 appellants in First Appeal Nos. 3868 and 3869 of 2017 are entitled for enhanced compensation for their acquired lands at the rate of Rs.2,250/­ per Are and in First Appeal Nos. 3285, 3287 and 3288 of 2017 the appellants are entitled for enhanced compensation for their acquired lands at the rate of Rs.1,500/­ per Are. 20. In the result, I pass following order. (i) Appeals are partly allowed. (ii) The market value of the lands involved in the present appeals shall be determined The as per appellants in their categorization. First Appeal Nos. and 3869 of 2017 are entitled for enhanced compensation acquired lands at for the their rate of Rs.2,250/­ per Are and in First Appeal Nos. 3285, 3287 and 3288 of 2017 the appellants are entitled for enhanced compensation for their acquired lands at the rate of Rs.1,500/­ per Are. (iii) fa3868.17 The appellants are held entitled to the statutory benefits and interest on the enhanced amount of compensation in accordance with the provisions of the Act. Interest under Section 34 of the Act shall be paid from the date of Award under Section 11 of the Act even on the amount of compensation awarded by the Reference Court. dbm (K.L.WADANE, J.)

This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.

Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong? Request a review

All Bombay HC judgments →
LegalFirms.in Directory
Find an advocate for this matter
Dealing with a similar case? Find an advocate who handles this kind of matter on LegalFirms.in.
Find an advocate →