Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN
THE
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT INDORE
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE PRAKASH CHANDRA GUPTA
ON THE 25th OF JANUARY, 2024
MISC. CRIMINAL CASE No. 54173 of 2023
BETWEEN:ARVIND S/O SHRI MADAN, AGED 26 YEARS,
OCCUPATION: LABOUR R/O GRAM DEDLA (MADHYA
PRADESH)
.....APPLICANT
(BY SHRI ANJUM PAREKH - ADVOCATE)
AND
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH PS MANAWAR
(MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENT/STATE
(BY SHRI RAHUL SOLANKI - GOVT. ADVOCATE)
This application coming on for admission this day, the court passed the
following:
ORDER
This petition u/S 482 of Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, has been
filed by the applicant/accused being aggrieved by order dated 08.11.2023
passed by II Additional Sessions Judge, Manawar, Distt. - Dhar (M.P.) in ST
No.67/2022, whereby the learned trial Court has dismissed the application u/S
311 of Cr.P.C. filed by applicant.
2. Facts giving rise to this petition are that S.T. No.67/2022, offence
punishable u/S 294, 323, 324, 506(II) and 302 r/w 34 of IPC and Section 25(i)
(b)(b) of the Arms Act is pending before the trial Court against the applicant.
During prosecution evidence, Pradeep (PW-1) and Lakshmibai (PW-3) were
examined on 16.02.2023 and 29.03.2023 respectively. Thereafter, on
20.09.2023, the applicant had filed an application (Annexure-6) u/S 311 of
Cr.P.C., which was rejected by the learned trial Court.
3. Learned counsel for the applicant submits that previous counsel for the
applicant could not perform effective cross-examination of the witnesses
Pradeep (PW-1) and Lakshmibai (PW-3) in respect of sequence of incident of
reaching police station from the place of incident, from police station to
Manawar Hospital, refer of the injured/deceased from Manawar to Badhwani
Hospital and admit over there, date of death during treatment, alongwith on
other subjects i.e., nature of injury of injured person and animosity between the
parties.
4. It is also submitted that for just disposal of the matter, the
aforementioned facts must be cross-examined from the witnesses wherein the
learned trial Court has failed by rejecting the application without considering the
same. Therefore, it is prayed that the impugned order be set aside. Learned
counsel has placed reliance in the cases of Dinesh V State of M.P. [1995 (II)
MPWN 73]; Uday Singh V State of M.P. [2004 (I) MPWN 140] and
Dinesh V State of M.P. [1991 (I) MPWN 14].
5. Learned counsel for the State/respondent has vehemently opposed the
prayer advanced by the learned counsel for the applicant and submitted that
both the prosecution witnesses have been elaborately cross-examined by the
previous defence counsel. This petition has been filed just to cause inordinate
delay. Therefore, the petition deserves to be dismissed.
6. I have heard learned counsels for both the parties at length and
perused the record.
7. It is apposite to reproduce here Section 311 of Cr.P.C., which runs as
under:“311. Power to summon material witness, or examine person
present- Any Court may, at any stage of any inquiry, trial or
other proceeding under this Code, summon any person as a
witness, or examine any person in attendance, though not
summoned as a witness, or. recall and re- examine any person
already examined; and the Court shall summon and examine or
recall and re- examine any such person if his evidence appears
to it to be essential to the just decision of the case.”
8. From plain reading of aforementioned provision, it is crystal clear that
Court has been vested with power to summon any person as a witness at any
stage, be it inquiry trial or other proceeding. This power is given to ensure
justice by bringing up the best evidences on record before the court for just
decision.
9. In the case of Dinesh Kumar (Supra), Coordinate Bench of this
Court had observed that discretion to recall witness should be exercise
judiciously, wherein witnesses could not be effectively cross examined by junior
counsel therefore, witness should be recalled. In the case of Uday Singh
(Supra), it has been observed by Coordinate Bench of this Court that
important circumstance left in cross-examination, hence, prosecution witness
should be recalled for cross-examination and power should be exercised for
just decision of the case. In the case of Dinesh Kumar (Supra), Coordinate
Bench of this Court has held that S.311 of Cr.P.C., is in two parts, former is
discretionary while latter is mandatory. Presence of eye-witness is disputed,
hence, witness should be called for further cross-examination.
10. The Apex court in the case of Rajaram Prasad Yadav v. State of
Bihar, [(2013) 14 SCC 461] has held as under :-
“16. Again, in an unreported decision rendered by this Court
dated 8-5-2013 in Natasha Singh v. CBI12, where one of us was
a party, various other decisions of this Court were referred to
and the position has been stated as under in paras 15 and 16:
(SCC pp. 748-49)
"15. The scope and object of the provision is to enable the
court to determine the truth and to render a just decision
after discovering all relevant facts and obtaining proper
proof of such facts, to arrive at a just decision of the case.
Power must be exercised judiciously and not capriciously
or arbitrarily, as any improper or capricious exercise of
such
power may lead to undesirable results. An
application under Section 311 of Cr.P.C. must not be
allowed only to fill up a lacuna in the case of the
prosecution, or of the defence, or to the disadvantage of the
accused, or to cause serious prejudice to the defence of the
accused, or to give an unfair advantage to the opposite
party. Further, the additional evidence must not be
received as a disguise for retrial, or to change the nature
of the case against either of the parties. Such a power must
be exercised, provided that the evidence that is likely to be
tendered by a witness, is germane to the issue involved. An
opportunity of rebuttal however, must be given to the other
party. The power conferred under Section 311 CrPC must
therefore, be invoked by the court only in order to meet the
ends of justice, for strong and valid reasons, and the same
must be exercised with great caution and circumspection.
The very use of words such as ‘any court’, ‘at any stage’,
or ‘or any enquiry, trial or other proceedings’, ‘any
person’ and ‘any such person’ clearly spells out that the
provisions of this section have been expressed in the widest
possible terms, and do not limit the discretion of the court
in any way. There is thus no escape if the fresh evidence to
be obtained is essential to the just decision of the case. The
determinative factor should therefore be, whether the
summoning/recalling of the said witness is in fact, essential
to the just decision of the case.
16. Fair trial is the main object of criminal procedure,
and it is the duty of the court to ensure that such fairness is
not hampered or threatened in any manner. Fair trial
entails the interests of the accused, the victim and of the
society, and therefore, fair trial includes the grant of fair
and proper opportunities to the person concerned, and the
same must be ensured as this is a constitutional, as well as
a human right. Thus, under no circumstances can a
person’s right to fair trial be jeopardised. Adducing
evidence in support of the defence is a valuable right.
Denial of such right would amount to the denial of a fair
trial. Thus, it is essential that the rules of procedure that
have been designed to ensure justice are scrupulously
followed, and the court must be zealous in ensuring that
there is no breach of the same.”
11. In the case of State Of Haryana vs Ram Mehar And Others [2016
(4) RCR criminal 154], Hon’ble Supreme Court has opined as under:“37. There is a definite purpose in referring to the aforesaid
authorities. We are absolutely conscious about the factual matrix
in the said cases. The observations were made in the context
where examination-in- chief was deferred for quite a long time
and the procrastination ruled as the Monarch. Our reference to
the said authorities should not be construed to mean that Section
311 CrPC should not be allowed to have its full play. But, a
prominent one, the courts cannot ignore the factual score.
Recalling of witnesses as envisaged under the said statutory
provision on the grounds that accused persons are in custody,
the prosecution was allowed to recall some of its witnesses
earlier, the counsel was ill and magnanimity commands fairness
should be shown, we are inclined to think, are not acceptable in
the obtaining factual matrix. The decisions which have used the
words that the court should be magnanimous, needless to give
special emphasis, did not mean to convey individual generosity
or magnanimity which is founded on any kind of fanciful notion.
It has to be applied on the basis of judicially established and
accepted principles. The approach may be liberal but that does
not necessarily mean “the liberal approach” shall be the rule
and all other parameters shall become exceptions. Recall of
some witnesses by the prosecution at one point of time, can never
be ground to entertain a petition by the defence though no
acceptable ground is made out. It is not an arithmetical
distribution. This kind of reasoning can be dangerous. In the
case at hand, the prosecution had examined all the witnesses.
The statements of all the accused persons, that is 148 in number,
had been recorded under Section 313 CrPC. The defence had
examined 15 witnesses. The foundation for recall, as is evincible
from the applications filed, does not even remotely make out a
case that such recalling is necessary for just decision of the case
or to arrive at the truth. The singular ground which prominently
comes to surface is that the earlier counsel who was engaged by
the defence had not put some questions and failed to put some
questions and give certain suggestions. It has come on record
that number of lawyers were engaged by the defence. The
accused persons had engaged counsel of their choice. In such a
situation recalling of witnesses indubitably cannot form the
foundation. If it is accepted as a ground, there would be
possibility of a retrial. There may be an occasion when such a
ground may weigh with the court, but definitely the instant case
does not arouse the judicial conscience within the established
norms of Section 311 CrPC for exercise of such jurisdiction. It is
noticeable that the High Court has been persuaded by the
submission that recalling of witnesses and their crossexamination would not take much time and that apart, the crossexamination could be restricted to certain aspects. In this regard,
we are obliged to observe that the High Court has failed to
appreciate that the witnesses have been sought to be recalled for
further cross-examination to elicit certain facts for establishing
certain discrepancies; and also to be given certain suggestions.
We are disposed to think that this kind of plea in a case of this
nature and at this stage could not have been allowed to be
entertained.”
12. In the instant case, the learned trial Court had observed that detailed
cross-examination has been conducted by the previous defence counsel for the
applicant/accused. Previous defence counsel was appointed by the accused
himself. It does not appear that the cross-examination conducted by the
previous counsel was ineffective. Accordingly, the trial Court has rejected the
application u/S 311 of Cr.P.C.
13. On perusal of the copy of deposition of both the witnesses, it
appears that previous counsel for the applicant/accused had cross examined
both the witnesses effectively and elaborately. Learned counsel for the applicant
has failed to show just cause to recall the witnesses for further crossexamination, which has been made an essential in several case laws as
discussed above. Therefore, it appears that the learned trial Court has rightly
rejected the application u/S 311 of Cr.P.C. The impugned order does not suffer
from any illegality, irregularity or perversity. Case laws cited by the learned
counsel for the applicant are not applicable in the instant case as they stand on
different footing.
14. Accordingly, the impugned order is hereby affirmed and the petition,
being sans-merits, is hereby dismissed.
(PRAKASH CHANDRA GUPTA)
JUDGE
Shruti
SHRU
TI JHA
DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF
MADHYA PRADESH BENCH INDORE,
ou=HIGH COURT OF MADHYA
PRADESH BENCH INDORE,
2.5.4.20=46283ba6a215e3d40573a7f0
ced0632c8b8e41b29405387437111f0f
1c897b84, postalCode=452001,
st=Madhya Pradesh,
serialNumber=975D0201B09C384735
41A4907EE0732D1EA079B8EE35C9E2
D19845AF26B0FBF4, cn=SHRUTI JHA
Date: 2024.01.27 11:28:28 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review