Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
SHAMURAILATPAM
SUSHIL SHARMA
SUSHIL SHARMA
Date: 2023.08.31 13:32:09 +05'30'
Page |1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
WP (C) No. 527 of 2023
Shri Athokpam Dolendro Singh, aged about 52 years old,
S/O Late Athokpam Manihar Singh, a resident of
Keishamthong Thangjam Leirak, P.O. & P.S. Imphal,
Imphal West District, Manipur-795001.
…Petitioner
-Versus-
1.
The State of Manipur represented by the Principal
Secretary/ Commissioner/ Secretary, (Tribal Development
and Hills), Government of Manipur, Secretariat Block, P.O
& P.S. Imphal, Manipur -795001.
2.
The Manipur Tribal Development Corporation Ltd.
represented by the Managing Director, Manipur Tribal
Development Corporation Ltd. Government of Manipur,
Lamphelpat, P.O & P.S. Lamphelpat, Manipur -795004.
3.
W. Robby Singh, aged about 51 years old, S/O Late W.
Bangshidhor Singh, a resident of Uripok Polem Leikai,
P.O. Imphal & P.S. Lamphel, Imphal West District,
Manipur-795001.
.....Respondents
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE M.V. MURALIDARAN
For the Petitioner
.
For the Respondents
::
Mr. HS Paonam, Sr. Adv.,
::
Mr. M. Rarry, Special Counsel
for State
Mr. Y. Nirmolchand, Sr. Adv.
WP(C) No. 527 of 2023
Page |2
Date of Hearing and
reserving Judgment & Order ::
25.08.2023
Date of Judgment & Order
31.08.2023
::
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
(CAV)
This writ petition has been filed by the petitioner to
quash the impugned order dated 26.7.2023 conferring the
charge of Chief Engineer to the third respondent in Manipur
Tribal Development Corporation Limited, Lamphelpat, and to
consider the petitioner for charge of Chief Engineer in Manipur
Tribunal Development Corporation Limited, Lamphelpat.
2.
Assailing the impugned order, Mr. H.S. Paonam,
the learned senior counsel for the petitioner submitted that the
petitioner is functioning as Project Director of Manipur Tribal
Development Corporation Limited (MTDC) and the petitioner is
senior to the third respondent amongst Assistant Engineer
(Degree Civil). Earlier, the petitioner challenged the seniority list
in W.P.(C) No.327 of 2022 and the said writ petition is pending.
The petitioner had also challenged the conferment of charge of
Superintending Surveyor of Works to the third respondent by
filing W.P.(C) No.330 of 2022, which is also pending.
3.
The learned senior counsel further submitted that
this Court passed an order dated 2.3.2023 in W.P.(C) No.327 of
WP(C) No. 527 of 2023
Page |3
2022 for redressing the grievance of the petitioner for conferment
of charge of Chief Engineer in MTDC Limited, as he is presently
functioning as Project Director. However, the State Government
in complete arbitrary exercise of power and without considering
the grievance of the petitioner, has issued the impugned order
dated 26.7.2023 thereby conferring the charge of the Chief
Engineer in MTDC Limited to the third respondent which would
result in allowing a junior officer to control a senior officer.
4.
The learned senior counsel would submit that an
enquiry is pending against the third respondent for payment of
mobilization advance security to the tune of Rs.12,66,64,862/against fake bank guarantee and bank cheque. The State
Government instead taking appropriate departmental enquiry
against the third respondent has conferred the charge of Chief
Engineer by overlooking the fact that the petitioner is holding the
higher post of Project Director in MTDC Limited, which is against
the norms of service jurisprudence. Thus, a prayer is made to
quash the impugned order and to direct the official respondents
to consider the case of the petitioner for charge of Chief Engineer
of MTDC Limited.
5.
Mr. M. Rarry, the learned Special Counsel for State
appearing for the respondents 1 and 2 submitted that neither the
WP(C) No. 527 of 2023
Page |4
petitioner nor the third respondent are eligible as per the
Recruitment Rules to be considered for filling up the post of Chief
Engineer, MTDC Limited. Hence, the senior most amongst the
cadre belonging to the feeder post of the said particular post is
appointed to hold the said post on in-charge basis.
The
substantive regular post held by the petitioner and the third
respondent is the post of Assistant Engineer (Degree Civil) as on
31.8.2021 when the seniority list of Assistant Engineer in MTDC
was published as on 31.8.2021.
6.
The Special Counsel for State would submit that the
third respondent’s name in the said seniority list of Engineer
under the MTDC Limited as on 31.8.2021 is shown at Serial No.1
while the petitioner’s name is shown at Serial No.2, and,
therefore, the third respondent is senior to the petitioner.
7.
The Special Counsel for State urged that in
conformity with the terms of the provisions at Clause No.4(ii) of
the Office Memorandum dated 3.10.2020, the State appointed
the third respondent as Chief Engineer, MTDC Limited on incharge basis vide the impugned order. Since the impugned order
is in conformity with and in compliance of the Office
Memorandum dated 3.10.2020, there is no arbitrariness or
WP(C) No. 527 of 2023
Page |5
illegality in appointing the third respondent as Chief Engineer,
MTDC Limited on in-charge basis.
8.
Adding further, the Special Counsel for State
submitted that the allegation of the petitioner that the third
respondent is facing departmental enquiry in terms of the order
dated 1.9.2022 passed in W.P.(C) No.506 of 2022 cannot be a
basis to override the mandatory provisions of the Office
Memorandum dated 3.10.2020.
The departmental enquiry
against the third respondent has different implication in regard to
the service condition of the third respondent. At this stage, when
the impugned order dated 26.7.2023 was issued, the relevant
condition to be applied is as contained in the Office Memorandum
dated 3.10.2020 for giving in-charge appointment and the State
has rightly done the same.
9.
According to the Special Counsel for State, the
petitioner has been designated as Project Director for EMRS
Projects taken up by MTDC Limited and the same will be coterminus with the completion of EMRS projects. Therefore, the
designation as Project Director is only for a particular project and
cannot be said to be a promotion to a higher post and neither
was it an appointment on regular basis for MTDC. Hence, the
claim of the petitioner on this ground is totally misconceived.
WP(C) No. 527 of 2023
Page |6
10.
Mr. Y. Nirmolchand, the learned senior counsel for
the third respondent submitted that insofar as the departmental
enquiry pending against the third respondent as alleged by the
petitioner is concerned, the main charge about the fake bank
guarantee is not the concern of the third respondent, but relates
to the Finance/Account Section. However, it is for the enquiry
officer or the disciplinary authority to decide who is responsible
for the aforesaid incident. Unless and until the departmental
enquiry is completed, a person cannot be considered as
unbecoming of a Government servant, violating the conduct
rules.
11.
The learned senior counsel for the third respondent
urged that the third respondent is always senior from the date of
initial appointment till the promotion to the post of Assistant
Engineer and being senior to the petitioner, the third respondent
was conferred the charge of Chief Engineer, which is neither
illegal nor improper.
12.
The learned senior counsel further submitted that
the petitioner is having a pending vigilance case relating to
forfeiture of Rs.14.7 crore regarding a project “Construction of 69
bridges in Myanmar” where he was the concerned Engineer.
There is no law that during the pendency of the departmental
WP(C) No. 527 of 2023
Page |7
enquiry, senior most employee cannot look after the charge of
the higher post. Thus, a prayer is made to dismiss the writ
petition.
13.
This Court considered the rival submissions and
also perused the materials available on record.
14.
The grievance of the petitioner is that since the third
respondent is facing departmental enquiry in terms of the order
dated 1.9.2022 passed in W.P.(C) No.506 of 2022 and the
petitioner is presently functioning as Project Director in MTDC
Limited and also he being senior to the third respondent, the
State ought not to have conferred the charge of Chief Engineer
in MTDC Limited to the third respondent and the petitioner alone
is entitled to be considered for conferment of charge of the Chief
Engineer in MTDC Limited.
15.
On the other hand, the third respondent contended
that as per the seniority list, the third respondent is senior to the
petitioner and as per law, in-charge appointment is to be afforded
to the senior most officer.
Further, the petitioner is facing
vigilance case relating to forfeiture of Rs.14.7 crore regarding a
project, namely Construction of 69 bridges in Myanmar.
WP(C) No. 527 of 2023
Page |8
16.
In
the
affidavit-in-opposition
filed
by
the
respondents 1 and 2, it has been stated that neither the petitioner
nor the private respondents are eligible as per the Recruitment
Rules to fill up the post of Chief Engineer, MTDC Limited. Hence,
the senior most amongst the cadre/officials belonging to the
feeder post of the said particular post shall be appointed to hold
the said post on in-charge basis.
17.
It is contended by the petitioner that he has
challenged the seniority list by filing W.P.(C) No.327 of 2022 and
the same is pending. By the order dated 11.5.2022, the said writ
petition was admitted by this Court. According to the petitioner,
when the seniority list is under challenge in W.P.(C) No.327 of
2022, the respondent State ought not to have considered the
third respondent for conferment of the charge of Chief Engineer.
18.
Earlier when the State issued an order dated
24.6.2022 conferring the charge of Chief Engineer to the third
respondent, the petitioner has filed W.P.(C) No.470 of 2022 and
one Brojendra Singh has filed W.P.(C) No.498 of 2022. By the
interim order, this Court stayed the order dated 24.6.2022
impugned in the said writ petitions and, accordingly, the
competent authority passed an order conferring the charge of
Chief Engineer of MTDC Limited to Brojendra Singh. The said
WP(C) No. 527 of 2023
Page |9
order of the State has been challenged by the third respondent
by filing W.P.(C) Nos.928 and 942 of 2022 and another person
also filed W.P.(C) No.232 of 2023. According to the petitioner,
W.P.(C) Nos.470, 498 and 928 of 2022 have been disposed of
and W.P.(C) Nos.942 of 2022 and 232 of 2023 are still pending.
It appears that since the contractual engagement of the
Brojendra Singh has not been extended, by the order dated
1.8.2023, W.P.(C) No.942 of 2022 has been withdrawn by the
third respondent.
19.
According to the respondent State, the substantive
regular post held by the petitioner and the third respondent is the
post of Assistant Engineer (Degree Civil) as on 31.8.2021 when
the seniority list of Assistant Engineer was published as on
31.8.2021.
In the seniority list as on 31.8.2021, the third
respondent is shown at Serial No.1 while the petitioner’s name
shown at Serial No.2.
20.
The Office Memorandum dated 3.10.2020 reads
thus:
“No.23/20/2019-Misc (PHED)/DP: A large number
of
references
has
been
made
by
various
departments under the Government of Manipur
seeking clarity from Department of Personnel in
WP(C) No. 527 of 2023
P a g e | 10
regards to appointments on in-charge basis to
various posts and candidates for making such
appointments, etc.
2. At present, there is no laid down norm for making
appointments on in-charge basis to posts under the
State Government. In the absence of laid down
norms, various departments have been resorting to
such appointment usually by considering seniority
of officials, place of posting etc. In other cases,
there is want of better logic apparent on the face of
such appointment leading to discontent in the
cadre concerned and ultimately affecting efficiency
of public administration.
3. In this context, the need to issue details norms
for appointment of officials to a post on in-charge
basis has been under consideration of the State
Government from some time.
4. Thus, with a view to bring uniformity, clarity and
enforceable norms in making such in-charge
appointments, the following norms are hereby
issued for compliance by all concerned:
i. Appointment on in charge basis shall be made
against a post only when there is no official eligible
as per RR to fill up the said post, either by direct
recruitment
or
constituted DPC.
WP(C) No. 527 of 2023
by
promotion
through
duly
P a g e | 11
ii. In the absence of any official eligible as per RR
to fill up a particular post, the senior most person
amongst cadre/officials belonging to the feeder
post of the said particular post shall be appointed
to hold the said post on in-charge basis, at no extra
remuneration and in addition to the substantial post
held by the appointee in the lower post. Needless
to say, the appointee shall draw pay against the
lower post substantially held by him.
iii. Where no arrangement can be made as in para
(ii) above, an in-charge appointment shall be made
to a vacant post from a person holding a similar
post (at same rank and/or designation) at no extra
remuneration.
iv. An official appointed on in-charge basis against
any post shall have the same financial power as a
person appointed on substantial basis against the
said post would apply.
5. These instructions shall be applicable while
making appointments on in-charge basis to all
posts under the State Government existing in all
Government departments, agencies, societies,
bodies, offices, companies, PSUs, autonomous
bodies. etc.”
21.
The pendency of the departmental enquiry against
the third respondent is admitted by the third respondent himself.
According to the third respondent until and unless the
WP(C) No. 527 of 2023
P a g e | 12
departmental enquiry is completed, he cannot be considered as
unbecoming of a Government servant, violating the conduct
rules. The pendency of the departmental enquiry against the
third respondent is evident from the written statement of defence
submitted by the third respondent. On the other hand, there is
nothing on record to show that the vigilance case was registered
against the petitioner as alleged by the third respondent. On a
perusal of the annexures to the affidavit-in-opposition filed by the
third respondent, it is seen that the petitioner and one
Chandrakumar Singh, the then Account Officer, MTDC have
been required for examination and accordingly, they have been
called for examination on 16.1.2021. Nothing has been placed
on record to show about the further progress in the aforesaid
vigilance enquiry.
On the other hand, the departmental
proceedings against the third respondent has been directed to
be completed within a period of six months from the date of
receipt of a copy of the order dated 1.9.2022 passed in W.P.(C)
No.506 of 2022. The operative portion of the order reads thus:
“(7) On considering the arguments advanced by
both the parties, this Court is inclined to pass the
following orders:
a) This writ petition is disposed of.
WP(C) No. 527 of 2023
P a g e | 13
b) The respondents No.2 & 3 are directed to
proceed
the
Departmental
enquiry
proceedings against the respondent No.4
as per the letter dated 24.05.2022 and to
pass an appropriate order within a period of
6 (six) months from the date of the receipt
of this order by giving personal opportunity
to all concerned.”
22.
Despite the specific direction given in the aforesaid
order, the departmental proceedings against the third respondent
have not been completed and neither any extension of time was
granted by this Court, nor sought for by the authorities. This only
shows that the action of the authorities is prima facie in favour of
the third respondent. The authorities are bound by the Office
Memorandum, but that does not mean that they should be
blindfolded to the directions issued by this court to complete the
disciplinary proceedings within six months, which period has long
lapsed.
23.
In Government of A.P. and another v. B.Vasantha
Rao and another, (1999) 5 SCC 183, the Apex Court held:
“4. We are at a loss to understand as to how the
High
Court
could
pass
such
an
order.
Admittedly, the disciplinary proceedings had
commenced on 28-7-1998. Even if before that
WP(C) No. 527 of 2023
P a g e | 14
date the said respondent had been empanelled
for promotion, the Government cannot be
prohibited
from
starting
disciplinary
proceedings if there are reasons for doing so.
The High Court has not quashed the disciplinary
proceedings and looking at the charges levelled
against the respondent, it cannot be said that
there was any ulterior motive for the respondent
being put under suspension. Furthermore,
when disciplinary proceedings are pending,
we are doubtful whether it was appropriate
for the High Court to have directed that the
select list for promotion should be given
effect to forthwith especially when the High
Court in the said order has permitted the
disciplinary proceedings to continue. It is
also difficult to appreciate the High Court
holding
that
even
though
disciplinary
proceedings could continue but no final order
should be passed. No reasons for coming to this
conclusion have been given.”
[emphasis supplied]
24.
From the above, it is clear that when disciplinary
proceedings are pending, it is doubtful for the authorities to select
and/or give promotion to the person to hold the high office. What
needs to be noted at this juncture is that the respondent
authorities, despite a time bound order passed by the High Court
WP(C) No. 527 of 2023
P a g e | 15
to complete the disciplinary proceedings within six months, which
has lapsed long back, have not taken any steps either to
conclude the proceedings or to seek extension of time. This only
shows that all is not fair with the authorities. That apart, the
respondent authorities have not placed any shred of material to
show what efforts have been put in by them to appoint a regular
Chief Engineer in the absence of any eligible candidate.
25.
Since the seniority of the petitioner and the third
respondent is under challenge in W.P.(C) No.327 of 2022, prima
facie, the third respondent cannot be considered to be the senior
of the petitioner. That apart, departmental proceeding is pending
against the third respondent.
26.
It is pertinent to note that aggrieved by not
conferment of the post of Chief Engineer, the third respondent
had earlier filed W.P.(C) No.435 of 2023 before this Court.
Pending writ petition, without leave of the Court, by the impugned
order dated 26.7.2023, the State had conferred in-charge of
Chief Engineer to the third respondent, which action of the State
is not appreciable.
27.
According to the petitioner, the petitioner is
presently functioning as Project Director of MTDC Limited, which
WP(C) No. 527 of 2023
P a g e | 16
is a higher post and, therefore, he is entitled for being appointed
as Chief Engineer of MTDC Limited. It is also the case of the
petitioner that the appointment of the petitioner as Project
Director has not been challenged by anybody, including the third
respondent and, hence, the petitioner should be considered
conferment to the post of in-charge Chief Engineer.
28.
Per
contra,
the
Special
Counsel
for
State
contended that the post of Project Director held by the petitioner
is co-terminus and after completion of the project, the designation
as Project Director cannot stand.
29.
In the order dated 24.8.2022, it has been stated as
under:
“The Governor of Manipur is pleased to designate
Shri
Athokpam
Engineer-IV,
Dolendro
MTDC
as
Singh,
Executive
Project
Director
(Technical/Civil Works) for EMRS projects taken up
by the Manipur Tribal Development Corporation
(MTDC) Ltd., Manipur with immediate effect and
without any extra remuneration for a period that will
be co-terminus with the completion of EMRS
projects or until further orders.”
30.
It is not the case of the respondent State that the
project mentioned in the order dated 24.8.2022 was completed.
WP(C) No. 527 of 2023
P a g e | 17
The order clearly states that “with the completion of EMRS
projects or until further orders”, which means that still the
petitioner is serving as Project Director. No contra evidence is
also let in on the side of the respondents. As the petitioner is
holding the higher post as on date, nothing prevented the
authorities from considering the claim of the petitioner. That
apart, it is seen from the documents on record that the services
of the petitioner have been utilized as in-charge Executive
Engineer in the Department of Medical and Health Service,
Manipur vide order dated 22.10.2011 for a period of one year,
which was extended for one more year vide order dated
23.11.2012. Thus, it is prima facie seen that the present
petitioner has rendered longer service in the said cadre.
31.
Since the impugned order has been issued pending
disciplinary proceedings against the third respondent and that
too without the leave of the Court while W.P.(C) No.435 of 2023
filed by the third respondent is pending on the date of issuance
of the impugned order, the same is not sustainable in the eye of
law. The pendency of the disciplinary proceedings has not been
stated in the impugned order, however, by referring to paragraph
4(i) and (ii) of the Office Memorandum dated 3.10.2020, the
WP(C) No. 527 of 2023
P a g e | 18
respondent State appointed the third respondent as Chief
Engineer, MTDC Limited on in-charge basis.
32.
For the reasons stated above, the impugned order
is not sustainable in the eye of law and, therefore, the same is
liable to be quashed.
33.
In the result,
(i)
The writ petition is allowed.
(ii)
The impugned order dated 26.7.2023 passed
by the Deputy Secretary (TA & Hills),
Government of Manipur, is set aside.
(iii)
The respondent authorities are directed to
confer the charge of Chief Engineer, in
Manipur Tribal Development Corporation
Ltd., Lamphelpat to the petitioner.
(iv)
No costs.
ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE
FR/NFR
Sushil
WP(C) No. 527 of 2023
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review