Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CRIMINAL REVISIONAL JURISDICTION
Appellate Side
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Ajay Kumar Gupta
C.R.R. No. 4830 of 2023
Asit Gorai & Ors.
Versus
State of West Bengal & Anr.
For the Petitioners
:
Mr. Subhas Chandra Atha, Adv.
Ms. Payel Paramanik, Adv.
For the Opposite Party No. 2
:
Mr. Malay Bhattacharyya, Adv.
Ms. Arifa Sultana, Adv.
For the State
:
Mr. Kallol Mondal, Ld. PP
Mr. Krishnendu Bhattacharya, Adv.
Ms. Ananya Chakraborty, Adv.
Heard on
:
31.08.2026
Judgment on
:
22.09.2026
Uploaded on
:
22.09.2026
Ajay Kumar Gupta, J.:1.
The petitioners herein seek quashing of the proceeding being
G.R. Case No. 1094 of 2023 arising out of Bankura P.S. Case No.
of
dated
01.08.2023
under
Sections
323/326/307/120B/420/506/34 of the Indian Penal Code, now
pending before the Learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Bankura.
2.
The sum and substance of this case is that Opposite Party No.
2/complainant filed a complaint case before the Learned Chief
Judicial Magistrate, Bankura, being M.P. Case No. 64 of 2023
dated 28.07.2023 under Section 156(3) of the Cr.P.C, alleging
inter alia, to the effect that on 04.04.2023 at about 1.30 pm,
when she was constructing her pucca house by demolishing her
old dwelling mud house, the petitioners/accused persons
obstructed her, and when she resisted, they hurled filthy
languages towards her and her family members and threatened
to kill them. They further started throwing bricks towards her
and her family members from their rooftop. As a result, the
Opposite Party No. 2 was grievously injured on her head. She
had to go to the Bankura Sammilani Medical College & Hospital
for treatment.
3.
Owing to her being occupied in medical treatment and on
account of the refusal of the police station to register an FIR
against the petitioners, there was a delay in lodging the
complaint before the jurisdictional Magistrate. She filed the
aforesaid case praying for the said complaint to be treated as an
F.I.R.
4.
The police authority received the complaint from the learned
court with direction to register the FIR. The police authority on
01.08.2023 at about 16.15 hrs registered a case being Bankura
P.S. Case No. 265 of 2023 dated 01.08.2023 under Sections
323/326/307/120B/420/506/34 of the Indian Penal Code
against the accused persons.
5.
She had eventually also intimated the I.C. Bankura PS regarding
the rectification of the date of incident in the FIR, i.e., the correct
date of occurrence being 16th April, 2023 along with correct
residential address of the accused. The application to the I.C. for
the correction and investigation is available on the record.
6.
After culmination of investigation, the police authority submitted
a charge sheet being No. 284/2023 on 31.08.2023 against the
petitioners by omitting Sections 326/307 of IPC as those
sections were not substantiated by the materials collected during
investigation in this case.
7.
Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioners contended
that the instant proceedings have been maliciously initiated
against them by the opposite party no. 2/de facto complainant.
Petitioner No. 3 is a college student; on the date of the alleged
incident, she was in college. Petitioner No. 2 is a school teacher.
She was also in school on the date of the alleged incident, and
Petitioner No. 1 is the husband of Petitioner No. 2. None of them
were involved in any incident as alleged.
8.
Learned counsel placed reliance on a decision of the Supreme
Court in the case of Ranjit Singh Bath v. Union Territory
Chandigarh in Criminal Appeal no. 4313 of 2024 to support
his contention that order of the Learned Magistrate directing the
registration of the FIR against the petitioners was bereft of
following the correct procedure of law. In the said case, the
Learned Court held that before a complainant chooses to adopt a
remedy under section 156(3) of the Cr.P.C., he/she must
exhaust the remedies available under sections 154(1) and 154(3)
but that was not done prior to filing of the complaint and the
learned jurisdictional Magistrate did not consider the said facts
while allowing such complaint.
9.
It was further submitted that the whole allegation is false,
frivolous and concocted as well as based on untrue facts, arising
out of previous long-standing property disputes between the
parties. They have been falsely implicated in this case without
any involvement. It was submitted that no such incident took
place on 4th April, 2023 as alleged in the complaint.
It was
further submitted that the Learned Court, while directing
registration of the case against the petitioners, failed to consider
the averments of the complainant, and that the complaint itself
was filed after a considerable delay without any explanation for
the same. Therefore, the case has been filed only to harass the
petitioners and with an ulterior motive; as such, it should not be
permitted to continue; otherwise, it would amount to a gross
abuse of process of law, and to secure the ends of justice, the
case is liable to be quashed.
10. Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the Opposite Party No. 2,
on the other hand, vehemently opposed the prayer of the
petitioners and further submitted that the petitioners were
involved in the alleged incident.
They threw bricks from their
rooftop. The Opposite Party No. 2 sustained injuries on her
person and was treated in the hospital. Medical documents
support
the
prosecution
case;
therefore,
the
revisional
application is liable to be dismissed.
11. Learned counsel drew the attention of the court to the affidavit of
the application and submitted that the accused No. 1, being one
of the accused persons, has affirmed the affidavit of the
revisional application, even though he is not competent to do so,
under the provision of Section 4 of the Oath Act, 1969. He prays
for dismissal of the revisional application on such ground as
well, since the accused is debarred from affirming any affidavit in
view of the embargo as laid down under section 4(2) of the Oath
Act. He has relied on a judgment passed by the Single Bench of
this Court in the case of Sushanta Kumar Pal v. the State of
West Bengal & Anr. in CRR No. 2096 of 2010, particularly
paragraph 16, to support his aforesaid contention.
12. Learned advocates representing the State produced the Case
Diary and objected to the prayer of the learned counsel
appearing for the petitioner. It was submitted that the case was
registered against the present petitioners pursuant to the
direction of the learned Magistrate in an application filed under
Section 156 (3) of the Cr.P.C.
13. It was further submitted that during the investigation, sufficient
material was collected against the petitioners. The statements of
the witnesses were recorded. Medical documents were collected.
It clearly supports the prosecution case. A prima facie case has
been established against the Petitioners for the commission of
offence punishable under Sections 323/120B/420/506/34 of
the Indian Penal Code. Therefore, a full-fledged trial is required
to be conducted to unearth the truth and punish the real
culprits; as such, the revisional application is liable to be
dismissed.
14. In reply, the learned counsel representing the petitioners refuted
the contention of the opposite party no. 2 and further placed
reliance on a judgment passed by the Division Bench of this
court in the matter of Bonneswar Dutta & Ors.1 to bolster his
submission that the accused can affirm the affidavit, when no
other family member and/or tadbirkars have come forward.
15. Having heard the learned Counsels for the respective parties and
having gone through the materials on record, case diary and
memo of evidence, it appears that the allegations in the present
case disclose that the Opposite Party No. 2 was obstructed while
raising construction upon her own homestead, that she was
abused and threatened, and that bricks were hurled at her and
her family members from the rooftop of the petitioners, resulting
in an injury upon her head for which she was required to be
treated at the Bankura Sammilani Medical College & Hospital.
These averments, taken at their face value, plainly disclose the
ingredients of cognizable offences. The investigating agency,
upon completion of investigation, has recorded the statements of
1998 SCC Online Cal 13
witnesses and the medical documents relating to the injury
sustained by the Opposite Party No. 2 was collected, and has
submitted a charge sheet. The materials in the Case Diary,
particularly statements recorded under Section 161 and 164 of
the Cr.P.C., are sufficient to constitute a prima facie case against
the petitioners in respect of the offences for which the charge
sheet has been laid. The injury report also supports the case of
the prosecution. It is significant to note that the investigating
agency has not acted mechanically upon the complaint; Sections
326 and 307 of the Indian Penal Code were consciously omitted
from the charge sheet for want of supporting materials. The
investigation, therefore, bears the character of an application of
mind rather than a mechanical endorsement of the allegations of
the complainant’s allegations.
16. The petitioners' case is factually based on alibi, that Petitioner
No. 3 was attending her college and Petitioner No. 2 was
attending her school on the date of the alleged occurrence, and
that Petitioner No. 1 stands implicated by no reason other than
being the husband of Petitioner No. 2. Such a plea, however
meritorious it may be, is a matter of defense. A plea of alibi is
required to be established by evidence adduced before the trial
court, and its acceptance or rejection depends upon the
appreciation of such evidence in the context of the entire
prosecution case. This Court, in the exercise of its inherent
jurisdiction, cannot undertake that exercise on the strength of
documents annexed to a revisional application, which have
neither been proved nor tested. To do so would be to convert this
proceedings into a mini trial, which is impermissible.
17. As regards delay, the complaint itself sets out the explanation
that the Opposite Party No. 2 was occupied with her medical
treatment, and that the police station declined to register her
information. The explanation is neither inherently improbable
nor unsupported, having regard to the medical documents on
record. In any event, delay in setting the criminal law in motion
is a circumstance to be weighed by the Trial Court while
appreciating the evidence; it is not, by itself, a ground for
quashing
a
proceeding
which
otherwise
discloses
the
commission of an offence.
18. The discrepancy as to the date of occurrence in the complaint
reciting 04.04.2023 and the correct date being stated to be
16.04.2023, has been sought to be explained by the Opposite
Party No. 2 through her intimation to the Inspector-in-Charge,
Bankura Police Station on the date of registration of the FIR
itself, which forms part of the record. Whether the discrepancy is
the result of a bona fide error, and what effect it has upon the
credibility of the prosecution case, is essentially a matter of trial.
A variance of this nature, standing alone, does not render the
entire prosecution an abuse of the process of the Court.
19. The reliance placed by the learned counsel for the petitioners
upon Ranjit Singh Bath v. Union Territory, Chandigarh
(Supra) is misplaced on the facts of the present case. The
proposition contended for is that a complainant must exhaust
the remedies under Sections 154(1) and 154(3) of the Cr.P.C.
before invoking Section 156(3). That requirement, assuming it
applies in the terms contended, is satisfied upon the very
averments contained in the complaint, which record that the
Opposite Party No. 2 approached the police station and that
registration of her information was refused. The petitioners have
placed no material before this Court to displace that averment.
Further, and in any event, the complaint was forwarded by the
learned Chief Judicial Magistrate to the police authority upon an
application of mind; an FIR was registered, a full investigation
followed, and a charge sheet has been submitted, upon materials
independently gathered. At this distance, an alleged irregularity
at the pre-cognizance stage cannot be permitted to efface the
fruits of an investigation which has disclosed a prima facie case,
in the absence of any demonstrated failure of justice
20. It was faintly suggested that the learned Magistrate did not apply
his mind to the averments of the complainant while directing
registration of the case. Having perused the order and the
record, I find no substance in the contention. The order directing
registration of the FIR was passed upon a complaint which, on
its face, disclosed cognizable offences, and the direction was in
exercise of a power expressly conferred by Section 156(3) of the
Cr.P.C.
21. It is necessary to advert to the objection raised on behalf of the
Opposite Party No. 2 as to the competence of Petitioner No. 1, an
accused person, to affirm the affidavit in support of the
revisional application, and to the rival contentions advanced
upon the decisions in Sushanta Kumar Pal v. State of West
Bengal & Anr. (Supra), and Bonneswar Dutta & Ors.
22. A question arises before this Court, i.e., whether the accused can
affirm the affidavit of the application filed under Section 482 of
the Cr.P.C. and, if not, what would be the consequence.
23. This Court fairly accepts the view of the Division Bench, upon
perusal of judgments, that an accused should not be deprived of
affirming an affidavit since the accused cannot be held guilty
until proven. The Division Bench of this Court has extensively
explained the situation where the accused can affirm the
affidavit in criminal proceedings as well. This Court would like to
quote some paragraphs of the Judgment to understand the
situation as under:
“16. Provisions of Oaths Act do not and cannot apply in case of
filing an application under s. 438 of the Code. The Oaths Act
applies for giving evidence before any court including a criminal
court which has been explained by the Supreme Court
in Laxmipat Choraria's case (supra). Section 4(2) of the Oaths
Act, 1969 provides that ‘nothing in this section shall render it
lawful to administer, in a criminal proceeding, an oath or
affirmation to the accused person, unless he is examined as a
witness for the defence, or necessary to administer to the official
interpreter of any court, after he has entered on the execution of
the duties of his office, an oath or affirmation that he will
faithfully discharge those duties.
17. In Black's Law Dictionary ‘Lawful’ means legal, warranted
or authorised by the law; having the qualifications prescribed by
law; not contrary to nor forbidden by the law. The Oaths Act is
not applicable in case of filing an affidavit in support of an
application for Anticipatory Bail. Secondly, the question of
testimonial compulsion under Art. 20(3) of the Constitution does
not and cannot arise at all as it is well settled by a decision of
the Supreme Court in the case of Chhotan Prasad v. Hari
Prasad, reported in AIR 1977 SC 407 and in Sudha
Devi v. Narayan, AIR 1988 SC 1381 that an affidavit is not
evidence and accordingly it cannot be used as evidence in the
proceeding. Further when the Parliament in its wisdom has
provided that in order to file an application under s. 438 of the
Code the applicant has to apply himself and the court cannot
ignore such expression as the Parliament intended that such an
application has to be filed by the applicant in order to avail of
his remedy as he is the person who can only say before the
court that he has reasons to believe that he may be arrested. If
a contrary view is taken and if it is held that a middleman or
a tadbirkar can affirm an affidavit to an application for
Anticipatory Bail, in that event it would result in a countermischief which would be contrary to the spirit and object of the
Act. Belief must be of the applicant seeking for an anticipatory
bail. It is well settled principle that when a counter-mischief
would arise if remedy provided by the Act where construed
widely, the court may avoid or at least reduce it by limiting
remedy.
18. Paragraph
of
Francis
Bennion
on Statutory
Interpretation provides that ‘Parliament intends that the
enactment shall remedy a particular mischief. It is presumed
therefore that Parliament intends the Court, in construing the
enactment, to endeavour to apply the remedy provided by it in
such a way as to suppress that mischief’.
19. Paragraph 141 of that Book provides that ‘the court seeks to
avoid a construction that produces an absurd inappropriate,
unfitting or unreasonable result’.
20. Paragraph 154 of that Book provides that ‘where the
application of an enactment yields an adverse result (that is one
detrimental to the subject of the state), the interpretative factors
may on balance indicate that the court should curtail its
application. This is known as strict construction.
21. There could not be any restriction on any person's right to
move the court as right to judicial review is one of the basic
structures of the Constitution and even if a man is accused of an
offence excepting that he may be arrested and may be punished
that does not show that all of his fights are suspended. On the
contrary all of his rights remain intact and as it is.
22. In our view, if the system of tadbirkar filing application
under s. 488 of the Code of Criminal Procedure is allowed to
continue, that would be encouraging a system contrary to law
and that would encourage Toutism and Middlemanship in the
legal system and this system is bound to cause destruction to
the present judicial system. If middlemen have no stake
excepting that they are doing this for wrongful gain and the
possibility of such making wrongful gain is there and this is also
admitted by the members of the Bar before this Court that the
lawyers when moving an anticipatory bail could not get any
instruction for the applicant nor could they see the face of the
applicant. There may be cases where the applicant may stay in
a foreign country or in remote places of the country hiding
himself and mere sending a Vokalatnama and merely on the
basis of Vokalatnama sent by some means, the middlemen
and/or tadbirkars, who are nothing but touts, could not be
allowed to function and it does not require the exercise of any
skill and/or research that these persons are polluting the
system.
23. After bearing Mr. Balai Chandra Roy, Mr. Milan Kumar
Mukherjee and Mr. Kazi Safiullah learned Public Prosecutor and
other learned Advocates and after considering the various case
laws and the provisions of Art. 20(3) of the Constitution of India
and the provisions of the Oaths Act and the Criminal Procedure
Code we are clearly of the view that there is no bar for the
applicants to affirm an affidavit for filing an application under s.
438 of the Code of Criminal Procedure and that mere affirmation
of an affidavit in support of the application does not amount to
any testimonial compulsion and that the same also does not
come within the purview of the provisions of 4(2) of the Oaths
Act which is only confined to criminal proceedings; or in other
words in course of trial and not in course of the investigation. In
that view of the matter the tadbirkar or an agent cannot affirm
an affidavit in an application for Anticipatory Bail and in each
and every case the applicant has to affirm it either before the
Oath Commissioner of this Court or before any Magistrate who
is competent to administer an oath and in case of genuine
difficulty the same could be affirmed by an agent duly
authorised by the applicant in accordance with law as provided
in the Civil Procedure Code. We also hold that this Court and no
other Court in this State can entertain an application for
Anticipatory Bail if it is affirmed by a mere tadbirkar and no
such application can be entertained unless it is supported by an
affidavit by the applicant or by his duly authorised agent in
accordance with law and not by the tadbirkar or a middleman.
Since this practice, which in our view, is contrary to law is
continuing for a long time, we do not propose to reject such
applications which are in the list and pending before this Court
and that those cases can be taken up only after a supporting
affidavit is affirmed by the applicant or by the persons who are
duly authorised by the applicant in accordance with law within
two weeks from today.”
24. This Court is unable to be satisfied with the argument of the
Opposite Party No. 2 that the accused cannot affirm an affidavit
in a criminal revisional application because High Court rules
strictly mandate that any such application must be supported by
an affidavit of a person who has personal knowledge of the facts.
The purpose of filing an affidavit is to bind the accused on oath
regarding the authenticity of the information and for the purpose
of preventing the abuse of the court’s process. The purpose of
affirming an affidavit to applications like anticipatory bail,
applications seeking stay or interim order, condonation of delay,
transfer application under section 406 or 407 of the Cr.P.C. or
petition for quashing is to fulfil the procedural demand and same
does not tantamount to an incriminating statement. Therefore,
this fails to prove that the accused cannot affirm an affidavit in a
criminal revisional application; accordingly, the contentions of
the
learned
counsel
for
the
Opposite
Party
No.
are
unacceptable and the same is turned down.
25. Section 4(2) of the Oaths Act, 1968 prohibits administering an
oath or affirmation to an accused person in a criminal
proceeding since courts cannot force an accused person to take
an oath or make an affirmation during criminal trials unless they
choose to be examined as a witness for defence. An accused
person can take an oath only if they voluntarily step forward to
give evidence as a witness for their own defence, as its permits in
criminal law.
26. However, having regard to the material on record, namely the
complaint, the First Information Report, the charge sheet and
the Case Diary, which have already been discussed hereinabove,
this Court has found sufficient material to hold that a prima
facie case is disclosed against the petitioners and that the
revisional application is liable to be dismissed on that ground
alone. Even though the objection relating to the affirmation of
the affidavit is not upheld, it leads to the same conclusion in
favour of the Opposite Party No. 2.
27. Hence the revisional application fails. Consequently, CRR No.
4830 of 2023 is dismissed. Connected applications, if any, are
also, thus, disposed of.
28. The learned Trial Court shall proceed with the proceedings in
G.R. Case No. 1094 of 2023 arising out of Bankura P.S. Case No.
of
dated
01.08.2023
under
Sections
323/120B/420/506/34 of the Indian Penal Code, now pending
before the Learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Bankura, as
expeditiously as possible and in accordance with law.
29. Let a copy of this Judgment be sent to the Learned Trial Court
for information.
30. Case diary, if any, be returned to the learned counsel for the
State.
31. Interim order, if any, stands vacated.
32. All parties will act on the server copies of this Judgment
uploaded from the official website of this Court.
33. Urgent photostat certified copy of this Judgment, if applied for,
is to be given as expeditiously to the parties on compliance of all
legal formalities.
(Ajay Kumar Gupta, J.)
P.A.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review