Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
signed
LAIREN Digitally
by
MAYUM LAIRENMAYUM
INDRAJEET
INDRAJE SINGH
Date:
2023.09.12
ET
16:28:56
SINGH +05'30'
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
W.P. (C) No. 597 of 2023
1. Arunkumar Singh Ashem, aged about 33 years, S/O A. Jiten Singh,
Chingamakha Ningthoujam Leikai, P.O. -Imphal, P.S.- Singjamei,
District – Imphal West, Manipur- 795001.
2. Dayanand Khuraijam, aged about 32 years, S/O (L) Kh. Guneswar
Singh, Khagempalli Huidrom Leikai, P.O. – Imphal, P.S. – Singjamei,
District – Imphal West, Manipur – 795001.
3. Bedajit Huirem, aged about 44 years, S/O H. Gehari Singh, Sagolband
Meino Leirak, P.O. – Imphal, P.S. – Imphal, District – Imphal West,
Manipur.
4. Sarangthem Meghraj, aged about 40 years, S/O S. Devendra Singh,
Thambalkhong Sabal Leikai, P.O. & P.S. – Porompat, District- Imphal
East, Manipur.
5. Tayenjam Ricky Singh, aged about 35 years, S/O T. Tejmani Singh of
Singjamei Chingamathak, P.O. – Imphal, P.S. – Singjamei, DistrictImphal West, Manipur-795001.
6. Pebam Satish Singh, aged about 30 years, S/o P. Mangi Singh of
Kwakeithel Heinoukhongnembi Leikai, P.O. Imphal, P.S. Singjamei,
District- Imphal West, Manipur.
7. Athokpam Manmohan Singh, aged about 31 years, S/o. A. Subol Singh
of Thoubal Athokpam Makha Leikai, Thoubal District, P.O. & P.S. –
Thoubal, Manipur- 795138.
... Petitioners
- Versus 1. The State of Manipur represented by the Secretary/Commissioner,
Department of Personnel & Administrative Reforms (DP), Government
W.P. (C) No. 597 of 2023
Page 1
of Manipur, Secretariat, P.O. & P.S. – Imphal, District – Imphal West,
Manipur – 795001.
2. The Secretary, Public Health Engineering Department, Government of
Manipur, Secretariat, P.O. & P.S. –Imphal, Imphal West District,
Manipur- 795001.
3. The
Chief
Engineer,
Public
Health
Engineering
Department,
Government of Manipur, PWD Complex, Khoyathong, P.O. & P.S. –
Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur- 795001.
4. The Manipur Public Service Commission (MPSC in short) represented
by its Secretary, North AOC, D.M. Road, Imphal, Manipur – 795001.
5. Gongguilung Kamei, aged about 36 years, presently working as
Section Officer Grade- I, C/o. Chief Engineer, Public Health
Engineering Department, Government of Manipur, PWD Complex,
Khoyathong, P.O. & P.S. – Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur –
795001.
6. Lalringdik, aged about 32 years, presently working as Section Officer
Grade- I, C/o. Chief Engineer, Public Health Engineering Department,
Government of Manipur, PWD Complex, Khoyathong, P.O. & P.SImphal, Imphal West District, Manipur – 795001.
.
... Respondents
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE MR. MV MURALIDARAN
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A. GUNESHWAR SHARMA
For the petitioners
For the respondents
:
:
Date of Hearing
Date of Judgment & Order
:
:
Mr. E. Premjit, Advocate.
Mr. S. Nepolean, Sr. G.A for
respondent Nos. 1,2 & 3; and
Ms. O. Momota Devi, for
respondent No. 4.
30.08.2023
12.09.2023.
W.P. (C) No. 597 of 2023
Page 2
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (CAV)
A. Guneshwar Sharma, J.
[1]
Heard Mr. E. Premjit, learned counsel for the petitioners; Mr.
S. Nepolean, learned Sr. G.A. for respondent Nos. 1, 2 & 3; and Ms. O.
Momota Devi, learned counsel for respondent No. 4.
[2]
Mr. E. Premjit, learned counsel for the petitioners, submits that
the petitioners are Degree Holder Section Officers in Public Health
Engineering Department during the year 2014 and 2016 and their names are
reflected at Serial Nos. 33, 34, 35, 36, 62, 85 and 97 respectively in the
Tentative Seniority List of Section Officer Grade- I as on March, 2023. As per
the relevant recruitment rules, the next higher post from the post of Section
Officer Grade- I (SO-I) is the post of Assistant Engineer (AE). The post of AE
is to be filled up as per the provisions contained in the PWD, IFCD and PHED,
Manipur [Assistant Engineers (Civil/Mechanical)/Assistant Surveyor of Works]
Recruitment Rules, 2013. As per the provisions contained in Column 11 of
the MPSC Form- 8 in the PWD, IFCD and PHED, Manipur [Assistant Engineer
(Civil/Mechanical)/Assistant Surveyor of Works] Recruitment Rules, 2013, a
Degree Holder SO-I is eligible for promotion to the post of AE after rendering
3(three) years regular service and a Diploma Holder SO-I is eligible for
promotion to the post of AE after rendering 8(eight) years in Public Health
Engineering Department. It is stated that the petitioners became eligible for
promotion to the post of AE during the period from 2017 to 2019. Column
W.P. (C) No. 597 of 2023
Page 3
10 of the MPSC Form – 8 of the PWD, IFCD and PHED, Manipur [Assistant
Engineer (Civil/Mechanical)/Assistant Surveyor of Works] Recruitment Rules,
2013, provides provision for filing up 60% of the vacancies in the post of AE
by promotion and 40% of the vacancies by direct recruitment. Out of the
60% promotion quota, 50% of the vacancies are to be filled up by SO-I
Degree Holder and the remaining 50% by SO-I Diploma Holders/others.
Relevant Column Nos. 10 & 11 of MPSC FORM – 8 of
[3]
Recruitment Rules for the post of Assistant Engineer (Civil/Mechanical)/
Assistant Surveyor of Works in PWD, IFCD & PHED, Manipur are reproduced
below:10.
Method of recruitment whether
by direct recruitment or by
promotion
or
by
deputation/transfer
and
percentage of the vacancies to
be filled by various methods
60% by promotion and 40% by direct recruitment. 60% promotion
quota shall be filled up in sub-quotas as follows:
(1) 50% by selection from officers holding Degree/AMIE in
Civil/Mech. Engineering or its equivalent from a recognized
University/Institution with regular service as specified in
Column 11.
Provided that if sufficient number of officers holding
Degree/AMIE or its equivalent are not available for
promotion, the remaining vacancies in this sub-quota may be
filled by persons possessing Diploma in Civil/Mechanical
Engineering with service as specified in Column 11.
(2) 50% by selection from Diploma holders in Civil/Mechanical
Engineering who obtained Diploma after doing a minimum
3(three) years course from a recognized Institution with
service as specified in Column 11 and from officers who are
not in possession of a Degree or a Diploma in Civil/Mechanical
Engineering with service and record as specified in Column
11.
N.B.: 1. Reservation of SC/ST in promotion quota shall be in the
overall vacancies and not with reference to sub-quota.
2. In direct recruitment, the number of the posts requiring
Civil Engineer - qualification and number of posts requiring
Mechanical Engineering qualification may be advertised separately
and recruitment made according to requirement on the basis of
separate merit lists for Civil Engineering post and Mechanical
Engineering post. At the same time, a combined merit list of
Mechanical and Civil Engineering candidates will be prepared for
the purpose of seniority.
W.P. (C) No. 597 of 2023
Page 4
11.
In case of recruitment by
promotion/deputation/transfe,
grades
from
which
promotion/deputation/transfer
to be made
Promotion:
S.O. Grade-I or post equivalent declared by Govt. of Manipur in
consultation with the Commission as equivalent thereto with the
following period of regular service in the grade.
(a) In case of Degree holders, 3 (three) years.
(b) In case of Diploma holders, 8(eight) years.
(c) In case of Diploma holders who pass both Section A & B of AMIE
Examination of Institution of Engineers (India), 3(three) years regular
service from the date of such passing.
(d) In case of Diploma holders who possess B.E./B. Tech while in service
from a recognized University, 3(three) years regular service from the
date of such passing.
(e) In case of officers who are not in possession of a Degree/AMIE or
its equivalent or Diploma, 15 (fifteen) years with outstanding records of
service.
[4]
It is stated that Department of Personnel & Administrative
Reforms (Personnel Division), Govt. of Manipur issued Office Memorandum
dated 09.10.2020 replacing ‘vacancies’ by ‘total sanctioned post’ at Column
10 of MPSC Form-8 in the said Rules. It is stated that the Department of
Personnel & Administrative Reforms (Personnel Division), Govt. of Manipur
issued letter dated 27.07.2022 under the subject ‘step for rectification of
systemic deficiencies in Engineering Deptts. - Regarding’ and suggested
revised provision proposed for appointment of AE as 80% by promotion and
20% by direct recruitment. 80% of the promotion quota shall be filled up as
per seniority list. Reservation of SC/ST in promotion quota shall be in the
overall vacancies and not with reference to sub-quota. The present writ
petition is filed challenging Column 10 of the MPSC Form-8 for providing
50:50 sub quota for the Degree Holders and Diploma Holders SO-I in the
60% promotion quota from the post of SO-I to AE as the same is violative
W.P. (C) No. 597 of 2023
Page 5
against the degree holder SO-I. In view of the fact that at present there are
152 Section Officers, 120 Section Officers are Degree Holders and only 32
are Diploma Holders and the distribution of sub-quota as 50:50 is violative
and not proportionate with the number of incumbent officers eligible for
promotion. It is also pointed out that there is no quota for direct recruit and
promotee in the cadre of Executive Engineer in the same department and in
the proposal put up by the Department of Personnel & Administrative
Reforms (Personnel Division), Government of Manipur. It is proposed that
promotion to AE be 80% by promotion and 20% by direct recruitment and
80% by promotion quota shall be filled up as per seniority list and there is
no 50:50 sub-quota.
[5]
Mr. E. Premjit, learned counsel for the petitioners, relies on the
judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Raghunath Prasad Singh Vs.
Secretary, Home (Police) Department of Bihar (1988) Supp. SCC 59
to the point that an officer should get atleast two promotions in his career
and the impugned rule amounts to forfeiting the right of the Degree Holder
SO-I for further promotion in their career.
[6]
The prayer is reproduced below:a) to admit and allow the present Writ Petition;
b) issue an appropriate writ, order or direction quashing
impugned provisions contained in Column 10 of MPSC Form8 of the PWD, IFCD and PHED, Manipur [Assistant Engineer
(Civil/Mechanical)/Assistant Surveyor of Works] Recruitment
W.P. (C) No. 597 of 2023
Page 6
Rules, 2013 providing division 60% promotion quota into
sub-quota of 50:50 between Degree Holder Section Officer
Grade-I and Diploma Holder Section Officer Grade-I so far it
relates to PHE Department, Government of Manipur;
c) direct the Respondents to fill the 60% promotion quota of
Assistant Engineer in PHE Department as per combined
seniority list of Section Officer Grade-I;
d) pass any further order/orders, direction/directions as deem
fit and proper under the facts and circumstances of the case.
AND
-In the interime) restrain the Respondents from taking any steps for holding
DPC for appointment by way of promotion to the post of
Assistant Engineer in Public Health Engineering Department
pending disposal of the instant petition;
f) pass
such
other
orders
and
further
orders,
direction/directions as may be deemed necessary and proper
on the facts and in the circumstances of the case.
[7]
It is prayed that during the pendency of the present writ
petition, the State respondents be restrained from taking any steps for
holding DPC for appointment by way of promotion to the post of AE in Public
Health Engineering Department under the impugned rule.
W.P. (C) No. 597 of 2023
Page 7
[8]
Mr. S. Nepolean, learned Government Advocate, assisted by
Ms. R.K. Emily, learned Deputy G.A., submits that the Recruitment Rules of
2013 providing 60% promotion quota into two sub-quotas of 50:50 between
Degree Holder SO-I and Diploma Holder SO-I has been formed under the
provisions of Article 309 of the Constitution and the same has been in
existence even before the petitioners joined the service of the PHE
Department. The only ground in the writ petition that out of the 152 Section
Officers, 120 belong to Degree Holders and only 32 are Diploma Holders is
not a criteria to challenge the service rule. Learned G.A. highlights that the
petitioners have measurably failed to show that the division of 50:50 subquota out of 60% promotion quota to the post of AE has infringed the right
of the Degree Holders. The same rule is applicable in all engineering
departments such as PWD, IFCD and PHED. It is submitted that in the
exigency of service, the numbers of Degree Holders and Diploma Holders
may vary from time to time. Learned G.A. has pointed out that if the numbers
of diploma holder increases in future then the rule is liable to be challenged.
It is submitted that reliance on the proposal sent by Department of Personnel
cannot be a ground for challenge of the existing rule. It is prayed that the
writ petition be dismissed at this stage as the same is without any merit.
[9]
Ms. O. Momota Devi, learned counsel for the MPSC also adopts
the submissions of learned G.A. and states that there is no basis for
challenging the sub-quota of 50:50 out of 60% promotion quota and prays
that the writ petition be dismissed.
W.P. (C) No. 597 of 2023
Page 8
[10]
We have heard the learned counsel appearing for the parties,
perused the materials on record and considered the relevant law.
[11]
The main ground for challenge in the writ petition is for
quashing Column 10 of MPSC Form-8 of providing sub-quota of 50:50
between the Degree Holder SO-I and Diploma Holder SO-I in the 60%
promotion quota from the SO-I for promotion to AE. The only ground pleaded
in the writ petition is that at present out of the 152 SO, 120 are Degree
Holders and 32 are Diploma Holders. Hence, 50:50 sub-quota is irrational
and it is loaded against the Degree Holder Section Officers. Another ground
is that Department of Personnel Affairs have proposed 80% promotion quota
from SO to AE and 20% for direct recruit. 80% promotion quota will be
considered on the basis of the common seniority list and no sub-quota (as
50:50 in the present case) is not proposed.
[12]
This Court is of the opinion that this 50:50 sub-quota out of
60% promotional quota to A.E. has been adopted and has been prevailing in
all Engineering Departments such as PWD, IFCD and PHED in the state of
Manipur and the Rule is framed under Article 309 of the constitution of India.
In the exigency of service, the percentage of the degree holders and diploma
holders S.O. Grade-I may vary from time to time. Larger proportion of degree
holders at a particular time cannot be a ground for challenge of the
recruitment rules providing the sub-quota of 50:50 unless the petitioners
have shown that the sub-quota of 50:50 violates the principles of equality as
enshrined in Article 14 of the Constitution. It is settled proposition of law that
W.P. (C) No. 597 of 2023
Page 9
there can be classification and such classification should be reasonable and
the object behind the classification shall have an intelligible criteria [kindly
see D.S. Nakara Vs. UOI: (1983) 1 SCC 305]. The existing rule cannot be
challenged on the basis of proposed rule in absence of any discriminatory
provisions in the distribution of sub-quota of 50:50 in the existing rule in
Column 10 of the MPSC Form – 8 for promotion to the AE. If the plea of the
petitioners are accepted, the diploma holders can also challenge the sub
quota 50:50 rules if the numbers of diploma holder increases subsistently in
a particular period. The number of existing incumbents of degree holders vis
a vis diploma holders cannot be a ground for setting aside the Recruitment
Rules of providing equitable distribution of 50:50 sub quota in the 60%
promotional quota from the post of SO to the post of AE.
[13]
We don’t find any merit in the plea of the petitioners.
Accordingly, the writ petition is dismissed at the admission stage.
[14]
No costs.
JUDGE
ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE
FR/NFR
Indrajeet
W.P. (C) No. 597 of 2023
Page 10
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review