Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
(Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction)
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Krishna Rao
W.P.A. No. 28623 of 2024
Biswanath Chakraborty & Ors.
-VersusThe State of West Bengal & Ors.
With
W.P.A. No. 28619 of 2024
Soumen Das & Anr.
-VersusThe State of West Bengal & Ors.
With
W.P.A. No. 28636 of 2024
Ashis Mondal
-VersusThe State of West Bengal & Ors.
Mr. Sudipta Dasgupta
Mr. Baibhav Roy
....For the petitioners.
Mr. Amit Gupta, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Biman Halder
Ms. Bineeta Bhattacharya
Mr. Shibasish Banerjee
….For the State.
Mr. Soumya Roy Chowdhury
Mr. Sujit Sankar Koley
....For the DPL.
Hearing Concluded On : 21.04.2026
Judgment on
: 30.04.2026
Krishna Rao, J.:
1.
The petitioners have filed the present writ petitions challenging the
order No. DPL/GM (HR&A) 2022/471 dated 27th December, 2022, order
No. DPL/GM (HR&A) 2023/13 dated 10th January, 2023 and order No.
DPL/GM (HR&A) 2023/17 dated 10th January, 2023 with regard to
their posting on deputation to the office of the District Controller – Food
and Supplies, Purba Bardhaman, Khadya Bhavan, Bardhaman, West
Bengal from Durgapur Projects Limited (hereinafter referred to as
“DPL”), Durgapur.
2.
The issue raised by the petitioners in their respective Writ Petitions that
as per the Standing Orders of the Durgapur Projects Limited, the
Workman of the DPL may be transferred from one department to
another department of the Company but there is no provision of
transfer or to posted on deputation from one organization to another
organization of the Government.
3.
The petitioners were appointed either by way of compassionate ground
or by way of direct recruitment in different Class IV (Tech) posts at
Durgapur Projects Limited in different dates since 1994 to 2012.
4.
By an order dated 27th December, 2022, as per the decision of the State
Level Committee on Rationalization and Optimal Utilization of Human
Resources, 102 employees including the petitioners herein posted at
Durgapur Projects Limited, Durgapur, were placed on deputation to the
Office of the District Controller - Food and Supplies, Purba Bardhaman,
Khadya Bhavan.
5.
The contentions of the petitioners are that the service conditions of the
petitioners are governed by the Standing Orders of the Durgapur
Projects Limited and as per Clause 10 of the Standing Orders, the
workman cannot be transferred on deputation from Durgapur Projects
Limited to other Department of Government of West Bengal but in the
present case, the petitioners have been posted in deputation in the
Office of the District Controller - Food and Supplies, Purba Bardhaman,
Khadya Bhavan from Durgapur Projects Limited.
6.
The respondent nos. 2 to 5 first raised an objection with regard to the
maintainability of the writ petitions on the ground that the impugned
orders were passed on 27th December, 2022 and 10th January, 2023
respectively and in terms of the orders, the petitioners have joined their
duties in the office of the District Controller- Food and Supplies, Purba
Bardhaman without any protest or objection and after two years of
joining, the petitioners have filed the present writ petitions. In support
of his submission, he has relied upon the judgment in the case of Kavi
Raj and Others Vs. State of Jammu and Kashmir & Ors. reported
in (2013) 3 SCC 526 and submits that consent of posting (or transfer)
beyond the cadre (or parent department) is inferable from the conduct
of the employee, who does not protest or contest such posting or
transfer.
7.
Mr. Soumya Roy Chowdhury, Learned Advocate representing the
Durgapur
Projects
Limited
submits
that
the
petitioners
have
suppressed the fact that after issuance of the impugned order, the
petitioners have without any protest reported their duty at their new
place of posting and are drawing their salary continuously. He submits
that the petitioners have not come before this Court with clean hand.
He has relied upon the judgment in the case of Auroville Foundation
Vs. Natasha Storey reported in 2025 SCC OnLine SC 556.
8.
Mr. Roy Chowdhury submits that altogether 332 employees have been
posted on deputation but only the petitioners have challenged the
impugned order after two years, even after joining the duties without
any protest only with the intention to frustrate the entire scheme of the
Company.
9.
Mr. Roy Chowdhury submits that the Company has been running
through financial crisis for the last few decades. Presently in a
moribund condition and there is no work in the Company and there is
no scope for further development of the Company. The Company is not
in a position to bear further burden of the employees. He submits that
the Coke Oven Group of Plants under the Durgapur Projects Limited
was closed in the year 2015 due to the lack of orders and business on
account of severe recession in the industries wherein it used to supply
its products along with major environmental pollution issues and
became inoperative since July, 2015. The other three power plants were
also closed as a result of excess manpower become a huge financial
burden of the Company.
10. Mr. Roy Chowdhury submits that due to such excess manpower
(employees) of the Durgapur Projects Limited, the Board of Directors
approved a policy of deployment its employees on different government
organization on deputation keeping in view of the manpower study, the
total sanctioned manpower is 892 whereas at the material point of
deployment on deputation the total manpower/ employees were 1594,
which excludes the employees already placed in deemed to be in
deputation under WBSEDCL/WBSETCL.
11. Mr. Roy Chowdhury submits that considering the financial unbearable
burden of the Company, the excess 332 employees of the DPL were
redeployed to the offices of the Government of West Bengal in terms of
the order of the Additional Chief Secretary, Government of West Bengal,
Department of Power dated 22nd December, 2022, following the
resolution of the Government of West Bengal, Finance Department,
Audit Branch dated 17th June, 2014, as well as the Notification dated
26th December, 2018 of the Government of West Bengal, Department of
Power and Non-Conventional Energy Resources.
12. As per decision of the State Level Committee of Rationalization and
Optimal
Utilization
of
Human
Resources,
under
the
Finance
Department, Government of West Bengal and subsequent order issued
by the Power Department, 102 employees posted at Durgapur Projects
Limited have been placed on deputation to the Office of the District
Controller - Food and Supplies, Purba Bardhaman Khadya Bhavan.
13. The issue raised by the petitioners in their respective petitions that as
per Standing Orders, the Workman may be transferred from one
department to another department of the Company but there is no
provision of transfer or deputation to other organization.
14. Clause 10 of the Standing Orders reads as follows:
“10. Transfer
A workman may be transferred from one shift to
another, or from one section to another, or from one
department to another, or from one job to another,
or from one place of work to another, or from one
establishment to another of the Company.
In the event of such transfer, the Workman’s total
emoluments or his basic conditions of service will
not be adversely affected. The workman will be
subjected to all other terms and conditions of
service as are applicable to the place/ section/
department/
job/
shift/
Division/Unit/
Establishment of which he is transferred.”
15. The impugned orders dated 27th December, 2022 and 10th January,
2023, contains the following terms and conditions:
“1. They will retain their pay in their existing
capacity in the scale they are currently enjoying in
DPL with deputation allowance, if applicable as per
rules of DPL.
2. During the deputation period, they shall be
guided by the rules of DPL as well as rules of
borrowing authority.
3. They may be entitled for promotion if otherwise
eligible during deputation service as per rules.
4. They will continue to enjoy the medical facilities
from DPL while on deputation.
5. Salary will be paid by DPL on the basis of
Attendance certified by Department where the
employees have been deputed and demand
will be placed by MD, DPL for disbursement of
the amount to DPL on monthly basis as per
the guidelines of the order from the Power
Dept., Govt of West Bengal.
6. They shall be covered under CPF regulation as
per rules applicable to them.”
16. The Durgapur Projects Limited with the consultation of the Government
of State of West Bengal has taken a decision to place 332 employees of
DPL on deputation on the ground that due to the closure of Coke Oven
Group of Plants under DPL was closed in the year 2015 due to lack of
orders and business on account of severe recession in the industries
where it used to supply its products. Due to which considerable
number of employees of DPL became surplus and idle. The other three
power plants were also closed as a result of excess manpower became a
huge financial burden of the Company.
17. To the utilization of the excessive manpower/employees, the Durgapur
Projects Limited took up the matter with the Government of West
Bengal and the State Level Committee of Rationalization and Optimal
Utilization of Human Resources under the Finance Department had
agreed to the proposal of DPL of deployment of surplus manpower in
DPL in other State Government and the same was approved by the
State Cabinet.
18. The orders of deputation were passed on 27th December, 2022 and 10th
January, 2023. The petitioners have accepted the same and have
reported their duty in terms of the orders dated 27th December, 2022
and 10th January, 2023 without any protest or objection. After
reporting their duty and after about two years that is in the month of
October, 2024, the petitioners have made their representation. In the
case of Kavi Raj & Ors. (supra), the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that:
“24. Before concluding, it is essential to deal
with certain inferences drawn by the learned
Single Judge of the High Court. According to the
learned Single Judge, prior consent of an employee
is imperative, binding, peremptory and mandatory,
before he is posted on deputation outside his
parent department. No statutory rule has been
brought to our notice, requiring prior consent of an
employee, before his deployment against a post
beyond his parent cadre. The mere fact that the
appellants' consent was not sought before their
posting at Government Medical College, Jammu
(and/or at the hospitals associated therewith)
would not, in our view have any determinative
effect on the present controversy. Broadly, an
employee can only be posted (or transferred) to a
post against which he is selected. This would
ensure his stationing, within the cadre of posts,
under his principal employer. His posting may,
however, be regulated differently, by statutory
rules, governing his conditions of service. In the
absence of any such rules, an employee cannot be
posted (or transferred) beyond the cadre to which
he is selected, without his willingness/readiness.
Therefore, an employee's posting (or transfer), to a
department other than the one to which he is
appointed,
against
his
will,
would
be
impermissible. But willingness of posting beyond
the cadre (and/or parent department) need not be
expressly sought. It can be implied. It need not be
in the nature of a written consent. Consent of
posting (or transfer) beyond the cadre (or parent
department) is inferable from the conduct of the
employee, who does not protest or contest such
posting/transfer. In the present controversy, the
appellants were issued posting orders by the
Principal, Government Medical College, Jammu,
dated 30-12-1997. They accepted the same, and
assumed charge as Senior/Junior House Officers
at Government Medical College, Jammu, despite
their selection and appointment as Assistant
Surgeons. Even now they wish to continue to serve
against posts in the Directorate of Medical
Education. There cannot be any doubt about their
willingness/readiness to serve with the borrowing
Directorate. The consent of the appellants is tacit
and unquestionable. We are therefore of the view
that the learned Single Judge of the High Court
clearly erred on the instant aspect of the matter.”
19. Standing Orders relied by the petitioners provides that a workman may
be transferred from one shift to another shit, or from one section to
another section, or one department to another, or one job to another, or
from one place of work to another, or from one establishment to
another of the Company. But it is also provided that in the event of
such transfer, the workman’s total emoluments or his basic conditions
of service will not be adversely affected.
20. The impugned orders by which the petitioners have been placed on
deputation clarified that they will retain their pay in their existing
capacity with deputation allowance, they will be guided with rules of
the DPL as well as rules of the borrowing authority, they may be
entitled for promotion if otherwise eligible during deputation and they
will get all the benefits which they are getting in the DPL.
21. The Standing Orders do not say that the workman cannot be placed on
deputation. The respondents have taken decision to place the
petitioners on deputation in the Department of Government of West
Bengal due to the circumstances mentioned in paragraphs 16 and 17
above and for the benefit of the petitioner.
22. Considering the above, this Court did not find any merit in the writ
petitions filed by the petitioners. Accordingly, WPA No. 28623 of 2024,
WPA No. 28619 of 2024 and WPA No. 28636 of 2024 are dismissed.
Parties shall be entitled to act on the basis of a server copy of the
Judgment placed on the official website of the Court.
Urgent Xerox certified photocopies of this judgment, if applied for,
be given to the parties upon compliance of the requisite formalities.
(Krishna Rao, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review