Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:BHC-AUG:48968
*1*
revn173a23a207o25
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
BENCH AT AURANGABAD
CRIMINAL REVISION APPLICATION NO.173 OF 2023
Ashish Vinit Marwaha.
...Applicant/ accused No.2
-VERSUS1. The Central Bureau of Investigation.
2. The Union Bank of India.
...Respondent
WITH
CRIMINAL REVISION APPLICATION NO.207 OF 2025
Arvind Dilip Patil.
...Applicant/ accused No.5
-VERSUS1. The Central Bureau of Investigation.
2. The Union Bank of India.
...Respondent
…
Shri Abhaykumar D. Ostwal, for the applicants/ accused.
Shri Sachin S. Panale, standing counsel for respondent No.1/
CBI.
Shri Yogesh Bolkar, advocate h/f Shri A.A. Mishra, advocate for
respondent No.2.
…
CORAM : SUSHIL M. GHODESWAR, J.
Reserved on : 23 September 2026
Pronounced on : 13 October 2026
*2*
revn173a23a207o25
Per Court:1.
As the contentions of the parties are substantially
identical and the prosecution arises out of the same FIR, both
revision applications are being decided by this common
judgment.
2.
These two Criminal Revision Applications arise out
of Special Case (ACB/CBI) No.12 of 2015 pending before the
learned Additional Sessions Judge and Special Judge, Latur. The
applicant/ accused No.2 (Ashish Vineet Marwah) in Criminal
Revision Application No. 173/2023, challenges the order dated
05.01.2021 passed below Exhibit-259, whereby his application
for discharge under Section 227 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure came to be rejected. The applicant/ accused No.5
(Arvind Dilip Patil) in Criminal Revision Application No.207 of
2025, challenges the order dated 18.03.2025 passed below
Exhibit-376 in the same Special Case, rejecting his application
for discharge.
3.
Both the applicants seek discharge from prosecution
arising out of FIR No. RC-BSM 2014 E 0003 dated 25.03.2014,
*3*
revn173a23a207o25
registered with the CBI, BS&FC, Mumbai and culminated into
Special Case (ACB/CBI) No.12/2015 for the offences punishable
under Sections 120-B r/w 420, 468, 469, 471 of the Indian Penal
Code and Section 13(2) r/w Section 13(1)(d) of the Prevention of
Corruption Act, 1988. Special Case No.12/2015 is now
transferred from the learned Special Court, Latur to the learned
Special Court at Aurangabad and is registered as Special Case
No.565/2025.
4.
The prosecution case, in brief, is as under:(a)
The Union Bank of India and Bank of Maharashtra
had sanctioned term loan of Rs.33.53 crores and cash credit
facility of Rs.6.46 crores to M/s. Victoria Agro Food Processing
Private Limited (accused No.1) for construction of premises and
installation of food-processing unit. The applicants and other
accused persons were connected with the borrower company as
directors, guarantors or otherwise and that the loan facilities were
obtained on the strength of documents relating to the property
offered as security.
(b)
The registered mortgage deed dated 30.07.2009 was
executed before the Sub-Registrar, Shirur Anantpal, in favour of
*4*
revn173a23a207o25
the consortium of banks in respect of property bearing
Survey/Gat No.289/A, admeasuring about 1 hectare 61 R,
together with construction admeasuring about 28,740 square feet.
During proceedings initiated by the bank under the SARFAESI
Act, a certified copy of the mortgage deed was produced on
behalf of the borrower company and the guarantors, which
described the property as Survey No.5/A, admeasuring 740
square feet.
(c)
The bank thereafter obtained a certified copy from
the office of the Sub-Registrar on 07.07.2012 and, on comparing
the documents, allegedly found that pages 17 and 29 had been
tampered and substituted. The substitution of those pages showed
the property of substantially lesser value in place of the property
originally described in the mortgage deed, thereby affecting the
security of the banks.
(d)
It is, therefore, alleged that false or forged revenue
records and property documents were used in connection with
the valuation and mortgage; that the loan proceeds were diverted
through other entities; and that certain transactions were shown
as the borrower’s own contribution towards margin money,
*5*
though
the
funds
had
allegedly
revn173a23a207o25
originated
from
loan
disbursements.
(e)
The CBI registered the case on 25.03.2014 on the
basis of the complaint dated 20.03.2014 made by the Chief
Manager of the Union Bank of India. After investigation, the CBI
filed the charge-sheet and the case is culminated into Special
Case (ACB/CBI) No.12/2015 for the offences punishable under
Sections 120-B r/w 420, 468, 469, 471 of the Indian Penal Code
and Section 13(2) r/w Section 13(1)(d) of the Prevention of
Corruption Act, 1988.
5.
The applicants sought discharge contending, inter
alia, that they had no role in the alleged substitution of pages in
registered document kept in the custody of the Sub-Registrar.
The prosecution had not collected material showing an
agreement or meeting of minds to commit an illegal act and that
the ingredients of cheating, forgery and criminal conspiracy were
not made out. They contended that the dispute was essentially
financial. The borrower had settled the bank’s claim under the
One-Time Settlement and paid Rs.25.50 crores, and therefore,
the bank had confirmed that no amount remained due. They also
*6*
revn173a23a207o25
relied upon the delay in registration of the FIR and therefore,
contended that they have been falsely implicated.
6.
The learned Special Judge, by the impugned order
dated 05.01.2021 passed below Exhibit-259, rejected the
application for discharge filed by accused No.2. By a separate
order dated 18.03.2025 passed below Exhibit-376, the learned
Special Judge rejected the discharge application of accused No.5.
The applicants contend that the material on record does not
disclose sufficient ground to proceed against them and that the
respective orders are liable to be set aside in revisional
jurisdiction.
7.
The learned counsel for the applicants submitted that
the prosecution has not shown how the applicants could have
tampered with pages of the mortgage deed after its registration
and while the document was in the custody of the Sub-Registrar.
The mere fact that the applicant was associated with the
borrower company cannot be sufficient to infer that the applicant
is involved in any conspiracy. The statements relied upon by the
prosecution do not establish the applicants’ participation in the
alleged tampering and that no agreement between them and the
*7*
revn173a23a207o25
other accused to commit the alleged offences has been shown. In
the case of accused No.5, the allegations that he submitted
property documents to the valuer and accompanied the valuer
during the site visit are also required to be considered with the
other material, and do not by themselves establish guilt.
8.
The learned counsel for the applicants further
submitted that the bank’s claim had been settled under the OneTime Settlement and that the loan amount had been repaid. The
bank had also issued a letter for removal of its charge over the
property. According to the learned advocate, after settlement and
closure of the loan account, continuation of the criminal
prosecution would serve no useful purpose. It was also argued
that the FIR was lodged after considerable delay, that the
applicants had been falsely implicated, and that the prosecution
case does not disclose the necessary ingredients of Section 420
of the Indian Penal Code, particularly when the borrower
company continued to exist and function. The applicants,
therefore, prayed that the respective impugned orders be set aside
and that they be discharged.
9.
In support of above submissions, reliance is placed
*8*
revn173a23a207o25
on the judgments, namely, Union of India v. Prafulla Kumar
Samal, (1979) 3 SCC 4; Dilawar Balu Kurane v. State of
Maharashtra, (2002) 2 SCC 135; P. Vijayan v. State of Kerala,
(2010) 2 SCC 398; and Yogesh alias Sachin Jagdish Joshi v. State
of Maharashtra, (2008) 10 SCC 394, and it is contended that
where the material does not give rise to grave suspicion, the
accused ought to be discharged.
10.
Per contra, the learned counsel Shri Panale for the
CBI submitted that the prosecution case is not confined to the
default in repayment of the loan. The main allegation is that the
property described in the original mortgage deed was replaced in
later copies by a different property of substantially lesser value.
It was submitted that the bank’s certified copy and the copy
subsequently produced in the SARFAESI proceedings contain
material discrepancies in pages 17 and 29. The CBI relies upon
the statements of witnesses, the property and valuation
documents, the input form signed by accused Nos.2 and 5, and
the forensic material collected during investigation. It is argued
that these materials, when read together, disclose a prima facie
case of conspiracy, cheating and forgery.
*9*
11.
revn173a23a207o25
The learned counsel for the CBI further submitted
that accused No.5 had allegedly submitted property documents,
including property card dated 10.07.2009, to the valuer and had
accompanied the valuer during the site visit. The learned counsel
for the CBI relies upon the statements of the valuers and the bank
officials in this regard. As against accused No.2, the CBI relies
upon his position as Managing Director of the borrower company
and the documents concerning the loan and security, including
the input form containing the description of Survey No.289/A.
12.
The learned counsel for the CBI specifically
submitted that the loan funds were routed through fictitious
concerns and that amounts were deposited and returned to the
borrower’s account to give an impression that the margin money
had been contributed from the company’s own resources. The
learned counsel submitted that these allegations must be tested at
trial and cannot be rejected by conducting detailed appreciation
of evidence at the discharge stage.
13.
The learned counsel for the CBI further submitted
that repayment of the loan or settlement of the bank’s civil claim
does not wipe out criminal liability for offences allegedly
*10*
revn173a23a207o25
committed by the accused persons earlier. The prosecution has
material to show that the alleged acts formed part of concerted
plan and that the alleged substitution of pages of the mortgage
deed and use of documents said to be forged, give rise to grave
suspicion.
14.
In support of the above submissions, the learned
counsel for the CBI relied upon the judgments, namely, State of
Maharashtra through CBI v. Vikram Anantrai Doshi, (2014) 15
SCC 29; CBI v. Sarvodaya Highways, 2025 SCC OnLine SC
2589 (also reported as 2025 SCC OnLine SC 2589); State of
Gujarat v. Parbatbhai Aahir alias Parbatbhai Bhimsinhbhai
Karmur, (2017) 9 SCC 641; CBI v. Maninder Singh, (2016) 1
SCC 389; and Asim Sharif v. National Investigation Agency,
(2019) 7 SCC 148.
15.
The learned counsel for the CBI also relied upon the
judgment dated 05.03.2020 passed by this Court in Criminal Writ
Petition No.759 of 2019, whereby the challenge to rejection of
the discharge application of accused No.3 came to be dismissed.
Similar is the fate of the discharge application filed by accused
No.4 and this Court dismissed his Criminal Revision Application
*11*
revn173a23a207o25
No.4/2021 vide order dated 14.07.2022. This order dated
14.07.2022 was challenged by accused No.4 in SLP (Criminal)
No.7421/2022 and the Hon’ble Supreme Court also dismissed
the said SLP vide order dated 12.09.2022.
16.
The learned counsel for the CBI, therefore,
submitted that the material collected during investigation must be
considered as a whole and that the revision applications deserve
to be dismissed.
17.
The learned advocate appearing for the respondent/
Bank submits that in view of the facts and circumstances of this
case, appropriate orders may be passed.
18.
After hearing the learned counsel for the respective
sides and perusing with their assistance the record before this
Court, it is seen that so far as accused No.2 (Ashish Marwah) is
concerned, the CBI relies upon his position as Managing
Director of the borrower company and he is aware about the loan
and security documents, including the input form containing the
description of the property offered as security. The prosecution
has relied upon several documents and circumstances which
connect accused No.2 with the transaction. Therefore, whether
*12*
revn173a23a207o25
those documents and circumstances establish his knowledge or
participation, is a matter to be tested at trial.
19.
So far as accused No.5/ Arvind Dilip Patil is
concerned, the CBI specifically relies upon the statements of the
valuers and other witnesses to the effect that he submitted
property documents for valuation and accompanied the valuer
during the site visit. The prosecution also relies upon the
property documents and the valuation material said to have been
submitted to the bank. These allegations are disputed, and their
truth cannot be finally determined in these revision applications.
However, the material relied upon by the prosecution cannot be
brushed aside at the stage of discharge. Its evidentiary value and
the explanation of the applicant will have to be considered during
trial.
20.
The allegation of criminal conspiracy is required to
be considered from the cumulative effect of the circumstances
relied upon by the prosecution. At this stage, the Court is not
required to write the final finding that a conspiracy has been
proved. The question is whether the material collected during
investigation, taken at its face value, gives rise to grave suspicion
*13*
revn173a23a207o25
that the accused persons acted in concert in relation to the alleged
alteration of the mortgage deed and the securing or diversion of
the loan funds. The principles governing consideration of
discharge application, as explained in Union of India v. Prafulla
Kumar Samal and Dilawar Balu Kurane (supra), do not require
the Court to conduct a mini-trial or to finally assess the probative
value of each circumstance. On the material referred to above,
the prosecution case cannot be held to be groundless at this stage.
21.
The contention that the loan account was settled
under the One-Time Settlement also does not furnish a ground
for discharge. The settlement may have consequences in relation
to the bank’s recovery proceedings and civil liability. It does not,
by itself, erase the allegations of forgery, cheating or conspiracy
said to have been committed earlier. In State of Maharashtra
through CBI v. Vikram Anantrai Doshi, (2014) 15 SCC 29, the
Supreme Court explained that repayment to a financial institution
does not, by itself, justify termination of criminal proceedings
where the allegations disclose a larger public or societal impact.
In CBI v. Sarvodaya Highways, 2025 SCC OnLine SC 2589, the
Supreme Court considered the effect of settlement in the context
*14*
revn173a23a207o25
of allegations of fabricated documents and misrepresentation to a
bank.
22.
The decision of this Court dated 14.07.2022 in
Criminal Revision Application No.4 of 2021, Sambhaji s/o
Diliprao Patil v. Central Bureau of Investigation and another, is
also relevant. In that matter, accused No.4 challenged rejection of
his discharge application in the same Special Case. The revision
was dismissed after the Court found prima facie material
concerning the alleged substitution of pages of the mortgage
deed and held that repayment of the loan did not, by itself,
discharge criminal liability. It is brought to the notice of this
Court that the said order was challenged before the Supreme
Court in SLP (Criminal) No.7421 of 2022, which was dismissed
on 12.09.2022. The CBI also relied upon the judgment dated
05.03.2020 passed by this Court in Criminal Writ Petition
No.759 of 2019, Prajakta w/o Ashish Marwah v. Union of India
and CBI, concerning accused No.3. In that matter, the challenge
to the rejection of the discharge application was dismissed. The
Court considered, among other things, the allegations concerning
the differing versions of the mortgage deed, the alleged use of
*15*
revn173a23a207o25
forged property documents and the effect of the One-Time
Settlement.
23.
The contention regarding delay in registration of the
FIR and the allegation of false implication are matters which
may be urged and considered in the course of trial. On the
material presently relied upon by the prosecution, these
contentions do not negate the existence of the documentary
discrepancies and the other circumstances forming the basis of
the charge-sheet. It would not be proper, at this stage, to weigh
those circumstances finally or to decide whether the explanation
offered by the applicants is more probable than the prosecution
case.
24.
Having considered the material referred to in the
charge-sheet and the submissions advanced on behalf of both
sides, this Court is of the view that the prosecution material gives
rise to grave suspicion and discloses sufficient ground for
proceeding against the applicants. At this stage, the Court is not
expected to conduct a meticulous appreciation of the evidence or
to determine whether the prosecution will ultimately succeed.
The applicants have not made out a case for discharge warranting
*16*
revn173a23a207o25
interference in revisional jurisdiction under Sections 397 and 401
of the Code of Criminal Procedure. Hence, the following order:ORDER
(a)
Both Criminal Revision Applications are dismissed.
(b)
Pending applications, if any, stand disposed of.
(c)
The observations made in this order are confined to
the adjudication of the present revision applications and the Trial
Court shall not be influenced by the same while conducting the
trial.
(SUSHIL M. GHODESWAR, J.)
25.
After pronouncement of this judgment, the learned
Advocate Mr. Ostwal for the Applicants prays for staying the
effect and operation of this judgment.
26.
The learned Standing Counsel for Respondent
No.1/CBI, however, opposes this prayer.
27.
Since stay has been operating in this application
since 2023, I am inclined to grant stay to the effect and operation
of this judgment for two weeks only.
Accordingly, stay is
granted for two weeks only.
kps
(SUSHIL M. GHODESWAR, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review