The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
22. 07.2017, it is mentioned therein that selection of OT Tech would be for CHC Billawar and applications from only the concerned block shall be entertained. In the advertisement notice, it is not specified whether the word ‘Block’ mentioned therein refers to ‘Medical Block’ or ‘Revenue Block, though in the same advertisement notice, in respect of posts of FMPHW, it is indicated that application forms from only the concerned medical block shall be entertained. The word ‘Medical Block’ is missing in the case of the posts of OT Tech for CHC Billawar. 10) The contention of the petitioner is that because word ‘Medical Block’ is missing in case of the post of OT Tech, therefore, it has to be inferred that the word ‘Block’ has reference to ‘Revenue Block’ and not ‘Medical Block’. On the other hand, learned counsel for the respondents has contended that whole selection has been made by taking the ‘Medical Block’ as the basis, therefore, even in the absence of specific mention of ‘Medical Block’ in respect of post of OT Tech, it has to be presumed that the selection was to be made on the basis of ‘Medical Block’. 11) The post of OT Tech, which is subject matter of the present writ petition, was to be filled up in terms of the guidelines of National Health Mission. clarification regarding “local criteria” As per the for hiring of contractual staff under the said scheme as contained in commu…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU &KASHMIR AND LADAKHAT
JAMMU
Reserved on: 11.02.2026
Pronounced on: 20.02.2026
Uploaded on: 20.02.2026
Whether the operative
part or full judgment is
pronounced:Full
SWP No. 1927/2018
Ashish Paul Khajuria
...PETITIONER(S)
Through: -
Mr. Ajay Bakshi, Advocate.
Vs.
State of J&K & ors
Through: -
…RESPONDENT(S)
Mr. Raman Sharma, AAG with
Ms. Saliqa Sheikh, Advocate.
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY DHAR, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1)
The petitioner through the medium of the present
petition has challenged order dated 01.06.2018 passed by
respondent No. 2 whereby appeal/representation of the
petitioner against the appointment of private respondent
No. 5 to the post of OT Tech on contractual basis has been
rejected. Challenge has also been thrown to selection and
appointment of private respondent No. 5 against the post
of OT Tech in CHC Billawar under National Health Mission
pursuant to Advertisement Notice dated 22.07.2017 with a
direction upon the official respondents to consider, select
and appoint the petitioner in his place.
SWP No.1927/2018
2)
Briefly stated the facts giving rise to filing of this writ
petition, are that vide advertisement notice No. 4 of 201718 dated 22.07.2017 respondent No. 3 invited applications
inter alia for the post of OT Tech on contractual basis for
the year 2017-2018. Both the petitioner as well as private
respondent No. 5 being eligible responded to the said
advertisement notice.
After undertaking the selection
process, respondent No. 3 issued provisional select list
vide notification dated 17.02.2018.
As per the said
provisional select list, name of private respondent No. 5
figured as selected candidate whereas, name of the
petitioner figured in the wait list.
3)
The petitioner challenged the selection list vide writ
petition bearing No. SWP no. 309/2018 contending
therein that as per the advertisement notice only the
candidates hailing from Block Billawar could have applied
for the post of OT Tech but private respondent No. 5, who
belongs to Block Nagrota Gujroo being ineligible, could not
have
been
selected.
This
Court
vide
order
dated
27.02.2018 at the threshold itself disposed of the writ
petition directing respondent No. 2–Chairman Health
Society, Kathua to consider the memorandum/revision/
appeal that may be filed by the petitioner and pass an
appropriate order after hearing the affected parties.
SWP No.1927/2018
4)
Pursuant to the aforesaid directions of this Court,
the petitioner submitted a revision/appeal/memorandum
before respondent No. 2.
Vide impugned order dated
01.06.2018,
No.
respondent
has
rejected
the
appeal/revision/memorandum of the petitioner.
5)
The petitioner has challenged the impugned order
passed by respondent No. 2 and also the appointment of
private respondent No. 5 as OT Tech in CHC Billawar on
the ground that the said respondent does not belong to
Block Billawar, as such, he was not eligible to participate
in the selection process.
It has been contended that
respondent No. 2 while passing the impugned order has
not appreciated this contention of the petitioner even
though he had placed on record documents to show that
the village wherein private respondent No. 5 resides falls
in block Nagrota Gujroo and not in Block Billawar. It has
been further contended that in the Advertisement Notice
dated 22.07.2017, it is clearly indicated that only the
applicants from the concerned block are eligible to apply,
as such private respondent No. 5 could not have been
selected.
6)
The official respondents have contested the writ
petition by filing their reply. So far as factual aspects of
the case are concerned, they have not disputed the same.
SWP No.1927/2018
The stand taken by the official respondents is that private
respondent No. 5 is more meritorious than the petitioner
and that selection was made from amongst the candidates
belonging to ‘Medical Block’ and not ‘Revenue Block’. It
has been contended that both petitioner as well as
respondent No. 5 are residents of medical block Billawar,
therefore, it cannot be stated that private respondent No.
5 was ineligible to participate in the selection process.
7)
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and
perused record of the case.
8)
As already stated, the factual aspects of the case are
not in dispute.
It is also not in dispute that during
selection process, private respondent No. 5 had secured
higher merit than that of the petitioner. The only issue
that is required to be determined is as to whether
selection was to be made on the basis of ‘Revenue Block’
or ‘Medical Block’.
9)
If we have a look at the Advertisement Notice dated
22.07.2017, it is mentioned therein that selection of OT
Tech would be for CHC Billawar and applications from
only the concerned block shall be entertained.
In the
advertisement notice, it is not specified whether the word
‘Block’ mentioned therein refers to ‘Medical Block’ or
SWP No.1927/2018
‘Revenue Block, though in the same advertisement
notice, in respect of posts of FMPHW, it is indicated that
application forms from only the concerned medical block
shall be entertained. The word ‘Medical Block’ is missing
in the case of the posts of OT Tech for CHC Billawar.
10)
The contention of the petitioner is that because word
‘Medical Block’ is missing in case of the post of OT Tech,
therefore, it has to be inferred that the word ‘Block’ has
reference to ‘Revenue Block’ and not ‘Medical Block’.
On the other hand, learned counsel for the respondents
has contended that whole selection has been made by
taking the ‘Medical Block’ as the basis, therefore, even in
the absence of specific mention of ‘Medical Block’ in
respect of post of OT Tech, it has to be presumed that the
selection was to be made on the basis of ‘Medical Block’.
11)
The post of OT Tech, which is subject matter of the
present writ petition, was to be filled up in terms of the
guidelines of National Health Mission.
clarification
regarding
“local
criteria”
As per the
for
hiring
of
contractual staff under the said scheme as contained in
communication dated 11.09.2013, a copy whereof has
been placed on record by the learned counsel for the
respondents, it has been provided that for all categories of
medical staff, the candidates residing within the villages
SWP No.1927/2018
catered by respective health institutions are to be
preferred subject to their availability and merit. In the said
communication it has been clarified that if a particular
health institution is catering one
village, then the
candidates of that very village are to be preferred but in
case a particular health institution is catering two or three
villages then the candidates of all those villages are to be
preferred.
From this it can be inferred that basis for
giving preference to local candidates has reference to the
area, which is being catered by the health institution for
which selection is to be made.
12)
In the present case, the post of OT Tech was
advertised for CHC Billawar. The said health institution
caters to the residents of medical block Billawar. Thus, all
the eligible candidates of medical block, Billawar had to be
considered for the said post. The emphasis of the scheme
is upon hiring of manpower from the area which is being
catered by the health institution for which the post is
advertised. Therefore, the residence of the candidates in
an area falling under a particular revenue block or tehsil
or district is not determinative of selection criteria. Only
the residents of the area that is being catered by the
concerned health institution would be eligible for selection
relating to the posts for said health institution.
SWP No.1927/2018
13)
In view of the above position, the respondents in
considering the petitioner and private respondent No. 5,
both of whom reside in Medical Block, Billawar for
selection to the post of OT Tech for CHC Billawar have
rightly taken the ‘Medical Block’ as the basis of selection.
Once private respondent No. 5 was found to be more
meritorious than the petitioner, he could not have been
denied appointment even though he may be a resident of
the revenue block Billawar.
14)
Apart from the above, even if it is assumed that there
is an ambiguity in the advertisement notice as to whether
the basis for selection is a ‘Revenue Block’ or a ‘Medical
Block’,
the
action
of
the
official
respondents
in
interpreting the local criteria as ‘Medical Block’ instead of
‘Revenue Block’ cannot be interfered with by this Court
in the facts and circumstances of the case.
This is so
because the respondents have selected more meritorious
candidate, as such, it cannot not be stated that they had
any oblique motive in selecting private respondent No. 5
so as to given undue benefit to a less deserving candidate.
15)
There is yet another reason for upholding the
appointment of respondent No. 5. He has been appointed
to the post of OT Tech in the year 2018 and his
appointment has not been stayed by this Court. The same
SWP No.1927/2018
has been made subject to outcome of this petition.
Therefore, respondent No. 5 has been working as OT Tech
for the last more than seven years.
It would be highly
inequitable to disturb his appointment at this stage after a
lapse of more than seven years.
16)
For what has been discussed hereinbefore, I do not
find any ground to interfere with the impugned order
passed by respondent No. 2 nor do I find any reason to
quash
the
selection
and
appointment
of
private
respondent No. 5.
17)
The writ petition lacks merit and is, accordingly
dismissed.
(Sanjay Dhar)
Judge
JAMMU
20.02.2026
NARESH/SECY
Whether the order is speaking:
Whether the order is reportable:
Naresh Kumar
2026.02.05 05:01
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
SWP No.1927/2018
Yes
No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review