Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:THE HON’BLE JUSTICE MADHURESH PRASAD
AND
THE HON’BLE JUSTICE PARTHA PRATIM ROY
F.A.T. 423 of 2023
(Assigned)
Arup Kumar Sur
Vs.
Anandamoyee Sur
For the Appellant
:Mr. Soumit Ganguli, Adv.,
Ms. Priti Burman, Adv.,
For the Respondent
: Mr. Debrup Choudhury, Adv.
Mr. Arkaprabho Roy, Adv.,
Heard on
: 12th August, 2026.
Judgment on
:14th October, 2026.
Partha Pratim Roy,J.:
1. The appellant has preferred the present first appeal against the
Judgment and decree dated 12th October, 2023 whereby and where
under the matrimonial suit filed by the wife has been decreed on contest.
Case of the plaintiff wife:2. It is the case of the plaintiff wife that, she got married with the appellant
herein according to Hindu Rites and Customs on 14.07.2010 at her
parental home, after marriage she went to her matrimonial home at
Bankura. The aforesaid marriage was duly consummated, and on
30.07.2011, she gave birth of a male child, namely Adrij Kumar Sur.
Just after the birth of the aforesaid child, the husband started
pressuring the wife for bringing money, from her matrimonial home.
3. The financial condition of the father of the wife was not sound, therefore
it is not possible for the wife to bring such a huge amount as
demandedby the husband.
4. Considering the inability of the wife to bring such amount, the husband
started torturing both mentally and physically. The further case of the
wife is that the husband used to return home in drunken condition and
torture the wife physically. She was neglected and even medical
treatmentwas also denied whenever she fell ill.
5. Finally, she along with the son, driven outof her in-laws’ house.
6. The husband neither visited the wife at her parental home, not took any
steps tobeing her back.He also never paid any maintenance, either to the
wife or for his minor child. Considering the aforesaid facts the wife filed
the application under Section 13(1)(ia) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955
seeking divorce on the ground of cruelty.
The Husband Plea:7. The husband contested the aforesaid proceeding and filed written
statement and denied all the material allegation made therein in the
plaint, the specific contention of the husband is that the statement made
in the plaint was false and concocted.
8. It is further the case of the husband that he neither caused any physical
or mental torture upon the wife, nor did he demand any money. It was
further stated that the wife herself was not willing to reside at her
matrimonial home with the husband and though the husband visited the
in laws house several times, she refuses to return at her matrimonial
home.
9. On the basis of such pleadings the Learned court below formulates the
following issues:“I. Is the suit maintainable in its present form?
II. Did the O.P. treat the petitioner with cruelty?
III. Is the petitioner entitled to get decree of divorce as prayed
for?
IV. To what other relief/reliefs, if any, is the petitioner entitled to
have in this suit?”
10.
The wife adduced herself and her elder sister as PW1 and PW2
respectively: whereas on the other hand, the respondent adduced himself
as sole OPW.”
11.
Considering the pleadings and the evidence adduce by the parties,
the Learned Trial Court decreed the suit on the ground of cruelty.
Argument of the appellant:12.
Learned
Advocate
Mr.Ganguliappearing
for
the
appellant
contended that the suit was decreed on the ground ‘cruelty’, but plaintiff
wife could not prove such allegation.
13.
He further submitted that during the cross examination of PW1,the
wife, herself categorically stated that “I did not lodged any complaint to
the police station or to the Panchayat about factum or torture upon me
by my husband to bring money from my patents’ house”,“Since Ileaving
my matrimonial house I did not lodge any complaint to the police against
my husband” therefore the ground for cruelty was not established.
Otherwise no incident was brought before the court which can construed
to constitute “Cruelty”.
14.
He further submitted that in view of the admission made by the
wife, it is apparent on the face of the record that there is no incident
which can construe to be cruelty upon the wife.
15.
He further argued that irretrievable breakdown of marriage is not a
ground available under the Hindu Marriage Act for granting of divorce.
16.
It is the specific contention of the Learned Advocate for the
appellant that as the parties are staying separately for a considerable
period, it does not mean that defaulting party will get degree for divorce
on the ground of ‘irretrievable breakdown’, and he accordingly prayed for
setting aside of the degree passed by the Learned Trial Court and
allowing the appeal accordingly.
Argument of the respondent:17.
Learned Advocate Mr.Choudhuryappearing for the respondent wife
draws attention to this Court in respect of the written statement filed by
the husband, he contended that in the written statement the husband
made evasive denial in respect of the allegation made by the wife. In
absence of any specific denial of the facts, the same amounts to
admission of those facts alleged by the wife in her pleading.
18.
He further submitsthat from the cross examination of DW-1, it is
apparent that he does not know the present whereabouts of the wife.He
also does not have any knowledge about name of the school,present
status of education and other such details. It is also pointed out from the
cross examination that the husband categorically admitted that he did
not take any steps for providing support to the child education. It was
further pointed out by the Learned Advocate of the respondent by
drawing attention to the cross examination of PW1 and submitted that
there is no cross examination in respect of the issues regarding behavior
of the husband towards the wife and discharging his responsibility
towards his family.
19.
The failure to put the material allegation to the witness during
cross-examination amounts to an admission by the husband regarding
the acts of cruelty inflicted upon the wife. It is further submitted that the
materials on record clearly demonstrate that no marital relationship
exists between the parties in any manner whatsoever. Furthermore, there
is no document or evidence on record to suggest that the husband ever
intended to resume his matrimonial ties with the wife.
20.
In support of his contention he relied upon a judgment reported in
(2023) 17 SCC 433 Rakesh Raman vs. Kavita that irretrievable
breakdown ofa marriage may not be a ground for dissolution of marriage
under the Hindu Marriage Act, but such cruelty is. In the present case,
when the other party after solemnization of the marriage subjected the
wifetocrueltya marriage can be dissolve by decree of divorce inter alia on
such ground.In the present case the marital relationship was rendered
bitter and acrimonious by such conduct of the husband over the years.
The same amounts to cruelty. The totality of circumstances inflicts
cruelty to both the parties.
21.
He further submits that the Learned Trial Court after considering
the materials on record and considering the submissions made by the
parties passed awell-reasoned judgment and it need not to be interfered
with.
Analysis:22.
We proceeded to consider whether the pleadings and evidences
adduced by the wife respondent proved the allegation of ‘cruelty’ as to
entitle her to get a degree of divorce on the ground of cruelty.
23.
The word cruelty is not defined under the Hindu Marriage Act,
1955. The Hon’ble Apex Court; as well as thisHon’ble Court interpreted
the word cruelty,whichmeans any physical or mental behavior by one’s
spouse that makes it unsafe, harmful, or impossible for the other to live
together.
24.
Cruelty can either be a physical cruelty or mental cruelty.
25.
Mental cruelty is more common and harder to prove, but well
recognized in Indian Law which includes ignoring emotional needs or
withdrawing affection. If behaviorcauses the mental agony or damages, it
amount to cruelty.
26.
In the present case, it appears from the testimony of this spouse
that just after marriage situation was created where the wife was forced
to leave the matrimonial home and live separately along with her child. It
is also admitted from the deposition of the husband that the he does not
know even his son’s academic activities,nor even his schools name. It
further appears that the husband admitted that he does not know
anything about the respondent/ wife herein though the parental home of
the respondent wife is situated in the adjacent village, Bhurkunda.
27.
This admission on the part of the husband itself proves that he
had no intention to live with the wife and/or to perform his duty either
as a husband or as a father.
28.
From the deposition of PW1, it appears that no question was put
forward by the husband in the cross-examination regarding oral evidence
of forceful eviction of the wife. There is no evidence to show that any
attempt on the part of the husband to resume the marital tie between the
parties.
29.
In this context, it will be profitable to mention the judgment of a
Division Bench of this Court reported in AIR 1961 CAL 359 (A.E.G.
Carapiet vs A.Y. Derderia)wherein the Hon’ble Court held as follows:
“Wherever the opponent has declined to avail himself of the
opportunity to put his essential and material case in crossexamination, it must follow that he believed that the testimony given
could not be disputed at all. It is wrong to think that this is merely a
technical rule of evidence. It is a rule of essential justice. It serves to
prevent surprise at trial and miscarriage of justice, because it gives
notice to the other side of the actual case that is going to be made
when the turn of the party on whose behalf the cross-examination is
being made comes to give and lead evidence by producing
witnesses. It has been stated on high authority of the House of
Lords that this much a counsel is bound to do when cross-examining
that he must put to each of his opponent’s witnesses in turn, so
much of his own case as concerns that particular witness or in
which that witness had any share. If he asks no question with
regard to this, then he must be taken to accept the plaintiff’s account
in its entirety. Such failure leads to miscarriage of justice, first by
springing surprise upon the party when he has finished the evidence
of his witnesses and when he has no further chance to meet the
new case made which was never put and secondly, because such
subsequently testimony has no chance of being tested and
corroborated.”
30.
Thus, we are of the firm opinion that that the relationship between
the parties has deteriorated to an extent that both cannot stay together.
The very fact that there was no conjugal life between the parties and
their continued separation for prolong period also points to an
irretrievablebreakdown of marriage.
31.
We are not unmindful of the law that Irretrievable breakdown of
marriage is not a standalone ground under Section 13 of the Hindu
Marriage Act, However in the present case, considering the evidence
brought before the trial court, on the avail of law declared in the case of
Rakesh Raman (supra), we find that continuance of the marital tie
would amounts to continuance of the cruelty as a result of bitter and
acrimonious circumstances.
32.
The Hon’ble Apex Court also considered mental cruelty in another
case, i.e. Samar Ghosh vs. Jaya Ghosh, reported in (2007) 4 SCC 511,
wherein it held that when there is a long period of continuous
separation, it may fairly be concluded that the matrimonial bond is
beyond repair. The marriage becomes a fiction though supported by a
legal tie. By refusing to sever that tie, the law in such cases,
does not serve the sanctity of marriage. On the contrary, it shows scant
regard for the feelings and emotions of the parties. In such a situation, it
may lead to mental cruelty separation, it may fairly be concluded that
the matrimonial bond is beyond repairable. The marriage becomes a
fiction though supported by a legal tie. By refusing to sever that tie, the
law in such cases, does not serve the sanctity of marriage, on the
contrary, it shows scant regard for the feelings and emotions of the
parties. In such a situation, it may lead to mental cruelty.
33.
Considering the above noted facts and findings, we find substance
in the reliance placed
by the learned Advocate of the respondent on
decision of the Hon’ble Supreme court of India in the case of Rakesh
Raman (Supra), where the Hon’ble Apex Court has been pleased to
observe as follows:
“22.
Irretrievable breakdown of a marriage may not be a
ground for dissolution of marriage, under the Hindu Marriage Act,
but cruelty is. A marriage can be dissolved by a decree of divorce,
inter alia, on the ground when the other party “has, after the
solemnization of the marriage treated the petitioner with cruelty.”
23. In our considered opinion, a marital relationship which has
only become more bitter and acrimonious over the years, does
nothing but inflict cruelty on both the sides. To keep the façade of
this broken marriage alive would be doing injustice to both the
parties. A marriage which has broken down irretrievably, in our
opinion spells cruelty to both the parties, as in such a relationship
each party is treating the other with cruelty. It is therefore a
ground for dissolution of marriage under Section 13 (1)(i-a) of the
Act.”
34.
Therefore, analyzing the entire records along with the pleadings
and argument advanced by the parties, it appears that the wife was
forced by the conduct of the appellant to leave her matrimonial home and
both are staying separately for a prolong period i.e for more than 14
years.
35.
From the deposition of the husband it is apparent that he had no
care or concern for the wife, or his son. He had no intention or eagerness
to maintain with his wife or his son.
36.
Thus, we are of the opinion that the Learned Trial Court after
considering the materials on record and evidences adduced by the
parties arrived to a correct findings that the suit is liable to be decreed
on the ground of cruelty.
37.
In view of the findings above, we find no merit in the present
appeal. The judgment and decree dated 12th October, 2023, passed by
the learned trial court, are hereby affirmed.
38.
F.A.T. 423 of 2023 is dismissed, without any order as to costs.
39.
Let the Lower Court Records be sent down along with a copy of this
judgment immediately.
40.
Urgent certified copies of this judgment, if applied for, be supplied
to the parties upon compliance with all requisite formalities.
I agree.
(Madhuresh Prasad,J.)
(Partha Pratim Roy, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review