Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
17.02.2026
Sl. No.393(DL)
Ct. No.14
AN
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
W.P.A. No. 29649 of 2025
Asera Khatun
Versus
The State of West Bengal & Ors.
Mr. Tanmoy Chattopadhyay
Mr. Joy Laha
… for the Petitioners.
Mr. Avishek Prasad
Ms. Richa Pramanik
… for the DPSC, Malda.
Mr. Biplab Guha
Mr. Debasish Bhattacharyya
… for the State
1. Report filed by the State furnished by the District
Inspector of Schools (Primary Education), Malda dated
16th February, 2026 is taken on record.
2. By the present writ petition, the petitioner seeks for
setting aside and/or quashing of and/or withdrawal of
the impugned order dated 9th December, 2025 passed by
respondent no. 5, the District Inspector of Schools
(Primary Education), Malda (Annexure P/5) rejecting the
prayer of the petitioner for grant of entire family
pension.
3. The
petitioner’s
husband
retired
from
service
on
superannuation on 1st January, 1992 and expired on
30th July, 2003. At the time of death, the husband of the
petitioner was survived by three wives. The family
pension was released in favour of the surviving three
wives in equal shares. Subsequent thereto, the first wife,
namely, Anwara Khatun died on 9 th August, 2003 and
the second wife, namely, Afroza Khatun died on 13 th
September, 2017. Neither the first nor the second wife
left behind any minor child. Upon demise of the second
wife, the divorcee daughter of the second wife namely
Meherun Nessa made a representation before the
authority concerned seeking share of family pension
which was earlier released in favour of her mother.
After demise of the second wife, the entire family
pension was initially released in favour of the present
petitioner. However, subsequent thereto, such payment
has been discontinued and the petitioner was directed
to refund the family pension of the second wife. Since
the
petitioner
did
not
refund
the
amount,
the
respondent authorities stopped her pension and started
process of recovery of the payments already made. The
petitioner
made
a
representation
requesting
the
concerned respondent not to take any amount from the
share of the family pension.
Since the prayer of the
petitioner was not considered, the petitioner approached
this Court by filing a writ petition being WPA 17428 of
2023 which was disposed of by a Coordinate Bench of
this Court on 21st August, 2024 directing the concerned
respondents to consider the said representation and
take a reasoned decision thereon. Pursuant thereto, on
8th April, 2025, a reasoned order was passed by the
respondent authorities concerned holding that the
present petitioner is not eligible to receive the pension of
other two wives after their demise. Aggrieved by such
decision, the petitioner again filed a writ petition being
WPA 9896 of 2025.
4. The aforesaid writ petition was disposed of on 31 st
October, 2025 by passing the following order:
“The matter is remitted to the District Inspector of
Schools to revisit the issue and take a fresh decision upon
due consideration of the notification vide No. 54-F (Pen)
dated 13th January, 1997, and in the light of the
decisions referred to in the preceding paragraph. If, upon
such reconsideration, the District Inspector of Schools
finds merit in the petitioner's claim, necessary follow-up
action shall be taken, which shall include payment of the
full family pension in favour of the petitioner w.e.f. the
date of death of the second wife, and release of the
amount, if already recovered from her. In the event the
District Inspector of Schools finds that the petitioner's
claim is without substance, a reasoned order shall be
passed and communicated to the petitioner. The entire
exercise shall be completed within a period of eight (8)
weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this order.”
5. Again by a reasoned order dated 9 th December, 2025,
the prayer of the petitioner was turned down holding
that she is not eligible for the shares of other two wives
after their demise.
Being aggrieved by the aforesaid
order, the petitioner has preferred the present petition.
6. Mr. Tanmoy Chattopadhyay, learned advocate appearing
for the petitioner submits, at the very outset, that in the
earlier round of litigation being WPA 9896 of 2025 a Coordinate Bench of this Hon’ble Court directed the
District Inspector of Schools (P.E.), Malda to consider
the prayer of the petitioner in the light of the notification
No.54-F (Pen) dated 13th January, 1997 and the decision
of this Hon’ble Court in Fuljan Bibi versus State of
West Bengal [W.P. 5822(W) of 2009] and Sahebanu
Bibi versus State of West Bengal [W.P. 10717(W) of
2017]. However, the impugned order has been passed
by the concerned authority without following the
directions that were passed in the earlier round of
litigation. The authority concerned as if sitting in appeal
on the order passed by this Hon’ble Court held that
such notification applies only to the West Bengal State
Government Employees whose service are guided by the
West Bengal Services (Death-cum-Retirement) Benefit
Rules, 1971 and does not apply to the case of the
petitioner who is squarely guided by the West Bengal
Recognised Non-Government Educational Institution
Employees
(Death-cum-Retirement)
Benefit
Scheme,
1981 (hereinafter referred to as ‘DCRB, 1981’). He also
indicates that the prayer of the petitioner has also been
turned down quoting the note of Rule 26 of DCRB, 1981
on wrong interpretation of the said clause. Relying on
the decision of the Hon’ble Patna High Court in the case
of Most. Bhagawani Devi vs. State of Bihar reported
at 2015 SCC OnLine Pat 9286, he submits that in a
similar scheme having the similar note, the Court after
due consideration has observed that the expression “the
payment of her share of pension will cease” cannot be
interpreted that the family pension payable by the State
would be reduced or the liability to make payment of the
family pension of the State would cease, for the reason
that the right to receive full family pension is earned by
the employee for his dependents as a matter of his
employment.
He also relies upon the decisions of
Hon’ble Punjab & Haryana High Court in Premwati vs.
State of Haryana reported at 2015 SCC OnLine P&H
10444 and Vidya Vati vs. Punjab State Power
Corporation Ltd. & ors.
(Re:- RA–CW-487-2025
in/and CWP-5001-2023) in support of his contention.
He seeks for appropriate direction for release of the
entire family pension in favour of the petitioner and also
for refund of the amount which has been deducted from
the share of the petitioner that was earlier paid to her
towards being the share of the other two wives.
7. On the contrary, Mr. Biplab Guha, learned advocate
representing the State submits that the Rules of 1971
and the
notification being 54-F (Pen) dated 13 th
January, 1997 does not apply to the petitioner.
The
case of the petitioner is guided by the DCRB Scheme of
1981 and note to Rule 26 clearly records that the
payment of the share of the deceased widow shall cease
upon her death. In such event, the petitioner being the
third living wife of the deceased employee is only eligible
to 1/3rd share of the pension and not more than that.
Referring to report of the District Inspector of Schools
(Primary Education), Malda dated 16th February, 2026,
he submits that pursuant to earlier orders passed in
Sahebanu Bibi (supra) and Fuljan Bibi (supra) upon due
consideration of the representation of the petitioner,
therein, the Department has rejected the same on the
similar grounds. Therefore, the impugned order passed
by respondent no.5 does not call for interference. In the
light of his above submissions, he prays that the writ
petition should be dismissed as petitioner cannot claim
for the entire family pension.
8. Mr. Avishek Prasad, learned advocate appearing for the
DPSC,
Malda
also
submits
in
a
similar
fashion
indicating that as per Rule 45 of the DCRB Rules, 1981,
the rules of 1971 shall apply mutatis mutandis subject
to the approval of the State Government. As on date,
there is no such notification approving applications of
Rule of 1971, the same cannot be applied to the
petitioners who are guided by the Scheme of DCRB
Rules of 1981.
9. Upon hearing learned advocates for the respective
parties and considering the materials on record, the
only issue which falls for consideration is whether the
petitioner being the third wife of the deceased employee
is entitled to the entire share of the family pension.
10. The prayer of the petitioner, which was directed in the
earlier writ petition to be considered, has been turned
down by the impugned order on two grounds. Firstly,
that the notification being 54-F (Pen) dated 13 th
January, 1997 does not apply to the case of the
petitioner who are guided by the DCRB scheme of 1981
and secondly, Rule 26-Note of DCRB scheme of 1981
makes the petitioner ineligible for the share of other two
wives.
11. In order to examine the issue as noted hereinabove, it
would be apposite to reproduce Rule 26-Note as
hereunder:
“Rule 26-Note: Where an employee is survived by more
than one widow, the family pension shall be paid to them
in equal shares. On the death of widow, her share of the
pension shall become payable to her eligible minor
children. If at the time of her death a widow leaves no
eligible minor child, the payment of her share of the
pension shall cease.”
12. The issues as raised in the present writ petition are
precisely relevant with regard to note of Rule 26 as
hereinabove. Mr. Guha, learned advocate representing
the State emphasizes upon the expression on the last
part of the note that “the payment of her share of the
pension will cease” which as means that the share of the
deceased wives will cease altogether. It is placed on
record that the family pension is not a bounty or
gratuitous payment. The family pension is paid to the
surviving dependents to support their livelihood. From
bare reading of the aforesaid note, it would be evident
that what is conveyed is that upon death of the second
wife, her share would not be paid to her beneficiaries.
However, that does not mean that the family pension
payable by the State Government would stand reduced
or the liability to make payment of family pension by the
State would be reduced. Upon discharging duties during
his service tenure a retired employee or his dependents
are granted pension or family pension, as the case may
be. In the present case at hand, the petitioner is the
only surviving wife of the deceased employee. The family
pension is an estate of the legal heirs of the deceased
employee. The apportionment of family pension of a
deceased employee is not the business of the State.
State is liable to pay 100% family pension, which can be
shared by the legal heirs of deceased employee but the
State cannot retain the share of one legal heir on the
ground that there are no minor children of the second
wife and upon her death, her share in family pension
has ceased. If there is only one legal heir, who is eligible
for the grant of the family pension, he/she will be
entitled for full 100% family pension and no portion of
the same can be retained by the Government by taking
shelter behind note of Rule 26 of DCRB, 1981. While
dealing with a similar note prevalent in the State of
Bihar,
the
Hon’ble
Patna
High
Court
in
Most.
Bhagawani Devi (supra) observed as follows:
"Note 1 - When a government employee is survived by
more than one widow the pension will be paid to them in
equal shares. On the death of the widow her share of the
pension will become payable to her eligible minor child. If
at the time of death widow leaves no eligible minor child,
the payment of her pension shall cease.”
…. …. …. …. …. …. …. …. …. …. …. …. …. …. ….
“6. The State emphasizes on the last part of this Note,
and specially the expression "the payment of her share of
the pension will cease". In our view, what is important is
"her share". All that is conveyed is that upon the death of
the second wife, her share would not be paid to her
beneficiaries, but that does not mean that the family
pension payable by the State would stand reduced or the
liability to make payment family pension by the State
would be reduced. This cannot be so, because the right to
receive full family pension is earned by the employee for
his dependants as a matter of his employment. As noted
in the very beginning, it is not a bounty or gratuitous
payment.”
13. Further the Hon’ble Punjab & Haryana High Court in
Premwati (supra) and Vidya Vati (supra) while dealing
with note of similar nature came to this conclusion that
the surviving wife is entitled to full family pension.
14. In view of the above, the impugned order passed by the
District Inspector of Schools (P.E.), Malda dated 9 th
December, 2025 is hereby set aside.
15. Accordingly, Respondent no. 5, the District Inspector of
Schools (Primary Education), Malda is directed to
sanction and release the family pension to the extent of
100% in favour of the petitioner with effect from 14 th
September, 2017 (i.e. the date following the date of
death of the second wife).
16. It is informed by the learned advocate appearing for the
petitioner that the share of the other two wives which
was initially paid to the petitioner upon the demise of
the second wife on 13th September, 2017, has been
deducted from the petitioner.
17. Accordingly, respondent no. 5, the District Inspector of
Schools (Primary Education), Malda is further directed
to refund the amount, if any, which has been deducted
from the petitioner, initially paid to the petitioner upon
the demise of the second wife of the deceased employee
on 13th September, 2017 as expeditiously as possible.
18. Such exercise shall be completed within a period of one
month from the date of communication of this order.
19. Learned advocate for the petitioner is directed to
communicate this order to respondent no. 5, the District
Inspector of Schools (Primary Education), Malda, for
necessary compliance.
20. With the aforesaid directions, the writ petition being
WPA 29649 of 2025 stands disposed of.
21. Since no affidavits have been called for, the allegation
made in the writ petition is deemed to be not admitted.
22. Interim order, if any, stands vacated.
23. All connected applications, if any, stand disposed of.
24. There shall be no order as to costs.
25. All concerned parties shall act in terms of the copy of
the order duly downloaded from the official website of
this Court.
(Bivas Pattanayak, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review