Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE BASANT BALAJI
MONDAY, THE 24TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 3RD CHAITHRA, 1947
OP(C) NO. 648 OF 2025
IA 34/2025 IN OS NO.667 OF 2010 OF PRINCIPAL MUNSIFF COURT
KOZHIKODE-I
PETITIONERS/PLAINTIFF/PETITIONERS IN IA 34/2025:
ASSOCIATION FOR THE WELFARE OF THE HANDICAPPED
(REGISTERED UNDER THE SOCIETIES REGISTRATION ACT WITH REG.
NO.26/75),17/194A,, M’SQUARE COMPLEX, PAVAMANI ROAD,
CALICUT-673001., REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY,
DR.T.MOHAMMED, S/O. AHAMMED, AGED 77 YEARS, 114/9A,
MYSHA, PANTHALAYANI AMSOM, DESOM, KOYILANDY TALUK.
PIN 673620, PIN - 673001
DR.T.MOHAMMED
AGED 77 YEARS
S/O. AHAMMED, 11/49A, 'MYSHA’, PANTHALAYANI AMSOM, DESOM,
KOYILANDY THALUK. PIN, PIN - 673620
DR.KUNH AHAMMED KUTTY
AGED 82 YEARS
S/O. KUNHI MOIDEENKUTTY HAJEE, THIRIKKOOTT VEEDU,
V.K.K.MENON ROAD, PANNIYANKARA AMSOM, DESOM, KOZHIKODE
THALUK. PIN, PIN - 673003
BY ADVS.
R.ANAS MUHAMMED SHAMNAD
B.VINOD
T.U.SUJITH KUMAR
SALEEK.C.A.
HAMDAN MANSOOR K.
OPC 648/2025
-22025:KER:25679
RESPONDENTS/DEFENDANTS/RESPONDENTS IN IA 34/2025:
K.P.MOHAMMED
S/O MOIDEEN KOYA, DHANIYA, CHEVAYUR AMSOM, DESOM,
CHEVAYUR POST. CALICUT-PIN ., PIN - 673017
P.AHMED KOYA
S/O ABDURAHIMAN KUTTY, 17/1057, AMAN, KASABA AMSOM
DESOM, PUTHIYARA PO, CALICUT, PIN - 673004
DR.C.P.ABOOBACKER
S/O.AYAMMED KUTTY, SHAMSUL KHAIR, POONGOTTUKULAM,
TIRUR POST, MALAPPURAM DISTRICT, PIN, PIN - 676101
K.M.FARIYA,
D/O ALIKOYA, PUTHENVEEDU POST, CHALIYAM,KOZHIKODE,
PIN, PIN - 673301
V.THAHIRA,
D/O.V.S.A.THANGAL, VARAYALIL HOUSE, AYANCHERI,
VADAKARA THALUK, KOZHIKODE, PIN, PIN - 673101
V.K.BAVA,
S/O.ABDULLA KOYA HAJEE, KULANGARA HOUSE, FEROKE
AMSOM, DESOM, KOZHIKODE, PIN, PIN - 673631
K.ZEENATH
D/O.K.P.ABDUL KADER, 22/1202, THIRUVANNUR NADA (PO),
KOZHIKODE, PIN - 673029
K.M.MOHAMMED ZAHIR,
S/O. K.P.ABDUL KADER, 22/1202, THIRUVANNUR,
KOZHIKODE, PIN - 673029
ABDUL SALEEM.C.C,
S/O.KOYAN KUTTY, S. BUNGALOW, CHALIYAM POST,
KOZHIKKODE DISTRICT, - PIN, PIN - 673201
ABDUL SHUKKUR THALATHIL,
S/O.T.HUSSAIN, THALATHIL, NANJILATH, KODIYATHOOR
OPC 648/2025
-32025:KER:25679
POST, MUKKAM, KOZHIKKODE TALUK, PIN, PIN - 673602
N.T.MUHAMMED SHEREEF,
S/O. N.T.MOHAMMED ALI, DEYA MANZIL, VENGARA AMSOM,
DESOM, VENGARA POST,, TIRURANGADI TALUK,
MALAPPURAM DISTRICT, PIN, PIN - 676304
SHABEEL ABOOBACKER.C.P,
S/O. ABOOBACKER.C.P, SHAMSUL KHAIR, THRIKKANDIYOOR
AMSOM, ANNARA DESOM, POST POONGOTTUKULAM, TIRUR
TALUK, MALAPPURAM DISTRICT, PIN, PIN - 676101
MUHAMMED MUSTHAFA.K,
S/O.KUNHALA, N.P.HOUSE, POST PUTHUKODE, AZHINHILAM
AMSOM, PUTHUKODE DESOM, MALAPPURAM DISTRICT, PIN,
PIN - 673632
ABDUL GAFOOR.N.P,
S/O P V MUHAMMED KOYA, VALAPPIL HOUSE, CHEVAYUR
POST, NELLIKKODE AMSOM DESOM, KOZHIKODE DISTRICT,
PIN, PIN - 673017
P.V.MUHAMMED BASHEER,
S/O.P.V.MUHAMMED,33/6206B, CHEVAYUR POST, CHEVAYUR
AMSOM, DESOM, KOZHIKODE PIN, PIN - 673017
M. MUHAMMED
AGED 66 YEARS, S/O. ABDURAHIMAN HAJEE,
MUNDATTUKANDY HOUSE, PUNOOR.P.O., KEDAVOOR
AMSOM, PUNOOR DESOM, THAMARASSERY. TALUK., PIN 673574
K.MUHAMMED KOYA,
S/O.BEERAN.K.C, HIBA, RAGHAVA MENON ROAD, POST
THIRUVANNUR NADA, PANNIYANKARA AMSOM DESOM,
KOZHIKODE THALUK & DISTRICT, PIN, PIN - 673003
KAITHAYIL IMBICHIKOYA
S/O.KUNHALI KOYA, KAITHAYIL HOUSE, CHAKKUM KADAVU,
PANNIYANKARA AMSOM, DESOM, POST KALLAI, KOZHIKODE
THALUK & DISTRICT, PIN, PIN - 673003
OPC 648/2025
-42025:KER:25679
P. ABDUL RAZAK,
S/O.K.MUHAMMED, POOLAKKAL HOUSE, POST
KARUVAMPOIL, KODUVALLY AMSOM DESOM, KOZHIKODE
THALUK & DISTRICT. PIN, PIN - 673572
P.K. MUHAMMED SHEREEF,
S/O P.K.MAMOO, PUKUNHIYIL HOUSE, PANOOR POST,
ELANHODE, KANNUR DISTRICT, PIN, PIN - 670692
P.K.HABEEB RAHMAN,
S/O.ABDU SAMAD.P.K, EMPLOYEA IN CALICUT UNIVERSITY,
DARUL KAUZER, AYIKKARAPPADI POST, CHERUKAVU AMSOM,
DESOM, KONDOTTY TALUK, MALAPPURAM DISTRICT. PIN,
PIN - 673638
K.P.SAINABA,
D/O.P.V.MOHAMMED BASHEER, 33/62068 B, CHEVAYUR POST,
CHEVAYUR AMSOM, DESOM, KOZHIKKODE TALUK, PIN, PIN 673017
V.V.ABDUL RASAKH,
S/O.V.V.MUHAMMAD KOYA, 22/1302, VAYALAKKARA
PARAMBA, THIRUVANNUR NADA, PANNIYANKARA AMSOM,
DESOM, KOZHIKKODE, PIN, PIN - 673029
ARSHAD VAKAYIL,
S/O.HAMZA, HILAL MANZIL, PUTHALAM, AREEKODE POST,
THIRUVANNUR NADA, AREEKODE AMSOM, PUTHALAM
DESOM, ERNAD TALUK, MALAPPURAM DT. PIN, PIN - 673639
A.P.ABDUSSAMAD,
S/O.MOIDEENKUTTY, ANAPPADIKKÄL HOUSE, POST
KALPAKANCHERY, MALAPPURAM DISTRICT, PIN, PIN - 676551
K.P.IMBICHALI
S/O M MUHAMMED, 3/113 A, KOVIL MOOLAM PARAMBA,
PULIKKAL LANE, NADAKKAVU POST, KACHERI AMSOM,
DESOM, KOZHIKKODE TALUK., PIN – 673011
OPC 648/2025
-52025:KER:25679
SHABIL AHAMMED
S/O.AHAMMED KOYA, 20/1247 J, AMAAN, THIRUVANNUR
NADA POST, PANNIYANKARA KOZHIKKODE TALUK., PIN 673639
ABDUSSALAM.P.P,
S/O.MUHAMMED KUTTY,P.P.HOUSE, PEZHUNGAL PARAMBIL,
POST MONGAM, MORAYUR AMSOM, MONGAM DESOM,
KONDOTTY TALUK, MALAPPURAM DT, PIN - 673642
SULEMAN ABOOBACKER,
S/O.P.K.ABOOBACKER, BADAR MANZIL, AYITTY,
THRIKKARIPOOR POST, THRIKKARIPOOR AMSOM, AYITTY
DESOM, HOSDURG TALUK., PIN - 671310
DR.IBRAHIM KUTTY,
S/O.A.ABDULLA HAJEE, PATHODY HOUSE, PONNANI POST,
MALAPPURAM PONNANI AMSOM, DESOM, MALAPPURAM.,
PIN - 679577
FAISAL
S/O.MUHAMMED. A, A.M.MANZIL, ATHIKKAVIL, OZHUKUR
POST, MALAPPURAM DISTRICT. PIN, PIN - 673642
BABITH.N
LECTURER TOOL & DYE DEPARTMENT, AWH POLYTECHNIC
COLLEGE, KUTTIKKATTOOR, KOZHIKODE- PIN CODE., PIN 673008
SAJITH.K.K
S /O. KRISHNAN KUTTY, KUZHIKKATTAKUZHIYIL HOUSE,
PANTHEERANKAVU POST, ARAPPUZHA, KOZHIKODE,, PIN 673019
BY ADVS.
V.V.SURENDRAN
P.A.HARISH(K/000392/1991)
DONA PAUL(K/001661/2018)
THIS OP (CIVIL) HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON 24.03.2025,
THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
OPC 648/2025
-62025:KER:25679
JUDGMENT
(Dated this the 24th day of March, 2025)
The petitioners are the plaintiffs and the respondents
are the defendants in O.S.667/2010. The suit was decreed as
per Ext.P1, which reads as follows:
“1.
It is hereby declared that, as on 01.04.2008,
AWH was having 42 members. (Since D2 is no more, as
on today there are only 41 members are available) A
commission shall be appointed by the court for
supervising the general body meeting of the members of
AWH and for the election of executive committee
members consisting of 13 members including the office
bearers. The general body meeting and election shall be
conducted strictly in accordance with the provisions of
Ext.A5 bye-laws, after giving notice to all the aforesaid
members. The commissioner appointed by the court shall
act as the returning officer in the election. The entire
process of election shall be completed within a period of
two months from this day.”
2.
Against the judgment and decree, an appeal
was filed as AS No.1/2017 before the Sub Court, Kozhikode.
The
first
appellate
court,
by
Ext.P2
judgment
dated
21.12.2017, allowed the appeal and modified the preliminary
decree as follows:
OPC 648/2025
-72025:KER:25679
“In the result, appeal is allowed in part and Judgement
and decree dated 31-7-17 is set aside. A modified
preliminary decree is passed in the following terms:
1) Declaring that as on 1.4.2008 AWH was having
alltogether 18 members and as on today on the death of
defendant No.2 during the pendency of the suit, there are
following 17 members: (1) Kunhahammed Kutty, (2)
Ahammed Koya, (3) Muhammed K P, (4) Abdurahiman.M,
(5) Aboobacker C.P., (6) Habeeb.V, (7) K. Ahammed, (8)
Fakrudheen. T, (9) Ibrahim Kutty, (10) Thahira.V, (11)
Amina. T, (12) Aysha Kalliyath, (13) Fariya K.M.,
(14)Abdul Saleem P.P., (15) Ali. M., (16) Ayshabeevi, (17)
Abdul Rasheed.V.V.)
2) A Commissioner shall be appointed by the lower court
for supervising the general body meeting of the members
of AWH and for the election of executive committee
members consisting of 13 members including the office
bearers. Terms and condition as well as his batta will be
decide by the Lower court at the time of his appointment.
3) A general body meeting and election shall be
conducted strictly in accordance with the provisions of
Ext.A5 bye-law and after giving notice to all the
members.
4) The Commissioner appointed by the court shall act as
the returning officer in the election.
5) The commissioner shall complete the entire process of
election within one month from his date of appointment.
6) Both sides shall suffer their respective costs.”
3.
Respondents 20 to 24 and 26, filed RSA
No.111/2018, before this Court and this Court by judgment
dated 17.08.2023 allowed the RSA and the decree and
judgment of the first appellate court was set aside, and that
of the Trial Court was restored.
OPC 648/2025
-82025:KER:25679
4.
Acting on the judgment of the Munsiff Court,
the Advocate Commissioner had issued Ext.P6 draft election
notification on 25.10.2024.
The plaintiffs filed objection to
the draft election notification as Ext.P8 and the 1 st defendant
filed objection on behalf of defendants 3 to 9, 11 and 12, as
Ext.P7.
While so, the matter was taken before the Apex
Court in Special Leave Petition (Civil) Diary No.53444/2023.
The Apex Court, granted the leave and converted it into Civil
Appeal
Nos.3734-3735/2024
and
passed
an
order
on
20.11.2024, which reads as follows:
“In such circumstances and taking note of the fact that
the last election to AWH was conducted more than 14
years back, we are of the considered view that an
interim order on the following lines can be passed:(i)
Let the Advocate Commissioner appointed by
the Court, as per the impugned judgment under
challenge, declare the date of election after complying
with the necessary basic procedures for conducting
election.
(ii)
An election shall be conducted, on the date
fixed by the Court appointed commissioner.
(iii)
23 persons whose rights to cast votes are under
challenge be permitted to cast vote in one box and the
votes cast by the others whose such rights are not at
issue be put in a separate box.
(iv) After the election, the right to cast votes of the
OPC 648/2025
-92025:KER:25679
aforesaid 23 persons would be decided in these appeals
and the question whether such votes are to be counted
or not to be counted would depend upon the outcome of
the pending appeals. The counting and declaration of
result of the election shall be done only after obtaining
permission from this Court.”
5.
The Advocate Commissioner filed an interim
report on 13.12.2024 along with the election notification.
Acting on the interim report, Ext.P14 was passed by the
Munsiff,
leaving
certain
directions
to
the
Advocate
Commissioner for conducting the election. The directions
issued are as follows:
“1. The Commissioner shall conduct the election strictly
in accordance with the directions given by the Hon'ble
Apex Court in Civil Appeal No. 3734-3735/2024.
2. The Advocate Commissioner shall prepare a detailed
voters list of the members of the Association 25 days
before the date of election and shall publish the same.
3. The Advocate Commissioner can finalize the list of the
members of Association who are entitled to vote on the
basis of approved identity proofs with photographs in it.
4. The Advocate Commissioner shall submit a draft ballot
paper for approval and after conducting the election, the
sealed boxes containing the ballot papers should be kept
under the safe custody of the court.
5. The Advocate Commissioner is at liberty to take
OPC 648/2025
-102025:KER:25679
decisions on videographing the entire election, counting
and result declaration. If such videographing is done, it
should be submitted to the court.
6. No sufficient grounds were made by the plaintiffs for
changing the place of election and for not seeking the
assistance of the receiver appointed by the court for the
smooth conduct of election.”
6.
aggrieved
The counsel for the petitioners is highly
by
the
directions
issued
to
the
Advocate
Commissioner to prepare a detailed voters list by himself and
also the fact that the commissioner is at liberty to conduct
the counting and declaration of the results, which is against
the order of the Apex Court in Ext.P9.
7.
been
On receipt of notice, respondents 1 to 3 have
represented
by
Adv.P.A
Harish.
For
the
other
respondents, notice has been served on the counsel appearing
for the respondents before the Trial Court and a
memo has
been filed evidencing the same.
8.
Adv.PA Harish, submits that clause nos.5 in
Ext.P14 directs the commissioner to take a decision on
OPC 648/2025
-112025:KER:25679
videographing the entire election, counting, and declaration
of the results. He concedes to the fact that the counting and
declaration
of
the
results
cannot
be
done
by
the
commissioner, as the Apex Court has directed to keep the
votes counted separately in two boxes, and the counting and
declaration of results shall only be done after obtaining
permission from the Apex Court.
9.
In Ext.P9, the question was regarding the 23
persons who are included in the voters list. The Apex Court
categorically held that the 23 persons who have the right to
vote are permitted to cast the votes in one box, and the
votes cast by the others shall be kept in a separate box.
10.
It
is
submitted
by
the
counsel
for
the
petitioner that a draft voters list has been published by the
commissioner and they intend to raise an objection to the
inclusion of three
members in the list of 17 persons. As
directed by the Apex Court as well as the Munsiff, the
OPC 648/2025
-122025:KER:25679
Commissioner shall take into consideration the objections, if
any, filed by the petitioners and then publish a final voters
list in respect of the 17 members and 23 members in dispute.
Therefore, I am of the considered opinion that the
election shall be conducted strictly in accordance with Ext.P9
as well as the bye-laws. The votes cast shall be kept
separately in two boxes as directed by the Apex Court. The
directions contained in Ext.P14 to the extent that the
Advocate Commissioner is entitled to videograph the counting
and election and declaration of the results, is interfered and
is set aside. The Advocate Commissioner is free to conduct
videography of the election process till the casting of votes by
protecting the secrecy of election.
With the above observation, this original petition is
disposed of.
Sd/BASANT BALAJI
JUDGE
JS
OPC 648/2025
-132025:KER:25679
APPENDIX OF OP(C) 648/2025
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
Exhibit P1
THE TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT DATED
31.7.2017 PASSED BY THE PRINCIPAL MUNSIFF-I,
KOZHIKODE
Exhibit P2
THE TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT IN
A.S.1/2017 DATED 21.12. 2017 PASSED BY THE
SUB COURT, KOZHIKODE
Exhibit P3
THE TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGEMENT DATED
17.8.2023 IN RSA NO. 111 OF 2018 PASSED BY
THE HON’BLE HIGH COURT
Exhibit P4
THE TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED 19.2.2024
PASSED BY THE HON’BLE SUPREME COURT
Exhibit P5
THE TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER IN I.A.17/2024
DATED 3.6.2024 PASSED BY THE PRINCIPAL
MUNSIFF’S COURT-I, KOZHIKODE
Exhibit P6
A TRUE COPY OF THE DRAFT NOTIFICATION
FILED BY THE ADVOCATE COMMISSIONER DATED
25.10.2024
Exhibit P7
A TRUE COPY OF THE OBJECTION FILED BY THE
RESPONDENTS HEREIN TO THE DRAFT
NOTIFICATION ON 05.11.2024
Exhibit P8
A TRUE COPY OF THE OBJECTION FILED BY THE
PETITIONERS HEREIN TO THE DRAFT
NOTIFICATION ON 06.11.2024
Exhibit P9
A TRUE COPY OF THE INTERIM ORDER OF THE
HON’BLE SUPREME COURT IN CIVIL APPEAL
NO(S). 3734-3735/2024 DATED 20.11.2024
Exhibit P10
A TRUE COPY OF THE INTERIM REPORT DATED
OPC 648/2025
-142025:KER:25679
13.12.2024 FILED BY THE ADVOCATE
COMMISSIONER ALONG WITH THE REVISED
DRAFT OF ELECTION NOTIFICATION
Exhibit P11
A TRUE COPY OF THE OBJECTIONS SUBMITTED
BY THE PETITIONER AGAINST THE
REVISED/MODIFIED DRAFT ELECTION
NOTIFICATION DATED 06.01.2025
Exhibit P12
A TRUE COPY OF THE IA NO. 34 OF 2025 IN O.S
NO. 667 OF 2010
Exhibit P13
A TRUE COPY OF THE COUNTER STATEMENT
FIELD BY DEFENDANTS IN IA 34/2025 IN O.S
667/2010 BEFORE THE MUNSIFF COURT DATED
13.01.2025
Exhibit P14
A TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER BY THE PRINCIPAL
MUNSIFF-1, KOZHIKODE DATED 12.02.2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review