Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
14.09.2026
Ct. No.655
Sl. No. 73
CO 4483 of 2025
Subadip
Ashish Kumar Chowdhury
Vs.
Nabin Kumar Lall & Ors.
Mrs. Shohini Chakrabarty,
Ms. Prajaaini Das.
…for the petitioner
Mr. Dinendra Nath Chatterjee,
Mr. Santanu Mondal,
Mr. Subhas Chandra Saha,
Mr. Soumitra Chatterjee.
…for the O.P. Nos. 1 & 2.
1.
The instant civil revisional application has been
preferred under Article 227 of the Constitution of India,
at the instance of the defendant No. 3/petitioner,
challenging the legality and propriety of the impugned
order dated 14th November, 2025 (Order No. 44)
passed by the learned Trial Court in connection with
Title Suit No. 805 of 2022, whereby the application
filed by the plaintiffs under Order VI Rule 17 read with
Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure seeking
amendment of the plaint was allowed.
2.
Being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the
aforesaid order, the present revisional application has
been preferred by the petitioner, principally contending
that the amendment sought for by the plaintiffs would
have the effect of materially altering the nature and
CO 4483 of 2025
character of the suit and would also permit the
plaintiffs to depart from the case originally pleaded by
the predecessor-in-interest.
3.
The suit was originally instituted by one Gouri
Prasad Lall, since deceased, who was the predecessorin-interest of the present opposite parties Nos. 1 and
2, seeking, inter alia, a decree for declaration and
permanent injunction in respect of the suit property.
During the pendency of the suit, the original plaintiff
expired
and,
upon
his
death,
his
heirs/legal
representatives were duly substituted in his place and
stead.
4.
It is the case of the plaintiffs that, after
substitution, a new learned Advocate was engaged on
their behalf and, upon a fresh scrutiny of the plaint,
certain mistakes and inaccuracies in the description of
the
case
property
and
pleadings
were
noticed.
According to the plaintiffs, the original plaintiff was not
an educated person and, owing to his inability to
properly apprise his learned Advocate of all the
relevant facts, certain errors had inadvertently crept
into the plaint at the time of its original drafting. It is
further contended that such mistakes came to light
only after the substituted heirs engaged a new learned
Advocate, who, upon examining the pleadings and
other materials, advised that the necessary corrections
ought to be incorporated in the plaint.
CO 4483 of 2025
5.
For the aforesaid reason, an application under
Order VI Rule 17 read with Section 151 of the Code
was filed on behalf of the plaintiffs seeking amendment
of
the
plaint.
The
learned
Trial
Court,
upon
consideration of the application, allowed the same by
passing the impugned order dated 14th November,
2025.
6.
Mrs. Shohini Chakraborty, learned Advocate
appearing for the defendant No. 3/petitioner has
strongly opposed the order of amendment. It is
submitted that the proposed amendment is not merely
a correction of an accidental or formal error but would
substantially alter the pleadings originally made by the
plaintiff and, consequently, would change the nature
and character of the suit.
7.
It is further submitted that, during pendency of
the suit, the learned Trial Court had already passed an
order for inspection of the suit property. Pursuant to
such order, the property was inspected by the learned
Advocate Commissioner in presence of the parties and
an inspection report was thereafter submitted before
the learned Trial Court. According to the petitioner, at
the time of such inspection, the suit property was duly
identified by the parties.
8.
It
inspection
is,
therefore,
had
already
contended
been
that,
after
the
conducted
and
the
Advocate Commissioner had submitted his report, the
plaintiffs cannot now be permitted, under the guise of
CO 4483 of 2025
an application for amendment, to alter the description
or identity of the suit property. According to the
petitioner, such an amendment would not amount to a
mere correction of a drafting mistake but would
effectively enable the plaintiffs to introduce a different
factual foundation in support of their claim.
9.
Mrs.
Chakraborty,
learned
Advocate
further
submits that the plaintiffs are attempting to change the
facts
pleaded
in
the
original
plaint
by
way
of
amendment and, in substance, are seeking to resile
from the position already taken by the original plaintiff.
It is argued that the plaintiffs, being the successors-ininterest of the original plaintiff, cannot be permitted to
withdraw
or
dilute
an
admission
made
by
their
predecessor during the pendency of the suit merely
because a new learned Advocate has subsequently
taken a different view of the pleadings.
10. Another submission advanced on behalf of the
petitioner is that, during the lifetime of the original
plaintiff, no attempt whatsoever was made to correct
the alleged mistakes in the description of the suit
property. The necessity for correction was raised only
subsequently, and particularly after the inspection of
the property had been completed and the report of the
Advocate Commissioner had been submitted. According
to the petitioner, the timing of the amendment
application is itself significant and indicates that the
proposed amendment is intended to overcome the
CO 4483 of 2025
consequences of the inspection report rather than to
rectify any bona fide clerical or inadvertent mistake.
11. Per contra, Mr. S.C. Saha, learned Advocate
appearing for the opposite parties/plaintiffs submits
that the learned Trial Court committed no error in
allowing
the
application
for
amendment.
It
is
contended that the amendment was sought essentially
for the purpose of bringing the pleadings in conformity
with the facts which, according to the plaintiffs, were
intended to be pleaded from the inception but could
not be correctly incorporated owing to an inadvertent
mistake in drafting the plaint.
12. It is further submitted that the original plaintiff
has since died and his heirs/legal representatives have
been substituted. After their substitution, a new
learned Advocate examined the pleadings and noticed
the
mistakes
which
required
rectification.
The
application was, therefore, filed bona fide and not with
any intention to introduce an entirely new cause of
action.
13. Mr. Saha, learned Advocate also submits that
the learned Trial Court, while allowing the amendment,
has
adequately
defendants
by
protected
granting
the
them
interest
liberty
to
of
the
file
an
additional written statement in answer to the amended
pleadings. Thus, no prejudice has actually been caused
to the defendants. The defendants would have full
opportunity to traverse the amended pleadings, raise
CO 4483 of 2025
all permissible objections and adduce evidence in
support of their case.
14. It is accordingly argued that the order passed by
the learned Trial Court is discretionary in nature and
does not suffer from any jurisdictional error, illegality
or material irregularity warranting interference by this
Court in exercise of its supervisory jurisdiction under
Article 227 of the Constitution of India.
15. I
have
considered
the
rival
submissions
advanced on behalf of the parties and have perused
the materials placed before this Court.
16. There is no dispute that the suit was originally
instituted by Gouri Prasad Lall, who subsequently died
during pendency of the proceeding, whereupon his
heirs/legal representatives were brought on record.
The explanation furnished by the plaintiffs for seeking
amendment is that, after their substitution, a newly
engaged learned Advocate scrutinised the plaint and
detected certain mistakes in the pleadings which,
according to the plaintiffs, required rectification.
17. It is well settled that the object of permitting
amendment of pleadings is to enable the Court to
effectively and completely adjudicate upon the real
controversy
between
the
parties
and
to
avoid
multiplicity of proceedings. At the same time, an
amendment
cannot
ordinarily
be
permitted
if
it
introduces an entirely new and inconsistent case,
changes the fundamental nature of the suit, or causes
CO 4483 of 2025
prejudice
to
the
opposite
party
which
cannot
adequately be compensated or remedied.
18. In the present case, however, the learned Trial
Court, upon considering the materials, has exercised
its discretion in favour of allowing the amendment.
Significantly, the plaintiffs have asserted that the
proposed amendment is intended to correct mistakes
in the plaint and to bring certain facts on record.
Whether such amendment ultimately results in a
material alteration of the identity or description of the
suit property, whether it constitutes a departure from
the original case, and whether any statement made in
the original plaint amounts to an admission binding
upon the plaintiffs are matters which can appropriately
be
examined
by
the
learned
Trial
Court
upon
appreciation of the pleadings and evidence.
19. The objection raised by the petitioner regarding
the earlier inspection of the suit property and the
Commissioner's report also cannot, at this stage, by
itself furnish sufficient ground for interfering with the
order of amendment. The fact that an inspection has
already taken place may undoubtedly be a relevant
circumstance
evidentiary
while
value
considering
of
the
the
proposed
effect
and
amendment.
However, whether the amended description is in fact
inconsistent with the property already identified during
inspection, or whether the amendment merely seeks to
correct an erroneous description without altering the
CO 4483 of 2025
identity of the property, is essentially a matter to be
determined by the learned Trial Court on the basis of
the entire evidence and materials available before it.
20. It is equally significant that, by allowing the
amendment, the learned Trial Court has not finally
adjudicated upon the correctness of the amended
pleadings. An amendment of the plaint merely permits
the amended case to form part of the pleadings. The
truth or otherwise of the facts incorporated by way of
amendment remains open for determination at the
trial. The defendants shall be entitled to contest the
amended pleadings, raise all appropriate objections
and lead evidence in support of their respective cases.
21. In this connection, another important aspect is
that the learned Trial Court has granted the defendants
an opportunity to file an additional written statement.
Thus, the defendants have not been deprived of their
right to meet the amended case. They will have
adequate opportunity to explain their position and
challenge the factual assertions made by the plaintiffs.
22. It is also relevant to note that the evidence in
the suit has not yet commenced. Therefore, the stage
of the proceeding is such that the parties will still have
full opportunity to adduce oral and documentary
evidence in support of their respective cases. Any
controversy regarding the effect of the amendment,
the identity and description of the suit property, the
alleged admission of the original plaintiff, or the
CO 4483 of 2025
evidentiary significance of the Commissioner's report
can accordingly be considered by the learned Trial
Court at the appropriate stage.
23. This Court, while exercising jurisdiction under
Article 227 of the Constitution of India, exercises a
supervisory jurisdiction over subordinate Courts and
Tribunals. Such jurisdiction is intended to ensure that
the subordinate Court acts within the bounds of its
jurisdiction and follows the settled principles of law. It
is not intended to substitute the view of the High Court
for a possible or permissible view taken by the learned
Trial Court.
24. Interference under Article 227 is warranted
where
the
subordinate
Court
has
acted
without
jurisdiction, exceeded its jurisdiction, failed to exercise
jurisdiction vested in it, or where the impugned order
suffers from patent illegality, perversity or material
irregularity
resulting
in
manifest
injustice.
The
supervisory jurisdiction is not ordinarily exercised
merely because another view on the facts or on the
exercise of discretion may also be possible.
25. In the present case, the learned Trial Court had
jurisdiction to consider the application under Order VI
Rule 17 of the Code. After considering the application,
it exercised its discretion to permit the amendment
and, at the same time, afforded the defendants an
opportunity to file an additional written statement.
CO 4483 of 2025
26. Whether the amended pleadings are ultimately
proved, whether the plaintiffs are entitled to rely upon
the
amended
description,
whether
there
was
an
admission in the original plaint and, if so, what would
be its legal effect, and whether the amended case is
consistent with the inspection report are all matters
which may properly be adjudicated by the learned Trial
Court
after
the
parties
adduce
their
respective
evidence. At this interlocutory stage, it would neither
be appropriate nor permissible for this Court, in
exercise of its limited supervisory jurisdiction, to
undertake a final adjudication on those disputed
questions.
27. Upon consideration of the impugned order and
the materials placed before this Court, I find no patent
illegality, jurisdictional error or material irregularity in
the exercise of discretion by the learned Trial Court in
allowing the application for amendment under Order VI
Rule 17 of the Code. The apprehension expressed by
the petitioner regarding the ultimate effect of the
amendment can adequately be addressed during the
trial, particularly when the defendants have been
granted liberty to file an additional written statement
and will have full opportunity to adduce evidence.
28. In such circumstances, this Court finds no
compelling ground to interfere with the impugned order
in exercise of its supervisory jurisdiction under Article
227 of the Constitution of India.
CO 4483 of 2025
29. Accordingly, the impugned order dated 14th
November, 2025 (Order No. 44) passed by the learned
Trial Court in Title Suit No. 805 of 2022 is not
interfered with.
30. The learned Trial Court is directed to proceed
with the suit expeditiously and make all endeavour to
dispose of the same as early as practicable, without
granting unnecessary adjournments to either of the
parties, subject, however, to the normal procedure of
law.
31. Accordingly, C.O. No. 4483 of 2025 stands
dismissed.
32. There shall be no order as to costs.
33. Let a copy of this order be sent to the learned
Trial Court forthwith for information and necessary
action.
34. Urgent Photostat certified copy of this order, if
applied for, be given to the parties on payment of
requisite fees.
(Prasenjit Biswas, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review