Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Non-reportable
IN THE COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP (C) No.264 of 2022
Z. Michael Zimik aged about 60 years, S/o (L) Z. Philip Siluiwung a permanent
resident of Saharkazeng, Luiyainaotang, Ukhrul presently residing at
Nagaramn, Block-C, Imphal East.
..........Petitioner
-Versus1. The State of Manipur represented by the Commissioner, CAF & PD,
Government of Manipur, Manipur Secretariat, Babupara, P.O. & P.S. Imphal,
District: Imphal West, Manipur-795001.
2. The Director, CAF & PD, Manipur, Sangaipurou, Imphal West, Manipur.
3. Ms. Premila, aged about 62 years, D/o (L) Chinaongai of Talui Village,
Ukhrul District, Manipur.
4. Smt. Athokpam Nibedita Devi aged about 42 years W/o W. Kenedy Singh a
resident of Thoubal Mayai Leikai, P.O. & P.S. Thoubal, District: Thoubal,
Manipur-795138.
5. Shri N. Banikumar Singh aged about 60 years S/o (L) N. Nabakishwor Singh
a resident of Keisampat Leimajam Leikai, Imphal West, Manipur.
.....Respondents
.
WP(C) NOS. 264 OF 2022 & 686 OF 2022
6. Shri K. Rabei Singh aged about 59 years S/o (L) K. Kullachand Singh of Thiyam
Leishangkhong Yumnam Huidrom, Imphal West, Manipur.
7. Smt. R.K. Sumitra Devi, aged about 60 years D/o R.K. Khellendro Singh of
Singjamei Mathak Chongtham Leikai, Imphal West, Manipur.
8. Shri Yumnam Lokendro Singh aged about 52 years S/o Y. Babu Singh of
Samurou Bazar, Imphal West, Manipur.
....Proforma Respondents
WP (C) No. 686 of 2022
With
MC(WP(C) No. 402 of 2023
Miss Rita Nongmaithem, aged about 52 years, d/o., N. Biramani Singh a resident
of Keishamthong Hodam Leirak, P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal West District,
Manipur, PIN-795001.
... Petitioner
-Versus-
1. The State of Manipur represented by the Commissioner, CAF & PD,
Governmnent of Manipur, Manipur Secretariat, Babupara, P.O. & P.S. Imphal,
Imphal West District, Manipur, PIN-795001.
2.
Selection
Committee
represented
by
its
Convener.
The
Commissioner/Secretary, CAF & PD, Governrnent of Manipur, Manipur
Secretariat, Babupara, P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur, PIN795001.
WP(C) NOS. 264 OF 2022 & 686 OF 2022
3. The Director, CAF & PD, Manipur, Sangaiprou, P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal
West District, Manipur, PIN-795001.
4. Ms. Premila, aged about 62 years, d/o. (L) Chinaongai of Talui Village, P.O.
& P.S. Somdal Ukhrul District, Manipur, Pin-795142;
5. Smt.. Athokpam Nibedita Devi,. aged about 42 years, w/o Waikhom Kennedy
Singh of Thoubal Mayai Leirak, P.O., P.S. and District: Thoubal, Manipur, PIN795138;
6. N. Banikumar- Singh, aged abvut 60 years, s/o. (L) N. Nabakishwor Singh, of
Keishampat Leimajam Leikai, P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur,
PIN-795001;
7. K. Rabei Singh, aged about 59 years, S/o. (L) K. Kullachand Singh,, of Thiyam
Leishangkhong Yumnam Huidrom, P.O. & P.S. Wangoi, Imphal West District,
Manipur, PIN-795132;
8. Smt. R.K. Sumitra Devi, aged about 60 years, d/o R. K. Khellendro Singh of
Singjamei Mathak Chongtham Leikai, P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal West District,
Manipur, PIN-795001;
9. Yumnam Lokendro Singh, aged about 52 years, s/o. Y. Babu Singh, of
Samurou Bazar, P.0. Samurou, P.S. Wangoi, Imphal West District, Manipur, PIN795009;
10. Integrated Rural Developrment and Educational Organisation (IRDEO), a
registered Society having Regd. No. 137 of 1988, represented by its Secretary,
namely, Kh. Kumar Singh, Wangbai, P.O., P.S. and Distrit: Thoubal, Manipur,
PIN-795138.
... Respondents.
WP(C) NOS. 264 OF 2022 & 686 OF 2022
BEFORE
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE A. GUNESHWAR SHARMA
For the Petitioners
:
Mr. Debdutta, Advocate in WP(C) No. 264 of
Mr. N. Mahendra, Advocate in WP(C) No. 868 of
For the Respondents
:
Mr. Th. Sukumar, G.A for State
Mr. Kh. Tarunkumar, Sr. Adv. with Ms. K. Mercy,
Advocate for R-5&10 in WP(C) No. 868 of 2022
& R-3&4 in WP(C) No. 264 of 2022; Mr. Sh.
Athoi, Advocate for R-6 in WP(C) No. 868 of
Date of Hearing
:
18-10-2024
Date of Order
:
20-12-2024
JUDGEMENT& ORDER [CAV]
[1] The instant writ petitions are filed praying for setting aside the impugned
order dated 21-3-2022 passed by the Department CAF & PD, Govt. of Manipur
for appointment of respondents as Members of the Consumer Disputes
Redressal Commissions (District & State) as violative of the provisions of the
Consumer Protection Act, 2019 and Rules of 2020. Since these two writ petitions
concern with the same notification and order, they are being considered and
disposed of by this common order.
[2] Brief facts in WP(C) No. 264 of 2022 are that the present petitioner
joined as Asst. Public Prosecutor cum Asst. Govt. Advocate (District) under the
Government of Manipur in the year 2008 on contract basis. Thereafter his
service was regularized by the authority in the year 2016. The petitioner after
WP(C) NOS. 264 OF 2022 & 686 OF 2022
completing his term of appointment as APP cum AGA (District) got retired from
service on attaining superannuation in the year 2021.
[3] Government of Manipur through department CAF & PD issued a
Notification dated 8-11-2021 inviting applications from the intending candidates
for appointment of President and Members of Consumer Disputes Redressal
Commission (State Commission) and District Consumer Disputes Redressal
Commission (District Commission) of Manipur respectively. The aforesaid
Notification was issued in terms of the relevant provisions of the Consumer
Protection Act, 2019 (hereinafter referred to as the Act in short) enforced wef
20-7-2020. The eligibility and qualification for appointment to the post of
President and Members of the State Commission are enumerated in Section 43
of the Act and Rule No. 3 of the Consumer Protection (Qualification for
appointment, method of recruitment, procedure of appointment, term of office,
resignation and removal of the President and Member of the State Commission
and District Commission) Rules, 2020 (hereinafter referred to as the Rules in
short).
[4] The relevant portion of the above mentioned Rules are reproduced below
for kind perusal:
"3. Qualifications for appointment of President and members of
the State Commission--- (1) A person shall not be qualified for
appointment as President, unless he is, or has been, a Judge of the High
Court:
(2) A person shall not be qualified for appointment as a member unless
he is of not less than forty years of age and possesses—
(a) an experience of at least ten years as presiding officer of a
district court or of any tribunal at equivalent level or combined
service as such in the district court and tribunal;
(b) a bachelor's degree from a recognized university and is a person
of ability, integrity and standing, and has special knowledge and
professional experience of not less than twenty years in consumer
affairs, law, public affairs, administration, economics, Commerce,
WP(C) NOS. 264 OF 2022 & 686 OF 2022
industry, finance, management, engineering, technology, public
health or medicine:
(3) At least one member or the President of the State Commission shall
be a Woman.
[5] It is stated that from the reading of the above provisions of Rules and
wordings incorporated, the number of post earmarked for candidate in respect
of the President or Member in the State Commission is 1(one). This condition is
made absolutely clear in both Rules as well as in the notice/advertisement dated
8-11-202 1 for appointment of President and Members in the State Commission.
In the said Notification so far as the female member is concerned, only one post
of member has been prescribed in the Notification, however, while issuing the
appointment orders altogether 2 (two) female candidates have been appointed
as Members of the State Commission which is not in conformity with the Scheme
of the appointment of deserving candidates for the posts of Members in the
State Commission.
[6] The petitioner having fulfilled the requisite qualifications for the
candidature of the same and also having high expectation of being appointed to
the post of Member, has applied by submitting his qualification and eligibility
certificates formally to the authority. The personal interview and viva voce test
was conducted on 30-12-2021 by a selection committee before which the
humble petitioner also appeared. The result of the aforesaid interview conducted
by the duly constituted Selection Committee was notified on 21-3-2022 and
appointments were accorded to incumbents (respondent Nos. 3,4, 5, 6, 7 and
8) in the manner as under:
(A) Members of State Commission:1. Smt. M. Premila
2. Smt. A. Nibedita Devi
3. Shri N. Banikumar Singh
(B) Presidents of District Commissions:-
WP(C) NOS. 264 OF 2022 & 686 OF 2022
1. Shri K. Rabei Singh
2. Smt. R.K. Sunitra Devi
3. Shri Y. Lokendro Singh
[7] To the utter shock and surprise of the humble petitioner, two females
were appointed as Members of the State Commission against the mandate of
the Act and also not in conformity with the condition prescribed in the
advertisement, wherein it has been clearly and categorically mentioned for 1
(one) post of Member (Female).
[8] It is submitted that the established principle of law that in the public
employment a standard yardstick of selection procedure is always expected to
be followed in a fair manner which is free from any arbitrariness and favouritism.
In the instant case, the procedure adopted by the Selection Committee appears
to be quite irregular and hence subjected to the deprivation of the legitimate
right of the humble petitioner to be considered in terms of the quota (vacancy)
earmarked for the male candidate. The 1 (one) number of post of Member of
State Commission meant for male candidate have been usurped by appointing
two numbers of female candidates by exceeding the advertised number of post
in the Notice. The petitioner came to know about the said appointment order
dated 21-3-2022 and soon thereafter he submitted a representation dated 283-2022 to the Hon'ble Chief Minister of Manipur with copies being circulated to
the competent authorities for redressing the irregularity and also to ventilate his
grievance. However, the same is still pending.
[9] The recommendation of the Selection Committee is tainted with non
action of mind and suffers from unreasonableness so far as the selection of
female candidate and male candidates are concerned. Being aggrieved by the
inaction, illegality, arbitrariness and unjustifiable actions on the part of the
respondents, the present petition is being filed bonafide before the Hon'ble High
Court for setting aside the impugned order dated 21-3-2022 in respect of
appointment of the Members of the State Commission as illegal and void abinitio and to direct the respondents to hold the fresh selection process.
WP(C) NOS. 264 OF 2022 & 686 OF 2022
[10] The State respondents filed counter affidavit stating that the mistake in
the Notification dated 08-11-2021 was later on rectified in terms of Rule 3(3) of
the Rules of 2020 by issuing a Corrigendum dated 11-11-2021, whereby the
number of vacancies of the Members of the State Commission be read as
“Members- 3 (three) vacancies and at least one Member or the President shall
be a woman” in place of “Member (Male)- 2(two) and Member Female- 1 (one)”
as occurred at Sl. No. 2 & 3 of Notification dated 08-11-2021. It is pointed out
that the only ground taken in the writ petition is appointing excess number of
female Members as advertised in the Notification dated 08-11-2021. It is stated
that after the issuance of the Corrigendum dated 11-11-2021, the cause of the
writ petition does not exist from the very inception and the petitioner has
concealed this vital document from this Court. It is submitted that appointment
of more than one female Member is not barred by Rule. The petitioner has also
failed to challenge the Corrigendum dated 11-11-2021. It is urged that the writ
petition be dismissed being devoid of merit and for concealment of vital
document.
[11]
Respondent Nos. 3, 4 & 5 have also adopted the stand of the State
respondents to the point that the initial defect has already been rectified and
the Rules permit appointment of more than one female Member in the State
Commission.
[12]
The petitioner did not file any rejoinder affidavit specifically to
counter the issuance of Corrigendum dated 11-11-2021.
[13]
Mr. Th. Sukumar, learned GA as well Mr. Kh. Tarunkumar, learned
senior counsel for the respondent Nos. 3&4 urge that with the issuance the
Corrigendum dated 11-11-2021, the cause in the writ petition does not exist
from the very beginning. The petitioner has also concealed this vital fact from
this Court with malafide intention of harassing the respondents. It is also
highlighted that the petitioner despite having a clear knowledge of the
corrigendum, he appeared before the Selection Board without any protest and
only as and when he was not selected, he filed the aforesaid writ petition by
challenging the legality of the appointment order dated 21-03-2022. Such action
of the petitioner is barred by the principle of estoppel as well as doctrine of
approbate and reprobate. Reliance is placed on the decision of the Hon'ble
WP(C) NOS. 264 OF 2022 & 686 OF 2022
Supreme Court of India in the case of Anupal Singh and Ors. Versus the
State of Uttar Pradesh & Ors. reported in (2020) 2 SCC 173 where it has
been held that a person having consciously participated in the interview cannot
turn around and challenge the selection process (relevant para 55). Similar view
was taken by the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Madan Lal Versus State
of J&K reported in (1995) 3 SCC 486 (relevant para 9).
[14]
It is submitted that as the petitioner has failed at the interview after
participating without any protest, he cannot turn around and challenge the
appointment order of the private respondents dated 21-03-2022, Moreover, the
appointment of the private respondents as Member (Female) is also permissible
in view of the aforesaid Rule 3 sub rule 3 of the Consumer Protection
(Qualification for Appointment, Method of Recruitment, Procedure of
Appointment, Term of Office, Resignation and Removal of the
President and Members of the State Commission and District
Commission) Rules, 2020. The writ petition filed by the petitioner is not
maintainable as the same is barred by the principles of estoppel and devoid of
merit and liable to be dismissed.
[15]
Brief facts in WP(C) No. 686 of 2022 are that Respondent No.1
issued a Govt. Notice dated 08-11-2021 inviting applications from the intending
candidates for appointment of President and Members of Consumer Disputes
Redressal Commission (State Commission) and District Consumer Disputes
Redressal Commission (District Commission) of Manipur. The petitioner,
respondents no. 4 to 9, among other candidates, applied for the notified vacant
posts. Petitioner applied for the post of President of District Consumer Disputes
Redressal Commission (District Commission) in response to the said Govt. Notice
dated 08-11-2021 by submitting application dated 17-11-2021 with necessary
enclosures. The respondent nos. 7 to 9 applied for the post of Members of
Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (State Commission) and as well as
for the posts of President of District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission
(District Commission) of Manipur.
[16]
Hon'ble Mr. Justice A. Bimol Singh, Judge High Court of Manipur
was nominated in relation to the constitution of Selection Committee for
appointment of President and Members of the State Commission and District
WP(C) NOS. 264 OF 2022 & 686 OF 2022
Commission under Rule 6(1) of the Consumer Protection Rules, 2020 vide Letter
dated, the 28 October 2021 of Registrar General, High Court of Manipur, Imphal.
The Selection Committee Meeting/interview was held on 28.12.2021 at Judges'
Lounge, High Court of Manipur as per schedule and the petitioner, respondents
nos. 4 to 9, among other candidates, took part in the said interview. On the
recommendation of the Selection Committee Meeting held on 28.12.2021 the
Govt. of Manipur issued the appointment Orders By The Governor: Manipur No.
CDRC-101/3/2021- CAFANDPD-CAF&PD(Pt-I) Imphal, the 21st March, 2022
thereby appointing the respondent Nos. 4 to 9 for the respective posts
mentioned therein. The respondent Nos. 4 to 9 have joined and started
functioning in their respective posts.
[17] It is stated that a person shall not be qualified for appointment as member
of State Commission unless he is not less than forty years of age and possesses
- (a).....(b) a bachelor's degree from a recognized university and is a person of
ability, integrity and standing, and has special knowledge and professional
experience of not less than twenty years in consumer affairs, law, public affairs,
administration, economics, commerce, industry, finance, management,
engineering, technology, public health or medicine vide Rule 3(2)(b) of the
Consumer Protection (Qualification for appointment, Method of Recruitment,
Procedure of Appointment, Terms of Office, Resignation and Removal of the
President and Members of the State Commission and District Commission) Rules,
2020. Prior to framing of Consumer Protection (Qualification for appointment,
Method of Recruitment, Procedure of Appointment, Terms of Office, Resignation
and Removal of the President and Members of the State Commission and District
Commission) Rules, 2020, S.16(1)(b) of the Consumer Protection Act, 1986
provided for the Composition of the State Commission, wherein it is provided
that member of the State Commission shall have the following qualifications,
namely: (i)......(ii) possess a bachelor's degree from a recognized university; (iii)
be persons of ability, integrity and standing, and have adequate knowledge and
experience of at least ten years in dealing with problems relating to economics,
law, commerce, accountancy, industry, public affairs or administration: Provided
that not more than fifty per cent of the members shall be from amongst persons
having a judicial background.
WP(C) NOS. 264 OF 2022 & 686 OF 2022
[18]
It is pertinent to mention that the respondent no.5 was appointed
as Member of Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (State Commission)
vide appointment Orders By The Governor: Manipur No. 5/5/2015-CAF&PD/112
Imphal, the 26th August, 2015. The term of appointment of the respondent no.5
as Member of Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (State Commission)
was extended for Six months w.e.f. 26.11.2020 or till regular appointment vide
appointment Orders By The Governor: Manipur No. 1/3/2020-CAF&PD Imphal,
the 12th November, 2020. The respondent no.5 was only of the age of 40/42
years and how she was able to possess special knowledge and professional
experience of not less than twenty years in consumer affairs, law, public affairs,
administration, economics, commerce, industry, finance, management,
engineering, technology, public health or medicine vas required under Rule
3(2)(b) of the Consumer Protection (Qualification for appointment, Method of
Recruitment, Procedure of Appointment, Terms of Office, Resignation and
Removal of the President and Members of the State Commission and District
Commission) Rules, 2020. The petitioner got suspicious about the experience
certificates produced by the respondent no.5 and therefore, applied for
furnishing the 'Experience Certificate and Certificate of High School Leaving
Certificate Examination' of respondent no.5 under Right to Information, 2005 to
the SPIO (State Public Information Officer) of the Directorate of CAF & PD by
submitting an application dated 25.04.2022 which was received vide RR No.3702
dated 09.05.2022.
[19]
The State Assistant Public Information Officer, CAF & PD had
written a letter dated 12.05.2022 to the respondent no.5 to make a submission
whether to disclose the information or not. As a follow-up, the petitioner was
served with a letter dated 23.05.2022 enclosing therewith the written objection
of the respondent no.5 by the State Assistant Public Information Officer (SAPIO),
CAF & PD declining to provide the information sought.
[20]
Being aggrieved by the decision of the SAPIO, the petitioner made
a complaint u/s 18(1)(b) of the RTI Act, 2005, being Complaint Case No.3 of
2022 dated 26.05.2022 before the Manipur State Information Commission
requesting for taking suitable action against SPIO and also to provide the
information sought. The complaint was entertained and hotly contested by the
WP(C) NOS. 264 OF 2022 & 686 OF 2022
O.P. but during the pendency and proceedings of the said complaint before the
Manipur State Information Commission, the petitioner was delivered with a letter
dated 15.07.2022 by the SPIO (State Public Information Officer) of the
Directorate of CAF & PD, enclosing therewith Experience Certificates dated
02.08.2003 and 08.04.2015 (two in numbers, purportedly issued by the
respondent no.10) and High School Leaving Certificate of the respondent no.6
through registered post. The said complaint u/s 18(1)(b) of the RTI Act, 2005,
being Complaint Case No.3 of 2022 dated 26.05.2022 before the Manipur State
Information Commission was closed vide its Decision dated 08.08.2022.
[21]
On perusal and analysis of the two Experience Certificates dated
O2.08.2003 and 08.04.2015 concerning the respondent no.5 who passed HSLC
Examination, 1995 and not even a graduate by the year 1999-2000 and having
managed by respondent no.5 to obtain Experience Certificate dated 02.08.2003
wherein it is mentioned that the respondent no.5 had served as a Project
Manager for all projects run under respondent no. 10 since 12.01.1998to
22.07.2003 and also the other Experience Certificate dated 08.04.2015 wherein
it is mentioned that the respondent no.5 had served as a Project Coordinator for
the project of Regional Resource Training Centre(RRTC) North East under the
Ministry of Social Justice And Empowerment, Government of India run by
respondent no.10 since O3.06.2005 to 06.04.2015. Being suspicion about the
authenticity/genuineness of the experience certificates, the petitioner
approached the State Public Information Officer, Office of the Registrar of
Societies, Manipur to provide information relating to the respondent no.10 vide
application dated 25.07.2022 of the petitioner. On receiving the said application
dated 25.07.2022 of the petitioner, the State Public Information Officer, Office
of the Registrar of Societies, Manipur, was pleased to furnish the information
sought concerning respondent no.10 vide its letter dated 26.07.2022 .
[22]
On the perusal of the relevant documents furnished to the
petitioner by the State Public information Officer, Office of the Registrar of
Societies, Manipur, it is revealed that name of Project Manager of respondent
no. 10 is not available and also the name of Project Coordinator as per the list
of staff furnished is one, Minthang Suanthak. It is also learnt that there is no
any project of Regional Resource Training Centre(RRTC) North East under the
WP(C) NOS. 264 OF 2022 & 686 OF 2022
Ministry of Social Justice And Empowerment, Government of India run by
respondent no.10 as on in the year 2005, 2006, 2007 or 2008. The petitioner,
as part of fact finding regarding the working of respondent no.5 under
respondent no.10, cont ted one, Mayengbam Ningthem Singh son of late M.
Ibohal Singh of Wangbal Lamboithong, Thoubal District who was working as
Accountant of Integrated Rural Development and Educational Organisation
(IRDEO), Wangbal, Thoubal District, Manipur during the period 1988 to 2000.
He stated that he was the Accountant, he knew all the staff members of the said
IRDEO. During his service as an Accountant of the said IRDEO, he had not come
across any female staff member by the name of Athokpam Nibedita Devi, d/o.
Athokpam Momon Singh of Thoubal Ningombam Mayai Leirak, P.O. & P.S.
Thoubal District, Manipur, Pin-795138 serving either as Project Manager of all
projects run under IRDEO or as in any other capacity. An affidavit was obtained
by the petitioner on this fact from the said Mayengbam Ningthem Singh on
01.08.2022.
[23]
The petitioner also contacted one, Naorem Pralhada Singh son of
late N. Ibobi Singh of Wangbal Lamboithong Leikai, Thoubal District who was
working as Cashier of Integrated Rural Development and Educational
Organisation (IRDEO), Wangbal, Thoubal District, Manipur during the period
1995 to 1999. He stated that he was the Cashier, he knew all the staff members
of the said IRDEO. During his service as Cashier of the said IRDEO, he had not
come across any female staff member by the name of Athokpam Nibedita Devi,
d/o. Athokpam Momon Singh of Thoubal Ningombam Mayai Leirak, P.O. & P.S.
Thoubal District, Manipur, Pin-795138 serving either as Project Manager of all
projects run, under IRDEO or as in any other capacity. An affidavit was obtained
by the petitioner on this fact from the said Naorem Pralhada Singh on
01.08.2022.
[24]
The-action on the part of the respondent Nos. 1, 2, 3, 5 and 10 is
objected to on the following, inter alia, grounds with prayer to quash the
Appointment Orders By The Governor: Manipur No. CDRC-101/3/2021CAFANDPD-CAF&PD(Pt-I) Imphal, the 21th March, 2022 and further to ask the
respondent no.5 to return the wrongful monetary benefits, by way of salary,
etc., obtained by her during the tenure of illegal appointment.
WP(C) NOS. 264 OF 2022 & 686 OF 2022
GROUNDS
i) Because there is violation of the petitioner's right to be considered fairly
and properly for the appointment to the post of President of District
Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (District Commission) of
Manipur;
ii) Because a bachelor's degree from a recognized university and then to
be a person of ability, integrity and standing, and has special knowledge
and professional experience of not less than twenty years in consumer
affairs, law, public affairs, administration, economics, Commerce,
industry, finance, management, engineering, technology, public health or
medicine is mandatory in terms of Rule 3(2)(b) of the Consumer
Protection (Qualification for appointrnent, Method of Recruitment,
Procedure of Appointment, Terms of Office, Resignation and Removal of
the President and Members of the State Commission and District
Commission) Rules, 2020;
iii) Because respondent no. 5 did not have the requisite and mandatory
requirement of being a graduate and then having special knowledge and
professional experience of not less than twenty years in consumer affairs,
law, etc., is lacking and as such ineligible for consideration for
appointment as member, State Consumer Disputes Redressal
Commission;
iv) Because wrongful decision and recommendation for appointment qua
the respondent no.5 has been made by the Selection Committee for the
post of member, State Commission despite knowing well that respondent
no.5 is ineligible for the post of member of State Commission in as much
as respondent no.5 did not have the requisite special knowledge and
professional experience of not less than twenty years in consumer affairs,
law, public affairs, administration, economics, commerce, industry,
finance, management, engineering, technology, public health or
medicine;
WP(C) NOS. 264 OF 2022 & 686 OF 2022
v) Because this experience of 'not less than twenty years' of the person
shall mean experience of 'not less than twenty years' of the person after
attainment of the bachelors degree from a recognized university and not
the experience prior to obtainment/attainment of the bachelor's degree
from a recognized university;
vi) Because respondent no.5 is unqualified person for the post for which
she was appointed to as member, State Consumer Disputes Redressal
Commission;
vii) Because the two Experience Certificates dated 02.08.2003 and
08.04.2015, concerning the respondent no.5 who passed HSLC
Examination, 1995 and not even a graduate by the year 1999-2000 and
having managed by respondent no.5 to obtain Experience Certificate
dated 02.08.2003 wherein it is mentioned that the respondent no.5 had
served as a Project Manager for all projects run under respondent no.10
since 12.01.1998 to 22.07.2003 and also the other Experience Certificate
dated 08.04.2015 wherein it is mentioned that the respondent no.5 had
served as a Project Coordinator for the project of Regional Resource
Training Centre(RRTC) North East under the Ministry of Social Justice And
Empowerment, Government of India run by respondent no. 10 since
03.06.2005 to 06.04.2015, have been issued by respondent no. 10 falsely;
viii) Because besides there are other good grounds for filing the present
petition.
[25]
In the counter affidavit of the State respondents, it is stated that
the Petitioner has admitted that she applied for the post of President of District
Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (District Commission). On the other
hand the Private Respondent No. 5 namely, Smt. Athokpam Nibedita Devi,
applied for the post of Member of the State Commission and was selected for
the said post by the Selection Committee. As such, the Petitioner has no locus
standi to challenge the appointment of the Private Respondent No. 5 since she
is not an aggrieved person and that no fundamental or other legal rights have
been infringed by appointing the Private Respondent No. 5. On this ground
alone, the present Writ Petition deserves outright dismissal.
WP(C) NOS. 264 OF 2022 & 686 OF 2022
[26]
It is the submission of the learned GA that the Constitution Bench
of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Calcutta Gas Company (Proprietary) Ltd.
-versus- The State of West Bengal and others [1962 AIR (SC) 1044]
has held as follows:-
“..5. The legal right that can be enforced under Art. 32 must ordinarily be
the right of the petitioner himself who complains of infraction of Such right
and approaches the Court for relief. We do not see any reason why a
different principle should apply in the case of a petitioner under Art. 226
of the Constitution. The right that can be enforced under Art. 226 also
shall ordinarily be the personal or individual right of the petitioner himself,
though in the case of some of the writs like habeas corpus or quo warrant
this rule may have to be relaxed or modified. The question, therefore, İs
whether in the present case the petitioner has a legal right and whether
it has been infringed by the contesting respondents."
[27]
It is also humbly submitted that the law laid down by the
Constitution Bench of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the above referred case has
been consistently followed in subsequent judgments. That, the Hon'ble Supreme
Court in N. Kannadasan -versus- Ajoy Khose & others [(2009) 7 SCC 1]
has also held that in Writ of Certiorari, a third party has no locus to canvass the
legality or correctness of the action. It is also further humbly submitted that the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in K. Kumar Gupta -versus- Sri Marken da ya & Sri
Omkareswara Swamy Temple & others [2022 5 SCC 710] has again
reaffirmed that in order to have locus standi to invoke the extraordinary
jurisdiction under Article 226, an applicant should ordinarily be one who has a
personal or individual right in the subject-matter of the application.
[28]
In view of the law laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the
above referred cases, the Petitioner in the present Writ Petition has no locus to
pray for issuance of a Writ in the nature of Certiorari since the authority has not
infringed any fundamental or other legal rights of the petitioner by appointing
the private respondent no. 5.
[29]
It is stated in the preliminary objection vide MC(WP(C) 402 of 2023
of the respondent Nos. 5 & 10 that the petitioner has filed the above said writ
WP(C) NOS. 264 OF 2022 & 686 OF 2022
petition before this Hon'ble Court praying for issuance of the a writ of certiorari
to quash/set aside the appointment order dated 21-03-2022 for appointment of
3 Members of Manipur State Consumer Redressal Commission (State
Commission) and Presidents of District Consumer Disputes Redressal
Commission (District Commission) Imphal, Thoubal and Bishnupur. The main
ground taken by the petitioner against the respondent No. 5 who was appointed
as a Member of the Manipur State Consumer Redressal Commission was that
she did not possess the requisite experience for appointment as a Member of
the Manipur State Consumer Redressal Commission. The State respondents
have filed their affidavit-in-opposition to the said writ petition wherein it was
clearly stated that the experience certificate and documents of the respondent
No. 5 were duly verified and found to be correct and genuine and prayed for
dismissal of the said writ petition. The respondent Nos. 5 & 10 have filed their
preliminary objection to the abovesaid writ petition by raising the question of
maintainability of the said writ petition and also sought a leave to file an
exhaustive affidavit-in-opposition if the said writ petition is found to be
maintainable.
[30]
It is stated that the writ petition filed by the petitioner is not
maintainable for the reason that she is not a candidate for the post of Members
of the Manipur State Consumer Redressal Commission (State Commission) and
she did not apply for the said post. This factual position is admitted by the
petitioner herself in her writ petition. Therefore, in view of the judgment and
order of this Hon'ble Court dated 20-03-2014 passed in W.P(C) No. 695 of
2016 (L. Jayananda Singh Versus The Secretary, Manipur Legislative
Âssembly & 2 Ors.) (para No. 13 & 16), holding that the writ petitioner does
not have locus standi to challenge the appointment of the respondent No. 5. In
Para 16 of the said judgment, this Court has clearly held that as the petitioner
of the said writ petition has not applied for the post in pursuance to the related
notification, he has no locus to challenge the appointment of the respondent.
The same ratio laid down in the said case by this Hon'ble Court is applicable in
the present case also. This Court has also relied the judgment of the Hon'ble
Supreme Court of India in the case of B. Srinivasa Reddy V. Karnataka
Urban Water Supply & Drainage Board Employees Association: (2006)
11 SCC 731 wherein the Hon'ble Apex Court has clearly held that certiorari
WP(C) NOS. 264 OF 2022 & 686 OF 2022
jurisdiction can be exercised only at the instance of a person who is qualified to
the post and who is a candidate for the post.
[31]
It is the contention of Mr. Kh. Tarunkumar, learned senior counsel
for the respondent No.5 that as the petitioner is not qualified for the post of
Member of the Manipur State Consumer Redressal Commission and also she is
not a candidate for the said post, she cannot seek for a relief under the writ of
certiorari to quash and set aside the appointment of the respondent No. 5. The
writ petition filed by the petitioner is not maintainable in view of the aforesaid
judgments of the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India and the order of this Court
and as such, the same is liable to be dismissed without entering into the merit
of the case.
[32]
Further, it is pointed out that if the issue of maintainability is raised
in a writ petition, the same must be decided first before entering into the merit
of the case. This settled position of law has been laid down by the Hon'ble
Supreme Court of India in the case of Security Exchange Board of India
versus Mangalore Stock Exchange reported in (2005)10 SCC 274. In
the said case, the Hon'ble Apex Court has clearly held that once a case has been
challenged as not maintainable, it should dispose of the issue of maintainability
first before passing any further order. A similar view was also taken by the Hon'
ble Supreme Court of India in the case of Union of India Versus Ranbir
Singh Rathaur & Ors. reported in (2006) 11 696 relevant para 42. In the
said case also, the Hon'ble Apex Court held that if the issue of maintainability is
raised in the writ petition, the same should be decided first before going into
merit.
[33]
In view of the aforesaid settled position of law, the maintainability
issue raised by the respondent No. 5 & 10 may kindly be decided first. And, the
writ petition filed by the petitioner is not at all maintainable as she is not a
candidate for the post of Member of the Manipur State Consumer Redressal
Commission and she is also not eligible for the said post. Hence, the writ petition
filed by the petitioner is liable to be dismissed with exemplary cost for filing a
frivolous petition.
WP(C) NOS. 264 OF 2022 & 686 OF 2022
[34]
In the counter affidavit of the respondent No.6, it is stated that the
writ petition is not maintainable as the petitioner has applied for the post of
President of District Commission only and she cannot challenge the appointment
of the respondents as Members of State Commission. It is pointed out that she
lacks locus standi to file the present writ petition, as the petitioner is not an
aggrieved person.
[35]
This Court considers the materials on record, the submissions made
at bar and relevant law in this regard including case law relied by the parties.
[36]
In WP(C) No. 264 of 2022, the only ground for challenge is
appointment of two female Members in the State Commission in excess of one
post advertised in the Notification dated 08-11-2021. However, with the
admitted fact of issuance of Corrigendum dated 11-11-2021 of making at least
one female Member, the cause in the writ petition does not exists as more than
one female Member can be appointed. Accordingly, writ petition is dismissed.
[37]
In WP(C) No. 686 of 2022, the petitioner is an applicant for the post
of the President in District Commission and she has challenged the appointment
of the respondent No.5 as Member of the State Commission. In fact, she is not
an aggrieved party, as she is not an applicant and has no locus to challenge the
appointment of the respondent No.5 in view of the settled proposition of law as
referred herein above. Accordingly, the writ petition is dismissed as not
maintainable. Misc. application is disposed of. Since the writ petition is not
maintainable, the question of eligibility of the respondent No.5 is not gone into
in the present case.
[38]
In terms of the discussions in para 36 and 27, the writ petitions are
dismissed.
JUDGE
FR/NFR
suchitra
KH. JOSHUA KH. JOSHUA MARING
Date: 2024.12.20
MARING
15:45:38 +05'30'
WP(C) NOS. 264 OF 2022 & 686 OF 2022
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review